My Top 10 Thomas Characters that NEED to be Televised

[@TrevortheTrainFan]

Correction: I know that Stepney and Boxhill are the same exact class of locomotive, but I what REALLY meant to say was, we don't have to have ALL of the Railway Series only characters into the show. If Thomas & the Great Railway Show were adapted to television, then maybe they can reuse Stepney's, Duchess', and Stephen's model for it in order to cut costs. But that's just my personal opinion. I'll be totally fine if anyone says otherwise. Thanks for the criticism btw and I'm sorry for the misunderstanding earlier!

[@dukethenarrowgaugeengine1685]

I want Agnes Ruth Lucy Jemima and Beatrice in the TV series however I don't want the younger audiences to get Beatrice confused with cora so I'm going to paint her red I'm also going to paint Agnes Ruth Lucy Jemima and Beatrice red too as well as draw their names on and Ada Jane and Mabel how about some people put the numbers on their backsides I mean I'm not trying to be childish but at the same time I don't want to get the younger audiences confused I know that might seem childish but you don't want to get the younger audiences confused now do you

[@dukethenarrowgaugeengine1685]

You know Neil's ghost haunts the scrap yard on the other railway

[@GNRA1GreatNorthern1470]

Bruh box hill is now different to stepney cuz it in its unrebuilt terrier form

[@dukethenarrowgaugeengine1685]

If bear ever gets televised he should keep his original livery because green would make him look too similar to Daisy and Boco Donald and Douglas were painted blue in The railway series but kept their original color in the television series and when Peter Sam and Sir handel were called Stuart and falcon they were painted red and blue to match skarloey and Rheneas but kept their original colors in the television series if they ever adapt super rescue for television if bear was ever in the TV series do you think he should stay blue

[@TrevortheTrainFan]

@@dukethenarrowgaugeengine1685 I agree that Bear should always be blue instead of dark green.

[@1stPeacePrize456]

I wish Wilbert and jock appeared in the TV series as well

[@lolololololololol8762]

Me to :(

[@lolololololololol8762]

Um I'm back?

[@Henryfan1Productions]

I think Wilbert and Sixteen should’ve appeared in the show

[@RetroPro7101]

I had to read your comment a few times bc I thought the comment said they have appeared lol

[@kaidenzarif9086]

Is hasbro fix thomas one day maybe they can bring them in tv series

[@iceeblueburst03]

I also discovered some railway series characters such as Wilbert, Jock, 16, Frank, Culdee, Big City Engine, and Mallard. I’d love to see those engines appear in the televisions series whether it’d the CGI series for specials, or better yet, the model series.

[@SplendillaVanilla-4289]

Bear and d199 were supposed to come back into CGI in either "Journey Beyond Sodor" or the great race- i think it was "JBS" BUT THEY SAID NAH AND CHANGED IT-

[@ToastTheThe]

No Splatter and Dodge were planned to be in The Great Race but from what I know, neither Bear or D199 were planned to appear/reappear ever in the TV series (after they didn't have the budget to adapt Super Rescue for season 3)

[@SplendillaVanilla-4289]

@@ToastTheThe They were supposed to for journey beyond Sodor. Not as background characters.

[@AndrewHager02]

I’d love seeing all them televised, too, but I’d especially love to see Pip and Emma in the TV series.

[@thomasegcouplesandships1956]

10. I don't really remember this one, because I've never red any of his stories. So I'll have to read them. 9. Peel Godred engines Hey? I'd quite like to see them televised. 8. Now I WOULD like to see these ones televised! Especially all of them. 7. Yes, I can just picture these ones returning! 6. He will appear in my rewritten series and I would personally name him Jason after Jason Michas. 5. These characters are pretty interesting and I would hope they would have appeared. 4. Now isn't he a most popular character? And I would have wished he was televised. 3. They're really good characters and I hoped they were televised. 2. I'm honestly gonna agree because in SLOTLT would have been a great opportunity to return more characters. 1. I, am, gonna agree with you BIG TIME! Because Culdee is my favourite RWS character of all times! So, my top 15 characters I would have like to have seen televised are: 15. Duchess of Hamilton 14. Stanley/No. 13 13. Wilbert & Sixteen 12. Green Arrow 11. Mallard 10. Angus 9. Jock 8. Frank 7. Sodor Railway Repair 6. Fred Pelhay 5. Rajinda 4. Abiar 3. Coran 2. Bear 1. All of the Culdee fell engines So, for a future video I think you could do top 10 characters who should return and who would voice them.

[@alexwinandy4792]

Abiar, Coran, and Rajinda are already televised, but they didn’t appear in the tvs.

[@mr.bluetankengine898]

god mattel had the perfect opportunity to introduce these characters and their episodes, but they flushed that opportunity down the toilet. postscript: good video :)

[@TrevortheTrainFan]

Thanks!

[@MmKk-fc8zh]

there were also plans to adapt super rescue for season 3, but it never came true, because the models for diesel d199 (a.k.a spamcam) and bear were too dificalt to model, since the crew workers did'nt had a huge budget

[@matthewhensley7752]

Here is my new opinion now: 1. Ada, Jane, Mabel and Cora 2. Big City Engine 3. Wilbert 4. Sixteen 5. Neil 6. Bear 7. D199 8. Jock 9. Frank 10. Culdee

[@steamzilla95]

Sixteen should’ve been televised in Journey Beyond Sodor. He works at a steelworks on the mainland so it would make sense. He could’ve helped Thomas and James escaped.

[@flowerfrombfdi]

Yea

[@wceyuki]

The peel godred engine looks like either a Class 90 or 91, as seen from the front.

[@stuartt9200]

Here is the thing about godred: he WAS in pieces when he was brought back from the mountain. And I think the reason he was never repaired was because the accident happened in 1900.

[@TrevortheTrainFan]

True, but still in my version, I want him to have a second chance.

[@stuartt9200]

Understandable

[@DavidBContentExtravaganza3967]

Which voice actor would you pick for Ivo Hugh and Fred the narrow gauge diesel?

[@TrevortheTrainFan]

@@DavidBContentExtravaganza3967 I don’t know. 🤷‍♂️

[@DavidBContentExtravaganza3967]

@@TrevortheTrainFan Right. Thanks.

[@joshuadunn3198]

Excellent Work and keep up the amazing work Trevor Davis!. :D

[@TrevortheTrainFan]

Thank you so much!

[@wyattmaldonado-zu5ks]

Also, I would have sixteen appear in journey beyond sodor as he sits in the back of the shed after his crash.

[@SEM4official]

Speaking of the Godred's faith, it was based of the same event that happened at the Snowdon railway (which is what the Culdee Fell railway was based off of) of which Ladas (the railway's number 1) fell off the rails and crashed into the ground. So basically Godred was brought back to their shed, it's just that Awdry nor Culdee never mentioned that he was brought back in pieces (yeah it's more dark if you consider this fact) but yeah, I would love to see the Culdee Fell engines make an appearance, heck they were actually mentioned in the TV series at time, just only at the Island of Sodor 's maps, so they do actually exist at least, but would like to see them in action, and I would like to see Godred as well, srill being arrogant, but after what happened with him, is more careful, and a little more friendly to his colleagues

[@kaydenthescottishwebbtankn9882]

Isn't Reginald Basically Patriot? I like the name Euston, named after the station. I'd also LOVE Wilbert and Sixteen, the Famous engines, D7101 and D199, Jock and Frank, Ada, Jane, Mabel and Cora (the others too, I'd like to see all of them interact),Neil... heck, they should all just get added right now!!

[@FerdinandProductions2021]

7:10-7:14 Personally, I would name Big City Engine Malcolm, like in Deviantart user RailfanBronyMedia’s Thomas AU, the SeventyVerse.

[@RailRocketRicky]

What about Culdee's old friends Ernest and Wilfred? Should they deserve to be televised too? I know that they are minor characters in "Mountain Engines", but whilst Wilfred gets illustrated three times in the book, we only see Ernest's cab, number and part of his nameplate in one illustration.

[@TrevortheTrainFan]

I actually want them televised too. Sorry that I didn't mention them earlier in this video.

[@West_Coast_Mainline]

10. The railway museum 9. Jinty and Pog 8. Big city engine 7. Peel Godred electric engine 6. Culdee fell 5. Sixteen 4. The elderly breakvan 3. Wilbert 2. Niel 1. D199 and d1701

[@aplane9625]

In nwr1991’s canon Neil was preserved at the vicarstown railway museum

[@engineboy53productions15]

Very Interesting list

[@TrevortheTrainFan]

Thank you!

[@DavidBContentExtravaganza3967]

My pick choices for characters that need to be televised are Bloomer, Dudley, Bear, Ivo Hugh, Algy, Belinda The Beetle from her books, Jock and Frank.

[@alexwinandy4792]

Who are Dudley and Belinda?

[@DavidBContentExtravaganza3967]

@@alexwinandy4792 Dudley The Vagrant Engine is a OC by TheBuriedTruck and Belinda the Beetle is a car character created by Wilbert Awdry in another series of books.

[@alexwinandy4792]

@ Why are they not on the wiki?

[@yadinejoe12]

Definitely wanted to see The Culdee Fell engines with also Alaric and Eric. Because it would be also pointless if they weren’t complete though.

[@heathertiplady]

To be fair, the Classic era and most of the HIT era relied on physical models, which came with limitations. One such limitation was the size of the models since the smaller the model, the more difficult it is to work with, as was the case with the first narrow gauge models. Also, due to having a smaller budget, Britt Allcroft and her team were often restricted in terms of which locations they could recreate and which characters they could televise. As such, it's understandable for some details to be omitted, especially during the first 4 seasons.

[@matthewhensley7752]

Never mind about Shane Dooiney, Alaric and Eric because I changed my mind on them. Anyways here are all the Culdee Fell Railway characters I wish were televised and what colors I think the Culdee Fell engines should be: Godred (red) Ernest (green) Wilfred (yellow) Culdee (purple) Lord Harry (purple) Catherine The "Trucks" Coaches

[@2182jenny]

Hi can you please make a top 10 diesels that should returned in full cgi a long time ago video

[@mycharity4kids]

I like listening to the Thomas railway series books. My favorite story is Thomas and the guard.

[@francisdominguez2097]

MAYBE you could name big city engine: TYRONE

[@Joey15811]

I would want: 1) All the CFR crew 2) Bear/D199 3) Ivo Hugh 4) Wilbert/Sixteen (and he becomes that new tank engines mentioned) 5) Albert, Helena and Victoria 6) Jock and Frank 7) Neil 8) Big City Engine 9) Old Stuck Up 10) Pip and Emma 11) Jinty and Pug

[@bunnyboi2417]

You got bear and D261 when you said they had takinplay wooden railway and Ertl

[@sobelabbesnabi3997]

I agree about the Culdie fell part

[@AbeTheBabe6233]

I wonder if Reginald is from from victor tanzigs stories of sodor

[@trainfanofjames13]

Rickity was in the railway series in toad stands by

[@TrevortheTrainFan]

Not really. He was created by Learning Curve. That other teal truck was just some other truck.

[@tempeorang]

0:43 i even think they are just a same engine since both have very similar looking

[@jannik2130]

Well the TRAINZ character of the Big City Engine is called Reginald. And also with the Stories of Sodor by Victor Tanzig.

[@pikachuthebananasplit9061]

It would have been so badass to see 16 in the tv series

[@wyattmaldonado-zu5ks]

Due to my series being a hybrid of the 3 LOVED timelines, every characters from those timelines would appear in my series. Yes it includes the bad characters, but I can find way to make them good ones.

[@elijahtrice8943]

They should make a trackmaster version of Neil and Wilbert for the 80th Anniversary of Thomas

[@TrevortheTrainFan]

Well the thing is, they don't do non-televised characters for Tomy/Trackmaster because they don't sell as well as the televised ones.

[@kaidenzarif9086]

If hasbro fix thomas one day maybe the hasbro toy copaney will make trackmaster toys and bring Neil and wilbert in the tv series

[@tuf9200]

I think sixteen and wilbert will be really nice ,neil aswel. I know this isn't the subject ,but i wish Bertram was in more episodes.

[@TrevortheTrainFan]

Yeah, Bertam had so much potential to be a re-occuring character.

[@joshbrony2204]

Another sad detail about Godred was that his wreck was based on a real story long ago.

[@GREATRJ1]

victor tanzig took big city engines name as reginald

[@fouraces2918]

i want to make a fan art of evry railway serie only engine and make them look like model series

[@timothyghost8899]

Algranon the big city engine

[@Where_is-it]

I'd love seeing the mid-sodor engines from the rws they never appeared in any media well except stanley but stanley appeared in one story , i don't count bulldog since its the illustrator who made the mistake

[@matthewpowell2429]

Many of these characters I do agree with. I would've been great to have actually seen the eclectic version of the Peel Godred Line and its engines. Having Thomas visit the National Railway Museum and see the engines would've made for an exciting story arc. The Big City Engine (Randolph in my fandom) would've made for an excellent rival for Gordon. Wilbert would've been a great example of a preserved visiting engine on the island (not counting Flying Scotsman in the model series) with 16 (Glenn) being a great new addition to one of the branches on Sodor. While just Neil would've been fine, I'd like it even more if all three Sodor & Mainland engines (Clive, Neil, & Matthew) were there, plus the Wellsworth & Suddery engines (Colin, Lily, & Adam). Bear would be at the top of my list as Super Rescue is my favorite non-television adapted Railway Series story, and him being a kind example of diesels. I also would've liked seeing all of the Arlesdale Engines together when they finally hit the screen in CGI. Also, many of the underrated characters and ones featured in that Sodor History Book (Such as: Elise, Albert, Fred, etc.), would've made the tv show more exciting and entertaining in my opinion.

[@wallygator92]

I would have liked to have seen the Mountain engines in series 4 but the models would have been too expensive to make! I can picture the kids in Shining Time Station being shocked after Mr. Conductor tells the story of Godred!

[@TheDirtyWork]

I like the CGI version

[@TrevortheTrainFan]

I like the CGI version better too when it comes to the addition of voice actors; but I still love the model era because it's nostalgic.

[@harrisonallen651]

Big City Engine and Wilbert should be televised if Mattel listens to us fans.

[@TrevortheTrainFan]

I'm afraid that's not going to happen now. But at the same time, I agree with you!

[@kaidenzarif9086]

If hasbro fix thomas maybe they can bring them into televised

[@randysawsomeworld1]

For big city engine name is Alfred

[@wallygator92]

The Big City Engine would have been a good recurring antagonist.

[@AlexsTrainYard]

Fun fact, Big City Engine is named, "Reginald" in a lot of fan made and video form series. If you want an example, ask @Victor Tanzig.

[@TrevortheTrainFan]

Interesting!

[@AlexsTrainYard]

Thanks

[@TrevortheTrainFan]

@@AlexsTrainYard Sure thing!

[@AlexsTrainYard]

@@TrevortheTrainFan quick question, are you going to mention my comment in a video? Just curious.

[@TrevortheTrainFan]

@@AlexsTrainYard I'm not sure yet.

[@alexwinandy4792]

I agree with mountain engines, Jock, Frank, Wilbert, 16, Mallard, Green Arrow, Bear, Neil, Algy, and Angus and my others are Spamcan, Duchess of Hamilton, Albert, Victoria, Ivo Hugh, Fred, Jinty, Pug, Tallylin, Dolgoch, Sidney, Flying Thistle, Dustin, Gold Engine

[@MattzWorkz]

cool umm rember that sharron miller video you posted anyway i like the sharron miller era bc just the cgi background that it has and some of the themes anyway cool video umm yea all i have to say

[@MattzWorkz]

btw it is 100xs better than the reboot

[@MattzWorkz]

lol and ty for hearting my comment 😍😍

[@brightredmogul1912]

Um, if you’re talking about characters that need to return in the REBOOT, you may wanna revise your list. Here, I’ll start it off. 10. *nobody*

[@TrevortheTrainFan]

Don't worry, I've already cancelled my Top 10 Characters I'd like to see return as well as my Top 10 Characters I'd like to see in Wooden Railway form.

[@abloogywoogywoo]

No Welsh locomotives was a bit of a shortcoming for the series, considering their dynamic history with the GWR. Duck: There's two ways of doing things, the Great Western way, or the wrong way- Taff Vale 28: DON'T dare lecture ME on the GWR, YOU got my brothers and sisters all scrapped!! The big engines snickered to each other as Duck for the first time went red in the face.

[@cadenware3222]

for me if I want to make my own Wooden Railway 16 I will probably get the Wilbert model and the Ertl sixteen improbably remove the face off the Earl model and put it onto the Wilbert model and turn into 16

[@wyattmaldonado-zu5ks]

My series would be a hybrid of the railway series, the model series, and the cgi series.

[@FRxmzi]

Do you khow reginald the scrap engine?

[@FRxmzi]

Hes a tank engine

[@FRxmzi]

And do you khow timothy the ghost train alwell?

[@TrevortheTrainFan]

@@FRxmzi No, I don't know Reginald the scrap engine. BUT...I've heard of Timothy the ghost engine.

[@FRxmzi]

Oh... i khow reginald, i just watch gordon fell in a ditch then i saw a scrap engine in the crash cene at the letf botom

[@lavaboyoh1893]

Reginald is the most popular name for the Big City Engine, and honestly, the name I would want him to be named too

[@Joey15811]

Catherine actually isn't in WR. Instead of Catherine they made the Truck but called it Catherine...

[@nssteampunk4865]

Personally I would like to see the entire list of them you mentioned

[@hunterneitzel3012]

Reginald makes sense for the big city engine, as it's wildnorwester form is named Reginald, and is friends with Peter the heavy goods engine, iris the container yard diesel, Owen the goods diesel, and Lily the sunken tank engine, all of which are wildnorwester characters. Even though they are fan made, they'd fit perfectly in the official show. Wildnoreester was also the first person to actually give names to the Peel godred electric engines, those being Steve and Shawn(both green), Andy(blue) and jeffrey(dark red). Number 16 doesn't appear, but another engine named Sheffield, happens to be an austerity tank engine and has the number 16. Wildnoreester has also confirmed Neil's brothers to be named Clive and Mathew

[@GNRA1GreatNorthern1470]

the fans agreed that BCE's name is Reginald

[@austin3471]

Just pointing this out if you didn’t know. Culdee made the story up but skarloey and rheneas didn’t tell sir Handel or Duncan that. So I think godred is fine

[@TrevortheTrainFan]

I knew that. But in real life, Godred's basis, L.A.D.A.S. fell down the mountain and was dismantled. So that's why I thought Godred died just like his real-life counterpart.

[@austin3471]

ooh I see

[@johnandtheduck3592]

i think that the big city engine name could be peter

[@atlasthenumber5msr440]

All of the MSR engines

[@Northern1225]

Big city engine=Reginald

[@kidz4p509]

6:07 Probably not. 7:07 Algernon?

[@seventiethcenturynicky6572]

Neil's two brotherz are Clive No. 1 and Matthew No .3

[@drevianedwardsproductions9244]

I literally have to agree with you I mean I was 10 years old back then when I saw those three episodes of season 20 Tit for Tat Mike's whistle and of course useful Railway those stories are very interesting and I had no idea that they're based on the Railway Series until now unlike today so I think it's a good idea

[@johnakabossx1800]

You could also do a top ten of engines that should come back to cgi

[@TrevortheTrainFan]

Well, I'm afraid that's not going to happen now because of the 2D reboot.

[@johnakabossx1800]

I agree

[@johnakabossx1800]

And the characters voices sounds annoying

[@johnakabossx1800]

And diesel do not look devious anymore😭

[@TrevortheTrainFan]

@@johnakabossx1800 You got that right.

[@johnmoore7926]

Phillippa & Emma should also be televised. Twin diesel locomotive express engines between the UK and Island of Sodor. Also referencing the episode called "a close shave for Duck", a city engine was to have the spot of James when pulling the coaches out of the station when Duck went to the siding of collision into the barber shop, too. Another one could have been advertise was the Marklin engine with a face.

[@nikkilaite]

For big city engines name should not be called Reginald cuz there is a scraped tank engine i like him as the original name

[@patricklawlor9629]

4:48 And Gordon

[@tristanchan4949]

If any Thomas characters that should be in the show (in my opinion, including ones that were part of the wooden railway era with two that were never a wooden train) it would probably be frank, jock (never became a wooden train), Neil, ballast spreader (Sodor railway repair), Catherine and Culdee, probably rickety and Fred (even though they’re just other troublesome trucks), Wilbert, Ivo Hugh, ada Jane and Mabel, diesel 199, bear (never became a wooden train) and big city engine. I don’t know what stories would have those guys, but that’s because of the fan series that I’ve watched called Thomas the tank engine and friends wooden railway adventures (the KZbin channel is called Thomas wooden railway (with no spaces)) which had those characters in it, also with the one episode characters and three Sodor story collection ones too named Logan Sam and Dustin (who are already in the show anyways).

[@alexwinandy4792]

Sam is already televised and I say Logan is as well.

[@tristanchan4949]

I was only mentioning those who didn’t appear often in the actual show, and were shown in the fan series of Thomas along with the railway series only characters.

[@alexwinandy4792]

@@tristanchan4949 Sam also appears in BWBA (cameo).

[@smartperson9642]

The guy in the thumbnail looks like victor

[@smartperson9642]

16 I ment

[@Officialaaravd]

Some characters won't be main in the reboot. But that's just Gordon and Emily. Can u please do International Engines

[@TrevortheTrainFan]

We'll see.

[@LMSHENRY-jn7li]

I wish the RWS Coaches and RWS rolling stocks appeared in the TV and CGI series too

[@TrevortheTrainFan]

You mean RWS coaches and rolling stock like Isabel, Dulcie, Alice, Mirabel, and Fred Pelhay the orange coal car?

[@LMSHENRY-jn7li]

@@TrevortheTrainFan yes

[@smlfan14]

it was probably because the model was too expensive/budget cuts

[@loanedengineproductions]

reginald is already take by victor tanzig the reginald is his series the stores of sodor reginald IS the big city engine

[@dukethenarrowgaugeengine1685]

Keep Lord Harry/Patrick purple as well

[@TrevortheTrainFan]

I agree because he's a different shape than Culdee.

[@megalosaurusstudios2]

I’d like to see duchess of Hamilton, he/she would probably be a rival too duchess.

[@reginacampbell8410]

Danger points doubles back and bad lookout on my favorite railway series chapters Cuz devil's back his super nice he's and really yeah plus am I going to name him at the station saying I won't have it goes to it's too it's called devil's back I mean I bet when Patrick first hit the name of devil's back he thought it was going to eat up his passages that hell and back

[@scifiguy9000]

So, which Mountain engine would you wish to see be added and which you don't?

[@ieuanbriers]

I think an extremely pompous souding name for the big city engine. Sir Vincent or Sir Percival. Sir-Somthing. I think.

[@wallygator92]

had a Godred toy when I was a kid and I thought he was just from an episode that I had never seen!

[@cadenware3222]

again I think the perfect name for Big City Engine is always Reginal

[@guilhermerossi807]

I also want to see the culdee fell engines back!😄😄

[@Unknown-nv7vh]

Especiall godred

[@Scott_3F]

I think you they should’ve kept bear or D7101 because at least he was kind to the other engine

[@TrevortheTrainFan]

Agreed. They should've kept Bear in the actual show.

[@Scott_3F]

@@TrevortheTrainFan 😏👍

[@matthewbreazzeal6338]

I wish they televised 98462 and 87546 from the rws

[@stevenmosco20]

For the big city engines name, I would go with either Avery or the person in charge of the city that he lives in

[@ToQ_Ichigo]

7:10 I’d think the best name for him would be Nickelolas

[@ad-sd-vids5332]

The show ended, and now we are never going to get any of these characters in the show 😢

[@alexwinandy4792]

The show did not end, it is AEG.

[@1stPeacePrize456]

Cool

[@TrevortheTrainFan]

Thanks!

[@Mskart109]

Sadly it will never happen thanks Mattel

[@kaidenzarif9086]

But if hasbro fix thomas one day maybe they'll bring them in the tv series

[@brodywilliams5374]

wilbert's model and livery appears in the original movie "chitty chitty bang bang"

[@TrevortheTrainFan]

I LOVE Chitty Chitty Bang Bang! It was one of my favorite live-action movies from my childhood along with Matilda!

[@kaidenbolyardst663]

I’ve never read The Railway Series in Thomas and Friends.

[@West_Coast_Mainline]

Nice

[@TrevortheTrainFan]

Thanks!

[@amitysluzara2022]

I wish Wilbert was televised

[@kaidenzarif9086]

If hasbro fix thomas one day maybe they can bring him in the tv series