Red Sea Reefer 170 Review

[@martijnbeumer01]

This video has been in my feed for about a month, youtube really wanted me to see this

[@MyFirstFishTank]

:-)

[@Buck0seven]

Awesome video review! I am looking for something like the Red Sea Reefer series but will have the tank in my office. Outside of the overflow noise you discuss, do you feel that the stand quells much of the noise from the protein skimmer and pump? Your video seemed very quiet, but you may have used a microphone. Thanks for providing such a thorough review! A+!

[@MyFirstFishTank]

Good question for sure. The tank definitely mutes the noise, but a lot of it is going to depend on you. If you have hard plastic tubing vs. silicone which is more quiet. Are your pumps touching the glass causing vibrations to radiate out? I find the tank to have a pleasant white noise sound, but sometimes the vibrations can get a bit much and I have to readjust my equipment in the sump.

[@secretguy6781]

This tank advertises in its video as complete. You installed a few items more. The way it arrived was not adequate? Since I've only owned freshwater, will this tank help me learn reef tanks? How much more will I have to spend to have a setup to yours? Thanks Jeremy

[@MyFirstFishTank]

Hey There. The Reefer series comes with tank, stand, sump, and plumbing, but you have to supply the lights, pumps, and other equipment. So it is not really an all-in-one system. Check out this system from waterbox. They are a newer company but I think this would be a great tank for a beginner! www.waterboxaquariums.com/product/waterbox-silver-marine-aio-30-2-plus/ref/18/

[@untoldleo4909]

If you want an all in one you’d have to go with the max e 170

[@ericolsen9799]

Nice job. Looks like corals are growing and looking good. Keep videos coming Matthew

[@MyFirstFishTank]

+eric olsen Thanks Eric!

[@johnsreef2622]

Great Vid, everything looks healthy👍. Was always curious how close you could put it to the wall. Thanks for the information. Have a good one.

[@MyFirstFishTank]

+John Stanfill Thanks John. Yeah, everything is healthy, except for the dino's growing! I'm now going to let them take over a bit and see what happens! There is always something with this hobby, but I keep telling myself that it is my chance to learn!

[@Kenny_Edmonton]

I have a chance to buy Red Sea 170 on marketplace, it would be my first saltwater tank, would it be good for a beginner?

[@magwarblood]

Nice vid mate ,,,, I got sick and tired of the sump in my 170 so after 4 months I decided to have the lot out and mod it my self , I cut out ALL the standard baffles and added my own ,, I now have a refugium in mine as well as space for skimmer and reactors ,, best move I've made by far so far on the tank , video of the whole tank and sump coming up soon

[@MyFirstFishTank]

+reef roid Do you have any pictures of the final result? I had not even thought about that, but now I'm definitely thinking of completely removing the sump and getting one custom made. I would love to see what you did!

[@magwarblood]

+Matthew Zahler got a few vids that you might be able to see a bit ,,, gong to do a vid on the entire system soon as I've customised pritty much everything

[@christopherb4680]

Great vid, what setting do you use for your light? Thanks

[@MyFirstFishTank]

Gosh I made this so long ago I don't remember. Nowadays I use some sort of variation of Eco techs a B+ schedule

[@brodie2511]

Great video, I love the scape, it looks great. I would agree with you regarding the down flow control value, only tiny adjustments are needed. I check the overflow level everyday and have to adjust every other day. The rear panel of the tank is glass wrapped in Black vinyl and the weir box is made from smoked glass. Cheers

[@MyFirstFishTank]

+Tall Col That makes a lot of sense! You definitely know your tank better than i do! What do you think of the sump? Have you made any mods on it?

[@brodie2511]

+Matthew Zahler The sump on the 250 is also very small. I feel your pain regarding space in the sump and I definitely feel your pain with the top off tank. I haven't done any mods to the sump its self but I am also thinking of turning the top off tank into a refugium. Have you watched " Wai Yin Wong's "video

[@RogueAquariums]

nice video Matthew. good job of maximizing your equipment w/the limited amount of space you have. the sump is the only thing I personally would like to change.

[@MyFirstFishTank]

+NW Marine62 Agreed! I might actually purchase a custom sump in the future, that includes space for a small refugium. But that is not in the budget right now!

[@adriang8355]

This tanks are awesome I don't really think it is anything wrong with them all depends on the reefer!!! It's a video here same tank all Acroporas!!!! Yes Acroporas!!! So that told you a lot about this tank!!!

[@MyFirstFishTank]

:-)

[@myselfdotcom]

do you have moist or high humidity built up inside the sump cabinet?

[@MyFirstFishTank]

Good question, but I would say virtually no humidity. I have never seen any sort of condensation in the sump area. I live in a low humidity area (Seattle), so it is an issue we just don't struggle with.

[@deandean8316]

Nice video, I like how you went into detail about everything.

[@MyFirstFishTank]

Thanks Dean.

[@georgearias7336]

Beautiful. Does that aquarium system comes with light system??

[@MyFirstFishTank]

Not the Reefer system alone, but they sell the Reefer Deluxe which does come with the light!

[@georgearias7336]

@@MyFirstFishTank Oh, I see. Is that the only difference between the reefer system versus the deluxe reefer system one??

[@ac3ray903]

Would two kessil a80 be enough for a reefer 170?

[@MyFirstFishTank]

I think so, but you might just want to go with this one instead. It costs a bit more, but good coverage and you can control it via your phone. www.marinedepot.com/partners/idevaffiliate.php?id=102&url=2200

[@Botzz28]

This did not come with a skimmer right ?

[@MyFirstFishTank]

Snapback_BR correct, but this was a while ago and they now are producing their own skimmers so I’m not currently sure. My guess is that you’ll be able to purchase one of their skimmers as an add on.

[@CJSAQUARIUMS]

Good honest review man... Tank looks great but seems like it's more for new hobbiest. I would prefer more control over the size and type of sump... With the clean design of the tank I self... Great info go any future tank I may get

[@MyFirstFishTank]

+CJ'S AQUARIUMS Thanks CJ. I think what I might do in the future is just completely get rid of the sump, and custom order something that suits my needs more. And thanks for the videos on your filming techniques! Really helpful stuff!

[@jameshong2010]

What is the dimension of the black overflow box?

[@MyFirstFishTank]

That is a great question, but I don't own the system anymore so I can't measure it! Hope you can find the specs online!!

[@jluusaltwateraquarium8320]

Hello sir I have same tanks you have... Is hard to build a system for calcium

[@MyFirstFishTank]

True true

[@thom7667]

Can you get the 45 Gallon without the light fixture?

[@oldmateize]

yeah man they all come with the option of zero hardware

[@louisromano8947]

You could probably fix your drain issue if u put a ball valve on your return line

[@MyFirstFishTank]

true that!

[@ann53090]

how many gallons is this?

[@MyFirstFishTank]

You answered your own question. Total volume is about 43 gallons with the 10 gallon sump

[@mcmanamon90]

Why doesn't the tank support the whole tank? It looks like the front glass is hanging

[@MyFirstFishTank]

+Chris Mcman You are absolutely right! So, the stand and tank are definitely going for the modern look. Basically, with the stand door closed, it sits flush with the cabinet. So the tank, with the doors closed, sits completely flush. Looks pretty slick actually!

[@pastoralantavares4480]

It's possible, you pass the measurements? How many fish can I put?

[@MyFirstFishTank]

Hi Alan, and thanks for watching. Not quite sure what your question is though. Let me know if I can answer anything!

[@brandonezdoofenshmirtz2916]

Fish is about 5 maximum for clownfish sized fish

[@zolawrx]

What lighting are you currently using?

[@MyFirstFishTank]

I'm currently using an ecotech xr30 pro. Was previously using th xr15

[@EvanLikesCake]

What’s a good price to pay for this?

[@EvanLikesCake]

For the 43 gallon

[@EvanLikesCake]

Also how many watts does this tank use

[@MyFirstFishTank]

Hi Evan. Good question. The Reefer's are expensive, upwards of $1,000. It is a nice tank for sure, but you can get a lot more for your money with other brands. Check out Fluval, JBJ. I would go with Red Sea if you had a big plan for customizing your equipment. Regarding your Watt question, I can't answer that because it depends on the equipment you buy. Good luck.

[@EvanXDev]

Fluvals don't have sumps.

[@bcribdog]

Hi! How often do you have to fill the RO top off? 3 days?

[@MyFirstFishTank]

+Outdoor Ben Let's see. I no longer use the 1.5 gallon RO container that came with the system. I was getting about 2 days with it. I now have a ten gallon tub that I use, and that last a week and a half.

[@jaysonmilsten6932]

Good review! Everything is spot on. Getting the overflow dialed in was the toughest task when setting this up. I'd suggest a hang on reactor like the Aquamaxx or TLF reactors. I have two Aquamaxx ones and they work great and look really clean. Check out my second video if you have a minute. I love these tanks! ;)

[@MyFirstFishTank]

+Jayson Milsten I'm going to check out your videos right now. I haven't really thought about any hang on reactors because I figured they would mess with the aesthetic, but I'll take a look at yours and see how they look!

[@reefglow1973]

good review ! i thought about getting a redsea tank when i was getting into the hobby . the one i wanted was to expensive. chk out my 120 when u have a chance.

[@MyFirstFishTank]

+Pedro loaiza I'll check it out right now!

[@jodia7435]

The weir inside the tank is a nuisance. I can't understand how Red Sea could have failed at that. It decreases the room available. On the sides of the weir there're left wasted areas.

[@MyFirstFishTank]

That's true that the weir does take up space, but it allows for a bit more of a flush mount against your wall. But I definitely prefer lower profile overflow! Thanks for watching and commenting!

[@go4384]

Boy, for a tank this expensive that dirty back side is quite unappealing. I get the improvement of being able to back it up to the wall, but if it comes at the expense of a dirty inside, not sure myself.

[@MyFirstFishTank]

True, there are always tradeoffs.

[@joseCalderon1976]

Awesome review! Thanks. Che out my nano reefs in my channel. Subscribed.

[@MyFirstFishTank]

+jose Calderon Appreciate it Jose!

[@ann53090]

oh 34G nvm