An India With No Muslims? | Saeed Naqvi's 'The Muslim Vanishes' | Barkha Dutt

[@PothuRaju888]

Barkha smiles from ear to ear only when she meets, interviews ppl of a 'certain' background.

[@kilangsungty1523]

please like, share and subscribe.

[@Critic224]

They are the only people who give some reason to smile!

[@thunderbolt4796]

@@Critic224 See ! You just showed religious bias , religious Supremacy! Just like ollah

[@Critic224]

@@thunderbolt4796 what religious bias ? No where in my comment or the original comment by Jay Veer , is there any mention of religion …. ‘Certain’ background could mean anything …. This is why they say… don’t poke your nose 👃🏼 where it doesn’t belong !!!

[@Chen-gl9hm]

She is B...

[@krishnendusanyal4678]

The Hindu vanishes - an utopian tale of India

[@penacle7]

I would like to know how India would be without caste system. Coz I get 100% it would be far more progressive and developed . Human life hoping to have more value so technology around conversing that .

[@thunderbolt4796]

@@penacle7 India was richest for 1000s of years because of proper following caste system!

[@kamleshlulla5303]

from Sindh, Punjab and Bangladesh

[@karthikeyanchidambaram6560]

"The Hindu vanished" and there are examples.

[@dingdong9277]

Boorkha Dutt, her agenda based press can't come out of old and stupid topic of Hindu vs Muslim... She has no other subjects for past 25 years

[@ameya7723]

This Ashraf Saeed Naqvi will never talk of PASMANDA Muslims. These guys have mastered the art of playing and inciting the caste card to forward their Islamic agenda.

[@nikusingh191]

They Islamize our top intellectuals, artists, writers, professionals using soft cultural and economic power but on the ground they go hard with violence and crime. This dissonance is leveraged to confuse the response of the target society. The reason masses hate their journalists and writers.

[@kamleshlulla5303]

according to us they're intellectuals who are being hired because of our acceptance to lies

[@sidmalhotra3862]

Simple fact is that it is the Hindu which has vanished from afganistan and its vanishing from pakistan and bangladesh. While muslim population has been steadily increasing in india. How do you explain this ?

[@salimhusain2814]

SID MALHOTRA...Just because you say they are vanishing does not mean its true. In fact its not factual at all. And when you say Muslims are increasing....its true. But this is because the fertility rate of Muslim Couples is the highest on the planet. Put it down to that delicious and nutritious Halal non-vegetarian diet. Now add to that great news is the fact that and more People accept and convert to Islam than any other faith today. It may Amaze you to know that 61% of new converts to Islam are..........wait for it......WOMEN ! More fertility ! More Muslim Births. More babies are named Muhammad than any other name on planet earth. (Yes ..Google it) And Guess what...thats the way God planned it.....So Live with it. Today we are 25% of the World population.........tomorrow WE ARE THE WORLD

[@karthikeyanchidambaram6560]

What he wrote is fiction imagined too far. When reality is not getting his attention.

[@varunsriniwasan6561]

The irony is that there has been no direct communication with the Indian Muslims Are they part of the Santani culture,although they may have a different faith,different practices, or are they only physically in Bharat and mentally dreaming of a Ghazwe e Hind where in India🇮🇳 🇮🇳 🇮🇳 itself santanis will live as second class citizens like they lived during the Delhi Sultanate era paying the Jiziya tax

[@penacle7]

What makes you think they are in gazwahe hind ? Only person who promoted is from Pakistan . Also all communal divide in India is always when Pakistan is in frame be Muslim league or after we break Pakistan into two by helping Bangladesh to seek independence . Coz even Kashmiri militancy was all done by Pakistani people , when Kashmiri exodus and all militant attacks were done by Pakistani so tell me what makes you think so ?

[@abdulquadir9427]

Very few muslims support such ideas. Most want to live in this country in peace.....

[@abdulquadir9427]

Even kashmiris did not support Pakistan in 1965 war.

[@abdulquadir9427]

It was in 80s that they got radicalized.....

[@ananthan8951]

That alone is acceptable in Islam as Pakistan in two wings and Kashmir have proved beyond any reasonable doubt as does the remorseless and immutable hostility and separitism that the faux liberals advance. They totally accept that one group will not change.

[@ravikumar12320000]

Hmmm...it seems Mr Naqvi will feel safe, confident & empowered only if all Indian Hindus get disenfranchised. So what's next, impose the Jizya on them again?

[@kafiruddinmulhiddeen2386]

He wants Hindus to vanish. He openly calls himself an outsider or mleccha.

[@sounakchatterjee2694]

That would be the start of a truly happiest and peaceful time.

[@abdulquadir9427]

Galat fehmi....

[@kanudatta]

Shameful and depressing!

[@anuvydehi]

You're so funny. We'd be fighting on caste, color and ideas 🙄. The only solution is to learn living with our differences.

[@sounakchatterjee2694]

@@anuvydehi Really! How do you know that?

[@Gappasappa]

@@abdulquadir9427 agree. We want the Indian Muslim, not the Muslim Indian. What the current Muslim leadership is doing is to detach Muslims from India. We gave Pakistan for that.

[@shauryamalik8473]

Why is it considered blasphemous to even start a conversation around the topic that when country was traumatically partitioned in the name of Islam, when almost all non Muslims situated in what is now pak had to flee their homes and were forced to move across the new borders forever (and many died in the process), then why were the muslims stopped from doing the same ie moving enmasse to their new muslim homeland. It was but a natural and logical concluding step. If it had happened, then root cause of many problems which plague India today wouldn't have been there in the first place. That's why gandhi is called father of the nation cuz he screwed India over, royally. #gandhi chala gya, musalman chor gya.

[@Skindia-y]

👌👌👌👌👌👌

[@Critic224]

Don’t worry 😉 it ain’t no more blasphemous to talk about partition the way you want, in fact what is blasphemy now is to talk about sare-dharma sambhav ….

[@shauryamalik8473]

@@Critic224 Firstly what value can one assign to someone's opinions when the person expressing them doesn't have the guts to say it in his/her own name and has to hide behind a moniker. I'm sure you must have learned this style of shoot and scoot from the OG- RaGa. Now coming to your point, you imply that: a) India wasn't partitioned in the name of islam (in that case, lemme know on what basis, do you think, partition happened) b) we should all follow sarv dharma sambhava idealogy. (noble idea indeed, in fact inherent in Hinduism and hence coined and propagated by the said religion. You say it's blasphemous to discuss this idealogy nowadays, you are only partly right here. It is indeed blasphemous to discuss this but only for those belonging to the abrahamic faiths and has been blasphemous from time immemorial. You seem to want to place the burden of this wonderful secular idealogy only on the shoulders of hinduism, as has always been. This incredulous expectation from hinduism and hinduism alone has actually led to the backlash from the majority and the current state of affairs in the country.)

[@sunnymitra6372]

@@Critic224 U mean Sarv Dharam Bada Pav.......which gave us Kashmiri Hindu Genocide

[@sunnymitra6372]

@@user-yh2vm2ti3c You forget Balochistan which became Independent on 4th August 1947 before Pakistan and India. Later Jinnah send his Army on March 1948 to Annex it.

[@abdulwadud3495]

Ganga jumuna tahzeeb is a blattent lie .

[@kafiruddinmulhiddeen2386]

Ghazwa e hind is the true goal

[@fairplay7417]

One can never be true to intellectualism by failing to dispassionately critique a religious text and calling out its ills, as they are. You cannot use liberalism of some refined individuals and pass it off as the thinking of an entire community. For many religionists, day-to-day actions and practices are governed by the ideology and diktats of their religious texts. The time has come to review divine books of all religions objectively, just as any other book review, by subjecting them to philosophic scrutiny and clearly identifying parts that are divisive and hateful towards other communities. Reconciliation only happens after truth is accepted!

[@youttt27]

Well said!

[@salimhusain2814]

@@user-yh2vm2ti3c kzbin.info/www/bejne/b6qkg4OnaJqfeNk

[@Gappasappa]

The Muslim vanishes and the Indian remains.

[@salimhusain2814]

@@Gappasappa WHEN TRUTH IS THROWN AT FALSEHOOD ….IT SMASHES OUT ITS BRAIN ! Holy Quran: Chapter 17 Verse 81

[@salimhusain2814]

Fair Play …. This individual is huffing and puffing and saying exactly nothing much. Islam , Muslims, The Prophet & the Quran have all been critiqued , attacked and fought against for the last 1400 years …..Our Enemies are in the Dustbin of History … and TODAY Islam stands Victorious. More people are turning to Islam today than any other faith. More babies are named Muhammad than any other name . ( yes ..Google it) And more women turn to Islam than any other faith .….TODAY . Islam welcomes scrutiny ...in fact the Quran urges its readers to do so. Holy Quran : Chapter 4 verse 82: “Do they not consider the Quran with care? Had it been from other than Allah, they would surely have found therein much discrepancy.” THERE IS NOT ANOTHER SCRIPTURE ON THE FACE OF THE EARTH THAT CLAIMS WITHIN ITS PAGES THAT IT IS FROM GOD... NOR A SCRIPTURE THAT INVITES SCRUTINY LIKE THE QURAN DOES. kzbin.info/www/bejne/hHetoYZjbZKCgdE

[@rekhaagarwal73]

why Hindu population in Pakistan and Bangladesh reduced to almost negligible and Muslim population in India increased .

[@mohammedd270]

Why you said muslim population in india increased? But you didn't said hindu declined in india. You answer is this. Even in india muslim grow but it doesn't mean hindu presecuated

[@Arcmid]

Musims just before partition voted for Pakistan. Yet 99% of those who voted for Pakistan in this side stayed back in India. Therefore the real homeland of Muslims in India is not here but in Pakistan. They really belong there, not here

[@MANISHKUMARSINGH-wd5vp]

The version of saeed Sahab is true. I have grown up in such romanticised village.

[@satyasingh5953]

Yes Manish that must have been about 40 years ago but with the advent of the Internet human innocence (was lost?) or awoke. Information/research is above ground now with media drivers - villages came into current world.

[@tirthankarmandal5101]

@Manish bro please convert to islam alhamdulillah

[@karthikeyanchidambaram6560]

We all grow up in cosy environments and it doesn't end there.

[@sksivapurapu]

Already we have Afghanistan, Pakistan, Bangladesh, Burma, Indonesia etc where Hindu were flourishing, Hindus have vanished over the last 1200 years. Thanks to Islam and Secularism. What if Muslims vanish from India... not a big deal...

[@raahinyapratapsingh1629]

Most of the muslims of india had a hindu ancestory They had relinquished the hindu faith under duress Now india is a free secular country where everyone has freedom to practice the faith of his choice They should now come back to the faith of their ancestors and honour their forefathers

[@sadas8154]

Who the hell are you tell anybody what faith they should follow?

[@kafiruddinmulhiddeen2386]

No but naqvi calls himself an outsider/mleccha. He is part of the Islamic borders who destroyed our culture.

[@magiccomments]

The lack of logic, they apparently were forced, so lets force them again.

[@sb9060]

@@sadas8154 it's Hindu-Dawa . Article 25 of constitution of India has given all the right to propagate any religion . Hindu may introduce apostasy in it's religious tradition soon as well. Hindus may well propagate , "there exists no God except Hindu God" La-ELahi-HinduGod... Sounding like El-Nino winds 😂

[@penacle7]

We all humans evolved from ape tomorrow apes if ask humans to convert back to apes would u agree to that ?

[@soumsarkar]

Thank you Barkha for putting another brick in your project “Destroy India” Who or which character do you bring next in weaponising your dream?

[@digitunni7391]

The vedas was written in Pakistan. Today Hindus have been driven out. The Hindus should unite

[@jamshedcheema3490]

Barkha Dutt seems so happy when people of certain community come and berate India

[@kilangsungty1523]

please like share and subscribe.

[@pratyaychakrabarti7014]

Hahaha, it's not a dream, it's already happened here, in our country, in recent times!!!!!! - somebody shud tell them that he s already have had the Hindus vanished from a certain city - yes in our times !!!! -

[@penacle7]

Seriously you can’t read or listen or see what happened to your sense . Seems like gt corrupted like brain what is the title no Muslims , It’s about Muslim vanished from the society . Read carefully before you start spreading fake propaganda

[@Critic224]

Which cities? Can you name some… and don’t say Kairana … I am from that region … known very well the reality

[@subadeepdas3397]

@@Critic224 then wtf the local Hindu were afraid bjp losing. Why they were saying if yogi lose will leave kairana. Btw Nahid Hassan supporters said if he loose "Bhusa Bhardenge in Jaato main".

[@DevaEkoNaaraayanah]

@@Critic224 abey Aatanki Qom Mahhaamad aatanki ke anucharo zaraa jaake apne Kitaab padho aatank ki daastaano se bhari hui Tuumhaarre din ab bahut kam bbacchhe hain yaa to insaan ban jaao nahi to Nipatne ke liye taiyaar ho jaao

[@chitrangadasamal5605]

Kashmir

[@shankarr8234]

LOL. The Pain in the voice of these lootyens mafia , remembering the good old days of their rule. Did he write one harsh article against gandhis after the 84 riots against sikhs in delhi ? zero. Please note that it is the hindu kashmiri pandits who vanished from Kashmir overnight, where as muslim population increases every year.

[@lalithapadmanabhan9250]

Burkha Dutta is the female version of KARAN THAPPAD. Ineffective to the core. But then they cannot reconcile to the present and refuse to accept that their game is over. They can live in the past and nostalgia. Present and future is Zero. Hahaha.

[@gv6800]

I can't live without muslims. Infact if I have to sit in autorikshaw , I search muslims. I like the way a muslim talks.

[@youttt27]

Go to Afghanistan….You will be in heaven:)

[@avishekmondal2982]

yes caste is a problem par aj BJP, RSS hi use dur kar rhi hai wo bol rhi caste jo bhi ho phle ap hindu ho jab ye log sochte hai to caste dissolve ho jta hai... iska praman raam mandir ke waqt mil gya tha.. us waqt koi caste nhi tha Sare hindu the... ye bahut acha kam kiya BJP, RSS ne... ye bahut jaruri tha... or hindu ko gali dene ke liy leftist hindu hai par muslimo ke bech koi leftist muslim nhi hai ye problem hai.. unki left BJP hai😅😅😅😅

[@apurvam921]

Lol your sarcasm is on point 😁👌

[@GDtalksss]

Not minorities only muslims mam , i am a minority and have no problem with indian news channels, unless they talk against india

[@satyasingh5953]

Fail to see how Saeed pins onto Indian Muslims the Ganga Jamuna cultural mentality while accepting that their inner core reverberates with an imported man made ideology as opposed to ancient scientific Sanatan Dharma which resounds in each tiny speck of Indian soil.

[@karthikeyanchidambaram6560]

He himself said here that the discussion is pertaining to the Hindi belt.

[@hariharans4962]

Syed Saab...what about pasmanda Muslims who are not even there in any political or social power and not even talked about. Why there is not even a mention of the muslim exceptionalism

[@skw5551-j2f]

Stop this nonsense, Muslims showed their true colours during partition

[@alterego1031]

13:25 "hin-du-twaah" which is what "I (Barkha Dutt) want you to say, but why dont you say that?" - the way she says "Hindutva" seems like she is Einstein talking about E=mc2 - what snobbery and utter foolishness, what absolute stoned-ness from Burkha! What does she smoke?

[@shibumahapatra2255]

Mr. Naqvi's fake propaganda at first modi never said in parliament about we got freedom after 12 hundred years if it is true please include his speech video on next topic

[@gaunikarora5157]

Great.. he should read out this to his co-religionists who can't tolerate hindu processions in " their " area

[@offencebestdefence500]

@@TQrfoeljU8lN8tVy1Y2ffA really ??? Examples plz...atleast in last 1 month

[@kafiruddinmulhiddeen2386]

@@TQrfoeljU8lN8tVy1Y2ffA yeah? Any evidence? I didn’t think so.

[@Husna-v2h1x]

Tanatan dharma hoisting flag in mosque will not be tolerated sad on u u don't the reality of stone pelting...stone will be pelted if u don't behave properly in procession

[@gaunikarora5157]

@@Husna-v2h1x You can build a whole mosque on out temple and we can't hoist a saffron flag ( which was a false story ). Even if we did, tera baap bhi nhi rok skta

[@Husna-v2h1x]

@@gaunikarora5157 tere baap mein dam hai toh karke dikha loduuu

[@shirazsamad9776]

these are the questions india needs to ask LOVE IT

[@SunilSharma-cw4qp]

Why did nehru succumb to negation of common civil code bu maulvis and Maulana.

[@SunilSharma-cw4qp]

Why do people of only one faith have problems all'over the world

[@Sindhi001]

@@SunilSharma-cw4qp Nehru appointed the first Islamist education minister Maulana Abul Kalam Azad. It was a big mistake. Nehru's big blunder was not to impose Uniform Civil Code and not banning madrasas, Waqf Board and All India Muslim Personal Law Board. He should have forced every Muslim child to be educated in real schools along with children of every faith. Nehru was guilty of social apartheid and we are paying the price. Now large percentage of Indians are semi literate and backward. Imagine if Muslims had received the same education as Hindus, Sikhs, Christians etc. India would have been lot richer and a more advanced economy.

[@sb9060]

It is completely utopian imagination (far far away from the ground reality) of Burkha and Saeed Naqvi. Because *Majority Hindus* are not Exclusivist Totalitarian Supremacist like *Majority Muslims* of like Pakistan and Bangladesh which almost obliterated Hindu-minority in their respective countries. It's ironic that peoples of Bangladesh and Pakistan belonged to the same Ganga-Yamuna Tahaseeb as propagated by Burkha ji and Saeed Naqvi ji few decades back! Peoples who voted for Muslim league in 1946 election, many of them stayed in India out of majority hindus's generosity unlike majority Muslims of Pakistan and Bangladesh. On contrary, in India, percentage of growth of Muslim population has always been higher than the same of majority hindus. In India caste also exists in Muslims in the form of Sharif/Ashraf at the top, followed by the Atraf (low-born), and with the Arzal or Ajlaf at the bottom. But No one talks about those facts of the ground. But i do agree that any government in India should include sane and secular minded Hindus and Muslims and parsis and jains and Sikhs and Buddhists and Christians. But again the following notions have to be agreed upon by them - that no woman should be beaten up by her man on *whatever context* , keeping four wives by a Muslim man is denial of woman's right , women-sex-slavery isn't justified at all on whatever context irrespective of time frame, Hindus and Muslims should get rid of caste based discrimination etc.

[@penacle7]

Also when you mention polygamy do look into Hindu code which was introduced by Nehru in 1958 to abolish polygamy in Hinduism and also give rights to females in divorce and right to inheritance . Which actually led to modernization of Hindu religion .

[@penacle7]

Nirbhaya was done by monsters so monsters who abuse women or rape them are monsters . Let’s not go into that coz India is known as rape capital and what is the majority religion coz more then religion it’s how as a society we treat ladies . Like we have dowry system where girls are burnt or killed , small babies are killed coz of their gender as females .

[@sb9060]

@@penacle7 There is absolutely no issue in appreciating Pandit Nehru's role in Hindu society reform. I'm all for reform in Hindu society today and in future to tune Hinduism with modern values. It's because it's the majority of majority- *Hindus* who allowed Nehru to do so. But Nehru failed to bring about any reform in Islam amidst objections from *majority* of *minority* Muslims. This is called a logical dissection with scientific argument. Please also do look into Hindu Succession Act and it's rights in the matter hindu women in which women are provided with same rights as of Hindu men.

[@sb9060]

Please ask government of India to publish annual report on crimes (including rapes) *per capita* in terms of peoples of each religious denomination. Truth will prevail if you have the courage to do so.

[@sb9060]

LGBT rights are upheld by India like any other modern countries denouncing religious prejudice of certain religious section. Adultery isn't treated under criminal laws in India denouncing dictates of certain religious sect.... Any atrocity against women should be condemned unequivocally irrespective of religions across breadth and length of this nation. Law of the nation should address that. But crimes against law happen in all the countries including India. But if women are ill-treated in disguise of civil laws of any particular religious community, ill-treatment of women happens with impunity. That's the crux of the problem. Woman's witness can't be allowed to be taken as half of that of man.

[@sabirshah2010]

#Barkha G … very well hosted… hats off to you and your highly educated guest Saeed G…. God may bless you Barkha G

[@jasjally1351]

Naqvi sir, with all respect to you, remind you of another Muslim akbar, who killed 40,000 Hindus in chittor. I hope you understand my message!

[@princerajput3864]

It was a war...ladai m sab marte h... jaise sikhs mare the ... Gujrat m musalman mare the

[@urmila16]

A must read. Such insights from this wonderful thinker. What programs he gave on Doordarshan in the 80s

[@rekhaagarwal73]

why ५७ countries are Islamic counties and not secular

[@patrickdial5810]

The problem you have in the Indian subcontinent between Hindus/ Muslim/ Christians is caused by the ignorance and decadence of the Indians. In the Caribbean e.g. Guyana, all the problems that seem to bedevil the Indians of the subcontinent are all solved. Could you learn from the Caribbean? We could point out a number of those ignorant facets. If anyone is interested, we could enumerate some of them.

[@jupiter-n4w]

If heed the advise of Jinnah Muslims should be migrated in1947

[@arabindamishra7065]

Was Modi wrong when he said freedom from 1200 years of subjugation ? Which part of the statement is wrong and how ? Will the erudite Naqvi elaborate? The fact is simple. We are not ready to face the truth.

[@penacle7]

What’s the truth are you ready to face the truth : we are today most corrupt country in Asia ? Corruption at 40%

[@penacle7]

Truth that we have increasing unemployment, educated and millionaires are leaving country biggest producer of immigrants in the world . Our economy is falling and achievement of this govt is 80 Cr given free 5kg rice or wheat and celebrated as “ food festival an utsav “ , communal violence will soon start pushing mnc and fdi away and is off the list of developing nations into categories with African countries which are considered third world place

[@arabindamishra7065]

@@penacle7 That is not the answer to my question. What ever you have raised is altogether a separate debate and we can argue on that till cows come home.

[@penacle7]

@@arabindamishra7065 wht kind of subjugation he wanted to seek freedom from was it the caste system ?

[@drfarahdeeba1344]

Indeed , Modi was talking about implenting "MANUSMRITI ' in society , this is what he meant in freedom from subjugation from 1200 yrs. Which was subsided after Mughal invasion and equality was established in society in INDIA after Mughals who were Muslims and believe all humans are equal ,about what Mr Naqvi is talking .Ganga jamuni tahzeeb belonged to Mughal ,so the followers of MANUSMRITI "Who want devision in society , to bring caste system , suppress Muslims, Dalit, women etc,they want freedom from equality . This is what Mr Modi, meant.

[@rekhaagarwal73]

why'd Muslims vote in mass which is single most reason of communalism .

[@tapsimavinkeredayanand8454]

The Krishna shloka was beautiful! Ras Khan❤❤. Kabir, Ras Khan, Shishunala Sharif. I think India as a civilization would be perfectly ok wothout Islam. But without Sufism, life would be so boring. I’m a staunch Vaishnava and think Sufism is an expression of my heart from another culture. We can all coexist. And that end prayer to Mahadev was heart wrenching. It is important for us to remember that Baba listens to all his sons and to be fair human beings first.

[@OO_727]

When in india there is No Muslim, there is Dalits...and the show must go on 😶

[@Red_Frankenstein]

Back in time there was no muslims

[@yulplateau]

lucky for him… hindus wont ask for sar tan se juda for his taking mahadev’s name in his disgusting diatribe at the end!

[@vinaymaheshwari3074]

This channel is helping India become Lebanon.

[@yulplateau]

Muslims were not in India for most of its history and India did wonderfully, with centres of learning such as Nalanda university. A land that gave the world Hinduism, Buddhism & Jainism millennia before Islam emerged or came to India. Why is Ganga Jamuna tehzeeb expected only in India… why not leave for Pakistan and advocate for Ganga-Jamuna tehzeeb there? He criticizes Muslims in power for not supporting him for fear of their secularism being questioned, but doesn’t wonder if pseudo liberal Hindus helped them to burnish their secular credentials. India without Muslims would be a freer more liberal country. No sar tan se juda, no terrorism, no hijab controversy, no fighting to reclaim destroyed temples.

[@hariharans4962]

Has any country been able to manage this ? Where as in the last 100 years Hindus and Buddhists, Christians have been wiped out of the following countries Afghanistan Bangladesh Pakistan Lebanon And what happened Jewish population of Algeria, Morocco, and entire Arab peninsula? Why no Syrian Christian in Syria No let's talk about the importance of nuclear arsenal for making earth safe.

[@imtiazulislam9547]

How come so many Israelis in Palestine? How come Christians & Muslims amongst Palestinians? How come No Weapons of Mass Destruction in Iraq? Sweetheart, there are far too many imponderables than you can think of. You might be feeling better playing on BSE/NSE with Ambu Baba, Adu Baba, Jhunjhunu Babas' scrips😉. That's what our Param Gyani PM would really 👍 💚💙

[@hariharans4962]

@@imtiazulislam9547 your love and commitment for Muslim countries is only matched by your hatred for India and successful Indians. If you want to know the truth what happened to that part of india fully infected called Pakistan?

[@rekhaagarwal73]

Muslims appeasement is ok for Muslims

[@bwarikoo]

Mr.Naqvi my favourite Those were the golden days🎉

[@offencebestdefence500]

THE MUSEUM OF THE EXTINCT HINDU Like all pagan polytheistic civilizations Untill then they will😭😭😭😭

[@UMESHPILANIA]

The Muslim personalities he is talking about are not respected by Muslims nowadays, Why?

[@ajaychaturvedi4765]

Hope this comes true for the world peace but India at the very least

[@DevaEkoNaaraayanah]

Bcz of ☪︎ANCER !

[@kaustubh14jr]

When are they disappearing? We are all waiting..

[@Muralisrinivasan-q3l]

BARKA IS a journalist who knows she can biased against certain people but not other people who will retaliate

[@vincentmulchand6532]

That is our dream what peace would reign in Bharat.

[@VinodSharma-xn8rc]

इस अशरफ़ी मलेछ का ह्यूमन राइट है की इनको एक मलेछ प्रदेश मिलना चाहिए। बुरखा को धन्यवाद है की मोहम्मडेन मज़हब के मसले का ध्यान रखती है

[@falhenchachal9817]

Is it not a fact that muslims did not want to live with other religion and thus why they wanted Pakistan then why should they stay here now ? They have already been given their homeland namely Pakistan, they should all go there.

[@ravikumar12320000]

Maybe, the reason they stayed back is to break India further into smaller pieces. This way, they could become a majority in some of those pieces over time. Jinnah apparently thought this way according, to some historians.

[@falhenchachal9817]

@@ravikumar12320000 you are absolutely right. I completely agree with your comments.

[@rekhaagarwal73]

why Muslims can not pray Indian idols

[@rekhaagarwal73]

Most Muslim were blatant in showing favours to fellow Muslims throughout since १९४७

[@iloveatish]

Barkha would disappear first if this hypothetical event happened.

[@rekhaagarwal73]

Muslims caste system also must also be exposed .

[@MichToJoshya]

29:02 Also please don't compare yourself with Ganga.... that is quite annoying.

[@divyanshu239]

Lucknow is truly an island of virtue amongst rabid communalism...we still love the bonhomie in chowk area of Lucknow

[@chitrangadasamal5605]

All muslims are not bad ..there are fringe elements every where in every religion... problem are people like barkha Datt arvind kejriwal nidhi razdan kanhya Kumar jignesh mewani Kunal kamra javved aktar rajdeep sardesai...the list goes on radhika Menon arundhati roy ...most of them are Hindus...normal Hindu an Muslim ar good popl busy in thir wok....

[@Chen-gl9hm]

Which ganga jamuna?

[@Gagan9016]

4 shadiyaan aur 26 bache paida kar rahe hain aur keh rahe hain political invisiblization ho raha hai. Largest minority hain aur politically invisible? What a joke?

[@olah22]

Drama likhne kya Jarurat hai Aap Pakistan aur Afghanistan dekho country with no Hindu Sikhs and Buddhists, Iran dekho country with no Parsi yaa Turky Dekho jahan se Christian khatam ho gaye..

[@sunilkaushal7171]

Why are you taking liberty to insult Mahadev

[@abuahmed6058]

India is a kind of democracy where its muslim population have little rights , the very government is in complicit in the violation of muslim rights .

[@shobhanavijaykumar8420]

Then how come, you are voicing your opinion ?

[@shobhanavijaykumar8420]

I notice that your fundamental right is still intact

[@jotendrakumar2852]

Muslims r not minority worldwide and India. 26 opposition secular Muslim loving parties congress aap sp bsp rjd jdu Trinamool ncp ss trs jagan jds dmk aiadmk cpi cpm pfi sdpi cfi Muslim league Bheem pdp NC aimim aiduf bjd all want Muslim votes. 2 % Muslim vote share means 56% Muslim votes and majority muslims and hence 26 political parties want Muslim votes all the time..

[@travelinwards5747]

Tell this to the stone pelters..... This idealistic, poetic BS has no relevance to ground realities.

[@MichToJoshya]

28:34 YOU ARE BEING TOO DRAMATIC, Remember, Because of YOUR good fortune you are a 'guest' at a Hindu country, (even though you ancestors did not leave any stone unturned to try and destroy it, but as the One ParaBrahma would have it , we still survive with all our vigor!), Nobody will harm you per say, unless you try to harm them. Also, you talked about pity in eyes of Pakistanis for you, but what about Hindus in Pakistan, who now DO NOT EXIST.

[@sattuprasad3568]

Aaj Muslims sirf aur sirf vote bank bankar rah gaya....kyunki sabhi political parties ko pata hai..Muslims Bina soche samjhe vote dete hai..jaha unke moulvi sahab bolenge wahi vote denge...

[@angoorseb7819]

Naqvi ji, hats off to you. Despite of present communal situation, still you have noble ideas. Pranam to such scholars

[@jaihindurastra1547]

Hello Barkha how are you how are you doing okay tell me one thing per short ka rate kya chal raha hai aajkal

[@TheSumanPandey]

initially the pretense..then the unease.. then the agony.. n finally the real avatar.. turk ka lahoo !! just a perspective...

[@Historystudent882]

It’s 75 years too late. In 1947 two latrines were made. One on east side other on west side to accommodate all these mixbreed offspring’s born out of enjoyment of Arabian turk Uzbek and mongol invaders. It’s so much late .. but better late than never.

[@jotendrakumar2852]

Never speak about suras in Holy Quran on infidels, idol worship and AL Taqiya on Hindus and what is taught in every Muslim home and madarasas about Hindus in Holy Quran to treat Hindus as Infidels and Gazwe Hind

[@rekhaagarwal73]

Muslims must luv for Bharat openly

[@jasjally1351]

Naqvi sir, since when equity is western notion. Life well wasted!

[@kusumjagtiani6680]

Most moving & heart breaking talk with Saeed Naqvi Sahib. I share your pain as I too belong to that great time of the 1980s & shudder at the evil designs of the current dispensation & the RSS. Where is the ganga jumna tehzeeb of that time? Where did it get lost? We must retreive it. How did the Indian lose its way in today's crass world of mammon & temporary gains forgetting the values of the Country & India. How long does one have to wait for it to come back. Barkha thx for doing this interview. Saeed Sahib we are greatly indebtd to you for expressing what a lot of us feel but do not possess your ability to do so. Thank you

[@Cmr_5vifail]

Also bring The new Madina author to debunk this guy hallucinated gibberish

[@AjitJoshi686]

Thinking Kashmiri separatists and rest of India Muslims as one group is stupid. Kashmiri separatists should be clubbed with these JNU chhap Tukde Tukde Gang May be 100 people & the Maoist from Central India.

[@youttt27]

Kashmir is what happens when the dream comes to fruition.Read the book the Muslims read everyday and swear by….That is the philosophy and believe me it is not kind to you or your descendants. Going by your argument if this is true only of Kashmiri separatists how would you explain what is happening in Pakistan,Bangladesh,Afghanistan,Lebanon and in many parts of southern India and London ( believe it or not)where enclaves are formed pushing out people who don’t subscribe to the faith and running their own mafia. People like this guy represent the soft side of the Jihadi…oh so ready to play the victim card.

[@chotaniraju]

Very well explained. Hope people get copies of this book at rs 50.. so that more read it

[@niveditamishra7021]

Boring... the best way to know if Muslims in India is to travel across the length and breadth of the country.

[@balishah82]

Very nicely conducted by pretty #Barkha G..... and of course the great Naqvi G.....

[@mohommedyakub3114]

I think Pakistan should take all Indian Muslims in Pakistan,because Muslims are dying every day in India and they will vanish,that’s why they are after Muslims about hijab, three talak,about madarsa ,Loud speaker Azzan killing Muslims for eating meat,all these issues

[@frankenstein1995may]

Won't we be relieved!!!😀

[@williamwatson72]

वो बरखा दत्त नहीं है, वो बुरका दत्त है.

[@pralaydas1521]

Islam Free India Mission successfully running In India 💪💪💪

[@DevaEkoNaaraayanah]

☪︎ANCER free INDIA !

[@rajivnair3455]

The Muslim population was 9.4% in 1951, today it's close to 20% there's no sign of them vanishing any time soon !! ☮️👍

[@va-ro]

go back to school and read again....hahahah

[@varunsriniwasan6561]

Muslims on partition got two states Muslim majority in the West and another one in the East

[@va-ro]

@@varunsriniwasan6561 generalization is bad...for example approx. 66% of hindus dont like hindutva....hahaha

[@400saar]

Andh bhakt..!! As the total population increase so the population of Muslim. What was the population of tbe world in 1951 and what is today?? Why do you look at only muslims on negative way?? Why did not talk about their education,unemployment,custodial deaths, false cases, why muslims are targeted since 2014????

[@sadas8154]

Population of fanatic andh-bhakts was 0.1% in 1951, today it is close to 5%. Seems population of fanatic andh-bhakt people is increasing.

[@sujay7301]

burkha , ek video salman rasheed pe bhi bana dete

[@rekhaagarwal73]

Pasmanda Common Muslim not allowed freedom

[@shridharaithal1433]

Found to be strange comparing Advaitha with Islam which is so clearly EXCLUSIVE and does not accept anything or anyone else leave alone Raam or Krishna. IslAm is more of a mono theistic like judaism and so on.

[@c.nagriknews8837]

Beautiful Bottomline Satyam Shivam Sundaram literally*

[@kaditya9]

Excellent interview Saeed Naqvi was so eloquent.

[@harshas7265]

Very nice discussion

[@rekhaagarwal73]

Moulvi Mulla Mufti all are blindly followed