Tata Punch vs Nissan Magnite vs Hyundai Exter vs Citroen C3 - Maha Comparison

[@motoroctane]

Get on a call with our Auto-Experts for the best car recommendations that suit your requirements. motoroctane.com/car-consultancy For faster communication drop a “hi” on this WhatsApp link wa.me/918779952811 Click on this link to download the app MotorOctane app cutt.ly/Aev7p5GP

[@surajkumar1601]

Bhai jin parameters ma aapna cars ko marks diya hai wo last section ma ek chart ka through display kar diya karo.5 second ka lia

[@paditajangpt]

Paid review for sure 💯. I have heard that Motor Octane received around 10 lacs for the promotion from citreon company.

[@user-sandydcooldude]

Magnite black beauty booked❤and delivered today

[@Hritwik007]

Congratulations

[@user-sandydcooldude]

@Hritwik007 thns

[@senseii2041]

Which varient did you buy bro I'm also planning to buy

[@DileepKumar0307]

Congrats...which variant?

[@vijju64]

Congrats which variant you booked share the on road details if you can

[@kyadekhrahahe-n6n]

Magnite is very VFM in this in this segment. C3 can also perform better if they add more features in it and stop cost cutting unnecessarily.

[@asmitsingh5245]

Magnite is ok but exter is better than C3

[@kyadekhrahahe-n6n]

@asmitsingh5245 yep

[@Adam_Moncy_David]

@@kyadekhrahahe-n6n imagine if magnite had a 4cyl petrol / diesel engine 🔥

[@MichaelScott69]

​@@Adam_Moncy_David turbo model has enough power.

[@Adam_Moncy_David]

@@MichaelScott69 not everyone can afford it

[@isyisy8282]

Proud magnite owner since the last 3 years. Absolute value for money subcompact suv with 6 air bags and 4 star safety right from the base model itself at the old price.

[@KeralaCricketLeague20]

Nissan Magnite button 🔥💪

[@ramprasad-ue5rz]

What if Nissann gets closed like it's sister concerned DATSUNN.

[@gutsarul]

Magnite... I used to drive fast n confident... (1lt manual) Past 9 months

[@Mithilesh563]

Hyundai toh kabhi nahi le raha mai bohot taklif dete hai service centre vale

[@adityakalaac-5022]

log to tarif kr rhe hyundai ki service ki

[@somya0009]

Pagal h kya, Hyundai offers best service

[@mikeyaugust8017]

Kitne paise mile tata waalo se yeh likhne ko?

[@truthspade]

Fake. Have an i20 and service is the thing which is forcing me to consider Hyundai again as my next car.

[@Samconery]

Magnite really impressed me. When its not the best in a category it ensures its the second best.

[@geetarthneo]

Watching on my laptop's screen: Exterior looks - Nissan Magnite Interior looks - Citroen C3 Headlight ratings - C3 > Punch > Magnite > Exter

[@KeralaCricketLeague20]

Magnite is far ahead than its competitors 😘🔥

[@viveksolanke8599]

It's price is also more than it's competitors

[@pranilchandarkar6595]

Magnite is not the correct comparison with punch and exter

[@asmitsingh5245]

Reliability not much as hyundai exter .... exter is best

[@kyadekhrahahe-n6n]

@@viveksolanke8599 It's the same

[@Adam_Moncy_David]

@@KeralaCricketLeague20 it's not even the same segment, wrong comparison though.

[@MIgoatteam]

According to my opinion best cars under 9lakh onroad ( we cant take turbos of C3 and Magnite) 1.Exterior looks - Magnite 2.Interior and dashboard design - magnite and c3 3. Engine - C3 ( 1.2 ltr na ) and exter (1.2 ltr) not including turbo of magnite as it falls a segment above (ie Sonet, Nexon and brezza) 4. Ride quality - C3 5. Features ( variant by variant) - Magnite 6. Fit and Finish - Almost all are good 7. Safety - Punch and Magnite ( a big no to c3) 8. Storage - Magnite and Punch 9. Rear seat space - Magnite anyday as it compete with upper segment also 10. Service centre - Hyundai exter Overall I would go for Magnite non turbo under 9lk onroad as ut offers more value for the product. Even we have to compromise a bit on the engine ie 1ltr naturally aspirated in city we wouldn't feel that underpower and initial pickup is also good as compared to punch. ❤

[@Adam_Moncy_David]

@@MIgoatteam na engine is not that powerful because car is quite heavy, also na engine has amt option which is too slow compared to its competitors, even segment below cars have quicker amts

[@sathwikshetty1041]

Bro in a car, engine is a primary and most expensive component. Don't compromise on engine it's not value.

[@thelunatic1875]

As an Indian we better support Nissan. Even if Tata Punch or Hyundai exter get discontinued. The company doesn't have no worries but if Magnite discontinued in India then there will be a huge problem in the coming years. I am afraid,We might see the company fleeing away in no years. Just see the Ford and Chevrolet 😢 Thank you for reading my comments Love from Nagaland India

[@adityakalaac-5022]

thnx to the taxing on cars also these brands haven't yet cracked the code like Maruti or Hyundai

[@Adam_Moncy_David]

Punch is top selling, so it won't discountinue nowhere near , exter is also selling in good volume. Nissan might leave India anytime if sales are getting any more poor

[@rishwina2189]

would choose Nissan's Magnite all day, in its segment it has no competition

[@Rvsharma1501]

Magnite best hai har chij meij safety and snd feature sab hai and magnite ki wjah se baki car company feature and safety deri hai and is price range mein koi bhi aas pas ni hai,just bought n-connecta, totally happy with it

[@ayushrock4745]

C3 is better

[@indiancricketteamfan18]

Magnite is the best in every aspect you take 😂👊

[@sathwikshetty1041]

If you need best build quality and higher seating position go for punch. Need best looks and interior space and CVT go for Magnite. If you need best engine, service, reliability, fit and finish go for exter Never tried C3 so no idea.

[@MIgoatteam]

Feels like little bit inclined towards exter. The only positive is that 4 cyl engine😂 Look at the rear end of that car you would vomit for sure 👍

[@bhatshahid2664]

Yes rear look awkward 😅 and rear side tyre seems to be in touch with body

[@adityakalaac-5022]

tbh it looks worse from the front end

[@vyshakkriss7765]

Awesome video, very informative. I don't understand why did they change the Instrument Cluster of Tata Punch, the older was was superb!

[@rohitanwekar3843]

U hv covered almost all the features, detailed video,Good work Team motoroctane❤

[@vinayakjariwala8742]

Actually Nissan Magnite is a direct compition of Nexon & venue not punch & exter

[@AshwiniShinde857]

Citroen is too expensive they should make affordable cars first🤷🏻‍♂️

[@HarshSharma-fc5sf]

I think u don't know that Citroen C3 Has 0 Star ⭐ safety rating 🤣😂 so any car is better than Citroen C3 🤣😂

[@fire532]

​@@HarshSharma-fc5sfNow it comes with all safety features just like basalt it can get to 4 star rating so🤡

[@theraildynasty_]

​​@@HarshSharma-fc5sf that was with the old one with 2 airbags although that's because it had a stable body structure but the car was tested when 6 airbags became compulsory to score more than 1 star, so even punch will get not more than 1-2 stars if it is tested again, if C3 was tested earlier before the rules got updated it would have scored 4 stars, but lack of features and being tested later lead to it getting 0 stars. First know how the rules of gncap work and how the rules are updated overtime. Secondly now the C3 has been updated with 6 airbags, abs, ebd, traction control, tpms, etc which will help it score at least 4 stars.

[@theraildynasty_]

That is Citroen C5 which costs 40 lakhs this C3 starts at 6.2 lakhs what are smokin bro 😂

[@AnirudhSsingh99]

Hyundai ki gaadi lene ke baad repair ka kharcha ready rakho😂😂

[@mikeyaugust8017]

Aor tata ki gaadiyan hamesha road pe hi rahengi na ki service center mein..

[@Adam_Moncy_David]

​@@mikeyaugust8017infact they are safer because the car never leaves the showroom 😂

[@cbclalsangliana4276]

What wrong bro ,if you don't like it don't mention, just mention the car you want..

[@NathanSubramani]

Very good video review content. Keep it up. Providing paint thickness, rear seat length in terms of inches - provides a data based judgement. Please do the same for 4 M and mid size sector also....want to see Elevate, Kushaq, Aircross, Creta, Seltos etc also analyzed this way. Kudos

[@12akul]

28:22 Please avoid Tata Punch for this reason alone. The suspension is very stiff. It is very uncomfortable to drive on the smallest potholes. Even hatchbacks feel better.

[@Radio_Active_Sapien]

Nissan Magnite 🧡

[@KeralaCricketLeague20]

Magnite is not in this segment Dont degrade kid Magnite turbo rivals with sonet, nexon, venue and brezza❤❤

[@hutashankaushik6782]

True. It's bigger than all others and have bigger boot than brezza

[@athuldominic]

Seen C3 Turbo with Torque converter 😁

[@sbmohankumarpsg88]

True . I don’t know on what basis magnite is compared with these kids

[@kyadekhrahahe-n6n]

@@KeralaCricketLeague20 C3 turbo is faster and bigger than Magnite

[@sbmohankumarpsg88]

@@kyadekhrahahe-n6nbigger ?

[@ScavengerYT9]

Inagine tata build quality and features with citroen's engine and driveability 🙆🏻😍

[@arjunkudva8817]

Such a detailed video 👍

[@beastislive7174]

ACCORDING TO ME: 1: C3(Best engine and AT in the segment, with all the necessary features that I would use!!) 2: Punch(best for every use case & safe+ EV is sick) 3: Magnite(Value for money) 4: Exter(just cuz it is in the list).....PLS dont reply on the basis of dealership or after sale service, cuz I own a Safari AT(2022), what I hear on the net and what I felt after 30K kms as service are totally opposite .. So yeah!!!

[@yadneshpawaskar7768]

I think exter is a good car I agree with your ranking but I think it deserves 3rd

[@motoroctane]

Punch misses out on the engine front.

[@rohitsreenivas]

I would consider magnite (turbo charged engine version ) and Citroen c3 with turbo as the top picks, punch and exter are decent cars but would be in the bottom half in this lot. That said though Maginte will be the overall better vehicle. Citoren would be the better perfomer. The engine of the exter will have better refinement and fewer issues in the long term but I don't like how it looks (least favourite design of the lot) .Punch will have the best crash rating and probably the worst engine( only engine that would be worse than punch here would be NA AMT engine of Maginte )

[@beastislive7174]

@@motoroctane That's what brother, I would have put punch in the 3rd or 4th ngl, but Just Bcuz of it's alt. fuel option like CNG and EV and OVIOUSLY those Rugged suspensions I kept it in 2nd

[@indiancricketteamfan18]

My rankinsgs 1. Magnite ( complete package) 2. C3 ( except safety and features and interior quality) 3. Punch 4. Exter

[@NissanMagniteclub]

12:36 Magnite horn ❤‍🔥

[@maroof8905]

I'll pick NISSAN MAGNITE any day..❤

[@nevin4075]

Please do a comparison between Magnite turbo vs Sonet vs Brezza vs Nexon vs 3xo . Only sensible option for me is Magnites turbo tekna variant and 3 xos base variant ❤

[@NissanMagniteclub]

Lol no question Magnite anyday. Even Magnite turbo is far better than Sonet venue, nexon and brezza

[@OpinionsKaDailyDose]

thanks for adding paint thickness test.

[@BirajKumar-s4b]

Complete test 👏🏻👍🏻

[@amitsingh2177]

Magnite is not available in cng and you are showing its milage ??

[@aksplod]

Why Exter? 1. Top class service - best in this segment after Maruti - wide service network 2. Reliable and niggle free ownership experience 3. Perfect city and highway car with ample power and a smooth refined 4cyl engine 4. One of the smoothest AMT gearboxes - even better than Fronx. AMT is cheaper to repair and maintain. 5. Loaded with features like cruise control, sunroof, auto ac, etc. Has 6 airbags and other safety tech like TPMS, Hill assist, Traction control, etc. 6. Most spacious interiors both in terms of legroom and headroom

[@asmitsingh5245]

I own exter sx ..... exter is best

[@myselfjeans]

at 24:31 where the milege chart is provided, i think there is an error where magnite & exter headings are interchanged

[@justlikethat8213]

Proud to be a Magnite owner for last 2 years.

[@hegade2025]

Do you own an automatic or Manual version sir?

[@justlikethat8213]

@hegade2025 Manual

[@mayurwadhwani2948]

Milege kita de rahi he ?​@@justlikethat8213

[@sameerrani1]

Why always do compare with top end. India's most seleble version ka compare karo...Which help more clear understanding.

[@anshbansal3508]

I own a citroen c3 NA manual and i love its drive quality

[@lafaraz]

Booked Nissan Magnite CVT Turbo today. One of the best VFM car in its segment. ❤

[@jayeshadavade]

Good video sir👍 If possible make a video on maintenance services too of all the above 4 cars.

[@AshishDeshmukh-i9n]

Magnite ❤

[@tradehut2782]

Main negatives: Magnite Turbo - Nissan CVT has known reliability issues. Have they fixed it? Punch - horrible service, poor reliability. Exter - Rear looks ugly Citroen Turbo- Will this go out of production?, Poor speakers , very few service centres. Main positives: Magnite Turbo - All rounder package, good comfort , good speakers(even in lower variants) Punch - Strongest body Exter - Comfort and upmarket interior, silent cabin, good speakers, all rounder package Citroen Turbo - best driving car, best suspension, most reliable transmission (Torque converter) for all types of terrains. Good comfort.

[@mostwanted_007]

The problem with this comparison was the price points at which these cars come at. The test cars were all top spec automatics And the ex-showroom prices are as follows (I've ignored the dual tone variants because they don't make sense at all) 1. Citroen C3 Shine Automatic - 9,99,800 2. Magnite Tekna Plus CVT - 11,50,000 3. Punch Creative Plus (S) - 9,99,900 4. Exter SX (O) Connect - 9,99,900 Clearly the rest of the 3 cars other than Magnite are from a segment below. And because of the Magnite's turbo variant it makes the comparison un-equal. Magnite with Turbo should be considered from a segment above. While the non-turbo variant can be compared to these other 3 cars. However, Citroen C3 is the only car that punches above its weight in terms of performance and comfort. It's clear that the choice should be between Citroen C3 and Magnite depending on the budget and preferences. For a prudent value conscious buyer that needs comfort and convenience with a little bit of performance - Both C3 and Magnite offer excellent value for money. If someone wants looks, value for money, and smoothest driving experience and can compromise on fuel economy and service availability-- Magnite is the clear option If someone wants performance and comfort with sorted dynamics and can compromise on fuel economy and service availability - Citroen C3 is the clear option If someone wants best safety and service center availability and can compromise on performance, quality control and service quality - Punch is the clear option If someone wants the quietest engine, good NVH and peace of mind service quality and can compromise on power and safety - Exter is the clear option Ultimately these are cars for 4 different types of demographic Magnite and C3 are more suited for people that do highway runs a lot. Punch and Exter are more suited for city dwellers. I have the Magnite CVT (pre-facelift XV Premium Turbo CVT). I've driven it for over 11,000km and I would have probably bought C3 Automatic if I were buying it today. Performance and Comfort are very important -- more important than features. And C3 Automatic is better value for money for the performance it offers.

[@teekaramahirwar3884]

At 25:41 you have written wrong engine specifications of Hyundai Exter. Otherwise it is best comparison video and one of my favourite type of Video 😊

[@udaikumarbaruah8717]

At 24:27*

[@rohitanwekar3843]

❤TATA❤

[@umarchitapure]

This is how comparison video should make all auto blogger need to learn from this video

[@battistagamingYT]

Punch best

[@spoiidy418]

Not everyone goes for top models You should compare mid variants of the cars or the most sold ones.

[@lokeshsaliyan8691]

Magnite all features loaded car middle clas family car❤❤❤❤❤

[@KeralaCricketLeague20]

King magnite anyday❤❤

[@prateekgupta7544]

Hyundai exter ko overall best bol diya bhaiya ne! Verdict i agree with.

[@sssskkkk2060]

Punch is best selling SUV for last 1 year❤

[@anandiyer8655]

Thanks to this great and informative video. I have made up my mind to buy Magnite.....but one thing that's bothering me is, what if this company exits in near future since they don't have a good basket of cars to sell😢

[@NVinay-b5x]

It will definitely be there they have 5 cars to launch in coming years

[@AD99-99]

there is rumour they are launching multiple models next year including new terrano/duster. nissan is exporting indian made magnite to 65+ countries now and thier alliance with Renault will help them to stay here.

[@nevin4075]

They will never stop production, because they are earning huge profit by exporting cars and they have more plans in launching 3 vehicles by 2025

[@MR-uy6lj]

I am plaaning to buy a new car under 10 lakh kindly provide some suggestion. I am buying car from family point of view which will be used on daily basis in citys mostly.

[@ramprasad-ue5rz]

@MR-uy6lj Hi, I suggest visiting the showrooms on the same day & and checking by yourself. Please don't depend on these reviews or comments. Also, go by stats. Just type top 10 selling SUVs for each month & you will arrive at finalization. Check which car gives more features for less price.

[@NVinay-b5x]

city ride go for maruti fronx for mileage highway ride magnite

[@umarchitapure]

Is nissan magnite natural cylinder amt gear box is worthy to buy

[@Adam_Moncy_David]

No magnite amt is so much laggy. Buy the cvt or consider amt cars from Maruti or Hyundai

[@dt1944]

Best content for viewers to make decisions by comparing...Skoda Kylaq need to add next time

[@indiancricketteamfan18]

By the way Exter doesn't fall in suv category. It can be compared only with hatchbacks like ignis and swift. Meanwhile punch and citroen are direct rivals. And magnite rivals with brezza, sonet, venue and nexon❤. Because of less engine size we can't compare with small segment cars. Compare cars with same dimensions

[@priyanshunigam821]

These cars falls under same price segment , that's why they are comparing.

[@p.k.5332]

None of them are suv category 😅

[@Adam_Moncy_David]

My point exactly 😂​@@p.k.5332

[@Adam_Moncy_David]

When did punch became suv 😂

[@atsonaga5520]

I own Exter, Hyundai Exter suspension is too soft but engine and Hyundai service is very good

[@Adam_Moncy_David]

Suspension is not a problem I'm using it for 6 months

[@atsonaga5520]

@Adam_Moncy_David it's okay if you drive really slow over bumps but if driven a little fast then it's bouncy

[@Adam_Moncy_David]

@@atsonaga5520 I mostly use it in city , so it's comfortable. Even in highways it'll give a slight feedback of ups and downs in roads in full load situation

[@vaibhavkale5673]

Hi MotorOctane Team, I think there is some confusion with the mileage chart, it shows 1.2 engine option in Magnite and 1.0 engine option in Exter.

[@gurjitsingh4156]

(1) punch (2) Exter (3) Magnite (4) Citro c3

[@Beautifulplacesintheuniverse]

If you are buying automatic in this segment, get c3 , it has the best automatic, best suspension, best driveability and powerful engine. For 12 lakhs, it's a great value for money. If features is the main thing, go for exter. If you want good base and mid variant, go for magnite. If you want star ratings, go for punch.

[@jiffinjose7541]

One of the best reviews I have seen, touching on all areas of the car. Just one thing is missing: you should have included the Fronx Delta Plus AMT, as it is the best-selling car in this segment.

[@abhisheksiktel3151]

Can you make this kind of comparison for kwid, alto, spresso tiago and celerio for low budget buyers...lower middle class people like me

[@ManinderButtar-rr5xo]

Esa comparison aur kisi channel pe nhi hota.... great job 👍👍

[@a5creations617]

anything....Tata punch 👊 most top selling in Market 😊 other comparison ❤... reality

[@sapnabansal1923]

Bhai kiger bhi isi segment me aati he usse bhi inse compare kro na

[@asmitsingh5245]

Exter sx is best ..... in terms of reliability , features and value for money

[@Narayanan-d9u3j]

punch i would say will give the most car like feel , like its best for someone who drives professionally u cant do lot of overtakes u cant be the guy who overtakes everyone and reach the next stop first , but what it will give is confidence a planted feel

[@manishvarma446]

Very True Bro.

[@Shloksrivastava95]

Why is there no Suzuki Fronx present in the comparision?

[@motoroctane]

too expensive. 16 lakhs on road

[@VANSHGond-cd3ex]

TATA PUNCH RELIABILITY LEFT THE CHAT 😅

[@shikhardhiman1235]

Nissan magnite

[@sanjankapur281]

Magnite is far better than other cars in this competition, pure japanese technology and easy to maintain

[@Kingmaker-ro8zj]

Punch nice 👍 car

[@Biswajit-pt4qp]

I will pick c3 for sure

[@Adam_Moncy_David]

All cars except tata punch provide good engine , King in sales , utter flop in after sales service, pickup, mileage, refinement, resale value and quality control. Common rusting issue only found in tata cars free from time of delivery

[@sbmohankumarpsg88]

That’s the power of Indian people mind 😂

[@Adam_Moncy_David]

@sbmohankumarpsg88 power❌tata exploiting peoples😂✅

[@khantuhaib5959]

Always best ❤❤

[@srinivaspalavalasa4578]

Magnite vs punch which is best

[@priyanshunigam821]

Magnite

[@biman2287]

Punch

[@lolthunderstorm2344]

Magnite all turbo models

[@amogus9440]

Magnite for Turbo, Punch for NA and CNG

[@arxmedia]

Does c3 have wireless charging..?

[@nevin4075]

Nissan Magnite 👊 That grill looks great after seeing many times 😅❤

[@bharath9884]

I want c3's engine in Punch with exter's interior and Magnite features 😊

[@VANSHGond-cd3ex]

TIME 18.35 BOLERO CAMPER PICKUP WITH NO HEADLIGHT

[@anantbedi5627]

hey i have a problem with digital screen in cars, is there a way to dim down the brightness of digital screen at night

[@anandkamat6701]

Nissan magnet 🧲❤

[@hutashankaushik6782]

I have taken Nissan magnite cvt to modt difficult terrains like Sach pass and killar and it performed beautifully. None of the others would be close to this one. This car is competing with brezza sonet so surely wrong comparison here

[@aslangrey5931]

actully they should have put non turbo version as it cost less than punch

[@kyadekhrahahe-n6n]

@@hutashankaushik6782 Price segment

[@umarchitapure]

Is AMT good

[@fire532]

Nah c3 has the best engine and gearbox

[@INTROVERTGAMINGx]

Compact SUV maha comparison with Skoda kylaq 😍

[@AD99-99]

only magnite have SUV ground clearance in these comparison though.

[@naughtysoul9760]

Citroen while hill climb rear left tyre is in Air for a sec, 28:34 😅😅

[@satishsaini215]

Tata Punch❤

[@mglv2542]

Nissan Magnite❤ n Hyundai exter

[@sanukrishnan7081]

Citron.. Great engine among all..

[@Adam_Moncy_David]

Safety ( safety only )- punch Fun to drive - magnite and c3 turbo versions Smoothness, refinement, features, service,resale value-exter

[@Aditya_Singh_Shakya]

Why is Fronx missing?

[@vigneshnair1339]

Kya kiger contention me bhi nahi je?

[@taslimbiri5969]

Rachit seems like be a Tatas fan boy. Reverse camera test punch was in light spot.

[@Max-dl6pj]

Selling figure tells itself.

[@stanleynixon5636]

Please include fronx or taisor

[@theliteratemiddleclass]

Review is clearly hyundai exter biased

[@VANSHGond-cd3ex]

C3 is the powerful car in this segment

[@MayankSharma-jd4ck]

Sir, Bring Maha comparison of Toyota Camry vs City eHEV vs other cars