Mutazila 10: A Framework to Understand Islamic History

[@muhammadfasihkhan8508]

Dr. Taimur is an asset to our education system

[@Ahmad-yi6d]

سر جی کماپ کر دیا ہے آپ نے ماشاءاللہ۔ بہت خوبصورتی کے ساتھ آپ نے نے خلفہ راشدین سے لے کر عثمانی سلطنت کے قیام تک کا ایک مجموعی جائزہ فراہم کیا ہے۔ اس سے بہت ساری بنیادی باتیں سمجھنے کو ملی ہیں۔

[@shabbirahmeddar7765]

Boht hi aala. You deserve standing salutes.

[@amhasan9911]

Excellent.... May Allah give you more knowledge and capability to dessiminate it...Ameen Suma Ameen..... . Jazak Allah Khair

[@Silicone5432]

Bravo What A Indebted Study & Lecture On Our Islamic Political History The Past Lives With The Present Cannot Define More On A Single Sentence

[@aqdasikram]

ماشا اللہ زبردست اور جو آپ نے آخر میں نتائج اخذ کیے گویا ساری بات ہی شیشہ کر دی۔ جزاک اللہ خیرا بھائی

[@ASMReating597]

kamaal ker diya hai Boss....zabardast lecture

[@mazharhussain-i8v]

Dr sab, good effort on history of ruling Islam. Unfortunely, what happened and what actual Idealogy says are different things. Unless you do not understand ideology well , history is full of confusion, and different terminolgies are taken with different perspectives. Overall, quite educative for a history student

[@worldview3565]

Read few books on Ummayad and Abbasid dynasty in the past. However, this 43 mins summary is quite precise and comprehensive. Thanks professor.

[@user-my4kt3nm8x]

❤❤❤🇧🇩🇧🇩🇧🇩 হলিউড মুভির চেয়েও আপনার ভিডিও অনেক অনেক বেশি আকর্ষণীয়। অতুলনীয় স্যার। আপনার ভিডিওর অপেক্ষায় থাকি সবসময়। apko salam sir

[@Redwhitewings]

Plato vi movie ki Tara Dil Kash hai magar Plato ne Greek or Roman civilization ko destroy kia magar Goethe said Charo or jhut ki beach Sach hai , take refuge there...o Sach ha Islam...read Mathew Arnolds memorial verse

[@fidahussain6312]

Thanks for educating us.

[@shahiawan]

Thank you for covering history objectively, everyone else focuses on their religious point of view. Hats off to you! Please continue covering history without any biases. One thing if you could please shed light on is the relationship of Abassis with Shia imams and when and how the 4 sunni doctrines came into picture along with their relationship with Mutazilla and other school of thoughts in chronological order.

[@suhailhamid8245]

Excellent assessment of our situation. In particular, the conclusion that muslims have not progressed, and still fighting on issues that have long since become irrelevant.. You mentioned that the people of Madina did not come to the defense of Hazrat Usman. Perhaps this was so because they were anticipating that the Islamic khilafat would not be limited to the Makkah tribes, and after some time, one of them would be entrusted with khilafat. When this did not seem to be happening, they felt alienated. If so, then they had a point... Please continue with the impact of later Islamic empires, such as Fatimid, Seljuk, Ottomans, and perhaps the Salahuddin Ayyubi one. These would be having further impact on religious belief systems in practice continuing till now.

[@waseemijaz4087]

Its a great way to look at history, thank you so much sir

[@sarahkhan3711]

Thanks a lot for such clarity in explaining Islamic history.

[@javaidkj]

Thank you very much you explained it very well in urdu we need more people like you in Pakistan

[@mansoorshahab]

Bravo... And wonderful synthesis encapsulated in the closure

[@manahil558]

Amazing! I wish this series never ended!

[@naseemarifraja1]

Great job ❤❤❤

[@Mukhtar_Ali]

Sir thank you for presenting an excellent account of the important history with it’s dynamics in an easy to understand and engaging way. Simply Brilliant. JizakAllah ❤

[@abdullahriaz3174]

So brave of you, very well explained ❤️

[@kassimtufail9061]

Great job 👏🏼 very nice impressive information!

[@advocatehafiznasirmahmood5980]

ماشاءاللہ سر جی ہر شیئ دے چھوڈے لا کے تے موچھے پائی اندے او

[@deanduniya8128]

سر آپ نے اس سیریز میں کمال کر دیا ہے

[@rahmancivilengr]

Mr taimur from episdo 1 to 10 Great great efforts Excellent work Keep it up Excellent energy Episode 10 ❤ summarizes every thing quite well . Please now make 10 episodes on current issue and how humanity can upgrade themselves in next century and what are solutions to humanity in current world

[@kashifahmed6913]

Wah, amazing analysis Really appreciate all the work and the videos you make

[@Gujjar-Gorasi_2k25]

Please Continue the Mu'tazili Series. I'm Learning a lot. Next Part soon. 4-5 more videos of 30-30 mins requested. 🌹 Thanks 💞 🌹 💞

[@mahnazqaiser3371]

Excellent 🎉🎉🎉 Waiting for your next video.

[@ssingha2071]

Refreshing and enlightening. Thanks. 👍👍👍

[@crochet_craft_by_iqra]

sir big respect. thanks for your contributions

[@fahadali6099]

آپکی کوشس نہایت عمدہ ہے۔ مولانا عبیداللہ سندھی رح تاریخ اسلام کو درج ذیل ادوار میں تقسیم کرتے ہیں جو کہ آپ کے لیکچر سے بھی کافی مماثلت رکھتا ہے۔ 1_ تاریخ اسلام کا اجتماعی نقطہ نظر اور قرآنی انقلاب۔ 2_ قرآنی انقلاب کی پہلی منزل (دور نبوی ص و خلافت راشدہ) 3_ قرآنی انقلاب کی دوسری اور تیسری منزل (دور اموی و دور عباسی) 4_ قرآنی انقلاب کا چوتھا دور (غیر عرب سلطنتیں اور حکومتیں ) 5_ قومی جمہوری دور

[@AliGilani-y8q]

Thank you, Dr. Taimor Rehman, for your insightful podcast series on Mutazila philosophy and its political implications. Your clear and thoughtful presentation made complex ideas accessible and engaging. I appreciate your efforts in sharing this valuable knowledge and research. If possible shape this valued asset into book. 🙏

[@DaraShikoh7]

Kamal kar chadyaa ayy Sir kamaal kar chadya....!! Salute ayy!! Bas ak gal mari ayy ju k jaiz vi ayy akhir Pakistan cha vi rahna ayy!! Glorification!!

[@sharjeeljawaid]

Informative. Good analysis.

[@Noor-gd6pd]

Always enjoy watching your lectures 👍🏻

[@saleemtaj2647]

AOA This vlog clear our several concepts, we appreciate your efforts and work. I request to make a series on our sects to understand the basics. Thanks

[@AliAkber-e7s]

Sir ap KY es trha KY lecture sy bhot Kuch janany ko Mila ap es ko ayk series mna dy or Jo complete series ho Es sy bhot awareness aa ay gi

[@muhammadehsan6524]

Brilliant and concise ❤

[@Bilawal-Bhutto]

Much needed Series ❤👍

[@faridpatel1532]

Framework to understand economics thoughts and history could be really useful, I benefited from different economics thinkers but I do lack similar Framework

[@pishoripashtoconsciousness]

زبردست ، یقین جانیے اس طرح کے لیکچرز ناپید ہیں، اور یہ مسلم کیمونٹی کی بدقسمتی ہے کہ وہ اس چینل سے فائیدہ نہیں اٹھا رہے۔ یہ لیکچرز جو ڈاکٹر صاحب مختلف موضوعات پر دیتے ہیں۔ رائیگاں نہیں جائیں گے۔ ❤

[@AmjedAli-pj2kz]

Early part of critical Islamic history couldn’t have been narrated so eloquently in such a short period.

[@mukhayar]

زبردست ۔بہت آعلیٰ

[@FaizMuhammad-l7t]

sir please make videos on philosophy like nihilism, metaphysics, epistemology, ethics, logic, stoicism, aesthetics and philosophy of mind please please please 🥺🥺

[@shoaz0611]

One more point is that during Hazrat Omer RA time it was case before him that the ppl who conquered the lands of Iraq and Persia wanted that land to be given to them. This was as per old tradition of that tribal system. But he refused to gave them and support taken from a Quraan verse where Allah SWT wants the fair distribution of wealth and should not the wealth to be circulated in the rich circle. That was great idea , also the soldiers were given salary rather then "maal e ghaneemet'. But after the caliphate in Umvee time and in Marwan family they became big landlords till the time Hazrat Omer bin Abdul Aziz reverted and it became a point of conflict with his own tribe.

[@Taimur_Laal]

Yes I have covered it. kzbin.info/www/bejne/mmnVi4mKbbJog5Ysi=ha20u2IDFKxVab5-

[@muhammadsami4002]

Great Lecture sir👏

[@sirfarhanilyas12]

SIR zor ka jhatka, dheere se lagaya hai aap ne, Great Sir, may Allah bless you and save from mol.............hahahah

[@ranjeetgodara4035]

Great sir

[@aliasad8544]

bht awla. end kia aapne

[@khansahab7031]

Nice Sir 👍

[@HaiderAli-jv6vr]

Great ❤❤❤❤❤❤❤

[@desidesigning]

Outstanding

[@dariusaasin5580]

Very beautifully explained and the lecture also opened a new horizon of thinking for me, esp. mawali, kufa, Baghdad Nexus, but one question is there regarding Spain political framework against Baghdad framework.

[@ArbazKhan-cp5on]

Sir❤

[@khanmislam]

Excellent. Sir, kindly mention sources of your lecture that may be consulted for further reading.

[@tipputippu5013]

Brilliant.

[@57NAEEM]

economic interpretation is unique

[@MalikHaris-b5d]

Sir plz books bhi share kia krein

[@ASMReating597]

is se yeh baat bhi samjah aati hai ke kaise islam main different dchool of thoughts baney. is kamatlab yeh hai ke different school of thoughts main se koi bhi poori tarah sahi nahi hai aur na he poori tarah galat hai. magar phir islam ki sahi interpretation ka pata kaise chaley ga?

[@batosato]

@Taimur_laal Could you do a video on Zanj Rebellion, please?

[@Taimur_Laal]

Oh yes. It is a must. Soon.

[@sonarbangla8711]

The prophet (SM) Mohammad said, go to distant China in order to achieve knowledge. But during the Abbasid period some fundamentalists voiced the opposite to what the prophet claimed. They said the Quran said everything (meaning that you don't need to go to China. The Abbasids decided to follow Mutazilla (question everything) and created the golden age of Islamic science and compiled 400,000 books enshrined in the various libraries. But this trend was halted by the fundamentalists.

[@KM____]

👍👍Sir bahut badhiya rational explainer. Lekin Abbasid wale part se aapne kafi speed pakad li. Bahut kuch samajh ana reh gaya. Pls make another video on that part of the Islamic history. 🙏🏻

[@rashidmehmood4829]

Lahore da pawa Taimur lawa

[@jfr321]

Boht knoob dr sab hats off to you. Please make videos on fatmi khilafat and usmani khilafat in the continuation of this series.

[@Silicone5432]

Dr Sahaib After Finishing This Series Can You Present Or Detail Study On Education System Of Pakistan

[@JehanAraShareef]

Hadis or qayas par bhi batayen

[@you_jay]

@Taimur_Laal Dear sir Taimur, you highlighted the implications that occur in Islamic Theology during each dynasty due to the subsequent causes that were linked with the continuously changing an economic centre/capital within a particular dynasty. Q: What changes, if any, occur with respect to the direction of Qibla that Muslims during each of these era were praying towards? Please kindly share your analysis with respect to a historical lense. Best gratitude!

[@shoaz0611]

Overall seems like good effort but there are some gaps. 1) For Madina the analysis seems not right. Actually it was Madina tul Rasool SAW means The city of Prophet SAW so early Muslims avoided to have fight in this city due to sacred place. A) Before Usman RA, Omer RA also being killed. The rulers were more with spiritual philosophy don't want security guards. Otherwise easy to call army from Syria to deal with rebels. B) later Ali RA also got Shahadat so logic seems not fine of city to defend the caliph. C) In case of Hussain RA it can be said that Kufa has first called him to come and to declare him the ruler. But later betrayed and he got painful Shahadat and that incident has still impacts on today. 2) Madina got status of spiritual capital and political capital has been shifted. Hazrat Ali went to Kufa for political cause but in Hassan RA time he came back to Madina. And Hussain RA again went to political reasons.

[@mohsinnaqebi5189]

تیمور بھائی میرے پاس الفاط نہیں ہیں کہ آپکی مدح سرائی کروں بہت ہی عمدہ اور اعلیٰ کام کر رہے ہیں آپ بس ایک گزارش ہے کہ انگریزی کے بہت مشکل الفاظ آپ استعمال کرتے ہیں وہ تھوڑی مہربانی کریں باقاعی لو یو❤❤

[@Taimur_Laal]

Thank you. I'll be more conscious of that now.

[@Ahmad-yi6d]

❤

[@muhammadmaalik8566]

Beautifully explained Dr sab

[@sirajuddin1058]

Bahut hi jami andaz main muslim civilisation or iskay fikri. Phyases ko fazil professor nay bayan farmaya. Bahut hi analytical or coprehensive.

[@JehanAraShareef]

Fiqa hanfi par vd0 banaen

[@farhanpathan2976]

Only a person with good historical and Islamic religious knowledge can understand this video.

[@iamgamer7006]

جہت ہی اہم معلومات - معلوم ہوا کہ معاویہ نے بہت ہی مثالی امن قائم کیا قتل و غارتگری جو علی کے دور میں شروع ہوئی تھی اسکا خاتمہ ہوا اس وقت تک جب کہ حسین بنو امیہ کے خلاف علم بغاوت بلند نہیں کیا اور معاشرہ ایک بار پر بدامنی کا شکار ہوا۔

[@user-xe1lx1pg9q]

Excuse me you said culturally less advanced civilisation when succeeded over more advanced civilisation militarily they didn’t finish off the ruled class’s culture n civilisation but adopted it, n that happened many times in history. can you give example of when that happened apart from the Islamic civilisation??

[@Redwhitewings]

Iqbal ne kaha for this reason : jis ko dub na hai dub jati hai safino me...

[@farhanpathan2976]

It looks like Islam is a mixture of Arab and Persian culture, that's why so many Persians converted to Islam so quickly.

[@ghafeershah5804]

قیصر و کسریٰ کے درمیان 602 /628 کی جنگ پورا نقشہ ھی تبدیل کر گئی جو مسلم نے کیا یہ اللہ کا پلان تھا کہ جہاں رسول اللہ صلی اللہ علیہ وآلہ وسلم کے خطوط گئے وہ مفتوح ھوئے

[@gamersland1061]

Sir 2nd video b private kar dee, Mai ne abhi pori Suni nai thi, AP private kyon kar rahy Hain

[@Taimur_Laal]

@@gamersland1061 will re upload.

[@gamersland1061]

@@Taimur_Laal ok sir

[@ranasarmad1214]

Dear Sir, thanks a lot for your lecture it was detailed and well analyzed. During the series you tried to distinguish the definition of Shia and Rafzi(stating that shia's believe in first two caliphates) can you please share the reference of this claim which is expected from professor from your claim. I also want to take the oppurtunity to clarify that Shia's belief that Quran is word of Allah and not created or creator is from 1st Imam Ali and i can share the refrence from Nahj ul Balagh. Similarly concept of Wahadaniyat, Adl and Amr bil maroof.... adopted by Mutazillah are core of Shia its actually plagiraized by Mutazillah not newly developed. May be you can mention it, again i can share the refrences if required that it existed before Mamoon etc . Hope you wont mind, its just a student's request to learn more.

[@JehanAraShareef]

Kaash musalmaan mutazilah kee philosophy ko samajh len

[@Redwhitewings]

Kaash pakistanio ne Kant ko Samaj ta south India ki tara

[@Redwhitewings]

Aap agar Mohammad at mecca Mohammad at medina par lenge to tyrannical society konsa hai democratic society keya matrimonial society keya hai patrimonial society keya hai sab Samaj jayengi

[@MAManiar]

Next video???

[@ANEWDAY66]

Hum se wo pichla bhool gya Hai 😅

[@nowie4007]

❤❤❤❤

[@Redwhitewings]

South indian cv raman pehla science nobel paye 1930 akela Hi aur pakistanione uski bahut sal bad bahut jhamela or lobby karke 1/3 nobel pane ki bad keya laaf jhaaf or gurur ???

[@sajjadashraf324]

Dr. Sahib while speaking about early islamic period we repeatedly mention that the Qurash were at top echlon, then came other Arab and then non Arab, why do we forget to mention the hadish of the Prophet that no Arab is superior to a non Arab. It is only a degree of piousness which makes a person better than other

[@Redwhitewings]

South Indian me Kant or gazali or Rumi ko samjha ,mutajila ko nehi, apj Kalam hamesha kahta tha Rumi porho

[@muhammadfarooq9903]

Bhai apke 10 episodes KO hasil apka last sentence hai.. The past lives with the present. Kiya hi ho If the Past and present Pave a way for the Future

[@muhammadfarooq9903]

InshaAllah Aamen

[@Ash-ir4dp]

👍👍👍👍👍

[@muhammadaliaslam4023]

who was nafs al zakiya?? If Mamun believe with Mutazillah on creation of quran to disapprove christian, then how as u explain in previous videos he want collab between islam ,persia and byzantine??? btw i dont understand what is actual answer to counter with christian argue if messiah is spirit of Allah as written in holy quran and Allah is eternal then why not messiah leading to conocept of quranic creation. ????????

[@Taimur_Laal]

@@muhammadaliaslam4023 great questions.

[@Redwhitewings]

This kind of petty question drowned Hume in real life, that great stupidity of Hume created grand Kant and grand Germany which unified east and west and eliminated colonialism from the world ...professor taimur very ignorant of great question of philosophy and allama Iqbal was wise person of philosophy And Bertrand Russell was a hypocrite of philosophy ...

[@muhammadmaalik8566]

Islam was always modified and used to gain power and khilafat it continues till today. Real deen is no more in visibility unfortunately 😢

[@AzharAli-kn3zs]

Dr taimur what you think main cause of Muslim downfall is lack of rationality lack of reasoning and why it is blind faith. Please give awareness and make a video on it. Thanks

[@Redwhitewings]

What is cause of German supremacy in Europe ...it is Islam...what is south Indian supremacy in India? It is also islam

[@imtiazdar7787]

*شُکریہ، انگریزی کے الفاظ کم کر لیں تو زیادہ مُستفید ہونگے معتزلہ پہ مُرتکز ہو جائیں تو اِسلام کو فائدے ہونگے ورنہ آپ ہزار اقساط بنا لیں موضوعات ختم نہ ہونگے*

[@JehanAraShareef]

Samajh nahj ata k aap ko kin alfaaz may kharaaje tehseen pesh karoon

[@abdulrahman-nf9li]

Objection on U That ARAB baddu na kaho Vo ISLAM ki Roshni me munavvar hone se hi unko ALLAH SUBHANATA ALA KAMIYABIYON SE NAEAZA

[@Redwhitewings]

Purab poschim movie, zinda dil movie, Munna Vai mbbs, three idiots movie se Islamic civilization ko samajh payenge

[@Redwhitewings]

Iqbal ne bola ki ek nation ek poet ki dil me janam leta hai magar ushe bara or destroy karta hai politician me, galat bat ushe bara or destroy vi poet hi karta hai...nation ko bara kia iqbal ne but ushe bara or desteoy ki faiz ahmed faiz ne...

[@Redwhitewings]

Yehi sarbulandi bartania andar Jake sustainable democracy payda ki ...yahi sarbulandi Martin Luther ko Germany me protestant religion kayem ki crusade ki Baad ...yehi sarbulandi kant ,Goethe or Hegel ko payda Kiya...samajh me Aya Kuch?

[@zaheerhassan1574]

Well bottom lines is, it is more politics then religion. So one should not take it seriously

[@313gazi]

مدینہ کے اندر لازما حضرت عثمان کی مخالفت پائی جاتی تھی۔ لیکن یہ کہنا کہ مدینہ نے اپنے خلیفہ کا تحفظ نہیں کیا ؟ یہ غلط ہے۔ تمام انصار حضرت عثمان کے۔لیے لڑنے کے لیے تیار تھے۔ لیکن حضرت عثمان نے اپنی خلافت کے لیے خون بہانے سے انکار کردیا تھا اور مسلسل کرتے رہے تھے۔ یہ وجہ تھی جہاں اہل مدینہ اپنے خلیفہ کا دفاع نہیں کرسکے۔

[@iamdon8482]

Plz color krle ap borhy lagty hn jise apki video dekhi ni jati 😢 Just like tariq Jameel sab wo bhi color krty hn q log onhy borha smj k ignore na kre