NFL Draft 2020: Chris Simms' Top 5 Quarterback Rankings | Chris Simms Unbuttoned | NBC Sports

[@noobgonebad9860]

If you come back 4 years you know Chris was right, he had Burrow, Herbert, Love, Tua. Exactly how it is right now

[@trae_brown]

Jalen hurts?

[@GKA11111]

@@trae_brownhe’s still 5th on that list

[@yaboi9419]

@@trae_brownis ass

[@leca4378]

5- Jacob Eason 2:20 4- Tua Tagovailoa 7:48 3- Jordan Love 15:38 2- Justin Herbert 25:07 1- Joe Burrows 35:21

[@GH-xy4zz]

I love people who perform public services!!

[@tyion08]

You’re the real MVP 👏🏾

[@Diostillrocks]

Jury is still out on Love and Eason.

[@toddthomas4761]

God bless you

[@CapstoneTider]

He nailed Tua. There's been no drop off with Mac Jones and he stays healthy.

[@rosihantu1]

A lot of butthurt Tuasexuals here.

[@paco7669]

Tuasexuals 😂

[@Alpha-bt9bh]

Mac is actually really good ngl

[@NameN0tFound]

Even Waddle and Smith both said Jones is better.

[@gregtrust5599]

@@NameN0tFoundMac Jones is trash and Tua is the second best QB from his draft class. He didn’t nail anything

[@lxvebassin2179]

I think Chris Simms gives the best QB evaluations. He goes deep into the good, bad, and ugly.

[@camberwickgreen5021]

🤣

[@Fent-]

@@camberwickgreen5021 what’s funny

[@bothen3605]

@@Fent- yea ask him what’s funny again lol

[@dylanvela2981]

he has eason over hurts

[@cw5205]

Chris Sims is the ONLY tv guy I’ve heard rate Tua in this way, based upon what he’s seeing, what he knows and just what his opinion is and he deserves credit for that. SO tired of hearing the same old CRAP. I happen to agree but even if I didn’t- hats off to bringing something unique to the table my man.

[@d.balbas6952]

The thing about Tua that is important is how clutch is he. He stays pose and clam and have that Tom Brady clutchness. He was born in the most clutches situation ever. Halftime during a National Championship game. Down 17. As a freshman. Game on the line. Needed a TD being down 4. Took a sack for a negative 11-12 yards. 2nd and 19 and kept calm and threw a dime for a game winning TD. Nothing rattles him. Including a hip injury.

[@CHAMPDOGZ]

I like Tua alot & he didnt bash Tua he just actually evaluated him properly where as other channels just rinse & repeat however i disagree besides injury i think hes the best qb these past 2 years & even next year so i think hes the best qb in the three year span

[@thomasc1753]

That 13 Wonderlick score Tua tossed out.... Wrong read? More like CAN'T read. My goodness!

[@allgold3rrthang]

But but but Tua is a left handed drew brees and he’s a mix of Dan Marino and Aaron Rodgers.

[@camberwickgreen5021]

No. He just has a blatant dislike of Tua. Pure click bait. 🤣

[@bandofgoonsdemopage]

Mad respect, best analyst out there, Justin Herbert is killing it

[@vl8962]

Chris Simms never afraid of going against the consensus 👍💪✌

[@KingDingeling590]

Chris Sims is the best QB evaluater by far. He is the Goat 🐐 of evaluating QB prospects. You see a lot of half wise bull💩 out there on other channels. I belive in what Chris said. He was absolutly right about the Prospects the last 2 years. I think he knows best of all this Analysts. 🤟🙂😎

[@eugenesutherland7185]

You're Chris Simms, aren't you?

[@KingDingeling590]

@@eugenesutherland7185 🤣 I wish I'm. But unfortunately I'm not😭.

[@JamesPerrone-qq1ph]

No he's not.

[@Frederick0220]

Trent Dilfer is also amazing but he's rarely on TV since he's a high school coach now

[@dylandylan8380]

Chris Simms definetly is the best qb evaluator but his prospect analysis is 50/50 on qbs hes gotten players right like Lamar but wrong on many others.

[@josetanon853]

I am starting to have new respect for Chris Simms... He's a Beast.. lol.... hahaha.... wow.. killing this mock.. for QB... love this guy..

[@reizahs]

I hope Herbert turns out well for the Chargers after watching this. In retrospect, Simms was right abt Mahomes and Jackson, and they turned out great.

[@SbLox]

he nailed on Herb

[@azma775]

@@Isaac-eh6uu how not ? Greatest rookie season ever

[@alvinodaol9594]

NFL teams need Simms evaluation to do their QB pick from now on!

[@larrygilman8896]

Simms does a great job rating talent. He was dead on with Burrow, Herbert, and Tua. He hit all of Tua's strengths and weaknesses. It's looking like the Dolphins are going to pick 3rd and will have a shot at either Wilson or Fields, both of whom I bet Simms is going to rank higher than Tua. Will they pick a QB?

[@didjen181]

No way and I hope not as a fan of not the dolphins

[@CodeineAbdulJabbar]

No chance. Ja'marr Chase is going #3

[@paco7669]

Gotta give the kid at least 2 years to show himself, especially the kind of year rookies have had with the pandemic.

[@SiDung-qg7rn]

There’s a lot of prejudice against Tua. He just needs a better team with better o line protection.

[@gregtrust5599]

He’s been dead wrong about literally everything he said about Tua 😂

[@dagoods528]

Well done fellas. Great show.

[@zayshairjourney5499]

Here after Jordan Love packed up the Cowboys and Tua folded against the chiefs lol

[@2008israelramos]

I'm looking forward to 2021 Chris Simms draft evaluations

[@joshkidd2075]

Simms always has interesting comments, not blathering. Just listened to his 2021 QB review, now I'm going back to see earlier analysis to see how he did int he past. Know what he's talking about - future GM.

[@sethfinberg348]

"Size is a skill" … as is availability … Tua is still a risk

[@St.SebastianGalasso]

I wouldn't want to risk drafting for Tua. Hip injury is serious, and he has shown a penchant for getting hurt. The things that Justin Herbert might be lacking can be taught. Herbert is much more athletic than some of these larger, lumbering QB's that were popular in the 80's and 90's (ie Vinny Testaverde, Drew Bledsoe) , and the idea that he's a weaker prospect because of his play as a Duck is silly. The offense they ran at Oregon was not suited for Herbert, and ultimately should change moving forward (its a crap system). The Dolphins should stand pat, or wait until 2021 when they can likely choose between Trevor Lawrence and Justin Fields.

[@cnelsonlv999]

He is a risk with unquestionably a much higher ceiling than Herbert or Love... MUCH higher!

[@St.SebastianGalasso]

C N I never said anything about Love. As for drafting Tua; the Dolphins can roll the dice if they like . There’s always Trevor Lawrence and Justin Fields next year.

[@CHAMPDOGZ]

Do you guys watch the games Trevor Lawrence's throws jump balls wr's make plays on them credit wr where as Tua actually throws wr open even when their open that sets up yac if it wasn't for his injuries hed be far above #1 for a few drafts and Tua throws a dime deep ball

[@sethfinberg348]

The Fins are acquiring a bit of talent already ... and if they keep most/all of their picks this year and hit on a good number of them ... they will win too many games next year to be anywhere close to a top 2 pick (especially with Brady now out of the division).

[@connor8627]

Can see teams over-evaluating both Herbert/Love and letting them slide in the first-round. Not sure why the Colts traded the 13th pick, would have been a prime spot to pick up one of those guys, Rivers might have another year in the NFL, two max. Expect the Patriots/Saints to draft a QB depending on how to board falls

[@lowernineforlife]

Great comment Sir. Who Dat

[@eugenesutherland7185]

@@lowernineforlife WHO DAT!!! ⚜

[@dachargedduck8636]

Dammm he’s was right..

[@kristie3003]

Chris, what do you think about Brett Kollmann's eval? Yours and his are my favorite in depth analyses in general.

[@jamryan45]

Interesting to hear both of them talk about Herbert... I listen to both as well, and I have to take Brett’s side on Herbert. He screams Mitch Trubisky and after hearing him say that, I can’t not see it.

[@Ghostface2point0]

James Ryan I loved when Brett broke down the playcalling and questioned WHY Herbert's coaches didn't give him more diverse plays. Maybe at points the kid lost their trust with his decision making.

[@milo8425]

BK is a half-educated storyteller that picks a narrative and runs with it. Fun videos, he's got some good insights and he puts the work in at least but his shit is really amateur in the big picture.

[@PastelitoPapi]

@@Ghostface2point0 I've heard their best receivers and TE were injured as well. That may have something to do with them not pushing the ball down field

[@ssj4gogeta77]

@@jamryan45 how about now lol. I too thought Herbert was gonna bust

[@deucefoAM206]

Chris's favorite phrase is "there's no doubt about it". There's no doubt about it...

[@rosihantu1]

No doubt about that

[@geckobrah4201]

Great analysis.

[@geoffsimpkins7650]

Tua reminds me of Matt Leinert, great college quarterback, super accurate. Think he will be disappointing.

[@cnelsonlv999]

I give it 6 months before you are pretending you never thought that...

[@liammcdonough1093]

C N I give u 6 months until u realize u don’t know football

[@cnelsonlv999]

@@liammcdonough1093 I have been betting on football professionally almost certainly since before you were born. I give it 6 months until you try to forget this conversation ever took place.

[@liammcdonough1093]

C N that’s cool, but i don’t remember asking

[@richardreptar1]

Geoff Simpkins I was thinking about this comparison but didn’t want to go all the way there like you did.

[@Connect662]

Tua is overrated. Chris is right. He played with 4 first round WRs. And 10 1st or 2nd round O-linemen. Injury prone.

[@azma775]

This aged well 👍🏼

[@Shortyd17]

Didn’t Herbert go back in part because his brother was coming in as a freshman? I can’t see how going back to school is a red flag

[@ryansuhaka9326]

Either way... lol he's amazing

[@Shortyd17]

@@ryansuhaka9326 not as good as my boy Burrow 🙃

[@ryansuhaka9326]

@@Shortyd17 I personally agree but the stats and eye test say it's arguable 😅

[@Shortyd17]

@@ryansuhaka9326 can’t really look at stats. Herbert played 5.5 more games then Joe did

[@dachargedduck8636]

He went back cause he has stated in interviews he didn’t like how the Oregon ducks season went. He loved that school and wanted to leave in a high note. Those are signs of a leader.

[@fakephoenixprince]

Chris Simms and Meril Hodges are my favorite NFL scout evaluators that appear on TV. Mind you, I disagree with these guys half the time on their picks, but it's clear, they're not paid off by agents😏😏😏

[@Frederick0220]

Trent Dilfer is also amazing but he's rarely on TV since he's a high school coach now

[@caleblotter9940]

It may sound initially weird, but he actually seems to get a close order to what it actually turns out being

[@Xix1326]

Might not be as specific to this era as it seems. Contrast the two old Viking QBs, Fran Tarkenton and Joe Kapp. Kapp was huge and immobile vs. Tarkenton, small and mobile. Kapp didn't last as long, even back then. Is it that the QB requirements have changed, or has defensive line play/strategy improved so much over offensive line play/strategy, that the mobile QB is now a requirement?

[@nicholasvalentine2428]

I was lucky enough to start watching the NFL when there was......Dan Marino, Joe Montana, Warren Moon, Randall Cunningham, John Elway, Walter Payton, Eric Dickerson, Dexter Manley, Charles Man, Clint Didier, Art Monk, Darrel Green ..........oh and Phil Simms :-)

[@erikpuka2627]

Phil was actually a solid QB for his era

[@gregtrust5599]

@@erikpuka2627he was terrible

[@whodatfanman]

Burreaux is a highly intelligent - son of a coach - footballer! Yes, he is a franchise QB!

[@kumar01234]

In Jacob Easons case, going back to college makes no sense. He has one year of eligibility left and the coach he transferred for retired so if he went back another year he has to deal with a brand new coach and likely has to compete again for the starting job in a new system all over again. Going back just doesn't make sense

[@sonofrobert]

Yes, Oregon's offensive scheme was brutal and embarrassing. Our recievers couldn't get open and the RBs had problems. So glad we have Moorhead and glad that Cristobal is flexible and can make adjustments. He could have brought in a young OC to follow his orders. Moorhead will do what Moorhead to thinks is best. Go Ducks

[@cg4224]

Turns out cristobal was the main issue . I knew he was the issue after that Auburn game...... man lol.

[@projekt679]

Please don’t shut up! Your attention to detail as QB is off the charts.

[@helmetculture]

Yeah he got this right

[@superbruhz2602]

this scares me, coz im a huge justin fields fan and chris simms says he gonna fail in the nfl

[@erikpuka2627]

Simms is the best in the business at evaluating college players(especialy QBs). Not quite evaluating the ones that have been active for a While cause he has some biases there (said Jamal Adams is a top 2 safety,Brady 10th best QB,AB and Scotty Miller are almost the same and Devante Adams is not a top 10 WR)- he got biases like that for established pros but as far as predicting college ppayers (especially QBs) - Simms is dead roght almost always.

[@edscott4729]

I think it's funny when people say Alabama QBs do well in the pros because they had NFL draftees on their college O-lines. EVERY NFL QB has current NFL draftees on their O-lines. It's up to the QB to know how to use it.

[@azma775]

Wow he was legit spot on . Hebert is better than Burrow but I can see why it went that direction .

[@nathantewkesbury8175]

*Still think Herbert is better. I think they both great Top5 QBs. But Burrow just took the Bengals to the SuperBowl*

[@investordangdaniel]

Chris Simms should be an NFL general manager. I take his word over all these so-called "experts". Simms is the real deal.

[@camberwickgreen5021]

Errrrr.... ok

[@hfbk858]

Get your facts straight Simms. Burrow was supposed to be the back up his redshirt sophomore year and then got hurt. Dwayne came in against Michigan and played great. Next spring, they competed for the job which Haskins won fairly by a slim margin. Haskins went on to throw for 50 TDs so it is not like he was a scrub. They did not hand the job to Haskins. He won it fair and square.

[@isaiahh4108]

HK my favorite moment is when they got stomped by PURDUE

[@Muskegon333]

I watched the 2018 spring game and thought Burrow clearly outplayed Haskins. Simms isn't just making this up. He has contacts all over college and pro football. The bottom line is Burrow is clearly a much better talent than Haskins and Urban Meyer missed it. LSU's coach saw it and reaped the rewards.

[@mistysowards7365]

1.Burrow 2.Herbert 3.Tua 4.Eason 5.Fromm Sleeper; Nate Stanley

[@cnelsonlv999]

Putting Herbert above Tua is going to look absurd by the middle of the year, and ludicrous 5 years into their careers.

[@THE-MAD-TECHIE]

The sleeper is Hurts IMO, 3rd best QBR under pressure only behind Burrow and Tua, McDonald was good also under pressure

[@cnelsonlv999]

@@THE-MAD-TECHIE He's a sleeper, but he shouldn't be drafted before the 3rd or 4th round.

[@tallflguy]

Fromm sucks. He won’t get drafted until the 5th round at the earliest.

[@scottyhaines4226]

@@cnelsonlv999 yeah cause you've definitely watched and analyzed more film than a former pro QB and coach.

[@ianeberhardt1238]

Interesting revisiting this in 24 re Jordan Love...

[@philippeglesener8717]

Does anybody think the dolphins may stick with Rosen and don't go Qb at all? (at least not with their top picks, since they simply don't like the talent of Herbert or Tua enough) I mean Rosen was not great last year but the surrounding cast didn't help him much either and it kinda feels like the Dolphins still like him and the way he improved.

[@jamryan45]

I think Rosen has gotten the worst shake when it comes to teams he’s been on...like he went from the 32nd ranked oline to the...32nd oline ha like he has talent, its still in there, but he has been put in places where no one is really set to succeed with his skill set.

[@enochalifasi6719]

I wouldn’t be surprised if Tua ends up with the Saints or Colts

[@RobVollat]

I would. None of the top QBs drop into the 20s.

[@fantasyhallmonitor311]

What do u think about Cole McDonald?

[@fakephoenixprince]

Nah.

[@danzemacabre8899]

He has a farm, e i, e i, o

[@rmooney6527]

Everybody disrespecting Hurts man smh

[@scottyhaines4226]

Its not disrespect, its realizing that he needs time to get up to an nfl skill level. Top 5 is guys that can start now or next year. Hurts is at least a 2 year project.

[@rmooney6527]

@@scottyhaines4226 he was a Heisman finalist dude. I dont want to here anything about him being a "project"

[@joey.thieme]

@@rmooney6527 that was such a stupid statement

[@dba_luke1327]

I like hurts but he isn’t that good

[@paulgosu2773]

@@dba_luke1327 he will be great

[@JoaodanielTrader1009.]

Chris Sims saying that teams are scared because of andrew luck and then saying oh a guy made a lot of money and his sick of this is just wrong , luck was destroyed by the colts , the guy retired because he was fucking done , if he cared about money he would just rehab and collect the check anyway

[@scottyhaines4226]

Luck was tired of being hurt. He wanted to play, he couldn't. So he cut his losses and moved on. I don't blame him one bit.

[@scottyhaines4226]

Luck was tired of being hurt. He wanted to play, he couldn't. So he cut his losses and moved on. I don't blame him one bit.

[@evh4611]

Gordon anyone??

[@Mr05Chuck]

E VH thinking round 4 . I like him.

[@Biz613]

Simms nailed Tua. Ryan Leaf said the same thing and actually had Tua lower. He’s just not that good.

[@exillens]

I'd wait to see Tua after a full off-season healthy and able to workout before I say "he's not that good"

[@danteistight]

I love the guy and agree with a lot of what he says, but I absolutely have no idea what he's watching on tape. Tua has more than enough arm strength and his accuracy is elite. Injury history is clearly a concern, but I don' know what he's talking about when he says "he plays small". Never heard him say anything similar when talking about Kyler Murray in last year's pre-draft process (he even called him Russell Wilson), who's smaller and played in a system that also had him throwing to wide open receivers.

[@rugbyking3133]

Fernando Alcazar cause Kyler has a better arm and much better athlete

[@psesh362]

Tua throws floating Matt Leinart balls

[@Mr05Chuck]

Wilson is the man

[@azma775]

Well looks like he knew what he was looking at on tape and your tape study is trash

[@9erjoeempire526]

The pocket QB is a dieing breed but mac Jones is the best QB in the 2021 draft🤔😁

[@rosihantu1]

@ryan Brinker yes

[@RobertSmith-px3ud]

Man. Chris Simms “ it’s not like you are a doctor and can have a stethoscope on to your 73

[@brettmacinnis6252]

he nailed, Tua sucks and Herbert is a beast, Jordan Love still hasnt played lol

[@dylanvela2981]

u just made the list. also he nailed it? he has eason over hurts

[@n.s.7293]

Love is a beast lol

[@ronaldcammarata3422]

If that's Chris Simm's house in the back, it looks like he lives in an historic, colonial era house.

[@edscott4729]

Stop saying, "Comp!"

[@wesleylockhart486]

Mad respect for Simms, but Tua’s size will not matter

[@azma775]

Guess it matters

[@Bleedgreenwes]

When Mac Jones took over for tua they were not the same team, nuff said Edit: I was wrong sorry he was better 🥴

[@alexshadowfax1119]

So the fact Matt Jones hadnt started much if at all, then gets thrown in towards the end of the year, factor in not playing well? Besides its just the fact Tua was hurt.

[@owencollins4612]

What about now?

[@paco7669]

Huh?

[@hawaiiguykailua6928]

@@alexshadowfax1119 so how did "Mac" Jones do?

[@robert3967]

1.Tua 2.Mason Fine 3.Burrow 4.Eason 5.Hurts 6.Fromm

[@mikehunt4371]

herbert?

[@owencollins4612]

Lol

[@mikeygolivee]

🤣🤣🤣🤣 ok u dont know football

[@robert3967]

Back by popular demand: 1)Davis Mills 2)Peyton Ramsey 3)Justin Fields 4)Jamie Newman 5)Trevor Lawrence

[@EATSLEEPREACT]

Simms hating his lefty bro

[@vivM.5497]

Chris wasnt good so who cares bout what he says

[@kingjordan6327]

@@vivM.5497 well he was right

[@vivM.5497]

@@kingjordan6327 no he hates tua

[@kingjordan6327]

@@vivM.5497 he was right about Tua. Do you even watch football?

[@alexahepple6167]

The cagey plaster densply squeal because ring anecdotally prefer as a garrulous angle. deafening, nimble foot

[@alf1380]

wrong

[@slothfinn1892]

The comfortable jelly univariably blush because can fourthly tap unto a protective cheek. unequal, stiff step-aunt

[@esoterictruthseeker5794]

What

[@SB-ui7uu]

I hate his lists. He said Jerry Jeudy is not top 5, Dandre Swift is not a top 4 back and he says Tua is only number FOUR.

[@isaiahh4108]

Gatorboy500 they all good players but I think it’s clear CD Jefferson Higgins Ruggs better than Jeudy. Taylor CEH better than Swift. Tua is QB 4

[@aadimehta3966]

He was right about everything

[@joey.thieme]

@@aadimehta3966 no. he’s a great QB evaluator but he was just wrong in both WR and RB rankings

[@aadimehta3966]

@@joey.thieme i meant qbs in terms of right on everything. But even wrs he hasnt done terrible nor rbs. Hit on taylor, claypool and metcalf. Cant predict undrafted guys that never come up like robinson. Regardless no one scouts better than simms so idk why he gets so much hate when no one else has credibility like him.

[@wavytrylen]

@@aadimehta3966 he really is prolly the most accurate analyst I’ve seen

[@bherbo3943]

I love Chris Simms but he lost me with his Justin Herbert ranking. He has all the makings of a bust. You can’t fall in love with talent and the prototype. He’s just no accurate.

[@mikehunt4371]

lmao

[@tuyenhoang5079]

Lol

[@aadimehta3966]

Lol you were wrong

[@danzemacabre8899]

Ouch

[@vantasticvoyage4145]

🤣

[@cnelsonlv999]

This entire video gets discredited by the fact that he has Tua outside the top 2. If he were a GM and drafted either of those guys ahead of Tua, he would be fired by the end of that season...

[@isaiahh4108]

C N if you pick Tua and he falls apart then your easily getting fired cuz the injury prone flags are there

[@cnelsonlv999]

@@isaiahh4108 No! Everybody knows it's a risk, but the ceiling is hall of fame level. Injuries are, by and large, random... most casual sports fans don't understand that.

[@isaiahh4108]

C N any QB can be HOF potential i actually agree that Herbert and Love have higher ceilings bigger faster better arms and more durable

[@cnelsonlv999]

@@isaiahh4108 Both of your statements are wrong! Any QB can be HOF potential? What the hell are you talking about!? And no... Herbert and Love do not have higher ceilings... these are not debatable issues!

[@mikehunt4371]

😐😐😐

[@coryjack606]

Did these dopes even watch Tua in college!?

[@allgold3rrthang]

Of course they did. But unlike you they don’t watch ESPN content religiously.

[@coryjack606]

@@TS-kk9ei Pretty sure saying Tua is a bust and not worth a pick cause injury is the sheep answer...

[@coryjack606]

@@allgold3rrthang I don't watch espn... I watched him play and he's one of the best college qbs in the last decade.

[@michaelshan22]

Ehhhh I think Chris did.

[@CodeineAbdulJabbar]

@@coryjack606 Tua is no Joe Burrow that's for sure

[@Bleedgreenwes]

Lol this guy has tua at 4 😂 get rid of Simms please!!

[@michaellayard5045]

Hard to disagree with any of the things he said about him though

[@ashwinprakash9618]

But Tua is still a super gifted prospect who's way above Herbert and Love as a quarterback right now. Simms lost it on this one.

[@shawnbaker3245]

He was correct. His injury history is risky.

[@michaellayard5045]

@@ashwinprakash9618 Talent doesnt matter if you spend more time in IR then on the field

[@diamondhickspharmd2808]

Simms likes big strong armed qbs. Always has.

[@danielsemmens6640]

Sims = dopehead

[@azma775]

Still think that ?

[@azma775]

Looking like a genius rn

[@the_chandler]

Simms has some of the worst takes that I've seen. He's trying to be Colin Cowherd with these hot takes for the sake of hot takes.

[@isaiahh4108]

Chandler Runyon he give explanations it’s a 30 min segment you just a fanboy

[@owencollins4612]

Where is the hot take here

[@danzemacabre8899]

Simms is accurate on his qb evaluations, actually , he might be the best over the last few years

[@vantasticvoyage4145]

🤣

[@kingjordan6327]

I love how people go into hibernation after their comment ages badly