Savra vs Geth vs Kykar vs Tymna | Silas EDH / CMDR game play for Magic: The Gathering

[@ZidaneTribal1989]

Ben where's everyone's sandwich?

[@pathkeepers]

Wow Martin was one turn ahead of that Tezzeret drain. Typical black deck, coming back from 3 life. Love it.

[@MTGGoldfishCommander]

Gotta root for Savra!

[@Chuubii]

Savra content?

[@danielharrison2383]

@@Chuubii asking the tough question

[@Sir_Logurt]

Black market , grinding station, phyrexian arena, rings of brighthearth, but ya know solemn really needs to get exiled here lolol

[@zachw3548]

A very stock decision but stuff like that happens when people let the fear of value overshadow more immediate threats in such grindy games

[@Quroe_]

Summon Sandwich - (No mana cost) Suspend 6 - (0) Create a food token.

[@em-jaelam4460]

I forgot this game existed.

[@esperderek5383]

That game needed some serious targeted land destruction to deal with Coffers/Stronghold.

[@trevorstokens2894]

Cleansing wildfire

[@qwormuli77]

@@trevorstokens2894 A really underrated card in EDH.

[@andersnielsen3163]

Can we get some decklists? Would love to see Geth and Silas/Tymna decklists

[@infernalspectre]

When Ben casts living death at 13:41, why does Max keep his treasure keeper at first (only to sacrifice it to the dictate trigger afterwards)? Shouldn't it have been sacrificed to the living death, since it was on his board when that was cast?

[@infernalspectre]

Also I think Max forgot that Tezzeret gives his creatures affinity for artifacts so battlesphere should've only been 1 mana or so

[@jestyrjohn]

Id love to see a decklist for the Tymna / Silas deck

[@benoitbusque3601]

Is there a deck list for that Geth? I love him as a commander but struggled to make it work and am reinvigorated by this game

[@MTGMuddstah]

I'll ask Martin.

[@germanyjones2700]

Love the way you say bojuka bog

[@Spetaelsk]

I'm pretty sure the second half of Finale of Devastation should resolve eventhough no legal targets are left for the first half, seeing as the spell say "up to three". It can be 0 target creatures.

[@tsho6131]

From Gatherer’s rule entry on Finale of Eternity: 5/3/2019 You may cast Finale of Eternity without choosing any target creatures. If X is 10 or more, you’ll just return all creature cards from your graveyard to the battlefield. However, if you choose any targets and all of those targets become illegal before the spell tries to resolve, the spell won’t resolve and you won’t put any cards onto the battlefield.

[@Spetaelsk]

@@tsho6131 Thank you! That seems weird to me, but alright. So the correct play would've been to announce 0 targets since he had a sac outlet in play. The more you know!

[@alexgera3224]

Sick geth deck

[@chas3btha1]

Kinda looking for the list if they have one.. I was gonna build a mono B gisela zombie tokens thing but geth has always been on my periphery in the past

[@MTGTheStack]

Poor kykar, never saw it coming 😢😭 stellar game

[@cringevids2570]

can you ask your friend to play his sliver deck

[@somerandomguy521]

Sliverssssss!!!!!

[@em-jaelam4460]

Which Sliver deck?

[@cringevids2570]

@@em-jaelam4460 the first sliver

[@em-jaelam4460]

I'll see about putting mine back together for a stream game in the future 👍

[@wiiblewobble]

But what did you tutor with your liliana copy?

[@Googleflax]

How come Yawgmoth's Vile Offering still resolved the 2nd half of the ability (destroying up to one creature or planeswalker) when its target was made illegal, but the Finale of Eternity did not resolve the 2nd half when its targets were made illegal?

[@NMS127]

Offering still had a legal target. Finale had no legal targets.

[@ButzPuff]

Is it legal to put Grasslands in a B/G deck?

[@MTGMuddstah]

Yep! Lands don't have color identities.

[@ButzPuff]

@@MTGMuddstah Wow, I did not know that. Thanks for the answer!

[@numnut154]

*Fetch* lands don't have colour identities, but if a land has mana symbols on it then normal edh rules apply.

[@hawkeye137137]

That Finale fizzle was a big oof moment for Martin, but his comeback with that combo was pretty impressive.

[@Sgt_Bacon189]

I gotta say mono black decks are exremely frustrating to watch/play against after a certain amount of turns, only due to the Cabal lands and the infinite removal in the form of Grave Pact, Dictate of Erebos, single target removals and board wipes. You can make a mono black deck, just throw in all the good black cards with no win cons and I guarantee that you will win a surprising amount of times.

[@bram8731]

Keep up the good content :)

[@mella4376]

A Netrunner playmat? Be still my beating heart

[@HansHurin]

Max hitting you without paying for Propaganda to draw with Tymna.

[@gustavomartinsdesouza5548]

Being an up to 3 creatures, finale can't be cast without targets? I always thought it could :O

[@MTGMuddstah]

You might be right. It was pretty late when this game wrapped up and we were all kind of tired. Wouldn't surprise me if we missed it.

[@mr.cuddles1805]

You can cast the spell without any targets and the secondary effect will happen if x is 10 or more, but if you have chosen targets and all targets become illegal the spell fizzles.

[@gustavomartinsdesouza5548]

@@mr.cuddles1805 "You may cast Finale of Eternity without choosing any target creatures. If X is 10 or more, you’ll just return all creature cards from your graveyard to the battlefield. However, if you choose any targets and all of those targets become illegal before the spell tries to resolve, the spell won’t resolve and you won’t put any cards onto the battlefield." I really didn't know that! Haha, it is a little strange ruling to be honest.

[@charlesmaillho367]

@@gustavomartinsdesouza5548 It is a consistent ruling with how targets are chosen in commander. If there are no legal targets for a spell when it resolves, the spell cannot resolve.

[@gustavomartinsdesouza5548]

@@charlesmaillho367 Yeah, but since it is an "up to" and 0 is a valid number to that, It is a little strange.

[@theliving1037]

Wonder how long we have to wait for a Thrasios reprint. Legends was basically the only time they could have, and they didn't.

[@olafthemoose9413]

Except they did

[@RyeGuy4821]

@@olafthemoose9413 unfortunately, the etched foil thrasios from the new set is already close to the same price on tcgplayer/card kingdom

[@DeltaFiend]

@@RyeGuy4821 Well, the set isn't out yet, so I wouldn't 100% rely on the estimated prices out right now. But yeah, price probably won't drop too much.

[@faerie7dragon]

Thrasios? Really?

[@014TheValentino]

Kykar, i love it

[@emeraldsky1289]

Wouldn't martin get creatures back with the finale being more than 10?

[@MTGMuddstah]

*EDIT* Looks like we did play it correctly. Thanks T Sho! I think you're right. In hindsight that might have been a mistake we made, but thankfully I don't think it changed the outcome all that much. Just made the game go a bit longer?

[@emeraldsky1289]

@@MTGMuddstah either way it was still a fun game to watch

[@tsho6131]

5/3/2019 You may cast Finale of Eternity without choosing any target creatures. If X is 10 or more, you’ll just return all creature cards from your graveyard to the battlefield. However, if you choose any targets and all of those targets become illegal before the spell tries to resolve, the spell won’t resolve and you won’t put any cards onto the battlefield.

[@Aeonsmagicks]

Didnt Ben get Emrakul out on the end step? Meaning why didn't he kill Martin with it on his turn before Martin stole his It that betrays and wins How? Also how would geths ability steal savra? If it would change zones, Ben can put her in the command zone. So if geth attempted to take her, that would change zones from yard to field and he could instead put her in c zone?

[@beltfedweapon9967]

Game needed more boardwipes. ITB on Martin’s board was SIIIIICK.

[@blackcherrybc2573]

Hello Where is deck list?

[@MTGMuddstah]

Ben doesn't really do lists, and the rest have since been disassembled and most likely deleted.

[@gdiridium5525]

I've got no clue why max kept swinging his ground creatures at everyone except andrew early on, when andrew had nothing to block with, and everyone else did. Just throwing his creatures away and what, hoping they'd trade?

[@guitargreg145]

Kykar where were your tokens?

[@thewizardprk6334]

Is there ever gonna be a game where Kykar does well?

[@MTGMuddstah]

Some of the past ones I feel like Kykar did well. Mainly the ones where Adam is playing his list. My Kykar list has shifted to Elsha and I've been much happier with it.

[@UnknownDutch]

11:06 shouldnt he pay 2 for propaganda ?

[@DanG626]

Lol super long game with 4 grindy decks. Yeesh

[@harounjusttrying6650]

To bad they scoopt. Deck was realy going off

[@johnsmithking]

That’s the ugliest sheoldred I’ve ever seen.

[@cringevids2570]

first

[@samb123078]

Max never paid for propaganda