Talking: Stormtail

this cat smells weird

[@marymccann3500]

Bluestar's mentor was a better father to her than Stormtail was

[@Feuersturm]

True

[@Get_Stuff3d]

Totally!

[@jeriko_studios]

And thats... depressing

[@Get_Stuff3d]

@@jeriko_studios yeah

[@mapleboo]

@FallenLion Art yes. Both of them

[@GracieFitzpeter]

I remember when I read Bluestars Prophecy as a 13-14 year old I interpreted Stormtail as being kind of a skeevy middle aged guy who liked Moonflower because she was young and pretty but then bounced out as soon as she had children. He then moved on to the next young pretty thing and ended up staying with this one much longer since she didn’t have children (or at least while they were together) I remember Goosefeather had a line that stuck with me, when he told Bluekit “you’re Moonflower’s kit and she’s the smartest cat I know…About most things, anyways.” While he’s looking at Stormtail. Which I thought was interesting back then, like it was saying that Moonflower was an extremely smart and capable warrior but even she missed a lot of red flags. I dunno, I doubt any of it was purposeful. I don’t like the huge age gaps in warriors but if they’re going to do it it’d be nice if there was acknowledgment of it being extremely toxic. Like if Dappletail got pregnant and Stormtail once again bounced and Bluefur realized that she had absolutely no chance of ever gaining his respect and in fact wasn’t someone who she wants to respect her anyways would have been interesting. I dunno.

[@PorkysPorky]

Now that I think about it that’s exactly what he’s like

[@Birbzz]

You were in deep thoughts as a 13-14 year old I was an idiot

[@thepinkelephant2520]

Honestly same

[@kitsuneWC]

Such a bad husband >:( Moonflower was like brainwashed with stormtail and didn't realise

[@asiangang0522]

ik stormtail liked dApPlePAw but i domt think they dated

[@GippyHappy]

I feel like the conversation between Stormtail and Bluefur was meant to be an important moment for her character in that the only piece of advice her father ever gave her was "life sucks, get over it, and work hard for your clan" is something she clearly lives by and is what slowly destroys her. She puts her clan above her own happiness and her children. And when that makes her miserable and unfulfilled she goes right back to hating Starclan the way she did right before Stormtail gave her that advice. Her not getting any resolution from Stormtail kind of makes sense given how it impacts her actions and personality, retroactively.

[@Moonkitti]

even if something can make sense retroactively, it certainly wasn't intended that way when that conclusion is never drawn in the book itself

[@GippyHappy]

@@Moonkitti idk maybe they're just bad at writing 😂

[@Draconicdisciple]

@@Moonkitti The book doesn't need to tell you everything to make it true, that's why most writers are told to show not tell.

[@Moonkitti]

@@Draconicdisciple Yes, sure, but the book clearly is trying to display the exact opposite of this sentiment with her resolution with Stormtail. If you read it it's clear they intended for it to be a meaningful resolution.

[@BravestarBDB]

I would love to hear you talk about Rowanclaw. He went from a pretty feisty (she)cat to a leader that let everyone walk all over him before dying. I know his leadership has been heavily discussed but I want to see more of a focus on the change in his character up to the point/brief talk about it. Also him and Tawnypelt don’t appear to have much chemistry (from what we saw beforehand) and yet were together in a seemingly decent relationship. Also his grandkid getting named after him only to have the same issues of what gender they are and their looks between the alliances and what is described in book is so strange and makes me wonder if the name is cursed in a way.

[@paradox-they-them9039]

Rowanclaw wasn't a she-cat.

[@imaginarylivingbody7154]

@@paradox-they-them9039 He was referred to as a she-cat multiple times in earlier books iirc.

[@nightly-ruse2925]

I’d love a breakdown of his mindset and personality. He’s an interesting character especially bc he’s a purposely bad leader. Tho I do love him always think of Russetstar- like image what we could’ve had with a horrible overly controlling Russetfur as leader but no one listens to her so she’s constantly on the verge of breaking down. I just love Russetstar au she’s amazing

[@enderwalkgang]

@@imaginarylivingbody7154 canonically trans Rowenclaw based

[@BitchboyOzzie]

I wouldn't call being transgender a "curse."

[@cheesydelphox1552]

I would want a video about Brambleberry! She's a generically good medicine cat but not in an unlikeable way. I loved her in Crookedstar's Promise. and Tallstar's revenge. She's a good example of what medicine cats should be doing in the current main series, I think

[@ArrowAce6262]

Brambleberry's always been one of my favorite med cats. She was a way better motherly figure to Crooked than Rainflower.

[@lemoncardboard3270]

i really loved her and I kinda wish they went into how Stormkit/Crookedkit saw her as maybe not a mother but an older sister of sorts. They seem close and it was really cute. I also really like her name

[@Danmeilover69]

I really liked her too! I loved her interactions with Crookedstar and found them to be fascinating.

[@carolynsnead3076]

Not to mention talking to Jayfeather later in omen of the stars. She wouldn't give him the answer, but seemed determined to try and help him despite the "clan boundaries" in starclan

[@salmonwish]

I love Brambleberry! She's so interesting & definitely one of my fav warrior cats, I really hope Moon makes a video about her!

[@smoozegum]

i think an interesting talking video could be daisy. people are very split on their opinions of her but she’s a very sweet little kitty and her story intrigues me a lot. the fandom tends to dislike her either for her interactions with cloudtail or her decision to stay a nursery queen (but i think it might be warrior cats fandom sexism… just me though...) her kids are also a little silly i like mousewhisker & hazeltail enough and berrynose is. berrynose.

[@lemoncardboard3270]

YES!! I’ve always really liked Daisy but she’s always just kinda been… there. She’s either mindlessly agreeing with what the plot says she should or talking about kits/being a nursery queen. Her choice to keep her name is powerful too and I really wish we saw more bonding between her and Millie.

[@smoozegum]

@@lemoncardboard3270 RIGHT!!!! not a huge fan of millie but i think there couldve been a lot of openings for learning & growth if her and daisy talked more

[@lemoncardboard3270]

@@smoozegum I totally agree. I’ve always liked Daisy more than Millie but I felt as though Millie got more screen time.

[@Celeste-jh2lj]

Eh im not a huge fan. I didnt like her in the beginning bc shes very obviously not a warrior cat and wouldve been better off as a kitty pet. Idk why they fought so hard to keep her

[@wind_scratch8387]

I didn't really care too much about Daisy until I watched the "It Never Rains in Southern California" MAP. It really made me feel for her.

[@eucalyptusfox7553]

Anyways, huge props to Sunfall for being an amazing mentor and father-figure to Bluestar. The Best Father of the year award goes to him. So glad that he's been there as her replacement dad. Amazing father-daughter duo right there.

[@evies_roses6579]

I would love a video abt Juniperclaw because he honestly feels underrated despite the fact of him being actually really interesting. The way he helped Shadowsight both as a kit and in the dark forest was really sweet, and I think he definitely deserved to go to Starclan and it would be interesting to hear your thoughts on how his punishment was handled.

[@Softwing_]

Yes

[@evies_roses6579]

@Freetzy (Formerly npc Hunters) She hasn't yet made a talking video about him, but yes she did talk abt him a bit in I think it was her video abt a light in the mist? But still I feel like there's a lot in his life that's interesting to talk abt outside of his sentence to the df (him poisoning skyclan food stores, saving shadowkit from drowning, ect)

[@mmmm-lg2mj]

He or Leopardfoot, I would love

[@ryguy7663]

already ranted about him in that light in the mist vid, a talking video would just seem like a repeat

[@yukimizukisisterstudios7366]

Yes!

[@miragracestudios5104]

To this day, I still sigh when I hear about Stormtail 😭 I should also note that the drawings in this are god tier. I laughed SO HARD they are the funniest thing 😂

[@newabbmantics]

Agreed

[@AGenericPerson984]

SCREW MY PRETTY EAR I LOOK COOL AS SHI-

[@GweenOfTea]

I would love to see a video about Jagged Peak! He's a disabled cat that doesn't really get much attention compared to other disabled cats and faces a lot of ableism from Gray Wing which is really annoying when the writers prove Gray Wing right rather than Jagged Peak

[@quince3664]

Never heard of Jagged Peak before sadly, hopefully he gets a video soon.

[@arex1072]

I love all dawn of the clans cats except for clear sky

[@iiTsukiidiscontinued]

I also hate Holly and she ruined him.

[@GweenOfTea]

@@iiTsukiidiscontinued why do you say that? Genuinely asking btw not in an argumentative way I thought Holly gave him more confidence in himself to realize that he's no less of a cat because of his injury, HOWEVER I have not read Mothflights book

[@iiTsukiidiscontinued]

@@GweenOfTea I can’t quite remember but I do remember that she didn’t like Greywing and that rubbed off onto Jagged peak. So she would say something rude to him about breathing problems and she would join in. He’s also very rude in Mothwings book.

[@Kay9youtube]

I'd love to hear your thoughts on Blackstar. He was the deputy for two Shadowclan tyrants and gained a redemption arc (if you can even call it that because Blackstars Reckoning was pretty bad in my opinion) upon becoming leader. He was the cat who managed to restore Shadowclan after Brokenstar and Tigerstar and I'd love to see more of him. He is a very morally grey character which we don't tend to see much in leaders of warrior cats. They're either completely good or completely bad. Blackstar is neither, he's more of a chaotic neutral. Also the dynamic between himself and sol was waaaay more interesting to me than whatever lionblaze or hollyleaf was doing at the time

[@imaginarylivingbody7154]

Blackstar is epic.

[@Danmeilover69]

I totally headcanon that Sol and him were lovers. Bit out of love, at least for sol, but as a way for him to further manipulate the shadowclan leader.

[@imaginarylivingbody7154]

@@Danmeilover69 Diversity win! The war criminal kitty cat is gay.

[@billcipher8645]

@@Danmeilover69 I headcannon is as more one-sided love. Blackstar loved Sol, Sol just used that feelings to his advantage. Later the big reveal happened and they broke up lol

[@MentalMetalNyan]

THIS.

[@saturnbubblez]

I really want one about Foxleap! I find him to be a surprisingly interesting background character compared to the rest of the cardboard cut-outs. One of the few completely unimportant background characters that DOES still have some sort of personality! And I mean…. By himself, not just him and Icecloud. I feel like he should’ve had kids so maybe we could have some more ginger cats NOT related to Firestar.

[@lemoncardboard3270]

Agreed. Also him wanting his warrior name to be Foxcatcher is very cute.

[@eliteemerald8636]

@@lemoncardboard3270Foxcatcher suits him nicer in my opinion

[@yikes7373]

I agree with this!! I headcanon foxleap as having adhd :]

[@FROSTED_LIGHTS]

@@yikes7373 OMG THATS SO FUNNY- because I also have that headcanon! It honestly just made sense to me.❤

[@beastmaster0934]

@@eliteemerald8636 Ehh, I like both names.

[@calliesauce]

I think a video on Star Flower would be awesome!! We hardly got to hear much of her after her villain arc, and after she bore kits. She kinda just transported from a main antagonist to a background character.

[@cheesydelphox1552]

i wish i could like a comment twice because i REALLY want a star flower video

[@Celeste-jh2lj]

I hated her. She played with Thunders heart then shattered it by being with his father which is just 🤢

[@WeirdCatLover]

@@Celeste-jh2lj I painfully disagree with ya there bud. She never really liked him. Besides, Violet Dawn was a better mate for Thunder

[@Celeste-jh2lj]

@@WeirdCatLover i didnt say she liked him. She played with his heart. Which she did. It was obvious he liked her. Didnt mean she liked him. I just thought it was gross she played him then became his fathers mate. Thats just gross in my opinon

[@WeirdCatLover]

@@Celeste-jh2lj Yeah she should have made it clear to him that she didn’t like him back, I agree with you on that. But who cares if she got with his dad? As long as their both adults I’m fine with it.

[@brightscarecrow7326]

I would say that the antithesis to Stormtail would be Shellheart. Crookedstar’s father. Shellheart was a good dad who stood up against his (former) mate Rainflower’s cruelty towards his son. Iirc (it’s been years since I’ve read Crookedstar’s Promise) he was a very encouraging and loving figure in Crookedstar’s and Oakheart’s life

[@stordoe]

Fr Shellheart was one of the best fathers in the Warriors series.

[@howlerbrine]

I personally would like to see a talk on Darkstripe. Sure he's more major than other suggested characters but he's such a fun character to think about. Mostly. His undying loyalty to tigerstar, his vendetta against firestar and his relationship with his half siblings are all interesting. And his whole character makes him seem like some sort of loser and I find that funny, especially for warrior cats. I mostly want to hear people talk about him because I think his character being a loser is funny tbh 😭

[@dangernoodleproductions8383]

We can all agree that he had some sort of affection for Tigerstar. This would 100% be fun to hear though.

[@CeaselessEnemy]

He was literally like "why did I go to Hell? : ( " which makes me laugh.

[@RandokatTheOnion]

Could you talk about sol? He’s lazy, and his backstory is interesting. Another reason it that he’s a male tortoiseshell, and he talked to midnight, a rouge, talking to a badger. I would love a talking video about sol. He’s also just my favorite lol

[@Jenny-it9iz]

What’s up with these full grown ass cats seeing a small kit and thinking “wow that newborn is beautiful, i’ll make her my future wife”??????

[@newabbmantics]

Talking Goldenflower? She’s been a character on my mind. I would love to hear your thoughts and comments on her. Edit: I think you mistaken Stormtail’s name for Stormflower.

[@imaginarylivingbody7154]

I honestly forget that Stormtail is canonically Bluestar's dad. He has such little impact on the books beyond being an absent father. Like the guy lives in the same community with his children and yet doesn't talk to them? Did he and Moonflower ever even talk in Bluestar's Prophecy beyond "hey look at our children"? Still kind of wild that Dappletail is said to have kits with RUNNINGWIND when Stormtail was right there. Just get rid of the line about her being barren and have Bluestar mention that Stormtail didn't give a crap about his other children (one of whom was stolen by a fox?) in the last chapters. (Edit: it would be interesting growth to have Bluestar crave his attention and respect initially but then realize that she doesn’t care if he respects her or not, because he sucks) Overall a very bad kitty.

[@bitteralmonds2614]

I really want to hear you talk about Shrewclaw from Tallstars Revenge. I think he’s a really interesting character and nobody really talks about him. Despite him being so important to Tallstars revenge, he seems kind of forgotten, like nobody remembers he exists. He also has a very complicated relationship with Tallstar, that once again, I find really interesting. Overall I think he’s neat and I want to hear you talk about him.

[@SproutTalks]

Seconded!

[@alyssasauce3844]

Yes this, please! Something else that is never mentioned at all- Mudclaw is Shrewclaw's son (as well as Tornear) and I think that is such an interesting addition to both Shrewclaw and Mudclaw's characters, that get completely overlooked.

[@swiftreii8864]

Lol well both picked Shrewclaw and our opinions on him are completely different

[@Danmeilover69]

I love how Shrewclaw and Tallstar play off of each other. Their interactions are fascinating to pick apart. I love how when you get to the end you see how Shrewclaw wasn't ever trying to be cruel. Tallstar just had such a jaded and negative view of the worldthat he interpreted Shrewclaw's behavior the wrong way.

[@lionblaze0384]

keep posting Shrewclaw and I'll keep liking it

[@Kiterally]

I would love one about Hollyleaf! she's my favorite character and I feel like there's a lot to talk about with her, not just about her parents but about the prophecy, being a medicine cat then warrior, her relationships with Willowshine and Cinderheart and Fallen Leaves, having so much potential, etc! I personally love how Hollykit wanted to be respected and looked up to and that's why she chose to be a medicine cat (until she learned that she was better as a warrior), I think it was a nice change from the typical "I want to be a warrior so I can fight the other clans to protect my clan" or "i want to be a medicine cat because i love healing cats" kinda thing that the majority of cats have. I also think it's so sad how she spent her entire life dedicating it to the warrior code and starclan and then believing she had a purpose with the prophecy, only to learn later that starclan chose only her brothers and specifically excluded her. I could go on and on lol, I just think she's an interesting character

[@spectacularslowpoke6018]

Sunstar I feel is very under appreciated- I would love to hear a talking video about him, he basically became a father to Bluestar

[@thewingedcheetahwolf2615]

Yessss

[@the-spork-consumer]

Definitely! He practically zapped out of existence during timeskips in Bluestar's Prophecy, despite him being such an interesting background character.

[@dawnsunlight]

I would love to see a talking or mini talking on Icewing. She is one of the few modern RiverClan cats who has done literally anything, for example she was a Dark Forest trainee, and I just want to see more people talk about her honestly.

[@angstyabby]

I think that Thrushpelt could be a could candidate for a talking video. He never showcased bitterness over Bluestar having kits with someone else and filled the role of the kits father happily,(and he also was even more involved with his foster kits more then most toms are even towards their biological kits except maybe Dustpelt). To me he’s just a sweet Cinnamon-roll character, and even though he’s a background character he makes an impact. Also he is just one of the more interesting background characters

[@willowwhisper4148]

I would really enjoy a video about Ashfoot she’s extremely underrated. I think she’s just a nice cat in general. She struggled as deputy right after being named it. She was also Crowfeathers mother. After her death Ashfoot kept on visiting crowfeather saying she couldn’t go to starclan until he’s happy. And it would be be nice to hear your opinion on her. :)

[@spectacularslowpoke6018]

I feel like a talking video about Needletail could be interesting - just because she is interesting to me and I would love to see an analysis of her - she’s not in that many books but manages to leave a huge impact regardless.

[@thegoatcarnival]

You should talk about Shellheart, Crookedstar and Oakheart’s father. I sort of liked his character when I read Crookedstar’s Promise but that was way back when. I don’t remember much about his character other than he apparently died of a “painful lump in his stomach” and that he dumped his wife over the whole Stormkit-Crookedkit thing.

[@Celeste-jh2lj]

I really liked him and how he defended crookedkit. It was surprising to see a cat call out abuse the way he did and the fact it ruined their relationship instead of him just ignoring it or even supporting it. It was refreshing

[@klltx2001]

@@Celeste-jh2lj It's too bad the Erins ruined it by saying that Shellheart always loved Rainflower... even tho she abused their child. Great, thanks Erins.

[@Celeste-jh2lj]

@@klltx2001 well you can still love someone despite them being a shitty person. As long as you arent excusing and allow their behavior, which shellheart doesnt allow if he can help it. Thats why some people break up, despite their love, the partner is toxic and thats not ok to the person.

[@fireworksforme2]

I believe it was confirmed he died of cat cancer?

[@thegoatcarnival]

@@fireworksforme2 yes, when I read it I recognized that “painful lump” as a tumor as my dog had a similar one on her leg.

[@dove5777]

I would love to see a mini-talking on Silverflame or Palebird! I think Silverflame is super underrated and would love to see some opinions on Palebird.

[@user-zx9hm6wl8w]

palebird goes from distant to kinda hostile towards talltail before making peace with him

[@SproutTalks]

I would love a Tallstar talking video! He has the super edition with arguably the best plot and character development, but also the most glaring example of Harper Collins stymying gay relationships in the series. If you were reading the series as a little kid back in the day, you got to see his story play out in medias res, starting from a low point in his leadership to WindClan returning to the lake, then watching his decision-making come into question when he suddenly makes Onestar his successor. But then in his SE we get context for where he came from. I think that this famously pacifist leader having such a bloodthirsty drive in his youth is really interesting.

[@swaanm]

Maybe a Cloudtail video? I’ve heard about a million different ideas about what the kittypet food is supposed to represent, and he was an atheist before Mothwing was. Maybe I’m stupid, but I also don’t remember him ever going into depth about how he feels about StarClan after The Great Battle like she did.

[@bluesheep7]

Wait, does the kittypet food represents something? wut.

[@swaanm]

@@bluesheep7 In my opinion, it doesn’t

[@vulpage]

The way Bluestar was treated in Bluestars phrohecy always made me so angry even as a child, she lost everyone she ever loved and her clanmates acted like she was ridiculous for "mourning for too long" and needed to move on like she didnt lose her mother and sister is horrible ways and as far as they knew all three of her NEWBORN KITS were taken and eaten by foxes. But my bad guys right she had a job to do bc otherwise the leader wouldve just HAD to choose the bloodthirsty idiot as a deputy instead and not like fucking thrushpelt or smthn.

[@masonbeeeeees]

I think it would be interesting to hear your thoughts on Mudfur! I think he has an interesting role as a medicine cat who was actually allowed to be present as a father in his daughter's life, plus I think his situation with Mothwing and his whole deal as a powerful warrior who chose to give it up is cool.

[@arrow21OG]

I would love to hear you talk about Icewing. Icewing actually has a really interesting background- her son beetlewhisker died in the dark forest and she trained there as well, she got held captive and starved by darktail, she disagreed with Mistystar and got kicked out of riverclan (lived with shadowclan for a while.) Not like the books will ever treat her as a true character because she isn't important, but I really like her! I hope she becomes Riverclans leader!

[@miink1861]

I think a video about falling feather and Jackdaws cry would be good, They’re interesting characters and their death was one of the most impactful in the series for me.

[@yes6651]

Definetly agree

[@Dragonemperess]

Same, close littermates that may as well have been twins killing each other at the same time. Loving sibling spent their last moments with the blood of the other in their mouth. If Falling Feather is the same cat I'm thinking of that Skystar called "as low as a snake's belly" (or something like that, for assisting with something I don't remember), then with the way she behaved just before the Great Battle compared to her in the other books implied to me that Skystar's treatment of her broke her and I felt pity imagining what he could have put her through. To be honest, that death was gut-wrenching, but it almost felt like a mercy for Falling Feather to me. Like Jack had to put her out of her misery, even if he went down doing it. It probably wasn't as bad as that, but that's what it felt like.

[@fishbal]

I never thought of Stormtail as a good cat. I remember being mad at him in Bluestar’s Prophecy because as soon as Moonflower died, he immediately starts flirting with Dappletail. Not to mention that in the battle that she was killed in, Stormtail helps Dappletail fight off a warrior. Which wouldn’t be a problem, but at the same time Moonflower is literally getting chased and attacked my multiple warriors and everyone else is occupied, but Dappletail is capable of defeating a warrior on her own. Not to mention when they’re returning to camp he doesn’t comfort his own kids. His obvious attraction to young she-cats is concerning, even more so when you factor in how young Dappletail is in comparison to him. Sure, so was Moonflower, but holy gosh Dappletail… and the Erins choose to write this. Sure, character stuff, but it’s just gross.

[@calliethewolfcat2183]

Unfortunately, I don't think even the Hunters put much thought into either Stormtail or Oakheart.

[@injunghugh9617]

I would really like one about Weaselfur! He's always aggressive to ThunderClan, but he is always defeated and he ALWAYS runs away. I find him funny. I also think that there's more to him in Crowfeather's Trial than cat who hates Breezepelt. He lost his brother in the battle against the DF, so he had a reason to be mean. His redemption arc was good to see too.

[@musicplaylists6718]

I think a video about Willow Tail would be great! I think she's a very interesting character and is severely underrated. She was saved by Wind Runner as a kit, only to be not recognised and outright shunned when they meet again as adults. She loses her brother and friend to dogs, yet only mentions her friend when getting revenge on the cat who she views as at blame. She starts an entire war over this friend, a cat that has nothing to do with the clans, causing the deaths of several cats as far as I'm aware, and yet is let into StarClan. I think she has a lot of potential, I'd love to hear your thoughts on her and honestly?? I just want her to get a bit of spotlight.

[@daisybloomfuzz7463]

I love this idea! Willow Tail REALLY surprised me in Mothflight’s vision!

[@musicplaylists6718]

@@daisybloomfuzz7463 I thought it was a neat twist as well, I'm really glad to see not everyone glossed over her :)

[@rengie-feather8]

Yes!

[@audge-audge]

I cried when Willow tail died XD

[@Mossfall]

I'm so glad that someone finally started to talk about Stormtail. Seriously, when I just started reading Bluestar's Prophecy I already hated him. He disappeared in life of his both daughters and Moonflower, he just starts to have interest in Dappletail which just freaks me out. He was a terrible father figure to his daughters, I'm glad that Sunstar was more like a father figure to Bluestar after her mother's death. OH YEAH, and Stormtail DIDN'T EVEN REACT to his mate death, it's so messed up... I just want to say that he's an awful character, I really want him to go to the dark forest instead of star clan, like REALLY. I JUST CAN'T THROW THESE FACTS ABOUT STORMTAIL AWAY. Anyway, Moonkiti's video disccusing is truly amazing!! ❤️ (I'm sorry if my grammar is so wrong:'))

[@jusminejustice2794]

I have been noticing that not many people are talking how bad of a father he is.

[@Mossfall]

@@jusminejustice2794 Indeed!

[@winsorsl]

I think that maybe SunStar would be a good cat to talk about. He was there for BlueStar when her mother died, and ultimately was much better than Stormtail was. I also think that his crush on Moonflower would be a fun topic to discuss.

[@MarbleSodaPop]

Maybe you could do a video on Redwillow? He's one of the only Dark Forest trainees who fought for the side of the Dark Forest besides Breezepelt. He also was the only cat who died during the Great Battle who went to the Dark Forest. He appeared later in The Broken Code, but he doesn't do much and disappears into the dark water. He really doesn't seem to have a real motivation besides that he was somehow corrupted by training in the Dark Forest.

[@dovewingseyesaregreen5664]

I am once again requesting Icecloud and Foxleap. Frequently bought together, do not separate. I know I'm not the only one who thinks they were done dirty when they got killed off in the space between OotS and AVoS (them and all the other young cats and Spiderleg that got killed offscreen in that timeframe).

[@waveeyes]

Agree, Foxleap deserved so much better. He's one of the most unique side characters and he's just really fun to see. Icecloud was cool too, but to me her brother stands out way more.

[@pinkydee10]

Everyone brings up Moonflower and Dappletail’s age difference to Stormtail, but why does no one seem to remember that Leopardfoot was still Leopardkit when Pinestar became leader

[@potato3322]

can u talk about jagged peak, he goes from this upbeat and defiant kit to a depressed and resentful adolescent, then finds happiness and a mate in holly as an adult, but they unfortunately bring out the worst in each other. i just find it interesting how much he changes from the beginning of sun trail to moth flights vision while simultaneously going from one of my favorites of the DotC era to one of my least favorites

[@damonricotello]

I feel like a video about Scourge would be interesting! He's only really in two books but he's probably one of the most iconic cats fandom/ design-wise which is fascinating for how little he's actually in the books..

[@skiidaddle.]

I think a Goldenflower video would be interesting. Goldenflower was a loving mother to Swift, Bramble, and Tawny, but the authors didn’t tell us how she reacted to Bramble becoming deputy, Swift’s death, her kits leaving after Midnight, etc. As well as her being former mates with one of the biggest villains in the series. (And they didn’t give her a death scene..)

[@krdt1111]

I would want to see a talking video on ivypool, she was a main character, lost her kit to the very thing she spent a ton of her life trying to get rid of and I think is a very good contender for a new leader because at this point I think squirrel flight will just retire with bramble

[@Wood-Song]

Please make a video about the breezepelt babies

[@AppleFlowersAJ]

Yes, pleeease

[@RachelWCUE]

That would be amazing!

[@Razoria_The_Therian]

Wait.. one of the breezepelt babies is Woodsong! 🤔

[@dbhdjdjfrbsnbdickehxjxjc1149]

YEEEEEES

[@quailstep]

Ooooooo, yeah!

[@alliemae9820]

I would really love it if you talked specifically about Jayfeather and Squirrelfights parent child relationship. They always seemed so close and because of his powers he knew she never pitied him for being blind and even after the reveal he knew she loved him and regretted losing her kits more than being shamed and losing her mate. Lionblaze and Hollyleaf especially break off from her after the reveal but in the recent arcs it even mentions Jayfeather defending her and comforting her over the imposter stuff. I love their relationship he even goes out of his way to mix her traveling herbs to be tastier as an apprentice and acts embarrassed when she notices- In that same light leafpool also seems jealous of how close they are even tho we know shes jealous in general we see it with jay a lot because when jaypaw interacts with squilf leafpool is usually there too. Love you moonkitti!!

[@goober435]

I think you should talk about featherwhisker! He’s never really talked about and most (if not all) of his emotions are completely ignored from the books and the fandom, he is seen only as a basic, nice medicine cat that mentored Spottedleaf and was apprenticed by Goosefeather-two characters that completely outshined Featherwhisker’s overall character in general, its not like Featherwhisker had much going on anyways but it’d be rlly cool to hear what you have to say about him!

[@Resident_minor]

I was wondering if you could talk about WhiteClaw!!! The cat that greystripe threw off the gorge in fire & ice. I just think he’s really cool in leopardstars honour :3

[@nightfindr]

WHITECLAW MY LOVE a talk about him would be so cool,,,,also how he got thrown into the gorge by his crush’s boyfriend,,

[@Resident_minor]

@@nightfindr A fellow WhiteClaw enjoyer !!!! :OOOO

[@marensadlowki5521]

I would really like to hear about Goosefeather. Since hes been a cursed cat since hes been a kit, already being an apprentice young, having his full name young, prophecies, visions, seing the future of Sunstar and Featherwhisker. Hes a really interesting character in my opinion and theres some things to talk about

[@meowing_wolf]

It would have been interesting to see how Bluestar would have interacted with Dappletail’s kits if they were her half-siblings, and I want to try writing a fanfiction with the assumption that Dappletail did in fact have kits with Stormtail. Those kits would likely experience the same lack of parenting that Bluestar did, and Dappletail might end up being treated the same way Moonflower was. Bluestar and Dappletail could connect over this, and Bluestar develops a bond with her younger siblings. Stormtail is simply a bad father and the narrative framing him as such is good. Making him unlikable is fine. Maybe his background could be more explored, but it shouldn’t justify his behavior.

[@_no_moon_]

Definitely agree on everything said here on Stormtail. Weird dude I cat I don’t see talked about often with a lot of potential for the new series is Hollytuft. She’s a bit spunky from what I’ve seen and I think could be an interesting person for Nightheart to interact with. They could have potential as friends, or even someone for Nightheart to confide in because she too is named after a long dead relative who did some important stuff. However Nightheart doesn’t really give her a second thought apart from when they’re on patrol together one time.

[@possumqe9751]

I feel like warriors is really lacking interactions/relationships like this now, most characters seem to only have mates and that’s it, POT is my favourite arc because there’s so many apprentices and characters with actual personalities (tell me one thing honeyfur or leafshade has done. please.) and they seem like genuine friends (and enemies at points, glances at berrynose and lionblaze)

[@i.i-i]

I think Crookedstar would be an interesting cat to talk about. He broke his jaw as a young kit, scarring himself and making his hate him and got his named change to something cruel. He ran away and met Mapleshade, who made him swear a promise that changed his life (plus faking an omen that made Crookedjaw question his deservance). We also got to see Brambleberry in his book who was a great cat towards Crookedstar and couldve been a better mother than Rainflower ever. Crookedstar eventually _stood up_ stood up to Mapleshade after all his heartbreak and self questioning. (you don't have to go too deep into mapleshade if you dont want to moonkitti but at least slightly mention (or more) her please)

[@grovejaws4842]

It would be cool to see a talking about Leafpool! She is my favorite character and i think there is a lot to be said about her relationship with starclan. And also basically she served as a temporary med cat within every clan at some point and even trained one of shadowclan's med cats. but despite everything shes done for other cats she was almost not allowed in starclan. i just feel like there is a lot of substance to her that is rarely talked about, and that shes often overshadowed by her sister within the fandom and conversations about warriors characters in general

[@ruesjunk]

I would love to see a talking video about Birchfall! He's the father of Dovewing and Ivypool, trained in the dark forest, was alive when they lived in the forest and lived through so many major events. He's underrated in my opinion!

[@sunnflare]

I forget, have we already done Spiderleg? The whole “bad dad” thing reminded me of him and I’d like to place a vote for him if not. Or Daisy, I think she’s amazing and a strong single mom if we haven’t done her either.

[@silversky2348]

I think that Sorreltail would be a good cat to talk about. She's mentioned for a while but ends up getting sidelined later in life. But she plays an important role and might have something to offer when it comes to talking about her.

[@glyphissketch]

goosefeather really do be a former talented and gifted kid

[@Neon_Swing]

I would *love* to hear you talk about Mousefur, she’s great. I love stubborn characters and Mousefur is just, so much so. I love her her.

[@lune_falls]

i think you should talk about fern leaf next! she's one of my favorite dotc cats and for once a dotc she-cat that doesn't die! she was an ex one-eye follower and and later on a reluctant spy for the moor cats which i found very interesting! seeing her finally getting to settle down and rest for once after everything she went through was really satisfying

[@rosewood8777]

I'd love to hear you talk about Speckletail, she was super loving to Snowkit, and was in denial that he was deaf, and after Snowkit died, she and Brightpaw sort of assigned each other to care for each other, which was really sweet, but I've never seen anybody talk about it

[@AxoBlu26]

I think it would be fun to talk about Daisy or Millie, they both get a lot of screen time in the books but they're not really main characters

[@EuqinimodArt]

I never realized that they had daddy issues, Snowfur choosing Thistleclaw out of all cats now makes sense. Her mother, Moonflower, did the same thing with choosing Stormtail.

[@imaginarylivingbody7154]

Thistleclaw was younger than Snowfur though. By a few months. Bluestar named him.

[@abrahamjean8176]

I dont think Moonflower had daddy issues, unless im reading your comment wrong.

[@snowfiredraws]

Can we please talk about Stick or Dodge? I find them to be interesting and Dodge’s vengeance towards Leafstar for helping Stick in SkyClan’s Destiny apparently inadvertently led to SkyClan’s downfall. Stick is alright and you can kinda see where his aggression is coming from, even if in the end, you cannot (and believe me, I don’t) excuse his actions towards Dodge’s gang, who were mostly afraid of him, minus a few loyal followers.

[@lemonpie_vanilla]

I'd love a talking video about Clear Sky of dotc! He's a great antagonist / villain and I love his dynamic with Graywing, his motive for the borders ect is also interesting.

[@What36868]

Stormtail honestly kinda reminds me of Dustpelt, and I think we all know why. Sure, Dustpelt didn't cheat on Ferncloud (who was a literal kit when he was a warrior) and he did at least help raise his kits a little but still. Dustpelt was interested in a Fernpaw, literally fresh out of the nursery, from the moment he set eyes on her. It's creepy. Apparently Stormtail was interested in Dapplepaw the moment he saw her too. While Bluefur was seen as having problems with Stormtail and Dappletail being interested in eachother despite the huge age gap, Fireheart thought Dustpelt having feelings for a LITERAL CHILD was "amusing"? Obviously there's more than that but I think I've gotten my point across. Ofc this hasn't been the only time it's happened, there are SO SO many cats having feelings feelings for cats WAY older or WAY younger than them; my point Warrior Cats seems to like normalizing p*dophilia, but it's very problematic. Not all series are perfect; they all have problems, but Warrior Cats has so many problems that it's insane..

[@crystalplayz3514]

Don’t lump in dustprlt with thistle claw and storm tail, he was a really good dad who raised his children a lot more than other warriors and a sweet good mate to ferncloud,and a loyal warrior

[@warriorofdramaclan8107]

Also Ferncloud was Dustpelt's NIECE!!

[@stordoe]

@@warriorofdramaclan8107 Oh my Jesus you're right

[@batbox_]

A character I’d love a video of is HeatherTail! I think she was a strong female character who inevitably fell victim to personality loss like a lot other she cats just to fit the role of a mate, but she was a no BS girl! And I love that! And I wanna hear how ud describe her. She had way more potential. Especially when it comes to her and DarkTail, there’s such good content that could’ve been explored, them being siblings and all

[@uglyfense7754]

She was consistently stubborn and determined well into Crowfeather's trial, not sure how she had personality loss.

[@katlord8612]

Why don't you do Tree? I think he's an extremely cool cat, coming from the sister's and his story with them.

[@_exolite]

One of my favourite scenes from Blusters prophecy is when Sunstar takes Bluekit out of camp just for a walk. I don't know why, but I found that kinda cool. I always saw Sunstar as a sort of cool uncle figure to Bluster.

[@asiangang0522]

honestly i feel like we should’ve had a conclusion for stormtail, swiftbreeze, adderfang, etc bc they got time skipped out if existence with sunstar and bc we never got to see most of them except for stormtail, but i feel like he should’ve gotten a redemption arc for a realization bc sunstar had to step in as father while stormtail was busy with dappletail

[@fawnycat4472]

A talking video about Frecklewish would be cool. She's misunderstood and seen as a bad person by lots of people, but i think theres more to her character than the cat that watched kits get washed away.

[@thegoatcarnival]

Stormtail is the Di Caprio of the Warriors universe.

[@MADRAMUZZLE]

Could we get a jake talking video? I think it would be cool to see your thoughts on tallstar and Jakes relationship aswell as his other mates

[@salt6200]

I would really like a video about stormfur, I think he is a really intresting character, being "dead" to the tribe for a point, and changing clans multiple times, having to adapt in multiplr situations I also really like his chapters in The New Prophecy. :)

[@Carpbay]

I feel like people don’t talk abt the fact Bluestar’s mother was groomed by Stormtail??? And then Stormtail went for a NEWLY made warrior.

[@Sheepie4055]

Can we get a gray wing video? He’s a pretty interesting character, my personal favorite if I’m being honest. He’s a sweet guy that is so full of love and wants to be able to share a nest with his kits and mate without worrying about them all suffering horrible deaths. He’s heroic, and still cares for his brothers even after being abandoned. Would love to hear your thoughts on him!

[@BreadDisposal]

I am here, once again, to humbly request Antpelt. Ever since I discovered him, I found him really interesting.

[@Patrick_Knowlton]

a very well-crocheted video

[@idothingssometimes8606]

I'd love to see something about Falling Feather and Jackdaw's Cry as I have the most random attachment to those two

[@willfraud]

stormtail waited for both moonflower and dappletail to turn 18 💀

[@CatraIsAdora-ble]

I read Bluestar's prophecy and I didn't know she even had a dad- I thought he was dead.

[@dali-dog]

I’d love to hear about Raggedpelt/star! Partially because he’s fresh in my mind since I just read Yellowfang’s Secret, and I think he might be fairly interesting to talk about- but also because I know you don’t like Yellowfang’s Secret, and I just really want to hear you rant about it lol

[@thewafflelord9621]

I think crookedstar would be an interesting cat to talk about, he had so much going for him and his story seemed well thought out and yet anyone rarely talks about him.(if not crookedstar at least a mini talk about his mate willowbreeze I just thought she was so sweet.)

[@Cottagecat2368]

“Yes, we know he was interested in dappletail, but- *BORING GUM.. FANCY GUM!*”

[@treefroag8607]

I dont know why but I fell like doing a mini-talk on Nettlebreeze and all of the really interesting elders would be nice (Rosetail, Nightstar, etc) Just an idea great content Moonkitti :D!

[@daisybloomfuzz7463]

I would love to see a video about Juniperclaw or Dustmuzzle(Mothflight’s Vision)! I love both characters and Juniperclaw could’ve been involved more. I was surprised to see him become some starclan/darkforest guard. Dustmuzzle is not very interesting but I’m curious about what you have to say about him.

[@musicplaylists6718]

Dust Muzzle*

[@daisybloomfuzz7463]

@@musicplaylists6718 I put names together, no spaces, srry

[@musicplaylists6718]

@@daisybloomfuzz7463 Why, if you don't mind me asking?

[@daisybloomfuzz7463]

@@musicplaylists6718 bc its a name, it’s like spacing the name Emily. Em ily. Most dont do that.

[@musicplaylists6718]

@@daisybloomfuzz7463 That was how they had the names back then though... if someone DID have a space in their name, it would be sort of rude to refuse to put the space there just because most don't do that. Anyway!! Sorry, not mad, just thought it was a little odd. Have a nice day!!

[@superfanamber]

Would love to hear a talk about Brambleberry! One of my favourite medicine cat characters and more of a mother to Crookedstar than Rainflower ever was.

[@temlikespienotcake8544]

I feel like one REALLY interesting character would be Ragged Star. He had skewed views and was a biased cat, but I feel as if he had good intentions, and still some bad ones. It would be interesting to heard you (MoonKitti's) views on a pillar of one of the franchise's most ruthless villans

[@MYHERO_2AM]

You should talk about Blackstar, did or did you not like his novella and other stuff. I just find him to be very layered but underdeveloped aside from the novella.

[@theblueblazing]

I think River Ripple would be interesting to discuss given that he's somehow getting a Super Edition soon. He's also a DotC character and I just really like that arc.

[@StillKURBBZ]

I’d like to hear you talk about Goldenflower I know technically she doesn’t really get any time to shine in the book and hearing her mentioned makes me happy idk I’ve always liked her for no real reason and want to know your opinions

[@hawktalon7890]

Honestly, I completely forgot Stormtail existed. That's how much impact he had.

[@finnsword8286]

What about a talking video about Hawkwing? I just think he'd be interesting as he's listed as one of your favorite cats your bio. We all know you like Squirrelflight and Dovewing, so I think hearing your thoughts about Skyclan's big buff and dumb deputy would be fun.

[@SonarTheBat]

Apprentices usually become warriors at 12 moons old, which is about 15 years old in cat years.

[@tundra5771]

A video on the original elders for thunderclan in into the wild would be cool

[@StinginqNettle]

You should talk about Rowanstar! The most useless father in the world.... maybe. I honestly don't know what to think about him. He is, or should be, a pretty big presence, yet he's very forgettable, despite being Tawnypelt's mate and Tigerstar II's father. That's my entire reason because my brain can't think very well.

[@briannacarter5146]

Maybe a mini talking for Brightflower? She seems kinda like a generic mother figure but it was definitely... interesting... when she immediately believed Yellowfang, her own daughter, killed her second litter.

[@koji2023]

Blue star confirmed has daddy issues. Your not alone, we can relate 😢