Mojang Messed This Up (Easy, Pale Garden)

[@dawnsoisson3140]

I feel like the better option for this is let players use keep inventory without considering it a cheat no matter what difficulty they’re on. Have it a setting you can turn on or off without enabling cheats. That way people can choose whether or not they want it. Java lets you turn on keep inventory and still have achievements let bedrock do the same.

[@toycat]

My thoughts too - I'd argue keep inventory should be limited and made not a cheat, or be an option if it's going to be a difficulty thing.

[@xx_ljdary_xx5643]

but on java the only reward from achievements are xp, while on bedrock is free accessories

[@FancyDakota]

I agree.

[@DragonTheOneDZA]

Why is it even a cheat???

[@guitaekm2]

I don't agree. Why would you ever turn keep inventory ever off when it's not considered a cheat?

[@killerjdog51]

They should make the Pale Garden it's own unique biome like Mangrove Swamps rather than a subvariant. Then parity may be better in terms of generation.

[@BetaRanger28]

I agree but i think Pale Gardens being a subvariant is alright as is. It makes the Pale Garden seem familiar, but also completely different. We also cant forget mojang has done the same in the past (tall birch biome, sparsed jungle).

[@WaldoFabio]

What we need the most is a massive parity update. At this moment Java and Bedrock are two different games, modding aside.

[@alexmiles2002]

I think it’s fine. It should just be a toggle on easy or only be peaceful

[@tristanshaltz2769]

Problem is, if they do split the update cycle, and have different features, then people will get mad at the parity difference. I do think that there are things that really could have been done faster, bundles would have been here by now if not for bedrock, but the amount of bad PR Mojang would get for that likely isn't worth the benefits in their eyes.

[@DuskYokai]

I honestly hate the parity system. Why are we throttling progress from the game so 1 version can keep up. I feel it hurt the development cycle

[@MrExdous69]

To be fair, yes, bundles didn’t come for so long because of bedrock, it wasn’t just about bedrock. It was about the lower end mobile devices. They simply didn’t offer enough processing power. Now those lower end mobile device are powerful enough to allow for bundles, thus they have arrived. It’s about time.

[@DuskYokai]

@MrExdous69 i mean should we really be restricting the games development because of MOBILE.

[@MrExdous69]

@@DuskYokai with the way they designed Besrock, yes… however in my opinion they shoulda released them ages ago

[@DuskYokai]

@MrExdous69 thats the thing minecraft used to allow java to develop then bedrock would catch up when it could. They purposely slowed development for java, and bedrock has proven to be terrible to develop with how long it takes them to pump out even the simplest features

[@basicallybacon2593]

Mob griefing be a cheat imo is absoultely dumb, its more annoying than anything.

[@Zejoant]

Skill issue

[@venus.kryvak]

@@Zejoantfr

[@AuriPlayzz]

Literally only like four mobs can grief anyway, it’s so silly 😭

[@superberries112]

bro it's just the game 💀🙏

[@trolmaso]

I honestly don't know why you would remove customizability and call it a good decision.

[@mylife-23]

I wish I could have keep inventory on without losing achievements 😭 I die alot....

[@toycat]

Would you like some help not dying? :)

[@EpicRandomness555]

Saaaame. Mobile is hard

[@mylife-23]

@@EpicRandomness555 facts 😭

[@Novacreeper231]

Why doesn't mojang just add faster natural regeneration for bedrock 😭

[@SonarTheBat]

It should be optional.

[@AnonymousAnarchist2]

Oh, here's a thought... How about NO difficultly slider, just choices, and just a few choices that disable achivements? Like enter in a field for mob damage mulitplier, and same for player, and envriomental, and a spawn rate multupliers and a whole bunch of toggles so long as they dont fully break the game keep them out of cheats and only take achievements away if you turn on cheats. Then if you dont apply enough difficulty through the options take away achievements.

[@HiWelcomeToIKEA]

This is a good idea

[@seratoninlover16]

No offense however i feel as tho if that were an option than everyone would play the game different then the original creators intended. I mean i hope thats what the devs goal is

[@naglis3518]

i think if you're on easy mode or peaceful keep inventory does not go under cheats however is off by default

[@josephrowlee]

Great video! I agree that good parity would be better than bad parity. I don't think you're considering all the context with the shots of Mojang switching between Hardcore and not Hardcore mode at Live, though. They're demonstrating how differently you play if you aren't on hardcore (when they did the water bucket clutch) verses with hardcore (being much more careful).

[@tacocat1921]

Why is the wood a different color in bedrock?

[@brainwater176]

Because mojang devs are incompetent

[@iheartblock3792]

Because Java had the updated colors

[@BrickWhyse]

As a father with a 7 year old that plays on Hard with me, but started at 3 and played peaceful for a while, it would have been easier to get him to play Easy with Mobs if he got to keep his inventory. (Yes my obsession with achievements caused us to not play with cheats on.)

[@deborasoares3623]

4:32 nah wheres the problem, the world is yours, you dont take advantage of anyone, also, if you take a bed at an ancient city how will you get home without navigation, keep inventory is just a way of never stop playing minecraft for 1 year.

[@WolvenMother]

I wonder if Mojang can tell how many players turn on Keep inventory?

[@dougsvoboda6091]

If they're reworking difficulty anyway, can they make phantoms spawn on hard mode only?

[@WowbaggerTheInfinitelyProlonge]

They should just place Phantoms on "Annoying Mode."

[@xgui4-studios]

@@WowbaggerTheInfinitelyProlonge and also lapis on that ! (it is a joke, cause when i played survival as when i was younger and saw that it was lapis instead of diamond , i was sad)

[@SlushysSecret]

@@xgui4-studiosthat would remove the point of the enchanting table, instead include the glowing vines in caves that are mistaken for diamonds

[@miimiiandco]

But then you can't get Slow Falling on lower difficulties.

[@JaydenLuna-bw7ce]

Imagine if there was a way to counter phantoms...... Ugh 😢

[@ewoker17gaming]

No I don't I think it's okay because the difficulties need an upgrade all they do right now is just change the difficulty level would that be cool easy mode could be keep inventory that's what I always dreamed of

[@Noone-po1fc]

They should add another difficulty for this: Facile Facile also means easy, but a little bit fancy.

[@JacobL1200]

If mojang want they could make a super easy difficulty where keep inventory is on and mobs do little damage. Edit: they would keep the easy difficulty not get rid of it.

[@beanietechie]

i say just make it not a cheat so keepinventory enjoyers can still comfortably get advancements

[@GloomyWarrior]

But if you can turn on keep inventory on hard mode would make it not hard anymore.

[@colin3ds1]

Why would you care about achievments if you didnt actually achieve them This is why we need per world advancements

[@miimiiandco]

​@@GloomyWarrior Then don't turn Keep Inventory on if you want the challenge.

[@GloomyWarrior]

@@miimiiandco But if you can turn keep inventory on on hard mode makes it not hard and so the purpose of this mode gets nullified.

[@AuriPlayzz]

@@GloomyWarriormaybe make the toggle available for peaceful and easy players, but have it locked away on normal and hard

[@jimwlazlak6492]

Don't leave floating trees.

[@dugoose6934]

I feel like easy instead of having keep inventory should have keep tools/armor. losing materials on death would still be a punishment but this would still be LESS punishing.

[@GinaNorden-z2o]

Thanks for making this topic simple!

[@Kat.Beanie]

Do you think they'll fix Bedrock regen while they are adding hard core? Would Easy and Peaceful still be able to get achievements?

[@e3thur]

no. hardcore for bedrock is coming this month along with bundles.

[@deborahhulme5137]

Are you gonna talk about the wikis one year anniversary?

[@brock3257]

I really like the idea that on peaceful it’s full keep inventory whereas on easy it’s just the hotbar and armor slots 🙌🏻

[@VanK782]

3:52 That's ridiculous tho - the game being easier is SUPPOSED to be easier, not be a damn trade-off

[@GreyTsaki]

I feel like they should stick with making keep inventory considered not a cheat but also make it a toggle like it is now

[@MinorLG]

The experimental feature toggle on Java is also winter drop

[@brandon-kg2vd]

It's really baffling how Mojang treats Bedrock as the ugly adopted kid when it's literally the main cash flow with most of the player base

[@seagullman87]

Tbf, most minecraft youtubers treat Bedrock the exact same way.

[@SparkingSparks]

This is debateable... Though it would make sense considering Java Edition is Mojangs creation while Bedrock Edition only exists in its current form because of Microsoft.

[@lhs1219]

​@@SparkingSparks Well.. Bedrock is mobile/PC/console port of pocket edition, which is clearly developed by Mojang before acquisition.

[@SparkingSparks]

@hslim9396 Yes, it was made by Mojang, but it probably would have remained as just the mobile version if not for Microsoft, while console editions would still be done by 4J. That's why I said "in its current form."

[@samanthaplaysmusic]

Ngl feel like the gravestone add on does dying way better then the base game

[@SleepyWaffleHead]

3:45 i think if you select peaceful or easy they should just nake it optional to turn on it. Without losing access to achievements thats ibe thing i hate about cheatings

[@kenny_the_real]

In an ideal world i would love bedrock having independent development tests. But this is the community that canceled the mob vote because they couldn’t have all three. Do we really think Mojang could handle the backlash of having 2 versions of a feature and only implementing one ? The community is definitely to blame for why we could not have something like this because Mojang will never risk it.

[@Americanbadashh]

Who doesn't like the idea of mending? It's like the most beloved enchant!

[@osmosis_8692]

MOJANG PARITY: no cares given Oh, Mojang... U silly.

[@justn1n]

I think it should only be Peaceful, Make health and food Java parity for Easy, items despawn after 30 mins (Only if dropped from death) on Easy, 15 on Normal, and 5 on Hard.

[@cxleb9432]

What about the curse of vanishing?? Does it affect that?

[@Rainbro109]

Curse of Vanishing items don’t disappear when keepInventory is enabled normally, so I don’t think it would affect that.

[@AAdielP]

3:33 you not bad on 1.9+ java pvp..

[@hatepaste]

Yeah I don’t like the color of the new wood on bedrock. It’s dirty purple not white.

[@thnecromaniac]

It wasn't in hardcore, cause it was an example of something you'd do outside hardcore, but wouldn't do in hardcore. "You play differently"

[@Nataliah20011]

Why are Mojang this incompetent?

[@TonioTalks1]

Watchin later, at work

[@SleepyWaffleHead]

My thoughts on it is that they should keep tus change. I don't like it but its ok. Also toycat they probably did the clutch in survival first because their like aren't you worried about dying and then they show how harder it is in hardcore idk the 2 clips that they used while the guy was talking didn't make even aense idk dont ask me those are just my thoughts....

[@joehughes5438]

Mojang just doesnt care about bedrock and every update backs up my opinion

[@DiegoSandoval-le3tk]

Java should be for consoles and PC and bedrock for cellphones and tablets stop mocking around mojang

[@justadictatorridingonanuke3714]

I believe the reason why java isnt on consoles is because java isnt supported on most consoles

[@Zejoant]

​​@@justadictatorridingonanuke3714java is most definitely supported. It just wouldnt work on phone because its not optimized for such devices like bedrock is, which was originally pocket edition

[@Webzpsy]

Ah yes the swamp update with a new name slapped on it 😂

[@SleepyWaffleHead]

7:18 whats that someone plz tell me idk plz

[@thenonbinaryzombie]

Will old world be affected by this change

[@puzzlegal17]

Parts that have already generated won't change, but parts that you explore for the first time after the pale garden is implemented can have pale gardens. The keep inventory thing will presumably affect all worlds.

[@colin3ds1]

Worlds with cheats enabled will remain cheats enabled and worlds that are not cheats will now probably have a keep inventory option

[@DamagedPotential]

Make Minecraft Great Again (MMGA)!

[@SleepyWaffleHead]

10:58 toycat WTFLIP IS DAT I SAW DAT WE ALLL SAW DAT

[@atelierlife-jo1sb]

I know!

[@atelierlife-jo1sb]

As someone who can ONLY play on bedrock, i am very tired of bedrock neglection

[@slenderthesavagemaster]

Whys the bedrock devs gotta be so unbearably lazy man...absolutely disappointing..

[@MikeVoidKai]

j ava is limited bcs of bedrock, jezus man thats sad java couldve become more better if they port over Populiar mods from the modded community

[@Mistahphoje]

0:36 ayyyyooooo

[@RantGrumps]

?

[@edenwayne8407]

Speaking of peaceful, why is minecraft's interpretation of peace genocide?

[@Zejoant]

What is bro talking about

[@edenwayne8407]

@@Zejoant instead of having peace between species, all hostile mobs are just gone

[@Zejoant]

@@edenwayne8407 oh lol

[@Americanbadashh]

It's bad for bedrock because bedrock is a pale imitation

[@matthewwright3310]

White oak meh would prefer green wood willow tree

[@simonghostriley9436]

Playing on Normal and Hard difficulty is pointless. All you're doing is gradually increasing the Damage Multipliers of hostile mobs without being given any benefits or gameplay changes in return. Hunger is more annoying than it is essential because food could be found literally ANYWHERE in massive quantities.

[@BetaRanger28]

Thats how difficulty works definitively... increasing damage and need for hunger clearly gives difficulty a point because it DOES make the game harder... I guess food can be found anywhere, but definition wise its harder

[@Zejoant]

Its not pointless lol. Some people want more of a challenge. However, hard mode should be harder than it is rn. There isnt much difference between hard and normal

[@EastontMyny]

bro i still cannot play the winter update how do i turn it on

[@ultragtman1563]

I just realized watching you play… its one heart per mob thats kinda annoying. If you had 7 on u

[@Iseewaters]

60 likes in 6 minutes is kinda crazy

[@SleepyWaffleHead]

Guys remember dont show SUS 😣 Wirld gen

[@ManFaceMan_YT]

How do I use bedrock

[@r.carter8378]

Wait… you can earn achievements in peaceful? But not with keep inventory?? Lame

[@Americanbadashh]

Peaceful and easy are there for mob damage, not cheating death and trivializing encounters. Keep Inventory is a cheat for a reason! Peaceful prevents numerous achievements already, are you dense?!

[@MCCDogmanYT]

Bro keep inventory is not working on Android

[@itsmrchimp1788]

Did he change the title as I clicked on it?

[@nicholasgeorge4156]

And once again minecraft is becoming more like terraria every update. I never thought it would be like this tho

[@falc0r313]

A ver cuándo te coscas que Java es la versión principal 🤙

[@loganwillis8537]

How get

[@flawyerlawyertv7454]

👍

[@willisthehy]

Keep inventory was always an option on Java…. Bedrock isn’t Minecraft sorry don’t care Java is mc

[@Americanbadashh]

This is the truth. It's practically a ripoff game.

[@whoistoft]

NINTH!!11!! !!!!

[@Planetmango48]

Hm.

[@kxjab]

They should just add new difficulties instead of changing the ones we already have. Keep inventory should absolutely be considered a cheat.

[@lpfan4491]

Then so should be peaceful. It's a "get out of jail free"-card.

[@kxjab]

@@lpfan4491 I agree.

[@cherricake1796]

FINALLY

[@colin3ds1]

The real issue is that we dont have advancements A per world achievement system that isnt effected by cheats Achievments as they are are just normal PSN and Xbox live ones that can be earned once and never again on the same account

[@SleepyWaffleHead]

Dont worry toycat this is my last comment Make Minecraft more if a sandbox game custom worlds custom terrain custom items idk custom things to the game that make it a good sandbox

[@Nonexistent-y6r]

Number 2516

[@LeReubzRic]

hi,

[@agsilverradio2225]

I would rather have mob greifing changed than keep invontory.

[@Malmorious]

Yummy

[@GNBMikey]

yo

[@ryandoesstuffapparently1540]

Coming soon in Hard mode: Thirst

[@evelynlovesjuno9880]

You should keep it different or actually parody and stop saying

[@timer192]

First day club l V

[@Zoltronyoutube]

Of course, bedrock edition doesn’t get more pale forest pale garden whatever. Mojang just thinks bedrock players don’t deserve any f***ing love.

[@zaroff7022]

I was here

[@Webzpsy]

Keeping inventory is dumb . Play creative. Survival is a way of life leave our game alone 😂

[@PrimitiveAspid]

16 seconds ago, no views. ibxtoycat fell off? 😕😔

[@Zacian2.0]

Its because bedrock is a cheap cashgrab and Java is a product.

[@Zejoant]

True

[@slothguy_]

bedrock should be deleted

[@fishfromsandiego-f5u]

Why?

[@Zejoant]

​@@fishfromsandiego-f5ujava is better. Bedrock drags java down

[@quazimanipulation4121]

​@@Zejoantonly a fraction of the playerbase actually play java, if bedrock was deleted Minecraft would be dead

[@kolkagaming1234]

Keep Inventory is cheating. Regardless of Java having no consequences of Disabling achievements, it’s still cheating.

[@galon_pro]

People can play their game however they want

[@ValToadstool]

It's not cheating if the game lets you do it

[@EmperorPenguin1217]

@@galon_pro Yes, doesn't change the fact that KeepInv. is cheating by definition.

[@EmperorPenguin1217]

@@ValToadstool It's still cheating, and it disables achievements anyway. It's also a crutch that enables teleportation by death as a viable transport method

[@megaman37456]

@@EmperorPenguin1217 If it's built into the game it isn't cheating, by definition.

[@changbrian6989]

lol 1

[@strategogod]

Java superiority confirmed once again 💪🏻

[@dingbaaat5569]

as a java player: get pranked bedrock players

[@mansionbookerstudios9629]

Ibxtoycat do you know Jesus ?if do not let tell about it!😊

[@fernoFURRY]

Cool, i know and i don't like it that much

[@TastyChocolatCake2011]

Average religious spammer