Monty Don Demonstrates How to do Hardwood Cuttings with Roses in the Autumn...

[@JKOakes]

I love you Monty Don. I could listen to you all day. I imagine you hate being put on pedestals, but you are the closest person who can ramble on like my grandmother about the garden.

[@jamesthompson2122]

I think exactly the same, I could quite comfortably fall asleep listening to Mr. Don!

[@JKOakes]

@@jamesthompson2122 right??!!

[@elisadutrasferreira441]

Ele é maravilhoso.. Volta a fazer o programa

[@raton_garden]

Wow so beautiful planting nice share 🎉❤🎉❤🎉❤

[@mariemac5347]

Monty Don is a wonderful man!

[@dotnb]

He is!🌹🌹💐

[@gregmf9427]

Tremendous garden! I hope you have BIGLY returns 🤗

[@scudderbunny6488]

awesome teacher 🙏

[@bbr9707]

I wonder how many cutting took… do we know is there an update to this?

[@gillianfernandez1781]

Do dog roses climb up a trelis or arbor?

[@MoonSpinners]

Excellent advice

[@kaittemurry4740]

I'm in zone 5 colorado.. I've had no luck rooting a rose stem

[@psisky]

If I take a cutting from a climbing rose, will the new plant also be a climber, or will it be a bush? i have a Gertrude Jekyll climbing rose. Thanks.

[@Thunderbird68-i2f]

Is this in the UK?? In Canada winter goes down to -35 Celsius. I'd think you may need a greenhouse to see them over winter.

[@corporatejungles]

great, I will have to try this method. I have not had good results with hardwood cuttings. For the last 2 years I have done cuttings in the fall which have netted me one new rose bush out of 200 cuttings. Not good odds.

[@GumriRN]

Thanks for this comment. I don't feel such a failure.You're lucky; you've had at least one rose succeed out of 200. After watching hundreds of YT clips with people saying: "it's SO EASY to root rose cuttings" I've not had one succeed yet. As meticulous as one is & trying all methods, including that Potato, the only rose propagated for me. And, it's not really my doing!.An Apricot Tea.Rose in my yard either seeded itself or a pruned branch fell amongst large rocks & now IT and it alone is the only rose that's propagated for me in 2 years!. What am I doing wrong???

[@TheGyreMadHatter]

I'll throw it out there - I don't know if this method would work particularly well for those of us in the US or in less mild climates than his place in Britain. Where I'm at, we have too hard of a winter freeze and too much winter moisture which would just make the cuttings freeze or rot. If I did it outside, I'd put it in a cold frame or I'd probably do it in a pot. Check out the Jacksonville Rose Society YT videos. From my own experience, their stuff seems solid. Good luck!

[@en1909s9iah]

I've done inumerous times also with no luck! My way of doing it now that proved to work it's to cut them, put them on a small pot, like a 2 liters pot, strip it of its leaves, then spray it with a fungicide, and cover the cutting with a ziploc bag spraying with moisture inside, and put in a semi-sunny side of your garden, and keep watering every day if it's dry and hot, or skip a day or two if it's cold or damp. I also keep spraying the inside of the ziploc bag every week with water and more fungicide. I don't spray my roses expect when they become too sick, but I think the fungicide helps it from black mold from setting in and killing the cutting and new leaves!

[@pertelote4526]

I would like to know whether this method makes any sense if one lives in central Europe where the temperature can drop to 10 or 20 degrees below zero in winter.

[@OurGardenChannel]

It works in Missouri where the temps get down to -10F

[@Angelwing1963]

He IS a lovely man

[@pritamsri]

Thanks for the video.. my dog rice cuttings is only vegetatively but not flowering at all since two years.. it receives direct sunlight for about 5 hrs.. can you please suggest me something.. thanks in advance

[@nacht98]

why are gallica roses so hard to root from cuttings? What should I do?

[@johno3326]

Can I do it with hybrid tea roses?

[@OurGardenChannel]

You can, but they are often much weaker on their own root, which is why they tend to be grafted to rootstock.

[@johno3326]

@@OurGardenChannel oh ok. Thanks

[@ZeNex74]

can i do the same in pots and put in garage etc that has some light over winter. maybe put in a bag etc??

[@alexhogan1]

ZeNex74 there’s no need to put them in a garage, they’ll be fine outside in pots.

[@MushtaqAhmad-jg3bn]

Masha'Allah very good thanks so much

[@johno3326]

Also, what is the song at the end?

[@OurGardenChannel]

🤷

[@johno3326]

@@OurGardenChannel ok

[@MarinaWilson1958]

Thanks for this. When then do you take them out and replant in their final positions?

[@OurGardenChannel]

Marina Wilson Monty says to leave them in for a year. Now, we've tried this technique twice, and the first time it was a total failure. We tried again this year, and through the winter the cuttings looked good, but then, after 20 inches of rain this spring, they all seem to have given up.Sort of disappointing, as I do rose cuttings successfully all the time, if I do them indoors under a cloche...

[@GumriRN]

So glad you commented on "replant in final position". Too few You Tube clips, actually show us this & indeed, the 4-6 weeks after cutting, when they've shown roots. Good comment. Tnx

[@montylangan]

nice thanks

[@sounasamdy8303]

Where are the results?????

[@thuggie1]

i have a raised bed made dry stone walls which i do my cuttings in they seen to do well with most hardwood cuttings

[@lameduck3630]

do you need to add hormone powder, I've just ordered a pack from ebay for £1.50

[@midoann]

Thanks, big fan from Japan. Is Japan's March okay for planting cuttings? Or do I have to calculate the U.K. March temperature and find what month will it fit here?

[@homestead.smallholding]

I think we (UK) and Japan are on similar maritime temperate climates within the Northern hemisphere, but there is a difference between Cornwall (SW) and the Scottish highlands (not as big as the difference between Kagoshima and Wakkanai)

[@Stampingerms]

I would like to know time frame when to do these jobs??? Nobody tells you that in their videos... 😤

[@yeah5363]

November time

[@221b-Maker-Street]

Look at the date of the video - November! The description box even says "Cuttings in the fall". Also, it's a clip from BBC Gardener's World, which is a weekly programme filmed live, so each episode focuses on the things to do *that week* in the garden. That's why he hasn't said as he assumes anyone watching will know - because it's now!

[@ГаляУфимцева-н7с]

Люблю передачи, уважаю Монти Дона, но Только ЛЮБУЮСЬ....хоть титры.

[@nl4064]

wilod rose is the only rose to grow and the bees agree

[@evafenyves3596]

Jó lenne magyarul

[@GumriRN]

Did anyone pick-out the name of this rose? The Closed Caption I'm sure is wrong; written as "Ocampo Carter." Maybe it was Ocampa Cara? And is this a hedge "Rugosa" rose, which I understand are impervious to everything from Artic cold to salty seashore conditions. Wish a "Rose Expert" on You Tube would actually show us what the "Successful Rooting" looks like & how to plant them once rooted.

[@Hidehorticulture]

Rosa complicata - look at his label at the end of the snip.

[@GumriRN]

Oh wow, you really got an ear for the Brits. Thanks I did hear it too. :)

[@regulasieber2119]

L

[@ducaschoenberg7156]

I did it myself. I used Woodglut woodworking plans for this.