Musical Theatre Coach Reacts to Idina Menzel Best LIVE Vocals

**Do you want a singing critique from me?
Send me your clip:
www.wisio.com/TheHonestVocalC...
**The Foundations of Singing - Online Course is NOW LIVE!
This course is ideal for beginners or those wanting to know more about the technique of singing and have a daily vocal routine.
Take the course:
www.udemy.com/course/the-foun...
**Let me be your vocal coach & mentor (1 x 30 minute vocal session or 4 x 30 minute session via SKYPE per month plus mentoring throughout the month)
SIGN UP: / thehonestvocalcoach
Twitter: / thehonestvocal
Instagram: / thehonestvocalcoach
I am the honest vocal coach! I have been teaching for 16 years and been singing since I was 16. I teach from my own studio and also teach and mentor via email, and online via Live & Skype. I specialise in teaching children, and teenagers pop and musical theatre but I am trained in all genres of music. I have studied every voice technique there is, including Speech Level Singing, Estill, Bel Canto, Robert Lunte, London College of Music, ABRSM, Ria Keen, Kim Chandler, Stevie Van Lange and many more. I have been around!
In 2008 I wrote the Vocaltutor Guide, 21 set lessons for singing teachers to get started, learning to teach, and produced 3 vocal exercise CD/Downloads.
#thehonestvocalcoach #vocalcoachreacts
This video is for educational purposes and is not intended to infringe any copyright.

[@patrickcleary6315]

I love Idina, I understand her voice isn’t always perfect but nobody can perform like she can

[@pneuma22]

Maybe Lea Michele LOL

[@millangullehag4138]

Idina is so down to earth and so nice with the audience

[@beej7286]

Ruan Carlos no way

[@sapphiccore]

i could watch a video of idina menzel literally just eating soup and i'd still be like wow she is SO TALENTED

[@footkk]

The real question is how the frick do you eat soup

[@shannoncrawford5812]

@@footkk With the kind of talent Idina has 😉

[@AbbeyKat]

the vocal damage is unfortunate, but even so, no one belts like her. the clarity in her upper register is incomparable

[@slider2754]

Does she really have vocal damage bc it does not show. Everybody has bad days.

[@Kaylee-uk7pn]

Slider 27 she definitely has vocal damage, you can tell her voice is partially damaged. You can’t expect to have a perfect voice as a singer forever. But aside form that. She’s amazing.

[@samcarpenter4230]

Leann Rhymes tori Kelly jojo

[@youwillneverfindme2396]

@@slider2754 she sometimes sounds like she has but it also could be that she’s changed how she sings like she use to be so raspy now she’s not

[@cidiaz3611]

As a huge Idina fan I’ve been waiting for this!! Also, these clips are good but there’s so much more they could add for her best vocals! It’s also kind of a shame how short they made the clips and only concentrated on belts when part of what makes her amazing is her vulnerability and authenticity as a performer, which I think was somewhat lost by making the clips so short.

[@queerchoreography54]

She’s GREAT one of the best REALLY. She’s a pure vocalist that anyone would like.

[@CharlieDavid-Lloyd]

YESSSSSSS! Been waiting for Idina! Love her voice - off too see Frozen 2 straight after this video!! So excited

[@danyielsays4621]

Her in wicked is amazing🔥😱 defying gravity 👌

[@millangullehag4138]

Danyiel Says favourite Elphaba for ever!!

[@useranon9571]

In her first years of theatre such as rent, I LOVED her raspy voice especially in take me or leave me but her talent is timeless 🤍🤩

[@marga_mld]

The song you didn't recognize at 8:40 is called "This Is My Story Now" it's one of her original songs. She only did it live, it was never released, she just recorded a demo for the next album

[@Meg63826]

I am obsessed with idina

[@JKDC97]

The song at 8:40 is on KZbin as "This Is My Story Now"

[@gothgirlgraveyard3539]

I honestly loved raspy voice in the 90s

[@Robbleheads]

Lucky enough to have been there to hear her sing that note in Seasons of Love in LI 😍😍😍😍😍😍😍😍

[@JoanFreese]

Just letting you know I look forward to your videos- you are a breath of fresh air and a lovely person !!

[@justyntimezzz9632]

I love this channel!!! You're amazing and so is your content!! Live for your acapella bursts #life! Thank you!! Justin.

[@arranblyth7618]

So glad you did this video! Her voice is amazing! So excited for your musical theatre Monday’s ❤️

[@edwardlegend1564]

Love Idina and you❤️❤️

[@adamG2001]

Thank you!!!!!!!!!!! I love idina!!!!!!!!!♥️♥️♥️♥️

[@killulgybixxes7137]

I love ur channel and you.😘

[@jaissapierce4057]

Her voice is unique but I like it.

[@emmadonaldson7876]

She’s like a young Streisand 💗

[@ezrealxshsh5460]

@David S. Must be sad to get offended by everything lol

[@nobodyspesh]

You should check out you+me - no ordinary love. Great song, great version!

[@lukerinderknecht2982]

Man, Adele Dazeem has a great voice!

[@jackhutchinson1457]

Some would say she’s wickedly talented

[@andrewbird3885]

I swear georgina is reading my mind. Katy perry is my Favourite female artist. Brendon and panic are my favourite band. Idina is my favourite musical actress. She’s done them all recently. Now if i see bruno mars pop up soon i’m gonna scream.

[@reybie8894]

She's amazing.💖

[@leticiags6395]

Loveeeee idina 💕💕

[@LilCraftyNook]

Interesting echo-y sound going on. Almost like she’s in a tunnel sometimes. Lovely nonetheless!!

[@wehttamaloveschicken7916]

Yes it's a bit annoying kinda like Beyonce's weird reverb

[@NducciaTube]

Her voice is too strong for microphones 😝

[@cristinamartin2507]

The song you were asking about is "this is my story now" and its a song she wrote and has only performed it on her tour with Josh Groban in 2018. It is actually an amazing song, hope its on her next album.

[@sidnunn7137]

You should react to tons and I Live performances !! 👋

[@ashitatatireddy8459]

oh god no, sorry I'm australian and here in Australia Tones and I is played EVERYWHERE, there isn't one place she isn't played, after hearing her that many times it gets kinda annoying, but if you like her thats your choice but yea xx

[@adamG2001]

What is the song that Georgina didn’t know!?!? I want to know too

[@amax1229]

You haven't forgotten about Floor Jansen singing Vilja Lied, Mama, Que Se Siente, Shallow, About Love I Don't Know A Thing, and Winner, on the Dutch TV show Beste Zangers, have you? (hint hint wink wink) ❤️

[@KAITooh7]

Hi bobbaaaaa

[@alejandrofeocecin3399]

She may be inconsistant in some performances but she is still great and great video btw :)

[@AndySaenz]

I’m first? Cool 😎

[@Rosannasfriend]

Actually I was more impressed than I expected to be. If she's capable of the level of singing we saw in some of these clips, then it's a damn shame that she's not consistent. She should really work on that.

[@JFPickus]

Never heard of her, I must be too old.

[@tessamaebryson1572]

James Pickus how have you never heard of her seriously

[@queerchoreography54]

James Pickus now u have!

[@benjamingonzalezr.5489]

Mom of Rachel Berry in my memory 😂

[@katiecotton6166]

..it is worth mentioning that she is pulling chest (is straining) in several of these clips! And she now has voice damage as a result..

[@grishkotoe]

Too nasal and thin - to me, has the effect of nails scraping a chalkboard. Voice needs to be “rounder”, more open, have more depth, fuller - something... Not classically trained?

[@millangullehag4138]

grishkotoe that's why she broke through. She isn't like other singers, with boring, Common voices. Her voice is so unique

[@sarahwithstars]

Hate Rain on my Parade, such an overdone standard that is too often done badly.

[@seano1515]

I appreciate Idina Menzel as a cultural influence, but I have to admit that I don't care for her voice. The belts without vibrato (à la Katy Perry, Taylor Swift...) just sound like screaming to me. When she does use vibrato, it seems by accident as a result of improper breath support. And sometimes she eats her consonants 4:54, it's "goNNNNNNa RRRRRaain onNNNNMMMmyy..." . Maybe a stylistic choice, but it sounds kind of annoying to me.

[@allifrodrigues3462]

She shouts to much - most of time strained. She is ten to hundred: sometimes sounds great sometimes sharp and flat. Lea is more constant than her - vocally - and her tone is more pleasant. But, it's all my opinion.

[@petitnicolas33]

She's just shouting during long time and she have a nasal voice...boring

[@sarahwithstars]

Focus too much on single note belts instead of phrasing and characterization... It's all always about building up to the bridge and 2or3 powernotes with her; which suits for musical theatre but means I'd never listen to her album or go to a gig of her soloing.

[@jinkertsun]

You’re right she’s sometimes hard work to listen to. All this belting out a song gets a bit repetitive after a while.

[@millangullehag4138]

Then why are you watching this video? hah;)