My take on the Bee Gees - For Whom The Bell Tolls (1993) | REACTION

[@hereonthe3L]

*_FOR MY FULL BEE GEES PLAYLIST, FOLLOW THIS LINK BEFORE MAKING REQUESTS:_* kzbin.info/aero/PLSnNE4tdNL-rR68vDdLHlOD-HXQ_vHUHE

[@GinaLoriDuncan]

I enjoy the Bee Gees even more than when I was younger. No one can sing at this level today.

[@GinaLoriDuncan]

@@billybob042665 The Bee Gees are still the greatest band ever. I was born a week before Massachusetts was released. I grew up listening to their music, thanks to my mom.

[@michelebriere9569]

I love how Robin just let's loose with the power of his voice.

[@dktwilsonwilson5334]

No other group does it like the BeeGees their talent were extraordinary

[@shineshine63]

I don't know how many times I've told people that if everyone would listen to the Bee Gees for just 30 minutes a day, the world would be a much nicer and kinder place. Thanks for a great review. #BeeBees fan since 1971

[@MyCarlson1]

Amen they have saved me

[@MyCarlson1]

I appreciate you so much Chad .

[@shineshine63]

@@MyCarlson1 Same here, and more than once ;)

[@ammoneggs69]

When you’re right, you’re right. I have a Bee Gee-athon several times a year, usually ending with some Maurice centric songs...Man in the Middle, The Bridge, Closer than Close, Hold Her in Your Hand, which are so soothing and calming. Love them so much x

[@maryhuhnke8496]

@ronniearmstrong I long for those days when music transported me to a safe place. Our Country Needs that Now! 🙏💔

[@onenight0666]

Robins vocals on this still make me cry.

[@robertaclark3286]

What can I say that hasn't already been said ? Robin rocks this song! His voice is amazing and just one of a kind!! I love this song and I love Robin!!! He is utterly awesome!! Love.and miss you Robin.

[@mariekeung7187]

So right you are! Robin's voice is just so magnificent!! Love this song!

[@erica_goats1997]

I like Robin too and always will

[@robertaclark3286]

@@erica_goats1997 I know the feeling Erica

[@alloyd759]

To me......it's TRAGIC and SUCH a shame that Maurice and Robin are not here to see the younger generation appreciate their music + enjoy it SO MUCH ALL OVER AGAIN!!!!! 😍😘xx

[@elizabethmencia6027]

Always makes me cry when Robin sings this. A beautiful songbird he was.🥰🥰🥰

[@lindajames978]

Best ever Vibrato you will ever hear ,raw and natural miss you Robin

[@MA-oy3sx]

I can never get enough of Robin singing 👍

[@trudywolfe2795]

Robin is my favorite and the way he sings blows me away.

[@trishafaulk2067]

I admit it, I'm a super fan, listen to their music every day, wake up to it. They make me happy 😊 I've listened to them my whole life.

[@mcarmensanmartin6650]

Me too Trisha!!

[@rexgoodheart3471]

Robin is INCREDIBLE! He gives me chills.

[@trb2021]

Me too!!!

[@judithoberpaul509]

Me too 👏🤗👍🙏

[@MA-oy3sx]

and me...

[@FeScully]

Yes!

[@soniasilvestrini7524]

Me too!!!

[@PenneDriver]

Oh, how I love this song and Robin 's voice!!!

[@pennykaine2306]

I love Robin's vibrato!!

[@izelindarodrigues8017]

BEE GEES FOREVER and EVER

[@sylviategroen1583]

GORGEOUS voice of Robin..Barry is epic. n let's not foget our precious Mo...his vocals in this great song are fabulous...luv the BeeGees..all so talented they are so real💕

[@patriciaewing8164]

It was Robin that sung most of the song with Barry 😁

[@MyCarlson1]

When my anxiety starts with today's trouble..I listen to the BeeGees and it vanishes immediately..they have saved my sanity through the last few years..I love them so much..

[@lindacabral922]

I'm the same way their music just has a way of calming me down

[@geri9261]

Totally ❣️

[@daleannphillips3730]

When we were on lockdown from covid I spent a lot of time watching videos on my phone and one of their videos popped up in my video feed and I watched it and immediately was hooked. I immersed myself in their history and learned everything I could about them. I’m mesmerized by their voices and their story.

[@vilmagapic-pc8ey]

I sincerely agree with you,their music will really live for the many decades to come....I'm born in 1972 and grew up addicted to the BeeGees music,but as I grew older I came to appreciate their music the more,I now have my grandchildren yet I still can't help but become emotional everytime I hear or watch them ..

[@marygriffiths2950]

It's December of 2022 and I'm one of those who listen to the Bee Gees almost on a daily basis.

[@judithoberpaul509]

This is a song I like to hear over and over again. Robin's wonderful voice is in the foreground here, I've loved this song since the day I first heard it and that was a long time ago.🤗❤👍👏 Chad your reaction "this is soul of music" is awesome. Thank you 👏👍🙋‍♀️

[@TheMsCrystalblue]

There is another verse to this song that they do not do onstage. Barry sings in his natural range for the last verse. This group of brothers were SO gifted! Been loving their music since the 60"s. Wish someone would make music like this now.

[@kaythomas8521]

Robin .....the one and ONLY

[@cathyopthof8136]

They are soooooooo awesome!!

[@karenhelsdon4873]

Great song by the best singers in the world

[@wandalewis5097]

Been listening to them since the 60’s never get tired of listening to them right up there with the Beatles

[@maryhuhnke8496]

Me too Wanda..Music was my salvation, my necessary escape. I don't believe I would've survived my childhood without them. "There's a hole in my soul.." 💔

[@wandalewis5097]

@@maryhuhnke8496 yes music for us back then was our Salvation ❤️❤️

[@monicshastings8945]

They knocked this one out of the ballpark. What an incredible performance. Barry and Robyn,s vocals were phenomenal. And then at the end Barry still being able to hit that note and sustain it- wow I'll bet they received a standing ovation. As usual, l loved your commentary Chad, especially the monkey branch analogy.

[@mariaterezaferrato1164]

You said it all. Perfection

[@MarcelaCastro-yn9rb]

❤❤que hermoso que reaccionen a estos temas me encantan!!!Amo a Robin esa voz que tenia enamora y llega al alma❤16/6/2023❤

[@cathyopthof8136]

The marvelous Robin Gibb!!!❤❤❤

[@stanB950]

1000s of 🤗 for you #ChadLSummers and an extra hug 🤗 for when you really need ☝️

[@elisabetereis2279]

I LOVE BEE GEES FOREVER. 😍😍😍 ROBIN MY FAVORIT, UNIQUE VOICE 🎧🎶🎼😍

[@kaynewsom6780]

Robin wrote this for his brother Andy who passed away

[@beeharbour]

Seemingly every song the Bee Gees wrote post 1988 was written for Andy. The gentlemen themselves only ever said Wish You Were Here was. They always dedicated a song to him in concerts but they never sang WYWH in concert because it got them too emotional. Maybe they did write this for him but I'm a a loss as to why they would care who Andy attended parties with. It's got a very 'lover' vibe and lyrics in my eyes.

[@gloriamaryhaywood2217]

Why on earth would you say that? Perhaps you are thinking of an entirely different song??🤔

[@shineshine63]

@@gloriamaryhaywood2217 From what I have read, they wrote this as if they were looking through Andy's eyes about his relationship with Victoria Principle

[@gloriamaryhaywood2217]

@@shineshine63 Nope. I Seriously doubt that. I would diffenetely require a link showing that one of them actually said that, or even alluded to it!?... (Either in an interview or an article.) I've been following this band of brothers for Quite a while and Never have I either read or heard them say that that song was written for Andy. The song "Wish You Were Here" is the ONLY song I've heard them say that about. Some people just project their own feelings and toss it out there as gospel with Nothing to back it up at All. (I am referring to the original poster of the comment. I notice that the person does not answer anyone back who is calling them out on this?)

[@gloriamaryhaywood2217]

@@shineshine63 Also Robin did not write this song by himself. As usual, it was written by all 3 of them!😉

[@debbielemons1576]

Love this song. Their writing is incredible! Big hit in 93!

[@bettyartis3648]

Jive Talking, How Deep is your love, Stayin Alive, You Win Again, Run to me, How Can you mend a broken heart, Nights on Broadway, there are so many. Plus all the hits they wrote for others. Really liking your reactions.

[@tinastanley4444]

Subscribed to your channel. Bee Gee's are the Beethoven of our time.

[@kellydeptula4016]

This gave me goosebumps and brought tears to my eyes. They r soulful and simply phenomenal 🥰😍

[@randyhein7324]

It was Robin who continued to convince Barry to sing his high voice.

[@Triumph-nz8pt]

You really should check out the live version under the bridge in New York. Robin just shines there. (sorry if someone else mentioned it first) You won't be sorry, honestly. Oh and by the way, you should bring some bedding and rations if you plan to get through the Bee Gee catalogue. Don't forget that Barry has written over 1000 songs including those for so many artists/genres other than their own, so if you want to expand from the Bee Gees, there's a hell of a lot of options waiting for you! Have a fun and fantastic time!! I know I am!

[@deanarjones9114]

That video is incredibly nostalgic and full of melancholy. Evokes the heartbreak of all we’ve lost.

[@beeharbour]

The vast majority--the very vast majority--of Barry's compositions were done with at least one but usually both his brothers. He's not proven particularly concerned if anyone thinks he wrote them all himself. He didn't.

[@robertaclark3286]

@@beeharbour No he didn't and he should give Robin and Maurice their due credit.

[@susieq9801]

Triumph 1983 - 90% of their songs were written by Barry and Robin together or by all three.

[@robertaclark3286]

@@susieq9801 Exactly right Susie!

[@annasaylor3566]

You Win Again is also a good one by the Bee Gees

[@tonicursio]

Great reaction. I’m a life long Bee Gees fan... saw them live in concert twice in early 70s. They bring a smile almost every day. Love that they are enduring the test of time.

[@duke4384]

You are so lucky, you must have seen the great Bill Shepard, their orchestra conductor?

[@susanrobinson8179]

Another fabulous song by the Bee Gees

[@mariaterezaferrato1164]

I love the Bee Gees since 1969., but, as for Barry I' m addicted...He is the soul of BGs.❤️❤️❤️

[@dennislang4375]

Very unique because Robin is NOT usually the lead, Barry is. Barry does an awesome intro and the Robin artistically takes over.

[@jamihede4440]

'And I'm missing you more. And the fire that will roar. There's a hole in my soul....' Wow. Can I relate to that. Been there, done that.as they say. Awesome xong and awesome performance.

[@kimberley1449]

Same here. Song were talking about is FOR whom the bell tolls!!

[@carollowery2416]

Such a beautiful song!! Thanks!

[@lindagabriel2733]

Also....I don't understand the mean spirited comments directed toward any of the brothers ... And a lot of the comments are not based on facts. We are all just trying to get thru LIFE....and the Bee Gees, as flawed as any other humans, just bring to us incredible talent, music and pure joy!

[@erica_goats1997]

I like the Beegees and I will always like them and nothing would or could stop me from liking them because I’m their biggest fan because I like them

[@MischaGER]

Your background information about the Brothers Gibb are simply stunning and very profound storytelling, i like the lyrics interpretation with the provider - amazing you have not only analyse the artits but also rated the lyrics, which honestly only 3% do here 😆 - outstandingly 🍾👍

[@MyCarlson1]

I am a fan and yes daily their b music helps me through my troubles

[@francescoriccio4630]

Grazie x aver messo le traduzioni in Italiano, in modo che si possano condividere tutti i pareri, dei nostri grandi BEE GEES. Salutoni

[@allymayful]

Love your description of Barry's voice.

[@judithoberpaul509]

This is my comment for Chad. I always like to listen to your comments and reactions, especially when it comes to a song by the BeeGees. Your way of communicating with your followers is empathic, respectful, and full of admiration for the artists you are presenting. This comment is for you, Chad, keep it up 👏👍🙏🙋‍♀️

[@detroitlady7201]

I'm one of those avid fans that still and will always listen to Bee Gees regularly and I now have great grandchildren that love them too! They will live on!

[@VickiSlater-mj3hg]

Beautiful!💜

[@lydiavivero8154]

Thanks again Chad!😀 so much appreciated for playing this song.

[@fireandice3537]

The best group on the Planet no bee gees no music.I saw them few times and I have the photos with them for ever.

[@dawnbinns7430]

There s no words to lift up these FAB GUYS..

[@thomasborth315]

Wow! Great Bee Gees! Check out "Love You Inside Out " . It's an amazing song by Bee Gees too ! Thanks for the reaction!

[@cindy-yq9mu]

I love the Bee Gees. I am in the same generation as they are. What I regret was when they were coming up I really didn't listen to them much. Now I can't get enough of them. They are amazing in every song they do. But that isn't all. They are/were just great respectful people. I have to admit though Mo is the one that I seem to gravitate to the most. His personality, his looks and his kindness I have read so much about. But they are all great. I sympathize with Barry, I too am the only one left of my immediate family, (parents, siblings). Chad, you are the best reactor. You, seem like a very gentle kind, man. Some of the reactors I can't listen to.

[@rebeccamunoz2948]

Listen to their early work. “ Words” is my favorite early work.

[@beeharbour]

I'd go with "And the Sun will Shine" one of the most beautiful songs ever written.

[@lindagabriel2733]

I just discovered this program. 3Ls. Love your reactions, thoughts, and discovering the Bee Gees! It is 1/19/2022. I don't know if your show continues. Hope so. I am only watching your Bee Gee reactions...because I do love them. And yes, I listen every day. They do lift me up. I am 71 years old. I lost my husband 26 years ago. One of my 4 daughters 3 years ago. The losses continue to overwhelm me, but their music warms my soul!! I find hidden gems of the group all the time. Thank you for your show. ♥️♥️♥️

[@hereonthe3L]

_Hi Linda, thanks for interacting here on the 3L, and following along on my music journey. Yes, the show does go on! My condolences on the loss of your loved ones. I do know there is comfort and peace found in good music, and hopefully my channel will help you during the hard times. Here is a link to my entire Bee Gees playlist:_ kzbin.info/aero/PLSnNE4tdNL-rR68vDdLHlOD-HXQ_vHUHE

[@lindagabriel2733]

Thank you for the link. I just heard you talking about it earlier on one of your segments and I couldn't figure out how to do it !! And thank you for your kind words. I really admire you for talking about feelings, life and love and your take on the lyrics. And yes ..music brings us all together. 🤗

[@timothyparsons8327]

The music is immortal, but there is so, so many talented artists from the 60s and 70s who have and still are in some respects giving a “new” dimension in music for the young people of today, and indeed, tomorrow.

[@RK-gg4dd]

You can hear the struggle Barry is having with his falsetto. I am a huge fan of Barry's falsetto, but you can tell that it just isn't the same here as it was when he was younger. Robin's voice is strong and rich in this song. It is truly a beautiful song! Love hearing Barry ending it with his trademark.

[@MA-oy3sx]

I can hear the same ting you do.

[@Pamsmith59]

Or maybe had a cold/allergies that week. . .

[@cathalenemontoure5610]

He was in severe pain from back issues. It takes a lot of muscle and strength to reach and maintain falsetto

[@susanhunter7124]

I could tell that Barry's voice sounded bad. Other reactors I watched, wondered the same. If it wasn't for Robin, the song would have sucked. Go Robin!

[@susanhunter7124]

I'm not a Barry fan. Falsetto was overused, and damaged my eardrums. As long as I can hear Robin, I'm 😊.

[@debgrable9035]

Chad I just ran across your page. Oh my God...I'm addicted already. I've been listening for 2 hours now. I LOVE the Bee Gees and you make it so fun to listen. Thanks my friend , keep it coming !

[@susanrobinson8179]

Yes definitely the best performance under New York bridge

[@paulodetarso7236]

Robin Gibb is the Best!

[@MA-oy3sx]

True

[@trb2021]

So true

[@mariemac3608]

Totally agree ♥️🎶

[@elisabetereis2279]

Yes, yes , yes 👏👏👏❤😍

[@cristinanavarro8103]

I really love the song " I started The Joke" 😍

[@kaynewsom6780]

I am sure you might of heard by now, but this song it was written for their brother Andy who passed away

[@beeharbour]

About 3/4 of the songs they wrote after 1988 are claimed to have been written about Andy. "Wish You Were Here" is the only one they ever said actually was. They often dedicated other songs to Andy but found it too difficult to sing that one.

[@gloriamaryhaywood2217]

@Kay Newsom Where are you getting that info from? That seems more than Highly Unlikely!!

[@joelatimer2334]

Thank you for playing their music, I admit am 75 . Over the years just heard a song now and but now I can rest and listen to all .love it

[@jimwalker4984]

CHAD, U CERTAINLY HAVE A HEART FOR WHAT YOU ARE DOING HERE. I AM LEARNING SOME THINGS FROM YOU. SOME DEEP THINGS. THANKYOU.

[@vivianapompei1940]

Gracias Chad, Ohhhh por Diosss el mas grandeeee amo a Bee Gees pero Robin es especial,brillante voz angelical que congela el alma en cada interpretacion,forever,forever Robin...Graciasssss

[@dorieann64]

There's another version where they're singing in New York City. I couldn't find that for about a week, because I forgot which song it was.

[@ullabuch4769]

The are soo sweet love there voice they make me happy ❤❤❤

[@kimberley1449]

One of the best songs out there!!! It's poinyet and just plain beautiful!!

[@dorieann64]

I did a stop clock on Barry’s note. 15 secs. He never ceases to amaze.

[@francisxray9900]

Congrets! You nailed it. Take a look on their live appereance on MTV Most Wanted, they played a brilliant Medley and also the song "Blue Island, which is phantastic.

[@maryhuhnke8496]

Watching you again.. "There'sa hole in my heart" "For you its goodbye, For me it's to cry, For whom the Bell Tolls" Thanks for your Real and raw reaction! 🎧😎👏💔

[@eaccristo]

Beautiful......

[@rwilson7197]

A beautiful song. Been single since 1993 - time flies. (My husband of 7 years "monkey- branched", as you put it, right out of my life!) Love your appreciation of the Bee Gees!❤❤❤

[@barry0709]

Please react to This IS WHERE I CAME IN by the beegees thanks

[@christinestornable1816]

Came back to this reaction after my 1st comments. Robin owned it.

[@MyCarlson1]

I lived the version.in New York outside.. acoustics were amazing

[@trb2021]

Robin ❤️❤️❤️

[@NancyDopko]

Love this song and find it amazing they are still sounding so amazing into the 90s. My favorite version was the one filmed in New York City. It’s so poignant because you can see the twin towers behind them. Robin sounds phenomenal, and Barry’s sustained note at the end was stunning. I loved your heartfelt reaction. Chad!

[@wandalewis5097]

I’ve been listening to them since the 60’s and they’ve just gotten better over the years. I agree I thank their music will live on

[@MyCarlson1]

I love Barry

[@foots-qt4pk]

Bee Gees trivia time! None of the brothers could read or write music!

[@bettyartis3648]

Yeah, they had to sing their parts to others to interpret

[@AlecMajerison]

Which illustrates the relative importance of author vs scribe.

[@kathibennett639]

Robin😊

[@ceciliarodriguezroge7692]

Ya había visto una reacción tuya a mis ADORADOS BEE GEES... Veo que no dejas de sorprenderte y embelesarte!! Y si los ves y escuchas de pequeñitos en los videos de TV Australiana.. ( Bee Gees little band), vas a admirarlos más todavía...sobre todo a ROBIN.. Tendrían 8,9 años y Barry 3 años poder. ME SUSCRIBO !!! Si recién los has descubierto, no sabes lo que queda!! La voz de Robin es para mí una necesidad, todos los días algo, tiene una vibración, algo tan tan especial!!! GRACIAS por ahondar el mundo BEE GEES!!! Es absolutamente DIVINO❤️❤️!!!! ABRAZO FROM ARGENTINA¡! 👍😍🇦🇷😃

[@bayaroyun1331]

Even among Bee Gees songs that are all the greatest, For whom the bell tolls is one of my favourites. Most people like Robin’s part on that song, but Barry’s parts make the song as it is and express the feelings. On the Size isn’t everything there is another beatiful song Heart like mine, one of the best songs with Robin’s lead, and increadible harmony. Please look at this song. I’ve seen you reacted to You win again - one of the best songs from 80’s. On the following - One album there are other songs you should react - One, Wish you were here, Bodyguard and Tears - amazing songs!

[@ellenmontgomery8533]

Robin owns this song!!!

[@susieq9801]

@@ellenmontgomery8533 - Absolutely agree. Rob blows it out of the water. POWER!

[@christinestornable1816]

The video to this is awesome. It starts with a young girl living with her boy in a camper by the ocean and you can see the evolution or destruction of the relationship throughout. Ends with the young woman dressed up with her glad rags walking towards the ocean where there is one of those stools like they use in circuses that animals would sit on. And of course there's Robin's awesome voice.

[@singluna888]

BeeGees are magic together. Beautiful song. Robin said the song could have different meanings depending on the listener. I forget which interview it was.

[@MyCarlson1]

Another great one is "one 'by the Bee Gees

[@dianeoliver9041]

One of my very favorites, around the top of my list, love this song. Sweet Perfection!♥️♥️♥️

[@allisons3663]

This is one of their best post-70's songs, though this live performance pales in comparison to the studio version. Barry sounds smoother on the album version.

[@HeatherMyfanwyTylerGreey]

I have been a conscious fan of the BeeGee's since the early 70's. However as a 3 year old I remember hearing this strange word Massachuesets, on the wireless and was fascinated by it's sibilance. I couldn't stop saying it, in rhythm. Perhaps I was already a Bee Gee fan in the 60's. Now in my 60's I have a cerebal illness that effects spelling so please let me off.

[@kimbarrett4179]

Love your reaction Chad x this is one of fave songs after you win again and Massachusetts x

[@barbaranorris6977]

This song!❤

[@adelsuleman5042]

Beegees the only love pls 🥺

[@micheladonofrio2285]

This live version is just as good as the studio version.