My ranking of all 167 Starkid songs (84-1)

[@AerisFierceSwag]

gilderoy walked so professor hidgens could run

[@mirandaelena-xu8pu]

Hell yes

[@zbotello1439]

👏🏻 👏🏻 👏🏻

[@Iyaamaxx]

YESSS!

[@vividly_valeska5738]

TEA

[@AquaDancer598]

tgwdlm is as great as any of their shows but it's also SO nice to see a top 10 that isn't dominated by it... starkid has some amazing villain songs and this is the respect they deserve

[@reeseygeesey]

Honestly, I think Twisted should dominate top ten over TGWDLM. I think a lot of people just like TGWDLM just because it’s new. There’s old musicals (aka HMB and MAMD) that are so underrated because of their age. Sad times ;-;

[@becca287]

Rowan yeah, it was really nice to Not see SSN at number 1/2 because there are much better songs tbh they just don’t get the recognition because they’re older

[@reeseygeesey]

Becca Bluebird exactly!

[@yodelgoats790]

soup kid to be fair a lot of the older songs dont get as much appreciation because the starkid actors have improved SO MUCH since the days of MAMD and such. think of joey in AVPM/MAMD vs him in TTO! granger danger to wagon on fire. i think thats at least half of the hype, and then another 49% of it for the amazing music. you cant deny that SSN is catchy and well done to hell. id say that 1% of it is idiocy of the fans ignoring other musicals.

[@reeseygeesey]

not zazu that’s true

[@sorbet_salamanderd2014]

If I believed at number 1? I couldn’t have asked for a better ranking list. The song seems to be very underrated, but I can’t get enough of it.

[@ethereallovebugz]

WAGON ON FIRE BEING SECOND PLACE MAKES ME SO HAPPY.

[@isabelleinman1038]

Ikr it makes me so happy

[@Foxy02016]

chloe ღ yeah but my top 3 is 3: American Way 2: Wagon on Fire and Caulk the Wagon (tied) 1: Let It Out

[@elenamarcato6727]

kick it up a notch reprise being so high??? we have no other choice but to stan

[@becca287]

elena marcato YESS

[@corigraham4778]

I like how you used all of the shows for ' Going Back to Hogwarts "

[@masonjacobs7952]

Those voices was finally dealt a good hand in a compilation 😭😭😭

[@a-z4278]

Those Voices is a severely underappreciated song, and that's a FACT!

[@masonjacobs7952]

@@a-z4278 👏🏼👏🏼 amen friend

[@alexashley9140]

@@a-z4278 yes!

[@livsigg]

SOMEONE ELSE THINKS IF I BELIEVED IS THE BEST STARKID SONG YES

[@chloeammond3754]

I think the ending of Dark, Sad, Lonely Night is very underrated, but I 100% agree with the rest of the list. I'm so glad someone else sees the beauty of If I Believed ❤

[@elisabethdenny2073]

I have been a fan of Starkid for I think 7 years now and I JUST realized "Get Back Up" is a pun??????????? I'm the stupidest person alive omfg

[@ameliabraybrooke6405]

took me a while too

[@clararose5336]

I still haven’t gotten it sooo

[@ameliabraybrooke6405]

@@clararose5336 the song is about getting her commander up back, instead of the wimp version of up

[@clararose5336]

Oh Bahahahaha I’m so slow 😂

[@TheJuliana0901]

oh. shit

[@becca287]

THE FACT THAT YOU PUT GUYS LIKE POTTER AT NUMBER 12 MAKES ME SO HAPPY BC OF HOW UNDERRATED IT IS

[@masonjacobs7952]

Let it out is the best tgwdlm song because of jon matteson's vocals and you can't change my mind

[@shaunchristopher7734]

But inevitable tho : (

[@val8869]

Shaun Christopher But consider this: Jon’s acting in let it out when he’s constantly switching back and forth

[@shaunchristopher7734]

@@val8869 yeah I just dont like the vocals that much I guess

[@anikathu]

RIGHT!! I love Jon so much he gets a 2ND LEAD IN BLACK FRIDAY AND I GO BONKERS

[@corigraham4778]

I thought I was the only one who took too long to get that "Get Back Up" was a pun

[@clararose5336]

Cori Graham I don’t get it

[@corigraham4778]

@@clararose5336 the guy that everyone is singing to is called Commander Up and he wasn't really in a good mood, he kind of turned into a coward and they wanted the old strong Up back

[@clararose5336]

Ohhhhh oh my god I’m so slow hahaha I knew his name it just didn’t click 😂

[@ayalaavt2459]

Even though some of this choices made me so triggered. I 100% agree w top 3 (we all LOVE a Dylan Saunders solo) Every song on this list was amazing and I could never list them (good job) And the comments that you made just made the video ten times better. This was one of the first videos where I really related to most choices. Really awesome (or should I say totally awesome? ) Just got urself a new sub! Continue making awesome videos! -fellow stakid nerd

[@findingyouagain]

While I don't agree with every choice on this list, thank you for putting Those Voices so high on the list. It's such a great song and so emotional, and it was honestly one of the first songs from Starkid that made me fall in love with their music, as well as show the depth they were bringing to the characters even in something that's considered a parody.

[@Lcy_Ane]

I hope twisted gets some justice in this ranking I WAS NOT DISAPPOINTED

[@fluffyfurbie]

this is probably my favorite starkid ranking I've seen yet. it appreciates tgwdlm for the great musical it is, but doesn't make it out to be the best musical ever. I've seen lists where the entire top 10 is tgwdlm

[@a-z4278]

Omg, thank you! That is so nice of you to say! And I agree tgwdlm is great and I love the songs but like Starkid as an impressive library of songs.

[@kayliehutson02859]

A lot of their songs are ridiculous and funny, and I 100% love it, but If I Believed sounds like a top notch Broadway song.

[@elderflower2133]

omg wait i just turned on the captions.

[@purpleapron4603]

Nellie Warren dang now I gotta watch it again...not like I wasn’t going to do that anyway

[@jupiterfalling4495]

You didn't have to do dark sadlonely Knight like that OOF

[@townesking9133]

It’s halfway through the list, so it did pretty well

[@emmajames4567]

I know! It’s the only rating that highkey triggered me 😂

[@pearlexquisite935]

Your random thoughts were actually the best part of this video for me. Funny and fun to read.

[@רוניבןעזרא-ו6ש]

This is an unusual ranking. I love the respect to inevitable (my fav)

[@emmadavis4039]

To be a man is so underrated it is SUCH A BOP AND SLAPS SO HARD

[@user-mx6vc5rc2y]

I can tell that you really like evil and emotional songs. I’m glad I’m not the only one.

[@a-z4278]

I'm also glad that I'm not the only one who enjoys them, I mean upbeat songs are okay but emotional angst and villainy speaks to me on a different level

[@user-mx6vc5rc2y]

A-Z it’s the same thing for me! I’ll listen to a happy song and I’ll kinda like it but when I listen to an emotional or a villainy song I’ll fall in love

[@hollyhorsfall]

I was today years old when i found out that Get Back Up was a pun holy sh-

[@julesk2629]

Holly Horsfall What’s the pun?

[@hollyhorsfall]

Julianna Kopa cus his name is Up

[@julesk2629]

Holly Horsfall oh my god I’m so dumb

[@jess1ca547]

Thank you for giving the reprise of kick it up a notch what it freaking deserves. *cough* YEAH IM SMOKIN POT

[@sarz248]

Okay but If I believed gives me goosebumps every time I listen to it and its about time it tops a list ♥

[@sarahcatehatley6202]

FINALLY SOMEONE WHO APPRECIATES WAGON ON FIRE!!!!! 💜💜💜💜

[@redvines2946]

I'm here for show stopping number not being top ten because everyone else is just sleeping in these bops so thank you

[@marsplanetspace]

nice to see those voices higher on the list!! that song is criminally underrated.....it’s so haunting. and If I Believed!!!!!!! the most poignant and beautiful song starkid has ever written :,)

[@juliawirt-rodin8553]

18:59 I think we all miss Darren. He is really totally awesome. Come back to Starkid, Darren!

[@littlecat7128]

I LOVE this ranking! I didn't agree with some songs, but with most I agreed and I'm in shock.

[@rye2973]

@19:11 is the most cutest face of love i've ever seen omigosh, i cant get over it

[@dumpywoof]

YESSSSSS finally someone who puts if I believed at number 1! 💛💛💛

[@mollymitchell5508]

So happy The Night Belongs to Snarl go as high as it did. It's one of my favorite songs and I think it's so underrated

[@Sam-tk6dq]

That "somewhere" at the end is what I live for

[@-somatryoshka]

so many people don't get that this is a part two and dark and lonely night isn't last,cuts in the middle i just-- guys it's got a decent rating

[@cmmusic0429]

Finally ‘those voices’ is getting the recognition it deserves

[@aleclai8063]

This is a great list. People always count out If I Believed

[@destiny6162]

here i am at the end of the video just realizing to turn on captions 😭

[@monarch2520]

I am actually crying! You put If I Believed at umber 1 I can't thank you enough! I love that song so much!!!!!

[@Sunrise-hj3yx]

Omigod!!! I never realized Get Back Up was a pun either :0 Thanks for pointing it out, otherwise I don't think I would've ever noticed :')

[@schokilade775]

I just noticed I wouldn’t survive a minute if the aliens tried to get ME to join La deh da da day😅

[@juliawirt-rodin8553]

Hey, I thought it's only me!

[@multifanderisverycrafty]

Came for the ranking. Stayed for the captions.

[@becca287]

If I believed has the best lyrics from any starkid song Change my mind.

[@hannahluis]

IF I BELIEVED AS NUMBER ONE IS THE BEST THING I’VE EVER SEEN

[@CloudytheLeopard]

Yes! If I Believed is my absolute favorite!!!

[@sonja5021]

I definitely don't completely agree, but I think this is pretty much it~

[@hannahbouldin1697]

This was beautiful and gave some of my absolute favorite songs the recognition they deserve

[@allisonthoma414]

I am so happy to see wagon on fire up at 2 that is like my favorite so 👍

[@carriewood3308]

THANK YOU FOR GIVING THOSE VOICES THE RECOGNITION IT DESERVED

[@lornacampbell6316]

i love this list because songs like those voices and if i believed are so underrated but they never fail to make me cry

[@Youdontknowme-398]

Finally a ranking without SSN at the top ahskdllgh

[@Camila-cd7xe]

Totally agree with this list, and I don't usually do

[@becca287]

That top five is SO perfect I can’t even-

[@andrea7239]

HEBSKDBSKJD BEAUTY GOT PUT UP SO HIGH IM SO HAPPY ITS GETTING ITS LOVE

[@solane2148]

Omfg I'm so happy this is the first list I've seen where If I Believed was at number one It's mt favourite song and when it was at two I wondered if I missed it I'm so happy wow

[@Bannyheart4]

I LOVE THE TOP TEN AND COMPLETELY AGREE

[@novaluna2829]

FinALLY A TOP 25 I CAN AGREE WITH!!!

[@joeytansey8466]

Dream a little harder is top ten easy Blasphamey!

[@wurderer]

While I wish Coolest Girl and Stutter were higher (I just love AVPS in general) I LOVE the top 20 - happy to see some of my favorite songs be rated so high

[@themickeysquad5121]

Turn on subtitles

[@meredithclark6580]

5:30 I never want to do the work Says the person who ranked all of the Starkid songs and posted to 20 minute videos on it. Either way, I spent 40 so minutes loosing my voice to this, thank you for the blessing.

[@kaitlynduarte568]

back to hogwarts as #3, great choice my friend.

[@jocelynnelson4426]

Ahhh you lost me almost right away! I love somebody's buddy and sing it randomly lol. Don't worry I still watched the whole thing 😂

[@kadyonamarie4821]

the golden rule (evil reprise) being 71 MAKES ME SO MAD ITS SO GOOOD EEEEEE

[@thathoneybee7605]

I literally just watched this to listen to all of them

[@andrea7239]

NOT OVER YET AND KICK IT UP A NOTCH REPRISE GETTING THE LOVE IT DESERVES

[@talya869]

GOIN BACK TO HOGOWARTS yAS Great list.

[@MadisonHartling]

I love this whole list but I am a Dark Sad Lonely Knight stan just for the somebody’s buddy part

[@florachambers8966]

You didn't do Granger Danger like that, but thank you for that No Way placement

[@DisneyStarkidPotter]

Yesss, If I Believed is my absolute faaaavee

[@val8869]

SHE SAID FIREBRINGER RIGHTS

[@hannahrubin9959]

74 YES SOME AJ REPRESENTATION AD;LFJ ASDLKF edit: I LOVE HOW MUCH AJ IS IN THIS VIDEO I LOVE THAT MAN

[@janecrest8142]

In the last video, paint me was labelled just a taste

[@annan.4666]

honestly, I would die for all of the ( ESPECIALLY Jeff Blim the Choas deity)

[@yanitatronic]

Please turn on the captions!

[@nemlo9950]

get in my mouth is a bop smh

[@OnlyJustJess]

Turn captions on!!

[@almapoole2663]

Those Voices being top 25 y e s

[@a-z4278]

Honestly, these days those voices is like in the top ten for me, I might redo this list after Black Friday hits so I can put it higher up

[@tramatsid]

some songs repeated but still a good list!

[@themickeysquad5121]

Very original list 👍🏽

[@honeytea1046]

i don’t agree with a lot of them but i respect your opinions and this was a lovely video filled with lovely songs

[@accomplished_clown]

83 82 81 80 are such good songs

[@cosmic3991]

Days of summer should be in the top 20

[@andrea7239]

my sexuality is brian holden as junior in starship

[@tryingtobeeloquent]

wow i already disagree but i'm still so interested!!

[@eliasisnotreal]

Why does no-one ever talk about the dance break sequence in rogues are we reprise? It is the best thing in that musical in my opinion.

[@Benji767]

They did days of summer in 2010 so some of them have gradueted and some not

[@arianatane]

TO BE A MANS CAPTION IS SO REAL AHAHAAH

[@Iyaamaxx]

I'm sorry listen to your heart at 74

[@nerdybird6112]

just 10:47

[@vividly_valeska5738]

IDONOTAPPRECIATETHEAJSMACK

[@therandompandaman4521]

I must say, it is so pleasing that Show Stopping Number isn't #1. I love the song, but there are better.

[@maxaroni2313]

Hmm what an interesting opinion

[@rebeccastanden9064]

What about climate change from firebringer?

[@workinprogress94]

For 69 Im pretty sure it was Karen

[@bloopity4117]

Wait how is Get Back Up a pun?

[@madeleinefisher9245]

Independence deserved better tbh

[@ladyinred868]

Where was climate change ?

[@townesking9133]

In the first video