Tap to unmute

My Two-Pronged Test on Montana Megaliths: Man-Made or Natural?

  Рет қаралды 26,000

Curious Being

Curious Being

Күн бұрын

Пікірлер: 350
@Maxpower50000
@Maxpower50000 Жыл бұрын
Finally, I’ve been waiting for your take on these structures! Always the best, creative and objective perspectives.
@CuriousBeingbyTina
@CuriousBeingbyTina Жыл бұрын
Much appreciated!
@thatcanadianwhitetrashguy
@thatcanadianwhitetrashguy Жыл бұрын
There is a magnetic Test that can tell You if it's man made or not. check my post above@@CuriousBeingbyTina
Жыл бұрын
@@CuriousBeingbyTina Thank you for your detailed work. I don’t know anyone else who researches these things in such a way.
@CuriousBeingbyTina
@CuriousBeingbyTina Жыл бұрын
@ Glad that you find my work helpful 🙂
@montanamegaliths4842
@montanamegaliths4842 Жыл бұрын
@ The conclusions in this video are flawed. The MM have been proved to be ancient authentic intentionally constructed sites by the most advanced technology...satellite deep geoscans and by several experts who have been here with boots on the ground. kzbin.info/door/dFeIhHZdjebI7WPgN-guhQ?app=desktop
@mind-guider
@mind-guider Жыл бұрын
definately one of the best, unbiased and indepth researchers on youtube, you deserve millions of views... keep it up girl you rock ;)
@imonoke7903
@imonoke7903 5 күн бұрын
I believe the problem with views is that she is too much true. Ufo fanatics dont like this reasonable approach and yet people who believe in mainstream knoeledge find this too much. I think so. But i believe this channel will keep groing slowly and gets very committed viewer base
@michaelnorthan5981
@michaelnorthan5981 7 ай бұрын
Excellent content! Well organized, well presented, and very interesting. Very well done!
@CuriousBeingbyTina
@CuriousBeingbyTina 7 ай бұрын
Thank you kindly!
@leppad
@leppad Жыл бұрын
Congratulations on your insightful analysis. I am a geologist and I find it very refreshing that you gave such careful thought to natural versus manmade stone features. You are a keen observer.
@CuriousBeingbyTina
@CuriousBeingbyTina Жыл бұрын
Wow, thank you! I appreciate your support :-)
@peteneblett9344
@peteneblett9344 Жыл бұрын
Youre absolutely right (and your video superb). Several points: 1. I lived next to The Dells for 4 years, climbed that wall you showed untold times, and its natural. And over a billion years old, has sharp GIANT feldspar crystals (multiple scars on my hands, 15 years later), and is amazing enough as is. Just appreciate the rock, people. Which leads me to: 2. There ARE megalithic walls. But going LOOKING for them encourages false identification. Dont give fodder to the sceptics!!! A "maybe" where its a maybe, not "OMG I FOUND ANOTJER WALL!!!". If we call everything vaguely wall-shaped a wall, we destroy our own credibility. 3. Possibility breeds thought, certainty kills it. Certainty 'for' or 'against,' each are equally poisonous to thought. 4. The Flemish Bond! Strongest brick layout, because every vector had been braced. The opposite of stacked grid. And THIS IS YOUR BEST POINT!!!!! The walls of Peru, Lebanon, Anywhere: no joints in a line. Not just the face, but EVERY SIDE of the stone, and yo7 have an earthquake resistant wall. The blocks literaly fall back into place. 5. The reason we have no massive structures is the same reason as Carolina Bays, and the same reason why my current home in Maine is sitting on 250 feet of Canadian soil, hundreds of miles from the border: a series of melts and floods and impacts SO MASSIVE its difficult to imagine. Its why ALL our megafauna (except the Pronghorn) got wiped off the map too. This helps me picture it: Look at Maine, on a map. Imagine the Hudson Bay flowing scross it, depositing sediment. Imagine covering the ENTIRE STATE WITH 300 FEET OF SOIL FROM QUEBEC. Which, basicly , is us. Theres 400 foot deep circular craters offshore here, vertical walls, gaping maws in the silt. In places, the ocean floor looks like Swiss cheese. All from methane generated from the decay of "organic matter" trapped during the floods. Thats a LOT of plants. And animals. And if there WERE a civilization, theyre buried there, too. Sorry to ramble! Ive enjoyed your vids for awhile, and I have to say its very refreshing to see someone else with as much curiosity, as well as logic and skepticism, as myself. Well done.
@chrisstanmore-major5889
@chrisstanmore-major5889 Жыл бұрын
Just up the road from you in Nova Scotia. Great points regarding our geology.
@VenturaIT
@VenturaIT Жыл бұрын
It's the other way around, most of the natural formations are actually man made.
@peteneblett9344
@peteneblett9344 Жыл бұрын
@VenturaIT While I disagree, I'm fully aware that I'm potentially way off, regarding monolithic structures. Just wanted to say it's good to see discourse with respect I really appreciate that. And honestly, I *hope* I'm wrong, haha. If having to eat my words means discovering a vast and advanced ancient civilization, I'll be wrong all day! Take care, bud!
@peteneblett9344
@peteneblett9344 Жыл бұрын
@chrisstanmore-major5889 Hey, a Newfie!!! 😁 Greetings friend! I do love geology. Started with prospecting for gold with my dad in California as a means to an end (where's the gold?), but there's so much cool minerals and gemstoneS, not to mention that every rock is a story. Traveling, place of formation, etc. One of these days I'm going time some tourmaline. And now I'm rambling again, but thanks for saying hi!
@VenturaIT
@VenturaIT Жыл бұрын
@@peteneblett9344 You can do scientific tests on it through Professor Davidovits and they can tell in most cases if it's manmade geopolymer or if it's natural stone... it's not possible to cut stones to fit like that... they've already done scientific tests using electron microscopes and magnetic resonance and other tech to confirm that the pyramid blocks were man made natural stone concrete called geopolymer also the puma punku megaliths... the recipe for the geopolymer is refered to on a nearby stella that talks about baking bread... since it's similar, you need the correct recipe and the correct mixing order and timing, like baking a cake or baking bread... again, it's not possible to get natural stones to look like that and it's not possible to cut stones to fit like that, and it's statistically improbable to have nature crack stones like that... geopolymer natural stone concrete can be made out of almost any natural stone... we are just rediscovering this. You can contact the Geopolymer Institute in France to order their textbooks about the science, they also have a website and videos on KZbin. Once you understand how geopolymers work it's just makes so much sense and you can see how they used it en masse all over the world, like kids used Playdough.
@jeffjeff4477
@jeffjeff4477 Жыл бұрын
Hello 👋 Tina Good vid! Symmetrical shapes, patterns ..... are all around us, naturally occurring in nature, down to the molecular level, ice crystals , crystals, leaves, tissues, rocks, minerals , even slices of metal meteors have incredible patterns. These megaliths are quite certainly natural. Loved seeing the cave , grottos, ancient machine markings at the start... Those were super cool and very good!!!!! Nice T !! Thank You again ⛱️😎
@CuriousBeingbyTina
@CuriousBeingbyTina Жыл бұрын
Good point - thank you Jeff! Have a great weekend :-)
@zanenobbs352
@zanenobbs352 Жыл бұрын
Great to see you on here again! Excellent video on a very intriguing subject. Thank you!
@CuriousBeingbyTina
@CuriousBeingbyTina Жыл бұрын
Glad you enjoyed it! Thank you for the support :-)
@StigTP
@StigTP Жыл бұрын
Denisovan found in Denisova Cave is not far from the Gornaya Shoria megaliths. Does this have a connection?
@CuriousBeingbyTina
@CuriousBeingbyTina Жыл бұрын
That's an interesting thought.
@marcjeffers4229
@marcjeffers4229 Жыл бұрын
The machine marks alone prove that there was a highly advanced global civilization before the flood 🤔
@CuriousBeingbyTina
@CuriousBeingbyTina Жыл бұрын
Yes these machine marks are hard to deny.
@ahrenryan2349
@ahrenryan2349 Жыл бұрын
What scientist says it was made by machines Did that scientist bring a metal detecting microscope
@christopher3d475
@christopher3d475 Жыл бұрын
Those hexagonal columns are in various parts of Washington state. I've seen them many times driving through the area. I've been skeptical of the claims made about the rock forms in Montana being man-made, they look a bit too organic to me. Have you looked into the claimed pyramids of Alaska that are supposed to be half buried in snow/glaciers?
@CuriousBeingbyTina
@CuriousBeingbyTina Жыл бұрын
No I haven't. I'll look them up!
@jean-pascalpillot6540
@jean-pascalpillot6540 7 ай бұрын
Very clever and simple criteria ! Very interesting as allways. Thank you Tina.
@CuriousBeingbyTina
@CuriousBeingbyTina 7 ай бұрын
Glad you enjoyed it! Thank you for watching :-)
@Dutch1954
@Dutch1954 Жыл бұрын
Welcome back, another great examination. I appreciate the way you approach a situation with an open mind. That helps me in my own considerations in this very wide field of ancient times.
@CuriousBeingbyTina
@CuriousBeingbyTina Жыл бұрын
Great to hear!
@jameshaddix4048
@jameshaddix4048 Жыл бұрын
Mother Nature does a good job
@andrewruiz7894
@andrewruiz7894 Жыл бұрын
She sure does. Imagine a glacier, pummeling a megalithic structure. How do you think it would look after? That's the angle I would take. Has anyone done any digging there?
@erikbelloni1502
@erikbelloni1502 Жыл бұрын
At Sage Wall if I’m not mistaken, they found some stone blocks with nobs like in the most popular megalithic sites around the world. To me is man made, also hundreds of thousands of years of erosion may have changed the way the pattern looks. About their functionality, I believe we do not have the specific time reference to understand their purpose. Not Natural to me 😮
@richarddullum2373
@richarddullum2373 Жыл бұрын
This video only shows a very small part of the 275' of the Wall. There could be as many as five or six walls across the top of Sage Mountain, from the drone videos by Mike Collins and others. Sage happens to be still standing. The time aspect you mention is appropriate, in light of some new evidence of humans in N. America. A moccasin-print(size 7) in a 1.2 MYR BP basalt boulder was found in Portland, Oregon. This is real, solid evidence, to be sure. You can see the outline of the fifth metatarsal base. It's private and in a safe. Only modern humans are known to use footwear. I would recommend you look up the Pleistocene Coalition; we have been this into era since 2009.
@Johnrack
@Johnrack Жыл бұрын
Thanks for covering this topic Tina. I’ve only recently become aware of these walls and don’t know much about them.
@CuriousBeingbyTina
@CuriousBeingbyTina Жыл бұрын
Glad that you enjoyed it :-)
@automaticmusicm
@automaticmusicm Жыл бұрын
I've always held the view expressed in this video. Thanks for explaining it in such a concise and logical way. Well done !
@CuriousBeingbyTina
@CuriousBeingbyTina Жыл бұрын
Glad you enjoyed it! Thank you for the support :-)
@erniemajor
@erniemajor Жыл бұрын
It feels like we are still missing something. Which kind of 'man' are we conjecturing in 'man-made' hypothesis? How long ago? How much has the surrounding terrain changed? Beavers can build, birds can build, termites can build. What ELSE might have been capable of building for reasons we are unable to understand.
@NWDestroy
@NWDestroy 7 ай бұрын
sulurians
@WatiSusu
@WatiSusu 6 ай бұрын
Yosep Priyangga Mukti adalah buyut dari Mbah kamituwo Kanimin, Mbah Saminah, Mbah Bonawan, Mbah Suratin, Mbah Diran, Mbah Moniah, Mbah Lasirah, Mbah Marso. Yosep Priyangga Mukti adalah canggah dari Mbah Kerto Lesono, Mbah Sungkem, Mbah Dirah, Mbah Sodimedjo, Mbah Karjo dimedjo, Mbah Rasinah, Mbah Surokarjo, Mbah Siyam, Mbah Markiteng, Mbah Menthik, Mbah Iro Medjo, mbah waginah binti sonto medjo, Mbah Baniyah, Mbah Tokromo, Joyo Japan, Sukinah. Yosep Priyangga Mukti adalah Wareng dari Mbah Joi Kromo, Mbah Manis, Mbah Soikromo, Mbah Katinah, Mbah Gendhu, Mbah Kaminem, Mbah Nadi, lurah sutokaryo, lurah sorejo, eyang karangjati, sonto medjo, joyokromosapi, mertodrono. Udheg udheg dari palang kromokaryo, merto dropo, ponco blimbing. Gantung siwur dari bagus sudarmadji ketok jenggot.
@imonoke7903
@imonoke7903 3 күн бұрын
Aliens
@donnysandley4649
@donnysandley4649 Жыл бұрын
Great video Tina 💯
@CuriousBeingbyTina
@CuriousBeingbyTina Жыл бұрын
Thank you 😁
@esotericist
@esotericist Жыл бұрын
another very interesting video. thanks Tina.
@craigcampbell6690
@craigcampbell6690 Жыл бұрын
Hi Tina... wandering wolf has done a few videos in Montana..The things is , there are megalithic Knobs on some.. maybe built by Neanderthals ,or an extinct species or Sasquatch..maybe they were built 250 thousand years ago, or more . Glaciers might have taken some other stuff away. Brien Foerster just shared megalithic polygonal walls from Easter Island.... once again, the joints are perfect..why were they built 🤔.. the Amount of work that was put into the Inca Trail (Peru) is amazing And , Machu Picchu & Sacsayhuaman are Beyond Incredible... Why so much work ???.. ALIEN'S👽😎.. maybe🙂
@standingbear998
@standingbear998 Жыл бұрын
complete BS. the 'joints' are not perfect. so 'bigfoot' went from building these to building nothing?
@CuriousBeingbyTina
@CuriousBeingbyTina Жыл бұрын
Thank you Craig. I think the knobs might be concretions or other natural geological features.
@JeremyLeighton
@JeremyLeighton Жыл бұрын
It also appears they go much deeper underground
@PatriotPaul759
@PatriotPaul759 Жыл бұрын
Thanks for your video.
@velaknap
@velaknap Жыл бұрын
You are so logical, pragmatic and scientific in your analysis. Your channel is always usefully informative.
@cmoorejack
@cmoorejack 8 ай бұрын
Great video and presentation…keep up the good works 👍✌️
@CuriousBeingbyTina
@CuriousBeingbyTina 8 ай бұрын
Thank you! Will do :-)
@birdywi5924
@birdywi5924 Жыл бұрын
As the Videos from Wandering Wulf show, there are a lot of machine marks, perfect holes and nobs. Also, the wall is absolutely(!) straight built - and its MAGNETIC like the stones from Tuma Puncu. No way this wall is made by nature. Regarding the time frame, we should have a look in history, when glacers covered the area. This gives another hint why a) the stones seem to be much elder than their counterparts e.g. from the Eastern Islands and Peru and b) why the whole area is covered with megalith stones without a similar structure.
@mikeC8756
@mikeC8756 Жыл бұрын
Great analysis and great t-shirt Tina!
@mikeC8756
@mikeC8756 Жыл бұрын
How about the Gosford Glyphs? I think we all need your analysis on those soon! Ancient Egyptian or not?
@CuriousBeingbyTina
@CuriousBeingbyTina Жыл бұрын
I'll do some digging :-) Thank you Michael!
@mikeC8756
@mikeC8756 Жыл бұрын
Thanks Tina, you made my day!
@pebbleoverpond
@pebbleoverpond Жыл бұрын
Do we see these formations coming in various geological timescale, or are they specific to a certain time period
@johndelong5574
@johndelong5574 Жыл бұрын
Scoop and trowel marks found at various megalithic sites, indicte the stone was still soft before petrfication occured.
@Cardioid2035
@Cardioid2035 Жыл бұрын
I think about this observation all the time tbh
@Cardioid2035
@Cardioid2035 Жыл бұрын
Something deep in my intuition tells me there once was megalithic structures in North America before the younger dryas period. I think we don’t find megaliths in North America today due to the ice sheets scrapping a layer of the landscape clean off and depositing everything down near the scablands or adjacent oceans on either side of the continent. It’s nothing more than a feeling but it’s a strong one
@macgonzo
@macgonzo Жыл бұрын
How old was the North American ice sheet? More than 2.5 million years. Early humans hadn't even left Africa at this time! Your claims cannot be true.
@Cardioid2035
@Cardioid2035 Жыл бұрын
@@macgonzo Well based on oral tradition and certain mythologies from aboriginal people located near/ around megalithic stone works near Mexico all the way down to Peru they claim certain sacred places inhabited by their ancestors where ‘discovered’. Or built by the ‘gods’. These stories are more common in Peru in places like sacsayhuaman. So every time I see multi-ton, interlocking, mortarless polygonal stone masonry globally sharing undeniably similar characteristics I can’t help but sense such masonry is indicative of a time when perhaps humanity was in fact globalized in pre-history. This polygonal masonry in question is found in Mexico, Egypt, Turkey, Italy, Polynesia, Japan Etc… Everywhere except North America. Given that we cannot satisfactorily replicate such feats of megalithic architecture to an exactitude even today, it really does infer a pre-younger dryas chapter of humanity lost to time. So that’s why I deeply believe there’s likely heavily eroded megalithic masonry under layers of sediment at the bottom of the oceans on either side of the North American continent. Or… basically the type of stuff we see in Saskatchewan and Montana
@andrewbarlow8937
@andrewbarlow8937 Жыл бұрын
Hello Tina . Great job. I enjoy you videos. Keep up the good work. ❤
@CuriousBeingbyTina
@CuriousBeingbyTina Жыл бұрын
Thank you! I appreciate your support :-)
@Slavigrad
@Slavigrad Жыл бұрын
Hi Tina, as always great analysis! Great topic 🙂
@CuriousBeingbyTina
@CuriousBeingbyTina Жыл бұрын
Thank you so much🙂
@jimmyrox8835
@jimmyrox8835 Жыл бұрын
Excellent video as always,! Tbh , I've been skeptical of the Montana megaliths for a while now. . I just learned about the, Megalithic Monuments of New York // Balanced rock at North Salem // Stone Chambers of Putnam County. Not your typical megalithic sites , but interesting all the same. There are definitely ancient structure's in America at the sites I listed in this comment though.
@CuriousBeingbyTina
@CuriousBeingbyTina Жыл бұрын
Thanks for sharing! I have passed by a big dolmen at North Salem - very interesting indeed.
@DerekFrazier2014
@DerekFrazier2014 Жыл бұрын
Your test make complete since. Another stupendous job.
@CuriousBeingbyTina
@CuriousBeingbyTina Жыл бұрын
Thanks a lot Derek! Much appreciated :-)
@MB-hx9sz
@MB-hx9sz Жыл бұрын
You're probably right but on the Montana site you can also find drillholes which are not recently made
@finnmccool4943
@finnmccool4943 Жыл бұрын
Great video!
@mickit7978
@mickit7978 Жыл бұрын
great points. i look forward to your next research project
@charlieparker6813
@charlieparker6813 Жыл бұрын
Very educational, thanks for you input on this very complicated issue, great video.
@CuriousBeingbyTina
@CuriousBeingbyTina Жыл бұрын
Glad you enjoyed it :-) Thank you for watching.
@jimhackman5184
@jimhackman5184 Жыл бұрын
Thank you, always brilliant.
@CuriousBeingbyTina
@CuriousBeingbyTina Жыл бұрын
Thank you!
@scotthcomyns3426
@scotthcomyns3426 Жыл бұрын
I've built a few stone walls in my time,your comparison of structural integrity looks rock solid to me.
@CuriousBeingbyTina
@CuriousBeingbyTina Жыл бұрын
Thank you!
@kananaskiscountry8191
@kananaskiscountry8191 Жыл бұрын
thank u Tina, hope everything has been going great for u. thank u for coming back on 🌹🌹👍🏼👍🏼🎶🎶
@CuriousBeingbyTina
@CuriousBeingbyTina Жыл бұрын
Thanks for listening :-) I hope all is well with you too!
@robertminor9297
@robertminor9297 Жыл бұрын
Another brilliant analysis, truly insightful, logical and very persuasive.
@CuriousBeingbyTina
@CuriousBeingbyTina Жыл бұрын
Thank you very much for the support :-)
@tucker5068
@tucker5068 7 ай бұрын
One day the world will see your greatness. Keep up the great out of the box thinking
@CuriousBeingbyTina
@CuriousBeingbyTina 7 ай бұрын
Interesting - thank you for sharing with me.
@davidvomlehn4495
@davidvomlehn4495 Жыл бұрын
Nice--a clearly stated and pretty objective framework for classifying rock assemblages. Worth applying in other areas, as well. The load bearing part of the test doesn't directly apply to non-load bearing features such as the Bimini "road", but even roads must follow certain patterns if they are to last.
@richardliles4415
@richardliles4415 Жыл бұрын
I find your two prong system quite compelling. Thank you Tina.
@CuriousBeingbyTina
@CuriousBeingbyTina Жыл бұрын
Thank you :-)
@andrewruiz7894
@andrewruiz7894 Жыл бұрын
That looks like a giant wall of ice pummeled a megalithic structure. Imagine
@someoneoutthere1866
@someoneoutthere1866 8 ай бұрын
Great analysis 😊
@CuriousBeingbyTina
@CuriousBeingbyTina 8 ай бұрын
Thanks!
@islandmonusvi
@islandmonusvi Жыл бұрын
Logically…discovery of a unique polygonal natural wall could inspire ancient builders to disassemble the structure top-down …trim the blocks during transport …and subsequently reassemble them bottom-up …as required.
@CuriousBeingbyTina
@CuriousBeingbyTina Жыл бұрын
That's a good point.
@davidperkins2103
@davidperkins2103 Жыл бұрын
Don't know about these structures but I love that tee shirt you are wearing. Great video . As always thanks.
@keithhowell4138
@keithhowell4138 Жыл бұрын
There are walls around Angkor Wat that have continuous vertical jointing ,,much have fallen but much is still there ,, It amazed me they were built that way instead of overlapping joints like in modern brickwork ,,
@Keopp69
@Keopp69 10 ай бұрын
7:28 It is Devil's Lake WISCONSIN in Sauk county. The Indians called it 'Spirit Lake' and was interpreted as bad, or devil by the white explorers.
@cwest394
@cwest394 Жыл бұрын
Plenty in the northeast. Giant stone rooms that have been buried by trees and dirt. They called them root cellers. Giant mounds everywhere. Snake mound. May not be stone but seriously impressive. Most megalithic sites were destroyed by early settlers to make houses and fence rows. Astronomical tower. Somewhere in north east America. Giant rock 60 ft square sitting in the middle of the Maine woods. No one can explain how it got there. Problem with America is that is much much older than people realize. The Appalachian mountains used to be taller than the Himalayas.
@chrisfleming701
@chrisfleming701 Жыл бұрын
If early settlers could move the stones then they probably weren’t megaliths. Unless you think they had the same capabilities?
@awalk56
@awalk56 Жыл бұрын
Great video, well done.
@CuriousBeingbyTina
@CuriousBeingbyTina Жыл бұрын
Thanks for the visit.
@johndelong5574
@johndelong5574 Жыл бұрын
Post flood sediment, (all sedimentary rock is a result of global flood) remained soft enough to carve record of preflood events including ark motifs inverted boat hull (lotus flower). Petrification turned these shrines to stone that is harder than copper tools.
@SeaLevel211
@SeaLevel211 Жыл бұрын
global flood? LOL, you cannot be serious. The earth is not a globe. there is NO QUESTION that the Holy Spirit authors of Scripture believed in a stationary, circular, flat Earth, set on pillars, under a dome, within which the sun, moon and stars were placed on Day 4. Even highly respected Biblical scholars and Ancient Near Eastern language experts and historians agree (whether they personally believe in it or not) that this is an indisputable fact. Only those who are not being intellectually honest with the text (and themselves) will disagree. Like it or not - accept it or not - the Bible IS a Flat Earth book. Yet, we are constantly shown impressive "signs and wonders" that are "in the heavens" coming from antichrist organizations like NASA, which directly contradict the Biblical model.
@bialy100k
@bialy100k 7 ай бұрын
Clever pronged criteria, I love approach :)
@CuriousBeingbyTina
@CuriousBeingbyTina 7 ай бұрын
Thank you :-)
@westho7314
@westho7314 7 ай бұрын
Existing natural design elements in so many forms are undoubtably the original inspiration for the advent/invent in creating concepts of geometry leading to reproduction of element design incorporated into both construction methods & cosmetic embellishment. Studying the natural fissures found in massive remnants of exposed granitic cores of solid batholithes, grabens and other more layered sedimentry rock that's often layed down in consistent symmetrical layers & fractures often at right angles that seem to be deliberate or human made. It' as simple as something like the pedals of a flower could have been the original visual inspiration for the spokes of a wheel.
@cosmoray9750
@cosmoray9750 Жыл бұрын
👍Excellent analysis.
@CuriousBeingbyTina
@CuriousBeingbyTina Жыл бұрын
Thank you kindly!
@danontherun5685
@danontherun5685 Жыл бұрын
She must read everything 24/7, in any case wonderfully concise but easy to understand diction.
@novacadian4745
@novacadian4745 8 ай бұрын
Would Machu Picchu pass your test #1? Your comparisons of natural to constructed, with attention to stacking styles, helped give me a better understanding of the subject. Thanks!
@drhexagonapus
@drhexagonapus 5 ай бұрын
Have you seen the knobs photographed at the montana megalithic site? I agree most of it looks natural but those knobs make me think there may be some artificial influence. Same for gornaya shoriya, most of it looks quite natural but a few pictures seem to show those protrusions common at other megalithic sites. I wish I could go to these places and see them in person, it is so hard to make such a call purely from photographs.
@Archaeonauts
@Archaeonauts Жыл бұрын
Thanks for the analysis on this! I saw the Montana megaliths recently but hadn't really looked into them. But I looked into Gornaya Shoria some time a while back and basically came to the same conclusions you did about it. It looks manmade in certain spots from certain angles, but if you zoom out and look at more of it, it doesn't really look manmade, and doesn't seem to serve a purpose. It looks like that's probably the same kind of thing we are seeing with the Montana megaliths.
@CuriousBeingbyTina
@CuriousBeingbyTina Жыл бұрын
Thank you for sharing with me :-)
@toni4729
@toni4729 Жыл бұрын
We know that stones have been carved weighing more than a thousand tones and moved distances in history. No one knows how this has been done. Until some excavation of many of these sites are done, we will never prove it, one way or the other. Where, for instance did all the stones of the pyramids come from and how were they assembled? It will remain a mystery for a long time.
@mrhassell
@mrhassell 7 ай бұрын
The Kaimanawa Wall, located near the southern end of Lake Taupo in New Zealand, is an intriguing structure. Composed of megalithic blocks with symmetrical corners, it's puzzled scientists and historians. Some even have speculated, this might be evidence of a pre-Māori civilization. However, the truth is in fact less mysterious: the wall is a natural phenomenon. The blocks are fractures having formed over 330,000 years, which began as the rocks cooled, and is a continuing process that can be observed. They look like somebody had purposefully built them but looks can be deceptive, as we all know.
@ideagora37
@ideagora37 Жыл бұрын
Very informative and convincing Tina. Thanks for getting it out so quickly after your last one. Your architectural and engineering education shows. It's nice to see a well researched and balanced video on the subject of ancient megaliths in an age where only sensationalism seems to sell. There are plenty of ancient megalithic monuments in the world, but as you definitively make the point, not all are man made. Will you do one on Puma Punku someday? I'd love to get your analysis on it and maybe make some architectural sense of it. Maybe even an analysis of the possible cause of its destruction. You're doing great work. I hope more people support you on Patreon! Ken S.
@montanamegaliths4842
@montanamegaliths4842 Жыл бұрын
Megalithic sites all over the world were constructed over gold and precious mineral sites. Many at the headwaters of major river systems and on earth energy grid lines. The Montana Megaliths fits all of this criteria. Satellite deep geoscans have veriifed the authenticity of these ancient structures. kzbin.info/door/dFeIhHZdjebI7WPgN-guhQ?app=desktop
@anthonystark6372
@anthonystark6372 Жыл бұрын
Hi Tina. Nice video. Have you ever researched the hexagonal pathways of The Giant's Causeway in Northern Ireland? When I was a school boy back in the 80's I visited a friend who lived close to the site. We walked along the paths and it was amazing to see these hexagonal formations. Legend tells that it was the Irish giant Finn MacCool who built the pathway to travel to Scotland to fight his Scottish giant foe. Not sure about that bit though. LOL Still, it is certainly something to see. Keep up the good work. Chris. x
@vulpesvulpes5177
@vulpesvulpes5177 Жыл бұрын
Let’s call this “Tina’s’ dichotomous key for the identification and verification of megalithic structures”. I agree with you. Natural. Moreover, all the existing man made megaliths occur in areas that were not subject to glaciation at the last maxima. We must recall that at the last glacial maximum a two mile thick sheet of ice extended about half way down North America. This would cover Montana and all of Canada. Such moving ice would leave nothing in its path standing. The same is true in Europe. So the existing megaliths occur only in areas not covered by ice. Presuming that these are so old as to predate the younger dryas. If, as is believed, these are newer, coming after the younger dryas, then population distribution or the lack thereof supports a natural phenomenon. The ice overburden also provides a mechanism for the fracturing process you point to, known as elastic dynamic fracturing of bedrock. Geologically speaking slower tectonic forces fold bedrock and result in the metamorphic rock type know to geology with its pressure folded rather than fractured nature. Imagination seems to set us apart from the other creatures. But sometimes we get carried away with our imagination. Someone has to pull us back to terra firma. Today that someone is you. Lucky us! Fox out
@CuriousBeingbyTina
@CuriousBeingbyTina Жыл бұрын
Great points Fox. Well said! You have a wonderful evening :-)
@vulpesvulpes5177
@vulpesvulpes5177 Жыл бұрын
@@CuriousBeingbyTina In the fur trade a foxes ears were referred to as “points”. Somehow I suspect you were not complimenting my handsome ears, but rather the content of my comment. One test of “intelligence” is how much someone agrees with your opinion. You may color me a “clever fellow”. Seriously, have yourself a pleasant evening as well. NFTATT Fox out
@CuriousBeingbyTina
@CuriousBeingbyTina Жыл бұрын
@@vulpesvulpes5177 You are indeed a "clever fellow!"
@armanasaintclair8962
@armanasaintclair8962 Жыл бұрын
Amazing video ❤
@CuriousBeingbyTina
@CuriousBeingbyTina Жыл бұрын
Thank you 😀
@AgelessRock888
@AgelessRock888 Жыл бұрын
Good research🧐. Good argument 🤓. But I think if it is flat on the ground, it is very likely natural. But a wall is a wall. Megalithic walls are all over the world. It is neither manmade nor natural, that's why it is still a mystery.
@DuckDodgers69
@DuckDodgers69 Жыл бұрын
I appreciate the information
@ricksanchez3176
@ricksanchez3176 Жыл бұрын
You have some very valid points, and there are many cases of natural being claimed man made. And the other way too. Not too troll, I'm not a geologist either, simply to discuss. Sincerely neither of the two criteria exclude man made, individually, or combined. As for purpose. Of the "seven wonders of the ancient world", massive constructions, yet only one had a known function other than ceremonial or power projection. Add to that changing geology, topography, climate, sea levels, and fresh water drainage. Plus the rise and fall of area populations locally due to the aforementioned, and all the social reasons. There are canal projects, harbors, fortresses, walls we can grasp the purpose for, but we do not understand many, if not most. As for the durability, the continuous joints, that's a great point, and it does near exclude some. The problem is that if something is standing after eons, whether the hand of God or the hand of man put it there, it was constructed with durability. Montana is a vast state, bigger than many countries. You have many pictures of the Sage "wall" located in Montana labeled as the "Montana Magaliths", (Giant's playground). They are two very distinctive sites. The Sage wall I'd lean towards artificial, while MM I'd lean towards natural, with possibly a bit of human tweaking. As for not being a geologist, those of that profession have identified much of Puma Punku as Andecite, yet it contains biological material when spectrographed. I enjoyed the video as always. Thank you.
@anasevi9456
@anasevi9456 Жыл бұрын
Thank you for your wonderful overview on the matter as always. Always glad to see an educator looking to take a class through a journey of likelihood, rather than a narrative.
@norrinradd8952
@norrinradd8952 Жыл бұрын
Amazing commentary on this subject. This is the best video I have watched regarding this location, hands down. I have a simple test myself for a structure like this. It is a rock. If there is no other evidence, then it can be nothing more than a rock. The only evidence that exists for this being a man-made structure is that it does indeed appear to look like a wall. At least portions of it. But, that's where the evidence ends. There are many videos surrounding the idea that this is a man-made structure, but they completely avoid the evidence that it is indeed a naturally formed structure. Not only do they ignore the idea that perhaps it is just a rock, they disregard many of the points you made in this video. Your test covers what I think is one of the most important criteria of answering the question of, why? You hit the nail on the head with, what is the purpose? That question leads us down the path of additional questions. What evidence exists of its function, the builders, how it was built and when? Without any evidence to satisfy any of these questions, we are left with only one piece of evidence again. It is just a rock. It never occurred to me to consider intentional structural integrity, or as you pointed out, the lack thereof. I believe this is a logical, intelligent follow up to the first part of your test. Absolutely brilliant. Again, well done.
@CuriousBeingbyTina
@CuriousBeingbyTina Жыл бұрын
Thank you very much for the support. I really appreciate it :-)
@andrewdavidson5209
@andrewdavidson5209 7 ай бұрын
Again you are correct Montana megaliths etc are natural...... climbed those in Cornwall as a kid..... drove Dad mad !! Ha ha ha. I LOVE your 2 criteria Superb, so simple Andrew
@aynrandish9106
@aynrandish9106 10 ай бұрын
You are very smart! Thank you for the interesting analysis.
@CuriousBeingbyTina
@CuriousBeingbyTina 10 ай бұрын
Glad you liked it. Hope you will enjoy my other videos too!
@Li_Ao
@Li_Ao Жыл бұрын
Clear logic and correlated to your previous videos.
@CuriousBeingbyTina
@CuriousBeingbyTina Жыл бұрын
Thank you! :-)
@BionAvastar3000
@BionAvastar3000 Жыл бұрын
Your hair looks amazing!
@A_Bone1972
@A_Bone1972 Жыл бұрын
hello my beautiful friend Tina. each new post of your work, especially your methods, give a feeling of being more & more refined. on subjects such as this, sometimes i like to think about the expression to think outside the box. i've always questioned why does there have to be a box. using this perspective reminds me of the human nature of describing something unknown to us by using comparisons of resemblance to things known. combine to this mindset to consider the source that claims a fact. what i'm getting at is that without knowing if these formations share a continuity of which direction magnetic north among the frequencies of each rock, or some other verifiable method supporting a naturally occurring process, how would we know that the structure we now see that we're being told are of rocks that are millions of years old aren't the remnants of a megalithic structure after enduring all of the erosion, chataclysmic events, and planetary changes both known & unknown that have occurred in such a time span? the more what once were stated facts from mainstream academia are proven not to be true the more i question the validity of what remaining facts put forth by mainstream academia are based to be proven from. somewhat akin to is the concept of gravity a proven fact, or a misunderstanding of our relationship to how we feel the force of Earth as it spins at a wobble while orbiting the sun as well as being part of a solar system that is constantly moving in a spiral through the vacuum of space? one might even ask did this comment become a rant, or did it inspire food for thought? much 💗 ✌️🐝➕
@finnmccool4943
@finnmccool4943 Жыл бұрын
These are definitely natural. I live in Montana, these geologic formations are all over the place. My kids play on them all the time.
@CuriousBeingbyTina
@CuriousBeingbyTina Жыл бұрын
Thak you for the information!
@ahrenryan2349
@ahrenryan2349 Жыл бұрын
Probably made from ice and glaciers
@Mr.Paul_Revere
@Mr.Paul_Revere Жыл бұрын
Shiprock wall in new Mexico is polygonal. that wall i believe is miles long with some areas 3 plus stories high.
@stig
@stig Жыл бұрын
I can show you a bunch of megalithic terraforming activity throughout North America all along the colorado river and the continental divide both. Trust Me.
@rodanone4895
@rodanone4895 6 ай бұрын
to answer 1: what if these walls are highways between continental areas? this transitions from north to south. agree that it could be natural but. the videos that have been posted recently show the "nubs" seemingly. I'd love to see you go there and pick it apart live. maccu picu also almost fails the cost benefit analysis too. we assume it was for "defense", correct? what if sage wall was a trade route? I've seen that argument made. also IF the younger dryas and north American fire, flooding evidence is accurate a great deal of large, violent damage occured in North America.... curious! thanks again for your content! it is fun and extremely grounded. you're like a Christopher Dunn pallet cleanser. 😅
@mikekaye7922
@mikekaye7922 Жыл бұрын
When I first saw some of those photos, especially Gornia Shoria(sp) Russia I thought they could be Megalethic, but somewhat degraded because they were even more ancient. But after seeing more photos, somewhat later, I determined they were natural. It hurts the argument for advanced civilization with academics when people take advantage of the appearance in a few photographs to suggest a naturally occurring formation is actually a man made structure. Nice work on the video.
@reesebroekhoven3962
@reesebroekhoven3962 Жыл бұрын
Awe that was such a great attempt at saying Saskatchewan with you accent. I'm Canadian and its a extremely tough one to say so great job at a great attempt!
@carlrichards5207
@carlrichards5207 14 күн бұрын
Excellent presentation. I think the ice sheets scraped away the North American sites.
@machinethesun9243
@machinethesun9243 Жыл бұрын
Things don't make sense if you look at them through today's criteria and lens. There's all kinds of ancient structures on top of remote mountain tops that seem impossible to build and pointless if you look at it from today's concerns.
@belavarplaniie8933
@belavarplaniie8933 Жыл бұрын
Agreed
@ashleytilling3257
@ashleytilling3257 Жыл бұрын
Tina, please look into the stone wall structures in Texas and also africa. They are from more recent civilizations but may be explained by geologic origins.
@DougBartlett-gb7ws
@DougBartlett-gb7ws Жыл бұрын
We have something similar in NEW BRUNSWICK CANADA HOW CAN WE GET SOME ONE TO LOOK AT IT
@peekaboopeekaboo1165
@peekaboopeekaboo1165 Жыл бұрын
Another fantastic subject matter . 👏👍
@CuriousBeingbyTina
@CuriousBeingbyTina Жыл бұрын
Thank you for the support :-)
@walterblanc9708
@walterblanc9708 Жыл бұрын
I do not see how anyone can see those Montana Megaliths as man made. Thankyou for another very interesting Video.
@cloudydaycauldron
@cloudydaycauldron Жыл бұрын
It’s easy to believe something is beyond natural when it simply is what it is. Great starting point. As far as function these could have been adapted for human use, like any cave or other natural structure.
@criticalthinkingtryit
@criticalthinkingtryit 2 ай бұрын
i agree with you all the way thru on this one.
@CuriousBeingbyTina
@CuriousBeingbyTina 2 ай бұрын
Glad to hear that :-)
@ppono
@ppono Жыл бұрын
Have you watched No forest on earth English version? Quite an eye opener if you decide to. Excellent video you made. Thank you!
@joedegoff1430
@joedegoff1430 Жыл бұрын
Well done.
@EvolvedWizard
@EvolvedWizard 8 ай бұрын
Rockwall, Texas?
@waynehall9939
@waynehall9939 Жыл бұрын
I love common sense. SO, what about the knobs on these megalithic structures in montana??
@CuriousBeingbyTina
@CuriousBeingbyTina Жыл бұрын
I think they might be concretions or other natural geological features.
@markkilley2683
@markkilley2683 Жыл бұрын
Water, weathering, pressure?
@toni4729
@toni4729 Жыл бұрын
I've never heard of Yangshan Quarry, at least I don't remember ever hearing about it. Is that one rock, that man is standing on?
@CuriousBeingbyTina
@CuriousBeingbyTina Жыл бұрын
There are three gigantic blocks - I made two videos on the Yangshan Quarry; hope you will find them interesting: World’s Largest Monolith: Yangshan Monument Created by a Lost Ancient Civilization? kzbin.info/www/bejne/iYGYg6qIoNChaM0 Tool Marks on Yangshan Monument Match Modern Machine Marks kzbin.info/www/bejne/apq9haWVj690a8k
@toni4729
@toni4729 Жыл бұрын
@@CuriousBeingbyTina Thank you, I'll find them.
@joshadsett4835
@joshadsett4835 Жыл бұрын
nice one
@sbkarajan
@sbkarajan Жыл бұрын
What do you think of the walls in Spain, shown by vlad9vt? I think these walls were constructed by humans, and then natural events, such as melting the rock, happened later.
@CuriousBeingbyTina
@CuriousBeingbyTina Жыл бұрын
There are tool marks on these blocks (5:10, 6:27 and more) so the wall is man-made. To me the man-made part seems to be the patching work for the natural rock.
@citizenguy
@citizenguy Жыл бұрын
At 15:38 aren't there Aztec megaliths in Mexico?
@CuriousBeingbyTina
@CuriousBeingbyTina Жыл бұрын
Those are not the same as the advanced megalithic sites with machine marks (such as Petra - kzbin.info/www/bejne/hnTKlYl3fdiEldk, or Longyou Caves - kzbin.info/www/bejne/p6KYg2uuZ56BiKc) or very precise conjoining lines with giant blocks (such as at Sacsayhuaman - kzbin.info/www/bejne/rmq2ZXanjpiYiaM)
@jamesn.economou9922
@jamesn.economou9922 Жыл бұрын
Never once, did you recognize that this place built on a geo-magnetic hot spot. Could these structures, have been collectors, and amplifiers of such power? I believe this is the case. I believe it, because all the ancient Mesopotamian, Indian, and Egyptian texts, tell us, that granite stone blocks, where used to transfer energy. We modern people, just can't believe, the ancients could do, what we cannot. It's sad really.
Attempting 1,000 Mile Traverse in Arizona's Backcountry
30:06
TrailRecon
Рет қаралды 49 М.
Closest Look Ever at How Pyramids Were Built
18:26
History for GRANITE
Рет қаралды 2,9 МЛН
Арыстанның айқасы, Тәуіржанның шайқасы!
25:51
QosLike / ҚосЛайк / Косылайық
Рет қаралды 700 М.
Каха и дочка
00:28
К-Media
Рет қаралды 3,4 МЛН
Tuna 🍣 ​⁠@patrickzeinali ​⁠@ChefRush
00:48
albert_cancook
Рет қаралды 148 МЛН
Mysterious Knobs at Ancient Megalithic Sites - Molded or Quarried?
24:06
Pre-Historic Mega Structure Discovered in Montana, USA - Sage Wall
21:05
Universe Inside You
Рет қаралды 2,8 МЛН
How Japanese Polygonal Megalithic Walls Differ from those in Peru
21:07
Lost Ancient Technology: The Colossal Statues of Ancient Egypt
56:27
Gunung Padang: the Oldest Pyramid? Facts Revealed!
23:51
Curious Being
Рет қаралды 8 М.
How were the Perplexing Giza Pyramids' Granite Blocks Created?
18:38
Mystery Solved on the Purpose of Longyou Caves
12:37
Curious Being
Рет қаралды 164 М.
Egyptian Pyramids: Prehistoric Mine Remnant?
20:04
Curious Being
Рет қаралды 9 М.