Natalie Merchant - Carnival (Official Audio, 2015)

[@mabelannand9324]

Rest now eilleen you are at peace now god bless you 💔💗💔

[@sharity3289]

Ms. Natalie, you'll probably never see this in a million years, but...Thank you for allowing "Carnival" to be played on the Aileen Wuornos documentary! I have so much empathy for Aileen, she grew up harder than I can probably even begin to relate to, and I truly believe the 1st male, whose death was attributed to her, really did violate her, and set her on the path that she took, along with the pressures of having Tyra to provide for as well. But, bless you, for having a heart!

[@christopherjohnson4935]

I've always believed songs artists write and create in their 20 and 30's grow and mature over time and need to be renewed in their 50's and 60's. This is a real treat. Thanks Natalie. Everything changes, in this case for the good.

[@SavannahRidout]

This is my all time favorite song and it's such a gift to have a new version of it. Thank you

[@jeraldlynch5113]

+Savannah Ridout Totally with you on this Savannah!

[@geraldprocella1681]

soo talnented Natalie. Your so blessed you will be blessed while on Earth & the hear After...GOD BLESS YOU!!

[@AaronHahnStudios]

I feel you. love & understanding through music Savannah.

[@ghostruner66]

I'm just glad to hear that angelic voice..anytime, anyplace, anywhere.

[@chrisnorthrop]

Stone cold classic. HELL YES, Natalie. Glad you got your voice back also.

[@sartainja]

Great version. Her voice is deeper and richer than back in mid 1990's.

[@Mad_Luv85]

I remember hearing and seeing this video when I was a young boy. she was my kid crush. Such an incredible and powerful artist. I'm still Amazed at 35

[@SebastianMcCrazy]

nothing beats the guitarwork on the 1995 version. one of the best guitar songs ever.

[@ALLinALLgood]

*eh wurst* ... idk dude, give this version a listen... let me now your thoughts .. *_Search: Natalie Merchant Carnival Lyrics www verdicries it_*

[@crystalbelle2349]

Orange-Cat-Bad agree. Same lyrics, two different worlds and mindsets. For me, this one is more Reggae. I love them both equally, but are for different times and moods. As beauty is in the eye of the beholder as is quality music is in tend ear (and heart) of the listener.

[@crystalbelle2349]

Orange-Cat-Bad I’m aware I’m late getting here. Better late than never. Loved ever note, melody and harmony.

[@ianmurphy8225]

Man, you ain't kidding. Jennifer's guitar work was unbelievably perfect. I've been playing for 25 years and it's still one of my favorites. The playing on that song is so fluid, complimentary and well phrased. Unbelievable tone, feel. Every time I've heard a live version of this song, the guitar player almost ALWAYS overplays and ruins the song, lol. This song's guitar needs to breathe and beat. It's also SO New York City in the early 90s.

[@YungItalianHandz]

truth

[@rylancapper6788]

Her voice is hauntingly beautiful

[@garyconner6151]

Imagine her voice.while she's giving herself to me.keeps me up all night.and she is so beautiful.pretty face and beautiful body.and that voice.

[@BenEmre4463]

Aileen wuornos is now in heaven Rest in peace.

[@jonathanmcdaniel5149]

With age, to some, comes wisdom. You have been blessed with both. I have loved your music since the 90's. Now I'm sharing it with my sons. I work in the county jail in the max security section and can relate to the words in this song. The eyes of both the inmates and the officers shows me that the tempo of this version is perfect. Thank you, Natalie!!!

[@REMChicagoBoy]

I can't believe she actually *improved* upon the original classic. I can't wait to hear the entire record!

[@konaguzzi1]

+REMChicagoBoy I think I am in the same boat as you

[@DogWithGuns]

The best version of one of the best songs of all time 🙌

[@ramseydawg]

I had a major crush on her during the 90s and then life happened! Just saw her on Jimmy Fallon last week singing These Were Days and a flood of memories from my 20's bombarded me! Tiger Lily was my favorite album.

[@SiddharthSinghFiery69]

Here in the memory of Aileen Wournos ❤️😘

[@roberthernandez7619]

You have been my favorite singer for the past 30 plus years.

[@keithdickens1395]

The voice is beautiful and the words are perfect,I’m glad we shared this planet at the same time,stay safe

[@Cranky_Crone]

What a strange world… 2022, here’s me in Australia, learning about psychopathy.. true crime… Aileen… and wikipedia leads me here… huh. Guess I’ve been under a rock. But otherwise might never have come across Natalie Merchant. Worth it! What a beautiful voice, song, soul. That Merchant allowed the doco to use this song; huge props for that. Takes a big person. Obviously not trying to justify anything, but who can imagine what that poor kid went through to become what she became.

[@sharity3289]

Aileen grew up harder than a lot of us can even begin to relate to. The 1st male that was killed, I truly believe that he violated her and she defended herself, but it set her on the path she decided to take. (It's been proven that male had a previous record of sexual & physical abuse against females...). I also think the pressure of providing for Tyra and being the only one bringing in any money, contributed to her decision to rob & kill the other men. But who knows the violence she encountered in her chosen profession?? I've watched and read a lot of true crime in the past 30 years, and there's so many friends & family of killers that always say, " I can't believe it. So-and-so isn't capable, they're too nice, etc." Well, the same could also be true about the men she killed. We can't possibly know, bc we were not there, if some or all of the other deaths were the result of violence perpetrated against Aileen, even if the friends & families say they were good, kind men. But I don't think killing her was the answer, but I also can't say that she would have, if given the chance, chose life in prison for herself - I think that was worse than death to her, especially at the end...Regardless, my prayers are with her & the males' families & friends bc those are the ones who are left to suffer...

[@mikepritchard332]

It is a rare thing Natalie has. A unique perspective to her surroundings and the ability to put it to lyrical words. Not only her solo music, but also in her 10,000 Maniacs days. "Candy" is as relevant today then when it was, you know, a few years back.

[@johnnyaldana7104]

Where have all the cowgirls gone? Thanks for your music real singers from the 90's, music with spirit and life! Love you too much for this Natalie one of my favorites of all time truly singers!

[@peterkim1999]

My mind just unwound to first time I saw Natalie perform live on SNL back in the 80's performing 'Like the Weather' live on NYC-Channel 4.

[@ripperb770]

What a thing of beauty has been created here.

[@pouderbernf.u.7021]

Her lyrics and insight were timeless when she first wrote this ... she is one of the only artists that could redo her work years later and still be relevant. Beautiful.

[@timothyortega5608]

I just love ❤️ your music 🎶 Natalie..... Thank You 😊 🙏

[@anthonybutt5988]

Nathalie gilding her own lily.... Awesome work as always. 👍🙏

[@quartzimaging]

Gorgeous! Liking it even more than the original. Can't wait to hear the new album.

[@henrigizowski5781]

Yes, the original version of Carnival was very good. I absolutely adored Jennifer Turner's guitar throughout the Tigerlily album. However, the new version is just gorgeous! The acoustic guitar solo is brilliant and fits in with the pacing and mood of the song. I just love a singer with an intellect as well as a voice. Natalie's incisive lyrics and great musical arrangements take her material to another level. Paradise ain't there, its here!

[@ambergraves798]

How does this comment not have a single "like" 7 years later?? You said it all, and perfectly to boot!

[@burridgeandy6982]

I could listen to her all day n night and still ask for .more

[@MoxieCat23]

So overjoyed to hear you again, Natalie!!

[@SuperBSmeter]

Her voice is like a heartbeat that gets this body of mine through another dark day on planet Earth....See ya'll in DC for Earth Day, April 22nd.

[@KennetSeanNikos]

This is one of my favourite tracks from the original 1995 album. I've only just bought the 2015 recordings and must say as I listened to this song on our mobile phone using earphones while going about my business earlier it sent shivers down my spine. Love when music does that to you.

[@Janasjewelryboutiqueonline]

She is speaking of truth, its her soul that speaks

[@Leon56367]

You still got it. It was not 100% your voice... but that feeling you bring.

[@garyconner6151]

She got me to.

[@Prof_O2]

His work is always much anticipated . Incredible, you will leave the Tigerlily recordings even better!

[@philistine2nd]

And once again, I'm listening to this song over and over.

[@wolramdave]

A 46 year old gig goer all my life I've pretty much given up apart from 2 acts: The mighty LOW from Duluth, and of course the greatest female voice if them all - Natalie. Looking forward to the RAH in the spring!

[@portcullis5622]

+wolramdave I wouldn't give up on other artists just yet. I am a few years older than you and I am still discovering great singers such as the awesome Rhiannon Giddens who I first heard sing live last year when I travelled the 200 miles to London to see Natalie Merchant sing a couple of traditional songs with Kronos Quartet as part of Nonesuch Records' 50th anniversary concert. It was well worth the effort as I hadn't seen Natalie sing live before and the real bonus was seeing Rhiannon Giddens sing a few songs. I went back to London this year to see Rhiannon with her own band and they were fabulous. A young singer-songwriter from London, Eliza Shaddad, was the support act and she was excellent as well-so there are still some fine young artists out there. I am also going to the R.A.H. (and Manchester) in March as I was unable to get tickets for Natalie's Barbican shows last year. I have decided to make the effort to see great artists while I still can, particularly as there are very long gaps between their 'tours' (if two or three shows can be called a tour!).

[@MrRicardobach]

This IS better than the original! Slower, clearer, her voice arises from a more jazzy version. Bravo

[@MrSteverrr]

+Richard Fohrenbach, Sr. Agreed!!!!

[@edvario]

Carnival is a masterpiece with such great Jen's eletric guitar solo and soft backing vocal. This version is perfect. Masterpiece and perfect is the less we can wait from her.

[@mikehydropneumatic2583]

Just bought the album on vinyl. The original (+ video!) is also great. The perfect soundtrack for street photography :)

[@xnotenia1053]

This song always reminds me of Aileen Wuornos...I love this

[@colonelsterling]

me 2 ♡

[@45streetproductions]

Me 4

[@mikewilliams235]

Niruu Chuu 5X

[@kabernat]

Scrltt Raven Try not

[@svenhardmann8985]

Mich auch! Die Frage die bei mir bleibt ,WO war der gute Menschen der Aileen hätte retten können. Viele Grüsse from Switzerland

[@StephenTrappDesertMouse]

Thank you, this is so amazing: your voice has grown😎

[@xbrandi12345x]

I have never heard this version. I love it!!

[@kabernat]

I love this acoustic version to really hear and appreciate her lovely voice!

[@craigvaughan1603]

Natalie is simply amazing

[@cisplatinus1828]

I love Natalie, she sing like an angel!!!!!

[@outtathyme5679]

Natalie is the best there ever was

[@marleencortez4420]

I have always loved this song! It has a haunting feels to it.

[@brianprickett6721]

This is a great version, but Jennifer Turner's guitar work was what made Carnival awesome. I miss her back up vocals too.

[@spider_hoss]

This is a solid re-recording. I was a little skeptical because a lot of artists re-record songs that are straight up hot garbage. This one is very good. It's a slight departure from the excellent original version but there's nothing wrong with that. It's a rethink and a reimagine.

[@serkangolcukluoglu450]

Best way to enjoy this song??? Treat this song and the original one as completely 2 different songs. Original one was written in 95, young Natalie comes to NY City from a small town and she really is mesmerized with what she sees around her. Different perspective of life, music, circumstances, and she writes the song and it is arranged to her liking and we have the Carnival V1. Fast forward 20 years, more experience in life, things change, she comes a long way in this time frame, and re-records Carnival, based on what she feels like today and how she wants us to hear the song. Same lyrics, same chords, same song with 2 different arrangements, which to me, are equally beautiful. Will i ever stop listening to the original version because this one is out, absolutely not. They are both beautiful in their own ways.

[@lorenzomaialetti4950]

RIP Aileen Wuornos.

[@kabernat]

Lorenzo Maialetti Please!!!!! 🙄

[@steveaustin7306]

Manson with a vagina

[@sharity3289]

@lorenzomaialetti4950 Amen...

[@stephaniemichelledavis1617]

I'm just over the Moon that, a new albulm is coming soo......she is STILL "THE BEST", love you Natalie!!!!

[@mabelannand9324]

Brilliant Natalie you are so amazing 😉 I just love 💕 that voice of yours keep going girl your smashing it love all your albums god bless xxx 💖💖💖

[@santarasa7387]

Love her voice, so real and what a tone. I'm a singer songwriter, just starting out, just recorded my first single and made a video too and uploaded it to my youtube page ~ love listening to Natalie's voice, she's an inspiration!

[@crystalpavlosky8708]

I also say RIP Aileen Wuornos I saw everything u went through what u did was wrong but i have paid as much as u can for ur sin. And u went through as a child im sorry for the childhood u had may u find solace now...

[@iwakeanotherday4838]

Life and death of a serial killer Brought me here too.

[@snakeplissken5136]

So, I have an interesting connection with the maniacs, close relationship with hometown. I always enjoyed the music and honestly never really explored it. This woman's voice is beautiful and I have a new phonic love for her wonderful music.

[@ThatWord]

A more soulful, wiser and overall deeper treatment. The simpler arrangement, without the hooky bounce of the original, conveys the wavelength of the song on a more personal level. Where the first held a bit of a swagger through those streets, this one is more of a contemplative stroll, not without the wry whimsy of the first, but more symbiotic with subtler vibes taking place.

[@qixotical]

Frankly, I like them both.

[@marielleforgotmylastname8282]

Oooor it just has a different tune.... All that extra stuff is just what YOU feel the difference is. For me, they mean the same.

[@Jeff-jg7jh]

Natilie. I can spell it I think. I was introduced to this or another album from the Columbia record club. I would randomly pick a CD by the review. The music rocked me. The prairie women song rocked me. I could picture it. I saw an interview where she was asked,; lyrics or music. She said, she'd rather dig a ditch than write lyrics (as I recall). The music is first. She's done a pretty good job.

[@karenwestlake6147]

COME TO AUSTRALIA NATALIE>>PLEEEASSE

[@konaguzzi1]

+Karen Westlake while she there it is only a small step across the ditch to New Zealand

[@cicijones6020]

🎉looooove this song and her voice with it!!!

[@StottMikel]

In 1992 they said "dont dance." I danced. She winked.

[@scottross3940]

Beautiful... as always.

[@stuartroberts7904]

I miss the guitar from the original though, played by the awesome Jen Turner...

[@scottdaunhauer2453]

Stuart Roberts I saw this being performed live (Saturday Night Live (I think) ) with a female guitarist.... (probably the one you're speaking of). Would Love to see That clip again.

[@willmpet]

It goes.into a special place for me along with Song for Sharon and Walking in Memphis!

[@legalboxers]

Blow away by the remake. Major flashback

[@shawshankdaspartan]

Dear Natalie, You are awesome. The end.

[@jimmyblais1502]

Aboutely gorgeous song!! Downloading now....

[@saltyspartan6939]

Thanks for your music. I wish I could meet you. I walked the streets too.

[@hermanzegerman2]

I do love her for a long time

[@marilynmartin4710]

Better then ever! love you Natalie

[@steveaustin7306]

More ethereal, open, mature. Beautiful as the original.

[@Rtroute]

Love it!!!

[@soulg1969]

The electric guitar on the original song was fantastic. It was a girl playing I remember. It still a great song here but the original is almost always the purest and truest version. That is the cast with Carnival too.

[@MesaMynx]

Love it! Thank you!

[@denisesmith835]

top notch...love her sensual voice....beautiful song

[@doglady2]

love the new sound

[@annacamfield2628]

I love it!!!

[@helencox184]

latest album _ a perfect purchase

[@janinegomes9072]

amazing!!!!

[@mysis11]

SWEET!

[@Mrmaliho001]

How sweet and smooth🍀

[@fefe435]

just perfect. The best Ever.

[@brucelee6387]

thank u

[@ThePerromestizo]

Love you Natalie...

[@druflo6775]

stuck in the head ♡

[@nicholaswykel40]

I had here sister as my 6th grade science teacher

[@5665mrdead]

i miss her singing

[@AsimKhanartist]

nice warm acoustic version

[@raykem7739]

WOW LOVE THIS Natalie Keep It Going You Make the days good for me Thanks

[@dusankeim6376]

yes yes yes...

[@DICKFORBRAINSASS]

WOW just WOW. i love this chick, she's the man. redo tiger and make it better? whatever i still love nat

[@dusankeim6376]

bravoooooo....

[@roxyredrose1]

you were a hero aileen

[@murrstevens]

nod nod, sway sway, yep thumbs up.

[@stevengill8866]

One of my favourite female singers along with Patty Griffin,both have released high quality albums for years.

[@leperheart]

While I like this version and its groove, it just isn't the same without Katell's ghostly echoes

[@ibrahimfrasheri8273]

Nje nga këngët me të bukura ...

[@cleberdantas2003]

VOZ SUAVE..REPERCUTE NA ALMA.

[@999mmj]

We are not worthy Natalie