My LOVE HATE Relationship with Minecraft BEDROCK...

People have been asking me to make videos about Bedrock redstone for years... Here are my thoughts!
The Mumbo Merch Store! It's beautiful!
www.awin1.com/cread.php?awinmi...
My INSANE PC was kindly provided by Chillblast, a company specialising in Performance systems. We have a full range available with 3 systems of varying price and power! Check them out here:
www.chillblast.com/mumbojumbo
My server is kindly provide by CubedHost free of charge!
Click this link to get a 25% discount off one of their servers!
cubedhost.com/thatmumbojumbo
2ND CHANNEL: / thatmumbojumbo2
TWITTER: / thatmumbojumbo
INSTAGRAM: / officialmumbo
OFFICIAL MUMBO JUMBO PCS: www.chillblast.com/mumbo-jumb...
-------------------------------------------------
My texture pack is Faithful and Codecrafted combined.
Faithful: www.minecraftforum.net/forums/...
CodeCrafted: • CodeCrafted Texture Pa...
Intro: ProleteR - Can't Stop Me
outro: ProleteR - April Showers
/ proleterbeats
/ proleter.beats
proleter.bandcamp.com/
Timelapse: LAKEY INSPIRED
/ lakeyinspired
Upload Schedule:
Tuesday - Redstone
Wednesday - Hermitcraft
Thursday - Redstone
Friday - Hermitcraft
Saturday - Redstone
Sunday - Hermitcraft

[@Josbird]

Having both bedrock and java editions feels like having a version of minecraft from 2 different alternate realities at once

[@Zackawesome11]

Like Spider man into the spidey verse

[@darkestmatter9824]

Same with me except I have console edition and pocket edition!😅😅😅

[@darkigor20]

@@darkestmatter9824 they are both bedrock (unless you are talking about the 360 version)

[@youssefesmail2107]

That’s so accurate

[@PsicosisYT]

@LNinja Eh. Thats subjective, I own both too and I like Java more, but Bedrock does have its cool perks.

[@cast3084]

I can’t “prefer” bedrock or java, because I’m too broke to get a pc so I have to play bedrock.

[@Lord_Reeves]

or you get all of the benefits of java redstone at a smooth 60 fps on the ps4 legacy edition for only $250

[@saafquatalsameer6045]

Sem

[@theresagriffin4062]

50th like

[@MonkeyPopper]

I have both

[@nd_4726]

@Lord Tachanka YOU CAN'T EVEN PLAY HERMIT(C) RAFT IF YOU'RE NOT INVITED xD

[@theplaguemaster6423]

Fun fact: the Wither boss is significantly harder in the bedrock version of minecraft when compared to the java equivalent, this is due to the bedrock Wither having twice as much health as the java one (600 in bedrock, 300 in java), as well the bedrock Wither has a powerful dash attack that destroys blocks making it significantly harder to contain/ cheese, one trait that makes it easier tho is the fact that the blue skulls can be reflected in the same manner as ghast fireballs in the bedrock version

[@jacara1981]

Bedrock wither also summons wither skeletons, explodes on death, and does the wither 2 effect vs Javas wither 1 effect.

[@dintwo8242]

But you can kill it easily with enchanted diamond armor

[@flowerify...]

@@dintwo8242 bruh i tried

[@slogoamv6744]

@@dintwo8242 yeah

[@sayhanahmed4527]

@@dintwo8242 me and my teammates in the Wither Termination Force went through like 64 enchanted notch apples just to make time for the sniper to make the wither low enough for the head commander to use his axe with smite 4 on the wither

[@jazzpasco4180]

Mumbo: "Bedrock edition is so smooth!" Me, a Nintendo Switch player:

[@camrynrussell6292]

It’s so slow 😭😭😭

[@eeveekyu221]

Its tough for us nintendo switch players

[@LoneIgadzra]

I sometimes fire it up on Switch, thinking "I'll just play a little casual Minecraft on the couch", ugh it's gotten SO BAD. Back to Java.

[@eeveekyu221]

@@LoneIgadzra for me i could load in had to delete all the save data

[@Godakuri]

Bedrock is so laggy, it's practically unplayable endgame

[@leosong829]

I always thought I was bad at red stone until I realized (quite a bit long ago) I was in bedrock and I was using Java designs.

[@matthewnoybn6656]

Wish it wasn't an issue but programing is a hellishly tricky thing, so having to be coded in different programing language's out of hardware necessity's can just..... Break things.

[@sombie_9454]

Me too 😂

[@closetdoorman]

tree...?

[@billblue5477]

yeah me to

[@tekaruki8899]

It used to work like 85% of the time I'm sad

[@S0URUS]

Years I have been following your tutorials on bedrock and I had no idea why they weren’t working. I thought I was just bad lmao

[@breanna8183]

Sourus same

[@oskarilaine1814]

Idk why but i feel sorry

[@MAXLevel-russianbarrier]

He said once on his other bedrock video that none of his builds work on bedrock

[@fletcherhoey5389]

Same

[@IveGotBeef]

Bruh

[@animatorguy8688]

He respects both Versions. He didnt say that Bedrock edition is bad. He is a man of culture. RESPECT

[@graceelizebeth2201]

224 likes and NO COMMENTS???!!!!

[@animatorguy8688]

@@graceelizebeth2201 xD

[@Coal_the_rock]

Bedrock is way too buggy for me tho

[@graceelizebeth2201]

@@Coal_the_rock mmmmmm for u

[@Coal_the_rock]

@@graceelizebeth2201 ok???

[@ThePotskur]

woah, a java player that isn’t dissing everything about bedrock

[@nedtrampz85]

Good people do exisist lol

[@xpnvh8785]

@@zakshei6967 java is better

[@xpnvh8785]

@@zakshei6967 hmmm.....

[@knight307]

but yeah bedrock is super cool

[@teenspider]

@@zakshei6967 chad

[@AL-71]

Mumbo: * Shows Underwater redstone * Me: Wait. That's illegal.

[@ViscoseComb24]

no you

[@alexisbilale4309]

You mean Minecraft java: THAT ILLEGAL MCPE: sh*t up dude is legal

[@orpheus8774]

@@alexisbilale4309 no mcpe Minecraft bedrock

[@eaaz09]

PE is same

[@duxystudios]

@@orpheus8774 bedrock came from mcpe

[@ninjaasmoke]

Me, who can't make red stone contraptions on both versions: hmmm... Interesting

[@YoshiLikesFate]

"its quite easy really" -Mumbo 2016

[@squidno4902]

@@YoshiLikesFate it is exactly

[@kooldudeno-lastname]

I wish I didn’t relate...

[@mineboy326]

Also who can’t spell correctly

[@maddoxxmartin3366]

I made a flying machine in bedrock and it works

[@msrplays9104]

2:58 Cursed Sticky Piston with 2 Extenders? One of the extenders is glitched LOL

[@joshuastoaac9572]

"gorgeous" "Wonderful" "beautiful" It looks hellish

[@mono2800]

9

[@mono2800]

Oh sorry missclick

[@shubhamsarkar3591]

Same goes for 7:10

[@masson5775]

bedrock has a lot of block lag, when I see someone in java mining smoothly with haste 2 i remember that in bedrock i can’t mine with efficiency 5 without blocks coming back. And the blocks dropped on the ground cause massive lag even in realms, so kill the wither underground is just impossible

[@ItsCrisp_]

Yeah. I get a lot of bugs on Windows 10 Edition, like having to equip armor items twice if they’re new, or having to re-mine the first block with a new pickaxe.

[@brostech2210]

@FireMaster 3129 bedrock is significantly smooth bcs I installed Java and bedrock in my pc and Java was kinda laggy so..

[@randomperson4198]

I heard something about monster is more being limited in pe/bedrock then jave that might be the reason why the smoothness. But when i play mcpe i have never seen the amount of spawn rate they have it's fukin ridiculous when it's night time even on easy. When watching let's play i don't remember when watching KZbinrs being the spawn rate is this crazy. Meanwhile being the spawner is somewhat shit

[@zachariahkindle8926]

Source for claims: Masters in CS here, not focused on gaming or anything, but I had a sharp disagreement over what was the better coding universe Java vs C/c++/c# Caveat: I've never played bedrock, but I have done custom java mod stuff and have a fair bit of experience in what things cause lag and why. So now that that's out of the way...... I'm gonna say, I imagine everything in this comment thread sounds correct for different reasons. The bedrock version is likely gonna be more stable and feel smoother *if* your setup can handle what it is being told to load, while the java version will be smoother if the game gets overloaded. My assumption here is hows the two different languages handle memory allocation. (There doesnt have to be a huge difference, and these days its usually even considered trivial to make one "normal" thing in language A be done the other languages "normal" way instead.) But the default is just so different, that 2 things might end up feeling wildly different, depending on ram amount, GPU, CPU, and how all of the entities are stored, created, accessed, and deleted

[@vivribs218]

Doesn't happen to me

[@jamesrocks130]

Anyone ever notice that when the sticky piston is facing a certain way in bedrock it has a glitched top texture.

[@teakivy]

YESS can we pls get a bug fix, been that way since 1.7 almost to 1.11 now

[@faded8257]

Yessssssssss

[@Tauntaun707]

Yeah, there aren't many bugs that really bug me in bedrock, but that one.. yeah I get a bit tilted over it. Also the fact that build height in the nether is purposefully lower than Java so you cant do anything up there. Seriously? If so many people are going through all the effort to "circumvent" the game just to get up there then maybe, just possibly, that's a feature the fan base wants. @@towmater383

[@realbland]

Lego Collin isnt is 0.9.0 now?

[@Sarah-dh4xf]

Yes!!! It is so annoying.

[@beefbossfromwiisports]

For the sake of my sanity and watching tutorials, why can’t both version’s redstone work the same?!

[@AMan-ct1gu]

Ask Mojang and Microsoft

[@beefbossfromwiisports]

Siker_7 okay! Thanks for telling me that! I never heard of him

[@RossLemon]

It probably has to do with the fact that they're both coded on completely different programs. Java was coded on (well) Java and Bedrock was coded on C++ I think not really sure tbh as I know practically nothing about programming and code

[@burn9379]

Beef boss I love you and abby

[@williamhawkins7083]

Beef Boss From Wii Sports this is the worlds biggest question

[@firstpersonsnooter2519]

On one hand, im glad that the quazzy connectivity isn’t on bedrock, because it probably would screw up a ton of my redstone contraptions. On the other hand, however, I wish bedrock had it so we could make a Jeb door without the hassle.

[@christopherbrown4391]

Agreed my bedrock redstone is considerably larger then Java stuff. I have played both and just love bedrock.

[@hydrochloric007]

quazzy

[@firstpersonsnooter2519]

@@hydrochloric007 yeah that’s what I wrote

[@bencarson8426]

You can make a jeb door on bedrock. It IS slightly harder, but it's not impossible by any means

[@djzanderoni6095]

@@firstpersonsnooter2519 it's quasi?

[@GeneralHowToTutorials]

I played on pocket edition for a long time (with alternative redstone) and then console edition and then I switch to Java and then I switch to bedrock. My Redstone learning curve has been very dramatic.

[@mangolie21]

Aren't console, pocket, and windows 10 editions of Minecraft all the same?

[@dejavu5287]

@@mangolie21 Believe he's referring to the console edition not bedrock. This was before bedrock.

[@paellamaster8305]

@@mangolie21 hes referring to the legacy console edition, which had quasi-conectivity and was a lot more like java edition

[@simonspettmann2937]

Java: It's not a bug, it's a feature. Bedrock: It's a bug.

[@MonsterTaming420]

i know, so many "features" in java are just bugs that they haven't fixed yet.

[@LeaoMartelo]

BUD Shitch: exists Bedrock users: Is this food?

[@rewrose2838]

@XAndroid1 what's your profile pic from?

[@678zelda]

@@rewrose2838 She's furrified Tracer from Overwatch made by an artist named: Liki

[@rewrose2838]

@@678zelda Thank you for letting me know (~.~)/

[@azekilldiablo9315]

No one is gonna mention the cursed bedrock piston textures?

[@tetsujin_144]

And thank goodness for that. Took them long enough...

[@alluka9468]

Azekill Diablo no one is gonna talk about the fact in bedrock edition you move so smoothly.- but-.. omg... I was about to say it was so smooth, and then mumbo just.. SAID ThAt im shook..

[@wellifailed392]

@Jane Doe nope, they didnt

[@azekilldiablo9315]

@Jane Doe wow if it's a texture pack that fixes it the bug must not be that hard to fix lol

[@bonesofeao3968]

Piston is still busted

[@AshenAstra]

Mumbo: “Bedrock is so smooth!” Me, who plays on switch: lol no

[@luisamador8460]

Yep 😂

[@AshenAstra]

@Tomás Salgado Salinas yeah, if you’re lucky.

[@lightningfox0654]

Nintendo Switch: Minecraft: PowerPoint edition

[@am_Nein]

Me: *breaks a wheat seed accidentally* My switch: *lolnope*

[@ST-wn7zt]

Any Java player who compliments BE is most likely talkinh about thr Windows 10 edition

[@painfullyaverage6949]

One of my biggest problems with bedrock is that red stone repeaters, literally never give the same delay. It’s very frustrating

[@4st634]

"Bedrock is as smooth as butter" Wait until there are 9 people joined on your world and you will see the true terror

[@chubnut3671]

Jaraid it runs better than java

[@malick9549]

On ps4 it lag and crash when there is just 1 friend in my world

[@katier9725]

Java is king for MP. Even I, a convinced Bedrocker, can't deny that. But for SP it is oh so much better.

[@nicolasfierro2143]

Or just try to play on switch if you place more than like 5 blocks at once they stop rendering for a bit

[@thsxi]

1 person and the world stops loading

[@pikarick8354]

"2+2 = 4 ..... or sometimes 5" Pretty much sums up redstone in bedrock edition.

[@ericli8792]

2+2=5 -Big Brother

[@ieo8446]

@@ericli8792 2 + 2 equals what the party says it equals

[@banjomc3569]

In my head 1+1=7 sometimes

[@PVP1470]

it's me MR parrot

[@Medbread]

@@ericli8792 Oceania is at war with Eastasia

[@100air]

The fact that you can build redstone contraptions underwater makese really happy, they're some basic things in Java I'd like to see in Bedrock, like /world border, sheilds with banners, mob heads and more. I like Bedrock better but both are great games

[@ezmiaice5787]

YES!!

[@crimson5689]

Are mob heads no longer in bedrock? I remember them when playing the Xbox 360 version

[@drdestruction5564]

I wish they had actual Redstone able to be put underwater so I don't have to worry about water ruining my red stone also so it makes it actually a useful feature

[@themeowfia7132]

Mob heads have been in bedrock forever?

[@drdestruction5564]

@@themeowfia7132 I think he Means customizable heads

[@butchqueensupreme3597]

one small annoying thing in bedrock is that when you have an enchanted tool and you equip it, the name of the item as well as all the enchantments show up and cover a good part of your screen, making it kinda hard to see where youre going. and as far as i know theres no way to get rid of this.

[@Agentfirestarter]

@Enderfenix lol you try to roast and can’t even spell

[@pearlinbluesea]

I have a Nintendo Switch with MC on it and sometimes I play it but its real smooth

[@AA-rx9ph]

But that’s also in java

[@Azure9577]

@@AA-rx9ph its not in Java, you have to hover your mouse while in the inventory to see enchants

[@thedankboi915]

If only we had the best of both in 1 game

[@Jacqueline_Hyde]

Minecraft: Javarock edition

[@qhondaman]

I truly believe that the idea of Microsoft is to migrate the entire system to the Bedrock version. I don't know when but I think it will happen, and when it does the Java version will stop receiving updates.

[@therandomnobody3407]

@@qhondaman then mods will add the new updates

[@ewangreen9406]

Laureano Paredes This is very likely to happen. Due to the nature of Java being an older, slower programming language that was designed to be used on different platforms with ease, it was not meant to be especially fast on 1 or 2 specific platforms, but rather run smoothly with very little quirks on many platforms. However, although C++ is older than Java, it is very lightweight in nature, and was designed with other things in mind - to communicate more directly with low level machine code such as assembly for less translations and more speed. Java is simply aging and I believe the motive was to transfer the users to Bedrock edition before Java became a non-standard programming language. Mojang holds no grudge against their own creation.

[@amgamingrblx8010]

there is no best of bedrock, everything is terrible and if you think different you should be euthanized

[@therisenatlas]

Mumbo: “here we have a simple red stone door” The redstone door: ⬆️⤴️⬆️↩️⬆️⤵️⬅️↪️⬆️⬅️↩️⬅️⤴️⤴️⬆️↩️⬅️↪️➡️➡️↪️⬆️⬅️↩️➡️↩️⬅️↩️⬆️↪️↔️⤴️↪️↘️↪️⬆️↪️↙️⬆️

[@antomegaytb]

He's the Dharni of redstone

[@bobosaurus331]

Peoples brains: brain stuff idk Mumbo’s brain: hshhehshhehdujcjhejikakakjemdnnfbbrhrudijejwjkakqoqppqpdoodkskwjsjsjxjxncnncnrbrbhrhduduusiwiwiiwjajansmmsjsjsjjehe

[@officiallyrandom2614]

I like your funny words magic man

[@therisenatlas]

@CrabRave isn’t an old meme He says here is a simple red stone door, but the door is crazy complicated.

[@guyfart3]

@@officiallyrandom2614 jfk quote

[@nategwright]

Quasiconnectivity is a really nice feature to use in builds, but I sure forget about it a ton and am left scratching my head wondering why random pistons are firing at the wrong times.

[@gordongreen3310]

Me who plays Bedrock: wait! My red stone has a chance. I think you have forgotten one tiny thing Mumbo. Bedrock players can make a machine that has a chance to open 2 different doors. Imagine that

[@ttmfndng201]

You could use some kind of dropper randomizer on java

[@gordongreen3310]

kep arani ...

[@EpicAndrew97]

@@ttmfndng201 yeah

[@thalassaer4137]

Just make two possible paths and voila its not that hard and quite franklg realistic

[@OREOUz]

I just love how you can have everything in your off hand amd we on bedrock can't even put a torch

[@extrility7086]

And dont forget "TNT Duplicator"

[@perttutunkkari3275]

Yeah and the stupidest thing is you can have nautilus shells in your off hand why not torches or shields? Just useless nautilus shell.

[@Fastwalker27]

@@perttutunkkari3275 You can have shields in bedrock

[@perttutunkkari3275]

@@Fastwalker27 oh I remembered that you couldnt

[@SingleDev]

Yeah! We really need that feature "Dual Wielding"

[@InverseTeardrop]

As someone who creates with bedrock edition redstone regularly, I can say that I 100% agree with you on all the topics concerning redstone.

[@wendygomez9549]

InverseTeardrop I love bedrock redstone

[@wicketsworld4388]

I don’t know why they just can’t make sticky pistons spit out their blocks

[@ceddidulli8846]

Wicket's World yeah and the fact that redstone is inconsistent makes it so hard to build something

[@YourMom-wi5to]

Exept the last one. Its not that they arent predictibale its just that pistons take 3 ticks to extend instead of 2 in Java

[@YourMom-wi5to]

@@ceddidulli8846 they are predictibale u would know if you did research

[@fredeo3906]

Hey Mumbo! I know this video is fairly old but I just want to point out something you might not know about why some of the delays seem broken. In Bedrock, redstone just needs to be a bit slower all around. For most circuits on Java that can be replicated on Bedrock, you need to add a bit more of a difference in delay. This removes the randomness you see with 0 and 1 - tick differences. I hope this helped :)

[@Youtube-handles-are-stupid]

6:30, I spent DAYS trying to figure out why my door would sometimes close correctly and other times it would halfway close. Thank you for that

[@vengefulbird6918]

Ive been stuck on bedrock for a couple years and never knew i could put redstone in water

[@mioyio]

Same

[@cococraft9650]

Lmao same

[@batatolol9867]

wait what

[@ltftegvbvthrg8026]

Same

[@bluboi155]

We can?

[@lance5755]

Mumbo: Bedrock is so smooth Unloaded chunks:Allow us to introduce ourselves

[@draketurcotte4760]

TheBlueFireHD I can’t use elytra in bedrock. The chunks render in SO SLOWLY! I might be able to use a minecart though...

[@RustyTorch]

@@draketurcotte4760 the render issue actually crashed my friends realms, its now unplayable so after hours of work and many redstone contraptions gone yeet yeet hello java X'D

[@platinumgamer3654]

@@draketurcotte4760 you can turn your render distance up. That might help chunks load ahead of time.

[@spinyslasher6586]

@@draketurcotte4760 depends on the device you use. I use a mid-high end tablet and the render is consistent even when using elytra.

[@aspenparker5855]

UGH YES IT NEVER FUCKING WORKS. It took me HOURS the one time I tried to find a woodland mansion because it just. wouldn't. load.

[@ShadowR2156]

I completely understand your feelings towards bedrock redstone and I agree with you. I come from old java and 360 + ps3 versions of MC redstone. But now I have a switch and the only version available is the bedrock edition. So I'm stuck with the redstone on there. And it kinda sucks to not have a bunch of great vids from you on how to make certain things in bedrock work cause it is a bit more complicated getting a lot of builds to work on there. But I'm sure with enough time I can figure most of what I am trying to do out. Great vids 👍

[@Danishtheman]

the fact that minecraft is not making some features of one version like Java has quasy connectivity and bedrock doesnt have that feature, its like minecraft wants you to buy both version of minecraft. so sad

[@randompersononline9532]

Or maybe just maybe Minecraft bedrock is under Microsoft's management with different employees! Crazy idea right?

[@bobettes]

C++ and Java is different

[@rufusrhodes3566]

no microsoft wants you to buy bedrock so you buy maps and stufs

[@keep_going_8T2]

Java: When this turns on, it activates that Bedrock: mmm. mmhmm. How bout

[@machy8515]

Ayden Gubac and I Waddled away til the very next day.

[@Bomboclaat66]

@@machy8515 you fucking legend

[@gingerfool]

@@machy8515 bum bum bum bum bum badum

[@Lex-of6vt]

PooCobra THE ONE and the duck walked up to the lemonade stand

[@hylo784]

Ayden Gubac *Yes, but actually no

[@rileypoynter2223]

You see a completely unreliable redstone circuit, I see a preprogrammed randomizer

[@BalterBlack]

lets keep the likes on 69

[@kookieblink6661]

I can also relate to you

[@WarpedWartWars]

I actually turned that into a 1-bit randomizer, using redstone blocks that the pistons push and pull. But when I made it, my head was blank as to where to use it.

[@WarpedWartWars]

@Kai Mercero Student Maybe... But what would you get?

[@yeppiidev]

or maybe the block update function runs on a different thread and fails to keep up with the render and logic thread

[@goosegamessss]

The unpredictability of the red stone can be utilised very well, like using the same circuit and adding a redstone block, if it goes one way, you win and maybe a diamond shoots out and the other way around being if it goes the other way, dirt shoots out

[@AHNIALATOR-sb6ux]

I saw QC on bedrock is under review on the feedback sight and upvoted it immediately. I had so much fun playing with it when I played java and its what got me into redstone.

[@KACPERGORA602]

Every time Mumbo says “simple”: Well that was a fricking lie

[@sarabjitkaurdhillon3621]

Its simple for him

[@stellatierney2642]

@@sarabjitkaurdhillon3621 OK then

[@stizaidtl2146]

Nah when he says simple it's friking the easiest thing for me

[@Kayso789]

It actually kinda is

[@horizonsky7474]

Seriously

[@mid69]

When Mumbo said redstone in bedrock is unpredictable..... me: GAMBLING MACHINE!

[@whoopiproductions3539]

O_O

[@hellothere6627]

Yes it is our randomizers, screw dispensers

[@sventhesilliest]

Keralis wants to know your location

[@funfetti7194]

@@hellothere6627 lol

[@kennethpark5029]

You are the type of people I'm happy like bedrock as well

[@amazingmrpig6369]

“Mom can we have sticky piston?” “We have sticky piston at home” Sticky piston at home: 2:59

[@NorskoGames]

I play bedrock and I've never played java but the clips I've seen on java just make everything better. You have access to mods, Pretty much all servers, dual wielding and being able to see chunk boarders!

[@oranplan1630]

this reminds me of ye olde days, when I would play pocket edition. Ah, the ridiculously tiny worlds, wishing I had redstone, desperately wanting to go to the nether, and the old painting-hiding-secret-base.

[@FormedGlitch]

Yeah, sadly nowadays people argue about which version is better instead of saying both have perks and cons

[@nowtmrb3337]

@@FormedGlitch heres why people fight because people want more features to the bedrock so they complain

[@kennetheddleman3382]

Pe sucked a few years ago but now with the controls changed some an fancy graphics down its smooth and you can play anywhere also not missing much like it use too.

[@jonathansaren1412]

Pterazei ahhh yes and making the massive nether thing

[@ryansensenig8205]

Nether reactors was the closest thing to the nether lol

[@hankmenzie3411]

Mumbo: I wish these bedrock feature were in Java Me: I wish these java features were in bedrock.

[@prism2451]

Yea :( Especially sticky pistons spitting out blocks in one tik

[@sonichedgehog8646]

And the command system. Lots of really cool command systems only work in Java.

[@ScooterinAB]

Or they could just work on parity and make the two have the same features.

[@One--chance]

Just built a massive honey block door for my brother who plays on bedrock wasted sooo much time finding out 1 tiks dont happen

[@sramnasciane1854]

they still havent added NBT tags to commands, and bedrock ps4 loads for ~40 mins, right now im reinstalling it because someone said it might help -_-

[@Kalin5513]

The unpredictability of bedrock redstone is still prevalent today. I recently built and piston/slime block armor stand shooter in my BE world and even being 3 blocks away from the trap door, there isn't enough power in the circuit for the trap door to catch the armor stand before it closes 100% of the time. It's so needlessly frustrating

[@thalassaer4137]

Its not unpredictable atall everytjing nere is logical, it will be random if you give it more than 1 path, like actual physics.

[@IAm-No1]

I always thought I just couldn’t do red stone bc I was using Java tutorials on my bedrock world. Turns out once I use the right tutorials for the right version, I’m not half bad

[@mule8064]

Mumbo in bedrock single player: "There's no massive lag spikes" Me in Multiplayer: "What's that? You clicked a button? Just give me like 3 minutes"

[@glitzyx4x852]

That’s your end Even for me there is no lag and my computer is horrible

[@mule8064]

@@glitzyx4x852 I mean on any device other than pc is horrible as far as lag goes

[@glitzyx4x852]

AWJ GG true

[@mermaid960]

XD Ikr? I was playing with my friend and lagged like heck

[@Terra_]

xbox isnt too bad atleast for me it doesnt lag

[@grittygrilledcheese3869]

My hate: There is no hardcore mode in bedrock

[@dimitris_official]

This is not that crazy you can turn a world on hard mode and if you die delete the world this is the same with java edition but in bedrock there isn't spectotor mode...

[@ojie285]

I hate this. I tried doing this but 5 seconds later i failed

[@Alexander-vm2ox]

u csn just download a behavior pack

[@user-zp4hh6jv9f]

Yes exactly!!!

[@orangecitron4367]

Next update

[@Diezombie4114]

As someone who messes around with bedrock redstone, the one-tick things is both a blessing an a curse. Mainly, however, it can be annoying when larger machines that require more precise movements and timings can act unpredictably, like a castle gate i made the other day

[@shadowbryant0vod153]

For the double piston extender run the back one on 3 ticks(repeater clicked twice), middle on 7 (two repeaters ond clicked 3 other clicked 2) and 3rd on 1(base repeater)

[@dez-m]

You have perfectly explained both sides of a story. As a bedrock player, who also has Java, I appreciate this.

[@tr4ff1cjam]

I dont play java edition even though I have because I dont like the controls.

[@MeedasGuy]

gingerheart of mountainclan theyre the same controls

[@danielhebard1865]

@@MeedasGuy I think he means he likes native Xbox controller support.

[@markix124]

#metoo (i have bedrock for Android but I use an xbox one controlled)

[@markix124]

@@tr4ff1cjam ExCuSe mE?

[@amnsiav]

It’s also bad how we can’t build on the nether roof

[@foopo5004]

FFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFF

[@Goonqq]

Fr bruh

[@teleportsbehindyou6580]

I tried it recently, and couldn't do anything. There was no way to kill myself either so I was stuck

[@ogpk3]

Program Man /kill

[@mermaid960]

@@ogpk3 But what if you have cheats off and want achievements?

[@devilexp10siv39]

Mumbo Jumbo: uploads this vid Bedrock players (including me): clicks faster than Eminem's rap..

[@icecube250]

Bedrock as updated and now I am the mumbo on bedrock lol. I have been watching ur view and now I can easily make many contraptions. Love ur vids

[@leoheywood2120]

I thought this video was gonna be about you moaning about the bedrock BLOCK 😂 I'm so stupid

[@ejgaming6048]

IndigoCat same

[@progect3548-alt]

Same

[@ArcticArmy]

Me too.

[@mrskarenhorrocks]

Same

[@sergeisamokhin9177]

What the- -I MEAN LIKE MINECRAFT BEDEOCK PROBABLY EDITION- *MA DUDE* *GET A MIND TEST*

[@the_jono]

Consistency is THE MOST important thing to have in a system such as redstone.

[@k9lego]

Agreeed!!

[@timmerman135]

Yep thats why i play java bugs are amazing for redstone just like consistency

[@_cyanite]

I KNOOOW RIGHTTT TOO BAD I DONT HAVE A PC ::(:((

[@skztr6151]

There's an edge there, though. There's "consistency" as in "a single device always works the same way" and there's "consistency" as in "every component of the device follows the same rules / every component behaves the same way in all situations". Quasiconnectivity is an example of fitting the first definition, but not the second. In the real world, it is a fundamental law of not only physics but of math that the orientation doesn't matter. In Minecraft, up/down or even east/west matters greatly. Basically: I feel like I'd be able to live with quasiconnectivity if there were some way of making it happen from a specific face, rather than just "above" the piston.

[@the_jono]

@@skztr6151 The orientation may have an effect on how it works, but it is always from the same orientation, at least.

[@maurixe2724]

being so used to bedrock, I took the positives as compliments and negatives as another reason for mojang to fckng fix both java and bedrock

[@rufusrhodes3566]

java is not broken

[@mr.chipotle9716]

7:48 I also tried to create a wall connected to two sides using sticky piston, and behide it is a series of blocks that can be used like furnaces, etc. But because I'm in bedrock, it sometimes just pushes the wall or heck even grab blocks it's not supposed to, I tried to test it in a different places and knew it won't work :(

[@holala13]

The unpredictable pistons make a great randomizer

[@theanonymous7221]

and is worse at every other aspect.

[@williamhuang8309]

Imagine having randomisers when trying to extend pistons. This post was made by the Java gang.

[@septanesium]

10/14/2020 Droppers and dispensers in MC Java (and prob bedrock) spit items in no order, so if u hook that up to an item filter, and make a random item in the dropper be filtered to the item filter, u got a randomizer Did I talk about that poorly? If yes sry ;-;

[@LocalLibertarian]

I use redstone on bedrock I got used to it but I wish I was on computer edited why cant they all act the same

[@limeisallowed2119]

@@LocalLibertarian yea

[@_Pigeon__]

He is a man of culture. He respects both versions

[@elvpse]

Im wana be doggo tooo

[@elvpse]

@@djungelskogmemes but how

[@silasharris3368]

I would love to try java but I my mum can't afford it

[@itzk1ndah945]

Something

[@fnaflover42]

@@silasharris3368 really? Not to flex it’s kinda cheap for me

[@henrytheriault-bevins1728]

You can make very reliable piston doors in bedrock with very smooth and good looking openings. especially a 3x3 flush trap door

[@captaincrust2180]

lets take a moment to respect that now we can place rails under water in java, i dont remember this being added but i greatly appreciate it

[@chompyzilla]

If Bedrock has modding support, then has someone ever released a mod to make the red stone work like it does in Java?

[@scarletrose8766]

Block launcher exist as for the mod not sure

[@KrysFG]

*Harvard wants to know your location*

[@theo6426]

Krystian Goczal Wdym? Is that a joke? What does Harvard have to do with Minecraft red Stone?

[@imperialrule6652]

You can do a lot of the redstone circuits from java on bedrock, it is just more complicated and has to do more with chunk borders and coding ratios the0n java, you need to be big brain to do redstone on bedrock

[@KrysFG]

@@theo6426 do you have any knowledge of memes buddy?

[@narleon3461]

5:43 Mumbo Jumbo: No lag spikes My old J1 Phone: Watch

[@Snipeozer]

Observe

[@elseagullo4979]

I used to have a j1. Minecraft was ok on it

[@yazidefirenze]

Observe

[@ExpomationStudios]

You were supposed to say observe U broke the meme

[@GummyVitamin]

The bug that makes pistons unpredictable is actually pretty useful, you can make a 1-6 random number generator with it. I made a 4 corners game with the “bug”

[@josephaxp4292]

Mumbo saying a lot of thing will be bigger and even impossible in bedrock redstone. Silentwhisperer and TheBowtieman: "hmmm, yes..."

[@funnyfox204]

5:39 “theres no massive lag spikes!” just wait till you try multiplayer.

[@magicmaster9769]

Yep, physically can't play anything on mineplex, it's so laggy that minecraft breaks at the seams

[@nicoa4945]

@@magicmaster9769 i mean if you had his computer it would probably be different

[@ThatsATHICC_RAY]

Well, he’s playing bedrock on pc. Bedrock on pc actually runs better then Java, but on console and phone, (ESPECIALLY PS4 AND NINTENDO SWITCH GOD DANG) is a lot laggier.

[@proguest_0618]

Phones just suck at gaming

[@Idk-uw3rd]

@@patcho7518 play bedrock on a nasa pc and still lag

[@yeetionary]

I expected a full documentary on what you loved and hated about the block “bedrock”

[@RGC_animation]

Really?

[@Carzy2]

LOL

[@legobullymaguire1375]

Lmao

[@piggyporkerss9680]

Lol

[@theumburgeryoy264]

wow

[@Ro_Gaming]

For me, none of the bedrock features are a problem but the main one that hits different is features; there's so many things I'd be doing that I wouldn't be dreaming of: including nether roof, most farms,procedural difficulty, hardcore and others.

[@mekt0r]

fun fact: 2 way flying machines do exist in bedrock edition, just takes a timed catch and redirect system to change the flying machines direction. We use glazed terracotta against the sticky piston as a push, and use a piston in a fixed location with an observer and obsidian in the redirect area to shift half of the flying machine over to allow direction change allowing the former push piston to pull and the former pull piston to push.

[@kirawbleach8821]

When you said "No Lag Spikes" my video started buffering... Thanks mumbo

[@raidarthegunwizard4520]

He is lag god

[@theunknown4834]

@@raidarthegunwizard4520Mumbo's Base: LAG PLANET

[@matthewfinnigan2700]

Well look on the bright side, it’s really easy to make a randomizer in bedrock

[@levymcgarden5513]

😂

[@thecode327]

Same

[@paradoxmaster2566]

mumbo: bed rock has no lag Bedrock players: don't tell him about the time I spawned 10000 silver fish

[@dennisfriasii7270]

lol

[@tudbut]

A while ago there was a mob limit

[@subscriberswithnovideo-vk7gr]

Briana Jorge I spawned 1838184828483 ender dragons. I cannot go on that world anymore.

[@crystalmanta6150]

My friend did this under the house on my server 😑😤

[@zyphergaming3187]

I also made a superflat world of TNT and blew up my ps4

[@Taylor_5724]

I would like them to make pistons spit out blocks on a one tick pulse but quasiconnectivity makes redstone less logical

[@sea1sa124]

I am a bedrock redstone player and till this day, i never knew rails could go underwater, never suspected it after reaslising repeaters can be underwater too. My bad, we could make sick underwater coasters and rides with this mechanic, especially with the minecart entity slowing in water

[@Adeone7368]

2:09 “simple piston door Me, a bedrock player: What in the actual name of god is this black magic you wire witch

[@hailchan]

f

[@alyssadimarco419]

I feel you he is a wizard

[@mikeysmyth6736]

In bedrock we have a 1 deep 3x3 piston door

[@n8dawg1812]

Mikey Smyth yeah I built one in survival

[@caantay08]

lol

[@reymax9053]

Redstone in bedrock edition is.... A very special boy

[@theHoldac]

Rey Max it’s actually the correct redstone

[@draketurcotte4760]

dyeilo but it’s so terrible and confusing! Keep in mind, I’m a bedrock player.

[@theHoldac]

Drake` Turcotte it’s supposed to be the actual way redstone works, but java has bugs that make it weird. I also hate the redstone on Bedrock and I’m a bedrock player

[@reymax9053]

dyeilo, Actually, you got that reversed, redstone is bugged and messes up in BEDROCK, java edition is not only the first edition minecraft released as but also the home of true non bugged redstone.

[@theHoldac]

Rey Max no, I didn’t get that reversed. Bedrock Redstone was originally how redstone was supposed to work. Java has bugs that make redstone much better. Bedrock Redstone is also bugged and it’s being fixed in 1.13

[@poopzy1443]

I love how mumbo predicted the rails under water feature in java

[@KO_Manic]

It just realised all this time for years I have been following your tutorials and wondering why it didn't work.

[@Germs_2128]

I’m guessing a lot of the bedrock players watching this also didn’t know rails and Redstone can go underwater Edit: did y’all not watch the video or somethin?

[@Magicnephi]

Omg yes the ocean tunnels I have spent ages clearing out

[@aaronwolfy7022]

@Jeannie Baya I've been playing since '11 and i was super confused when I saw that

[@ScooterPS]

Water destroys rails and resstone. If it flows and hits the redstone or rails they will break. Its because he places them directly underwater

[@Natalia-en4vt]

i didn't know that 😂

[@Mikecomptontrumpet]

I have played on bedrock since it came out and I didn't know

[@tomeatoe]

You should add “edition” to the title, I went in expecting a 10 minute video about the pros and cons of the block.

[@vladkrstevski1482]

Lol so've I

[@margutvandervjucht6436]

Yeah same

[@redknight100]

Same here😂

[@soulswordobrigadosegostar]

Why would someone talk about bedrock for ten minutes ?

[@LloydTheZephyrian]

@@margutvandervjucht6436 you'd be surprised

[@jackbattle1451]

This video has the old outro. This is amazing.

[@aim_bot8739]

Mumbo, for the double piston extender you had to have a block before the first piston and have a few repeater ticks run into the block and have a delay on the repeater for the second piston

[@noodlesgamer9920]

Still waiting for crawling in bedrock edition 😞

[@LilMsSmiley55]

Do you mean like crawling in a one block path? Because you can you just have to use water.

[@sulevislattery2620]

Me too

[@sulevislattery2620]

😞😞😞

[@sulevislattery2620]

And 1 1/2 blocks Sneaking 😞😞

[@milkuetea]

you need to swim in water then swim into the 1 block hole you wanna crawl into

[@ideac.]

Jumbo: THE BEDROCK EDITION IS SO SMOOTH! My phone:

[@diamondreactor9863]

True

[@AverageT-90]

My 1 GB ram 2014 phone.......

[@InspectorWave]

your phone must need upgrading then...

[@AverageT-90]

Yeah

[@dimitris_official]

Is trash then bedrock has been made so Mobile devices are better on the gameplay

[@RegencyOfCarnaro]

I’ve been playing bedrock from the day I got my first console. Never changed it.

[@JOENAD0]

The bedrock weird thing is a nice randomizer

[@arf101088]

i see java edition as more technical and mechanical, with features that enable large-scale builds, where bedrock is more consumer-friendly and fluid for a more casual audience, including some honestly helpful QoL changes in just vanilla. Like, imagine how bad it would lag with snappy one-tick pulses on pistons all on a phone, when it runs totally fine for someone else playing on Windows 10.

[@boxbird5723]

Problem is that Microsoft is starting to focus more on bedrock opposed to java. Look at RTX ray tracing for example, they're developing a version for bedrock only. 3rd party developers have proved that it's possible to add some form of path tracing onto minecraft java, but they have to deal with workarounds that an official teams wouldn't have to worry about. The RTX team also talk about what restrictions that a 3rd party developer has to deal with and how their official team don't have to worry about it, which is ironic, because java is the only one that can have 3rd party path tracing but there's no official path tracing version for it.

[@SuperPhantomUser]

Mumbo: bedrock redstone is unpredictable Me, a bedrock player: so thats why none of my contraptions worked....... Edit: When did I get so many likes

[@persondude2505]

Dude every time I test a redstone build I feel like I need to sacrifice a controller to rngesus for it to actually do the same thing it did the last time I tried it

[@mreverything7056]

I actually built a redstone elevator, that required two observers so that the redstone order didn’t get mixed up by the game. Also, it sometimes didn’t start up

[@himmel8901]

@@persondude2505 dude you should already know that bedrock redstone doesn't work like java, i don't get it ppl will watch so many tutorials and will get frustrated if it doesn't work rather than trying to figure it out yourself.

[@downhourproductions1399]

It’s predictable as long as you know how it works. I’ve found that if you work on something long enough, you can make pretty much any contraption reliable

[@himmel8901]

@jack bauer no its not like its not predictable, you just need toknow the bedrock rules for it. There is a set of rules for bedrock too

[@Creeper_Me]

6:15 can sort of be useful as a randomiser that produces a random output each time.

[@xcorrelation]

What about in bedrock being able to power pistons on the top without the redstone breaking and how redstone blocks actually work without breaking the piston

[@tysquii1914]

As someone who started on pocket edition and who has played bedrock their whole life. I learned some new things today.

[@randomeevee6048]

Haha yes

[@randomeevee6048]

@Sparky The Jolteon, hello there

[@KO_Manic]

Pocket edition is bedrock but k

[@spqdz]

@@KO_Manic that's what he said

[@bruhmoment227]

Same here but I'm hoping to get java soon

[@lordmctheobalt]

When I saw the underwater-redstone my mouth was open like: "What in Notch's name is this witchcraft!!!!" Lol

[@Throlash]

/Confused Screaming/

[@DaSheepie]

I'm loading it up now to check!

[@bloodshard18]

Yeah that's pretty much how it felt for me.

[@failedslime936]

It was added in the aquatic update and I had a notification about it on my xbox.

[@ameerlouly6628]

Although I am a bedrock players I didn't know this XD

[@elwan_]

6:29 Yeah I have to work with this for all my journey and it's quite raging...

[@lasersound4842]

Well put. I find the 1-tick piston problem annoying as well.

[@memetrain2702]

Mumbo: mcpe is so smooth My phone:wait a second

[@Rikashi]

Lol bro😂😂

[@wyrdvora]

It is smooth on phone ain't it?

[@zero-one2585]

@@wyrdvora On The Laptop Mcbe is smooth But on the phone it's 24 fps instead of 60

[@wyrdvora]

@@zero-one2585 oh. Still faster than my 0-30 FPS with lag spikes on Java.

[@raquelbattifora8161]

As someone who plays only on bedrock, I always thought I was just doing the circuits wrong and that was why they would change everytime, until I started doing research and realized that's just the way it is.

[@davidgwenuro7417]

You can find a tutorial on KZbin on how to make a 3x3 piston door in bedrock. I followed the tutorial and it can spit out blocks for the door to work.

[@FishyLookinLemon]

It’s the old textures wow this such a nostalgia trip