My Top 10 Thomas Characters I DON'T Want Televised

[@thecartoonmanist956]

3:53 And plus: we already have a character named Stanley in the TV series.

[@HaydenBlox]

i do not want thomas season 25 televised

[@HaydenBlox]

@The Cyan Kettle Studios yea i know its bad

[@MariaLuiza-ry4xs]

i agree

[@ToxicDoesStuffAndMoreStuff]

but it did sadly :(

[@HaydenBlox]

@@ToxicDoesStuffAndMoreStuff yeah I think we're getting more now I think we're stuck with it forever so I'm there watching Thomas again only the old episodes still buying toys though

[@HaydenBlox]

@AThePlaya when this video is out I didn't know that at the time it's sad thinking that we might never see the original Thomas ever again and we're going to be stuck with this

[@baltasaralaniz-ruiz146]

Title: top 10 thomas characters i don't want televised Mattel vision: top 10 thamas chatacters i want televised

[@GamerB2022LikesTugs]

In my opinion, Pip and Emma can’t return because in the RWS, Gordon was retired from the express and Pip and Emma took his place. Gordon is an “exciting” character to Mattel so they can’t replace him.

[@TrevortheTrainFan]

Good point. I've never thought of that. It's been a while since I've listened to the audio recording of Gordon the High-Speed Engine by Ted Robbins.

[@Joey15811]

Gordon keeps express. They have a new direct service knapford to London none stop and that's fixed and only gives them 1 location they can be given roles interacting

[@DarkBlueEngineProductions2024]

@@TrevortheTrainFan in my head-canon Ivo Hugh and Fred do work on the SKR with Freddie and Mighty Mac but their numbers are Ivo Hugh SKR 7, Fred SKR 8, Freddie SKR 14, Mighty Mac SKR 15 and Ivo Hugh is violet with white lining

[@zero-sama1182]

It's a little interesting hearing you say that we already have a Sidney and a Victor in the show, but we don't question the show having 2 Olivers (which I'm also pretty sure the writers emphasized in Legends of the Lost Treasure)

[@Fiftyfourthengine]

Not gonna lie, when I first so Sidney in Roblox CBR3, I thought he was a custom character. But then I realised he’s a character from the magazines! XD

[@Ninja11125]

Lol

[@emeraldphoenix5868]

Good Job and I think that I want to see Albert,Victoria and Helena Televised.

[@TUUTTIapua]

Top 10 Favourite Railway Series Characters

[@steamzilla95]

If I was I change of the reboot, every single Railway Series story is adapted because I just want to bring back the real and original Thomas the Tank Engine

[@iceeblueburst03]

Some of these characters I don’t know, while some of them I recognized since they had merchandises before such as Ivo Hugh and D199 in Wooden Railway.

[@lennymarroquin]

Top 10 worst new model era episodes

[@aidandunn1009]

I thought the controller 4 the Culdee Fell mountain railway was Mr Barrane. (I wouldn't mind seeing him introduced if the original show was bought back However).

[@CalCon04]

Well you don't have to worry about this with the Reboot.

[@JerrytheVideoGamer257]

I think that Jinty and Pug are the most interesting Thomas characters because I remember seeing them in the Roblox game Blue Train With Friends and that they live in the sheds with The Flying Scotsman, The Big City Engine and City of Truro at Vicarstown station. I want them to appear in the TV series because of those reasons.

[@guilhermerossi807]

You can make a top 5 characters from series 8-12 like Dennis, Rosie and Whiff and from series 13-16 like Scruff, Charlie , Den and Dart. Great video by the way, keep up the good work! 😄😄

[@TrevortheTrainFan]

Thanks!

[@AndrewHager02]

1:25 Kana’s actually a stolen OC reworked into their own creation. Look on Twitter and you’ll see once you meet Kohana. Edit: Just type in “Kana vs Kohana” and you’ll see what we’re all talking about.

[@TrevortheTrainFan]

Yeah, I've seen that, and I thought it was a strange decision on Mattel's part.

[@KatelynNightlight]

Can u send the link to the post?

[@drevianedwardsproductions9244]

I will respect your opinions about non-televised characters that you don't want them in the show

[@TrevortheTrainFan]

Thanks!

[@drevianedwardsproductions9244]

@@TrevortheTrainFan by the way eventually and I quote Thomas Thomas: I don't know what it eventually means but it sounds very very long

[@tuf9200]

You are very right Trevor ,some engines really don't need to be televized.

[@reasonablebutcrazy]

Thanks for not saying you dont want Frank the grey diesel televised because I had a wooden railway of him, everytine I saw a new episode of Thomas the tank engine I always wanted to see him, but never did😢

[@trainguy2007]

I want D199 to return (which I doubt highly)

[@TrevortheTrainFan]

I know how you feel.

[@joaocarmozambom4964]

TOP 5 FEMALE CARATHRES FROM THE MODEL SERIES

[@joshuazillatheapexdinosaur3174]

The one that definitely shouldn't be televisionized is Alfred the B12 he would turn Thomas and friends from G to PG or PG-13.

[@TrevortheTrainFan]

I agree. And besides, he's a fan-made character, and fan stuff isn't meant to be taken seriously.

[@joshuazillatheapexdinosaur3174]

@@TrevortheTrainFan oh ok

[@wjos]

these videos are banging trev. keep it up

[@TrevortheTrainFan]

Thanks!

[@steamzilla95]

1. 10. I wanted Pip and Emma to be televised because we never got a HST (High speed train) as permanent resident on Sodor plus it would’ve nice if they interactive with Rebecca, Molly and Kenji. 9. I agree with Old Stuck Up/Diesel 40125 and sure D261 would be a good replacement but I wanted D199 to be the role instead. 8. I personally like to see them televised. 7. Same as well. 6. I prefer him over Smudger and I like T1E2H3’s canon where Bertram and Smudger as the same engine. 5. I know he looks similar to Bear but longer, I personally would have him in a different coat of paint and a proper introduction. 4. I want them televised but extended their character development. 3. I agree with you on this one and I think of the name: Fiona. 2. I prefer Fearless Freddie as the tenth engine of the Skarloey Railway and Ivo Hugh (purple with white lining) as the seventh. 1.I agree with you on this one.

[@zacharykim5596]

What about Mighty Mac?

[@zacharykim5596]

I would’ve made Ivo Hugh number 7 Mighty as 8 Mac as 9 Fearless Freddie as 10

[@CelestinaakaClonaClox9999]

I don't know about you, but personally I like it when characters get introduced even if they were only used one time. Because 1) I like it when numbers get high, 2) I get this weird enjoyment out of listing things (then again I'm a writer what do you expect) and 3) In general my favorite thing ever is variety, so I love the variety in characters. (PK Variety! Hopefully somebody gets that reference or I'm going to feel very old)

[@3unskippableads51]

I feel like saying they're too obscure Isn't a strong enough reason to not bring them in the show. If that's the case, we might not have gotten Daisy.

[@TrevortheTrainFan]

Well, Daisy is not that obscure. They brought her back in Sodor's Legend of the Lost Treasure as well as in Season 20. But yeah, I get your point.

[@Michipicoten]

7:29 I don’t want him anyways, that face will haunt me forever.

[@joshuadunn3198]

Excellent work and keep up the amazing work Trevor Davis!

[@TrevortheTrainFan]

Thanks!

[@joshuadunn3198]

@@TrevortheTrainFan anytime!.

[@Hashim.Khadwardi]

It would be interesting to see Thomas and Boxhills’s relationship become from the same railway.

[@alexwinandy4792]

I agree with Pip and Emma, Stanley, Victor, Old Stuck Up, and faceless Stephen and my others are Edward Thomas, Douglass, Sir Haydn, 13, Carlos On Wheels, Old Bennet, Station Coach, Special Service Bus and Naughty Pink Truck

[@catavlad8722]

I want all the characters that you mentioned in de TV series

[@star.dust_15]

Well we might not like it now

[@SlowsmeltBM17]

Bruh

[@alexwinandy4792]

Can you make a top 10 of what wooden railway items that don't exist but should including some you make up and some canceled, and one of wooden railway items that do exist but shouldn't just like James Is Here did.

[@Officialaaravd]

5:49 My headcanon is that after Sir Walter died, Mr Percival became controller

[@Fiftyfourthengine]

Also, I never wanted characters from the railway series, because I was only collecting characters that appeared in both seasons 1-7 and the cgi series, so I was not aiming for Tomy Trackmaster BoCo, Stepney, duke etc. But for some reason, for Christmas 2020... I GOT D199 AND BIG CITY ENGINE WOODEN RAILWAY MODELS!!!

[@justinkessler3092]

I would love to see stanley and smudger back.

[@JonathanAnimations04]

3:19 and 3:21 if Samson and Logan appeared in the Model Series

[@victorgaminglounge3967]

Ok Trevor I do have to clarify one thing when you mention the works diesel because fun fact Derek was suppose to appear in the Season 16 Episode Bust my Buffers Derek was suppose to be in that episode but he was mistaken for Paxton in the script.

[@TrevortheTrainFan]

Interesting.

[@victorgaminglounge3967]

@@TrevortheTrainFan indeed it is

[@purplowso]

420th like lol also, do you use the deafult video editor like me?

[@TrevortheTrainFan]

You mean Microsoft Edge Video Editor?

[@purplowso]

@@TrevortheTrainFan i think so

[@LittleNoddyLemmyVideos]

My honest thoughts on each spot on the top: 10: I mean... I kinda agree on that, just to not oversaturate the show, like... They could work but i can't think of a way honestly 9: The problem with old stuck up is that his story and him overall... Are kinda cliche (top 50 different ways to fuck up as a diesel on trial on the NWR), Maybe if Christopher took a different spin and made him at least a character worth televising, or the tv show writers for that matter, maybe he could work?? Kinda?... 8: I mean, if they could create a shit ton of nothing characters in the great race, they would basically do it again!... Or not, you are correct about Stephen tho, but maybe Boxhill could have some depth regarding to his brotherly bond with Stepney boi and Duchess of Hamilton is... Idk 7: Again, they could easily work their way into the TV show if they were just given a little more development, but i guess that's up to us fans to do... Kinda 6: i kinda agree with you there, i don't know if there's a way to add both into the same canon without making it confusing, and with the different character... Maybe give him PTSD from WW1 but with a different treatment 5: I mean... If there was at least a decent idea for his existance, maybe just make him the diesel that rescues other engines to take to the works or just the dieselworks, and give him some moments with diesel 10 4: i mean... They basically share the same purpose as 98462 and 87546, be on the background so the railway isn't as deserted, but if the thing is that they deserve some spotlight if they ever get adapted, check out "the slopes of culdee fell" by T1E2H3, it's cool.(plus i think Wilfred and Ernest have the same problem since idk what they do besides be there) 3: Fred... He is just an NPC with the premise of a lazy mf who is just lazy, same argument about having no excuse to exist if they ain't giving him a decent character development 2: Ivo Hugh... i honestly agree with you on that one, or even better, make him challenge Freddie into a race and the one who wins is the real number 7 that would be fire 1:...i agree with you on that one, there might be hidden potential hidden on them but I'm too lazy to explore in depth

[@cinnamonmantrainsareawesom7224]

I honestly I would’ve like to see Thomas and the great railway show adapted for a special keep in mind this was before aeg

[@thomasegcouplesandships1956]

10. I would have liked to see them televised but I might agree with you there because there's never been model recreations online. 9. I might have to sort of agree with you because of what you said about D199. 8. I would have personally like to have seen them televised. 7. They would have been perfect to see in the TV series IMO. 6. I would have liked to have seen him. 5. He would have been perfect IMO. 4. I would have liked to have seen them. 3. I might have to agree with you because he's not recognized that much. 2. I could pretty much picture him appearing in the series. 1. I'm probably going to agree with you because some of them are not recognized that much. So, in summary I think I might televise all characters into the show. And for a future top 10 video I think you should do top 10 Hit Entertainment era episodes.

[@dukethenarrowgaugeengine1685]

Duke also deserves a return

[@dukethenarrowgaugeengine1685]

Do you also think Duke deserves a return

[@TrevortheTrainFan]

Yes, and I think he should sound a lot like Bradford or something.

[@dukethenarrowgaugeengine1685]

How about you do a top 10 characters I want to return

[@TrevortheTrainFan]

@@dukethenarrowgaugeengine1685 I'm going to put that on hold for a while because of the upcoming reboot.

[@dukethenarrowgaugeengine1685]

I think he should have the same voice as he did in the audio stories sounding like that one KZbinrs uncle

[@dukethenarrowgaugeengine1685]

@@TrevortheTrainFan don't worry I hate the reboot too

[@reptisaurusking8494]

I’m surprised you didn’t put in any fan made ones like Alfred and Timothy the Ghost Train, to me, I think they’re excellent villains. But if you like to have your opinion then by all means, talk with me about it

[@Bepe223]

If I'd do pip/Emma's story with another character I'd say Rebecca to make her more interesting.

[@jztrains3794]

I wish every RWS character ONLY was introduced

[@damianhendriks6162]

My theory is that ivo hugh did exist in the tv show but ended up beyond repair and got scrapped and replaced by freddie

[@jonathanali1800]

Top ten or 5 favourite thomas songs

[@Fiftyfourthengine]

Also I would wish to upload my Top 5 favorite international engines on my channel, for you and all fans to see...

[@saulgodinez3667]

Epic

[@sophiepagan7899]

Please do some tugs top 10 videos

[@Johnny-sm5kq]

True

[@LittleNoddyLemmyVideos]

Well, if they released another Culdee Fell book, maybe they could give more spotlight to the obscure characters Also, did you think about making top 10 fan characters that could fit in the TVS??

[@TrevortheTrainFan]

I don’t do fan content, especially when it comes to fan characters. But thanks for the suggestion!

[@LittleNoddyLemmyVideos]

@@TrevortheTrainFan yeah, i didn't know that and tought of the idea while i was binge-watching the stories of sodor

[@samuelvillaroel2414]

that's every character now for me

[@West_Coast_Mainline]

Jinty and POG POG IS POGGERS

[@mary.of.mares.1470]

I wish that Sidney the narrow gauge engine is in the series aswell as Pip and Emma

[@TrevortheTrainFan]

I understand and respect your opinion.

[@mary.of.mares.1470]

@@TrevortheTrainFan there express from Sodor to the London when Gordon's Express from Sodor to the Barrow and Furrnes

[@dukethenarrowgaugeengine1685]

In my Thomas series smudger is an American locomotive like Stanley but painted black and with the number two and get this I was originally going to call him smudgeley but then I decided to go with just smudger because that name sounded a bit childish

[@harrisonallen651]

And guess what, Mattel won’t let that happen because of All Engines Go

[@TrevortheTrainFan]

True.

[@aydenanaya3908]

Victor the old engine is my favorite he has Henry’s footplate and looked like Oliver

[@edward002gaming]

7:28 the rods are confusing

[@romansgalaxy9093]

6:43-6:48 reminds me of a Thomas wooden railway adventures episode from the channel

[@lucasf0xBR]

hmmm actually pretty interesting, there could be a video about the most useless characters tho

[@rickgarst1452]

They should have Ivo Hugh as the number 8

[@Ninja11125]

7:35 I want him returned he reminds me of a book I used to have

[@wyattmaldonado-zu5ks]

For my series, jinty and Pug qould work as shunter at either vicarstown or barrow. For their characters, jinty would have a neutral personality as he is friendly to tank engines, but hates tender and diesel engines. Pug would be friendly to all engines, but would also be miserable as he would constantly be having to hold jinty back to stop him from ripping diesels and tender engines wheel from wheel.

[@Ninja11125]

Smudger returned in my made up ep called smudgers restoration and like the title says he gets restored and becomes apart of the skarloey railway

[@sebasllaura7254]

I think Pip and Emma should be replaced by CGI versions of Farona and Frederico from Race for the Sodor Cup, because I want to see more realistic redesigns for these two.

[@TiasVsEverything]

What on earth is up with the coupling rods on Victor’s wheels in that pic? HOly hell.

[@gamecubeboy9708]

Kana doesn’t count Season 25 is literally gonna be a new Thomas Canon. Therefore none of the events of Seasons 1-24 will be mentioned or have happened. So that means Season 25 is Non-Canon and every character plot and settings don’t exist in the Original Thomas universe

[@TrevortheTrainFan]

True. But in my opinion, some of these new reboot characters had the potential to be good if they were given an actual backstory and some flaws.

[@amitysluzara2022]

I pretty much agree

[@matthewpowell2429]

While I respect your opinion about Pip and Emma, I honestly wished they would've brought them into the tv show, not to replace Gordon, but just to help. I'd be fine with using D261 (Thedore in my fandom) in place of D199 (Francis). I also would've liked to have seen Genti (Justin) and Pug (Paul) arrive in the special letter because they would've shown realistic examples of BR Steam Engines and having other engines on the island take over the duties of the 8 Famous Engines still left gaps in the roster. As for Stanely, I'm fine with Smudger permanently replacing him as Mid-Sodor 2, through there were many questions left after he was turned into that generator and never heard from again. I also agree that certain Culdee Fell engines shouldn't be televised. Also, I honestly feel they should've televised Fred because he didn't get the coverage in the books he should have. They could've brought Ivo Hugh, just with a different number. Finally, I agree about not having the characters in Annuals and Magazine stories appear, as many of them tend to wander away from what I consider canon in the Railway Series Universe.

[@Officialaaravd]

4:52 Sharon was going to but the animators mistook “Paxman” for “Paxton” so 😭

[@TrevortheTrainFan]

That’s understandable. And I know that this is off topic, but I wished Sharon Miller stayed longer on the production team just so she would voice more characters (besides the queen).

[@DavidBContentExtravaganza3967]

Scrap is part of Thomas & Friends and if the show wants to show characters who got scrapped, their choice and you have to respect it.

[@antoniettapetrillo8956]

I thinked that the diesel from old stuck up was spamcam untile i have seen that the Number was different

[@ScrapyardStudios]

I personally think Jinty & Pug are VERRRY overrated. Like just because we see them once doesn’t mean they have to be permanently on Sodor.

[@nonitalace9029]

I disagreed on jinty and pug. alaric and eric. Shane dooiney. Pip and emma. fred. albert. Helena and victoria ivo hugh they could just change ivo hugh's character But i agreed on the rest

[@doggiedoge4167]

Who was the 8th narrow gauge engine?

[@TrevortheTrainFan]

Duke.

[@doggiedoge4167]

Ok thansk

[@Love-re5xc]

I have a complaint

[@TrevortheTrainFan]

What is it?

[@wyattmaldonado-zu5ks]

For me, why not ivo number 7 and Freddie have a different number.

[@TrevortheTrainFan]

Beats me. Maybe one of them is enough for the TV series? Besides, I don’t mind Freddie being number 7 in the show.

[@Joey15811]

Loughborough is pronounced luff-buh-rah btw. I would say: Stanley (because we have Smudger now) Alice and Mirabel (Because duck now has slip coaches but Isabel and Dulcie should) More mountain railway stories could be made for the other characters. Set a few stories from before Culdee and Shane Leave and the other 3 arrive and have them adapt to life.

[@TrevortheTrainFan]

I know that now.

[@jadenamoako5731]

Remove Charlie

[@rayryde1724]

I think pug and jinty should be televised and ivo Hugh could be 10,11 and 12 to distinguish them

[@Ninja11125]

6:44 too late that’s in my made up episodes

[@svsmodelling2857]

It’s pronounced Duchess of Lufboror but spelt Loughborough

[@Officialaaravd]

4:04 He flooded himself to death in 1946

[@ashertheking5023]

What about 98462 and 87546?

[@atlasthenumber5msr440]

Do a Mid sodor engines like who is your favorite engine and you hate Plz trevor

[@TrevortheTrainFan]

I don't really have a favorite Mid-Sodor engine. I like them all. In fact, I should've added them into the honorable mentions earlier.

[@atlasthenumber5msr440]

Do a list about them plz

[@MattzWorkz]

cool video and um do you play roblox????????????? um probably not but yea cool video like all the other ones and yea thats all i have to say bye! .

[@TrevortheTrainFan]

I don't play roblox.

[@MattzWorkz]

@@TrevortheTrainFan oh well

[@MattzWorkz]

your should make an account

[@MattzWorkz]

its your opion

[@joaocarmozambom4964]

IT'S SHANE DONNEIY

[@dukethenarrowgaugeengine1685]

My Thomas and Friends story of smudger goes like this it happened one sir Handel and Peter Sam were called Stuart and falcon there were four other engines Atlas Jim Tim and Jerry a new engine known as smudger arrived he was reckless and he kept coming off the rails no one would buy him the manager did not want to scrap smudger but at the same time he did not want to keep him as an engine so he decided to turn him into a generator smudger remained there until one day a man with some Dynamite came to the back of the shed where smudger was the dynamite was lit the man put the dynomite at the back of the shed and left but little did he know what he was going to be responsible for the next day Duke came back with a passenger train when all the sudden smudger exploded paramedics were called to put out the fire Duke was in shock when he saw the remains of smudger there was nothing the paramedics could do for smudger the remains of smudger were cut up for scrap and the man who put the dynomite at the back of the shed was arrested for murder of an engine some people say that late at night smudgers ghost haunts the small railway so in my version of the story of smudger smudger did get scrapped like his railway series counterpart

[@aydenanaya3908]

Trevor Davis I rather like Martin Sherman’s Thomas voice better than meesha Contreras’s Thomas voice from AEG

[@Ninja11125]

4:36 I have a friend who agrees with that

[@jamieglover9237]

I add Victoria in my video

[@loganthewolfbear2671]

Stanley was never scrapped, he was moved to the old Mines as a pumping engine then failed, him being scrapped was never mentioned

[@TrevortheTrainFan]

I knew that. Just trying to use my own words.

[@dukethenarrowgaugeengine1685]

Along with Duke

[@DodotheWishFanboy]

U know what really grinds my gears? How rapidly Covid-19 is rising.

[@user-ii9bb2kj9z]

I disagree with you on Pip and Emma, I think they should have a least returned to the great race as competitors in the speed contest

[@mary.of.mares.1470]

Plz trevor made top 10 scaries epizodes of ttte

[@TrevortheTrainFan]

We'll see. Maybe on October of 2021. But I'm not good at keeping promises.

[@aydenanaya3908]

What I want to be in CGI Kelly Neville murdoch Arthur and the other characters from model series

[@thetransportationguy7930]

What if Casey Jones was in Thomas and friends And his engine would be 382 / cannonball And it would have the whippoorwill Call whistle

[@thetransportationguy7930]

I wonder if the shows ever made a reference to Casey Jones