My Rating of Fullmetal Alchemist Brotherhood

[@smallfryskilledge1550]

I would give action a 9/10 I like how the fights are never interrupted by a flashback or drawn out.

[@jojoplanka3678]

Yes but the drawback is that there not really an expected fight, like something you waited for. Most fights were unexpected. And they were not real fights, considering that there was always one opponent exponentially stronger than the other, you pretty much knew who was leading and who would « win ».

[@smallfryskilledge1550]

@@jojoplanka3678 by that logic OPM and Mob Psycho have bad fights as well then

[@jojoplanka3678]

@@smallfryskilledge1550 i did not say it was bad you didn’t understand my comment. And by the way I didn’t watch mob psycho so I can’t explain myself on this one.

[@bmxgu2361]

@@jojoplanka3678 That's not really a drawback. That comes down to peoples preferences in how they like their fights. Because by that standard, Chainsaw Man, One Punch Man, Evangelion, JJK, Jojo, Berserk, and many others have drawbacks in their fights

[@jojoplanka3678]

@@bmxgu2361 no, during one punch man, you were expecting fights and they were not played by advance, and don’t tell me that saitama’s fights were over before they did start because saitama’s fights are not the point of the manga. I didn’t watch nor read lots of these mangas, however, I’m not saying that a bad point, I’m just saying that, the hype there is for Pain Vs Naruto, Goku vs Frieza, Gon vs Hisoka, Ichigo vs Byakuya (and basically, the whole gotei 13), Tanjiro vs an upper moon. And else, this hype is not present and it causes to not expect fights or confrontations. (I don’t have lots of examples considering I do not watch a lot of anime).

[@byrondowling]

I’d personally give this a 10

[@Mydog858]

Same

[@gogito4213]

O or 1 for me

[@anaskhan-sr5oz]

@@gogito4213 bro has a dbz pfp ofc lol

[@halloween_cereal]

​@@gogito4213watch the 2009 not the 2003

[@That_mewingrussian]

I give this a 50/10

[@alperonce]

For me 10/10 a masterpiece

[@felipebenedetto6350]

Totally agree.

[@traguy0_0]

Ofc I watched it 3 yrs ago And still it's better than most of the so called masterpiece animes

[@moonmagickal3634]

Same

[@alisamorayi7869]

I agree with you 🤜🤛

[@hytech9574]

The animation was amazing for the anime released in 2009, the fluidity and colors were very good

[@vnlcully]

Protagonist and plot are 10/10

[@skyden4637]

agree with plot but Ed kinda got on my nerves

[@Not_Error92]

​@@skyden4637he is smart but sometimes so dumb for some reason lmfao

[@VampireA1056]

I love Ed but idk if I would give him a 10/10

[@allergictoliberalism]

​@@Not_Error92he's a teenager 😂 smart yet incredibly dumb at the same time

[@gigabit6226]

@@Not_Error92 he's just arrogant, but by the end he realizes his arrogance

[@Hero_15]

10/10 It is rare to see a good work from start to finish

[@vurified]

It def did not work at the start lmao. Don’t lie to yourself. 9/10 tho, top 3 fasho

[@abdulrehmanamjad4116]

​@@vurifiedit kinda worked for most since they had watched the og fma. For others like me,it felt a bit rushed

[@MioneytMioneyt]

​@@vurifiedthe nina stuff dont work for you?

[@vurified]

@@MioneytMioneyt The pacing felt rushed

[@mrwildzilla1449]

I personally think the final fight wasnt that good but it was still enjoyable. For me it's a 9.5

[@AlooParantha_311]

I think protagonist really deserves a 10/10

[@snowbell2617]

Totally 😭🤧♥️

[@alfonsomendez9787]

10/10 are characters like Guts, Musashi, Thorfinn, Tenma or JoJo. Im not sure if Edward is on the same level that any of these.

[@AlooParantha_311]

@@alfonsomendez9787 haven't read Vagabond or Jojo so can't anything about their protagonists, but yes Ed is just as well written as Tenma, Guts or Thorfinn

[@iosonidoti970]

​JoJo? Wich one?

[@elismart13]

same hes one of my fav mc's and characters

[@beansprout_apg886]

My favorite anime…the storyline was phenomenal

[@StrawberryMuffin777]

It’s my sec fav and I’m very sad that the brotherhood one ended at 64 episodes😭 ( I know their is a little more things to watch in the franchise but idk if I should so ops? Watch or not? )

[@Yohoho-tg6si]

Mine too. Favourite of all time and will probably NEVER change

[@deepjyotiojah3069]

10/10. This is the one of the few anime I have seen without plotholes. Everything is connected, beautiful executed and great character development and emotions.

[@daandepauw5252]

I’d say there is a plothole. How the fuck does pinako look so young in the flashback with hohenheim. She was talking about ed and al so she has fking grandkids.

[@wizzly6162]

@@daandepauw5252not a flashback, it was a dream

[@daandepauw5252]

@@wizzly6162 oh wait ur right, it’s been a while since I saw it. My point still stands tho why does she look this young when she is like 50.

[@wulfric4755]

​@@daandepauw5252Hohenheim, being an immortal being, knew Pinako when she was in her 20s and 30s most likely. We also see what is probably Trisha Elric as a child in this same dream. It's a dream so it doesn't necessarily take place at a certain time and just jumbles up memories of people.

[@yektaagra741]

But 30 years down the line turns nobody from a normal human being to funko pop

[@basimfarhan3042]

ENDING WAS 10/10 ending was best ever

[@edwardholder429]

This show is 10/10. It proved that you dont need to make a huge op character and story. As long as you have a good story, animation, and characters you can make a great and amazing story. This will always be at the top for me

[@mart7784]

Best anime .

[@alfonsomendez9787]

Monster 💀

[@vijimove9659]

@@alfonsomendez9787 Monster has a very good writing but is not enjoyable for all viewers as there is no comedy etc but personally I love monster I got hooked because of Johan Liebert I love how he runs the whole game without even engaging in it and also how he manipulates people

[@mehmetonatyldz7176]

​@@alfonsomendez9787not the Best tf☠️😊

[@ballz_eater]

bruh Monster is peak, you need to be smart enough to understand it. I can say that monster is not the best anime, but that's an opinion. It is peak, you cannot deny that and has a right to be considered "the best"@@mehmetonatyldz7176

[@mazureqp]

nope

[@MortonCammar]

9/10 because nothing is perfect, but I wouldn't really know what to give a 10/10. It is one of the greatest anime. So possibly should be a 10 (for me.)

[@Frosto_Boi]

Do I smell a fellow bleach fan with that comment on perfection?

[@mazureqp]

usogui is

[@Gryguss]

Dragon ball Z,Naruto shippuden,Made in Abyss in my opinion is better than this

[@yektaagra741]

Naruto manga? Maybe. Naruto anime? Not even close

[@Gryguss]

@@yektaagra741 anime is allways better than manga xD

[@izzahamir]

10/10 definitely good story with deep theme and great protag also bonus point for not having any unnecessary filler episodes which is rare for anime nowadays

[@pallavisaravata2875]

My favorite anime of all time. Everything is perfect

[@high.level.noob.]

This is the best anime in my opinion. It might make you laugh and it might make you even cry. But it will surely blown your mind with an ever expanding and detailed story that keeps on giving. The fights are so detailed and fun to watch with great animation. The plot and narrative is so well put together and the characters are all enjoyable to watch. This show takes you on an adventure that will leave you feeling filled of the best meal in the world instead of empty and wanting more. This is something everyone needs to watch.

[@Unrank123]

100% true

[@loremasterhendrix]

the problem with doing a video style like this to rate a show is you leave out every concievable thing that makes this story exceptional, and instead just give it like the writing animation characters ect ranking. this show is as close to a 10/10 an anime can get, the pacing is some of the best you can find, the action towards to end was ahead of its time using things like impact frames before other animes and movies did. and the writing and symbolism and themes are perfect. as well as having a amazing ending FMAB is just that good

[@_.r3xsp2ge._]

Friend asking me how to spell Fullmetal Alchemist: Me: M A S T E R P I E C E

[@-.Ascendant]

I respect the harsh rating. This is the only anime I give a 10/10 it's absolutely perfect imo.

[@dragonballmaster8789]

True

[@vampura6334]

Watch steins gate

[@CarmenSilviaFranciscodaSilva]

One of my fav animes 10/10❤

[@gpshadow2134]

The best anime forever

[@Cxm_clips]

We ain’t watch the same show bro was watching the Netflix movies 😂😂😂 this anime is literally perfect and nothing is perfect 👍🏾

[@fajarkurniawan9434]

I wonder if the remake the fight scene in FMAB in the latest anime style But for that time, that fighting scenes are awesome. especially the fight in the opening

[@faviolamartinez4818]

Im watching the series right now and it is amazing

[@drengrxena]

Hope you enjoy it to the end 😄

[@gamergirl3000]

it is amaaazing, it's so meaningful and expressive

[@spartanAXA]

The animation and soundtrack are 10/10!

[@kendrickbettis3328]

Wish they would make another one. Best anime, hands down

[@MadaughtaUcheetah]

He’s said 9 more than my grandma call me and my cousins bitches

[@aaaa-qf3wo]

This be my favorite anime of all time. I can't find a single flaw. Edit: The manga is a lot better than the anime with a lot of things. When I first wrote this comment I was in the middle of reading the manga so that was probably what I was mostly referring to.

[@hassanwaseem4186]

The only flaw imo is that the villains were pretty underwhelming compared to other big animes

[@aaaa-qf3wo]

@@hassanwaseem4186 Yeah I think that the manga is a little better to express everything now that I think about it. The anime has a few flaws

[@anshuman230]

​@@hassanwaseem4186 King Bradley was a great antagonist compared to Father

[@hassanwaseem4186]

@@anshuman230he was good but compared to other shonens like one piece , bleach , naruto , dragon ball , demon slayer , they all have better antagonist

[@anshuman230]

@@hassanwaseem4186 OP, Bleach & Naruto are understandable, DB debatable but Demon Slayer ? 💀🤣

[@elismart13]

ye for me its a 10/10 and people that say "overrated" and "its def not the best" usually never say "their best" as its usually has tons of issues, unlike FMAB where the "issues" are just minimal if none by the end

[@miyamotomusashi005]

Only anime that deserves a 10 on 10 score

[@Law17303]

Charatechers are 10/10 no doubt,the strongest point of the show.

[@siddrajput_8]

Easy 10/10 the only anime which i binge watched without any break 🔥

[@2FJanUS]

Wow how good this edit : music and words match so good, impressive

[@JonathanRobertoo]

The GOAT anime.

[@Gence-qe2wh]

There are all fans of Fullmetal Alchemist and it's so cool. Because nowadays it's not popular anime and it's sad. FMA will be in my heart and best anime ever

[@dantederi5062]

Fmab might not be the most innovative or new, but what it did it did it masterfully. That's why it's still regarded as a masterpiece or as a top ranked anime.

[@necomiller5892]

It will always be a masterpiece FMA ✨✨✨✨✨👏🏼👏🏼👏🏼👏🏼👏🏼🌟🌟🌟🌟

[@gustavfrye2736]

Pacing in this anime is definetely a 10/10, the best ive ever seen. I never felt like a single minute of my time was wasted, nothing was ever delayed, I always just wanted to keep going and watching more and more.

[@saidurrahman5467]

It's a masterpiece

[@Helvett.]

By far the best Anime . I watched it some years ago and even without nostalgia the anime is just a 10/10 .

[@Ribbit153]

My fav anime tbh

[@wallace_fawkes]

Pacing is 10/10

[@Shavedlion97]

I honestly feel this is a masterpiece. Truly the most accurate adaptation from the manga. And the Vocal Performances are TOP TIER!!!

[@CelsoJaimes]

Spelled characters wrong so your judgement goes out the window lol

[@bcook2184]

Greatest anime of all time

[@manameds6903]

10/10 one of the best anime i have watched no question

[@Anantinfinit]

Generally, i don't prefer to see shonen anime especially the longer one because most of the time these animes have same plot with the same secret baby Jesus protagonist and weird female characters with no character development but FMA and hxh are truly two of the best stories that I've ever watched.

[@Jmei1]

Perfect ending

[@bradbretl3018]

Manga hits so hard

[@tanzeelhaider5339]

Its my favorite anime of all time. Perfect from start to finish. A Masterpiece, a 10/10, Fullmetal Alchemist: Brotherhood.

[@tanzeelhaider5339]

@@abhaykumar-tr6go I agree. A genius mind definitely.

[@waiyukumnao5430]

Rewrite is still my favorite FMA opening

[@Abdul_The_One]

the pacing should have been 10 ngl

[@adventures_by_nessa]

I give it a 10, just bc the fights weren’t drawn out for episode upon episode like so many anime.

[@faresktari8977]

I think this is a 10/10 might be the best anime I've ever seen ngl

[@gruchothegr8159]

Writing being a 10/10 is too real

[@NotAMoron42]

Y’know, I was always apprehensive about watching Fma:b for years because I thought it might be bad and I never thought to check. About maybe 3 or 4 months ago, I finished it and it was an experience. First anime or show to actually make me cry more than when I broke an arm.

[@shaistashams-bk7mi]

I really like the editing skills. As fmab is my fav anime. The unbelievable editing skills made this video touch my heart

[@trolldude3301]

bro the animation is definitely a 10. you know when it was made?

[@clunt2548]

2009

[@trolldude3301]

@@clunt2548 exactly

[@clunt2548]

@@trolldude3301 yep, the animators were god tier

[@Wei06177]

doesn't matter when it is made tho there's a lot of anime with insanely good animation early 2000s to 2010 like Ippo

[@kapski_]

Animation is amazing especially for when it was made but a 10/10 to me is the best out there, to be a 10/10 you can’t be beat by anything else and there’s a fair amount of anime with better animation than FMAB.

[@potatoguy5161]

a 10/10 ending is a HUGE feat.. there are a lot of good anime.. but a 10/10 ending? not everyone has it

[@Black_Shogun]

This anime is the most valid anime ever made. for the gen watchers they dont even understand us people who watched one piece, naruto, naruto shippuden, full metal alchemist brotherhood, Inuyasha (I was forced to watch that shi), Hunter x Hunter.

[@okipullup6103]

FMA is one of the greatest creations I’ve ever seen. I started with the manga because I got lucky that all the issues were in my school library and read through them in a couple days. After that I watched the original anime and then brotherhood. It’s the best thing I’ve seen. 10/10

[@siev1271]

10/10 for me, my favorite anime

[@HakaiDEVxMETHA]

😭 my favo Anime

[@user-gd7yb8ww6i]

My favourite anime personally

[@shin.z_]

10/10 masterpiece imo

[@user-pn1pt9zg5c]

Who's here after the ending? 👇

[@santi_el_nobueno9167]

I'd give it a 10, but you have good arguments

[@yourwaifunino]

One of the best anime’s

[@tacomiester]

Honestly completely agree.

[@esther589]

I would give both the original and brotherhood a 9/10. Both stories are very complimentary to eachother at least for me. The music in the original and the movie is god tier ❤️

[@sameersingh8588]

I would personally give it 10/10

[@randompersonwoexists]

this is my favorite anime,its just pure art.

[@EnzaroV]

9/10 perfectly fair

[@lawrencedelfin160]

10/10 one of the best

[@user-zk7vh1je8p]

AOT IS MY FAV ANIME FMAB IS 2ND BUT FMAB IS THE ONLY ANIME WITHOUT A SINGLE FLAW

[@Susturucutakar]

Nice edit I like ppl who make my day with good edits

[@mr.e3123]

id give the action a 9 personally just because we almost never get a shonen anime that takes the approach to fighting where the characters actually have to think up a strategy for fighting that relies on the environment or on knowing the periodic table its a hyper realistic approach to anime fighting that i personally havent seen replicated all that much

[@EnzaroV]

You are VERY wrong but my English is very bad and I don't think I can explain why :(

[@drawingnoodles2867]

Goated anime

[@Cohow]

Fullmetal Alchemist Borhterhood is one of the most consistent and high quality anime ever made, because of its merit, 10/10 should be the most acceptable choice. It's not my favorite, but I really enjoyed it

[@iloveyt123]

Young Hoewenhin reaching out and then seeing Ed and Alphonse having to door close was perfect for the story

[@souravs8797]

a true masterpiece

[@TM-co2xi]

I just finished it it’s SO FUCKIN GREAT

[@weirdghost3064]

I know right!

[@user-qz9dw5ct3d]

best anime EVER is literally my favorite

[@willnicholson780]

Bro someone reminds me what happens in the end bc I’ve watched the original and this but I only remember them being separated in the end and ed is on a train somewhere and he reaches his hound out then it flashes to Al in a different word living with no brother but he has his body and then it ends

[@sohailrahman735]

That one Anime we don't deserved 🤌

[@daviddossantos8884]

This is my favorite anime of all times so... it's an 11 in all categories for me 😊

[@llesus5411]

characters and pacing is 10

[@ankitpratapmaurya5985]

Masterpiece ❤

[@ItsInfinity69]

10/10 character for sureeee

[@drali355]

This anime is perfect, 10/10.

[@LoafCircle]

115/100

[@johnnyreaper9714]

It's funny how I just came across this because I just started watching it again, for maybe the 8th time, this week and I posted on my Facebook that It is one of the best anime ever made. I'm going to put it right at the top with Bleach.

[@harshabhigyan928]

Bleach us great but it doesnt compare to FMAB bro. Im a fan myself but gotto stay honest haha

[@yamumsleftslipper]

My only complaint is that it isnt long enough, and it doesn't even need to be any longer.

[@AtifAli93074]

In starting the person is not edward he is his father

[@icaughtalopunny]

Eng dub gets a 9/10 from me, Wrath’s VA is perfect and the accent helps for sure.

[@royemmer3703]

I feel like fmab is that one anime where it’s not a lot of people’s favorite of all time, but it’s in almost everyone’s top 5 or ten

[@Meliodas-uv1tp]

Plot: 10 Characters: 10 Action: 9 Protagonist:10 Soundtrack:10 Enjoyable:10(even though It’s one of the saddest shows I’ve ever seen) Emotional moments:♾️ Overall: 10 There is a reason it’s on the top of so many lists.

[@Literallycarmella]

best tv show of all time hands down

[@EnzaroV]

No XD

[@Shoya-bg3bf]

Great but definitely not best

[@Literallycarmella]

@@Shoya-bg3bf imo

[@Literallycarmella]

@@EnzaroV imo

[@Hummingbird_335]

This is the only anime I watch 2 times.

[@rowdeemunkee]

Sucks when the first anime you watch is the best ever made