Mysteries of Indian Astronomy with Nilesh Oak and Sanjay Dixit

[@THEJAIPURDIALOGUES]

LIKE and SHARE the VIDEO 💸 Support Sanjay Dixit and Jaipur Dialogues - www.jddigital.in/support/ 📲 Subscription Plans of Jaipur Dialogues - www.jddigital.in/subscription/ 💳Support via PayTM - [phone] 💻Join Our Telegram Telegram - t.me/thejaipurdialogues

[@joogledaily4937]

I agree with the logic that earlier folks were not obsessed with accuracy of pi. I have long held the belief even circle being 360degrees is with this same logic. 360 can be split in all parts from 1 to 9 equally except 7. And 7 can be approximated if really needed

[@joogledaily4937]

en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Manu_(Hinduism). Sir I somehow feel just like Dhruva is north pole and constant with respect to earth, Uttanpada is constant with respect to a larger celestial object and Manu is contant with respect to the universe. The more I read this literature and associate to stars, the more logical it seems.

[@amolpapewar]

Sir, my question to Oak Sir is as per him what is period of kalyug n when will it end? Any insight? Also as per dates of Mahabharata n Ramayana can we guess the 'kalavadhi' of each yuga?

[@chaina357]

What a gem Dixit ji you are. No news channel has shown these much informative programs in last 50 years which you showed in this short span

[@THEJAIPURDIALOGUES]

Thank You

[@amarjotsharma4798]

@@THEJAIPURDIALOGUES sir kya aapko aisa nahi lagta ki bharat ke jo viewer English jaante hain woh hindi bhi jaante hain lekin jo hindi jaante hain woh Engkish mein itne ache nahi hai is liye is tarah ki knowledge wali videos Hindi mein hone chahiye. Main aapki maximum videos share karta hu aur mujhe woh yahi bolte hain english wali hamare kisi kaam nahi hai. Jinkp English nahi aati main unki baat kar raha hu.

[@THEJAIPURDIALOGUES]

@@amarjotsharma4798 Ji. Ham hindi mein bhi banaege

[@amarjotsharma4798]

@@THEJAIPURDIALOGUES bahut bahut dhanyavaad Sanjay sir. Pranaam svikar karein 🙏🙏

[@experience_india]

Listening Nilesh Oak ji works always makes me feel proud of our culture. Har Har Mahadev ❤️

[@lateshkumar1950]

I as a Layman in Astronomy can Say with great Conviction that Conversations took place Here was So Brilliant that It's Brilliance shall Enlighten Many Souls... Thanks To Both Excellent Guest & Host... ✨✨ 🙏 🙏

[@meetkhatri1099]

Always a delight to have Nilesh Oak Ji.

[@vikasmishra99]

People are just mesmerized with facts and the parallels Nilesh ji draws. That's a treasure. Let's let that go down before we can even begin to ask questions.

[@VP-hm7zo]

While visiting other channels do recommend people by commenting in their comment box to watch The Jaipur Dialogues, Tufail Chaturvedi, Neeraj Atri, Faiyaz Ahmad Fyzie, Defensive Offence, Dr. Fouzia Rauf and Jyoti Tiwari.... This could help spread knowledge and reality....

[@country9825]

I came across a new channel Project Shivoham. Its video related to Sankarit is interesting.

[@user-ft3ep1ep8y]

@@country9825 +1

[@मनीषरंजन]

Vaidic physics

[@priyadhar2011]

JD is doing excellent job, Thank you Sanjay sir and JD team.

[@aghildyal]

Enlightening as always!!!

[@rajenbhad7728]

🇮🇳🙏 Vande Mataram, Jay Hind, Bharat Mata ki Jay . 🙏🇮🇳🚩🚩🚩

[@avm4377]

Nilesh ji is pleasure to hear 👍

[@jayantmishra3360]

In Kerla people sing a hymn and use KATPAYADI numbers system to decode the hymn for value of pi upto 36 place of decimal.

[@ushabaluni4526]

Kaash yeh sab vidya bacho ko padhai jaye taki unhe humari sankriti aur ancient knowledge ki jaankari ho

[@abhipatil1]

Gr8

[@nileshb-ij1rg]

Listening to Nilesh Oak Ji is like listening to poetry. Though I don't undergrad very deeply, I like to listen to him as his exposition is very sweet in terms of its purity, scientific nature and the mysterious depth of the topics he takes us into.

[@shobhitsah9411]

Very insightful webinar. Thanks 🙏

[@nkmahale]

Nilesh's exposition in his videos is excellent description of Indian Astronomy. "Descriptive Archaeoastronomy and Ancient Indian Chronology" by Amitabha Ghosh also gives a good introduction to Indian description of Astronomy.

[@abhitanshusoni]

Absolutely fantastic info. Keep up the good work

[@parveenkumar6559]

I have become your fan for bringing forward such unique subjects to awak Hindus/Sanatnis. We feel indebted. Keep it up, we are all with you to achieve the goals targeted by your vision.

[@2010sunshine]

Wonderful human being, Neelesh ji... Thanks to SD ji for bringing him in.

[@sappyab90]

Great great discussion. Nilesh Oak, I like him as he clearly says what he knows and what doesn't know. He is clear in his mind.

[@viralvieralmehta8613]

Niles is class. I have been hearing him since long .

[@komalchopra8419]

Maa bhawani bless both of you 🙏🙏🚩🚩for serving sanatana Hindu Sanskriti and Bharatvarsh 🚩🚩

[@marigoldStudio]

Wonderful exposition by Mr. Oak. Hats off to him for the deep knowledge he possesses thanks so much for inviting him on your awesome channel to share his priceless insights. 🙏🙏🙏 Would love to see him back for deeper discussion very soon! 😊

[@Kapil_Abhi]

हार्दिक धन्यवाद नीलेश जी & संजय जी!😊😊🙏🙏♥♥♥🚩🚩

[@nitinjoshi3842]

Excellent and enlightening session.

[@ramkumarsharma6603]

Very knowledgeable talk, feel proud to know about our rich civilization,All salutes to Nileshji for his highly strenuous research works....

[@Chen-gl9hm]

Thank you Nilesh ji

[@shyamsundarchatterjee8540]

It was really a great example. The name itself states that from ancient times we always believed earth is round. "BHU" means EARTH and "GOL" means "ROUND".

[@RKailash1616]

Har har mahadev har 🙏🧡🕉️🚩

[@laxmanraosalunke8874]

Sir, I would request shri Nilesh ji pl read the book by Krishnaji Vitthal Soman on Astronomy as well as Astrlogy. It is necessary to have proper knowledge of astrnomy to further study astrology. I know you are not much interested in atrology, but I am sure you will develop interest in astrology also. And Astrology is one of the parts of Vedang. Please do so and let us know your views through Jaipur Dialoges. Thank you both shri Sanjay ji and shri Nilesh ji. I am regular listners to your pgms and looking forward to the above pgm.

[@ram4226]

I see it many times for reference... Thank you both

[@harichandrabp365]

First thing required for a researcher is keep onself miles away from prejudice and this is what is lacking in most modern researchers. They first decide what is to be concluded and do research to prove their conclusion. Thank you NNO sir for your open minded approach which help us knowing the roots of sciences. Your submission in 48:00 of the talk makes it clear - just an example.

[@subhangkar]

Nilesh Oak ji, you have dirgha aayu. Congratulation!

[@rajsh7657]

Wow!!!! Great discussion. High class of knowledge.

[@sunilvishwakarma488]

Namskar Sir ji aap dono logo ko

[@agastya8999]

It's very heartening to see Nilesh ji Always 🤗

[@desairajtube]

Great topic. Nilesh ji, I am going to buy your book on Indian Astronomy!

[@nilalondon]

Sanjayji, pls get a panel of such experts, Bharatiya & videshi, to debate on these issues. While Jpur Dialogues is doing an par-excellence job in Bharat chetana, it will make little impact unless such old-new knowledge is extensively talked about worldwide (with focus on institutions that have money and make a difference worldwide).

[@sunilfauji]

He is a genius sir.

[@harichandrabp365]

NNO sir, kindly conduct an exhaustive course on Indian Astronomy and scope for more research. Kindly share all the knowledge you have.

[@jayantmishra3360]

As per Yajurved before initiating any action we do sankalp as below. Spell about place time day month tithi etc then say the position of sun and moon with respect to nakshatra and rashi wise and other planets in respective position then invoke the intended action.

[@lovkhokhar]

Wonderful session!

[@GlobalOdia]

PaThāNi Sāmanta from Odisha- the naked eye astronomer- author of Siddhānta Darpana: in addition to the names you say at 10 minutes

[@ajinkyasumbarkar8252]

Yes. Siddhanta Darpana is really an important text.

[@harshphysik]

Very interesting & enticing dialogue. It would have been helpful if Nilesh ji had explained little more on celestial radius & nautical mile. The design, location of temples and their relation to observable astronomical phenomena, the astronomical aspects to time travel, speed of travel in ancient indian scripts could have been discussed. It reported that chinese observed some massive explosion of stars and supernovae then why they aren't spoken about in indian texts? How astronomy, season change and ayurved can be correlated?

[@balbeersingh7226]

Sanjaya dixit sir you havea ful knowledge of hindu dharm commandable

[@rajusarkarinternetentrepre9036]

very good analysis.......

[@Aman123-x8t]

Great 👍👍

[@sameeroak3150]

This's a magnificent dialogue. One question if I may ask. Does Bhaaratiya Khagol Shaastra also talk about the vertical distance between various celestial bodies? For instance, stars in Saptarshree, though they appear on the same plane from Prithvee, they are not.

[@amolpapewar]

Sir, my question to Oak Sir is as per him what is period of kalyug n when will it end? Any insight? Also as per dates of Mahabharata n Ramayana can we guess the 'kalavadhi' of each yuga?

[@kamleshnautiyal3087]

विश्व त्रि-काल ( वैदिक - रामायण - महाभारत - चाणक्य -...) घटना-क्रम के समय 12 भावों के अंश-कला-विकला-प्रतिविकला में, 12 राशियों - 12 ग्रहों - 27 नक्षत्रों की पूर्ण सही ( हर एक उपग्रह प्रक्षेपण की गणितीय ) स्थिति, समय रहते पूर्ण सही ( perfect) हर एक सुरक्षा-शान्ति-खुशहाली सम्पन्न जीवन एवं जनरेशनों के जन्म-पोषण-संरक्षण परम-परा के अस्तित्व के लिए,

[@MrAjoysingh]

Its great discussion. Nilesh Sir is great. 🙏

[@vanisaxena3723]

It was a Superb Session 👌🏻

[@SpaceFactsWax]

Thanks for uploading. I had the chance to see a rocket launch in 2018. Memorable experience. I shared a pretty cool montage of the journey to my page.

[@nkmahale]

Though the shortest day occurs at winter solstice, currently Dec 20/21, the latest sunrise occurs closer to mid January. Question is whether Indians marked uttarayana on the basis of time of sunrise rather than shortest day which needs two observations, sunrise and sunset, and sunset are not that easy to observe as the sunrise. Human eye is more accurate when it is exposed to darkness to light rather than light to darkness.

[@Archak77]

Post Alexandar's arrival and failure to proceed in India ...Greeks kept coming to India and they took Surya Sidhanta with them that lead to the Astronomy of Greek and remaining European - western science.

[@rupeshsalunke5838]

High class podcast

[@mb8585]

Brilliant

[@gupt1699]

Sanjay ji aap ko mera pranaam 🙏 Meri aap se ek request hi ek video banaye Ramzan kyon manate hi muslim.muslim bolte hi holy month hi unke liye.baaki ke 11 month phir kya hi🙄

[@ussspirit4812]

Nileshji and dixitji, have you tried to get in touch with Dr. Amit Goswami to get your theories into academic circles? It is very hard to get academics to look past peer reviewed journals, esp. tenure seeking profs. One look at the mess that Schoch and John Anthony West got into tells the whole story. But a retired physicist with an open mind like Goswami might just be the person you need....

[@nilotpalsarmahsarma8344]

Nilesh ji ko lekar yuga par video banayaa

[@dharmaandus6682]

There's a team who would like to debate NNO, it's a team of indologist. Let me know when he is ready to do that?

[@omasktrading1732]

In Vishnu Purana given a definition for Yavana is One who does not eat Pig/ Pork Meat ..

[@Utopicfarmer]

@JAIPUR D NEED MORE DISCUSSIONS ON THE GITA

[@lalitha8021]

Gita quest on Instagram.

[@padmanabhaswamy]

Nilesh'ji, if you see a pendulum from a distance, moving in a circle, it will appear as moving perpendicularly.

[@drsutendergaur9794]

संजय जी उत्तम होगा यदि आपके संवाद हिंदी में भी प्रसारित होते रहें।

[@experience_india]

1:00:35😂😂 that much is sufficient to debunk the narrative of greek being center of astronomy 👍

[@Bharatabharati]

I wish we still had our nalanda university

[@Dadda_Chambal_G.S._Academy]

जय भवानी

[@tanush841]

Dear Sir.. In Vishnupuran it's written that Dhurva Star was created by manifestation of the devotee Dhurva. So is it possible that the actual date of our Civilization may be much older than before creation of Pole star or Dhurva Star.

[@bharathrao3218]

Kentum/Satem divide says that Kentum is older than Satem. The direction is K->S. Kendra will have to be older than center by this argument. Kentum/Satem is a flawed theory, since we see bidirectional change. Eg: Kaisar (Greek ΚΑΙΣΑΡ)->Caesar(Latin)->Kaiser (German)

[@abhishekmishra8236]

🇮🇳🇮🇳🇮🇳

[@nkmahale]

Descartes' treatment of geometry makes trigonometry obsolete. Descartes' treatment is superseded by tensor representation; however, you need Descartes to facilitate tensor representation.

[@nkmahale]

Spin, Precession and Nutation are related by conservation of angular momentum of the Earth. This, of course, is only approximate and would be true only if the earth is isolated, technically if only a single body in the universe. But other planets affect this through gravitational interaction which is generally classed as tidal effect. Surprisingly the fact that the Moon shows exactly the same side to the Earth is due to tidal coupling and was a mystery until 1966! This was explained by Peter Goldreich in his Ph.D. thesis which was regarded as great accomplishment by none other than Richard Feynman. Tidal effects lock the ratio of orbital period and spin period to a small number if spin rate is not very high in comparison to orbital period.

[@experience_india]

16:01 😂😂 bang on point

[@TheB657]

1:31:34 - Most outside India people are descendants of Bharatiyas and Bharatiya sanskriti although they became malecha (non - vedic following tribe/society/community/people) , many still have few vestiges of our Dharmik civilization.

[@anupamagujadhur413]

Could you recommend some good books on astronomy/ Indian astronomy.

[@natalkumar6132]

Pushya Paksha Ayanamsa gets it right people , it is more closer to what Nilesh Ji states . Please use Pushya Paksha Ayanamsa.

[@shishirtamotia3992]

I think, in Kal Yug answers are sought using material objects. In other era the Rishi’s could think and understand the universe without the instruments.

[@Bharatabharati]

I love astronomy

[@shailendrayadavbp2361]

जय माता‌ की।

[@bhaveshdk]

Om

[@nkmahale]

Obsession has silver lining. Greeks were obsessed with circle as perfect solution to everything which lead to axiomatization of geometry. Indians had obsession with perfection of language and pronunciation which lead to most complete description of language by Panini. Greek obsession lead to Aristotelian Logic while Indian obsession with language lead to Nyaya System of Logic which is actually superior to Aristotelian logic, and was rediscovered as "Fuzzy Logic" in later part of 20th Century. Aristotelian Logic leads to paradoxes when applied to language though works perfectly when applied to finite systems. Nyaya System of Logic doesn't have this defect since it includes so called excluded middle ides at out set since it was developed to be applied to language in the first place. Mathematics needs natural language while natural language doesn't need Mathematics.

[@aniketaggarwal1224]

Fuzzy logic = Nyaya Logic Great revelation

[@nkmahale]

Before Newton it was all kinematics and scaling laws such as Kepler's Law. It is only after Newton that dynamics, through three laws of motion, came to life. Newton's Law of Gravitation in conjunction with Newton's three laws of motion explains most of Solar System.

[@murthykrishna3834]

Rashi is there in Tamil ancient literatures of Agasthya Muni

[@virenrathore1024]

sir if possible would love to meet you in person if possible...

[@GabbarSingh-Azad]

👌👌👌👍👍👍

[@rdrr5973]

indians knew precession ....gravity affect of moon

[@swastikagarwal5953]

Jai shree ram

[@anitachaudhary2144]

Please ye program hindi me bhi karo

[@jtta8282]

Can anyone explain what sanjay ji said at 14:45 , doctrine of discovery.

[@goutambhattacharya9068]

Vedic system of math should be taught in India.

[@ŕóśĥáń-3002]

२.१ लाख।।🚩

[@drishtisingh1373]

👍👍👍👍

[@nitink15]

In Ionian history i.e. Greek history (यवन इतिहास) they call Monarch ChandraGupta Maurya (सम्राट चंद्रगुप्त मौर्य) as Sandryacottas. In same way ancient Indian Text denoting Sanskrit word केंद्र as सेंत्र the Centre. यवन = आयोनियन = यवन म्लेंच्छ बर्बर = मोगल

[@dharmicrobin8367]

Sir :- namassssteeee Me :- 😍😍😍😁

[@oneindian9147]

🙏

[@rajnishagrawal423]

1/123/6 rigved उषा moving one by one by 30 yojan at a time.

[@rajeshmehta1933]

Surya Siddhanta is written by whom *when *WHICH LANGUAGE IN ORIGINAL.

[@rachitpatel1126]

रोज गार मुदा तो हमेशा रहेगा लेकिन उसे ज्यादा जनसंख्या नियंत्रण के बारे में सोच ना चाहिए, आज 135cr आबादी हे, आने वाले 50शाल के बाद करीब करीब 165cr से 175cr हो जाएगि 30cr_40cr ज्यादा जनसंख्या होगी तो समझो उस टाइम में Technology काफी advance होगी तो जाहिर है उष टाइम पर बेरोजगार खाफी ज्यादा होगे, ये सबसे ज्यादा चिंताकी बात हे लेकिन कोई आवाज उठाता नहीं है, बस आजकी शोचे और painkiller लेले। अश्ली मुदा उसकी जड़ों पर काम कोई नही करता, 50शाल पहले जनसंख्या नियंत्रण पर काम किया होता तो इतनी बेरोजगारी के बारेमें आज ये मुदा नही होता, ये हमे सोचना चाहिए आज हमे painkiller लेनाहे या आने वाले जनसंख्या विष्फोट से बच ना हे, ये हमे तय करना हे, तो देश में ईश बिल के लिए हमे माहोल बनाना चाहिए तब जाकर सरकार को बल मिलेगा और >One nation one Election >Uniform civil code >Population control bill पास कराओ, 🙏 जय श्री राम 🙏 जय श्री कृष्ण 🙏 हर हर महादेव 🙏

[@sarar4004]

🙏🇮🇳🙏🇮🇳🙏🇮🇳

[@KSHITIJPRATAPSHAHI]

Rigveda मे किसका भाष्य पढना चाहिए?