Can We Redeem The Internet’s Worst Food Crime?

Today, Josh and Nicole are trying to cook legitimate meals using TikTok's most horrific food crimes!
Subscribe to Mythical Kitchen: www.youtube.co...
Submit your Dreams Become Food photos here: forms.gle/cBop...
Check out our podcast, A Hot Dog Is A Sandwich!
Apple Podcasts: mythic.al/ahdias
Spotify: mythic.al/hotdog
Click the bell icon so you'll know when we add a new video!
Want more Mythical Kitchen? Check out these playlists:
Fancy Fast Food - • Fancy Fast Food | Myth...
Snack Smash - • Snack Smash | Mythical...
Food Fears - • Food Fears | Mythical ...
Food Feats - • Food Feats | Mythical ...
Pick up official Mythical Kitchen merch at mythical.com/c...
Check out Sporked, Mythical's new website dedicated to helping you find the best food on the shelves! - www.sporked.com
Join the Mythical Society: www.mythicalso...
Follow Mythical Kitchen:
Instagram: / mythicalkitchen
Facebook: / mythicalkitchen
Mythical Chef Josh's Instagram: / mythicalchefjosh
Follow Mythical:
Instagram: / mythical
Facebook: / mythical
Twitter: / mythical
Website: mythical.com
Check Out Our Other Mythical Channels:
Good Mythical Morning: / goodmythicalmorning
Rhett & Link: / rhettandlink
Ear Biscuits: applepodcasts....
Good Mythical MORE: / goodmythicalmore
Want to send us something? mythical.com/c...
In the spirit of minimizing food waste associated with the filming of this series, Mythical is donating to the Hollywood Food Coalition ( hofoco.org ) who provide daily, nourishing meals to underserved communities in the Los Angeles area.
Closed Captioning provided by Rev
Get Mythical Kitchen gadgets and equipment!
Pots and Pans - www.amazon.com...
Instant Read Thermometer - www.amazon.com...
Immersion Blender - www.amazon.com...
Dehydrator - www.amazon.com...
Vitamix Blender - www.amazon.com...
Food Processor - www.amazon.com...
Kitchen Aid Stand Mixer - www.amazon.com...
Kitchen AidPasta Attachment - www.amazon.com...
Spice Grinder - www.amazon.com...

[@tripletoruses]

Nicole puts so much love and details in her recipes and then the freak of nature storms into frame and barks all over his food shoves it into his apron pockets, jiggles it around, and presents it on his plate. one of my favorite series

[@tuxieblue_onyxshadow_adahm201]

Your comment had me dying 🤣🤣🤣🤣. Thank you!

[@Mephistozenith]

Nicole has yet to truely grasp that you need to be a full blown food criminal to succeed in this contest. she is too pure, too good, she needs to have this vile food darkness in her heart in order to defeat Josh.

[@CedricBassman]

This is unironically true. Her problem is that she looks at the Food Crimes, the Flavors, and always tries to mask or run from them in some way. She plays it safe. Meanwhile Josh dives headfirst into them and tries to elevate them, without trying to hide the original flavors.

[@joellynncrowthers4623]

Or biased judges like the smosh dudes

[@SmokeyTheBandit]

​@joellynncrowthers4623 Josh is not a "Smosh dude" and nobody is biased. He's just better at what he does. Not everything is a conspiracy.

[@sclemson8541]

"nutso" "sick twisted" "a delicious doughnut for perverts" what a good explanation of Josh's cooking

[@LemmonDP]

You could just make a regular peanut butter cup but fill it with sweet red bean paste and it would probably work pretty well.

[@geronimus4288]

do it.

[@daasbuffy]

Or even the flavoured white bean paste (if you can get your hands on them).

[@ceceliakra7234]

I was going to comment the exact same thing. 🍡 (How is there no mochi emoji!?) Alternatively, there is such thing as navy bean pie, it's very cinnamony and creamy. (10/10, love navy bean pie) That same concept could make a great cup filling.

[@ceramiccoconut]

Yeah, this was my thought, as well.

[@13thMaiden]

Yeees the mung beans would work well with this.

[@ginacronkhite8698]

Nicole referencing Josh's childhood trauma and suddenly finding herself torn between laughing at the joke and almost making herself cry again was a moment

[@Jzzmus]

The cultured man, Josh: *Makes stellar ‘The Producers’ & Steinbeck references* Also cultured man, Josh: “Don’t whip your beans too much, or you’ll get hairy palms”

[@Ibetrolling1337]

Thats the adhd with no filter

[@TheFilmsKaper]

leopold bloom, isnt that from ulysses? which makes it more impressive

[@NotUlpoadingAnything]

@@TheFilmsKaper Leopold Bloom is one of the main characters from the movie "The Producers." He's an a nervous accountant who winds up becoming a Broadway producer by the end of the movie. There are two versions, the one with Gene Wilder that Josh mentioned, and the remake based off the Broadway musical.

[@mpbx3003]

The way Jordan described the doughnut as "a delicious doughnut for perverts" at 24:04 spoke to me so much. She absolutely nailed the vibe of this entire channel.

[@smitty2821]

Mythical Kitchen: Food Perverts - "They don't molest kids. They just molest the culinary arts!" What a tagline

[@chosethebluepill]

Red bean filling is such a popular thing in Korean and Japanese desserts, so I was surprised Josh struggled this mmuch.

[@stephaniek4508]

When he said he was making doughnuts, I thought he would make a version of anpan, but he took a weird turn.

[@thewhiteniinja]

it gets a lot harder when it's based on baked / bbq style beans

[@Kelarys]

I think it would have been a huge copout if he just used dessert beans. That wasn't really the point of the challenge

[@elizacarrie7433]

It seems unfair to use red bean tho. That would be like if they were in a baked potato challenge and they used Ube

[@Natethegr809]

Petition to make Josh eat a 1 pound jawbreaker in one sitting

[@jscotthatcher380]

once me and my friends did that as teenagers in a competition to see who could finish theirs first. never again. would not recommend. 😂

[@jasperdoesstuff9082]

Live stream idea

[@Perfftetysheeeeeets]

But he has soft teeth ):

[@Plain_Lane]

So like Ed, Edd and Eddy?

[@MeAuntieNora]

RIP his tongue.

[@plumislands]

was not expecting josh to win this one based on how it was going lol

[@rachelh1720]

if Rhett had judged I'm fairly confident Nicole would have won, even with her chocolatey beans

[@shadowfyre.]

One of the first examples of the Reese’s Bean-nut Butter Cup being popularized was a photoshopped image created by James Allen McCune, posted to Twitter in 2019 - it’s still the top result on Google Images when searching “peanut butter cup beans”. William Osman (of scuffed engineering KZbin fame) made a video later that year where he recreated the bean-nut butter cups and then tried them with James Allen McCune. Prior to 2019, there are no examples (that I am aware of) of the bean-nut butter cup existing as it does in the thumbnail of this video, akin to James Allen McCune’s original image.

[@Person2541]

Famous actor James Allen McCune?

[@IsaTehGothicMando]

Course, William Osman did make them first

[@Poppacap79]

From SP7?

[@gr33ngirlsea]

Thank you for being an internet historian!! 😊

[@andrewfenton7278]

This, I was afraid the original knowledge was lost with most but I also remember and I'm glad that you do to.

[@THEUrinalCake]

There is a fine line between genius and madness and on that line Josh has built himself a lovely cottage where he lives year round.

[@jogreer9814]

How did you not get Rhett to try a beanut butter cup?

[@vincedibona4687]

Why y’all trying to ruin tomorrow’s episode of GMM?

[@SirJorb]

Will it... cup?

[@liamoneill7692]

Instead we got Jordan. Lame.

[@musicmaniac32]

I thought it would be Link because of how much he loves peanut butter and "Ree-seas." But "Yassified Link" is just as good if not better. I love Jordan! Has she been on a Hotdog is a Sandwich yet?

[@Brasc]

Josh is like the Jazz Chef. He gets on his stage with his instruments, he improvises, he throws random sounds around, but in the end it somehow comes together and works.

[@jonstamey8409]

I love these episodes and no matter how hard nicole trys josh is just the master of making food crimes better

[@benf6822]

It's genuinely where he excels. He isn't the best at everything, but he absolutely is the best at making something that shouldn't work work.

[@abbyenglish7020]

It's because, in the best way, he's a human trash panda. He can take any wild mixture of junk food and elevate it.

[@jessicaclakley3691]

No, imo Nicole gets robbed bc this is Josh’s brand and it means something for him to win

[@Jzzmus]

@@jessicaclakley3691he’s lost plenty of competitions before; and I don’t think Jordan would pick him for that reason

[@benf6822]

@@jessicaclakley3691 losing one wouldn't ruin his brand, he's been wrong and lost plenty of things involving chances he took that didn't work. He happens to be really good at this one.

[@gauchegreyhound]

I want to see Nicole channel Keith Habersberger and start screaming at the judges 😂

[@HonestWolf4Lif3]

YESSSSSSSSSS

[@d.sblack5900]

It isn’t just bold flavor that wins it’s embracing the flavors of the food crime.

[@NerdLifeChoice]

Josh killed it with this one; that abomination of a donut looks ready to go on sale in a bougie boulangerie where you expect to get weird stuff that tastes good.

[@erikdesoir]

It's interesting how Josh wins competitions when it's 1-on-1 but Nicole wins more team-based challenges.

[@joshwilliams8863]

8:10 - I feel like I just want to quote Captain Picard to Nicole: "It is possible to commit no mistakes and still lose. That is not a weakness. That is life."

[@_korbo_]

Regardless of the outcome of these episodes, the more time that passes, the more I love nicole. Nicole keep doing your thing!

[@melody_shmelody]

Josh knew the whole time it was delicious. He was rubbing Nicole about being self deprecating but I see right through you, Josh.

[@rethwi]

Nicole!!!! I’m so angry that you haven’t received your WELL deserved win!!! You got this sister!!!!

[@mytbread108]

Well of course Josh removes the bowl in the most awkward way possible. He still has issues with turning on appliances, especially the blender. He also can't secure lids on the instant pot and food processor. The biggest issue of all is his unnatural ability to touch and eat food directly from the deep fryer.

[@MrVovansim]

They made beanut butter cups, and didn't have Rhett try it? What are y'all thinking?

[@bonnieb9238]

exactly! I dont think Jordan is a great judge either. They just keep trying to push spork and no one is interested

[@sachyriel]

@@bonnieb9238 Spork is a great rabbit hole, If you like reading listicles of Best Product. TBH I read them on my phone in bed in big batches, what a rabbit hole.

[@EFFITEFFIT]

@@bonnieb9238 THANK YOU! I don't mind Jordan that much and actually think she can be funny on the main channel sometimes. But the amount of promotion and how hard Mythical tries to shove SPORKED at us, I have a feeling it was a massive waste of resources and money. Failed experiment, time to move on guys

[@LLG-ix8kd]

@@bonnieb9238I used sporked everyday lol what

[@kayh9090]

​@@EFFITEFFITi have to politely disagree. My husband and I have tried a few of the sporked recommendations and were pleasantly surprised. One becoming somewhat of a staple in our snack rotation.

[@narfeyfjola]

Famous actor James Allen McCune created the Bean-nut Butter Cup and actually also the Snickle which you've featured before. They were both part of a series of messed up food photoshops he posted on Twitter

[@benb55point55]

Famous actor Mickey Mouse. Aw nah dude!

[@Kelarys]

This series is everything that the dart competition Rhett and Link did used to be for me before Link learned how to win and I'm so happy. The joy I feel from Josh sneaking in with the victory despite somehow being an undefeated underdog. Incredible.

[@leahacampbell8656]

Nicole’s confidence is empowering, inspiring, and most importantly- valid. She is so good at what she does and I love watching her in her element, whether it’s talking smack or making magic in the kitchen. She is “stunning, gorgeous, beautiful.” ❤

[@Neal_YouTube]

"No, I can't have done it again." ~ Josh as he totally believes he could do it again.

[@Fuhnora]

"Delicious Donut for Perverts" is my new favorite

[@keithmwest]

I'm not a chef, but I feel like Josh should have made a whipped cream and blended the beans seperate and folded them together. It seems like it has so much potential!

[@Sardine_3]

I know this is random, but I think Josh should make the nastiest version of any food possible and see how much Trevor can eat

[@snithfferx]

Josh, Maybe some search could be good next time. You made "Anpan", is a japanese desert, make with sweet beans inside a bun. Also, Mole, has a version where chocolate is the main ingrediant. Also, also... I think nicol has the win. but, next time, no use sweet chocolate, you have too much sugar in your recipe

[@joneg7777]

Love how much Josh respects Nichole. So much respect, he doesn't pull back when gloating his victory despite her deplorable state. Beautiful

[@demitriussmith741]

The most obvious thing that came to mind for me was chili. Many people put cocoa and a little bit of sugar in their chili.

[@ARabidPie]

That or go full Mole sauce

[@haleywood8040]

@@ARabidPiethat’s what I was thinking. Or red bean paste if u wanted to keep it sweet

[@galix_c]

Mythical is really out here fist fighting my depression

[@NaAa-lc5lm]

Same here

[@itkejoki3818]

Right? This 25 minute fighting of how far a culinary mind can venture into the unknown, did a straight muay thai back-hand slam into the face of mine.

[@Courier_07]

josh repping a dan sugarman shirt 😭 i love ice nine kills sm

[@Boomstick_94]

Gotta love josh's Dan Sugarman shirt! Ice nine kills ftw! 🤘

[@victorevans2867]

Josh having less than no faith in the doughnut then winning is hilarious. "This is delicious. This is a doughnut for perverts."😂

[@RuttorBlacksand]

Some say Nicole is still stuck to the chair to this day

[@karenamanda1958]

I want those ribs!!! I’d like the donut if it was filled with sweetened adzuki beans instead of pintos. Huge hug for Nicole 🤗

[@mikellanas1207]

Josh "I'm a donut pervert." Me too, Josh, me too!

[@galacticmechanic1]

Josh is the king of trash food, nicole did so great but come she's coming for the king.

[@mandijones551]

How did nobody think to go with a recipe using red bean paste. Its basically a sweet food staple!

[@zevo9314]

probably because using red bean paste would defeat the purpose of the challenge. the challenge is making chocolate and baked beans work together

[@aprilvanillasunshine8408]

Yeah it would have been perfect to build on! I thought the same thing And then Josh kind of made a sweet bean paste in the end anyway 😅 so we were still right

[@MrCunningham4]

Keep trying Nicole! I believe in you!

[@adude6896]

Have you guys ever tried making a bean pie? It's a staple desert in many black cultures. Pro tips if you search recipes online-you almost always need to triple the listed seasoning to the mix, and the beans need to be way smoother than you've probably ever made them before to avoid baked bean texture. I'm talking run through a very fine meshed sieve type of smoothness. Would love to see your attempt at the dish!

[@ArnLPs]

I want Nicole to win one of these, like how I always wanted Candace to bust Phineas and Ferb.

[@MeeowzerStrike]

My immediate thought was sweet red beans that they use for desserts and snacks in Asia. Goes great with chocolate

[@AcktongueBaby]

I'll tell you what's a crime is that baggie sticking out the top of that drawer behind Josh on his right.

[@British_Rogue]

Do the thing requested for a dollar, then withhold whatever the requested thing is until the debt is settled.

[@abigailvanvleet]

YES another cooking episode!

[@oscarchacon2878]

I really thought Nicole was laying the foundation for "because he's jewish" when saying Josh doesn't pay people lol

[@NeverMetABadCheesecake]

Has anyone asked Nicole if she's doing alright lately? Everyone else jokingly trash talks ... she just straight up bullies everyone with an air of superiority. The joking trash talk is a much better look.

[@LowbrowDeluxe]

I will never not be amused by chefs, "add a hefty pinch of salt" *immediately reaches back into the salt for more*

[@zacharyhahn7670]

I’m confused on Jordan’s judging. It supposed to be a take on baked beans and chocolate and having baked beans was a complaint. What?

[@lexiefaith]

Josh talking about whipping out a guitar immediately reminded me of the Barbie movie. Josh is Kenough.

[@tuxieblue_onyxshadow_adahm201]

The only thing I could think of during this was they should have remade B. Dylan Hollis' bean pie recipe....

[@AlsoGDotNosis]

Either get Josh on a Food Theory episode, or get MatPat on Last Meal. Or both. Both is good. It’d be the best chaotically informative collaboration the internet has ever seen

[@acgeewhiz]

I had a realization. Nicole is out here trying to be Batman, fighting the food crimes because she thinks that doing wacky stuff with food is her ally. "But she merely adopted the food crimes. Josh was born in it, molded by them. He didn't see good food until he was already a man, by then it was nothing to him but potential crimes!"

[@jfellsie]

You definitely could do an Asian fusion take on this with a barbecue pork, peanut sauce, and red bean filling with a bittersweet chocolate exterior.

[@Knee_Boy64]

"This is a delicious donut for perverts" is the best review I've ever heard from Jordan

[@kellinomnom]

LOL! I've been saying 'I'll give you a dollar...' for as long as I can remember. My dad said I used to say that to him when I was 4 and he doesn't know where I picked it up 😂😂😂

[@Uberphish]

The trouble here is that Josh just has too much practice from working on Will It? prior to this. Making things that shouldn't be somehow taste better than they have any right to was literally part of his job description! To beat him, first you must make several foods out of entirely unrelated foods... and possibly also a bile cheesecake.

[@KimtheBakedPotato]

Agreed! I love watching Josh cook. He's def my favorite of all the kitcheneers. But I agree, he's experienced. Should be battles amongst the other kitcheneers with Josh judging!

[@twinjas512]

To be fair Josh wins the challenges where they have to make insane foods and Nicole wins when they make normal food 😂 they both have strengths!!

[@geminiofel]

That Dan Sugarman shirt! First the Otep reference, now this. 🤌🤌🤌🤌

[@DanSugarman]

lollll just keeps getting better

[@DiyosaLifeTV]

The doughnuts make sense to me because I love mung bean bread. But I would probably love the ribs with beans, as well. 😍

[@scotthatfield8479]

Love the Dan Sugarman shirt Josh!! Great guitarist for a fantastic band!

[@AllabackA]

Not me setting the audio of Nicole laughing while saying 'you're a boob' as my new alarm clock sound lmao

[@EK-xz8ig]

I'm pretty sure Josh dissing his donut while cooking was an act, to make his win appear like the underdog

[@MsSamareh]

No matter what, I'm always rooting for Josh.

[@BigDaddy-vr2ut]

1:38 look at Nicole pretending she don’t like this food. 😂👌🏻

[@biltonomega5682]

“Childhood trrrraaumaaa” lol. I imagine Josh loved her ripping him apart

[@RubyDoobieScoo]

Nicole merely adopted food crimes, Josh was born in them, moulded by them.

[@jennaheiser625]

Nicole: There aren’t really any particulates in this sauce. Also Nicole: *adds brown sugar and multiple spices*

[@vincedibona4687]

I don’t get it. That’s not the particulates she was referring to and you know it. You willfully misinterpreted her statement just to make this silly joke in the comments. _slow clap_ 👏🏻

[@aarongreen1654]

@@vincedibona4687 Really? What particulates do you think she was referring to? 🤡

[@jennaheiser625]

@@vincedibona4687 She might have meant there aren’t any particulates needing emulsifiers? Brown sugar is particulate, but is also hydrophilic.

[@ill2dawill]

Love you, Nicole!!❤

[@vincedibona4687]

Nicole channeling Paula Deen when she said “pap-a-REE-ka” gave me the giggles. 😂

[@vincedibona4687]

At the end, Nicole channeling Trevor from his last loss made me a little sad, but I still giggled 🤭.

[@noahklauser]

When Nicole ate that bite of pork, I was more jealous than ever in my life, it looked so good

[@imwizy8293]

Josh is chaos in the best way possible

[@kelseypalmer7035]

I’m shipping. If josh and Nicole don’t end up together then I am becoming a real mythical beast

[@4lyeskas]

Nicole is married and Josh is engaged??

[@ghostreporting3769]

Its fun that sometimes on this show you can see the bullets being loaded into the chamber for good mythical morn.

[@SpinX522]

If you want to make the beans the French Canadian way, just add some maple syrup to the recipe and of course no chocolate.

[@Kilamwatkins]

A peanut butter donut with a bean pie fill and the chocolate glaze w/ candy bacon would have been great

[@thaddeusk]

Josh is the embodiment of food crimes, so he excels at this.

[@BluesfireTV]

Am I the only one who fails to see how Josh's mixer bowl removal technique is "Asinine and stupid"? Seemed perfectly fine to me lmao

[@The_Crooked_Path]

Love the Dan Sugarman shirt. Josh has great taste

[@ethereality1565]

i was hoping i’d see someone else who noticed!! 😄

[@psychrot]

Second this 👍

[@DanSugarman]

brooooo I lost it when I saw this hahahaha

[@benjabaccabean2103]

Petition to teach Josh what Game Theory is and possibly have MatPat come on to guest chef

[@mingpagoda]

Azuki bean donuts exist. Embrace the sweet red bean paste.

[@livierae95]

Loving the Dan Sugarman shirt, Josh!

[@DanSugarman]

riiight!

[@InquisitorLavellan]

can mythical kitchen collab with Keith from the tryguys again? you're so funny

[@SparktehFox]

Beans are legumes. Peanuts are legumes. Peanut Butter is made from legumes. Peanut Butter Cups are already Bean-nut Butter Cups

[@markjohnson-rz2sc]

Petition for mythical kitchen to make or hire vulgar chef to make all of his amazingly delicious food.

[@TheLadyLiddell]

Josh mentioning Game Theory makes me want a Food Theory x Mythical Kitchen crossover.

[@LeeBasil]

Nicole's childhood trauma dance ended me on the spot

[@blankoblanco]

Josh Scherer is one of the greatest minds of my generation, and I will die on that hill.

[@terencedigan3932]

Josh shouted out “The Producers.” He wins on that alone. Edit: complete with his very own “Where Did I Go Right?” moment.

[@Electricdynamite]

Nicole specifically plating "brown things" is a win for Josh.

[@mountednoble]

Thanks for keeping me in chuckles you guys! Great content!

[@quidy2764]

I gotta say I was really hoping for Rhett to be the judge because BEANNNSSS

[@pmcdermott]

Nicole’s little diddy of childhood trauma made me lol

[@HaltNCatchFire]

No one has mentioned his Dan Sugarman shirt. Shout out Ice Nine Kills!

[@pugmonzzz]

Was just scrolling through looking for this comment. \m/

[@DanSugarman]

LETS GOOOOO