Immigration minister says temporary migrants will leave 'voluntarily'

[@LahcenAbassi]

This guy grilling Mark Miller should be immigration Minister.

[@JamesCassidy-cv4cy]

yup 4 sure.

[@AlokKumar-cf5rq]

True

[@MC_Alaba]

You read my mind.

[@DavidMelvin-ob5dq]

DEPORT DEPORT DEPORT

[@amrhefni9565]

I see that he tries to embarrass the minister yet he needs to learn math first.

[@S.W.A]

They don't want them to leave, they are not done destroying Canada.

[@jmshwood2801]

You spot it on! Look on how they Indians behaved here in Canada! They are not even united . .

[@DeborahDoyle-u3u]

Bingo 💥

[@Barbbfly]

Libs have proved this is True

[@pth6060]

Exactly

[@beyourownboss3414]

✅✅

[@AWARHERO]

ffs... This government is delusional

[@markmaloney3140]

HES LYING THROUGH HIS YELLOW TEETH

[@Drareg-x3m]

What a clown! Lock this loon up! The damage this simpleton done is extraordinary.

[@Drareg-x3m]

Meth.

[@ft.6806]

I was thinking the exact same thing.

[@ft.6806]

this guy is immigration minister. He thinks people leave voluntarily. All these leaders will only do something when those illegal migrants do some criminal activities to their family. Wake up Canadians. I am Asian canadian.

[@eskimomonkey2]

This Liberal government must really thinks Canadians are stupid.. it's downright insulting.

[@TheWalamala]

Maybe cause they are?

[@DeborahDoyle-u3u]

They have felt that way years

[@contribution741]

I'm Canadian and I agree with the Liberals. Let me ask you a question: what would you call people who built a great society that was prosperous, fair and pleasant... and then allowed corrupt politicians to import wave after wave of foreign nationals who have nothing to do with our history, culture or values... and simply stood by, dumbfounded, as those aliens broke and twisted the law to extract the taxpayers' money... what would you call those people? What would you call people who simply passively watch their country be destroyed, knowing that their children and their children's children will never be able to buy a home, so we can accommodate migrants who frankly don't deserve to live here?

[@DavidMelvin-ob5dq]

DEPORT DEPORT DEPORT

[@ahdnaji]

Canadians who believe temporary foreigners to be the problem are indeed stupid.

[@jerryk6530]

"Canada first", Leaves no room at all for Trudeau the Liberals or NDP. Remove trudeau and the ndp and most problems will disappear.

[@Drareg-x3m]

The clowns completely failed, now Trump is making them dance like little puppets! Pathetic! What a joke Canada has become.

[@Cali736]

& illegals

[@davidlefranc6240]

@@Drareg-x3m We are stuck with 2 principal party to choose from yes its pathetic like you!

[@Drareg-x3m]

@@davidlefranc6240 are you suggesting the current leadership isn’t clownishly incompetent and corrupt? Is that you Mr Socks. 😂

[@flomo7382]

Ya could always VOTE Quebec or GREEN PARTY SCANDALS FAILURES WITH LIBERALS AND CONSERVATIVES

[@LahcenAbassi]

Why on earth we got 50% of our international students from India alone. Our immigration system is broken and needs overhaul. We should have a quota of how many students each country is allowed to send to Canada. We need to diversify our immigrants into this country. There are 195 countries to pick from

[@arunsakthivel9964]

There is a lot of loop holes…..many agencys working on this visa…..most Indian students can afford that much of money for these agency’s to get a seat easily here….its not based on qualifications or intelligence…..Well qualified Indians pick USA to do masters and no way would consider Canada or UK….where everything can be faked…..the so called university’s don’t even have a proper building in Canada…..Canadian officials if not corrupted should shut down these fake colleges…..

[@AlokKumar-cf5rq]

It’s because Indians pay more money upfront.

[@rayan668]

Brampton Ontario is full of Indians Disgusting 🤢

[@marniejane88]

Agreed

[@JohnnyRotten-uf6xw]

As an Indian, I wholeheartedly agree. Canada must find students in Latin America and Africa who can pay five times of what Canadians pay for an already-overpriced degree to live in a country that does not have enough homes or medical services or jobs for them, despite of all the money they bring in. A sector responsible for 20% of Canada's GDP and literally keeps the country afloat, a country that cannot even provide their own citizens housing or heating, let alone them. At the front of the line when it comes to overpaying for degrees and taxes when they start working in tech and finance but at the back of the line when it comes to receiving the benefits and blamed for all of the nation's ills despite the fact that they commit crimes at a much lower rate. I'dd say Canada should go ahead and try to bring in 280bn in student fees from Bolivian and Gambian students.

[@Jayjay-ji7ty]

He's an idiot like his boss we need an ice division of cbsa

[@watching-the-watchers55]

Mr. Miller should leave Canada 'immediately'. He is clueless!

[@nwc3270]

Totally clueless

[@michaudmech]

There is obviously millions of Canadians that are clueless. Remember Canadians voted for trudeau 3 times or maybe I'm clueless.

[@mikewoo4663]

marc miller should take his boyfriend tredeau to india and never be allowed back in to canada.

[@lauriebromberg3880]

​@@michaudmech No Canadians didn't

[@John-fl3lp]

Check his personal bank account. Paid politicians by Chinese Triads!

[@drewa4235]

They won’t leave until the free money dries up. Which doesn’t seem likely any time soon.

[@feastongluten-free1763]

There is no free money for the students. Their tuition fee is 3 times more . They do slave labour , earn less than minimum wage working under the table. But if you're an asylum seeker , it's a different story...free hotel , monthly paycheck etc...

[@Drareg-x3m]

Should be 10x and they should be held to actual academic standards as that’s not what I’ve encountered with these “graduates.”

[@feastongluten-free1763]

@@Drareg-x3m thats what happens when the government approves hundreds of diploma mills , some are just a room in the strip malls ! It's a govt approved scam....looting money , giving empty promises .

[@JohnnyRotten-uf6xw]

@@feastongluten-free1763 Don't burst the bubble. Canada is taking in millions of tech and finance students from halfway round the world, just to give them free housing and healthcare and getting nothing in return. Absolutely passes the smell test....if your olfactory lobe is missing.

[@sharonfelix7244]

You mean the money they bring into your economy. All these dumb racists in the comments with no economic knowledge😂

[@InvisibleHotdog]

He has no plan, CBSA wouldn't have the resources to remove all those people

[@eddychiu8855]

They will leave if their working visa not approved... no job and you need to go home .. this method so suck

[@AR-pm3zp]

​@@eddychiu8855 crime will increase exponentially

[@tymciach5003]

@@eddychiu8855they can work for cash for Indian run businesses. Why would they leave ?

[@eddychiu8855]

@@tymciach5003 so, the method is suck（The true is immigration department had no plan 😂)

[@markmaloney3140]

​@@eddychiu8855It must be a failure.... You're still here and haven't mastered English yet......

[@gilliangirl1]

As someone who works 'in the system', trust me when I tell you that Service Canada has no flying clue where any of these people are. Even when we tell them where they are, nothing gets done. This government has turned Canada into the world's welfare system, on the backs of hard-working Canadians.

[@Mazingamzito]

What welfare? No international student or foreigner gets free money. ONLY CANADIANS GET WELFARE. Immigrants work hard and can work for free if they could.

[@deesmith6363]

Sure they will. What a liar.

[@viorelstan408]

We're fucked 😢

[@Abdominal65]

Just wait until Canadians start getting pissed off.

[@rbt5462]

With protection or without protection?

[@db4492]

Without, and wrapped in sand paper​@@rbt5462

[@Spiderman20080]

​@@Abdominal65We immigrant are here to stay for ever and we are the future of Canada, we immigrant have human right and entittle to stay here under human right and entittlement law

[@pangdada5208]

@@Spiderman20080 this not about immigrants, but "temporary" migrants.... these are 2 different things

[@The_Saxon_of_Riverstone]

… then the migrants can apply for refugee status.

[@mrsreebz]

Delusion ....they don't leave Marc. You know this. I had a neighbor who overstayed his visa and he did not leave, not only that he stopped paying rent for a year, he caused all kinds of problems. When we contacted CBSA they did nothing! Called police (because this person was angry and making threats) and was told there was nothing they could do. So this person had no right to be in the country, paid no taxes, was not paying rent, was causing harm to citizens and there was zero consequences. This was four years ago.

[@CanadaDubaigirl]

😳 😡

[@joffinmathew5654]

Is this guy indian ?

[@grandmufftwerkin9037]

It sounds like the neighbourhood needs to take its own action....

[@Slipshott]

Sounds like you live next door to Justin.

[@jmshwood2801]

​@@joffinmathew5654What more to expect . . .

[@northernlight696]

Lies, lies and more lies. None of these scammers plan to leave voluntarily.

[@derekbooker3677]

“Temporary migrants will leave voluntarily “ “The budget will balance itself “ Etc….. What exactly do these people do all day long?

[@marquee2066]

Marc is delusional he lives in a perfect world. Temporary workers, International students, and visitors would just leave voluntarily after some of them protested to stay.

[@praiseisraelomaghe7021]

Take their paycheck

[@johnlocke_1]

They do everything they can to line their pockets while they can before they are ousted in the next election

[@Pandeburak]

They will eventually leave because of the cost of living, most of them cannot work after their Visa's expire eventually they will leave rather than die due to hunger.

[@bcatbb2896]

This immigration minister is delusional My family know several individuals that came to Canada illegally and they’ve stayed for decades at this point because working under the table is still more than what they can make at the home country

[@PeeyushGupta-q9s]

All international students applying for asylum should be send back & let them sue Canada in their home countries .

[@Drareg-x3m]

ASAP!

[@contribution741]

Sue Canada? For being required to leave after their TEMPORARY visa ends? They have no grounds to sue Canada, that was a strange comment. We owe those people nothing. We should incarcerate them and deport them, then do a deep dive into anyone who received PR in the past 10 years and deport a bunch of them too. Then we should offer money to remigrate people back to wherever they came from if they agree to never return to Canada.

[@Amarpreet-Singh-Dhindsa]

Shut up....u are an immigrant too.PEE💦-YUSH😂

[@galabaga]

There is no mechanism to send them back. They will commit crimes and at the very least find every loophole to every law.

[@sharonfelix7244]

Asylum? That’s for refugees. Everyone who’s not indigenous is an immigrant, peeyush Gupta 😂

[@cd5098]

Ha, yeah like that's going to happen! Total BS.

[@Sangini-e2x]

What a great answer by Miller 2:34 “I dont know.”

[@PeeyushGupta-q9s]

Track all these people through their education institutions, bank accounts & employers.

[@Bernardstlouis-wo9hg]

He's delusional! He doesn't care about immigrants; just $ to come here! Once all their $ gone, they won't have anything left to leave.

[@tigerlancer]

I don't get it. Why aren't their visas getting renewed? Don't they have to graduate?

[@darrylanthonybriones46]

@@tigerlancerdue to the new immigration rules (that are changing in a suspiciously fast pace) most graduates and TFW are left with Little option to renew their permits. In other words, Canada used the student pathways to earn exponential amount of money and welcomed millions of TR into Canada without any actual plans to keep them inside Canada. Par example, local tuition fees pays $2000 for a course and an international student pays 3-4x that depending in the school.

[@tigerlancer]

@@darrylanthonybriones46 so these foreign workers knew this going into Canada? They knew there was never a path to pr cards?

[@darrylanthonybriones46]

@ No. 1-2 years ago there were multiple streams that are clear and fairly easy to achieve PR. Due to the increase of “acceptance rate” of new students / WP that were unplanned this caused immigration to dramatically overhaul the immigration rules.

[@tigerlancer]

@@darrylanthonybriones46 got it.

[@mehtaank1]

Gross negligence and incompetence demonstrated by this clown from Trudeau's circus!!!

[@sophieeeaaahhs6547]

Good on Tom for putting the pressure on Marc. He’s been gaslighting for too long about immigration and he has got to go!

[@speroskoufis7505]

Remember the criminal negligence? It was intentional

[@JacobAdam-l9k]

All government crew must be prosecuted!! Is this Canada first, or INDIA first! What is wrong

[@Lashley-jp9bo]

They have Indians who also work in government and help their own people pass the test to stay. Corruption at the highest level.

[@sharktooth7966]

It’s become pretty obvious over the last few years that they are not here to assimilate. When they get their own businesses they only hire their own people. Look at the service Ontario car theft ring Indians employed by Service Ontario going out of their way to help their fellow Indian criminals steal vehicles. Notice the protest in multiple parts of the country involving the Indian students not wanting to go home and even so far as to say this is stolen land and we can’t tell them what to do and eventually if we cave enough times them protest will turn into them demanding their own pice of land in Canada.

[@MobyK-o1i]

You are 100% right about them

[@vasujuneja5460]

Not really. It doesn’t work like that.

[@sharonfelix7244]

Hmm, the hypocrisy 😂 and your ancestors committed genocide of the native people, did not immigrate, but in fact colonized and caused major cultural, environmental and human violations

[@rayuanedwards7389]

This guy don’t have a solid answer

[@skaulan]

No body is leaving voluntarily. This minister is delusional, has no plans.

[@halburd1]

program should NOT exist in the first place

[@bawlingchicken1]

What he is really saying is, "It won't be my problem, why are you asking me this?"

[@navisall-rr]

The “students” protesting non stop in Brampton will never leave willingly.

[@safiakhan840]

Deport them immediately

[@JohnnyRotten-uf6xw]

God forbid people protest against unfair treatment in a country that claims to have free speech and freely lectures India about its moral superiority.

[@gymrat9072]

@@JohnnyRotten-uf6xw Canada doesn’t have free speech

[@AR-wm9lv]

​@@JohnnyRotten-uf6xw The students have free speech to protest, and I have free speech to criticize them. That's how free speech works, bud. Free speech for all of us, not just you

[@JohnnyRotten-uf6xw]

@@AR-wm9lv Yes, but unfortunately we've seen how quickly free speech translates into disproportionate crackdowns as was seen in the case of the right-wig truckers, even if some of them had opinions beyond the pale. If you're from the wrong stripe politically or culturally you get shut down pretty quickly in the supposedly 'free' country. If this were a bunch of Ukrainians protesting about their problems pretty sure ya'all wouldn't mind.

[@Stevi987]

Clearly no plan!

[@Reorks911]

Basically this guy has NO IDEA WHAT IS GOING ON. WHY ARE WE PAYING THIS GUY OUR TAX DOLLERS TO STAY IN OFFICE??????

[@Chloe-ez5bf]

I am a citizen and I would like to apply assylum just like the students ...coz they have better situation than I am. They are getting free support from the government while here I am struggling .

[@sharonfelix7244]

What are you smoking? Free support. Do you know the amount of money these “ immigrants” bring to your economy. Do your research for once. Why is it that racism and stupidity go hand in hand?

[@galabaga]

This is one useless Immigration Minister. He has no answers, he has no plans.

[@EDWARDOholyjesusheaven]

visiting a doctor or hospital is like visiting behind enemy lines of a refugeee camp...

[@ytwatcher6020]

Lazy, incompetent fool, like his boss.

[@benelliot8737]

Hahaha what a joke. We’ve given this country away

[@sharonfelix7244]

You mean the country you stole from the indigenous people. The hypocrisy 😂getting all puffed up about immigrants coming in through immigration channels Canada created, all the while your descendants- wreaked havoc on this land which rightfully belongs to the indigenous people - turned these people into criminals and outcasts in their own damn country. Just wow, there is no end to the arrogance of colonizers, runs through generations

[@robhersey1796]

How can so many idiots be in one party?

[@halburd1]

the left is always that way. yet the maroons keep voting them in.

[@user-yn9mx7xu1r]

Idiots are good at finding each other 😂

[@CanadaDubaigirl]

Omg this is sickening 😡 so basically he’s saying we could see another 3M immigrants in the next 2 years .

[@Drareg-x3m]

The destruction of Canada.

[@danpopescu5716]

Basically we are screwed!!!!!!!!We need elections now, no time to screw around anymore!!!!!!!

[@cowubl]

Yes As native canadians all whites should leave

[@psysword33]

Give them enough notice. Then, just debank them like they did with Trucker's. Keep their SIN active, and blacklist it and all the privileges associated with it. Open call centers at all police stations for individuals to report those who are illegally working, let the police officers go and do the checks based on it, collect data, write-up charges, and give identifying data to CBSA. If a trend from individuals of a certain country is strong on this matter, announce less study permits would be given to individuals applying from those centralized areas, then do it, make it like 5 years or so. It is not like they don't know how to handle it. It is just that they need them to be on the news on a weekly basis, to just agitate people. Meanwhile, fix the education system, make it competent and aligned with job market needs. Provide less money in funding to students who are seeking education from institutes that have bad practices and are just operating like cutthroat business.

[@estebanperez4171]

This is lunacy

[@VS-n6d]

what are they smoking???

[@grandmufftwerkin9037]

The basic Trutatorship must end.

[@akacurryful]

Next in Canada: we expect criminals will turn themselves in and go into prison volunteerily

[@nattie911]

😂 yup that seems to be how he thinks 🙃

[@renegaderabbit222]

Miller proving once again how incompetent he is, every time he opens his mouth.. well that would be un-parliamentary for me to say..

[@samtahm749]

Nobody leaves voluntary. This clown thinks we are naive

[@Dominicanwine-t5k]

And the budget will balance itself - Sunny days my friends Sunny days

[@jaysonnazareth119]

Yes, temporary migrants will leave and refugees will stay forever, this is Canada's ultimate plan, RIP Canadians.

[@kimc555]

Student visa expiration should never lead to asylum application. Go home.

[@saurabhsinghal102]

Pierre for PM and jail for JT and JS

[@jimrudolph2864]

Claiming asylum after student visa expires is just taking advantage of the generous Canadian system to buy more time at the cost of Canadian taxpayers.

[@laurets25]

Yeah, that's why those people who will voluntarily leave are protesting on the streets to stay. Because they will leave.

[@gleobricksscaptain2483]

There are better places to migrate than living in Canada… Hong Kong needs immigrants, Singapore is another choice or even Malaysia … Canada is too cold for them, go to a better place. In fact Australia and New Zealand have better opportunities than here. As a Canadian I am thinking move away here 😅

[@SurprisedAirplane-zb4ci]

We are fucked honestly, marc miller needs to be arrested for treason.

[@abdihassanahmed5357]

How is this treason? He was not immigration minister when this mess started. How is he to blame?

[@upreydeen]

Many people from Mexico "temporal workers" or "students" who have over stayed for years, some of them married Canadians, have families, bought houses and absolutely have no intention to go back to their countries

[@JohnnyRotten-uf6xw]

What about the immigrants from Europe? When are they leaving?

[@sly_g]

Why would they go back if they're married to Canadians?

[@bxba4589]

@@JohnnyRotten-uf6xw You mean the ones that came legally, pay their taxes and contribute productively to society?🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣

[@JohnnyRotten-uf6xw]

@@bxba4589 Yes as opposed to Indians who are the richest and more educated demographic in North America.

[@richcasanova]

The plan is not having a plan. Genius plan.

[@sparshrastogi2646]

Like his boss, this guy can't answer a basic question. Anyone who is overstaying/has expired status needs to be removed by FORCE. No more of this politically correct bullshit. You are not welcome, wanted or needed because you are a net drain on Canada.

[@queryhsje7514]

I'm quite surprised that he's not ready with any supporting data when answering all the questions. This is something super serious, and he should've been ready with his plan when it comes to immigration issues.

[@adamwarnell4612]

I live in Canada. A few doors down there is about twelve 20 plus year olds living in a three bedroom house. There are 9 cars in the driveway. These men are clearly from the Middle East and I’m sure everyone’s name is not on the house!

[@halburd1]

all their names are mohamad so obviously one name covers it and the entire mohamad murder cult membership,

[@abdihassanahmed5357]

I don’t think they are from the Middle East. Middle East basically is Arabs. The overwhelming majority of immigrants are from India and I would think that is where they are from. From my interactions with middle eastern people they don’t crowd out into apartments like that. They like living large. I am from Africa and I know a thing about immigrants, being one myself

[@yvs0911]

Most dangerous is students applying for asylum based on fantasy threats

[@bankai1234561]

They apply for protection from Canada 🇨🇦 l😂😂😂

[@NoGattsuNoGlory]

Lol voluntary....😅

[@judahnanneti5599]

No one will leave unless are forced out. Government needs to take steps to force these temporary visa holders to leave else Canadians will have no jobs and food to eat.

[@sampowa2943]

the indian landlods will ensure that these people will not leave so they can pay their mortgage. 7-8 international students per basement.

[@marklande3752]

These liberals absolutely hopeless

[@criskrishnan6508]

They not going to leave, they will seek asylum ...Period!

[@darshiliyanage9429]

He has no any plan, why he is a minister

[@unknown-hi5cf]

Why is he so concerned about someone staying in the country anyway? You don't own Canada, buddy.

[@wivinek2815]

I think the government needs to enforce this , you can’t just expect people to leave. International students are clever they know that the backlog of refugee claimant is huge and you have to wait 5 years or even 10’years so they will still be in Canada 🇨🇦 😊

[@ryan7735]

That’s really messed up, he didn’t even know what he was doing or talking. Shameful for this government.

[@gagandeepsingh1583]

My wife is a surgeon and we are not settling here, because the conditions have been so bad lately. No doctors in emergency.

[@AmitSoni-xz6be]

He is an idiot, the crime will rise, they dont care abt this country as this country didnt cared abt them

[@leecrumble3921]

Why would they leave? They will work under the table.

[@gjo1232]

Recover the money from colleges, agents , rentlords and businesses to give back to those students who got scammed to be in Canada .. hopefully they will leave then..

[@WAVM2024]

That's ridiculous. Canadian are not responsible for the problems of those foreign students.

[@gk5233]

Joke of the year! Trust me majority will not leave but Marc Miller Will definitely leave his position by that time.

[@AussieBodybuilder]

Lock this guy up

[@John-fl3lp]

Another politician on drugs!

[@chrisbrunette9495]

Estimating???? They should know the f ing numbers 🤯🤬

[@abdihassanahmed5357]

You must be so smart @chrisbrunette to have all the answers. Easy to talk obviously

[@chrisbrunette9495]

@ are you retarded or just uneducated? Or just one of the ones that’s supposed to leave???

[@SB-zj2pm]

Great questioning by the conservative minister. Honestly impressed, asking all the right questions. We need this guy head of the conservatives instead of PP

[@princedjaba4626]

Don't forget covid 19. Don't be ungrateful. This world is not without God

[@sparetire3]

You know its bad when Joe Biden answers questions better than this fool.

[@derekwilliams1066]

The only way to get them to leave voluntarily is to cut off their benefits. They will then leave.

[@wkwkwkw1216]

What benefits do international students have?

[@Rock_Girl_Daze]

@00:32 answer: here >>>read this. 🙈

[@specialiseesi6746]

Nobody listened to the very end: Liberals tried to reform immigration and refugee systems, but Conservatives voted against playing politics. We´re doomed indeed.

[@terapeo2027]

Unless of course they file refugee cases in which case they will stay for years until the case is adjudicated.

[@bearbull8437]

This is your government😭 Absolutely unthinkable🤡

[@drewhendry8172]

How does this 🤡 even have this position

[@jmcb3411]

What a big mess. Completely clueless.

[@lauriebromberg3880]

Everything we're seeing is being done on purpose

[@EDWARDOholyjesusheaven]

$43 a day, as a 60yr old brain and spinal kidney patient..no housing...no food, no clothes...43 a day is 1450 a month...new arrivals in our own gov denying me help and rights..

[@brettfavreify]

The minister shows great faith that temporary migrants will always do the right thing. This government refuses to govern, yet they keep hiring more bureaucrats.

[@Fred-ms1hu]

Sure they will 😂😂😂😂 Is he high on drugs??

[@vancouverviking4652]

They all are. Look ar Freebase Freeland

[@abdihassanahmed5357]

No he is perfectly sound and sane. He is getting grilled with questions he has no answers to

[@jdog2345]

These individuals need to leave whether voluntarily or not…this Liberal Minister cannot hide the fact that Canadians are not ok with his lies. We are watching while our Conservative Party makes sure the Liberals antics are exposed. Thank you Mr Kmiec.

[@marquee2066]

There are still more International students with expired visas that are still here. He ain't gonna do anything about it. He just talks the talk.

[@karanveersinghdeol73]

People on study permit will not leave because they can opt for three year work permit if they have followed rules regarding work hours.

[@snow-by1po]

The Minister must leave; we should sue him for bringing thieves and students who rape

[@ridgwayorais8429]

Looks like Miller doesn't know his job.

[@decebalignat3531]

Violation of the law. What law? Canada doesn't even know where deported people are now and can't find them to deport them. If any deportation at all.

[@SunnyKooner13]

What a mess these guys made