My top 15 Starkid characters

[@catrin777]

in conclusion, moral of the story *dylan saunders :)*

[@GoodMorningButch]

Precisely.

[@historicallyacrow]

*Exactly-*

[@mydarkstrangeson2691]

everywhere & nowhere and Meredith Stepien :)

[@RubiRenegade]

@@mydarkstrangeson2691 So twisted is simply the best of their productions because Dylan and Meredith are deities sent to us from heaven?

[@mossthemage9948]

As a young woman, I can confirm that I want the moon, I want to live on it, eat it in a pie, keep it as a pet and wear it like a gemstone in my hair. Finally a character the says what we are all thinking.

[@alisondices]

And someday soon the people who say I’m just dreaming will see how wrong they are as I laugh in their faces with mouthfuls Of moooooonbeam PIEEEEEEEEEEEE

[@mckenziechristian8463]

alison i wanna make my own choices i mean please is that so much to ask? but decisions are hard and i’m being bombarded!

[@crystalwaters7573]

And I wish to fix the socio-economic inequality by establishing communism and making everyone a princess.

[@jlg9941]

I wish to buy the kingdom of Pixar for $2.2 billion to stop the war I started by siccing a tiger on a prince’s ass.

[@Amelia_H-A]

me watching wicked: this is some hetero nonsense me watching twisted, sobbing loudly: this is MY hetero nonsense

[@GoodMorningButch]

THEY’RE SOULMATES AND THEY’RE GONNA BE WITH EACH OTHER FOREVER

[@GoodMorningButch]

for me, THE deciding factor is that I cannot (CANNOT) get into any het ship where the guy is cocky and acts smug. It’s why I absolutely hate Fiyeraba and why Ja’far/Sherrezade works so well for me.

[@deathbydrano]

@@GoodMorningButch YES THEYRE LITERALLY MADE FOR EACH OTHER

[@jlg9941]

MMMM SO TRUE

[@Tsuginocest]

I forgot this was a ranking and just read the commentary like they were anime subtitles

[@JoeSmith-db4rq]

Clark during Lauren's monologue as Craphole/Son is literally me watching my own self-destructive habits lmaooo

[@JackieBorelli]

as much as I love jeff being loud & batshit & a rock god, his "be right there, honey" moment was so sweet & tender, I wish we could see more of that from him. I need more quiet soft boi jeff.

[@GoodMorningButch]

I agree! I love Jack Bauer best of all his roles because we do see some of that emotional shit! It’s so soft.

[@elizabeththompson1643]

i love that this entire video is just women of starkid appreciation you're so valid

[@GoodMorningButch]

They’re so good! So many talented women.

[@kiki8792]

Dylan is my favorite woman 😌💅

[@bea2860]

@@kiki8792 lol

[@mariabrady4900]

My girl Charlotte just wanted some cuddles, the most relatable character ever written. Has my uwus.

[@Sebastian-of4ln]

Conclusion: Dylan's characters are amazing and he plays them all so well

[@katk.8603]

also i accidentally adopted craphole's little smile when he says "skinny dipping" and it's now my awkward smile i love him so much

[@typingnoises]

FINALLY someone who thinks batman and superman should've had a relationship at the end

[@GoodMorningButch]

I JUST THINK THEY LIKED EACH OTHER

[@sarahkinsey5434]

Fun Fact: The reason Dumbledore was reading off of a legal pad was Dylan didn't memorize that part! I never would have guessed it wasn't planned! 23:36 Dylan literally has tears in his eyes! Edit: I love how many of these were played by the same actors! Just goes to show how utterly talented Starkid is!

[@katk.8603]

the whole jane monologue is the entire reason i, myself, fell in love with emma perkins and this is great

[@sarahkinsey5434]

That scene between her and Paul made me ship them so hard! That and someone commenting on another ranking video saying that whenever Paul is with someone else, especially Emma that he is protective made the ending so shocking!

[@krystleurban7345]

The little (beautiful legs) side comment in the Charlotte section sent me. Because honestly, if you say you didn’t constantly get distracted from the action of TGWDLM by those legs, you’re lying.

[@GoodMorningButch]

LEGIT what even happens in that show, I don’t know. June Saito has always been an excellent lesbian ally.

[@krystleurban7345]

Fucking preach.

[@sarahkinsey5434]

Seriously those shorts look AMAZING on her!

[@MerphyWatchLinkClick]

GoodMorningButch I’m going to add a total of 0 (units of your choice) to this comment and just say that I have genuinely never noticed those legs for days until I saw this video.

[@jordan_i_guess5928]

In relation to your "Meredith be like *noises*" thing, in the captions on firebringer, they're described really weirdly and it's amazing. One I remember was something on the lines of "*sad deflating balloon noise*"

[@GoodMorningButch]

Yessss and with Molag it’s "Robot noises" it’s adorable! the captions of SK shows often have great jokes :)

[@xaxasluv]

i k n e w jemilla would be #1 and i 100% vibe w that

[@GoodMorningButch]

She is unmatched in any universe 😔 Queen of beauty, flirting and weird noises

[@roj6895]

ur profile picture is Jamie ofc u know whats up

[@rhollaroid]

Me: that one that Lauren Lopez plays in the Harry Potter trilogy, that one Lauren Lopez plays in Twisted, that one Lauren Lopez plays in Trail to Oregon, that one Lauren Lopez plays in Firebringer, that one Lauren Lopez plays in TGWDLM, and that one Lauren Lopez plays in Black Friday. And like, Ron.

[@GoodMorningButch]

woah I can’t believe you hate the one that Lauren Lopez played in Starship and the one that Lauren Lopez played in Holy Musical B@man

[@masterizzy3]

Of course, my opinion on Starkid characters is way different than yours and stuff, but I love your commentary. It's my fav out of all the other Starkid fan youtube channels!

[@GoodMorningButch]

Oh thank you so much! I think it's a good thing that everyone has different opinions and interpretations, it really proves that Starkid tells many very different stories that appeal to all sorts of people!

[@masterizzy3]

@@GoodMorningButch Yep and I really hope that everyone can understand that

[@waynefodor3762]

I totally agree. My opinion is very different, for one thing Jemilla has always made me want to rip my hair out (so does firebringer) and I took sooooo much pleasure watching Zazzalil wack her with a stick. And I hate Becky, Tom is talking about the fact he lost his wife not too long ago and Becky's just abusing that fact he's hurting

[@waynefodor3762]

Also these are just my opinions everyone has different opinions and Im always openminded about peoples opinions, epecially bc people have been very nice about the fact I hate firebringer (not the duck though, He is lord) Thanks for reading my rant love ya'll

[@minceroft3710]

also can we talk about how Firebringer really depicted so many different growth and learning journeys and the different ways people can react so well?? Grunt and Emberly discover flavour mixing and painting together, and respond with pure awe; Ducker learns that blind faith won't always lead him to the best result, and at first he denies that he was wrong, and tries to cope by worshipping the fire, but in the end he finds comfort in encouraging the love within the tribe; Tiblyn learns not to define her self worth through one singular thing, and while the realisation affects her greatly, she comes out stronger; and while jazzalil's contrasting reactions to fire (impulsively cautious and impulsively reckless) are really a main focus, discovering their feelings for each other and how they handle them is also a theme (jemilla just wants to protect zazzalil, but fails to make her intent explicit, resulting in misunderstanding, but in the end she learns to vocalise her thoughts and feelings; zazzalil, on the other hand, learns to listen to others and especially jemilla, and grows to admire her and her dedication). That highkey became an essay but I felt the need to say that-- Firebringer isn't perfect, but it brought us some great characters and storylines

[@randymarie]

"I wanted a salad but now I have a child" made me laugh way harder than it really should have

[@norriec6323]

How in Dead God's name did I not ship hmb Batman and Superman before this?????? BECAUSE I SURE DO NOW

[@GoodMorningButch]

THEY’RE SOULMATES AND THEY WANNA KISS EACH OTHER

[@toobashaikh5922]

Slippery When Wet and Mouthface walked so Ladybird could run.

[@all1swan]

5:59 oh my god. I never even thought about the possibility of Tom having to be the one to send her the funeral invite. That’s probably why he was so reluctant to invite Emma over/have her around later on, he was upset that Jane tried so hard to connect with her and it’s too late now.

[@j.j.225]

THE MOTHER FROM TRAIL TO OREGON appreciation makes me so so happy

[@GoodMorningButch]

I have some… advanced mommy issues in my own life and I latch onto fictional mothers for comfort. She means the world to me.

[@daliah8883]

I stan her too much because she’s really not that great but I love her so much and she seems like a great mom still

[@nora3067]

I’m worried I’m going to blink and miss the whole essay on the character.

[@GoodMorningButch]

Yeah think fast, the comments are only for the fans who will take that time lol, others can enjoy just a compilation of scenes!

[@nora3067]

@@GoodMorningButch haha yeah. Thanks for taking the time though. They're really good analysis of the characters.

[@marinarasauce5701]

i love these videos because the commentary alternates between making me cackle and making me sob

[@TheAceUpYourSleeves]

It is actually beautiful when you used the names of the characters in trail to Oregon so sincerely.

[@HeadphonesGal215]

24:01 this line KILLS me because Sherrezade has probably spent most of her life telling stories to other people for entertainment and being put on display for others, and finally someone wants to know HER story and who SHE is, not just what she can give others 😭

[@shadowdogs5070]

Honestly, I agree with the ranking. But I also wanted Linda, Draco, Paul, and Akhmed... it would be a very hard decision for me to rank them

[@apffee7287]

*sees Emma in the thumbnail* Me: oh yay she’s gonna be quite high up! Video: Emma is #13 Me: rip ;-; Jk lol it’s your opinion I just really like Emma Edit: nvm I forgive you for the wonderful comments *LIKE*

[@GoodMorningButch]

lol I’m sorry I totally clickbaited this shit cause I know my other choices are less mainstream she’s the one I thought would get people to watch lol

[@apffee7287]

GoodMorningButch fair lol Also further into the video and yes THE FACE SHE MAKES WHEN TOM WANTS TO TALK ABOUT JANE HURTS ME AND DELIGHTS ME because spoiler alert: THEY DIDNT GET TO TALK ABOUT JANE DAMN IT

[@featherlight858]

Oh, what I really hate about Wicked's ending is them lying to Glinda

[@elenahaase9134]

Honestly i was rlly surprised that Mouthface wasn’t your favorite, but i love this all the same

[@GoodMorningButch]

Nobody tops Jemilla 😭

[@elenahaase9134]

GoodMorningButch Jemilla is a queen and Meredith is a goddess we do not deserve

[@LilyGrace95]

All I can say as a result of this video is that Starkid's script writing is *amazing* (not being specific cos it's not always the Lang brothers, even if it is mostly them): the humour is SO good, and they always manage to find the unexpected jokes. The drama is just... Like, Becky's monologue just comes out of *nowhere* and it's one of the most compelling pieces of theatre I've ever seen. And as for the acting/singing/choreography.... That speaks for itself.

[@lewismcintosh8029]

I'm glad you included Becky and Tom in your list. I recently saw Black Friday and instantly loved their connection and chemistry between each other. I was surprised not many people liked them compared to other Hatchetfield characters on their lists. Their duet is definitely my favourite song in not just the musical, but the whole franchise. I'm glad I'm not the only who loves them not just as a couple, but as characters too.

[@relaxolotl788]

honestly I am happy you included the cabbage patch kid Emma line

[@GoodMorningButch]

I absolutely love the Emma content in Black Friday!

[@beck4557]

this list is valid and while i dont 100% agree, i love seeing other ppl's opinions and your commentary was pure gold! also, the small little (beautiful legs) and 'arms...' is me everytime i try to watch starkid so thank you for that

[@GoodMorningButch]

Thank you so much! I definitely don’t consider that my opinions are or should be universal, they’re just a reflection of how I personally receive these stories.

[@ceciliacrasto4602]

11:06 the dude in the background has no right to look that concerned and it SENDS ME

[@ErinaBleu]

ok i almost didn't watch this bc ive seen a bunch of these ranking videos and they're usually just the same scenes that every other video uses but i actually love this so much bc your commentary is so analytical and made me think about some of these characters differently or realize things i'd never noticed?? so... this video is amazing and you're so smart???

[@GoodMorningButch]

My goal is to share my love for these beautiful stories so mission accomplished!

[@Ray-hk1zm]

This isn't that related to this video but I need to scream about how Mad I am at people Specifically some of my friends and the people in the live chat during Black Friday More specifically the ones who were calling Becky JD or saying that she was a crazy evil murderer, like Did You Listen To That Monologue Or Did You Have Your Head So Far Up Your Own Butt That You Missed It- *ahem* I'm fine It just really sucks to see people look at her trauma and her bravery as just that of a crazy woman??? I dunno maybe I'm making a bigger thing out of this than it needs to be,, But anyway, yes, love all of these characters!! My list is probably wayyy different but I literally am incapable of picking a favorite character in most of these shows (my favorite character in Black Friday, for example, is All Of Them) so I'm just gonna enjoy yours.

[@featherlight858]

Also can I just say I love your thoughtful commentary, like, you seem to put a lot of thought into your rankings

[@alexandranoellemuliadi6488]

The difference between wisdom and intelligence is Jemilla and Zazzalil

[@qwertyqwerty-jy9fc]

I never thought abt my favourite characters because i love all of them tbh but that ranking is superior

[@isabelle4317]

Here just to say how much I love your comments and analysis on the characters, your videos are a blessing

[@GoodMorningButch]

Thank you so much!!! I love this format of chill commentary without putting on myself the pressure of a structured analysis or tbh of quality standards cause it's just for entertainment purposes

[@thephandmphamilywithalvefo3307]

27:00 this tiny clip gave me goosebumps and tears in my eyes, I love the ending to Black Friday so much oh my goodness

[@JoeSmith-db4rq]

OMG honestly I needed this video in my life... now I finally understand the true magic of all of Meredith's noises lmaoooo I don't know how I've lived in ignorance for so long

[@GoodMorningButch]

she’s so cute 😭

[@yayitabro5680]

“I love you” Thanks friend, I love you too. 😭

[@jparker9191]

Idk the name of the guy who does the music, but he always looks angry and confused and I'm here for it 😂

[@GoodMorningButch]

Clark? I love him so much

[@daliah8883]

Putting Megagirl on the list is very exciting Becky Barnes appreciation squad😌✌️

[@featherlight858]

Oh you definitely SHOULD see HSM (maybe it's not great plot-wise, but it's still fun to watch, the songs are absolute bops and the memes are awesome)

[@GoodMorningButch]

the weirdest thing but: I really love Corbin Bleu for precisely two musicals he was in that I’ve seen, In the Heights and Holiday Inn. so I should watch it one day.

[@djwilson1993]

I highly recommend the music in HSM2 as well.

[@featherlight858]

@@djwilson1993 Yeah, all three movies have some very good songs to be honest.

[@djwilson1993]

featherlight you can definitely bet on it... Wait...

[@crystalwaters7573]

Jemilla, the one who Knows Things

[@duckislord7187]

I love the ranking and commentary in this video! Thank you so much for taking the time to make it.

[@TonkarzOfSolSystem]

My favorite Starkid character is Lauren Lopez.

[@mylahobbit1815]

im so fucking glad that i'm not the only one who loved jazzalil - people are always like 'oh it was forced bad rep :(' but I fucking love it. the parallels, the beauty, the understanding, the foreshadowing is all just **chef kiss** also bold move having only one AVP character on this list I respect that though I do not agree with it

[@roj6895]

you are right tho i wanna to wear the moon in my hair and eat it in a pie

[@LosTrilocos]

It's 2 AM but I couldn't press stop on this video, your ranking is totally logical and I really enjoyed the comments!! I wasn't the biggest Jazzalil shipper but now I understand them a lot more. Thank you so much for that Dylan appreciation too 💜

[@GoodMorningButch]

I love Jazzalil so much

[@rockassassin64]

This list is kind of close to what mine would be just in different orders also Lex would be on my list

[@rockassassin64]

Tom loves his lesbian daughter... tim isn't a les... oh wait Lex. Yeah that cheeks out

[@averyguilbert6314]

I love Becky Barnes and I’m in love with Kim Whalen and she better be in more things!!!!

[@haileygalbraith6260]

I paused and read every footnote. I WANT TO LIVE ON THE MOON!!

[@5TailedArtist]

I'm actually so glad to see Becky so high up on your list (and I agree with a lot of your list too!), but I feel like so many people dislike her for...I guess progressing Tom and her relationship too fast after Tom's wife's death. Thank you for giving her the appreciation I feel she doesn't usually get!!

[@duckislord7187]

I completely agree with this statement! Becky is usually seen as simply Tom's girlfriend - her personality doesn't get the recognition it deserves.

[@alisondices]

I just have one question do meredith be like noises though

[@aoife8977]

This video just reminded me how gay I am lmao

[@fabsybox1538]

I personally just love all the characters!

[@GoodMorningButch]

There’s so many engaging and interesting ones!

[@michaelgreico9630]

I love how half of these are Lauren and Jamie

[@GoodMorningButch]

They’re very talented and good

[@michaelgreico9630]

@@GoodMorningButch Absolutely. Lauren Lopez is phenomenal.

[@GoodMorningButch]

@@michaelgreico9630 And so is Jaime Lyn Beatty :)

[@michaelgreico9630]

@@GoodMorningButch Also true. But If I had to pick one above them all, gotta go with the OG Latte Hatte

[@cococovers1333]

i LOVE emma perkins! She's literally me, a depressed sarcastic chaotic girl who has no idea what shes doing with her life

[@Amelia_H-A]

big fucking mood. i love merediths noises they really capture the brain thoughts of a useles wuhluhwuh like myself

[@CyFiWasTaken]

13:23 I wish Joey Richter would hold me like that

[@theqwertykeyvoard100]

honestly shocked there’s no robert manion but i respect it

[@GoodMorningButch]

Yeah I’m a lesbian.

[@mydarkstrangeson2691]

I don’t completely agree with this completely but it’s still a really well made video! You did a really good job👍👍

[@phoebe8719]

Princess gives me Amy March vibes

[@sophovot5079]

29:48 THAT LINE CONFUSES ME SO MUCH?!? like I thought Jemilla was just being awkward about kissing Zazz on the cheek but she does that to several people? idgi

[@avxd7]

personal fave is voldemort/quirrell together

[@GoodMorningButch]

Those are great characters too!

[@banana-xj6yk]

HECK YEAH DUMBLEDORE’S HERE!!!!! FRICKIN LOVE HIM

[@bisexualbestie4351]

8:21 I THOUGHT YOU MENT JIM AND I GOT SO HAPPY FOR A SECOND-

[@breadcrumbhoarder]

I love that it’s mostly Dylan and Lauren because same lol

[@jimmy_the_squid9456]

Dylan Saunders is the underrated gem of Starkid

[@priacolclough7938]

we need more INFP representation

[@SageShadows]

i didn't realize it but jemilla really gets her kisses in huh

[@waynefodor3762]

who else went straight to the comments after to see if anyone said anything about Becky being on the list? No one? okay its just me then.

[@harpykrates]

is it sad that I've seen so many of your videos that I accurately guessed the top five

[@GoodMorningButch]

I’m not a very unpredictable kinda person so this doesn’t surprise me

[@cai_4602]

12:12 the text. tHe TeXt *THE TEXT* wow same

[@jessewhitney4188]

Man I love reading at 10,000 mph

[@GoodMorningButch]

This is a speedreading channel, I duped y’all into thinking it was SK.

[@femkeedelbroek4118]

4:20 (potfarm,,, iconic): my wife is a bitch and i like her so much

[@greenishfrogs]

Actually, I thought that the Holy Duck was the best actor of them all 😌✨ 🦆

[@willowrosenberg9967]

HE IS LOORD DUCK IS LOORD HE IS LORD LORD LORD *DUCK IS LOOOORD*

[@greenishfrogs]

White wolf indeed 😌✨

[@willowrosenberg9967]

@@greenishfrogs indeedindeedindeedindeedindeed - it's growing on me (bad B99 reference/joke, sorry, I have no life, gotta go, love you binders :))

[@48917032]

Trunkell deserves a place on that list. She's a great elephant.

[@atemsbofen]

Dylan + Lauren = best STAGE PERFORMER.

[@kiki8792]

+Joey

[@redscrunchie222]

My top 15: 1) Professor Henry Hidgins 2)Professor Henry Hidgins 3)Professor Henry Hidgins 4)Professor Henry Hidgins 5)Professor Henry Hidgins 6)Professor Henry Hidgins 7)Professor Henry Hidgins 8)Professor Henry Hidgins 9)Professor Henry Hidgins 10)Professor Henry Hidgins 11)Professor Henry Hidgins 12)Professor Henry Hidgins 13)Professor Henry Hidgins 14)Professor Henry Hidgins 15)Professor Henry Hidgins

[@nicoleciampa8804]

Tootsie Noodles is my fave and I am kinda sad that he is not even on this list

[@GoodMorningButch]

I absolutely love him but I really do prefer their love story more from the point of view of Mega-Girl, I think she’s the one who had the most to learn and to grow and that’s just more compelling to me. He’s so cute though!

[@oliviamurray3909]

*what the hell is a hufflepuff?!*

[@GoodMorningButch]

*sits back down utterly defeated*

[@Ghoulxh]

I love Emma too!!

[@sophovot5079]

in conclusion: WAMAN PRETTY

[@weirdflexbutok]

Draco isn’t on the list Me: 😧

[@breezyiscool8025]

There's not enough Joe Walker in here, but other than that, a pretty solid list

[@GoodMorningButch]

It's my personal list so there's the exact amount.

[@booorue4876]

#1 has to go to Cornelius or whatever his name is the lobster.

[@quiroz923]

Come on, we all know you missed one... WE'RE ALL JUST PAWNS IN A FUCKING GAME OF CHESS!

[@GoodMorningButch]

She has her spot in my video of my ranking of Meredith’s roles, she’s so beautiful and perfect… nameless citizen with the cute green sweater… the love of my life

[@gwendolynjonsson853]

A hwedding

[@rae_zina]

*noises*

[@minceroft3710]

yes rebel against the gelphie erasure

[@malifalcon]

Why did I get so upset that Linda and Draco weren’t on this list 😭😭

[@GoodMorningButch]

Oh I fucking hate Linda lmao she’d never be anywhere near the top 100 for me

[@malifalcon]

GoodMorningButch 😂😂 she’s so evilll but that’s why I love herrr 🥺

[@GoodMorningButch]

@@malifalcon Yeah I empathize with Becky way too much to be able to

[@jessicasmith1611]

I love star kids