My Ideal Douglas

[@hugothomas1199]

I’d like to see Murdoch next

[@joshuaW5621]

I have a bad feeling he might only be doing Awdry characters. Hopefully he does extend to the later classic era though.

[@noahmaybin1781]

@@joshuaW5621, he did with Murdoch.

[@joshuaW5621]

@@noahmaybin1781 this was before he did Murdoch.

[@joshuaW5621]

@MurdochA9F well you’re in luck because he already did.

[@thomaseadbhardmcqueen7511]

That rewrite actually sounds kinda neat. I'd be interested in seeing Fergus next. Also, Truly Madly Meaply. I see what ya did there

[@lunablueslushie]

Woo, great to have you back. Your ‘ideal’ videos have been such an inspiration for me

[@dokkis_island]

Finally, someone else who hates twin trouble!! I love your interpretations and headcanons. You *really* think outside the box.

[@Sudriantank12]

I was half expecting mavis to be a class 35 in your au

[@tomyoldiron6715]

Man, Some of your Takes on the characters i really dislike and like at the same time. I think it's the boldness

[@PCMan8922]

Dougie Go Blue. Yay! Finally, You're Back!

[@ARandomThomasFan]

Glad you’re finally back! Great vid btw, Douglas having a higher pitched whistle and Percy having a lower pitched one is a pretty interesting idea

[@MagicLampStudios]

Donald gets the high-pitched one. I held off mentioning it until now.

[@ARandomThomasFan]

@@MagicLampStudios oh ok. Still a cool idea tho :)

[@WillyPanama]

Been waiting on this one for awhile Glad you're back. Happy 2024

[@TankEngine97]

For the next character, or should I say characters? My pick would be Bill and Ben.

[@ScorchZaneTrains]

Maybe Emily since some in the fandom say she arrived early on Sodor and later onto Sodor. Gotta day I had a feeling Douglas would be painted in NWR Blue.

[@PowaOfTheFlowa]

No way! Btw can you make Murdoch next?

[@Henryfan1Productions]

Great To See This Series Is Back, Do You Think We Could Get Annie And Clarabel Next?

[@reeceemms1643]

Could you do Lady? because Lady is one of my favorite characters. Loved her since I first saw Thomas and the Magic railroad. Or could you do Emily maybe. PS. If you do Lady could you try and give her a number? I really want to see Lady with a number.

[@TheRuinedBreakfastOfficial]

Let's see an ideal Bill/Ben

[@JoeyMBrooklyn]

Can you do Trevor?

[@oldwarriorproductions8411]

Got to say, I’m real fascinated by ur idea of colouring the engine’s faces to match they’re liveries. You don’t mind if I have a go at that idea myself with my own character interpretations?

[@MagicLampStudios]

Go ahead.

[@gray298heavyweapons]

This is really good! Maybe you might do Arthur next. He's a really interesting character.

[@StanierBlack5]

Glad you're back with this series, if you don't mind me asking could you do one of either Mildred or Eunice on your other channel? Or any oc for that matter like Phillip

[@StuartTheSaltVan]

I would love to see Bill and Ben next.

[@tidmouthsheds4596]

Maybe a narrow gauge engine like skarloey or Duncan. Maybe bill & Ben who knows

[@craigdallingproductions4430]

I’m not sure if your only doin railway series characters but it’ed be nice if you covered over characters like from the 6th and 7th seasons, my picks on Murdoch

[@stationshunter]

How do the colours the face it work.

[@thetrainspotters502]

Great video love your work. Would you one of the characters from your audio stories ? Or maybe Annie and Clarabel ?

[@nelissa29ify]

Bill & Ben or Derek

[@OfficialDUNCANOMG]

maybe try Sir Handel next

[@thomaswalsh8726]

I would like to see your take on Bill and Ben.

[@thewiseoldowlproductions6127]

Any TVS original characters you like

[@Pusherthepush]

Can you do Derek next please? also, I love this!

[@ThomasOfSodor_1]

Mighty Murdoch shall be next

[@greenengine03]

Day 1 of asking for Ideal Billy

[@Splendid_Studios]

Ideal Billy would be scrap

[@X3RTLE]

Possibly Stepney or harvey?

[@Steamteamrailworks88]

Here’s a suggestion: Your ideal Bill & Ben (The Cuphead and Mugman of TTTE)

[@Caledonianpug]

I would love to see bill and Ben!

[@Brony2T]

So..... Yona. Who's a yak, is cute, but I'm starting to question myself about talking mythical creatures. Oops! xD (Note: This is from the Manor Review ep. 'Reformating')

[@hudsontrainguy1217]

Do an ideal of Bill and Ben next

[@ReallyUsefulPinkEngine29]

Amazing!

[@scifiguy9000]

Could you cover Annie, Carabel and Henrietta?

[@WilliamPictures]

I Like To See Bill And Ben Next

[@NexusWorks924]

I'm really hoping to see Eunice and Mildred next I do like that one of the twins is blue while the other one is black and orange I feel like the show had a missed opportunity they could have made Donald blue and Douglas green the same green as Percy and Henry

[@uncertain_tug]

Can You show us your oo scale collection?

[@jovialpictures1997]

Can you do Bertie The Bus next?

[@ThomasSirHandel]

My head canon Douglas is a darker blue more like Sir Handel and Donald remains black.

[@Alledgreedystudio]

I’m really hoping for your interpretation of Murdoch or 98462&87546❤.

[@IVATTMOGUL]

How bout Arthur next

[@LukeOfSodor22]

Maybe Bill and Ben next

[@user-DeLorean-Dude2024]

Do Skarloey next

[@Wooden_rails]

Can we see bill or Ben next please?

[@islandofsodorflims8712]

Will Bill and Ben be next?

[@danijelapetricevic5490]

Can you make Murdoch pr Neville NeXT?

[@WitchWerewolfEdd]

Ideal Neville please

[@faweed2002]

Murdoch Murdoch

[@JoshTheBigEngine]

Can You Do Bill And Ben Next Please

[@alegotankengine5413]

Bill/Ben next please!

[@Geographyfan123]

My is his face blue?

[@jordandorsett3106]

Wouldn't Douglas have been upgraded to a Caledonian 34 class if his front was damaged that bad and its just an idea and theory

[@MagicLampStudios]

He only got scratched; no need for a drastic rebuild.

[@jordandorsett3106]

@@MagicLampStudios I know that

[@jordandorsett3106]

But what I meant was that would his running board get extended out a bit, and he gets a front Pony on him

[@Dafurnessrailwayguy]

Cool au

[@easykeysy5973]

I wanna see some oc’s

[@auraknight1004]

Rosie the USA Tank Engine please. I want to see your take on her.

[@floridasteamer]

How about one of your original characters?

[@nathanthesaddletankengine]

Agreed. Jd love too see Mildred and eunis

[@uncertain_tug]

skarloey of Other narrow gauge Charakters

[@MetroStudios]

Try flying scotsman maybe.

[@ReallyUsefulEngine13]

Can You Do Your Ideal Of My Oc My Oc Is Orange Has The Nameplate Tom On It And Number 1 And Its An E4 I Also Put Edward's Face On The Front :)

[@Sudriantank12]

I don't think he does other people's OCs

[@ReallyUsefulEngine13]

Oh..

[@Chanellegray-t8u]

Can you do Mike

[@joshuaW5621]

Why do you hate Twin Trouble?

[@MagicLampStudios]

It was the first time I personally realised something was conceptually wrong with these new episodes. The show had some weak ones before, but rarely, while the Rebrand gave us nothing but weak stories. When the argument broke out, it hit me and I was disturbed. I'd find the premise easier to swallow if Donald said something like "I didn't bring you here to get thrown into carts and ditches by you!"

[@joshuaW5621]

@@MagicLampStudios I like that episode, but I understand what you’re saying about it. I respect your opinion anyway.

[@the_birb23]

Bill and ben would be cool

[@MichelleGray-m5v]

Can you do bert

[@wyattm6782]

Nice

[@Theblackzoneof2012]

Could you do Charlie Cause it's my channel name & thumbnail

[@JamesRailroad05]

Can i use some of you ideal ____/engines? Its for my game that i will be making in the future. I will credit you in the description of the game

[@MagicLampStudios]

What sort of game? Card? Computer?

[@JamesRailroad05]

​@@MagicLampStudios I will making a game in "Roblox", a online game. Also you can play the game in a Mobile Phone, Computer and a Controller like XBox.

[@MagicLampStudios]

Okay then.@@JamesRailroad05

[@JamesRailroad05]

​@@MagicLampStudios Thank you so much!

[@wilberttheforestengine2496]

plz do bill and ben

[@CPTRailfan]

Hehe blue man group hehe

[@stevenmosco20]

Trevor

[@atenana1774]

Blue face😂😂😂