Moral or Evil : Decoding the Original Manu Smriti (Manava Dharma Shastra) in Sanskrit

[@jitendrainamke646]

No controversy, just go on. We are eager to know the true knowledge.

[@ABhattacharya]

Oh my! Sanskrit channel is gaining ground...people ARE watching and contributing. Wow! I was one of the older fans and wanted the channel to grow....you are AMAZING!!!

[@Rohit-ij7mb]

Well said. I m one of older fan of this informative channel and happy to see people now realising the greatness of Sanskrit and our logical dharma

[@ABhattacharya]

@@Rohit-ij7mb Yes, Sanskrit is logical for sure!

[@shahindranmoonieya4742]

After I watched this presentation for a second time, I still hold to the fact that you are quite brilliant! well done and thank you for your service to all of our people all over the world!

[@SmartRPh24]

I’m pleasantly surprised to see that this channel has grown considerably since I found and subscribed to it. I was so impressed with the thought behind this channel and that someone thought of doing the research and putting out content on this ancient language and texts. I had made a contribution early on but maybe a subscription is a better way to go about supporting it. More power to you 🙏🏽

[@smitaaga]

Very nice effort I really wanted to know about Manusmriti in Sanskrit itself. Thanks a lot 🙏

[@uday-pm1ml]

🔥Burn Manu Smriti , Jai Bhim ✋

[@fitlit]

​@@uday-pm1ml read it first before burning.

[@moumitanandy8162]

​@@fitlit they won't. They will just blindly follow other people and will blame us saying that we are creating divisions or castes divisions. Whereas they have no interest of being one with us at all and following the true meaning of our sanatan dharma books. They follow B R Ambedkar but if u ask them about what Ambedkar ji told about Muslim community of India, they will completely shut their mouth. These people only have issues with everything about Sanatan dharma and that is also without knowing the real meaning, they just want to look like cool people may be. God knows.

[@uday-pm1ml]

@@fitlit we trust babasaheb ambedkar , no need to study castismSmruti (manusmruti) 😄

[@fitlit]

@@uday-pm1ml good for you.

[@shanthsp2002]

Wish people had patience to listen instead of blindly believing the misinterpreted versions by anti Hindu elements.

[@rajapalamittam2443]

Thor. 😂😂😂😂 If anybody is misinterpreting the treatise on the social structure it is primarily the Brahmins who distanced people from them, the measurement being the caste of the person, In practice Hindu upper castes have had one grand sway over each other; each defecating on the one below in caste all the way downwards until the Dalits wear the brunt of all this nonsense.

[@digitalbath6057]

​@@rajapalamittam2443 i think 75 years of independence, your tribe hasn't exactly won anything in any dept. You can blame high caste but then it is just a title. Jains, Sikhs, parsis, jews, Tibetan refugees etc succeeded as a community and you think it is caste system kept you behind? You think if someone cares if brahmins think they are high caste?

[@sureshp751]

​@@rajapalamittam2443for your kind info their is no caste system in India, Brahmins reason of not allowing inside dity garbha guddi is different and due to few fellows in that caste( due to British force) they may have acted like it.

[@rajapalamittam2443]

@@digitalbath6057 Dude if you are not Brahmin nor Kshatriya then tell me which glorious era in the past of our sub continent you would love to go to and you will be sent there in a time machine on a one way ticket. Even the pre British era. Then you will know how animal like you will have to live and how badly chewed up were your own ancestors of that period. Now you may tell me it is all my thoughts. No it is not my thoughts it is what I saw with my eyes. People were distanced, were referred to up to the face as miserable louts. Education and healthcare were not provided. They worked at all times. Lived in leaking hovels during rains. You are the kind who close your eyes to the suffering your own ancestors went through and believe the caste system is a fantasy which the British thought up and imposed on India. Today you live under the Constitution a gift of the British educated men like Ambedkar, Nehru, Krishna Menon, Gandhi and others. The Indian Constitution was primarily influenced by the British Constitution. You breathing fresh air now just brush away the suffering of your own ancestors as fantasy.

[@rajapalamittam2443]

@@digitalbath6057 What makes you think that I am personally affected by the caste system.That I am at the bottom and you at the top. And you can shit on me. In fact my Khandan must have shat on your Khandan going by our caste nomenclatures. I am not the kind that stands in the hierarchy and views everything. I have my own perspective. I have an eagle eye view from above on the whole mess of the country. The situation is pathetic. You very simply say my tribe, your tribe. This itself shows your caste expression. I am free of any such nonsense and has only viewed the morons of the Indian Subcontinent as a bunch of morons. Pathetic.

[@rsbbpt]

A very commendable sincere effort! Congratulations for this! No controversy at all ! You are providing access to the ancient wisdom which has mostly been felt non-accessible to general people.Please continue the good work of raising awareness! It's important that we r aware of the gist of actual contents in the texts especially when malicious efforts are being made to bring down the culture and mislead the next generations. Thank you so much!

[@dvikauglaumishrauca]

I missed joining the live session. But I would have stopped you on giving your time of day to hateful comments and go straight to content. Main content starts at @34:00

[@jacquia.7340]

🙏🙏

[@guruprasadiyer]

Thank you.....a lot of time is wasted on explaining the position

[@anishkoppikar6789]

Thank you for discussing this... I am trying to understand why is this considered controversial.. People are trying to judge prehistoric texts with a 21st century logic. Hope people grow up and become humble enough so that they can learn more and evolve themselves .

[@karmaisntreal]

Because rapist BRAmans who rape dalit women and made her drink urine use this pre historic text to justify their deeds.

[@--Sreekarsai]

@minni5503 It is not dumb we cant say women are discriminated in hunter gatherers society because women are not given the role of hunters. Now a days we can say women are equal to men because most of job requires mind not physical work. If there is society where physical work is more then men will become more important to society,it will have different rules from us and it will feel women are discriminated through lens of our eyes.

[@vakarthi4]

@Minni Don't cherry pick lines that showcase discrimination and judge the book. Read it in its entirety. Manusmriti is just as harsh on Brahmanas who fail in their duties. If Manusmriti is applied today, most Indians would lose their Varna and become Shudra - so you automatically become equal. Read the book with a proper translation and then make these judgements

[@ronaknarkhede674]

@@--Sreekarsai You mean in todays age, if there is a family wherein the man is the breadwinner then nothing must be done independently, even in her own house?

[@shobhanareddy6063]

I really respect your focus and work sir . I wish you enormous success in making people realise the sense in adopting Manu Smrithis

[@Vivek_singh_s1]

Great endeavour and really courageous kindly do not stop the book that has so long being in deabte due to political reasons we need to know the correct answers, knowledge, Shiv shiv 🙏 🙌

[@bapparawal2457]

Guruji , please keep going on. We need to know what's written in our scriptures . धन्यवाद 🙏

[@Lokesh-lm8uc]

Great job brother, god bless you for removing the negative impression on manusruthi . Thank you so much ......🎉🎉🎉🎉

[@vvkumar4806]

I salute to you for the good work. Finally you made us understand that those who are speaking ill do not understand Samskrutam. Thank you vey much

[@pbpati9291]

Your explanations, minus the blame others, are gems. Request you to focus on the true meaning of scriptures which would benefit all.

[@subhodutta6163]

excelent video, will share to all of my friends. i am from far east assam

[@shreyashkalluri5912]

namaskaram

[@subhodutta6163]

@@shreyashkalluri5912 namaskaram🙏

[@shashimenon1000]

My mental status is truly just beginning to be engaged, listening in on this channel. Time to leave the 'pashu jeevan' behind. And I'm 72. What a waste. But then, all experience has some learning. I have to discover that, too. Thank you again. These last two years of 'vaanaprastham' have been astounding, to say the least. Three more to go. realise

[@Mrjicmqn]

Fix things with ur younger generation teach them dharma

[@gb-universe-9001]

Thanks for this effort 😊.

[@subbaraosanka2994]

Most needed in these times when ignorance of Sasthras and special hate towards Manusmruthi is spread in a campaign mode with frequent celebrations also. Dhanyavad and Namaskaram.

[@hajarmatveeva]

Waste of your precious time. Study Tamil instead. Pure language, vivid and beautiful with lots of quality literature to read.

[@subbaraosanka2994]

@@hajarmatveeva dear friend I appreciate your interest. It need not be 'instead'. It can be additional. People like you interested in literature should take pains to learn Sanskrit and other Indian languages also and explain the importance of languages to youngsters. The present matter is about original Sasthras and not language. Subham. Jai Bharath.! Vandemataram.!!! 🙏

[@tanumishra407]

Bhaiyaa you are doing great work Thank you for such a good content . Love from kashi .

[@bitrabhattacharjee220]

Thanks a lot for taking this kind of initiative. I always love your videos 🙏❤

[@sudhanshusharan5602]

Your program will be very interesting with you talking about Manu Smriti 😊👌🏽🙏🏽🇮🇳

[@sarojinichittoor45]

Such an inspiring and knowledge- filled video. We can bring in Sanskritham as a spoken language only if we sincerely try to speak without fear of making mistakes. Most of us understand that ManuSmriti is a misunderstood work but are unable to defend and ßpeak about the great truths it contains. Your video has come at the right time giving us such a wonderful perspective. Thank you so much and wish you all the success you deserve for enlightening us. May your good work bring about a healthy change in society.

[@jagadishsaligram9551]

I think we should look upon Dharma Shaastras as guides to lead a healthy, peaceful, fruitful fulling life, not as a set of rules to be followed, the violations of which entailing punishment. They guide every member of society to perform their duties in a manner that is good and just for all, and act as a firm foundation to a stable, peaceful, dynamic, and thriving society.

[@ashraypathania4342]

Very Great effort. Let there be a non political debate about writings and know not just the worst but the whole.

[@this-abledtheextravertedhe5299]

Thank you for tackling difficult subjects ❤️🤗

[@spunkdudeg]

Nice job bratha, may Bhagawan Shri Maha Vishnu bless you with immense knowledge. After videos about manu smriti please also if possible make videos on Parashara Smriti. Hara Hara Mahadeva

[@gowrishankarbharadwaj3975]

Excellent introduction - so pleased that you have been able punctuate the critical need of learning from our original repository as opposed to western agenda based translations

[@srinathcaitanya]

Very valuable approach to teaching Manu Smriti. I applaud you 👏👏👏🙏

[@strange_stranger725]

I found this channel today... And now loving it... Hope more and more people subscribe you..... Specially those who think hindu scriptures are illogical and discriminative

[@Uchita-salahadaru]

I like the way you discuss - very calm and cool🙏

[@mna5484]

Thanks for taking this subject. Please make this exhaustive podcast and expose the likes of Wendy donigier etc.

[@b11-x3o]

What about the Indian authors who translated it ?

[@Batega_toh_Katega_Hindu_108]

@@b11-x3o Some mistranslated it to demonise hinduism.

[@senseisky]

Ahaha I always heard it was controversial by the media But why ? Never explained It's like everyone is just riding the bandwagon without thinking and fact checking Thanks for bringing it up Turns out it's good and it opposes the consumer society and conglomerates giant & They need mindless consumers for profit not thinkers so they abused the language that's now not known to a lot of masses After watching your video i was able to connect a lot of dots about the foundations of sanatana society structures & why they are that way... And how the slavery period might have lead to the evils that originated through the period of destruction of foundations

[@daksh6388]

The social evil that exist in Christian and Muslim societies are because of their holy book, so people put alot of effort finding a source for social evil of hindu society. South was very much casteist throughout history, but that was not the case with North and central India. That's why you don't find stories of caste discrimination in North india but south has festivals dedicated to people who taught against caste or varna discrimination. Britishers came to india and documented thousands of castes, misinterpreted "varna" as "Jaati" and found the most book which could have lead to caste discrimination and BOOM they found manusmriti. Totally misunderstood it and believed that brahmins believe they are superior because manusmriti says so which it doesn't. And our respected most educated hindu BR ambedkar burnt manusmriti calling it the reason for caste discrimination, he spoke against Hinduism throughout his life, but if you read his books he was a misogynist person with no respect for women.

[@manusharma7487]

@@daksh6388 please elaborate misogynist, because that's the first time i heard about this. Example? sources?

[@daksh6388]

@@manusharma7487 He did alot of things for womens later on , don't wanna completely ignore his contribution for women's rights but still he had some serious issues with women joining politics pre independence.

[@daksh6388]

@@manusharma7487 found the source for you, he said things in his speech at nagpur 15/10/1956 , and it is documented in volume 40 . You can google it, and what I found is a reddit post because there is no article regarding this.

[@llj500]

​@@daksh6388 boobasaheb said women belong in the kitchen and they participating in election is biggest disgrace. He was a misogynist. I have seen it on reddit too. Those ex hindu people reported that post.

[@infinixultra.]

I feel happy to see this growing channel ❤👍

[@qwertyman9560]

Excellent initiative Sir! Looking forward to the series. One thing I wanted to point out - you said certain creatures - did you "Creatures" because you pronounced it as "Create-tures"?

[@ritukiran]

Shreyas Sir may i ask for a favor - i love ur lectures minus these hitches could you please upload edited vdos where u r delivering the pure sweet nectar of knowledge minus the opinions of others and other interruptions like buffering etc? will be highly obliged! :)

[@suga022]

It’s good to know the others views and when someone comes up to you with same nonsense, you will know where that person belongs to instead of you getting baffled.

[@zlibz4582]

amazing that you are taking up different shashtras , manuscripts , scriptures etc on the channel because even if they are available for free to the public most dont know sanskirt and most of these important and pure scriptures hold the eternal knowledge , can you please also take up gorakshnath samhita , and more samhitas which are widely important .............

[@SofiyaGustavo]

❤ from Ukraine... Even To understand basics of Sanatana Dharma one requires a lot of Pious Karmic balance ...

[@kadambarih.a9038]

Thank you for putting this together and available for us. Even with my rudimentary Sanskrit knowledge (high school language subject) I realize how much intentional mistranslation has been done of this text.

[@Tech.Maniac-X]

You did a great job bhrata! ♥️🙏

[@HGujarati]

This is of an immense value to discuss all Sanskrit texts that are left with the most destroyed. For naysayers, what do you have to say about Abrahamic books that have resulted in hundreds of millions of deaths, slavery, destruction of civilizations, destruction of the planet, etc.?

[@charithacaraboppa3674]

im in 11th, today my history sir talked about manusmriti and called it the law book. he also told that it was lessening the status of a woman and caste discrimination too. he talked about 'brahmanism' and told how post vedic period everything went down and became discriminatory. he told how brahmins got more 'power' bcs they were educated and was a link between god and local people and how they seriously discriminated other castes. :) i told what he was telling were only half-truths and tried my best to talk but he only always interrupted me and the fear of judgement caught me i cudn't speak confidently, i was afraid of getting cancelled by my class and esp my sir. i dont want to listen to his classes anymore.

[@sakom1834]

Good attempt my dear. Keep exploring and stand for real truth

[@anonymous-yl3pd]

My professor too did same thing

[@subhodeepmaji2975]

The brahmins by Hindu law were not allowed to amass wealth and were supposed to live in minimal subsistence. Many of the panchantra stories will have a "poor brahmin" character.there were a number of Shudra kings. The most famous was Mahapadma Nanda. The Nanda dynasty was conquered by Chandragupta Maurya who established his own Maurya dynasty which under his grandson Ashoka the great actually went on to become the greatest, largest and most powerful dynasty to have ever ruled the Indian subcontinent. One of the misconceptions of the caste system is that the hierarchy was based on economic power. It was not. The Brahmins in fact were an economically disadvantaged community because they could only live by teaching, performing rituals and by begging/charity. The Kshatriyas earned through wages and taxes, the Vaishyas through business and mercantile activities and the Shudras were land owners, farmers, skilled artisans and craftsmen and musicians who were highly respected and commanded very large incomes, as well as being the menial workers. The building of many temples and charitable foundations have been commissioned by the Chettiar and Velala castes in South India. In many districts the wealthy landowners are Shudras who actually employ Brahmins in their service. When India was in the golden age of the Guptas, and Sudras had expanded their roles to become the artisans, craftsmen, goldsmiths, silversmiths, stonemasons, potters, carpenters, builders, ship-builders, weavers, artists, dancers, musicians, traders etc. they were very well paid and many became extremely wealthy. Many Sudras became land and real estate holders and employers and then managed to activate caste mobility to become “high caste”. The idea that Sudras were always slaves and serfs is incorrect. In the Gupta period (300 to 600 CE), trade appears as one of the normal functions of the Sudras ………. And in this respect the brahminical lawgivers obliterated the distinctions not only between them and the Vaishyas, but in some cases between them and the first two varnas………. As artisans and traders the Sudras played an important part in promoting trade and industry which continue to be generally steady during this period. (Sudras in Ancient India R.S. Sharma pg 267 - 268. During this period (300 - 600 CE) we also hear of Sudra rulers such as those in Saurashtra, Avanti, Arbuda and Malwa. Along with them are mentioned the traditional Sudra, Abhira and Mleccha Kings, who all are described as reigning in the regions of the Sindu and Kashmir, and are assigned by Pargiter to the 4th Century CE. (F.E. Pargiter - Dynasties of the Kali Age p 55.) The first two Christian centuries were an age of crafts, commerce, gold and silver coins, trading ports and inland towns. In no other period of early history international trade thrived so much. Naturally the artisans (Sudras) came to the fore, as can be inferred from the epigraphical records of their guilds and donations. Free from state control the guilds could function effectively, and a large number of towns could provide alternative sources of livelihood to oppressed members of the lower orders from the countryside. (Sudras in ancient India p. 319

[@tjshivajith3683]

First of all namaskaram uday ji, everyone needs to to know the Truth.some narrow minded people struggling to overcome the same.

[@radheysherekar7973]

Great video. Please continue this series..

[@subbaraod45]

Manu smriti what Manu said - it is for you to follow it or not - talking bad of it only exposes your personality. Follow what you like kuran, Bible, vedas, upanishads, communism or what ever yourself - saying bad of others will recoil on you.

[@reenapaliwal5724]

Thanks a lot for this channel especially Patanjali Yoga Sutras

[@kalyugiexplorer]

Very good initiative, please keep it up...

[@vincentbrk]

Outstanding work 🙏

[@learning.healwithkamalika]

was waiting for this. thank you!

[@moushumikhatun3020]

The first, second and third Varnas were allowed to perform rituals unlike the fourth Varna. Women and Shudras (those from the fourth Varna) were prohibited from studying the Vedas since, according to the ancient Varna System, they were only expected to do the tasks allocated to them.

[@profitmegamood]

Ex Muslim from Pishor(Peshawar Pakistan) Sir. I now live in Guyana but working in Bolivia. I am following Hinduism now. Thanks

[@b11-x3o]

😂then speak pusthoo with me , let's see how much pishori are you

[@InvinciblePepe]

Close the Bible and open the Manu Smriti. It has an affirmation of life, a triumphing agreeable sensation in life and that to draw up a lawbook such as Manu means to permit oneself to get the upper hand, to become perfection, to be ambitious of the highest art of living. - Friedrich Neitzsche

[@MrEStreaming]

Manu… might also be understood from the perspective of: ॥ निर्वाण षटकम्॥ मनो बुद्ध्यहंकारचित्तानि नाहम् न च श्रोत्र जिह्वे न च घ्राण नेत्रे न च व्योम भूमिर् न तेजॊ न वायु: चिदानन्द रूप: शिवोऽहम् शिवॊऽहम् ॥ In the poisonous [“English” ‘man’ language], the subtle nuances of “MIND” is in its conception of a single minded ‘Grey’ matter mindedness… that is unfamiliar with such concepts. मनो नाहम् - the silo of memory, not… am I बुद्ध्य नाहम् - intellect, not… am I हंकार नाहम् - identity, not… am I And apparently नाहम् चित्तानि if मनो is stuck in that one minded gray matters of English language ‘Man’-ificationing and refashioning meanings… into patriarchal poetry’s… twisting things… out of context… for which there is a German word ‘Schadenfreude’ that sums it up best… The beauty of Sanskrit is the opportunity to an exacting of meaning so that this type of confusion and miscommunication can be irradiated. The 16 aspects of “MIND” so eloquently expressed, (embrace the punn here…), ‘trumps’ the gray-matter one-minded mindlessness of English and its ability to confuse everything it touches. In short, it’s context. Just like the class issue… put it into context… Sanskrit is humankind’s only hope for clarity and exactness of meaning. The Global Mental Health Pandemic is in English. Sanskrit is the vaccine. Get vaccinated! Namaskaram

[@pgkrishnaniyer7606]

The best Punishment for Udayanidhi Stalin is to make him sit through 50 hours of knowledge imparting peep into Sanatana Dharma by any expert!

[@vednote]

W soo big all groups who are ready to spam report cannot fathom and comprehend, thanks for the stream!!

[@viveknsharma]

Namaste Uday Bhaiya... Accept My Humble Pranams... Accept me as Your Younger Brother and a Disciple from Delhi... If I may, I requestYou to create a playlist on Manu Smriti, going in detail of this Great Work shlok-by-shlok... Namaskaram...🙏🙏🙏

[@naban77]

The Manusmriti is beautiful. If one can only understand the Manusmriti it will do a lot of good to their intellect. For those who can’t, do try harder. For those who are malicious, no hope for the malicious.

[@bikramroy5529]

And what about Manusmriti adhyay 2 sholk 32 to 40 ....bro it ect. But I can tell we should follow TRUE devotee of gods I am devotee krishna and mahakal mahakal and I probably says that we need to throw out this in dustbin

[@Vivek-3-12]

@@bikramroy5529 I think we should throw our copy paste constitution in dustbin first coz it gives us caste based certificates directly. Which is discriminatory.

[@sameer-fk8oy]

​@@Vivek-3-12 yes😂😂😂😂

[@Vivek-3-12]

@@sameer-fk8oy 😑🙏

[@sameer-fk8oy]

@@Vivek-3-12 🫂😃

[@xbio657]

Pls Make The Video On shiv Mahapuran Full Pls Pls....😔😟

[@HinduPhoenix]

Whole purana?

[@llj500]

​@@HinduPhoenix yes please

[@drgsrinivas]

Ignorance is the root cause of maliciousness. One can't be wise and also malicious...🙏

[@vineettyagi7973]

great work, please keep it up

[@vedhavallimeenakshisundara1716]

❤sanskrit is lovingly passionately learnt now.

[@uday-pm1ml]

sanskrit dead language 😄

[@nish5383]

मानवता, अहिंसा, नैतिकता, समानता,प्रेम,दया,करूणा,संवेदनशीलता, न्याय यह धर्म और संविधान कि मूल आधार रूपरेखा होनी चाहिए, दुनिया में जितने ईश्वरीय व्यक्तित्व अवतरित हुए, उनका हमेशा से यही संदेश और शिक्षा रहा मानव समाज के लिए ।

[@sapnabaldua828]

कृपया संस्कृतेन किञ्चित अधिकं वदतु, महोदय।🙏 Thanks for taking up the topic of मनुस्मृति, wished to know about it since some time. ( If possible please translate this sentence in संस्कृत )

[@satyanarayang6589]

मनुस्मृतेः विषयं गृहीतवान् इति धन्यवादः, तस्य विषये कदाचित् ज्ञातुम् इच्छति स्म।

[@sapnabaldua828]

@@satyanarayang6589 अनुवादस्य कृते धन्याऽस्मि|🙏🙏👍😊 उपरोक्तः वाक्यः सम्यक्, खलु?🙏

[@satyanarayang6589]

@@sapnabaldua828 सम्यक् इति ।

[@sapnabaldua828]

@@satyanarayang6589 🙏🙏😊

[@satyanarayang6589]

@@sapnabaldua828 🙏🏾🌝

[@sisirchandrachudmalladi751]

Thank you sir,i was really waiting for years for this knowledge I haven't read texts but was looking forward to the knowledge about caste division and wanted people to knowthat it's not about birth Why it is there and why is

[@rudraofficial592]

Discussion on Parashar smriti .positives and negatives will be relevant so.

[@nutanpanda6771]

Thank you so much.

[@namavenugopal8682]

We are going to be one million ❤️❤️

[@HGujarati]

The surname based system is clearly a fusion of feudal systems prevalent in the Middle East and Europe. It doesn't require a rocket science degree to understand. Even today many Mughal and colonial period setups are being followed from the police station to courts to everyday life. So yes it's head scratching that oppressors would have allowed hierarchy to be followed that's native when nothing native was allowed to be followed. I have yet to see everyday sarkari work that can be traced back centuries to Dharma. However even simple sarkari forms have traceability to Mughals and colonials.

[@aiLoveE]

namaskar, it wld be awesome if u cld discuss the entire Manu Smriti

[@siddharthapte1713]

@The Sanskrit Channel नमस्कारं गारु I do not know whether you have come across a channel by the name Satya Anveshi but there is a person by the name Manohar. He has made a series on How Manusmruti is the most Disgusting book. He has even called it worse than Quran and Bible. Please counter his points It is a humble request.Your excellent content and research will really help the society to enlighten. As certain section of the society may get misguided by his video and may start hating manusmruti like never before. Please it is a humble request but for that you may have to go through the filth which he has poured into his video but please do it garu for the sake of society.

[@sanjivgupta1418]

No need to be apologetic about Manu Smruti. It is required that someone who knows the texts, talks about them, irrespective of what they are about and controversial they are. Someone have to speak up.

[@relaxedkiddo]

Hindus don't need to be apologetic for anything. We've apologized and kept our heads down for a long time. No more. We need to share channels like this, iskcon channels, sham sharma show, ranveer alabadia, etc that focus on our religion and bharat. Pass this knowledge to needy and younger generations.

[@news_sportshbcuedu]

Audio and Visual both are fine🧘‍♂📿

[@nagarajarao8399]

Please suggest some good translations in english/hindi/kannada which can be relied upon.

[@b11-x3o]

You will be sad to know some (many)verses

[@uday-pm1ml]

🔥Burn Manu Smriti , Jai Bhim ✋ಜೈ ಭೀಮ್

[@sureshk-ie8yg]

@@uday-pm1ml If you trust only Ambedkar why do you visit this channel. Ambedkar great person but he is also human being. But Manu is son of Vivasvana (also known as Surya), the Sun god

[@tsunamiotoko6321]

Everyone should keep in mind the time and era of all ancient documents… in modern context they might not be so relevant but it might be years ahead of others in the world at that point of time… there must be controversial portion but also some interesting and basis of future progress

[@mashnasa1]

Caste oppression is a reality ? I agree , but suppression of "upper" castes by Indian state though reservations from cradle to grave, SC / ST law, scholarships, financial schemes etc...Uddaya ji , dont keep propagating the narrative unless you have data to back up.

[@anjalianand8437]

Abrahmic Invaders and their stooge politicians have tried their best to creat the monster called caste

[@Just_randomhuman]

Well, I'm hindu who went to cbse school and taught it was bad Without even reading once. P.o.v- must Read then keep it to our Community!!!!

[@gudakesa]

Gurudev , dont you think manu smriti and noah' ark (nuh) is same event? syria was a region where sanskrit was spoken and we find oldest sanskrit inscriptions in syria 3300bc. Mount ararat is near syrian and turkish border. They got only 1 book and we have libraries of books.

[@trollarasan]

nah it is from India Sanskrit was spread to Syria due to trade.

[@gudakesa]

@@trollarasan entire earth was snatan. So not point of origin. Indian barely made 1% archeology yet, we need to find more

[@ibarora4344]

All those people who hate Manusmriti have perhaps never studied it, I doubt they even know Sanskrit language

[@concernedcitizen4117]

How many people know Sanskrit language? If I were to hazard a guess it is not even 0.01% of the total population.

[@chinanumbawun111]

​@@concernedcitizen4117 These days Sanskrit is an optional language in CBSE and State Syllabus schools. I myself chose Sanskrit and learn it until my 2nd year BCom.

[@b11-x3o]

Lol you are funny man Arora , i doubt you have eben read it completely. 😊

[@uday-pm1ml]

🔥Burn Manu Smriti , Jai Bhim ✋

[@sureshk-ie8yg]

@@uday-pm1ml If you trust only Ambedkar why do you visit this channel. Ambedkar great person but he is also human being. But Manu is son of Vivasvana (also known as Surya), the Sun god

[@chaisma]

He secretly did not touch controversial part😂😂😂😂😂

[@manishmehta7739]

Namo Namah!!!....🙏🙏

[@dogged_unexpected6664]

Finally the most awaited series

[@b11-x3o]

Awaited for brahamns 😊only

[@sureshk-ie8yg]

@@b11-x3o You dont the meaning of Bramhana

[@MP-ol2iu]

"Why do people burn it adding to extra pollution that already exists!" was OP sir😂

[@hajarmatveeva]

Why do people burning dead bodies? This book is a pollution to the mind

[@MR.X9X]

​@@hajarmatveevabro are you atheist?

[@zf24d]

Keep up the great work 👍

[@somnath1235]

Let us not make the anti Hindus dictate what books we can read and what we cannot... They are just hippocrytes who don't react on those books which blatantly order non believers to be finished off...

[@b11-x3o]

Yeah let's clearly discriminate with shudras ! After all everything ancient is complete and final truth ! Hell I will even blindly follow a book even if it was written by a serial killer if it was written in sanskrit! After all its "ancient " , how can it be wrong ?

[@Rohit-ij7mb]

​@@b11-x3o No text of Hindu scriptures says to discriminate

[@trollarasan]

@@b11-x3o are you talking about your Abrahamic brethren? and dumb dumb every person is born shudra. It's shudras who produce the other three varnas that's why other varnas are called twice-born. no use talking to hinduhaters who have zero knowledge of Sanskrit or Hindu texts.

[@noone-hd1ck]

​@@b11-x3o did you watch the video?? I swear y'all are just purposefully ignoring all the truth at this point... If you ever have free time in your life go and actually READ the manusmriti instead of just commenting it's bad because daddy told you its bad. The manusmriti clearly states that varna is not decided by birth but rather by your actions. A child of 2 shudras can be a brahmin and a child of 2 brahmins can be a shudra. Again, educate yourself

[@noone-hd1ck]

​@@b11-x3o nevermind.. Just saw your other comment and found out you're a pakistani... Of course, just busy spreading hate. It's what you guys do..

[@Tech.Maniac-X]

Btw I know Bengali. How can I help you? I'm from Kolkata.

[@simhagirikona3118]

... Any religion or society should always be ready to change its dharma according to the times. Due to blind faith if they want to remain as it was medival ages they will be treated as fools. ... We should learn lessons from neighbouring countries.

[@nayanchakraborty7705]

I am a Bengali. I want to go in your state and learn Sanskrit by you. What I do?

[@eshwarswaminathan3031]

Without studying book we cannot tell Best wishes.

[@SunilGupta-rc1nq]

Voice is clear.

[@ИринаАрхангельская-у2с]

Its very interesting. I read this book in russian.

[@KUROSAKIKUN-dn6gv]

Congratulations brother.

[@mathsbyvt6887]

We want to learn Sanskrit please start lecture on it

[@triptabhanot686]

Wonderful descriptions 👍 keep it up ❤

[@heyjude4340]

But then if changing Varna is ok, then in Gita, Arjuna says that I don’t want to perform the duty of the Kshatriya and I want to beg like a Brahmin, but Krishna rebukes him for this! I understand one can say that the context is different but ultimately if we say that the choice of Varna is a function of the agency of the mind and it is not space and time specific, then Arjuna should’ve been allowed to Change his Varna and become a Brahmin

[@ijkl9405]

Bhagvat Gita 18.63 - "Thus, I have explained to you this knowledge that is more secret than all secrets. Ponder over it deeply, and then do as you wish." It is very clear (from BG 18.63), that Krishna gave a CHOICE to Arjuna.

[@ijkl9405]

Bhagvat gita 4.13 - "The four categories of occupations were created by Me according to people’s qualities and activities."

[@arunachalamganesh1157]

Changing varna out of conviction is not the same as changing varna for convenience

[@ReligioCritic]

You can't change you varna 15 times, Arjuna trained his entire life to become a good Kshatriya, but he wanted to stop being a Kshatriya when he was on the battlefield just so that he could get away from the problem, it's not that he always wanted to become a Brahmana, later Krishna also explained what it means to be a Brahmana, the qualities of a Brahmana, which Arjuna obviously lacked.

[@adash7841]

Dude arjun wanted to change varna in war field by being a coward it's like saying I have studied mbbs dedicated entire life to become a doctor now I don't want to operate on people I want to an engineer. How dumb this will sound?

[@gksquad2024]

Only British agents can hate this

[@Batega_toh_Katega_Hindu_108]

Christian agents to be more precise. they are present in all religions to misinterpret the texts so that Christians can easily convert them if the verses are unjust.

[@uday-pm1ml]

Sanskrit dead language 😄 learn any programming languages atleast u ill get some job 😄

[@ishaanrohmetra3447]

Manusmriti with the Commentary of Medhatithi translated by gagannath jha is reliable or not ? should i buy this edition? please reply if possible.

[@shrirambhandari1463]

मनुस्मृतौ अद्वैतमपि भवति बहव: जना: न जानन्ति ।

[@deepakjoshi823]

Great job❤

[@bharathn1059]

Also instead of changing caste you can say changing varna because we want to debunk caste as orthogonal to this book

[@rravisankar3355]

Manusmriti isn't considered as a sacred scripture of Hinduism.

[@royp6986]

is the below translation accurate ? एकजातिर्द्विजातींस्तु वाचा दारुणया क्षिपन् । जिह्वायाः प्राप्नुयाच्छेदं जघन्यप्रभवो हि सः ॥ २७० ॥ ekajātirdvijātīṃstu vācā dāruṇayā kṣipan | jihvāyāḥ prāpnuyācchedaṃ jaghanyaprabhavo hi saḥ || 270 || If a once-born person insults a twice-born one with gross abuse, he should suffer the cutting off of his tongue; as he is of low origin.-(270)