NEW CARS VS OLD CARS CRASH TESTING! - BeamNG Drive Crash Testing

[@danc2581]

Those old 1950's cars didn't have a collapsing steering shaft. On a hard frontal impact the steering shaft would launch out of the dash into the driver's face. They named it "the harpoon" after they changed the design.

[@ps2bndled]

This is also why some vehicles had an upward-facing steering wheel back then.

[@krubzbubz]

No airbag, no seatbelt. Neilogical: Dead. No airbag, but with a seatbelt. Neilogical: Dead. Airbag and a seatbelt. Neilogical: 5/5 would drive again.

[@gr4nco892]

tru facs

[@abdulgill5013]

-_-

[@nevergonnagiveuupkfc7377]

'-'

[@encaram3ss1]

Lol

[@krubzbubz]

@@encaram3ss1 lithuania 3

[@HWFG1872]

90% of those crashes would've resulted in death, the other 10%? Paralysed, limbs amputated, life changing injuries. 60 into a wall, is never a good ending.

[@small_SHOT]

Now i know to never go straight into a concrete wall at 60 mph

[@kpotter2546]

@@small_SHOT I suggest you don't

[@kpotter2546]

At the end of was 90mph

[@kpotter2546]

Ranger are you a doctor

[@kpotter2546]

Are you a doctor

[@beanie640]

Sir, what’s the damage report? *DEATH* Sir, logical answer please. *points to car which is a pancake in a wall* Oh, I see now.

[@gdnormie2469]

Meh.. it’s decent

[@brucej6198]

A pancake on the wall. Not in. But still funny either way

[@yeahh2085]

This isn't the best

[@unkkelkesseli8827]

its a neiLOGICAL answer

[@gillianbrown6052]

Henry it is the best video ever

[@codymoncrief8478]

Many old steering wheels are designed to fold over when a body hits them, likewise the steering colum itself collapses at a calibrated force to act as a bit of cushioning too.

[@TheAsdffaaa]

airbag enough, said the sixties

[@jblbasstester6198]

Any crash at 60mph will likely result in death, as the body isn't able to withstand such forces. You also have to keep the legroom in mind. A general rule is that every time the A-Pillar is pushed back, either the dashboard or legroom is compromised.

[@snuffleupagus8268]

The sudden stop too

[@horror_man915]

airbags exist and seatbelts

[@xanderfolfsky1699]

Should use crash test dummies with and without seatbelts in another video. That way you can say for sure if they are killed or just hurt.

[@jointaimbot55]

Xander Folfsky no way to tell

[@xkuivs5514]

And crash test skins

[@dominick2890]

jman_jd10 ikr

[@stinger_2237]

All of the people in these cars are dead, they are 1 not crash ready/ safe cars and a head on crash at 60+ mph is somewhere around 100gs and that's fatal.

[@hyperpengu8722]

There's still no way of knowing for sure cause its a FREAKIN *VIDEO GAME!* get that through your stupid little head! Games don't follow real physics some might say they do but really NONE of them do! Beamng just made it look realistic by making EVERYTHING fall apart basically on impact of only around 30 mph and somehow people fell for it its hard to even believe the speedometer!

[@jamesknight8974]

hey neil, my name is james. been watching a long time. i've always hoped someone could do a mod where there's a way to determine if the driver of a vehicle would servive a accident in this game. if you know any modders or anyone who could create anything like that, I think it would be a huge change for this game. cause instead of guessing if they survive like most of us do, we would have a better guess due to the dummy, stig or mod of them. let me know what you think.

[@unknownuser1736]

i guess just put a dummy and decide yourself

[@xvumns]

There is some dummy mods i have i cant reme,ber the name but there is alot of tutorial videos!

[@facemcshooty6602]

It would very hard to simulate something like that It's kinda like getting shot, some people survive, some don't

[@ddylla85]

Older cars did not absorb/deflect energy created by crash away from the driver. While the vehicle may appear to have less damage visually, the likelihood of injuries are significantly higher due to design.

[@noonxrs]

this is how many times Neil said "seatbelt" \/

[@Fuggincreature]

9

[@Nathan-bg6bu]

The angle of the crash also matters as it may or may not concentrate the force onto a smaller portion of the car.

[@gamingspider-man9858]

Test 7: leg injuries Test 8: legs possibly shattered Test 9: passed👍 Test 10: passed👍 Test 11: passed👍

[@lynda5968]

Gaming Spider-man hi

[@urabusliberty9258]

iihs does it at 40

[@leoellis8304]

Jaye Bush Neil does it at 60mph

[@hyperpengu8722]

iihs does it by average speed Neil does it by highway/interstate speed!

[@Aluxix]

It's because those cars doesn't do any damage at 40 mph but in real life it does do a lot of damage. No clue why?

[@fair.]

well the 60 in bmg is pretty much 40 in irl

[@ThomasFarquhar2]

I do it by how fast can I push it down the hall

[@keeponwishin]

No matter how good of a car you’re in, it’d be pretty hard to survive a 60mph head-long crash into a solid wall. Not only speaking about the effects on the vehicle, a person’s internal organs are colliding with the chest and abdominal wall and cause massive internal injuries. Good part about it most people won’t hit a wall that fast. Most folks will try to brake before impact.

[@murilopirrialves343]

You could have used the year filter on the right side of the car selector menu !!!!

[@hyperpengu8722]

Murilo Pirri Alves I think he did....

[@liammoore8343]

@@hyperpengu8722 That was infuriating. I was sitting there like "Just click the YEAR FILTER!!!!

[@FluffyUnicornAsian]

I think it was starting in the early 90s, with increasing safety regulations for cars around the world tightening, many auto manufacturers started designing around the passenger/cabin safety cage idea. And to this day, cars are structurally designed around keeping the cabin as intact as possible to increase the safety for passengers in the event of a serious crash, rollover, etc.

[@Elraiquis]

Yes, but the ford sierra From the 90s I had very bad security

[@willsaygoodbye]

... Miramar my dude

[@OhioanGhost]

Old cars- built like a tank New cars- built like a lego set

[@awesomeman3258]

Driver in old car: *DEAD* Driver in new car: Alive

[@peterlaing2537]

Seatbelts were mandated in the US, according to Title 49 of the United States Code, Chapter 301, Motor Vehicle Safety Standard, on January 1, 1968.

[@hyperpengu8722]

Peter Laing NERD!

[@arturofelix6485]

Actualy it was on 1958

[@devandriggers8779]

The US government didn't make seatbelts mandatory in passenger cars until 1966.

[@davidsindlinger4031]

they may have been required to be in the car but you were not required to wear them until the mid 90s

[@Dixieflinter]

I've never in my life seen someone get so pissed off over seatbelt laws....

[@Cyberdyne-kg8ku]

I can't believe they crashed these beautiful, irreplaceable classics. 😆

[@derrickgray8503]

I know!

[@MBG141]

Should've done them with the dummies. Also the IIHS, NHTSA, and other governmental agencies does the crash testing at 40 mi/h.

[@plazmoap6577]

MBG141 hi

[@anthonybreedlove336]

MBG141 e

[@user-ui5bx4pf9v]

@A real bisexual petrol-head r/quityourbullshit. Also it's you're

[@wulfffo]

@@user-ui5bx4pf9v no

[@sta255_]

NHTSA does it at 35 mph not 40 mph

[@randomthingswithrandarawan8077]

Just use the g force meter and you decide on dead vs alive

[@angrydalek]

Nobody is ever ”ok” after an accident.

[@redfixesjunk]

Mortified Pancake So if I bumped into a wall at 2 m.p.h. I wouldn't be ok?

[@hyperpengu8722]

Or if you accidentaly drop an egg... He just said an accident he didn't say what kind of accident!

[@macgaming-gs6co]

Mortified Pancake I flipped a car and came out with only a bruise

[@hyperpengu8722]

mac10987 gaming NOPE YOUR NOT OK BRUISE EQUALS NOT OK! (just making fun of the dude who posted the comment)

[@hyperpengu8722]

notthelegend27 that makes way LESS sense...

[@igeneralyt]

2:30 DEATH 5:00 DEATH 6:40 DEATH OR CRITICALLY INJURED 8:43 DEATH OR CRITICALLY INJURED 10:24 CRITICALLY INJURED 12:00 CRITICALLY INJURED 13:13 BADLY INJURED 14:33 BADLY INJURED 15:46 INJURED 16:27 INJURED 17:25 SLIGHTLY INJURED 18:37 SLIGHTLY INJURED

[@charlesray93]

Hey Neil! One way that I love destroying cars is to spawn them inside the crusher that comes stock with the game, but spawn the car in the crusher while the crusher is all the way compressed. Then, pull the crusher apart. It tears the cars to shreds.

[@samanthanewland9581]

Charles Ray jjeyueueuwiiuwuwiiii

[@avsti]

So painful to watch you overlook the Gravil Blue Collar Series when looking for old cars. X_X

[@slonky821]

you would not be "okay" in most of these crashes ahaha

[@AlfredHawthornBennyHill]

The Oldsmobile Regency had that particular body style from 1980-84 and a similar body style from 1977-79.

[@andreaseie8650]

the new cars might look more damaged because of the deformation zones, and that will make you safer

[@Dawso80]

Neilological: See a totally destroyed front of the car Neilological: You'll be fine.

[@scottthewaterwarrior]

Some of these cars you crashed more offset then others, than can also have a big impact on the results, as there is less structure to help absorb the same amount of force.

[@___z___7713]

Hey Neil i love your videos keep up the good work

[@millielancaster2248]

Neil should review the Gavril Blue Collar Series! He has it in his mod list. Who wants to see that next? ^^

[@hyperpengu8722]

Not me

[@trollsthatlol1]

^^

[@Jame5man]

Every car prior to the Pigeon was if not fatal. Guaranteed to cause brain trauma due to lack of airbags and permanent removal of your legs due the complete crumpling of the footwell

[@Adidas1037]

2:15 is the start

[@GamingMaster007]

honestly the most dangerous thing aobu told cars, IS that they are tough, when you crash that means there is no crumple zone, so the newers LOOK worse but in reality the new ones are ALOT better

[@nwadiogoanumba2809]

I remember this is the first video I've seen from neilogical

[@Good_Game525]

Same me too

[@trekkerfletcher]

My apologies as I am very new to your Channel but what platform are you using for this program? The graphics are spectacular and I could practically watch these crash tests all day just to theorize whether or not one could actually walk away from an accident or even start the car up and drive off afterwards. Oh and to answer your question, seat belts became mandatory in Wisconsin in 1961, Nationwide in the United States in 1968. At least for the front seats. I'm assuming or at least hoping that that included the rear passenger seats as well. Seat belt laws, on the other hand... I wish everybody would just Buckle the hell up. So many lives would be saved. Truly.

[@rymacreeks2k07]

he's using the video game BeamNG drive, this is the baseline physics for the game, completely unmodified

[@basedana]

G'day Neil well actually cars had seatbelts since the end of the 40's d had seatbelts since. PS: you didn't test the at least 7 other cars that are official.

[@cyberwolf5075]

poor malimar ;( my favorite car in the game. So Neat ='(

[@willsaygoodbye]

Both wrong, it's Miramar ;)

[@RoastFlea61]

they had them as an option but seatbelts didn't become mandatory in the U.S. until 1968

[@arwinartwell]

No cars in beamng have seatbelts but the 200bx has seatbelt buckles but no seatbelt which is weird.

[@joeypalmiero7576]

Yeah but they were pretty crap. Volvo made the first proper seatbelts in 1959 and they didn’t become mandatory for the next 20 years

[@lgtpsychojnr6184]

Neilogical: There's no way you can walk away from that Dominic toretto: Oh yeah well I got family

[@the_padzer3456]

হ্যাঁ হ্যাঁ হ্যাঁ হ্যাঁ

[@spaghetti9067]

Seat belts were invented by Volvo in 1959

[@knowledgeispowermediaprodu7094]

So I did it Neil...I bought Beamng. And I am NOT disappointed!!! My roommates think I'm absolutely insane. Always laughing...cheers!

[@Leo_Santisteban]

And the Hirochi SBR4? It´s my favorite car 😱😩

[@Packle.]

Safety wise its nearly identical to the ETK so there really isn't a point.

[@Leo_Santisteban]

@@Packle. lmaoooo I’m now reading this 2 year old comment from me and why tf did I use those emojis lol

[@Packle.]

@@Leo_Santisteban relatable

[@CPorter]

the thing is, the older cars will survive better that newer ones in a collision, because the older cars werent cheaply made. they were made to run for a while (with the exception Plymoth)

[@adhamghaly7256]

you missed the Miramar, legran, roamer, sbr4, etk 800

[@mrlego609]

Just subscribed!! Great video man

[@darkcrypto_yt]

Maybe the airbags, in the future for beamng, could be a config you attach to your car.

[@Cornsyrupisgood]

Bro I see u everywhere on beam vids. Seen u on Manjaros channel and now here

[@darkcrypto_yt]

@@Cornsyrupisgood yea I love watching beamng videos lol

[@crazycars81]

@@darkcrypto_yt u have it?

[@Pretzil43]

According to this logic, if cars didn't have steering wheels, no one would ever die, since that's the only thing that ever kills you...

[@notanalt2771]

not really, on a small overlap crash test if the car performs badly, the steering wheel would slip off with the airbag a bit to the left/right and because it's a small overlap, you also experience forces to the right/left because it's not full head on. your head would smack against the dashboard then so it's not really only the wheel. g forces are what kills you

[@therangerhelix7126]

Uh Neil where did you get that Lamboghini Huracan? Because all Lambo mods are private for some reason

[@juliannawrobel8537]

11:09 Neilogical: you dead Me: yup

[@kingsavage2272]

There's an app you can put on screen for cruise control. It's in the default game too

[@hyperpengu8722]

King Savage shhhhhhh he doesn't know that... And lets keep it that way cause its hilarious when he messes up!

[@speedy1595]

My grandfather and his mom drove of a cliff accidentally it was 300ft and they both survived and are still able to walk to this day

[@carterkamolnik7555]

OMG

[@waylongreger8158]

The “i6” stands for straight six. Just so you know.

[@ianmchale2789]

Inline 6

[@packardexelence]

JUST A SHAME --THE "BURNSIDE" NEVER EXISTED!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

[@Steve1766]

inline 6

[@matthewkoen6124]

That pigeon did well 😅

[@Ludoki]

60 mph = 96 km/h... thanks Google

[@FalzoonFX]

wat

[@Ethanthegrand]

@@FalzoonFX get good at school

[@FalzoonFX]

Ethanthegrand14 I am good at school k

[@Ethanthegrand]

@@FalzoonFX k

[@jennifermcquillan1041]

it would be cool if iihs used this game as a crash test simulation

[@eight10aaronn]

15:37 My favorite car.

[@kevinwallis2194]

just found this, and had to share my thoughts. ive been running demolition derbys for over 45 years. you cant strengthen them. ive run mostly 60s cars and never once had major damage to myself or car, until i ran a 94 lincoln. the actual door skin ripped right off, and the trunk was in the back window. if you want to know if im lying, i have a few videos on my youtube. i never want to crash in a new car.

[@kevinwallis2194]

@Le-Grande they say they do, but i believe its only in their tests. i could be wrong and most likely are because ive not gotten millions to test them. but then, im not getting millions to make people feel safer in a car either. I believe they have gone to the opposite extreme and made them too easy to crush.

[@notasixpack]

pessima marimar and sbr4 are the ones you forgot

[@lukecona2749]

and 800 series

[@kermikal6296]

Seat belts exist since 1968. Airbags exist since 1989.

[@im_restoring5384]

I like how most of the deaths are from the steering wheel but mind you the steering wheel where it gets positioned after a wreck is not accurate to real life and most of those wrecks with the old cars are survivable and they did have seat belts in the burnside era but they were lap belts so you would smash your head into the steering wheel and most people didn't wear them

[@thefella9120]

Or The lap belt would come up and crush Atleast 7 organs

[@thiccysnikkys2nd526]

The hopper just chilling there

[@numbblackpicture]

I heard somewhere that you're dead when you hit a wall with around 70km/h like 50mph no matter what because of the G forces that render your insides useless.

[@sleedysleedy4199]

My mom was driving 80 mph she’s alive but has 2 broken Rist forever so your wrong

[@numbblackpicture]

@@sleedysleedy4199 And she went from 80miles per hour to 0 in what? What did she hit? If it's something with zero give she souldn't be alive, glad she is though.

[@terrabeats6953]

Nope your forgetting crumple zones make it a slower transition from 60 -0 not instant that’s how people survive

[@PamelaChatman-eb6tr]

I just found out 1800s cars didn’t have crash physics💀

[@trabantfreak2370]

seatbelts became mandatory in around 1968-69 if i remember correctly.

[@spencerdosh6663]

Volvo invented the shoulder belt in 1968 I believe, but they weren't standard on American cars until the mid to late 70's, before that it was lap belts starting in the mid 60's, and airbags weren't standard in passenger cars til I believe the mid 80s, and in trucks til the late 80s

[@oliverbryson2583]

I'd like a 1957 Plymouth fury/ Christine and a vintage car

[@dogboy1610]

Yeah I like christine to bro

[@playy28]

i seen this video 4 years ago. what the nostalgia

[@knuckleberry4720]

air bags came in in the 90s

[@isaacsrandomvideos667]

80s

[@dontgotroughlol8148]

not even close

[@knuckleberry4720]

@@dontgotroughlol8148 i mean standard

[@AlfredHawthornBennyHill]

American car manufacturers Nash (in 1949) and Ford (in 1955) offered seat belts as options, while Swedish Saab first introduced seat belts as standard in 1958. Nils Bohlin, an engineer at Volvo, invented the three-point seat belt in 1959. The first seat belt law was a federal law, Title 49 of the United States Code, Chapter 301, Motor Vehicle Safety Standard, which took effect on January 1, 1968, that required all vehicles (except buses) to be fitted with seat belts in all designated seating positions. In 1983, front seat belt wearing regulations for drivers and passengers (both adult and children) came into force. In 1989, wearing rear seat belts became compulsory for children under 14. However, pre-1966 cars aren't required by federal law to have seat belts. State laws do vary, however. Some hobbyists like that they can drive vintage cars and trucks without seat belts.

[@gamingspider-man9858]

Test 1: dead Test 2: dead Test 3: your legs would be crushed Test 4: 60 mph feet crushed 90 mph dead Test 5: legs shattered and possible brain trauma Test 6: minor injuries to face and legs

[@danbeard4854]

interestingly, the more the car crumples the safer it is in theory

[@northamericanauto43]

You need to consider the cabin intrusion

[@williamh_2x693]

The old cars irl hold up better in a crash the new ones are designed to break when you crash so the car takes more impact instead of you

[@phoebeepps5916]

You forgot one of the older vehicles the oldmodle truck I think it was made in the 1980s or the 1990s do y'all agree like if u agree comment saying that you disagree

[@andrewsullivan6559]

and he did not do a 1965 cobolt

[@timdobb]

A 60mph crash vs a fixed object like this is in the fatal g-force range.

[@vidtech2630]

True. At the same time I don't think these crashes are realistic, at what would be 60mp/h

[@cameronbrownlee308]

I have a 1986 Oldsmobile cutlass supreme and some lady hit me on the side she was on her phone she had like a late 90s early 2000s Pontiac i only had dents in my door and her car had pieces in the road i just got my doors pulled out and repainted i wonder what she did with the front of her car 😂

[@abramo7700]

Cameron Brownlee what an asshole

[@packardexelence]

@@abramo7700 DID YOUR MOM PICK OUT YOUR SUBARU?????????? --BECAUSE YOU ARE WAY TOO STUPID TO PICK --(THAT) CAR OUT FOR YOURSELF!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

[@abramo7700]

packardexelence yes

[@skyscall]

@@packardexelence Says the guy who can't properly spell "excellence"

[@AerialFootball19]

I’ve seen worst nascar crashes then this🏴‍☠️

[@rubbertoe.]

CAN we get the download for this map PLZ

[@henryjhost]

beamng.com/resources/b-i-h-s-crash-hall.3205/

[@vinceventresca6719]

we should crash test cars we make in automation lmao

[@LHVing]

@@vinceventresca6719 Mind you automation cars don't crash very well...

[@nucleatomic]

On the barstow: "I am only 16! I want to have kiiiiiiiiids!"

[@lamborghinitestarossa2133]

great video

[@brandonclark8846]

The D series looks to be about a late 80s to 90s model GMC 1500 and I was driving and had a head on wreck, broke the steering column in like 3 or 4 pieces the cab came loose from the frame in the back and slide sideways and where the emergency brake is was on top of my left leg, almost in my gut and my right foot broke the gas pedal off and still almost went through the floorboard. That happened this February of 2020, before all this Covid stuff started.

[@rednack9961]

seatbelts became mandatory in the us at least in 1959

[@joeypalmiero7576]

That’s actually the year Volvo created the first proper working seatbelts, they didn’t become mandatory for over 10 years after that

[@janisbosse455]

All of the first crashes would have resulted in death. The passenger compartment is completely destroyed 😬

[@theswedishpanda]

I would like to have a Volvo in BeamNG.drive!

[@DVAMEKAGK]

I have watched allot of IIHS videos (on the KZbin) and most of the time intrusion into the passenger compartment can be fatal if not severe. As well the momentum of the accident can persuade the momentum of your body. Allot of the time in an offset crash. Your heat could be thrusted into the drivers side A pillar. The IIHS got on top of car companies and urged them to craft better air bags, and create side curtains airbags to protect you in an off set collision. In the early days of this the dummy’s head would shoot straight between the airbags and hit the dash. So most modern cars have fine tuned them so you will no longer make contact with the stealing wheel , dash or door frame. Momentum and inertia are very powerful forces. And it is important people who drive automobiles know this. I love your videos and I would so wish to work for the IIHS study ways to make automobiles safer.

[@cibulkaaa]

Jako proč tam byla Škoda? :D

[@fastwing3295]

Protože logika Američanů.

[@seancasey9828]

It doesn’t matter what car you have 60 miles an hour to a dead stop is a 95% chance of death even with the best technology 🥶

[@vjtoysreviewandgaming3145]

The Tesla Model X is 5 star.. Do it plz?

[@alexpratt99]

Those old cars actually had the little around the waist seatbelts lol

[@BuckBewENOfficial]

You know how more the damaged the car is the better? because the more damaged the car the more it absorbs all the impact energy for the people inside :D so you should not be happy that the car holds itself pretty well.

[@jeremiahboria9173]

YOU FORGOT THE GRAVIL VANDETTA AND THE BRUCKEL HOREPOWER! i subbed and turned on notifactions

[@matthewshields214]

Id rather have a wreck in the 70-80s modle cars, because there actually made out of medal. Instead of what ever cars are made out of today

[@justingoodman2241]

New cars are made of metal

[@tadeusracety]

Tea has been spilled. .

[@reubenvanloggerenberg996]

My friend owned a 2017 BMW 540d, a very safe car by all standards, he died in a head on collision when he hit a tree at 55 MPH. I feel that the game is pretty realistic, but some things just aren't: The S- series is basically a 5 series, so it is not a very realistic simulation.Otherwise, GREAT video!

[@MOMAZOSPATO]

I know im 2 years late but im sorry for your loss, i hope youre doing well irl

[@danunrau8671]

Ur vids are awsome👍

[@thomas1055213]

The steering wheels and the columns won't collapse which I think is why they wheel does come into the seat. Honestly a great video and it's nice to have a change of pace where you talk about the crashes and what damage the driver would expect. :)

[@symulatoryinietylko4757]

Great video! But in past cars was be slower and most time before crash people using breaks, so impact speed is slower

[@Longerbow]

8:45 - cabin has crumbled, engine and transmission gearbox should have been pushed back into the spot where you legs would be. Neoilogical: "Ok, that was not actually that bad, granted if you had a seatbelt on, I think you might be ok". Also same this thing at 12:05 I am not a doctor, but at the very least this looks to me that the driver will lose both legs.

[@HUNTERXP-os3ff]

Anyone just come back and watch neils older videos?

[@Master_customs]

I do