Vickie Barton - The Betrayed Nurse - 88

On this episode of MWMH, Payton and Garrett discuss the murder of Vickie Barton.
Case Sources:
Links:
linktr.ee/murd...
Ads:
Seed: www.seed.com/HUSBAND and use code HUSBAND
HydroJug: www.thehydrojug.com and use code: HUSBAND
LightStream: www.lightstream.com/HUSBAND
Cozy Earth: www.cozyearth.com use code HUSBAND40
Betterhelp: www.betterhelp.com/husband
Olive and June: www.oliveandjune.com/husband use code HUSBAND
True Bill: www.truebill.com/husband
Forensic Files S11 Ep23
www.cbsnews.co...
www.wcpo.com/n...
www.cleveland1...
www.cincinnati...

[@murderwithmyhusband]

Hey everyone! Thanks so much for listening.

[@lorieaprica6406]

Thank you so much for completing my Monday and for giving us a great true crime story ❤ Happy Birthday Payton 🥳

[@Pakelcigariet]

Thank you for doing this ❤️❤️❤️

[@bealong8718]

I took holidays from work in September for 2 weeks, and caught up every episode of MWMH. It was so satisfying to have the library marked in red, and stay kept up with new releases, adding Patreon on weekend. LOVE your channel xx

[@althea7210]

HEY BIRTHDAY SISTER 🥳 Im the 25th too fellow Sagittarius ♐️ & occasional Thanksgiving birthday girl 🦃 (Im not a fan of turkey & when I was turning like 5 my family brought a turkey with candles instead of a cake & I was balling & they were laughing hysterical-I would never trade growing up in 70s thru 90s! Of course the cake eventually came)! Im ALMOST double your age! I was laughing when Garret said you were 47 as I turned a YOUTHFUL 49 👩🏼‍🦳🤣 Enough babble… I HOPE YOU HAD A WONDERFUL BIRTHDAY & ALL YOUR WISHES COME TRUE 🎂 🎈 🎁 💝 🥳

[@sandirhodes9126]

Thanks for talking! 😁

[@essencehunter9849]

my jaw literally dropped when he said she was turning 47. 😭😭😭 i’m like no way 😂

[@Kayli3D3]

Literally same

[@heezypeasy8611]

That would make her 9 yrs older than me which is in no way possible 😆😆😆

[@caseymarie625]

I literally gasped

[@magretrivas419]

Same

[@chaoswitchofthewyrd]

I just discovered y'all through TCKR and Mile Higher, and I love you guys! The whole premise is so fresh and entertaining (as far as it's interesting to see Garrett learn about the cases for the first time with his non true crime attuned mind). I am a huge TC junkie, and I really enjoy how y'all tell the stories so honestly and victim focused. When Payton talks about the victims and gets emotional, she really expresses the way we feel while hearing the cases as well. So glad I found y'all!

[@AlE-ld3ld]

O,kihbyonzmnulki Nux7†(

[@acenothanks]

Would love to hear some more survivor stories, but I'm loving everything you guys have been putting out so far thanks for the hard work!

[@mercedeswilliams5956]

I have the perfect one for them to do

[@GH-ks9zb]

Check alison botha episode

[@daninash5048]

I discovered you guys from Mile Higher and got hooked! I have watched almost every single episode now and I just love y’all. I think I really like the more script/story with reaction type rather than people already knowing the case and just discussing with eachother because everything garrett reacts is usually a similar response to myself so it feels like a live like i’m with y’all thing!

[@kristi_vera_parker]

I found out about them through Mile Higher too!!! ❤❤❤🎉🎉🎉 How great is it?!? 🙏🙏🙏

[@Bhavishah8]

So the guy who actually sexually assaulted her and killer her walks free... this is just so sad... 😥

[@kearam8829]

Listened to this one over on Patreon already 🙊 But it's like a whole different experience getting the visuals too! Another great podcast, guys! Keep it up 🖤

[@murderwithmyhusband]

We upload an ad-free video version on Patreon but we also love having you here too!!!

[@MichaelMartin-kz2ts]

I needed this so bad on this crappy Monday!! Ty both!!

[@murderwithmyhusband]

Awh we love you!!! Hope you have a better day tomorrow 🖤🖤🖤

[@breezybee3774]

When I am in pain and overstimulated, your show is perfect to regulate to Your voices are great, and your hubby says what I think SO OFTEN.. Lol Thanks for what you do. You create a safe space within crime without even meaning to. Thank you Xox

[@cassielynn1023]

I felt like her husband was some how involved the second you played the first 911 call recording! I know everyone reacts differently in these situations but just something about his tone of voice & how he almost seemed calm? I’m not sure if that’s the word I’m looking for but he literally sounded as if he was just calling up a buddy to chat to me. I feel like there would be something, some hint of sadness, heartbreak, anger SOMETHING after just finding his wife shot execution style in their home. Idk though like I said everyone reacts different in different situations so you can’t always base guilt off of that but it just sent chills down my spine hearing the way he said it to the 911 operator. 😳😩

[@timothyhalsey6480]

You're very pretty

[@wonderfred]

He was calm because he's accustomed to stressful situations. If you noticed he said something about her clothes still being on, which doesn't really make sense. His mind was definitely reeling.

[@nollypaetra931]

@@wonderfred but ur wife being dead is more then enough stress to drive a person mad

[@wonderfred]

@@nollypaetra931 I suppose that depends on the person and their capacity to handle stress.

[@nollypaetra931]

@@wonderfred now that i think of it fair point it’s hard to determine if he genuinely was innocent and that was just his reaction

[@GIJaneUSAF]

I started listening to you guys a while back & had made my way through all of the episodes fairly quickly lol but my husband had overheard me listening to the podcast one day and was actually interested & now he likes listening/watching as well! Which blew me away because he does not like true crime & I absolutely love it. So in a way our relationship is like you guys! I grew up watching Snapped & Forensic Files and I've been hooked ever since. I can watch/listen to true crime stories all day everyday, but I think that my husband starts to think I'm a psycho or something if I'm steady bingeing it all day lmao but he actually likes y'alls podcast! I will let him pick an episode & I'll re-listen to the story along with him, and now we will watch the new episodes together 😊 It's lovely! I love it & you guys 🤍 Thank you both for doing this podcast and slowly bringing my husband into the true crime world, one story at a time lol

[@GIJaneUSAF]

Also, Happy Belated Birthday! ❤ I always felt that we were probably around the same age, only 1 year apart! I'll be turning 26 on December 1st 😝 My husband & I share a Birthday, which is fun. Only 2 days away & looking forward to it! I hope you had a great Birthday & Thanksgiving ♡

[@maddielloydlove1d]

My bf and I are the same!!!! its so crazy he has never had an interest in true crime until he started watching these vids and listening to the podcast, we love it!

[@laurenmcintosh1508]

I’m waiting for the episode when you say “I love it” and he says “I don’t mind it “ I feel like you are slowly turning him into a true crime junkie

[@ericainncca9771]

I heard him say I don't hate it that much!! She's getting there!

[@ashielowden1734]

this podcast has become part of my weekly ritual 👏🏼👏🏼👏🏼 love your guyses looks on theese cases !!!!!

[@heezypeasy8611]

Of course, I suspected the husband from the beginning mainly bc he seemed way too calm during the 911 call. Then he gets married not long after his wife's murder. Ahhh the photo of Phelps drinking out of the so very 90s paper cup made me laugh too hard 😆

[@monicagarcia7765]

I saw betrayed nurse and instantly clicked lol so excited love you guys!

[@TinaRoxx]

Found you guys on tiktok like a week ago, and then binged every episode. Now I'm sad that I'm all caught up and I have two days off! Keep up the awesome work!

[@madeleineritchey2230]

Loved that I found you guys, you're my new work podcast obsession!!! I hope you decorate for Christmas, happy holidays!

[@shelbys669]

Omg he was so convincing when he said 47! My mouth dropped I was like DAMN NO WAY she looks like she's in her 20s.

[@Lily-zp5hf]

But i just started watching you guys a few days ago and love it! I watch your videos all day long! Love it!

[@Lanna_Bananas]

Sameee!!

[@murraybabington9953]

genuinely just want to hang with you guys. yall are the best!

[@christinalee2072]

Love your channel - discovered it recently… I really appreciate that you briefly cite sources before giving your account and that you are so respectful of the victims - always giving them the final thoughts…. Please consider looking into the Lauren Agee case and/or the Harmony Montgomery one…

[@uhmokay5995]

Hello! My Spotify wrap just exposed me that despite listening to DOZENS AND DOZENS of other podcasts, you're my FAVORITE one this year! ::) I listened to 74 of your episodes on Spotify and the rest are what I viewed here in YT. You guys definitely made my pandemic quarantine world better ::))) stay safe always AND ADVANCED HAPPY BIRTHDAY PAYTON!

[@hihelloizzy]

Literally binging all your videos. Here from Mile Higher!

[@donovanguerin2124]

Just found this channel less than a week ago and have been binging hard at work all day. Love the chemistry between you both, works perfectly. Keep up the good work, love from Sydney, Australia. 🇦🇺

[@chantelkemp2405]

Can't wait to see that Christmas set! Mr and Mrs. Clause would be fun to see too 🎅🤶

[@keellyxo]

Found you on Tiktok & I have binge watched every episode in 2 weeks and now I’m all caught up 😭😭😭

[@evieo4153]

Your podcast is my only source of happiness lmao love you!!💗

[@Opiinferidii]

So glad I found y'all's channel, love the content

[@philnewjams1274]

I like how they actually give you there sources on each case they do..

[@emilyjohnson8036]

Lmfao! I was like DANG YOU LOOK GOOOOOD FOR 47!!! 😂😂😂

[@elenatodorovska7410]

She said I am gona be 25 on the 25th 🤔🤔🤔

[@emilyjohnson8036]

@@elenatodorovska7410 I know but her husband said she just turned 47 as a joke 😅

[@murderwithmyhusband]

Hahahaha😂😂

[@demetrisray7806]

I heard this story before but it lacked so much details I'm glad you put in the time to fill them in

[@MauraMoo97]

You’re my number one podcast on my Spotify wrapped 😍😍

[@chrislynnparmer6045]

I stumbled upon you's on Mile higher and really liked you. So I decided to give your channel a try and I love it now I'm just started binge watching all your old videos....... And just realized me and you have the same birthday Payton I thought that was so awesome I however am "just alittle" bit older than you though I am 41!!! Thanks for the content and I love Garrett's reactions and input too!!!

[@janelleparkins5091]

I've been busy so I haven't heard your voices in like 3 weeks! I'm finally catching up now, and I've missed you guys! 🥲

[@ktrudy1]

Binge watching ur vids and having my coffee. Yay. Love y’all 🥰

[@BenLacy2112]

This is pretty wild to just stumble upon. My mom is Maryann and I was Jim’s stepson for those 15 months or so. I don’t think about this case often, but it came up when watching other true crime videos.

[@davidtassy9901]

A lot of true crime cases really don’t realize how much they go off the prosecutors case. That’s all forensic files is “The state is right “. Glad to see this podcast cover all grounds. This case was based off a line on a phone call that’s it. It was never good enough for trial.

[@KGB4200]

So glad I came across y’all’s podcast I now look forward to Mondays !!!

[@marararahplays3772]

I have went through all the episodes and I NEED MORE!!!! I love listening to you guys :D

[@skullmarie13]

Omg!!! I came across this channel and finished all their videos in 2 days🤓. I am like Garrett asking questions when Payton just said it 20 secs ago 🤣. I also have them now on my Spotify, their voices help me relax and fall asleep in a very good way. 👍🏼👍🏼👍🏼

[@jessigaming]

Golden birthday? I’m less than a minute in but I’ve never heard that before. We call it a champagne birthday in Canada.

[@kayleecreelman6581]

I had a bad day at work and tonight this is definitely what I need, thanks for always being there

[@JohnAlex1]

Twists and turns!! Great job - thank you!

[@audijohnson5271]

How did I miss?? Love this podcast, such great story tellers and Garrett’s reactions are amazing!

[@awesomeblossom6156]

Hey guys I just found your podcast today love it so far. Going to have to catch up lol.

[@SugaaKatt]

Watching you guys grow is so great !!

[@gwaley]

You said that they rifled through the guns. Rifled through the guns. It was a glorious pun!!!

[@daveh1065]

I think Alfred pleas also prevent the suspect to sue for anything, such as false imprisonment, etc.

[@anshrutarasania7718]

You should take up a very mysterious and unsolved murder case of Arushi Talvar, the most high profile case in India

[@stephaniec0625]

Lol I've only watched a few episodes and am hooked and was just wondering if Garrett was going to ask about cameras🤣

[@rorybrown8346]

me and my boyfriend love you guys! thank you for all your hard work

[@mariodavissa1085]

I'm from South Africa and patreon is not something I can do due to currencies being so different, I just can't wait a week for a new episode

[@fananzo]

Hey fellow South African! Same here 😂

[@12inchhammer59]

Polygraphs are used for investigators to clear people, it helps direct the investigation. It’s allowed to be used as defence but not for prosecution. It’s kinda like a meter used by investigators to clear people.

[@Caitlinparkex]

I hope you guys do decorate for Christmas!! I love watching on KZbin! 🥰

[@samuelrobson510]

I don't think you say that you gotta "call for help" when you are literally already on the phone to 911.. if he needed to call anyone else he'd have said... my family.. my parents... etc... Just my gut instinct... I understand why the justice system had to do what it did still.

[@charlibrodnick]

as someone who lives in the small town of springboro i feel i should voice my opinion on the police here , I feel that there defintley could have been some evidence that was over looked , Springboro is such a small town and i dont think that they would have had proper police raining at the time . which may be why the audio analysis showed that he was moving stuff around during the 9-1-1 call . I have looked up the adress of this house and if there were any gas stations near at the time of the murder , THERE WAS less than a mile away from the bartons house so why wouldnt the person that needed gas just walk to the gas station rather than knocking on the bartons house for gas seems weird . but I dont know this is all just my opinion .

[@benjaminh.clement1292]

I hope it does not sounds unsensitive to the stories, but you made me laugh by going ahead of Garrett question saying "there were no cameras" because he loves them so much 😛 and what you guys do is amazing, giving the poor people that meets a fate like that more awareness and a voice so that their stories aren't forgotten is really amazing.

[@marqueethekey]

She swiped out 😂😂😂 and Mary Ann swiped in ☠️☠️☠️

[@lenamae6831]

When she said 47 I almost lost it I took her way too seriously I immediately started studying her face 😂😂😂

[@tristaeaster8466]

I grew up in SW Ohio (all those towns are super close and we all know everyone’s business) and I e NEVER HEARD OF THIS CASE! So crazy

[@bronsonnewman2657]

Loved the video. and I love the new thumbnail.

[@lenagaaa]

The husband says right away in the 911 call that his wife has been mur- and then cuts himself off. Then changes his wording immediately

[@laurenking5946]

YOU HAD ME WITH THE 47 BIT I was like holy god Payton what's your secret. 25 makes more sense XD

[@madelynlietz2949]

oh my gosh! I remember following you all from tiktok a couple months ago and I am just WOWed at how you much your socials have grown! I am a true crime podcast fanatic and you all are my favorite. I love your victim centered view and both of your genuine care of the stories of these individuals, such a fresh perspective. Keep doing what you're doing!!!!!

[@cN-xv7ju]

An Alfred plea is also so u can’t sue for being locked up for a crime u didn’t commit , Memphis 3 comes to mind

[@paigebarker1468]

I live like 20 minutes away from Springboro and I've never heard of this case! I'm learning about a case that's pretty old but brand new to me, it makes me feel like Garrett! 😂😂

[@JjMmCc_123]

His small town comment. Yes crimes that happen in small towns are much more scarier. A girl I went to school with her dad sex trafficked girls our age. It could of been any one of us.

[@elliottwilliams9221]

He did it! I’m like Garrett the Phelps thing is a dead ringer. Ppl just sympathized with him so he got off light but he hired those men, but there’s no honor amongst theives

[@missdaytona2004]

I wonder if this is part of what Fargo was based off of?

[@rachelezeugo9740]

Thank you guys for this! God bless you. I love your podcast!

[@bessiebabycrossing9627]

You said in the beginning that when Vickie had called Jim that day to tell him about motorcyclist that stopped by he was upset and had already told her to be more careful. Maybe she was too wreckless for a cops wife and Jim wanted to scare her so she’d stop and to not make him look bad? Idk just a thought. Would explain why nothing was stolen and he was shocked to find her dead and said he had to call Phelps.

[@trishbaum6364]

The west Memphis 3 got the Alfred plea. He was already on the phone with help. He could have had another connection to Phelps and maybe it was some kind of payback.

[@debmacdougall9744]

Just found your channel from Mile High , loving your content going through all your old videos. We call your Birthday ( 25 on the 25th your champagne 🥂 BDay ). Was a year ago just an fyi.

[@SebaVDP]

Another creepy episode!!! Love your channel guys!!! Just one question how many baby albino wookies you need to decorate your tea table 🥺🥺🥺 you psychos!!! 😅 hugs from Argentina and have a great week guys!!!

[@murderwithmyhusband]

It’s a fake fur blanket! Thank you for listening 🖤

[@aleecran]

Omg i remember this one from forensic files so tragic☹️

[@denisebacher5040]

I heard “Phil” the first time and every consecutive time you played the recording. Not “help”. Plus I also heard him moving stuff around. Which, I guess, could be him clearing the house but it doesn’t sound like him opening and shutting doors. It sounds like him picking up and setting down things. I do believe it was the husband and I wish he’d just come out and admit it so the person who killed his wife could be caught. I think everyone would forgive him more if he admitted he did it to scare her and it went horribly wrong. 😞

[@sabrinanguyen9620]

i’m watching your videos in reverse chronological order and just found out me and payton have the same birthday!! 🥳🥳🥳

[@sosanis3127]

My top podcast for 2021 Spotify wrapped 🙌❤️

[@Hamous83]

Listening to this was weird for me because i knew a cop growing up that was a police chief named jim barton

[@FreakyNightCreature]

This is gonna help me fall asleep tonight

[@morganlea9783]

New fan here! You guys are amazing 💕

[@justinemason1163]

He said Phelps dammit !! Lol

[@austindoxtator107]

Hi guys! I was just wondering where I might be able to find episodes 1-29 31-40? Also I made a suggestion for John List not reliezing it’s literally one of your first episodes 😂 thanks for keeping entertained and focused at work even though a few of these(kids cases, what the AH Lester did, Oklahoma girls, and the South African lady who survived, who is an absolute warrior) I’m currently on episode 88 and I’m catching up fast 😂

[@dovenunery5640]

i live 12 mins away from springboro…this is insane

[@allisonmcdonald661]

AYEEE any other speech therapist get excited hearing that!!

[@janewaysmom]

Idk I always think an Alfred Plea is for people who are smart enough to realize they don't have the resources to fight the cops, or they're under-educated enough to not fully understand how strong their case is, but they actually didn't do anything. Less of an ego issue and more of a victim of the system issue. I've heard episodes of podcasts where people are very obviously totally innocent and take Alfred Pleas because there's some weak circumstantial evidence against them.

[@Lena-vh3mh]

You guys should do an episode on Jean-Claude Romand it's a super interesting case that happenned in France.

[@JustRoleWithIt]

Lol the intro cracked me up...btw I've come to the conclusion Peyton looks like, Christy Carlson Romano aka Ren from even Steven's or KP ( Kim possible) and I love it... haha oh nostalgia...but in all seriousness this is a tragic loss that should have been solved sooner

[@sashafierce9879]

Omg... My birthday is November 25th as well... Sagittarius Queen... I knew i loved u for some reason... 😂😂

[@meganjudd8027]

Ffs when u said 47 my jaw hit the floor lol. U got me.

[@aperseghetti]

After watching many docs on Netflix like "The Staircase" and "How To Fix A Drug Scandle" just shows you that you can't always rely on that state's "experts." It is still an opinion but like a doctor, it is an expert opinion, which is backed up with tons of education and scientific evidence obviously. The Staircase's defendant even says that you should always hire your own "experts" but if you don't have money you can't afford to do so. He went broke from trying to prove his innocence and then it comes out years later that the state experts were lying or wrong about stuff. It's been a couple years since I've watched it so I apologize for not saying the exact reasons. I'm not saying that the expert in this case with the breaking down of the sounds is wrong though either. The state obviously isn't going to get a "second opionion" but if you truly are innocent and can afford it, always get one with your own expert.

[@Anxiousella]

HAPPY BIRTHDAY PEY (late lol) love listening to your podcast

[@doubleyouayee_]

I’m so happy for cc now!!!

[@mama_bear_0425]

Omg happy belated bday girl.. I rember 10 years ago when i used to be 25 years old.. The best year of my life

[@jaylyncaban7850]

Your nails are 😍🤌 love the box design!

[@yashpaste7700]

"Swiper no Swiping" LMAO

[@kennymiskell4918]

I believe the Alford pleas are used so the defendant can’t sue the state for wrongful conviction. The defendant takes the deal so they can say they are innocent, but mainly to get out of prison. Cause it could take years to get out or they could be found guilty once again.

[@Caitlynxoono]

Can u do the ellie gould case ! I know there isn't that much about it but everyone needs to hear about it

[@Lanna_Bananas]

Not sure if you have done this case before, I just found you guys *and love you* I'm in the middle of watching all episodes- there's a lot- Lol But, you should do the case of Andrea Yates It's a very interesting case- I'm not sure if you will find a lot of info on it but....you could try...? Not sure.. But it seems you are very good at finding a lot of info on these cases. Love Yall!!

[@crenshaw3xs]

Love u guys keep up the good work