My Version - Peanut Butter Pie

My version of Peanut Butter Pie does not contain Coolwhip.
Here are the ingredients:
The crust
14.3 ounce pack of Oreo Cookies with sugar removed from 2/3 of the pack
1/2 cup melted butter
Filling and toppings
16 ounces whipping cream, very cold
2 cups confectionary sugar
8 ounces cream cheese at room temperature
1 cup Jiff natural creamy peanut butter
1 1/2 teaspoons vanilla extract
1/2 cup milk chocolate morsels
2 tablespoons milk
1/2 cup freeze dried salted peanuts, rough chopped
Cut pie into 8 equal pieces to equal 11.25 grams of protein per slice.
SEE VIDEO FOR MIXING INSTRUCTIONS.
The pie crust is baked for 10 minutes in a 350 degree preheated oven then cooled so that it will hold together better when sliced.
This pie freezes very well.
Thanks for watching.
My website southernfrugal.com

[@emmadalrymple4102]

My dear Phyllis, this must have been decadent! Your recipes and videos never ate, and I will never tire of watching your channel. RIP dear lady. You are missed!

[@carolekinsey7835]

I miss Miss Phyllis and her tutorials....but thankfully she made so many. Now I look and find ones that I've not watched. It's almost like she's still here and still posting. I truly love peanut butter, so I'm sure this is a winning recipe. (for those that like peanuts.) x Long live the memory of our Miss Phyllis. X

[@melodycapehartmedina2264]

Well over the last few day I have watched all 36 of your desert video's while it has poured rain outside. I just enjoyed them thoroughly. I have always cooked and baked from scratch and I just loved watching you do the same. It was just like being in the kitchen with my mom and Aunts, lots of memories came back. Thank you so much for sharing your time, tips and humor.

[@Jennifer-qo4kz]

love this recipe miss Phyllis. my family just loves peanut butter and oreos. ☺ thank you for being so thorough with your videos. explaining steps and all. another reason that makes them so enjoyable to watch.

[@annahorton650]

This is my all time favorite pie. I like it after it sits for a day in fridge. I'm telling you....I'd eat that whole pie. Hugs

[@ritar.hallburleson9505]

This does look delicious.... I especially like the peanut butter mixture, along with the Toppings of fresh beaten creamwhip and chocolate drizzle with crunchy peanuts.. Bone apetit... You share frugal ways... Stories are homespun yet professional that truly teaches Online...

[@vivianctk]

Thank you Phyllis for this delicious recipe, it's on my list of things to try. I bake and cook all my food from scratch.......my mother was an excellent teacher. Once every other week I would cook my version of sloppy Joe's for our family of six. They make chocolate graham crackers, FYI.

[@rebeccanewland2886]

That is such a good looking dessert! I bet it tastes even better. Will be making this for sure, thank you for the recipe, Phyliss.

[@ou7124]

I made this today and it was so good! Thank you so much for these videos. I enjoy your recipes so much and your stories.

[@indialukeluke690]

I really miss my daily visits with Ms Phyllis & Mr. Bucky! Thank you Connell for continuing their legacy going. They were my personal friends I never met. We had many days of coffee and conversation, right at my kitchen table. The "Real Life" stories ,recipes & cooking,, shopping, walks, pets, and mountain visits.... we all went together. Missing my friends, now they are on their forever journey. Connell, thank you, I so enjoy your family journey adventures.

[@blancaw6280]

I made this last night. It was very delish! The only thing was I didn't have any milk chocolate for the topping so I used semi sweet. That was a mistake definitely need the milk chocolate. I ended up scraping that part off. Thanks for the great recipe! Going to freeze the rest as you suggested and pulling a slice out here and there.

[@moblackbird]

That looks wonderfully scrummy! I make one similar to that, only I use a regular cooked peanut pie filling and a premade oreo crust. I've always used the cool-whip, but this looks so much better that I will do it your way next time. I do love a peanut butter pie with a cooked filling and meringue, though. Really good either way!

[@heeltapsgm]

Ms. Phyllis , I am trying my first peanut butter pie . However , I grabbed a ready made crust from the store. I put the cream in the freezer and forgot it so I had to thaw in the microwave. It still worked other than the whipping cream and the crust , I had everything on hand. After watching you demonstrate it several times , I felt qualified , if not compelled to try. My pie is in the freezer. Not as pretty as yours ,but i think Mr. Jerry will like it . I plan to serve it to him for his mid - morning snack tomorrow . thank you for sharing your wisdom , your stories , and your precious Mr. Bucky with us , dear heart . I know your loss is great , but the LORD is with you! Peace. your friend Gina

[@cheshkat6321]

I've been planning to make those buttery tartlets of yours for a few days. Still haven't done so yet because I was trying to think of a good filling for them. However, I made a custard pie last night that had to be "improved" with whipped cream and fruit to have for brunch today. I made my whipped cream much like yours, except I used just a couple tablespoons of sugar. I was sitting here thinking I need to use that whipped cream in something tomorrow because it has been tempting me to eat it all day. (Nevermind the fact that I gave in and had a little custard with a heap of whipped cream just a few minutes ago!) Homemade is definitely the BEST. I have an excess of peanut butter and have spent most of the day looking up peanut butter pie recipes. Most of them seem to have a chocolate crust and chocolate topping. I've almost decided I'd like to make it with vegan whipped cream for something different. (Made with coconut milk or coconut cream.) And then using Keebler's pecan sandies for the crust. Then drizzling caramel and chopped pecans on the top. Because I LOVE pecans, in case you couldn't tell. Sound good? I'll let you know how it tastes. But I'm probably going to be dreaming about your peanut butter pie until I get mine made. You really had me nearly falling over when you tasted it and said you weren't going to tell us how good it is. My imagination took over then and that's when I had to pause the video and have some custard drowned in whipped cream. If I make a double batch of that peanut butter filling, I could have enough for a pie and filling up some of those tartlets for taking to friends.

[@lauradiem6905]

Miss Phyllis..That peanut butter pie looks so yummy! I'm gonna have to make this. For sure. Thank you for sharing this recipe!!!

[@connieheitz8982]

I absolutely love my Kitchenaid. I use it for so many things including kneading bread. I don't like Cool-whip either. I think it has a chemical taste to it.

[@lisaspikes4291]

I agree. Anything that calls for cool whip I substitute whipped cream.

[@HAVENWELLE]

That looks so good!

[@KMVM46]

OMGosh! That looks amazing! Thank you for sharing!

[@eilidhaylee9519]

We are having a family get together on Sunday, this is going to be one of the deserts I will be taking, along with your lemon meringue pie. I need to bake a birthday cake as well, now to scour your videos for a yellow cake. Thanks for all you do..

[@lilbitatatime3763]

I'm going to have to give your version of Peanut butter pie a try. This is one of my teens favorite pies. I top mine with the nuts and mini chocolate morsels. We've had this out in a restaurant and on top of the nuts they drizzle with chocolate and caramel. I'm salivating!

[@deannadelacruz1283]

I love watching your video's. you seem to be a very sweet person and so does your husband. please keep making more video's

[@SweetTater]

I have been watching your videos for about a week, I'm addicted to listening to you and you even inspired me to make my own pie crust. I love watching you, your husband and your four legged babies on lifes journey. God bless you.

[@yvonnevieira9595]

OMG! I'm going to make this soon! I'm glad that you go to Walmart for all your baking supplies. I Loved that v plastic wrap with the button zip thingy Lol how many times have I fought with it! I work at a super market called Fry's (Kroger's) I'll see if we carry it Love my employee 10% discount & you! 😊

[@Heraclitean]

Your voice soothes me.

[@justmeleslie5970]

that looks delishous! can you do some more pie or holiday foods recipes. I enjoy your channel. I have a channel too. But mine is just starting.

[@susanlinginfelter706]

I'm so glad you made your own whipped cream.....I don't like Cool Whip either.....it, along with soft serve ice cream, give me heartburn......I read on the package and they are made from soybean oil.....I don't think soybeans in any fashion are good for you. I will try your peanut butter pie....it looks very yummy!!!! And....knowing that the whipped cream is all cream is the biggest plus!!! Love your "from scratch" cooking!!!!

[@rachelalcorn5967]

rest in peace Miss Phyllis I didn't know you personally I wished I would have you seem like a very sweet kind woman I love all of your recipes and I hope you're resting in heaven watching all of us God bless from Nashville Tennessee

[@boy456781]

Looks just wonderfull and iam sure it is i could sure go for some great recipe phyllis.

[@pamelarobinson8459]

You made my day... as usual! I appreciate your recipes and watch your channel regularly. Thank You so much!

[@RedKittieKat]

Wow!!! That looks amazing! I love that you used real whipped cream. I'll be making this soon! Thanks Phyllis ♥

[@TressasSouthernHomeCooking]

Thank you so much Ms. Phyllis for another great recipe and its PIE!! Love it as I do all your recipes and videos!! You make me smile!

[@randilarocca8812]

Yummy. Making this on the weekend. Thank you for sharing your amazing recipes. God bless. You Rock.

[@dmdohse55]

in the store you canbuy a chocalate cookie crust in a shell allready made and l didnt know this but now you can get a family size shell like a 10 inch in the grahamcracker and a shortbread one also

[@miretter330]

That's a very delicious pie Phyllis !!

[@rebeccamcmahan5285]

Oh my Goodness!!!!! I think I gained twenty pounds through this entire Video.....Looks Delicious and I know it is!!!!!

[@martinacrank6836]

This Peanut Butter Pie is AMAZING!!! Thank you..

[@ginafriend1690]

Simply WOW! You are making a baker out of me, Miss Phyllis! Another added to my list. Thanks! 🌹

[@Oldebookworm]

Putting heavy cream on my shopping list along with Oreos! Making this pie!

[@AussieAngeS]

Oh goodness that peanut butter pie looks fabulous Phyllis! I love that it has an Oreo crust. Rich but I bet it's fantastic

[@PhyllisStokes]

+FitAnge S Hi Ange, good to see your smiling face. Thanks for the comment.

[@MJYouAreNotAlone1]

I cannot wait to make this. Thank you so much for all you have done for us. ❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️🙏🙏🙏🙏

[@deborahadams8600]

I'm riding out Irma here..bad Hurricane , no power.. I can't wait to make this !

[@twirlyfish2144]

I am, definitely, going to make this sometime....looks delicious

[@deathdragon745]

Hi Phyllis, Your so cute lol. At the very end when you chuckled saying your not even going to tell us how good it is hahahah your so cute. Hope you both have a wonderful day! Liz

[@kleineroteHex]

Super rich sounds good !! I so like your inventions! Yup, watching some I haven't seen yet.

[@annmariezarzecki5787]

That looks so yummy!! Great job and thanks for sharing your kitchen with us! 💕Annmarie

[@lilamydogscruffy8842]

Hi Ms. Phyllis. Yum,yum,yum!!!!! That is one delicious looking pie. I wish I had a slice of that right now. Big thumbs up. :)

[@emmalove135]

I just want to say “Thank you” for this ingenious recipe. You have a very good taste bud for mixing and blending tannins, flavors etc. I made your peanut butter pie. I and my sons thought that it is super rich. It is “Super Awesome “. Thank you.

[@cathyslaton9998]

Thanks ,for sharing it does look delicious !!

[@mamasuso]

Nabisco makes a chocolate wafer that sometimes can be difficult to find. I think they are Famous Choc. wafers and are available in a box with one large sleeve of cookies with no extra sugar. only the larger grocery stores here is Houston carry them.

[@michaelwatson9995]

she reminds me of my aunt Susie anything that she made oh my god it was good

[@lescharlton988]

Another peanut butter recipe. I know am not watching in order but I love it.

[@lucillenaber5278]

Looks excellent Phyllis. Going to have to try this.

[@lisagialucci2296]

Your pies always look so delicious !

[@lucyba]

Hi Phyllis, this looks delicious I will definitely try it! I have a question, where did you get your food processer, and did you get it at a good price? Knowing you, I'm sure you did. Thanks Phyllis, take care!

[@PhyllisStokes]

+lucyba The food processor came from Walmart about fifteen years ago, it's a Black and Decker.Don't remember how much I paid, but it was probably inexpensive.

[@UncleJewnyer]

that looks really delicious! I'm definitely going to try this recipe out. That you Phyllis!!!

[@watchman218]

I absolutely LOVE ALL your videos! I could actually sit all day watching you make every recipe. I just made my brother in law a low carb peanut butter pie, however, I think next time I will make your version, but low carb. Thanks for sharing this recipe. ~Anthony M.~ Goodyear Arizona.

[@watchman218]

Just realized that Phylis and her husband passed away! 💔

[@PhyllisStokes]

Thanks for watching, Anthony. Trying to keep her legacy going with these videos and keeping hers going.

[@watchman218]

@@PhyllisStokes you are doing a great job. Your parents would be proud!🖖🏽🔆♥️

[@greenwoodreid3796]

Yum this looks amazing! I'm going to make this next weekend- thanks for the recipe!

[@roseannebennett2437]

Oh my , looks absolutely delicious, "Miss Phyllis ", I most definitely got too make me one of these for Thanksgiving or Christmas ! ! 😊😍🤗❤🎅🎄🎁❤💚💞

[@Enedina665]

You've outdone yourself again Miss Phyllis! That looks amazing.

[@tammyulgen]

I made this pie. What really set off the recipe was the dry roasted peanuts! That bit of salt is what that rich pie needed, I had used regular salted peanuts before in other recipes, but it's not the same! Everyone should try this recipe! Thank you so much!... the only think I didn't have was the nuts, so I ran to the DG store for them. Who knew those Clover Valley peanuts would be so tasty?

[@honeybadger8893]

Miss this lady🥺

[@MamaBear1]

hey Phyllis could you make a homemade cheese cake? I love them and some use a crust and other ones don't so I am confused. Much appreciated/thanks

[@PhyllisStokes]

Here's a video of my raspberry topped New York style cheese cake with cookie crust. I prefer making a crust for the cheese cake. kzbin.info/www/bejne/eXS4c3xoZpehqck

[@aclark30121]

This looks so so good--cant wait to try it-thanks

[@alicemilling3706]

That looks amazing I love peanut butter miss phyllis this is a winner lol this made me so hungry☺

[@essemsween818]

That looks divine,!

[@glendadavid1374]

Ok Mrs Phyllis :) You got me again! I can"t Stop Myself, You got me hooked, My Husband just said, Glenda stop watching that darn pie video because you ant going to be satisfied until you make that pie sugar, yea as usual he is Right Mrs Phyllis :) You got me crazy like that Mississippi Mud Pie, LOL I have made that at least 20 Times in the past couple Months, I made 3 on Mother's Day and 5 For Father's Day. There are some Family Members and 2 really nice Gentleman from Church that are Great Daddys and Grandaddys that I just had to show how much I think they are special Godly Men. I asked their Wives about one for Mother's Day and they asked For my Greek Potato Salad inside the Greek Salad with Shrimp. I can make that Well. I wish You were Closer to where I live or You Live, I'd be your Best Buddy. Well I'm going to buy the stuff today Ma'am and I will holler back atcha and let you know if I'm going crazy making it LOL. God Bless Your Heart Mrs Phyllis :) I miss You making more Video's But I know You have a Life too :( David and I are talking about Retiring up close by You, in Myrtle Beach. Maybe we can visit each other if we relocate. God Bless You and Mr Bucky!! I Pray you are not working too darn hard in this Heat. Big Huggz ox ox

[@alicemilling3706]

Miss Phyllis I miss you so much God bless you and Mr Bucky a!ways

[@linaloves5154]

Looks delicious

[@carolsterling4953]

I can't wait to try this recipe!

[@ianscianablo4674]

Inspirational pie! Love the fact you're not a Cool Wip fan. Gross white slop I always thought. Could I pipe out the cream?

[@PhyllisStokes]

you could pipe out the cream and make very fancy.

[@ljjackson7106]

Ms. Phyllis, where do you and Mr. Bucky keep your defibrillator, to the right or left side of your fridge? Ouch! That looks heavenly!

[@PhyllisStokes]

+LJ Jackson You're just too cute. We don't need a defibrillator because we have a Vitamix and have very nutritious green smoothie every morning. Therefore we are able to indulge in delicious deserts sometimes.I might add that one piece of the peanut butter pie contains 11.25 grams of protein which is much better than having a very small piece of lemon meringue pie. All things in moderations including animal protein.

[@ljjackson7106]

I've got my advanced degree in the Phyllis Stokes video library! I am rather addicted to your videos (I think I'm driving my husband a bit nuts!) :)

[@markusgibson8596]

Markus

[@transplantclub]

This looks so good!

[@e.conboy4286]

Lovely Lady, you are missed.

[@southernprairiehomestead8266]

We also do not use Kool whip it is awful and has toxic ingredients. Recipe looks yummy but I am going to skip the Oreo cookie crust and make my graham cracker crumb crust. My husband is going to love this :~) Thank you for sharing another wonderful recipe!!! God Bless

[@roxanne1092]

Use the ingredients and exact steps for the main filling. You can add whatever with this recipe .. although I use imitation vanilla or very low alcohol in it. Without baking the pie the alcohol won’t cook off. The taste remains. I mix in small chunks of a Hershey milk chocolate bar in and whipped cream on top with chocolate shavings, no peanuts And always Jiff or Peter pan peanut butter. Most brands leave a bad taste. I use the original Smooth Jiff. This pie is crazy good. She’s not kidding this pie is like.. that amazing desert you ate that one time at that one restaurant. And you have never forgotten how good it was. The kind you talk about a few times a year, yearning to eat it once again. It’s like that. Get exact ingredients or Your pie will be off and might even be gross. Always use Philadelphia cream cheese. Walmart generic vanilla is best in this recipe. I give these as presents and people have asked for one for their birthday. I only use 1/2 cup peanut butter.

[@MJYouAreNotAlone1]

I love you so much Phyllis and your wonderful husband Bucky. I miss you guys so so much! I will see you one day in heaven. ❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️🙏🙏🙏🙏

[@cristywyndham-shaw5111]

I like how she always called confectioners' sugar "confectionary" sugar. I miss her. 😭

[@daphnerodriguez9980]

AMAZING CHOCOLATE PIE YUMMY 😋,REST PHYLLIS 🌈🌟 DAPHNE COTTON ALWAYS 💜 AWESOME BEAUTIFUL ✨,

[@eileenriker6465]

I make my peanut butter pie with the whole oreos

[@rnempson1]

I'm making this tomorrow . My husband loves peanut butter chocolate ice cream so I know he'll love this.

[@Sp-qr4ve]

Oh my this pie looks super delicious 😋

[@DarianHarder]

Maybe I am crazy but I would use that peanut-butter crust you made for your gelatin pie, with this. It just Guilds the Lilly a little more.

[@russelloverton9496]

These videos will never get old to me, like listening to an old friend. Strange to feel that way about someone you've never met and even more strange to mourn someone you've never met. RIP sweet lady.

[@MoonFlower52798]

No need for me to look any further!! I think I have all the ingredients without even going to the store! Thank you!

[@stpierreno]

i want a piece,please

[@PatriotChick]

Yummo 💟

[@laurac5451]

I love hat she made her own version. I add about three times as much water if I make grape juice as it calls for

[@tonyabailey97]

can you use pudding instead of cream cheese

[@PhyllisStokes]

I've never tried it with pudding, you could give it a try it might just work great.

[@jaxinco]

What's with the cool whip comment at the end? What do ya have against cool whip? ;)

[@rudy6222]

I love your voice!!!!!!!

[@Navygrl58]

Can I make and freeze this 3 days before a baby shower, or will it be ruined that far in advance?

[@PhyllisStokes]

I think the peanut butter pie would do well even frozen for 3 days. Remember there is a frozen peanut butter pie you can buy that I'm sure is frozen months before it's purchased so if they can do it we can do it. Good luck. I would put it in the bottom of the refrigerator the day before to thaw.

[@Navygrl58]

Phyllis Stokes Thank you Phyllis, your a sweetheart, I'm sure everyone will love it!

[@lizziesangi1602]

You've got a lot more of a thinking process going on than I ! I never thought to warm or melt "Cool Whip" and on your advice I won't. I'm an heavy cream user. Coming from a large family, as yourself, one of my jobs wz to whip the cream, with the hand held egg beater. Hmmm, I never thought, until just now, why always with the rotary egg beater? MAYbe it kept us little ones busier, longer? 🤗

[@brysonhatfield9557]

+ PhyllisStokes "Hi, Phyllis here, southerfrugal.com....This afternoon we are going to fix a peanut butter pie. Now, this is going to be my version of the pie. I AM GOING TO FIX IT SUPER RICH (Looks at camera: Don't judge me) I'm sorry, I'm going too".....LOL....

[@sherrytromatore]

I was just thinking of you. Your first Thanksgiving without Mr Bucky......I hope you are not alone. Miss seeing your face ♥️

[@glendadavid1374]

Mrs Phyllis, first time seeing this video. I make a chocolate peanut butter pie, not like this, but Do you know what I'm talking about? Maybe you can do a Video of a Real Chocolate Peanut Butter Pie, because Ma'am I did a search and ant nobody made a video of one. I wanted to see how other folks did theirs and they ant a one available except strange versions, a Pie to me also has the Crust you make in that video, I make that same crust for my Chocolate Peanut Butter Pie. I hope you know what I'm talking about and maybe you can make a video. None on utube. God Bless You and Mr Bucky!! Big Huggz ox ox

[@twirlyfish2144]

Did you get rid of your Oster stand mixer?

[@ShirleyJewellBowenyahoocomBowe]

That looks so good.

[@barbaraelford9285]

I was hoping to see the big smile on Mr/ Bucky's face as he tasted his piece. Looks lucious. I think my spelling is off and I don't know how to use spell check.

[@littlejoan7473]

Oh! That looks good. I should be looking up something to do in the crock pot for dinner...so why am I here? Ha! Ha! Ha!

[@deborahbuhrman2874]

Where did the paper on the bottom of the pie go?