Muldoon's SHOCKING Return! What REALLY HAPPENED to him in Jurassic Park

[@TwistedAnimatronic]

This guy SOUNDS FAMILIAR...

[@dedmed8139]

Chair

[@HighBluey]

Chair

[@strandalx]

@@HighBluey sofa or couch

[@lightmite2476]

True that Mr animatronic he was a good support hero

[@Tyrantwuztaken]

@@lightmite2476 i think a hippo?

[@NewfieBeast]

His quote “clever girl” in the first movie is one of my favourite scenes ever out of all Jurassic parks!

[@eevee-wg7vm]

When you load jwe1 or jwe2 his quote is the games their's just quotes by so many characters that you might see or not.

[@ZealotsACH]

I quote that line all the time still to this day.

[@eevee-wg7vm]

@ZealotsACH well their's quote's from the movies of jurassic Park to jurassic world dominion in jwe1 and jwe2.

[@SKOTxFREE]

Yep honestly aside from Malcolm’s chaos theory explanation “Clever Girl” is indeed the best line in the whole movie.

[@NewfieBeast]

@@SKOTxFREE there was honestly a lot of good quotes throughout the series!

[@Boppinabe]

I can hear the actor's line now: "Somehow, Muldoon returned."

[@rc59191]

Cloning secrets only InGen knew.

[@haydenbennett3547]

He survived in the books

[@Rinksiderips]

Haha yup. Disney SJW Wars level writing.

[@jeffwalker7185]

I always thought the way Muldoon died did not fit well with the character who is a seasoned big game hunter/warden and the island's expert on raptors. He would not have walked into the trap the raptors set, especially as he picked up on the fact that they were hunting Ellie and himself.

[@kelvingriffiths6017]

LOL dude knew he was dead moment he realises they have escaped. Hes the face to their suffering for one thing. Sorry but guys dead and any "he miraculously survives" is sheer nonesense.

[@chris.3711]

He was tunnel visioned. Pr perhaps he under estimated his opponent. Big game animals don't set up traps like this against an opponent as depicted in the movie.

[@kelvingriffiths6017]

@@chris.3711 True. But most game animals arent as intelligent as these. They set a trap for arnold and ellie too if you think about it, just Ellie got very lucky.

[@Th0ughtf0rce]

But him surviving due to a "bond" with the raptors is even dumber. He did say they should all be exterminated.

[@AngryGerbils]

The real reason is because the actor was dying in real life, and he wanted the character to be "sent off."

[@grandadmiralzaarin4962]

Bob Peck was originally scripted to survive and potentially return if there were future films, however Peck had cancer and worried he might not live to be in future films, so he suggested killing Muldoon off. This was about midway through production allegedly.

[@SvanTowerMan]

He was actually diagnosed after the movie came out, so it's probably unrelated.

[@AlfonsoHernandez-wz4on]

I hate cancer it killed him on April 4 1999

[@grandadmiralzaarin4962]

@@SvanTowerMan not exactly, he released the news to the public a year later, but as with other actors that had cancer, they often waited months or a year or two to let anyone outside of close friends and family know about it.

[@65FASTBACKMAN-dx9ge]

Per Google, it says he was diagnosed in 1994, of which the movie was released in 1993 and was probably done with shooting in 1992. I'm betting you're incorrect in your statement.

[@trmpt35]

I thought that myself as I realized the actor died in the late 90s. It’s a shame he didn’t get to live as I really liked his character in the book and movie. I think that’s that’s why we got Roland timbo in the lost world as it was supposed to be a continuation of his character

[@williv]

RIP Bob Peck. Great character and performance.

[@kimberleysmith818]

Fantastic character. My aunt was an actress and knew Bob Peck. Lovely man apparently.

[@strandalx]

Yes, he was quite literally Ripped in Pieces by the raptors

[@WellWisdom.]

@williv I Agree.

[@TarsonTalon]

The way Muldoon said "Clever Girl..." didn't suggest fear at all, now that I think about it. Bro really believed "Naw, I'd win."

[@aromalkrishnana2032]

the way he screamed after getting jumped on did suggest fear

[@ShadowsLew]

Would you want MULDOON to Return? *WATCH UNTILL THE END FOR FULL CONTEXT on HOW HE COULD RETURN*Love to hear your thoughts on this!

[@AriBranch-k7u]

Yes I love muldoon I would love to see him in the game

[@Ross_Stewart]

Unfortunately, Shadow, Bob Peck (Muldoon) died of cancer in 1999. Would have been great if he was still around to do a cameo or have a decent character in the JW series ❤

[@Ross_Stewart]

Obviously if he's in Jurassic Park Survivor, having survived but pretty injured that would be cool, and it would add another person/character into the game!

[@ShadowsLew]

@@Ross_Stewart Lucky enough though, with tech these days, they could digital make him appear in Jurassic Park Survival :)

[@Ross_Stewart]

@ShadowsLew actually yeah I hadn't thought of that but it'd need to be good CGI though, like Luke Skywalker in The Mandalorian, not Leia in Rogue One lol

[@SquirrelGamez]

He was my favorite character as a kid. Kinda reminded me of a more civilized Crocodile Dundee Frankly I think the only reason he wasn't shown to survive is they didn't have time. And the reason he wasn't shown dying for sure is they wanted to keep it open-ended.

[@kelvingriffiths6017]

Wasnt shown dying for sure? Its a PG thats why. From what we do see hes clearly a gonner. You dont scream like that unless your really being injured.

[@SquirrelGamez]

@@kelvingriffiths6017It wasn't as clear as Nedry where the jeep shook a lot, or as Ray Arnold whose arm fell on Ellie. Also, it was PG-13, not PG.

[@kelvingriffiths6017]

@@SquirrelGamez Wasnt as obvious? No offence but you need a reality check. Theres a raptor on him, given the noise we hear coupled with the movies opening, plus the other one he was aiming at? Hes a gonner.

[@stevepalpatine2828]

Tbf he had a 12 gauge in his hand if he managed to keep hold of it he could have still killed that raptor, he'd have been cut up though, I don't know if he would have survived it. He did in the book, he blew the leg off of one.

[@steveguse4481]

​@@stevepalpatine2828 True. A 12 gauge would make a mess out of anything at that range

[@threesquid]

eddie's death was so sad tho

[@ShadowsLew]

It was, a true legend

[@mattt233]

But he saved their lives by giving his.

[@Joey_Sabre]

Yeah in both the novel and the movie. Man can’t catch a break.

[@angievergauwen1212]

'You see any family resemblances here?' 😐🤏

[@Chucknoodle]

His body was cut in two and no blood was visible because of the rain

[@cruisingbongos4913]

My personal headcanon is that he knew he was gonna die, not how or that he was walking into a trap, but that he was gonna die somehow going after the raptor. I think this because he knew that the raptors probably remembered his face and how knowledgeable he was on them, they knew he was a priority so he simply used himself as a distraction so ellie could get the power back on.

[@crypto40]

Yk..you’re a genius. Iv seen this movie so many times and Iv never thought of it that way

[@High_Key]

Ok, now this I can get behind. I think take this as my new headcanon now too.

[@mikoto7693]

That’s going to be my headcanon. But I was always sad that he died because he was my favourite character.

[@StormX6]

As much as I liked Muldoon, he’s dead in the movies. Theres no chance he’d return in the films because Bob Peck died shortly after JP1. I feel like Muldoon’s death added to the story that the Velociraptors were a major threat and were developing tactics to manipulate and outsmart their prey.

[@vanyadolly]

Exactly. He's the best -- that's why he's so adamant that the dinos are absolutely too dangerous to exist. Him surviving would just undermine his point *and* the fact that the raptors outplayed the most competent character in the story.

[@TheCrabLord_]

I like the thought that the reason he said clever girl was because in all of the time he spent raising them they had never successfully "hunted" him, he always caught what they were doing before they could catch him (like a game). So that is also why she poked her head out right beside him and makes a sound rather than just springing out like an actual hunter would do, they wouldn't let their prey know they are there before attacking, especially with how intelligent they are supposed to be. So it is almost like she was saying "Ha Dad, I actually caught you this time!" by poking her head out at him and making it clear she was there. And because they had never successfully hunted him before he screamed when she pounced him, not knowing if she was going in for a kill or not. But in the end she was only playing with him (not that it looks that way to the viewers lol). Could also be why he recognised so quickly that he and Ellie were being hunted by them, he had experienced it before. But because Ellie had no experience with them made her go ahead as he was confident in his hunting ability and the fact he knew their game so well, but also because they may be far more swift and violent with a stranger involved.

[@88chavin]

I always felt that the noise the raptor made was like she was saying "you".

[@tazman2253]

does not hold water sadly. The big one took over the pack and locks eyes with Muldoon in the very first scene of the movie. No she was out for his death end of story.

[@foggyh1425]

@@tazman2253 I do remember reading somewhere that the raptor at the beginning may not be 'the big one' due to the gunshots at the end of the scene

[@foggyh1425]

To excuse what Muldoon tells Grant about 'the big one' killing all but two raptors perhaps the story he wasn't true and told to spook Grant. Could be in the same vein as Dr Harding's fake mustache (headcanon for difference in appearance between movie and game)!

[@TheCrabLord_]

@@tazman2253 I know XD It was just a fun thought I had to make the comics make sense to me and how he survived, so more a head canon thing if we were to say that the comics are canon. :)

[@atothebtothezakadonutlord2951]

If only Muldoon and his actor where still here😢

[@hunterkiller86]

I had heard that the reason Muldoon died in the movie was because Bob Peck had been recently diagnosed with cancer and Spielberg changed his fate because of that

[@Jaytee.]

I think Mr Peck was diagnosed with cancer years after the filming of Jurassic Park.

[@Jasonxknot]

That would be a pretty fucked up thing to do. Doubt its true.

[@grandadmiralzaarin4962]

@@Jaytee. it was publicly announced one year after JP released, but it's not uncommon for an actor or celebrity to wait to release such heavy news to the public, in part because it can often negatively impact their opportunities during that time

[@Dan261178]

I remember hearing the same thing.I don’t know how true it is but I heard that Bob Peck asked for the character to be killed off dramatically because he knew he wouldn’t be around for any sequels.Either way RIP Bob,you were brilliant.

[@keyofdestiny857]

He was a great actor apparently I been living under a rock because I didn’t know that he passed away oh I was ten when he passed away I guess I was too young to notice

[@ijnfleetadmiral]

There's a fanfic out there called "Muldoon", where Robert Muldoon survives the raptor attack - albeit grievously wounded - due to the Big One being called away by her pack mates to help them at the visitor center. He eventually makes his way to the Visitor Center and frees the raptor trapped in the kitchen, which ironically forms a bond with him (and whom he later names Priscilla). It's currently on hiatus, but it's very well-written, and I could see it actually happening. Also, if only Bob Peck were still with us! He could've returned in Dominion with the rest of the cast and had a scene with Owen comparing raising raptors. Then he could've met Blue somehow and turned to Owen and said, "You've raised a clever girl."

[@Alucard-lz2hb]

@@ijnfleetadmiral do you have the link to the fan fic so I can read it?

[@way9883]

Is this on AO3?

[@mangrove]

What Muldoon was shouting as the raptor pounced on him was "Dino, down! Down, Dino!"

[@NordicDan]

You win 🤣 Someone needs to edit that scene with the sound of Dino and Fred now.....

[@stephenraynes2148]

He died. I'm not sure what I have to add to the conversation except Spielberg clearly sacrificed him to make Grant's original point about attacking from the sides. I wish Bob Peck was still alive though. ❤

[@sidewaysonhighways]

The deleted scene in LWJP, I think could be considered confirmation enough. I doubt the scene was deleted for inaccuracy, but it increased runtime, and was well enough summarized between Peter Ludlow and Ian Malcom at John Hammond’s estate. The “deaths of three people”, mentioned by Malcom must have included Robert Muldoon, as the death of the gate keeper whom died in the Raptor crate. The coinciding case was being processed before Ian Malcom and the others made it to the island,and has well been closed before the board meeting in the deleted scene.

[@ShadowsLew]

*All my Best VIDEOS and Theories on Jurassic Right here* - kzbin.info/aero/PLw5JdjrQaWSHn6NT4D2OxxZ4DtVBLjahZ

[@Andrew-Bastin]

The raptor was biting his head in the film, even if he somehow miraculously survived he would be missing most of his face.

[@porpus99]

You never actually see the jaws open and close. No blood, no bones, nothing. More than likely just limitations of the animatronics, but still. More than likely dead, but an interesting theory none the less.

[@Andrew-Bastin]

@@porpus99 well considering the actor has passed away, needlessly bringing the character back in such a contrived manner for shameless fan service would not only be stupid but disrespectful.

[@steveguse4481]

Maybe it was a gentle bite

[@Elvis-m3i]

@@Andrew-Bastin I strongly fucking agree

[@obengrupperfuhrerheinrichv7230]

@@steveguse4481 it be didn’t look gentle lol

[@ShadowsLew]

PS - We've Partnered with GAMERSUPPS!! ► www.gamersupps.gg/shadows *Use code* "shadows" at checkout for 10% OFF!

[@Syntherios]

I'm very skeptical about Muldoon's survival, but I did notice something regarding the theory that the raptor is playing with him: the raptor didn't immediately jump on Muldoon and start biting/slashing him. It peeked through the vegetation first, making itself very visible, almost like it was playfully saying, "haha, found you!" In nature, ambush predators don't behave that way. They attack their prey and go for the kill as soon as they get in range. Granted, it was almost certainly a theatrical choice for dramatic effect to allow Muldoon to say the famous line before getting attacked, but it's fun to speculate nonetheless.

[@ShadowsLew]

That's very true, I never even thought of that angle !

[@kelvingriffiths6017]

It is toying with him. Thats why hes dead. The raptors do have a grudge agsinst this guy.

[@lindamagagula7476]

​@@ShadowsLew I have seen Jurassic Park so many times. I am so surprised😮. So this means that he is still alive

[@hplovecraftcat]

​@@lindamagagula7476No it doesn't. Muldoon does survive in the novel, but in the movie he clearly dies. In The Lost World there's a deleted scene that states that 4 people died in the park (Nedry's body was never found so no one knew he was dead, and assumed he managed to leave the island).

[@cameronmcconnachie7794]

I just don’t like the way they killed off Muldoon in the movie. Which all his experience as an African hunter and Raptor expert in his back story. He should’ve seen it was an ambush

[@undead9999]

in the novel he also uses far more weapons, and has a much more prominent role. Unfortunately Bob Peck, the actor playing Muldoon, insisted that the character be killed off, because he was suffering from the cancer that ultimately took his life, and didn't want to not be able to deliver a performance in a sequel, had the character survived.

[@joesmoe71]

Oddly enough he survived in the book, he broke his ankle but was able to hide from the raptors in a drain pipe they couldn't fit in.

[@PhenomProductions-tn5fj]

Since Hollywood has been doing so many remakes of classic films with new actors, why not do a New Version of Jurrassic Park 1 with new actors and revive the Muldoon character and do the screenplay just like it was in the book. They did the same thing for the True Grit remake with Jeff bridges, closer to the novel, whereas John Wayne's version was more PG and less Dark than the Novel.

[@Mike1064ab]

If he was able to get back to the visitor center the phones were working there was nothing stopping him from calling a chopper to rescue him.

[@mspeilberg]

I’m the BIGGEST Jurassic Park fan there is. I’ve flown to events for a DAY. I have a huge memorabilia collection, converted my wrangler to a JP Jeep, and I even teach the movie and break down scenes in my Video Production class. As much as I love the character Muldoon- He’s dead. It hurts to say, but he’s dead. The whole point of his scene was that he thought he was smarter than the animals. And Grant foreshadows how raptors attack “not from the front, but from the side” earlier in the movie the dig site scaring the kid. The whole point of his death was how no matter how smart and experienced you are, science in a way beat man. “Life, (or death in this case) found a way.”

[@MagSouille]

Muldoon makes it clear that if it were up to him, he would kill every last one of them when he shows the visitors the Velociraptors' cage. Knowing that in addition, he threatens one of the three raptors with his shotgun, which clearly does not please the ''clever girl''. As for the blood, I think he was simply grabbed by the throat or the head (image) to get it broken like Udesky. So, I think there will simply be another group like Jurassic Park: The Game

[@Dinoslay]

If you look closely at the shot of the raptor mauling him you can see it bite down on his skull. Good luck surviving that. 💀

[@patrickrichardson2518]

The one thing that always bugged me about Muldoon's "death" was that the raptors outflanked him despite what I assumed was expert knowledge of how the creatures behaved. Grant lays out their whole attack pattern right there at the beginning of the movie, and surely Muldoon would know even more about raptor behavior at that point. It just seems so unlikely that he would fixate so much on the one in front of him to the exclusion of knowing one was right there, just inches to his left. Even more baffling is the "clevah guril" quip just before he's pounced upon. Was he genuinely unaware of how raptors hunt? Was this just bad writing? Was this scene written for another character who was hastily swapped out with Muldoon? The whole scene has confused me ever since I was old enough to understand the movie. A couple of IT nerds (sorry Jackson!) and a lawyer bite the dust - totally believable - but 2 pre-adolescent children, 2 doctors who play in the dirt, an old man with a limp, and a philosopher (who was most assuredly somewhere "on the spectrum") all survive but the legitimate big game hunter with weapons and first hand dinosaur experience is outsmarted by one of the animals he's been studying first hand? Some sort of studio politics had to be going on for this "death" to occur.

[@octipuscrime]

I like to believe that Muldoon "knew" if he and the crew were to escape the island the raptors would need to be stopped. To an extent, he went in with some idea he was going to die and so wanted to take out as many of them as he could, specifcially the "big one". Im new and have subbed! I look forward to more content!

[@ShadowsLew]

Welcome to the channel :)

[@YuriNikolajavič]

"My death is greatly exagerated." Lol

[@AzraelThanatos]

I believe he actually used the quote in the old, Topp's comics

[@barrettharger]

They should bring back Mr. Arnold too and he just walks around with one arm

[@Princess_Celestia_]

No. Ray, Geoffry, Donald Dennis and Robert all need to stay dead. There needs to be some consequences in this movie otherwise John would never learn his lesson.

[@racingraptor4758]

No. I dont want this franchise to be next Star Wars (,,oh I got stabbed/cut, slashed by a sword hotther than a star. Guess ill just walk it off!")

[@The_Primitive]

nah

[@Filthy_Larry]

I’m all for Arnold’s return. Samuel is still alive and acting.

[@TuskieBoi]

Robert being alive would make sense because just like Ian Malcolm he could be bribed by ingen to keep quiet about the incident

[@tigerstoneman5727]

Plenty of people have been injured or worse by large predators who were only technically playing with them, so it's entirely possible that Muldoon could have survived. It'd be like a big cat tackling and putting it's mouth on someone who raised it, not necessarily biting down or actively digging it's claws in.

[@whitmerule2753]

I'm a dog groomer and this afternoon I groomed a (massive!) German Shepherd, more than 6 years old, whose owner still has a serious scar on his hand from when this guy was 4 months old. The owner picked up a ball and the puppy, with big jaws and puppy teeth, went 'OH YEAH A BALL' and grabbed ball and hand at once and sliced him to the bone. (Not an isolated incident as that was far from teh only scar - kiddo was severely undersocialised as a pup and this was never corrected, so he tried to disembowel me or remove my hand several times today for the crime of brushing him or cutting out a knot behind his ear, but hey, muzzles exist, so he only bruised me.) Point being - yep, teeth and strong jaws plus play, PLUS (very relevant here for dinosaurs without the socialisation of real parents) lack of bite inhibition learned from parents and siblings... that play could very quickly become fatal even if the dinosaur was just meaning to play.

[@burritowarrior5367]

In the game he's either alive or his shotgun is a weapon we can pick up in the story coming across his body

[@abritnamedsethinnit]

imagine if they added an achievement called "Muldoon's Vengeance" or something like that where you kill The Big One with his shotgun

[@Kaydenthegoat473]

"clever girl" bow that was my favorite lines ever. Muldoon is awesome

[@Quaglander]

I really hope they give him some crazy miraculous survival. I love the character and he's far better than Owen Grady and his seemingly magic power to hold out his hand and solve every problem. He took it all seriously and was very experienced and his death in the movie never sat right with me. I'd go absolutely crazy if they decide to bring him back, ideally with a dedication to Bob Peck in the credits.

[@ShadowsLew]

The comic adaptation which I shown in the video around 5 min mark, explains how he could return :)

[@ShadowsLew]

Let's keep our fingers crossed

[@digi7773]

@@ShadowsLew to be honest watch the the "clever girl," clip i watch it 0.25 speed while target the head but but not the neck, plus looking at the other kill that the raptor did we see Ray Arnold see his arm, no body no blood in the room that the arm was found, it "COULD" be that Raptor wasn't hunting for food but was hunting like we do with animal. so could he be injury yes, to head and chest of Muldoon' would be heavily cut, plus with right medical treatments the game "COULD" be saved

[@Dwayne_LaFontant]

I’m not sure if they should. His death really raised the stakes in the movie.

[@KarlSturmgewher]

His face was mangled by the Raptor. If he DID survive, he might need to get more than a plastic surgeon.

[@P-C-Principle]

It would be sick if Muldoon somehow survived on the island all alone for a decade. All scared up and old. That would be sweet

[@shishoka]

If a kid could do it so could he.

[@Tucher97]

So here is something about animal attacks, Muldoon is said to be a seasoned games keeper, however there are several rules when it comes to hunting but there are two major ones, that is you and hte animal at a distant, then there is you and the animal up close, Muldoon at best may had methods of for both even for the raptors.

[@ikaiju-eu9wn]

i really hope muldoon somehow survived, he was my favourite character in the movie and the book

[@Casual_guy1234]

He died because his actor got cancer and they tought he might not make it for the next film so they gave him an epic death and paved the path for the man, the myth, the legend, Roland Tembo

[@BeforeMoviesSucked]

Dang, all the coolest actors from Jurassic Park are dead now... RIP Peck and Postlethwaite.

[@Casual_guy1234]

@@BeforeMoviesSucked yeah, yeah I'm very sad about this

[@WaveDaSeaWing]

Ik its so sad 😢 Also why u say Ronald TEMBO its Ronald Muldoon

[@chrisdavies3913]

I feel like if he did survive, it would take away the effect of that set up from Alan Grant in the first film.

[@gabrielhenning1620]

This was really interesting! I could definitely see him returning for the game. Also I’ve never thought about how the main cast just abandoned Muldoon without knowing whether he was alive or not 😂

[@chazchaz2121]

5:24 Yeah... she is playing with him. He screams of joy in that scene...

[@2091riveraisrael]

Glad Robert survived because he was actually shown to live in the comics which I have no idea is considered Canon to the actual lore, but In the Raptor Comics which were read by Kayfotii, he actually survived and was revealed to have almost died and actually wrestled the Raptor that attacked him with his bear hands, and managed to overpower it. That was his words in the Raptor Comics.

[@maxpayne69.]

1:40 in the novel he used a rocket launcher to blast a raptor to bits & shreds 💀

[@Jaytee.]

Maybe Muldoon could return. "Aren't you dead?", we'll all ask. And he'll reply "No, I'm Muldoon from the book."

[@darkforge633]

One way to bring him back would be some type of clone. After all, Maisie Lockwood is a clone, so they could, in theory, bring Muldoon back as a clone.

[@outofpocketsquad]

Yo bro welcome back

[@ShadowsLew]

Thank you :)

[@drk_hrs_of23]

If they can't AI him, Charles Dance would be an almost uncanny replacement. He's very respectful to roles as well.

[@beamngcrash134]

I was thinking about this the other day and today you uploaded this video so i guess i don't have to overthink now thanks you really have read my mind now for the second time😊😊

[@ShadowsLew]

You're welcome 😊

[@foggyh1425]

Muldoon was always my favourite character, when I found out that he survived in the book I was very happy. This video's theory becoming canon would be brilliant, if its done as part of the game that should help too.

[@ChrsGotFourEyes]

Loving the Dino Crisis save-room theme...u aint slick lol

[@madfifer5]

Love the Dino Crisis save room music playing in the background, there's some nostalgia right there. Capcom really should do a remake of that series.

[@hmbtfdcu5539]

Dennis Nedry’s body was found by Miles and Nima in Jurassic Park Telltale game.

[@T1000skynetforever]

The fans: I thought you were dead Muldoon: my death was greatly exaggerated

[@JurassicFan93]

This is so cool muldoon was so under used in my opinion so bringing him is legendary ❤❤🎉🎉cool vid

[@maverickfox4102]

It’s too bad that the actor who played Roland Tembo had passed away. And I think it would’ve been interesting to see him making a comeback in the Jurassic World franchise. If the actor who played Roland Tembo would’ve still been alive.

[@LordRazer3]

Rule of film making if you are suggested to have died off camera that doesn't mean your character actually died

[@LordRazer3]

@@Amp661 You don't watch a lot of movies do you? People are constantly being brought back for dumb reasons that make no since but you jump at insults because I'm pointing out something that hollywood has done time and time again? Hell they did it in Jurassic park 3 where Billy was last seen being pecked at by pteranodon yet you see him again and the end in a military chopper! Someone that should have been "ripped apart" in your words? Welcome to the idiot club your not impressing anyone lest of all the idiots your surrounded by

[@UsagiArwen]

I actually looked this up. It wasn't until 1994 when Bob Peck announced he was diagnosed with an undisclosed type of cancer. But it is entirely possible that he had known before, just didn't want to tell anyone. There is a theory that said he was initially meant to survive it, but as the actor's health began to decline, they decided to give his character a send off. This is unconfirmed, however, and should be taken with a grain of salt. That being said, I do not want them to bring Muldoon back. We have a propensity to now bring back characters that died in earlier movies (Brent Spiner in Independence Day Resurgence, for example), and it honestly really just kills the idea that characters can die, and gives them an unholy level of plot armor these days. Furthermore, I would not want a recasting of Bob Peck, as I just don't think anyone else would do him justice, and I don't like deep fakes. So I am hoping that Muldoon stays dead for the sake of the story and respect to the actor who played him.

[@0megacron]

For the record, we never saw what happened to him - just one raptor pushing him down and then the other watching. For all we know, they started to finish him off and then ran away cuz the T-Rex roared nearby.

[@TwesomE]

Denis was became a meatball for dinos i believe! But muldoon's supposed death scene was even for me really quick and had my thoughts for what actually happened to him! That's a really informative video about this character on the franchise thanks mate!

[@JustinJamesOGuinn]

I miss Eddie 😢. Wish they could bring him back too.

[@darylreeder3400]

I can remember seeing his death as a kid. The set up, the music, the stillness before the pounce and him screaming bloody murder. (That's a scream even to today rings vividly if I think about too much. Oh my god did it ever disturb me. I just knew he was dead. But it's cool if the writers bring him back. Obviously recasted bc RIP Mr. Peck.

[@mickjigg]

Would love for this to be true. Even followed the comics where his blood brother saved his life last minute. I think we're looking at quite a stretch here. Muldoon is not coming back.

[@novahoth3406]

Ok, might also consider this as to how he survived: Experienced hunter.... WOULD ABSOLUTELY HAVE SOME KIND OF IDEAL BACK UP IN THE EVENT OF BEING PINNED. Its very clear that the raptor went teeth first not claw first. Give muldoon a knife in the boot. Nastly stab to the underbelly of the raptor. Possibly break away with ease. "What about the second raptor?" Either ran away when the first was injuried... or assuming he got the first one off... the spas 12 stock was deployed and had the hook (which means he could comfortably fire it with one hand)... weird technical detail but if a couple rounds of buckshot went by me I'd eff off in the other direction, I'd imagine a raptor would be bright enough to reconsider a fight

[@TheMalootrager]

Muldoon has always been my favourite character in Jurassic Park

[@jonathanlojas3696]

I love that you used music from Dino Crisis in your video. I'm getting so much nostalgia vibes from that game. Such a horrifying and adventurous game.

[@Kr0nicDragon]

They could just pull a palpatine, somehow he just survived.

[@williamwall3403]

That at least had some basis in previous lore with clones and his spirit taking over clones but Muldoon had nothing to fall back on.

[@allenkeith7160]

I totally believe that. Especially, in the chaos of the attacks... Why wouldn't there potentially be potential survivors that got trapped on the island, and missed the evacuation? It just makes sense to me, especially in areas of the attacks where they would get trapped in buildings and things and unable to leave.

[@RedbearwhiteAnimations]

Shadow never's gets old

[@ShadowsLew]

Appreciate it

[@ryanmay1298]

Incredible video, absolutely incredible! Love this content. Muldoon played by Bob Peck is such a gem in the original Jurassic Park movie, the way he delivers his lines, his seriousness when nobody else seems to truly understand that these creatures are not only to be respected but feared is fascinating to watch "QUIET, all of you... they're entering the Tyrannorsaur paddock". I love your theory that the Raptor was just playing with him, and although seems unlikely for the Jurassic World movie, it seems perfect for the game. I hope they listen to the fans and see videos like this and see how much we want Bob Peck's Muldoon back in the Jurassic World cannon! Thanks for the video look forward to more like this, until then.... Hold onto your butts.

[@AriBranch-k7u]

Hi shadows I hope your eating well and this video is amazing we love youuuu

[@ShadowsLew]

Thank you

[@conscript900]

To be perfectly honest. I think Muldoons death in the movie is honestly for the best. Why? Because it also shows that the situation is genuinely out of hand. The expert the head of security couldnt control the situation. Just plays out better that way in the movie.

[@DelainaTheJurassicFan]

Welcome back, Shadows! Missed you! I do hope you're feeling better! I do believe that Robert Muldoon is alive and may return in future Jurassic movies...and could we see him in Chaos Theory!? I hope so! Absolutely epic video today! Loved it! Keep up the great work! You're the best! Edit: Can you please do a video about the possible shocking return of Cathy Bowman?

[@ShadowsLew]

It's great to be back!! Hope you enjoyed today's video. Some great material in this video I never even heard about before!

[@Teabone3]

I always felt the point of his death in the film was to show that Raptors had the ability to out-smart even our brightest and knowledgeable about them.

[@BleachFan2007]

"Clever girl, but I'm Cleverer."

[@Vamroc]

I've notice each subsequent film seems to "barrow" an event that happened in the original novel like the whole trek through the jungle in the second film but during that journey in the original novel Hammond falls and is attacked by the "Compy", in the original novel it's Grant & the kids chased by the Pterodactyls which they escape by getting in rafts but that scene is the third movie. Malcolm's injury was FAR more gruesome too, it's implied Malcolm was on death's door when the helicopter came to save them but his popularity in THE MOVIE is why Malcolm made such an amazing recovery.

[@TravisMcInroy]

Muldoon is dead. A deleted scene from The Lost World: Jurassic Park confirmed it when Peter Ludlow was addressing wrongful death lawsuits to the Ingen board.

[@davidcolantuono3622]

I had mentioned this a long while back that the Raptors were playing with Muldoon. This video proves me right, all along.

[@Clonetrooper9341]

I would love to see him return

[@foggyh1425]

Y'know they should really make a Mini-Series following the book plot, they could bring back Muldoon that way too

[@MasterCooperGaming]

This just doesn’t make sense. It seems more of hopeful wishing than anything else. The raptors in the first movie were as animalistic and dangerous in the entire series. Especially with how the Big One ran the pack. Only the strongest survived. Muldoon was hunting the raptors, and the raptors most certainly would have finished him off. There is absolutely no reason to believe they were “playing” with Muldoon. He had a badass exit from the series and that scene is iconic! Leave it alone

[@icdeadpipol]

Perhaps the "Clever Girl" just mugged Muldoon and took his wallet 😂

[@TheGodzillafriend]

In 0:10 the raptor said hey

[@GhostRider-420]

HOLY SHIT YES I WOULD LOVE IT IF HE RETURNED, he did survive in the Jurassic park comics

[@simonmaguire5250]

Just get Burt Gummer in!

[@anthonycurby4606]

I think they want them to survive, and sending burt results in no survivng dinos. Burt only knows overkill

[@simonmaguire5250]

@@anthonycurby4606 That is kind of true, if Burt goes in there would be nothing left.

[@anthonycurby4606]

@@simonmaguire5250 not even ammo

[@simonmaguire5250]

@@anthonycurby4606 I do find it odd that he seems to always run out of ammo.

[@anthonycurby4606]

@@simonmaguire5250 i imagine its satisfying and sad at the same time though. Its never for too little ammo he runs out, but because too much has to be used.

[@DownHereInChile]

Bob Peck did NOT miss leg day, GAWD DAYUM

[@thejaredmyers]

I have a pretty vivid memory of a raptor with its mouth around his head from childhood... LoL 🤣

[@flukay72]

According to Lego Jurassic World he survives with Nerdy and Gennaro and they live together in the old visitors center. I read the book in anticipation of the movie and was absolutely heartbroken when he died in the movie because he was my favorite character. Then my dad got me the comics and I was so happy he was alive lol. Now I watch these movies with my young nephews.

[@marioschmitz180]

Loving the Dino Crisis Music in the Backround! Really looking forward to JP Survival.

[@maximumvio1et677]

Honestly, Muldoon surviving wouldn't be any wackier than anything we got in Dominion sooo why not? At least it's a returning character and not a super genius scientist that no one ever heard of even though she did all this awesome cool science stuff 25 years ago.

[@jaredteasdale7414]

Love this channel man. You make Theory’s make wayyy too much sense 💀

[@Elias_Auxilibus]

Holy crap, the music that starts playing in the background at 2:28 is one heck of a 20-something year blast from the past!

[@SteveRanke]

Muldoon was awesome! My favorite character since my dad took me to the theater in 93 ( i was 8) to see it. Everyone was so excited for this film. Just like Batman ( my first ever movie to see in a theater) and the original " Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles" movie ( 2nd film i seen in a theater) those were great times.

[@echeese63]

"Knows more about raptors than anyone" and they expect us to believe he'd be taken out by the side attack, which Grant knew about without ever having seen a living raptor

[@jacobdrolet4262]

Amazing video of Muldoon in the Jurassic Park franchise,fantastic job.

[@ShadowsLew]

Thank you very much!

[@saltyman1375]

Watched you since day one with Isle content. Glad to see how much your channel has grown

[@ShadowsLew]

An OG :) thanks for all the support :) appreciate it

[@joshuafallet5690]

i really liked him honestly. muldoon and eric kirby are my favorite characters of the whole series. to me kirby is the best because he survived alone on a dinosaur infested island. eric is more impressive to me because he had zero experience at all and managed for 6 months. i liked muldoon because he was a realist and respected the raptors as truly dangerous and intelligent creatures. his dialogue with alan in front of the raptor cage in the movie was so good. it really created a moment of awe and simultaneously portraying a horrifying gravitas.

[@michaelkata2342]

So the raptor was just "playing" with him, I guess he made those horrible screams of agony because it was licking his face off.

[@ShadowsLew]

Yeah seems it haha