#NileshOak

[@jayant5601]

Great Nikesh ji. All your researches should reach maximum sanatani. Salute with big thank you.

[@AnandRajappan]

Long awaited session and really very encouraging to open up for critical thinking. Super session by Sri Nilesh Oak ji, as usual.

[@nagarajmb6345]

Xv

[@brahmanandgoyal9100]

@@nagarajmb6345 qqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqq0⁰qqqqq

[@deepakhem]

Our ancestors were very smart, they left the puzzle for us to solve.....

[@TheArora3]

I stumbled on it accidentally.. I think he is one of the best indologist I have heard. Very very enlightening discussion and presentation.

[@arunade1168]

Thank You Sir. You have completely changed our Views about the Great Indian Civilization. May young ones draw Inspiration from you & Re-established the position of Bharat on Apex of the Wisdom & Knowledge. 🕉️🌹💐🙏💐🌹🕉️

[@NileshOak]

🙏🙏

[@SJ-zo3lz]

@@NileshOak You have such a Dhanya Janm sir! I'm sure the spirit of this land, the millions of great sages she gave birth to would guide you in unravelling those great epochs! Please could you look into Adi Sankara's life ? I'm from Kerala. Per the Malayalam calendar said to be established by him, this is year 1196. Did he really live just 1196 years ago? Did Periyar river change course then?

[@NETKINGSHUBHO]

I have waited for over a week for this video.. thank you Jaipur diaries. Nilesh sir is the best Indologist ever

[@theriam6281]

Jaipur dialogues

[@dev4rajan]

Such invaluable Vdos gets few thousand Views while a Vdo with BiggBoss in title enough to get millions. A reason why History would repeat for Hindus!! Deserve it

[@jonik2121]

Dont me so disheartened I feel the ratio of people who r learned n wise versus the uninterested n ignorant is constant throughout the ages... It is the job of the learner to keep learning..n giving it to ppl who r ready to receive.. N it should start young slowly n steadily 🙂🙏

[@dev4rajan]

@@jonik2121 Agree, but this is not to say Iam wise ;) enough. There is stark contrast between us and ancestors, now as we get more educated(more degrees?) we are becoming mere nominals instead of showing interest in pursuing in depth, in this case, our ancient History.

[@jonik2121]

@@dev4rajan 🙂 yes we have education but not wisdom...but I see it changing n we must take it forward..with conscious effort...reading literature in our regional language..make our kids fluent in their mother tongue...so that it is not alien to them..so much knowledge is lost because we dont read in our mother tongue I have started myself reading in my mother tongue.. Also.slowly learning sanskrit It is an uphill task But one has to start somewhere right🙏🙏

[@nileshsharma8469]

It is a struggle and ll take time, but have faith, and believe it to be sure that this generation is studying and reading a lot, and curious to know all these factual and our history. Im very positive and feel happy everyday, looking youth, both the boys and gals to be studying and discussing sanatana and indus valley, so yes, we are on the right oath, however its a long journey, may take 2 or 3 generations at least. So, we ll be carbon dated, before we see the day of ultimate truth being told and believed by everyone. But, the day ll come.

[@रणबंकाराठौड़]

अद्धभुत प्रस्तुतिकरण। आप पर माँ भारती का आशीर्वाद सदैव बना रहे श्री नीलेश जी🙏🙏

[@indiannationalfirst8286]

What a intiligent man,,,, Thanks Jaipur dilogs,,,,,,

[@rnarayan62]

would have been better if we could have seen the slides

[@debanjanchakraborty4004]

Here you could listen to his explanation with slides kzbin.info/www/bejne/maWraIaNZcSHfKM

[@sanjeevnagargoje7162]

What a dedication , commitment n conviction sir !!! but Lokmanya Tilaks Artic home in the vedas n Gitarahasya must be referred !!!!!

[@pranavsinhchauhan8149]

Thank you for uploading this session..

[@vinodmishra2888]

Har. Gareb. Dash. Kea. Leya. Mar sakta..hea..lakin.harAmer..Nahi. Marsakta.unmea.Sea..hero.uddav. Bambea.kaa.kuch.Jeahadi

[@vinodmishra2888]

Sardar. Pateal. Kee. Spech. Sunlo Yea. Palnea. Valo. Ko. Hee. Kateaga Aaj. Bhul. Jao. Nahi. To. Marnea. Ko Teayar. Ho. Jao

[@ashokashtekar4265]

Simply mind blowing work done!!!

[@ugc1784]

It was such an enlightening experience and Sri Nilesh ji as usual introduced himself to us with that priceless information and professional presentation. But the camera work was hardly praiseworthy. Looked like it was immobile and could not be moved to any other direction.

[@deepakhem]

🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏 I had tears while listening to you Sir, I don't know why.....

[@porasshrivastava5637]

Amazing sir...you have expressed every single point with great depth and preciseness and I am going to read all of your books, and the scientific approach which you have inculcated in your stas is credible and precise....what you are doing and what you've done is praiseworthy ...👌👌🙏🙏

[@hansapatel6024]

This video is really eye opening lovely I enjoy it watching you sir 🙏

[@ankitsinghnegi3587]

Great research work..🙏

[@NativeVsColonial]

1. Krishna was born 3228 BCE 2. Month: Bhadrapada 3. Day: Ashtami 4. Nakshatra: Rohini 5. Biological Father: Vasudeva 6. Biological Mother: Devaki 7. Adopted Father: Nanda 8. Adopted Mother: Yashoda 9. Elder Brother: Balaram 10. Sister: Subhadra 11. Birth Place: Mathura 12. Maternal Uncle: Kansa 13. Shishupaala and Dantavakra: his cousins 14. Shri Krishna lived 125 years, 08 months, 07 days 15. Date of Death: 18th February, 3102 BCE 16. When Krishna was 89 years old; the mega war (Kurukshetra) took place 17. He died 36 years after the Kurukshetra war 18. Kurukshetra war started on Mrigashira Shukla Ekadashi, 3139 BCE 19. Bhishma died on first Ekadasi of the Uttarayana, 3138 BCE *Jai Shri Krishna* 🙏

[@media-rn6zc]

This is who's theory that you are writing? He has perfectly explained how he collected the evidence and came to his conclusion and you can refer to his book and rebut. Similarly, pls produce evidence of the theory you have written about so that it can be studied and rebutted if need be

[@krishnatrivedi5625]

Great job hope you finish the work And let all indians read the material, many questions are unanswered

[@bhagwatshah]

Great info. I wish the audio was as clear as the earlier session.

[@vajra4556]

Sound is not up to mark.

[@rajnishagrawal423]

After reading all the books, in goa, while going by car from अटल सेतु Bridge, three big balloons are flying distance apart each other near cruze big daddy, one day I observed that balloon no 1 South, balloon no 3 at North one is between them, during crossing the bridge road I observe the balloon no 3 visible second in sequence, because I read your book I understand your representation on vashisht and arundhati, whenever I passed bridge I was regularly observe and play with grand son, that by magic I am changing position of balloon.

[@NileshOak]

Thank you for sharing your beautiful experience. I did share it in my SM posts.

[@ravindas3148]

@@NileshOak Namaste Nileshji. Of late, I have been watching your videos...brilliant and ground-breaking research, I admit. Nileshji, going by your inferences, I am taken by discomfort relating to the Indian 'time scale' of yugas...In 1 chaturyugi, 1728000 years was satyayuga, 1296000 years was treta, 0864000 years was dvapara and 0432000 years is kaliyuga of which this is the 5121st year, this being the 28th manvantara. I, a lay person, don't know where these figures come from. But, I know it to be a long-standing belief originating, probably, from a purana. Could you kindly help me reconcile...dhanyavad.

[@sanjaybahety1113]

the video is incomplete without those slide presentation... not expected...

[@suryanarayanabegur2026]

PLEASE Mr Nilesh sir always make it a point to deliver your profound lectures in ENGLISH. It will not only enable some of us from south to understand & appreciate your lectures, but would also interest INDOLOGISTS from abroad to refurbish their stock in trade notions.!!

[@HasnaAbubekar]

Hindi is needed because northies are the biggest believers of western theories.

[@shishiragrawal4394]

Your presence is commanding

[@hasmukhjain891]

So informative 🌷🌷🌷🌷🌷🌷🌷🌷🌷🌷🌷🌷🌷🌷🌷🌷

[@UMS9695]

Enjoyed it thoroughly!

[@MyviewsonEnglish]

I hope that the truth will be accepted by the historians of the world.

[@murg27]

Use camera men who understand how to cover these kinds of events. Just focusing on the speakers face is like covering a political speech. It is frustrating every time he refers to the presentation and you cant see it.

[@crypton_8l87]

So true!

[@jbiswas5762]

The mythification of our Itihasa by Wendy, Pollock, Devdutt, Audre (all Xs), should have been made a punishable offence. They wrote entire books on just opinions, while here is a scientist with hard evidence.

[@accessanirban]

Nkj0oknjnpmnoo99s.okmp m

[@AshishSingh-ut6fk]

"...Anyone who does not understand english at all...please raise your hand" this question was asked in english, lol

[@lakshmivaidyanathan2254]

Hee hee that's what I was thinking that only

[@sanatanananta2100]

Audio is not clear. Please correct and relaunch

[@kamleshnautiyal3087]

रामायण महाभारत वैदिक काल की घटना-क्रम के समय भ-चक्र के 360 अंश-कला-विकला-प्रतिविकला में 12 ग्रहों, 12 राशियों, 27 नक्षत्रों की 12 भावों में पूर्ण सही स्थिति समय रहते पूर्ण सही हर एक सुरक्षा-शान्ति-खुशहाली सम्पन्न जीवन एवं जनरेशनों के जन्म-पोषण-संरक्षण के लिए हर एक अवसर पूरी तरह निःशुल्क भरपूर मिलता रहे,

[@priyadhar2011]

Thank you,🙏🙏🙏

[@jagranosho]

🕉🙏जय गुरुदेव🙏🕉

[@naveen508001]

Imagine a dream wherein someone is chasing and trying to hurt you, and you wake up all of a sudden. Your heartbeat is at its peak. In the above scenario, is the dream real, unreal or has it happened? On the physical plane (body) if we measure, only the heartbeat increase is seen. Some better measuring tools can show some brain activity. The question remains as to what has happened and has it happened. Mahabharata is known to have all the knowledge of the Vedas (Universe). So if you take any concept it has to be there is the epic. Let us see if Quantum mechanics is there in the epic. The dating of Mahabharata is an ongoing thing with each researcher coming up with a different date and having some points which support their observation. We see the Quantum mechanics principle of the act of observation affecting the outcome. So has Mahabharata happened? As you keep analysing this, it will make you question "the happening" itself. What does it mean to say that something has happened. This might sound crazy but as said Mahabharata should help us in understanding all the knowledge of the universe and this is a fundamental thing being questioned here. Our understanding of happening is limited and that needs to be corrected so that the question is answered itself. First, we have to be clear that not everything is happening in the physical plane and is visible. A celestial vision is needed to see things. Vyasa had given the vision briefly to Drupada (father of Draupadi) during the discussion if having five husbands is dharma, explaining the story behind it. Let us see an analogy for better understanding. If someone asks Is God there. The answer would depend on their existing understanding of God. That is the reason we have varied descriptions of God and as your understanding grows things become clear. The same has to be extended to happening. As is the case with the dream (happening inside a body) everything is happening within the entity called the Universe.

[@thisisnegi]

Great Sir 🙏

[@mangeshkulkarni7299]

Thank you for this session. I would like to see QndA session. I have one question. How the people in mahabharat or ramayana times observed or studied positions, movements of stars and planets without telescope. Is there any reference about this study and how did they do it.

[@yudrika3007]

Answer to your question is ancient Indians were not at all primitive..they had every single tool needed in the astronomical studies, scientistific studies, nuclear science studies, medicinal studies etc. They even had advanced tools for construction of such a beautiful temples we see today... For eg:- Kailasa temple( foreigners claim that it was built by Aliens, is it so?) No.. Becoz they have no option to say this thing due to lack of knowledge n to prove their claims to be true..that Indians had only chisels n hammers... Go n explore our ancient temples n you'll find that ancient Indians were so very advanced in technology in comparison to modern world... Or if you're not able to go n see these wonders..then just go through Praveen Mohan's video about archeological researches...hope he'll you to clear your doubts...🤟

[@HasnaAbubekar]

No telescope is required to see the movements of stars in sky. Naked eye is sufficient.

[@akshay1962]

Great contents but needs improvement in videography with slides

[@murg27]

Net time you do video coverage, please make sure the presentation screen is also visible. Because when he rfers to the screen and people cant see it then the understanding of the subject will not be in sync

[@bishtharmonicats1060]

🚩🚩🚩हर हर महादेव 🚩🚩🚩

[@prafullanath2152]

From some reference I got to know B G Tilak in his book used some astronomical triangulation and proposed this Aryan Invasion theory( Arctic home of the Aryans). Left historians repeatedly refer it. How far BG Tilak was correct in his argument?

[@akanshaverma1206]

Wow enlightening knowledge

[@dibyakantimahato7075]

Sir, I request to you to speak Hindi . Because all the Indians are understand that. Thank you.

[@abhimanyu2713]

He speaks very little Hindi as he has been living in US for 25-30 yrs . And his mother toungue is Marathi

[@atlantissurvivor9810]

not all indians

[@rudrarishi2523]

We will try to translate

[@abhishekanand8945]

Was the Q&A session recorded?

[@THEJAIPURDIALOGUES]

Abhishek Anand Link is available on request.

[@prasaddixit75]

@@THEJAIPURDIALOGUES please can i get the link to that q and a session ?

[@pradipk2448]

Fantastic, very scientific way of looking at our scriptures.. astronomy was our base.. somehow we fell in entangles of astrology (crap)

[@TheKinix13]

Amazing

[@debabratabanerjee7461]

Noted that time line Ramayana & Mahabharata (when Sanskrit was well developed) are older than Mahenjodaro & Harappa civilization ,then why the later's scripts cannot be deciphered at all? Why was there a need for a different script/language? Can anyone explain?

[@berdenmayur]

Because Sanskrit is laguage .sankrut is written in seven lipies like morden one devnagari .alse people use pali bramhi lipi to write languag.there is shushruta script find in morden china rasia border it was written in chaniea lipi but laguage was Sanskrit

[@debabratabanerjee7461]

@@berdenmayur Your reply does not answer my question. Sanskrit was there before & after Mohenjodaro & Harappa in the same region. Then why Mohenjodaro & Harappa had a complete alien language & skript which has not yet been deciphered ( as best as I Know). There is something not right about each other's time line.

[@berdenmayur]

@@debabratabanerjee7461 first search about difference between language and script.

[@debabratabanerjee7461]

@mayur berde : So you mean that all throughout the Mohenjo-Daro & Harappa era the language was Sanskrit but during that time the script used was different & un-decipherable?

[@berdenmayur]

Yes exactly

[@rajanikantjoshi9029]

Thanks to oak

[@MsRkshukla]

If mahabharat has evolved over the years from jaya to bharat to mahabharat. Will it be trustworthy for dating?

[@yogeshroy9913]

You have separate wheat from the chaff using logic and external evidence- can't go on like him saying everything is true.

[@v290576]

if devnagri lipi has been developed only 1000 years ago then in which language mahabharat was written 3500 years ago ??? ofcourse not in sanskrit because even today sanskrit cannot be written without devnagri lipi..

[@ajikottarathil3204]

@@v290576 it was not written, orally transmitted to generations, and in later years nearly 12th century got its final form. Thats why researchers say it has lot of additions and omissions in due course.

[@ravirajpandit2444]

@@v290576 1000 years? Dude there is pre vedic sanskrit, vedic sanskrit, post vedic sanskrit. And the script was developed during the vedic period, Which is more than 7k years.

[@aprati99]

Arundhati and vasistha are twin stars they say. One revolves around the other..right? In this process, it might occur that arundhati will be followed by vasistha.

[@rk99318]

Correct That phenomenon happened no less than 7000 years ago and no more than 12000 years ago.

[@keshavsikdar9284]

Beautiful.

[@thejohngalt]

Where can I find this speech along with a view of the slides?

[@theriam6281]

On srijan talks

[@theriam6281]

Or sangam

[@HasnaAbubekar]

Many of his talks with slides are on KZbin

[@thrinethran2885]

That a condition, say a disease, has a material here a physiological cause, does not obviate a karmic - psychic cause, such as a curse.

[@venkateshab5423]

Shriman, they are doing this because, we are not doing any time estimation.

[@KumarGaurav6064]

why so much chit-chat??

[@mr.artistpalwe2732]

am i the only one jisko kuch bhi samaj me nahi aya

[@takshak.09]

हिंदी भाषा का प्रयोग कर सकते थे

[@PH-jh6mw]

He asked in English to raise hand anyone who does not know English😂😂

[@takshak.09]

@@PH-jh6mw just to know how many are there

[@sumantpatnaik1451]

What Sir, In the beginning of your lecture you ask the audience in English; *if there is anyone who does not understand English " ? Aap bhi to same galti kar rahe ho Sir. Although I love your lectures but kindly be a little more careful while making such comments. Namaskara 🙏

[@radhamaadhav4609]

Hare krishna 🙏🏼pls promote these videos . There are many videos giving importance to mortal aliens. People think our gods are mere mortal aliens. Request everyone to read Srimad Bhagavatam and Bhagavat Gita and subscribe these kind of videos. Enough damage done already to sanatan dharm lets save our sanatana dharma by learning the difference between the divine and mortal extra terrestrials

[@canadalifemaharajaranchhod2322]

આજની જનરેશન માટે ભારતીય સંસ્કૃતિ અને ઇતિહાસ નો subject ફરજિયાત કરવામાં આવે તો સારું રહેશે.

[@satyajitverma2158]

Good, Mahabharat dating portion OK but instead of talking about dating methodology - only stories about Ramayan episodes! And the audience was sitting hungry!

[@rk99318]

There are many videos of him and also published books, his blog. Go through it if you are interested to find more evidence.

[@ManOfSteel1]

bears sleep for a long time and eat accordingly so they dont die in their hibernation process

[@bappa2161]

मैं खुद ये सब चीज जनाना चाहता हु ओर जन जन तक पहुंचाना चाहता हु पर भाषा का माध्यम हिंदी हो

[@bappa2161]

भैया हिंदी में बोलो न तो ज्यादा अच्छा रहेगा हमारे जैसा व्यक्ति भी अच्छे से समझ पायेगा

[@justforknowledge6367]

I am not sure if Nilesh ji will refer to these lines ever. If he does this should be a caution for him to direct the organisers of his talks to consider these aspects. This is a DUMB video. Focussed on Nileshji's face. Multiple references to Slides and Charts (likely) are simply not within the video. Nor are the requisite links provided. Watching this video quickly became irritating, to say the least. Organisers of The Jaipur Dialogues were expected to have a greater sense of responsibility and have used their minds on these aspects.

[@bhairabduttpandey3360]

I think you want to read sir's book

[@justforknowledge6367]

@@bhairabduttpandey3360 I already possess Nilesh ji's first three books. I was actually talking about the poor cinematography that ruined the talk, because of ignoring charts / pictures.

[@bhairabduttpandey3360]

@@justforknowledge6367 ok bhai

[@chandraspant8679]

जिसे काल अवधी का ज्ञान न हो वो हमें बताएगा श्री राम कब अवतार लिए थे ? सतयुग की अवधी १७ लाख से अधिक की है त्रेता की १२ लाख ९६ हजार , द्वापर ८ लाह ६४ हजार कलियुग ४ लाख ३२ हजार त्रेता के लगभग मध्य में श्री राम हुए तो कितने वर्ष हुए ?? आदि गुरु शंकराचार्य की बात कर रहे हो तो उनको भी हमने नहीं देखा वह भी पुस्तकों में ही लिखा है ?

[@chandraspant8679]

@Shaktiman Channel द्वापर ८ लाख ६४ हजार कलियुग के ५ हजार त्रेता के लगभग मध्य में श्री राम हुए तो लगभग ८ लाख और जोड़कर कुल बनाता है १६ लाख ६९ हजार के पहले !! अतः श्री राम का अवतार गणितीय केलकुलेशन के अनुसार १६ लाख ६९ हजार के पहले का बनता है।।

[@chandraspant8679]

@Shaktiman Channel होशियारपुर के इन होशियार चंदों को मेरा कहना है श्री राम का नाम तो रामायण और पुराणों के आधार पर सत्य मान रहे है तो फिर त्रेतायुग के जन्म और उसी रामायण और पुराणों में दिए समय को क्यों सही नहीं मान रहे है ? ये दोहरे लोग है। या मानो या मत मानो ! इन्हें छेड़छाड़ करने की परमिशन कौन दिया है ?? ये सनातन धर्म के मोदरान टाइप विरोधी है जो अपनी लच्छेदार स्टाइल में इस तरह से हिन्दू का अपमान करते है।

[@shreyanshsharma9787]

people coughing in the background scaring me #corona

[@kanishkgulwadi9245]

14000 yrs ago it was ice age. Ramayana happened 1400 yrs ago. Acc to prof BB Lal

[@sunilkumarpanday969]

Where we can put Indus Valley civilization

[@NileshOak]

~7000 BCE through ~1800 BCE

[@NileshOak]

@May ur I agree that 'IVC' is also a dogma. It is all Indian civilization. It is a blunder to excavate one place or one area and think of it as 'another' civilization.

[@sunilkumarpanday969]

@May ur thank you so much

[@sunilkumarpanday969]

@@NileshOak thank you sir 🙏

[@akhileshsharma8582]

कृपया हिंदी में बोलो अगर ज्यादा लोगों तक अपनी बात पहुंचाना है तो सामने बेठे पचास लोगों से मत पूछो कोनसी भाषा बोलना है बाद में लाखों लोग इ से देखेंगे

[@moolnivasiwaheedraye5024]

Sir find the date of birth of spider Man please.

[@Ur_Aman_17]

First, find or prepare your paper 😂

[@sanjaychaudhary9128]

Sir woh kaam madarassa achha karta hai 😂😂

[@quasiosa]

@@sanjaychaudhary9128 oo maa go turu lob😂😂

[@arunsamele5647]

हिंदी में भी lecture दे नहीं तो ज्ञान जेब में रखे अपने

[@chandankumarprasad2138]

Hindi me bolte to achha hota

[@moolnivasiwaheedraye5024]

You nice gay.

[@akashfixolite]

sir, your reserch is wrong ,river can change there flow pattern many times ,sorry but mahabharat and ramayana can be dated by carbon dating techniques from stones of dwarka ,and ayodhya so please dont focus on this Christian prophecy. we are very old civilization, that's why we are so advanced in terms of soul knolowdge.

[@moolnivasiwaheedraye5024]

You are looking for begining of a myth !!!!

[@keshavjha5091]

Can you explain how ??

[@NikhchansGaming]

Its a THEORY. He made it abundantly clear.