Na'Ziyah Harris Case: Jarvis Butts preliminary hearing closing arguments

[@bellabella9100]

They need to charge that damn auntie and grandma with child endangerment

[@toshianawest7579]

definitely the auntie should be charged she allowed her to go around that man unsupervised knowing he was a registered sexual offender and predator who targeted women who had young daughters and girls who were close relatives yo sexually abused them

[@antjortina]

Yes you’re so right. I agree

[@MrsRoRo2fine]

You black girls are always over sexual by the black women who should protect them with terms She "fast.""gtown" "hot ass" NEVER holding the man accountable still blaming the victim in death

[@lisamoton7776]

That grandma and auntie knew what was going on and chose to ignore it ! They are to blame for this as well . This beautiful young lady didn’t deserve any of this ! God bless her soul ❤🙏🏽

[@thekaerichtexas]

The ending was soooooo grwat, the judge said EVERYTHING we were thinking in the chat. No matter what happens in this case, im soooo glad the judge said everything she said to all parties involved. She held back but didnt hold back. Much respect to the judge. 👩‍⚖️ 👏 👏 👏

[@kimkeller2983]

I couldn’t agree with you more….everyone failed her and it’s sad, what’s even worse is that the first officer they interviewed with his lazy ass, did the bare minimum because he was retiring. It’s like nobody had a care in the world for this child, and the women that he dated CLEARLY had a low self esteem and low standards, because how can you continue to date someone who you know is messing around with other women, you’ve convinced yourself that he’s a good father figure and a dad to his kids…this was sad ALL THE WAY AROUND 🤦🏽‍♀️

[@peachprince4168]

That part

[@staceyjackson5192]

I been watching this this last yr

[@MsBrittChannel]

👩🏽‍⚖️👩🏽‍⚖️👩🏽‍⚖️👩🏽‍⚖️👩🏽‍⚖️

[@tiandcimom]

Yes she did! I’ve watched the judges speech soooo many times cause she literally said everything I’ve been thinking and feeling all week following this case?

[@KelarRivera]

The defense is fighting for their life. They know defending him is a lost cause. Their questioning doesn’t even make sense.

[@naraanderson5256]

OMG right 😡 Give it uppppp

[@TheCrissyb31]

They are just talking in circles cause they know he's guilty.

[@adrienvanetta553]

At all! Some of the questions actually seem more damaging 🥴

[@lifeofcashley]

He don’t deserve a gotdamn defense team

[@lifeofcashley]

FAST FORWARD!!!!!

[@ticca_9217]

I agree

[@Camistar85]

Idek what the defense is talking about! They know his ass is cooked!

[@MsBrittChannel]

@Camistar85 Literally grasping at anything hoping it stick .. It makes them look incompetent, but in all actuality it’s because the evidence is strong, even without a body they can’t properly defend him

[@aliciabriones3984]

@@MsBrittChannelwell said

[@infiniti2073]

Wow thanks Judge Sabree the entire family failed this child. Grandmother, Aunt, Business Partner and the PREDATOR!!! Your words brought me to tears. #LittleBlackGirlsMatter

[@shonequeaugustine6021]

Absolutely

[@Ninotchka0902]

They did, and I’m glad she called them out … one by one.

[@Nisha_84NY]

💪🏾🫶🏽#LittleBlackGirlsMatter

[@leashannnn1216]

💔💔💔

[@KpTheG]

People have to be so desperate to keep a man that they endanger the welfare of their children and others! He never should’ve been around anyone’s children & these women never should’ve even given him the time of day knowing what he was already convicted of!

[@junkandthangs]

He’s light skin with good hair and may be able to fix their beat up cars so they can get back and forth to work.

[@aliciabriones3984]

@@junkandthangsthe cars were so beat up!! The car he borrowed from the one was all falling apart and the inside was trashed. Then the so called fiancé said she drove a 2005 suburban. 😭

[@Love_me408]

I seen that also n she sitting up with no problem* like Lady you had a baby with a known predator no one can say they didn't he liked messing with like kids. This world is a ghetto

[@Camv-fs8nk]

And she gave him 5 kids smh

[@Love_me408]

@@Camv-fs8nk who was messing with after he got out the first time. So some thing wrong with them mentally! No one can tell me differently

[@HoneyBchildz]

Why was he allowed to hide behind his attys? He should have been made to sit at that darn table .

[@Countrygirl44]

With his mask off!!!

[@destinyhorton5304]

All that shave his head bald tf!

[@KpTheG]

They need to check that river again & any body of water it leads into. Time to bring that baby home so she can rest!

[@opalmaytoday5625]

He owned a mechanic shop. I think he disposed of her body in a car crushing yard honestly. Perhaps they’ll search those type of places and request a video to see if they notice anything strange with him. 🤞🏾

[@juliewillis6499]

Yes please do go search the Detroit River and the place where he worked at

[@juliewillis6499]

Yes

[@MsBrittChannel]

@@opalmaytoday5625 I was thinking the same, that he used something he had access to at his business to burn her remains. I looked deep into this case, they had a dive team in the water, and K9 unfortunately she passed away Jan9, and they didn’t start searching for almost a month. Knowing the decomposition process, her remains would be unable to identify

[@ShiquitaKendle]

I think the auntie unalived her and he possibly helped dispose of the remains

[@agooden90]

To the Honorable Judge Sabree, I just want to thank you!! Thank you for being a voice for this little girl that had her entire life left to live, and a monster as you rightfully called him took that from her. Thank you for your professionalism and for being brave enough to tell that pos what he really is! I commend you, you have inspired me more than I could ever put in words! Much Love from North Carolina! ❤️

[@lifeofcashley]

wow the end brought me to tears. What a sick sick sick world we are living in! God do what you have to do to make your world safe again because this is not it. Lord have mercy on our souls

[@PrOpHeTiC9786]

if we repent of our sins and turn from our wicked ways then he will heal the land 🙏

[@LadyRishae]

@@PrOpHeTiC9786 I came to say EXACTLY this!!

[@Lifeskills06]

You gotta be a strong sick individual to be a criminal defense attorney especially in a case like this....strait up disgusting 🤢

[@tiffanymcduffie6497]

It’s not easy!!!!

[@Hilda-sr7tm]

Yes, I couldn't do it.

[@marienoel303]

Yes they both disgusting defending him I hate when his attorneys speak

[@KingJohnny24]

@@marienoel303 they're just there to make money they don't care two fucks about him. They know he's already cooked

[@marieprince3994]

The grandmother and aunt need to be in jail also !!!!

[@shonequeaugustine6021]

Absolutely

[@ReniaBethany]

It seems that they was also tricked by a narcissist too the aunt had 5 kids by this monster all the parties (women) involved seemed delayed to me not taking up for them just saying that they was tricked just like this beautiful lil girl was he acted alone and he thinks because there is nobody that he will not be convicted that’s why he running his prelim like a Fool he is a monster beyond compare demon filled

[@leighkelly4577]

Thank you judge. This is so horrible. Poor child was failed by many! I hope others come forward that may know more. 😢

[@marlat.4221]

Thank you Judge Sabree. Now let’s get more justice for Na’Ziyah.💜💜💜💜

[@ericawilliams9099]

Life without Any possibility of Parole!!!

[@opalmaytoday5625]

💜💜💜💜💜💜💜💜💜 💜 💜💜💜💜

[@TheShellybaybee]

This is so sad! All my friends always try to rush me into relationships but I have two daughters so I am very cautious of who I bring around. My child has only met one man 7yrs

[@brittbrat0907]

I just said I’m not dating until my babies are grown even then it’s just scary period

[@KheilyahMechelle]

❤Thank You for protecting your babies❤ Gods continuous blessings 🙏🏽

[@sierramcpherson9895]

I’m the same and I have sons

[@honestcomment862]

I read he was under investigation or suspected of two more cases and dealing with minors besides spending 7 years in prison for doing the same thing. Why wasn’t he in prison and allowed to have contact with children? Why are so many young children allowed to be around this random ass dude?

[@stanfieldfamily3877]

Exactly

[@destinyhorton5304]

Wow 😢thanks for awakening me better. Stay woke and trust no1.

[@kaielise7935]

The aunt stayed with him after he raped there 10yr old. Had 5 kids with him sick people in the world.

[@GlitterBrixx]

Yes look up the arraignment court hearing. He was also charged with penetrating his 10 year old daughter and a 4 year old that was his girlfriend’s daughter, giving her Chlamydia.

[@memoryhoward8119]

@@GlitterBrixxwtfff

[@brianabicy395]

His attorneys are idiots ... Smh

[@toshianawest7579]

they work for the court their job is to be a shitty attorney for the defendant because they already know that either he will get a deal that they have already agreed on with the judge or he will try to go to trial which he probably might not win just based off evidence alone either way he cooked

[@spitfirestake54]

Good

[@rinitarankin6217]

the Judge read them for filt and i love it. anybody that seen her failed her especially the family

[@dichondrajohnson6516]

I don’t want my KZbin to get cut off, but I wish them inmates would make him tell them WHERE she’s at. And know what I mean by MAKE him.

[@bumpyjohnson236]

Unfortunately he still will be safe in prison he can go to pc prison isn’t how yall think it is

[@destinyhorton5304]

Same and shave hs head

[@deelove2109]

Judge Sabree read him and that piss poor family for filth …. The ending had me in tears 😢

[@kandj4450]

Thank you Judge for calling it right!

[@amiyahmack8140]

As a Lawyer, I’m not representing nobody I KNOW GUILTY!! Sick asf man .

[@dashiemamiller4344]

YASSS I'm so happy the Judge read him exactly how she should have! Let's go

[@BlessedMomfmTexas]

Yes!! 2 both young Proscuters killing this case!! He will get LWOP. Justice ⚖️ is coming for Na'zsyiah. 💜💜💜⚖️⚖️⚖️⚖️💜💜💜

[@nenewashington9204]

Cap! They are mediocre if that. If this wasn’t so disgusting and he had better lawyers reasonable doubt could be found unfortunately

[@brittneywalker4138]

She said everything I’ve been thinking about

[@lauralee9694]

This is the way a cop should testify, no bias just the facts

[@sharonpatterson2223]

Thank you Judge!

[@usernotfound4454]

TIME STAMPS: 26:00 - Further testimony by Shannon Jones, Sergeant with the Detroit Police Department, Homicide Division, Missing Persons Unit. 01:34:58 - Request by the prosecution for the charges against defendant Jarvis Butts to be upgraded due to witness testimonies and evidence presented to the judge.

[@meihamac]

Thank you judge❤

[@catldyyuh]

This Judge did the damn thing!

[@ElizabethConway-kf9ed]

The defense team must not have children. I could never defend anyone like this....

[@ashleyharris3294]

Her defense and logic is weak and distorted. If we listen closely the defense attorney isn’t defending him. Literally, she can throw out a bunch of attempts at “inconsistencies” all she wants but she is not creating a strong defense and it’s because she also believes this man to be guilty. Why were you texting her up until that day but you didn’t see her. Why is she talkin to you about a baby at all, the inappropriate relationship has been proven, the speculation that a baby was his motive to get rid of her was proven. The defense can’t disprove these facts so she is literally just creating a distraction not a counter reply to all of the evidence presented. Explain it… she can’t. He’s guilty, she has to look like she’s defending him. That must be a rough position, I personally could never speak as if he was innocent because as a mother myself my conscious wouldn’t allow me to make up any type of defense or excuse. He’s guilty! He set in the back of that court, with a mask on when Covid is at its lowest, hiding behind his attorneys and away from the view of those who he can’t look in the face because he is a pathetic sorry excuse for a human who preys on children and was given the opportunity to harm a child while a bunch of women and mothers turned a blind eye. They failed that baby

[@brittneywormley9010]

That’s all they need to do. You can’t dispute physical evidence so the best defense they can offer him is to broadcast the inconsistencies. It’s hard to defend somebody like this for something this heinous. I wouldn’t want to be in their shoes.

[@Amirracle]

‼️

[@brittbrat0907]

This story is so heartbreaking everyone failed her. I want the aunts and grandma to meet me on 7 mile and greenfield

[@teawitthadiva]

I swear I said the same thing. I bet not see them at the gas station. I just need 2 min w/them.

[@rithabrad8666]

THANK YOU JUDGE! we need more of you ❤

[@niki1736]

Awesome Judge 👍🏽‼️‼️

[@AveaniaRichardson]

Yes judge hit everything on the nose and I hope their in the courtroom listening 😢

[@hilarioushaun313gifted2]

You can see the pain in the beautiful judge face smh 🤦🏽‍♂️ what a tough job🙏🏾❤️🌹

[@Riahhsanii]

Very tough job idk how they do. Absolutely heartbreaking

[@lynnroundtree0801]

Thank u judge 🙌🏾

[@lirpakcalb]

His defense attorney lady just basically told on him by saying he disengaged after finding out that she wasn't pregnant, had he not been engaging with her at all, he wouldn't have had to.

[@shannonsmith5419]

He had no business being around Na’zyia by being a registered sexual offender. He shouldn’t have picked her up, the grandmother, and aunt never should have let either girls around him. Period!!! Yes they failed her, and seems that no one cared. Sad😞

[@thekaerichtexas]

This judge is amazing!!!

[@yasminerogers9470]

So why wasn’t the grandma not questioning her where she would go. Did they look at every camera angle to track every move. How did the family just not know

[@em4001]

She probably didn’t care

[@jujustalling6318]

Because she don't care in my opinion I feel like the grandma and auntie know more then what they saying. The only one that I give thanks to is Na'Ziyah cousin Roxy Because she is the only one in her family that was investigating and looking for her and trying to get justice for her. Roxy and 7mile radio really helped get alot of clues and evidence into missing Na'Ziyah. I really hope they find her body for real true closeure❤

[@domonicole19]

Make him take that mask off ‼️‼️‼️

[@SlimTheTruckHER]

Exactly !!! Don’t hide now

[@Denise-i4s]

......

[@crystaldixon1762]

Yess show your face

[@ticca_9217]

For real he's such a 🐈 he wants to hide behind the mask! Coward

[@opalmaytoday5625]

😢😢😢Let this case be an example to many, were Judge Sabree’s words along with many other words. Thank you Judge #blackgirlsreallymatter She was failed by MANY. He knew no one cared about her, that’s how he was able to do what he did & carry it out for soooo long. Can’t wait til January 16, I’ll definitely be tuned in.

[@elyserock3223]

Her auntie knew he like kids she said he said he changed that’s how you know she Slow

[@lindajones1527]

In the

[@ashleyharris3294]

Even his defense attorney knows he did it. Morally I wouldn’t be able to represent a child killer. She has a job to do and it’s eating her alive because her defense makes little to no sense and she looks completely in distress and in no particular order. He did it! The entire court room knows he did it

[@emeraldjones5195]

The grandmother and the aunt need to be charged with neglect bc they didn't keep up her at all and it showed. who waits until the next day to file a missing persons report?!?! lock em all up. I agree he should be made to sit at the table with his attorney’s and take the mask off if its not on for a cold or allergy reasons. I pray the judge implements this requirement for the trial on jan 16th. He doesn't deserve the option to hide behind his attorney’s or a mask.

[@hilarioushaun313gifted2]

Aunte let her feelings get the best of her,so she stopped caring for Neice when she find out about the sexual incident with boyfriend 🤦🏽‍♂️ so sad 🙏🏾🕊️♥️🌹🎈Give him the Max

[@simonelockhart9404]

factzzz

[@memoryhoward8119]

Facts😢

[@aliciabriones3984]

How can the girlfriend, Angel that he lives with be able to ignore the police? She should have a warrant if she won’t comply. He lived with her so there could be evidence there. She would know when he leaves and comes home and if there was any strange activity the day and days leading up to Na’zaiyah disappearing

[@kaylarenee3565]

Oh she will be subpoenaed

[@Branlee]

This is so sad. So many people failed this poor young girl. The grandmother and aunt need to be ashamed of themselves. All of the women all of the children of his and the ones he groomed... Jarvis is sick. This brought me to tears. The judge read him as the person he is...a monster. Thank you Judge Sabree.

[@Chynadolliee]

This made my cry…thank you judge.

[@hilarioushaun313gifted2]

The most beautiful judge in America 🌹

[@JayZ-Hova]

I hadn’t heard of her prior to this trial, but I have so much respect for her!💜

[@stanfieldfamily3877]

This Monster Haven’t Never Been Let Out 😢

[@destinyhorton5304]

Should've never been ,trust no1....

[@couleenjoyner5102]

His stupid A-- defense Attorney is ANNOYING

[@WGTAIPODCAST]

Why would he take this case to trial knowing he did this sht??????? He could’ve saved this family so much grief and just gave them the body and took his time

[@MariaChavez-Waddell]

Not only that, if he “ didn’t “ do it why not admit the truth so that charge can be dropped 🫣

[@ramsaymorris5717]

Defense attorney looks like he’s sleeping on and off smh this story is so sad.

[@itsyevette836]

He is… how can you fall asleep next to a monster though

[@ash21loyal]

Why does it matter who the search was about he still was messing around with a child!!!! Did they check to see if she was pregnant

[@tianabryant6677]

They can’t check. There’s no body

[@ash21loyal]

@@tianabryant6677I know I made this comment while watching for the first time

[@deelove2109]

Whew the tears rolling down my face 🥹

[@garlenebarber1536]

Great job judge 👏🏾💯

[@Breadandbutta]

1:59:52 not the member of defense falling asleep 😂

[@gabriellemccarver3133]

Literally knocked out lol

[@crystalsmith6923]

😂😂😂😂

[@alanne1.17.77]

Im annoyed listening to his attorney questioning the officer. I dont care about none of this nonsense he is talking about. Its too soon for me to be this annoyed. I think im going to fast-forward.

[@HerKingdomSpace]

The line of questioning from the defense attorney is really annoying. Did anybody even get a verification where he dropped her off if he was not the last person to see her?

[@ISHAUNSMOM]

Everyone involved with him needs to be tested. All of the kids produced proves that he COULD single handily be responsible for an endemic outbreak.

[@deracajess]

Yes JUDGE!!!! Yes!

[@lauralee9694]

Wow I agree the judge spoke the truth 👏

[@Hereforthisfoolery]

I love this judge. I love that read all of the people that failed this child. This predator needs the DP. There’s another predator that was sentenced last year for doing almost the same exact thing to a little girl. So so sad.

[@shantelmccomb5382]

His name is Johnathan Quiles of Florida she was his wife’s 16 year old niece. His ex wife and niece was pregnant at the same time. She didn’t wanna have an abortion, he told her he couldn’t loose his family and he kilt her. His brother told in him and I live that for him.

[@laj4186]

Looks like the court admin got emotional in the end. Who was that yelling out?

[@brittanybonds1022]

That was her cousin Roxy. She live in Texas but after Na’Ziyah went missing she moved back to Detroit right after and been Na’Ziyah’s voice ever since

[@jaajoker]

The defense attorneys should be ashamed of themselves for showing up to court to defend this pos...my integrity would be more important to me than my career

[@brianmitchell117]

Man I wish I could publicly comment on this but due to my career choices… I have to let the legal process play out 🥴

[@shaunnaprice6795]

Does anyone know of the podcast that ppl keep talking about concerning this case??

[@AngelaInTheCity]

Didn't she say turn off the camera. How disrespectful

[@junkandthangs]

Cause they been on the while time recording private conversations when the case wasn’t going on

[@qonny1]

I'm just flabbergasted at the lack of parenting, protection & love with this baby! My Son is now 24! & I did random phone checks, and I didn't care who had anything to say about it. How didn't anyone know, she was pregnant!??? How didn't anyone see these explicit text messages from this monster!!! Everyone failed her!!!

[@classicasi88]

Everyone in her life knew they were handing her to the devil and none of them cared. I don't care what the aunt, grandma, sister or his friends say....they ALL knew! But for some reason the protection of a child sexual predator was more important than the protection of a child's life.

[@PlannersByKat]

I will never know, but I guessing what Na'Ziyah went through is generational. I hope it stops.

[@heyritarenee]

You’re absolutely correct. There is an interview with NaZiyah’s family members who tried to help and they clarify that sexual abuse was prevalent in that home.

[@Studtacular78]

I ❤ YOU JUDGE BREE....LOVE YR BIGGEST FAN,,,im very confident you got this sis...I kn it's hard to see and hear this case....may the lord keep you in God health and spirits....

[@ShkiaSteele]

How and why would you want to represent him!!! Just why!!

[@nenewashington9204]

Who was that screaming? Couldn’t have been the family. That didn’t gaf about that baby . Had she called the police she might could’ve been here today

[@MariaChavez-Waddell]

Who was “ shan” that Na’Ziyah was talking about? If its her auntie shannon she need to be locked up.

[@peachprince4168]

Beautiful young lady God couldn’t let her suffer no more he needed his angel home with him she is in his loving arms No pain walking streets of Gold

[@stacyhenry5578]

His lawyer nodding in agreement with judge...

[@junkandthangs]

They finally got the message about the cameras and the hot mic… all at the end of the case

[@whoathur]

its crazy he just sitting in there knowing exactly where her body is/was

[@lirpakcalb]

He wanna limp n act like he the victim.

[@hilarioushaun313gifted2]

Can’t find the murder weapon, because Jervis placed the weapon with Na’ziyah’s body 🤔

[@07Glazier]

It’s not a weapon because he unalived that baby with his bare hands. Those holes on the hoody were from her trying to fight him off from the ground

[@adinajohnson3505]

Exactly

[@posiabuse421]

I also suspect he had her drink red anti freeze in an attempt to abort the baby. He purposefully did not get her medical attention when it went sideways and then probably killed her with either his bare hands or a weapon. She was already in a bad state from the botched abortion ​@@07Glazier

[@posiabuse421]

​@@07Glazier his Google searches ended with abortion queries and "what happens when you drink red anti freeze"

[@Ninotchka0902]

With all that evidence I don’t know why his attorneys are letting him waste all this time. Now they still have to go through a trial smh. He just needs to go ahead and tell them where she is and serve his time, damn creep.

[@shonequeaugustine6021]

This judge said everything that i had questions about,these ppl failed her big time,they didnt care about this lil girl, there's more ppl who needs to be in jail,this man had hi head down the whole trial, he's guilty asf,i just wanna know why was Cordell incarcerated

[@marcuslangston7358]

He got pulled in for questioning & that alone made him violate his probation

[@hilarioushaun313gifted2]

RiH Na Na🙏🏾🕊️❤️🌹🎈

[@LiyahandJayy]

sad part is no one will ever know what really happened to this baby smh i wish someone can make him tell

[@crystalskitchen2408]

why he didn’t tell them where her body is like wat is going on

[@chefalexzandria7011]

Girl how are you representing this man 🤦‍♀️

[@carlenewilliams1024]

Definitely the right call by the judge , I can’t imagine being a defense attorney in this case. I don’t think I could defend this guy , knowing everyone deserves to have a defense but cases like this one makes me question that . I know everyone involved will get their do justice and there is more than just him that needs to be prosecuted and we all know who they are . I pray the state follows through and more will follow this pos

[@patmacd-wk2qn]

So well put Judge! So that future generations of children don't fall through the cracks can we start raising kids to not sleep with someone until they are: 1. GROWN 2. Mentally and financially able to raise a child 3. Wait until you know someone and their circle very well Social services can help, but they will Never care for your child as well as you do and depending on them is a Hard life for the parents and our precious kids. I never want to hear of this happening to another child! Justice for Na'Ziyah! 💔💔💔

[@msimmons39]

I would have to quit my job before I defended this monster!

[@ticca_9217]

Why are they allowing him to wear a mask!?!? Coward doesn't want to show his face! He is sick

[@ericwoods4577]

Good job judge , some sick shit in our community ….. we focused & moved by the wrong shit , before we ever get respect from others , it starts with self first …

[@hilarioushaun313gifted2]

She never left his job, he killed her there

[@memoryhoward8119]

I think so too

[@deracajess]

Miss lady with the colorful jacket was out of pocket a couple of times during break. But continue…..

[@Samiyaluv]

She Wants to be seen and heard so badly just ghetto. They're doing a case on a child being S.A and M***** and she acting like a hyena

[@memoryhoward8119]

@@Samiyaluvghetto as hell

[@mkwins642]

So what is the trial gonna consist of; the same witness testimonies; but in front of a jury?🤔

[@teeteetyler5372]

Judge Sabree took no prisoners and held all accountable for failing this beautiful black baby. Rest Easy Baby Girl. This world didnt deserve you.. God has prepared a place for you where you will only receive true and unconditional love. No more pain suffering mental or physical abuse only only genuine love and affection.

[@shuggieee9467]

Shannan was jealous of that girl and didn’t give a damn about her. Her immediate family failed her terribly.

[@trishapalmer3816]

40:22 The judge is cracking up because, she knows the defense is pulling straws trying to defend the MADNESS!

[@pollyheyy]

Idk how you could be a defense attorney in a case like this.. I’ll be the worst, I wouldn’t even try especially after reading those text messages to a child.