MYNH: First Time Hearing and Reacting to Kino - A Star Called the Sun! How is this band not bigger?!

[@ЮрийТерентьев-и9ы]

"Сказка", "Печаль", у Цоя полно прекрасных песен с невыразимой грустью и гениальным исполнением. И огромное спасибо автору, эту гениальную композицию никто так не слушал (разбирая стихи) на ютубе!👍👍👍

[@Mr1983Andrei]

Thanks for the feedback on this group. I want more reactions to KINO!!!

[@ricdreacts]

More to come!

[@maksmadson3605]

I very glad that you comment Kino songs and talk about text meaning because in case the great music group it very-very important! Thank you for your translation and comments for English - speaking people! Very recommend to you make video with "Song without words" by Kino.

[@alex_6772]

на этой песне рождались, вырастали, шли, падали, поднимались и снова шли !поколения!

[@ДмитрийСССР-ю7п]

Удивительно правильное понимание текста песни Виктора Цоя. Второй раз смотрю Ваш обзор и второй раз удивляюсь тому, как точно улавливаете смысл спетого.

[@ВладимирБосов-у5ь]

видимо вы нихрена не понимаете в этой песне .... а этому пиндосу и подавно не понять... но вылизать очко вы умеете гениально... дб.бл!

[@cubaasid3002]

@user-hd6wc7eb9i В каком месте "Удивительно правильное понимание текста песни" ?

[@nekinggoldcrest]

В песне "Спокойная ночь" он трактовал текст совсем не так, как задумывалось.

[@nightnotes3122]

​@@nekinggoldcrest С политической точки зрения он как раз таки верно всё понял!

[@nekinggoldcrest]

@@nightnotes3122 с политической точки зрения можно трактовать тексты Цоя как угодно, лишь бы попасть в удобную повестку.

[@BillWeapon]

As my father was in Afghanistan and I served in the second Chechen war kino has been carried through my family and I am even passing it down to my children.

[@oscaroscar258]

Hey man. Finally waited! Thank you very much for feedback, that fulfilled my request. I appreciate. Please next another great one - Summer will be end.

[@ricdreacts]

More to come!

[@myamya7910]

Thanks a lot ! Very intresting for lissten and watch ! Kino « changes » кино «перемен» we will like to see !

[@ваняиванов-э6щ]

Спасибо . Как новый подписчик , требую больше реакций на Виктора Робертовича и группу КИНО .

[@padma7775]

Классная реакция. Цой всегда будет актуален

[@ЮрийТерентьев-и9ы]

Great thks for your reaction on KINO and this legendary song! Even bofore watching!

[@alexeyshestov7294]

Thanks for the reaction! The third verse is a bit wrong - it is not about a war, it is about an exceptional man, who does exceptional things without an effort, and he is doomed to die young. He feels no limits in life - because of that he doesn't know what is yes and what is no, doesn't remember social hierarchy. And because he feels no limits, he also doesn't see when he puts himself in danger, so he will die young. It is about all those talanted men who had burned too early - including Tsoi himself, he died when he was just 28

[@RoadToFuture007]

Btw. Tsoi's car was hit by a bus which types name is "Icarus". If you reads the last verse of this song you will find reference to the Icarus Myth (this was the guy who flew up tho the sun but the sun melted the glue which was fixing his self made wings so he fell down to the earth). So there is some kind of real mystics and prophecy around this song!

[@Yakushef1]

I see love in your eyes))) thanks

[@ricdreacts]

😊 thank you

[@JohnDoe-do8yd]

...и способен дотянуться до звёзд не считая, что это сон... И стать Звездой. Спасибо Вам за то, что слушаете и цените наше сокровенное.

[@omc912]

Потрясаюшая реакция! 🙏💕

[@slicemf5347]

correction. "He CAN reach for a Stars and same time not believing that this is a dream". Its means not that guy is in a dream, but that he can do fantastick dreamlike things not realy bothering that they are fantastic. And than he falls scorched by the sun.

[@RoadToFuture007]

Agree. "Falling scorched by the sun" - this is the myth of Ikarus. Btw. the bus which hit Viktors car was also an Ikarus ;)

[@RoadToFuture007]

So the meaning is not that pessimistic and fatalistic as Ric described it. There is just this perpetual process that is prety old and it is not peacefull but there are certain individuals who are "out of this world" and maybe die young in the battle or because they are trying to reach the Sun (the stars, because Sun is also a star) but they are loved by the fate because they are pushing our limits and dont care if someone is calling them dreamers. This is how i understand it.

[@alekseyskornyakov7784]

И способен дотянуться до звёзд, Не считая что это сон. Оказывается все это время неправильно понимал эту строчку, правда особо не задумываясь над ней. Теперь как осенило, благодаря Вам :) Просто автоматом легла с не верной интерпретацией.

[@oscaroscar258]

На самом деле Виктор пацифист. И его песни это не военные песни. В своих песнях он использовал войну как метафору. Здесь надо копать глубже. Это жизненная война одной гороической жизни пожертвовавшей сабою ради высокой цели, ради благо других. Об этом свидетельствует цветы выросшие на земле, где пролилась его кровь. Значит его жертва не было напрасной. И этим он "дотянулся до звезд" выполнив свое высокое предназначение на этой земле, свою миссию до конца. Потому что нет выше ничего, как отдать свою жизнь ради других.

[@Nani_torova]

Думаю лучше было бы написать коммент сразу в переводе. А так, согласен и оставил подобный по смыслу коммент.

[@RoadToFuture007]

Yes I agree, this song is about Viktor himself.

[@oscaroscar258]

​​@@RoadToFuture007 Про себя, про других из своего поколения или будущих покооений - кто знает...А может быть про нас?

[@user-dime]

Совершенно верно, никакой войны. Просто "у кого-то есть день и есть ночь... у кого-то есть сын и есть дочь..." нет никакой войны...

[@abzstr]

You're wrong guy. Blood, after it hit the ground, in just an hour nothing happens to the ground, after two hours there are already flowers and grass on this land, and after three hours (not after three years) the earth is alive again (metaphor) In general, the text of the song is not about the war as such and the fact that everything on earth goes in a circle, only people change. It's also not about any particular city that is 2 thousand years old, it's a metaphor. Any war on earth is a matter of the young who do not live up to their wrinkles, but again, war can be just life if it takes place in difficult conditions, like most......And actually I don't know why they put here Afghan theme......

[@RabidWildCreature]

u didnt need to debunk his entire idea like that. he was just expressing what he thought it meant u didnt need to be like "well ur wrong its actually a metaphor and blah blah blah"

[@Романбаклажан-х8д]

Ты либо Русский ! Либо просто выёбываешься ! Вот и разбирайся 😂

[@Nani_torova]

Great response, great analysis, amazing how you felt about the song! But in the case of Kino's songs, there is one point. Even among the Russian speakers, many disputes continue about the meaning of Tsoi's songs - on the one hand, the meaning lies on the surface and everything seems to be clear, on the other hand, it is often a metaphor. The example with the song of Changes(Перемен) is very indicative - many perceive it as a call for political changes, especially given the context of Perestroika, but Victor and other members of the group said that this song has nothing to do with politics and that it is about internal experiences.

[@antigoneoedipus7037]

Вы все правильно понимаете... Спасибо!

[@Mr1983Andrei]

Super!!!

[@ricdreacts]

Thank you! Cheers!

[@valeriy.1446]

Si pity that you dont use concert videos. But your videos aro so interesting. Thanks!

[@Horoshayamoya]

Спасибо

[@boristurovskiy351]

Tsoi is immortal. Along with Vysotski. And Elvis:) But my generation grew up on his songs. He's special to a generation of Russians.

[@ЮрийТерентьев-и9ы]

За Витю лайк всегда!

[@sergeyconner7460]

comment in support of the channel

[@freeant44]

Hi, please listen to the Kino - Song without words

[@justine5799]

I found Kino a few years ago and I was looking for an English speaker to react to it. I was wondering if you would consider doing "Peramen" or "Change".

[@ДмитрийСССР-ю7п]

Уважение Вам сэр. Человек с англо-сакской культурой не может так понимать нашу музыку и лирику как Вы...а Вы понимаете...НОНСЕНС!

[@nikolayg5926]

❤❤❤

[@НиколайИванов-с5к6к]

🤝✌

[@allanek7881]

на видео- это советская группа войск в Афганистане (1987) и эта песня была написана во время афганской войны

[@boris_bulletdodger9109]

Positive comment

[@the_martian_45]

There is a band called Brazzaville which did a cover of this song (Star Called Sun), but completely changed the lyrical theme. I highly recommend you check it out especially since you liked the original.

[@nikolayg5926]

У Виктора Цоя есть альбом "группа крови" в нём 7 песен 10/10 баллов !!! "Спокойная ночь" "Звезда по имени солнце" "Перемен" " Группа Крови" " Жёлто-красные дни" "Пачка сигарет" и другие

[@Mr1983Andrei]

Kino❤❤❤

[@Qazaq0611]

Виктор был бы против подобного видеоряда к его песне.

[@БакэМ]

ЦОЙ ЖИВ

[@SakhForester]

Man!!! You think like a Russian!!! How? How do you do it? How can you feel all this? I'm just amazed!!! We Russians are no worse and no better than others ... but we really are not like that. Yes, at first glance we are gloomy ... but this is because perhaps we understand a little more. Great Russian writer Andrei Platonov said - "I feel so bad because I understand too much ..." and this is true. you amaze me more and more with each of your reactions.

[@ricdreacts]

Wow! TYVM for that! 1💛💛💛

[@SakhForester]

@@ricdreacts You are an amazingly smart person. It really moves me to tears. A smart person who listens to music and gives his comments. What could be better. don't we all come here for it. you give us your wisdom, it's just wonderful. I would like to tell you more, we have something to talk about because I think and feel the same way as you...we are people...we think...we live! I am immensely grateful to you for being you, I would like to shake your hand and hug you like a brother.

[@saltifate]

Hi, Ric, just thought i'll point out a slight inaccuracy in translation to the 3rd verse. It's not laws of others, it's other(different) laws, basically meaning he doesn't follow the laws/rules that everyone else does. Essentially labeling "that" person a trailblazer of sorts. It's my top 5 favourite songs of all time

[@Mocsk]

Most people remember the quote "I love the smell of napalm in the morning". Very few realise the quote they should have remembered was a few seconds later, "Someday this war's gonna end."

[@straycat4371]

👍👍👍👍

[@АлександрМортис-к9п]

I found the translation about seige is pretty weird. Literally it's exactly about city in a road loop or circle. And I've never heard any similar idiom.

[@privatizzato]

а над городом плывут облака закрывая Небесный Свет, а над городом желтый дым, городу 2000 лет...это христианская цивилизация

[@RoadToFuture007]

This is "calm song" because it has a marching drum pattern and tempo. Kino used marching pattern very often. I think even "calm night" is a march. "Wrinkles medicine" i always interpreted it as "war is wrinkles medicine" in the sense that war resolves some complicated situation "easy way" but now i think your interpretation has also some sense.

[@bukvarem]

Да, Достоевскому наверное понравилось бы творчество Виктора Цоя.

[@polyakovNN]

Kino - Mom, we are all seriously ill Live 2020 Mother, We've All Fallen Gravely Ill Seeds have fallen in dirt, seeds are asking for rain. They need the rain. Cut open my chest, have a look inside, You will see that a fire is burning the core. It'll be late in a day, it'll be late in an hour, In a blink you won't be able to stand. And if the keys are unfit for a door, use shoulder to knock out the door. Mother, we've all fallen gravely ill... Mother, I know that we all have gone insane... Steel between fingers, tightly clenched fist. Hit above wrist, still tormenting the flesh, Poison in veins, instead of the blood, slow poison, poison froze up. The world is destroyed, the foreheads are cracked, and bread has been broken in half. And now someone's crying, and someone is mum, And someone is glad, someone's so glad... Mother, we've all fallen gravely ill... Mother, I know that we all have gone insane... You've got to be strong [yeah], you've got to be able to say: Keep hands off! Keep hands off me! You've got to be strong [yeah], or why else would you rather be? What will be worth a thousand words, When a strong hand will be all that you need? And now you are standing on river shore and thinking: to swim or not to swim? Mother, we've all fallen gravely ill... Mother, I know that we all have gone insane...

[@roberthovhannisian]

Please do reaction video of легенда (Legend) and сказка (fairy tale) great reactions, thanks a lot

[@АлександрТкач-у1ф]

The city in a road loop is the Moscow, because it really lays inside a big road loop that is circling around the city's borders, but other vice it is a metaphor to all our civilization witch counts already 2000 thousand of years and have well known problems with wars and aggression

[@Antosza]

Moscow is not unique in that way, a lot of cities have a road loop around them, and Moscow is definitly not 2000 years old. So you are wrong, it's realy just a metaphore for human civilization.

[@bastetowl3258]

russian is a pretty complex language to translate into english, and some things don’t sound as good in english compared to the original. their lyrics are pure poetry, so it’s hard to keep the complete vibe of the original song, and that’s why you have a million different translations lol. love your analysis of the lyrics btw and how you really dove deep into it. were you a good english lit student when you were younger? you’re right about us russians but i think it’s just because we’re more realistic while americans have more of a culture of blind optimism. i’d say kino also has songs with melancholic hopefulness and call to action, so they’re not always completely gloomy lyrics lol

[@furiousrabbit4926]

You understood the meaning of the song perfectly. Tsoi was against the war and the Soviet regime.

[@Dfg13930]

We Russians (this is not a nationality, but a state of mind) do not have a gloomy, but a sad soul, and it is deep. We grew up with amazing books, songs and movies. Choi is one of our geniuses. And Russians have a lot of deep images and metaphors in the language itself. We're thinking on it! This is happiness! And yet in our everyday communication culture, there are no smiles for strangers without a reason (if a Russian is happy, he can smile at strangers). But in general, when you get to know a Russian closer, he is open, sincere and friendly. Our "how are you?" requires a sincere answer. We're wondering what you're thinking about, what you're feeling. Share it with us and we will smile at you from the bottom of our hearts.

[@9873sergey]

The lyrics are much deeper, this song is not about war at all

[@ultrax2002]

Русские суровые только с незнакомцами... И да, у нас много образов и метафор, мы философы по жизни, т.к. жизнь не сахар...

[@МагдалинаКочкина]

Мне не нравится что песня наложена на такой видеоряд это сбивает и загоняет в рамки этого конфликта, что ошибочно

[@steppe_dweller_locky]

the band is big actually, it's just absolutely not popular abroad for some reason. anyway great reaction, love from russia, fuck putin, peace! ♥️☮

[@Роман-с8з3л]

Мы любим нашего Президента В.В.Путина и нам не важно что вам там говорят в ваших нечестных СМИ

[@steppe_dweller_locky]

@@Роман-с8з3л zомбированный момент. байдуже, Ромка...

[@Dany-u4d]

This song is not about war

[@Роман-с8з3л]

Я вырос на этих песнях магнитофон на батарейках во дворе друзья подруги отсутствие современных гаджитов оооочень прекрасное время было ЦОЙ ЖИВ!!!!

[@gelo1987]

false translation. Not "except that this is a dream" but "he believes to be able to reach the stars"

[@СолнечныйЛуч-х9х]

kzbin.info/www/bejne/i5zVY2ZvapyUq9U Пожалуйста, сделайте реакцию на песню В.Цоя ,Спокойная ночь.🙏🙏🙏

[@user-td5kx1pt4s]

Реакция здесь : kzbin.info/www/bejne/bXLZapqGe895esU

[@igormoshkin]

Вот скажи мне, американец, в чем правда?... Вот потому мы и угрюмые..

[@Yakushef1]

Of course it is anti-war song and video dont suit for this song)))

[@cubaasid3002]

I'm already watching your second reaction to Kino's songs .... Sadness ... Again, the video sequence does not correspond to the meaning of the song. Who advises you on these self-made videos superimposed on Kino songs that are off topic and confuse the meaning of the songs? Look for original clips of the band, from concerts, from films and with normal translation. And there are also clips where Choi sings in English. Maybe then you will begin to understand what these songs are about ... Good luck. Смотрю уже вторую Вашу реакцию на песни Кино.... Печаль... Опять видеоряд не соответствует смыслу песни. Кто вам советует именно эти, самодельные видео, наложенные на песни Кино, которые не в тему и путают смысл песен? Ищите оригинальные клипы группы, с концертов, из фильмов и с нормальным переводом. А ещё есть клипы, где Цой поёт на английском языке. Может тогда и начнёте понимать, о чём эти песни... Удачи.

[@vladver1292]

ЭТА ПЕСНЯ НЕ ПРО АФГАНИСТАН

[@сысойборзяк]

как вы задолбали.ю..вы не умеете паррарельнно??????нихгрена не ваш паьлик если вы чужое творчество испотльзуете

[@Роман-с8з3л]

Обязательно послушайте песню АПРЕЛЬ

[@Vadim-Volk-h4b]

верно сказал,все циклично! но в этом цикле,побиждает всегда Россия. а вам,Рик,красавчик вы,мужик,не поддаетесь сранной политикой,понимаете,что куда)

[@Роман-с8з3л]

Спасибо всем войнам которые воевали в Афганистане за службу.а ЦОЙ ЖИВ