Nicola Bulley | Refined EXACT Theory | Plus Caravan Plea (MUST WATCH)

This video is largely based on my thoughts and opinions going off of all of the work and research I have done on the Nicola Bulley case over the last two years. I am expressing my right to free speech.
Please see below my full Nicola Bulley case playlist
• The Nicola Bulley Case
Link to DJE Media’s Video RE the caravan
• Nicola Bulley - PROOF ...

[@Breaktheice123]

To support this channel so that I can spend more time creating content please consider donating here ko-fi.com/breaktheice

[@claireandislamineandmumnys407]

Where is this video of the caravan?

[@Peter-James66]

@@claireandislamineandmumnys407 In the description as he said.

[@evan14vev]

Curtis media

[@cherylspandley8270]

@@claireandislamineandmumnys407 DJE Media Video RE: The Video

[@mariondewit]

I feel so sorry for Nicola, never the real justice for her…corrupt system

[@christinewannell9667]

The fact that Penny phoned her sister in law I think at the school and also the vet to ask about the owner of the dog seems very suspect, when I think it is likely that Penny knew who the owner of the dog was and then later the vet Penny had spoken to was found murdered in very suspicious circumstances that as far as I know was never properly investigated. I also read that Nicholas's husband had an office on the caravan park. This case is extremely complex , but having followed this tragic story from the beginning I have never believed the conclusions to this case.

[@cherylspandley8270]

You would be very suprised, I've been in Situations, where the most obvious thing to do is dial 999 straight away, and ask for river police, as you believe someone has gone in the water, but once you get more than one/two people on the scene, they all seem to know better, than the first person, that came across the situation. Penny was already an old lady, she had a doctors appointment, That man walking his dog, phoned his wife, who was penny's sister in law. People don't just do the obvious.Dial 999 First, police can always be stood down. time was wasted, that costs life.

[@SueWilson-wl7lr]

Paul was related to the caravan park woman that's why he had a business run from there

[@jimtheyid]

I believe Nicola was abducted,then killed in the caravan park,then her body was put in the river overnight . I believe her husband/best friend knows what happened ,always have

[@nan3271]

I'm glad to see that she's still got people thinking about her. The weirdness of this case and the way it was handled left many people totally dissatisfied with the outcome. It needs reopening because it was never properly investigated.

[@shelleyprice9488]

Thank you for all your hard work in seeking justice for Nicola. Great Video. I do feel there was some police corruption in this case though. Peter Faulding found her very quickly but police wouldn't let him dive. They later said they searched where he had and she wasn't there but she was there and police then found her many days later after someone spotted her while on a walk. Poor Peter was made scapegoat over it. Why would the Police say she wasn't there when Peter had the sonar evidence to prove she was? Also the policeman in charge was found dead at home sometime after aged just 50. I find this most suspicious. ❤

[@evan14vev]

along with the vet

[@Rachel.hydepark]

@@evan14vev what happened to the vet?

[@redleadervfr-v4906]

I have always been suspicious of the caravan park and the owners, the owner of the caravan park was not happy with the caravan owner who spoke to Curtis. Penny and her grandson are very unapproachable and do not want to be spoken to. Peter Folding did a good job but the police just cast it aside all seems very odd. Will we ever get to the truth of what really happened to Nicola Bully, just think it’s too late now as the police will not have the funds or the resources to re investigate this case. Well done Luke you work has opened up another theory

[@MysterCD]

Think grandson may have tried something?

[@susiewatts1982]

Hear hear hun x

[@cerealkiller4248]

Paul had businesses registered everywhere, inc the caravan park. Don’t tell me Penny didn’t know Nikki personally. The dog lead theory as the catalyst is a plausible one, one thing for sure is it wasn’t investigated properly, and the way people retired and died after this case causes people to question the way the Police handled this case.

[@lllillibeth]

Just wanted to say thankyou so much for all your hard work on this case .. can't wait! ❤️👏🏽👏🏽

[@Breaktheice123]

You are very welcome, I have seen you comment a few times now and appreciate your support

[@joycemalone5767]

@@Breaktheice123 Did they mention when she had a PM done whether they found water in her lungs?

[@PatriciaGalvin-ke5fh]

Water was found in her lungs, it was mentioned at the inquest

[@evan14vev]

but not that it was river wyre water it said watery fluid

[@SusanMowe]

I always knew there was a big cover up . Nicola needs justice bless her soul .

[@MarionLovell-v1t]

Nikki was unalived and then failed massively from the people and authorities that was supposed to protect her . Heartbreaking

[@chickedee1085]

What does unalived mean?

[@meme-mu8mg]

He is not allowed to say certain words on KZbin so the word he has used is the opposite of alive.​@chickedee1085

[@powerdisney]

The aggressive grandson of Penny needs forensic interviewing The man in black too? And I still don't trust Paul Ansell or Emma... And what about the MI5 Stuff and the father of Nicola breaking animal rights trafficking So much of a psy op

[@Pauly-m4z]

Paul showed zero emotions for someone whose partner was missing and then found dead.

[@Peter-James66]

The so called 'Man in Black' I can put to rest as a drone operative for SLY News!

[@robertp2577]

Always said this was a PSY operation.

[@evan14vev]

really where did you get this information?

[@robertp2577]

@@evan14vev There are a lot of people in this country who's jobs and lives are not what they make them out to be. They work silently in the background for the establishment.

[@michaelsmith-dm3kb]

Hello Luke,brilliant stuff.One thing has stuck in my mind.Reporter Isla Traquair(cant remember which channel) said she said she spoke to probably the last person to see Nicola Bulley.This person said that Nicola told them she had an altercation on the towpath with someone about her dog being off the lead,then after Isla said about this it was all hushed up and was never mentioned again.

[@cal56191]

I saw that and that she straight away thought it was all strange.

[@ralfgertie]

Police is knee deep in it

[@katlowe1228]

Could the person Nicki had the altercation with about her dog being off lead be the woman, Penny, that owned the caravan park?

[@DavidBarry-kn2uk]

@ralfgertie yes! a million times over they are all connected with the caravan mob,thats how they got away with it .

[@irenebain4396]

Was it Penny who found the phone on the bench with the dog and reported it to the Police and what was her reason for being there? I too remember the report of an altercation, but who saw or heard that and reported it?

[@kellythompson-ne9uj]

I dont think penny outwitted the police, they were all in on it for whatever reason, i think it was all organised and everybody knew their role.

[@nickcoles9246]

All in on what, exactly? And who are 'they'?

[@kellythompson-ne9uj]

@nickcoles9246 the murder of nicola bulley, that's what we are talking about here isn't it

[@2essie]

If Nicola fell in the river, Willow would have followed her. Spaniels will swim in freezing cold water for fun. They are water dogs. I have two dogs that aren't water dogs but if I fell in the river they would follow thinking I was playing and it would start as a game to them. Once Willow realised it wasn't a game he could have come out of the water but would still have been wet. I believe Nicola did not fall and she wasn't pushed in the water where Willow was and Nicola had no reason to go walking off without Willow. So, wherever Nicola ended up in the water, Willow wasn't there. That's my belief. I think there are just a few holes in your belief on this video. If Nicola was kept for 8 days whilst unalived, the smell would have been awful. The guy who owned the caravan would have smelt this when he returned to his caravan and said someone had been in it. Carpets, flooring and furnishings would have had to be destroyed, unless she was alive. Also there would have been no water in her lungs, which would have been picked up when her body was examined. I think she was alive for those 8 days. Maybe badly hurt or maybe barely alive. Also would it be possible to move a decomposing body? That would have made the transport smell that she was moved in. Too many holes in your theory i think for it to be true, but very close to the truth maybe.

[@bionicnichola9251]

Spaniels adore their owners and will do their best to rescue their owners and defend them. They are one of the most intelligent dogs. So i agree with that. 👍

[@Janeswhitfield]

I have alway said if she fell in the river Willow would have been at least on the waters edge not at the gate ,I absolutely don’t think she was in the water that morning

[@Rachel.hydepark]

@@2essiesomeone moved Madeline McCan after weeks, Nicola could have been moved surely?

[@timhughes6164]

I have a spaniel, you are correct, they stand/swim in any water they can, and are also joined at the hip to their owners

[@jennybarnsley8338]

Thanks for keeping this alive luke❤

[@Breaktheice123]

I think we are getting closer

[@kellyrobinson8892]

Thankyou Luke, great work, i know in my heart you're onto something representing more truth than the official narrative💯✌️#JusticeforNicola

[@Peter-James66]

The owner of the caravan who also owned a 2016 Suzuki Jimny Adventure reg: - PR09 ENG can be contacted through DVLA or the actual Govt webpage. His vehicle is still registered in Preston and he is the only owner. for about £6 quid you can get his info online.

[@TaraVixen]

Well done!! 👍

[@lllillibeth]

Might be worth the police seeing whether paul took out life insurance before she died? . Also Luke the police said from start he wasn't a suspect , but anyone can alter their cctv , he knew how to do it plus what if he gad an alibi ie Louise, nicola sister was there , that way thry each give each other an alibi .. did nikki even go that day?? She wasn't spotted on any dash cam walking to bridge, why not? Why did nobody see her? Because she was never there . Some may think it's far fetched, but most people kill for love or money . My personal opinion is she didn't fall in the river by the bench or anywhere else . Be interested to see what you think happened Luke , apologies for waffling on!👏🏽🤔

[@Rachel.hydepark]

The cctv is really interesting, although didn't a witness say they saw Nicola in the field that morning?

[@bettyboop5177]

A policeman, dark hair, had a beagle dog... didn't be catch n.b on his cash cam, but something happened to him..

[@VK-qe7if]

Nicola had recently taken out life insurance.

[@Pauly-m4z]

Paul & Louise had a thing going on 💯

[@EvaEl31]

If someone else was wearing the Fitbit - surely it would show their movement/ steps as well - and I think they had stopped on the Fitbit - but agree there is something about it that doesn’t add up . . . x8 days

[@generalsemedo]

Penny should be investigated as well

[@nickcoles9246]

On what basis?

[@jennybarnsley8338]

Really hope this gets re opened

[@jennybarnsley8338]

We need justice❤

[@katlowe1228]

The inspector, Rebecca Smith was so adamant Nicola had "just gone into the water" if she was in the river, she would have been found that day.

[@Breaktheice123]

Precisely!

[@Jacqz-k9l]

@@tommystewart1745Whoa! You’re one angry person. What do you know & what are you hiding? Talk about overreaction!

[@nickcoles9246]

What makes you so certain of that?

[@katlowe1228]

@@nickcoles9246 Peter Faulding, said he would have found nicola in one hour if she was where the police thought she was. He used all of his equipment looking for her.

[@susiewatts1982]

Good for you Luke , I totally 100% Agree with you about how she died .

[@Breaktheice123]

Cheers Susie

[@TaraVixen]

I’ve been screaming this theory right from the beginning! I never believed she was in the water during the police search, there was too many people searching for her to be missed in that river, it was barely moving on the day. If she was kept in the caravan she would have to have been alive cos you can’t store a corpse for 8days without a freezer. I think she was alive for a while! The only bit I dont agree with is the use of the man’s caravan. It’s too risky. I always believe she was kept in one of the cabins owned by the caravan park. They back onto the top field and they would have been empty. They have COMPLETE controll over those vans because they own them. I believe they went into that man’s van to see if he had cctv that would have caught them taking Nicola to that van. I think they THOUGHT she was dead or she was taken for “other” reasons by a certain angry young man & killed at a later date then put in the river. The reason I have always believed that is because I saw a psychic who doesn’t have a big channel so a lot of people missed her. She said Nikki was being held and that she could hear people searching and she didn’t understand why police dogs did not pick up her scent because she was SO close to where she was last seen. This woman described where Nikki was and it matched the caravan park! There was also an ex marine who said the easiest way to take her was via the tow path or via THAT GATE you mentioned and take her to those wooden cabins! He offered to show the police that he could do it without being seen by anyone! From then on I believed the caravan park is where Nikki was held & put in the river just before Peter searched. Being held would also explain the injuries Nikki had when she was found!

[@blu4085]

ANd the water level was really low that day

[@WindyWeatherAllWinter]

I agree with your caravan hiding theory and the fact that they would need a freezer especially if she was deceased for at least 8 days. I do believe IMO that the caravan people are somehow involved . Also there was supposedly nothing in the autopsy to indicate a head injury which I’m sure they would have indicated because it would fit with their theory of falling in the river. But there was an indication of petechiae which can be a cause of strangulation. So could it have been the grandson that lost his cool?

[@TaraVixen]

@@WindyWeatherAllWinter yes I agree with you! I think the grandson is involved! The fact that everything was related, they had time to cover their tracks and get their story straight. Would not be the first family to cover up something like this.

[@ralfgertie]

Yes the two devine camping pods are the most likely place. Also the caravan but the pods more likely. They are very basic under trees. Apparently they got underfloor heating as advertised on wyreside farm website

[@aspadeaspade7163]

Tying Willow up seemed to be priority. This was either for her own safety, ( not livestock as none there). Just look at the amount of signs re dogs off leads!! OR to prevent her from following wherever Nicola went. Dogs, especially spaniels, have a great sense of smell, so unless Nicola was wet, Willow would probably have traced her. And don't you remember that Nicola was having an altercation with someone in the upper field about dogs and leads. That would have been earlier. Penny's brother in law was all flummoxed when interviewed by ? Sky news. And the caravan owner who was there checking on his van one morning said that someone had been in it. The harness and phone originally were on the ground between the bench & river then it was said they made their way to the bench. It was an icy day, easy to fall. Too many discrepancies with this case to accept accidental. Odd that she was found near the road with the only lay-by. And wasn't the bottom of the kissing gate fence later chicken wired off? There was only about 20 mins where she was unaccounted for.

[@jacquelinealexander1052]

An absent caravan owner noticed, upon his return days later...someone had been inside during his absence...he had proof!! 01.34

[@Di-Three-Legs]

Great video. I don't think it's implausible that a caravan park has more than one industrial freezer. They must sell ice creams etc in the summer so I think she may have been initially taken to the empty caravan in a panic and then moved to a freezer. Can they tell that at an autopsy or didn't they check? I think if she was dead for 8 days, yes, the smell would be unbearable and hard to cover up. Absolutely brilliant work.

[@CarolineEllison-h8v]

I'm glad you are covering this case, it's so sad what happened.

[@gloriamcneil5398]

X thank you Luke . ..l think they have got rid of the old guy and his caravan

[@Breaktheice123]

Yes they have, we need to track the van down

[@GigiShar]

Dont forget what Isla Traqauir said right at the beginning about Nicola having a conversation with someone on the tow path, (on her way in), about dogs on leads etc

[@eliandranogekoskiuk]

Unfortunately, if the police couldn’t go in phone records and listen to all conversations it’s their problem and because of this we will never know the truth. The cctv was turned off for a reason. We all know she didn’t do anything against her own life, something happened and it was a perfect crime. Like the one Jay Slater case one, Liam Payne, Madeleine McCann and many others.

[@garydenton7741]

From experience they wouldn’t have left Nicola dead in that caravan for eight days in their even if they wrapped her up the body starts to decompose straight away after only a few days the odour or smell of death is horrific once smelt never forgotten they would have struggled to removed her decomposing and the carpet or anything surrounding her body would have her bodily fluids on it this is why body’s once out of the freezer are embalmed x

[@Peter-James66]

Your absolutely spot on! The smell is rancid and all carpet would have flesh decomposition and the smell never leaves the area its placed in. Besides, the police did visit the caravan after two weeks so this theory can be put to rest.

[@jennybarnsley8338]

Penny had really bad attitude

[@Breaktheice123]

Absolutely

[@lynn8143n]

Didn't penny's son go missing after Nicola went missing​@@Breaktheice123

[@Paul-11]

@@Breaktheice123 Shes very domineering, that vid when she chastised that elderly guy she grabbed his arm to talk to him at back of his car.

[@Nick_iii67]

I'll say it again. Nicola died of drowning & this was shown in her post mortem SO how did nicola get water in her lungs if she died on land by a supposed whack to the head (manslaughter)?? You can't get water into your lungs with specks of dirt on your vocal chords once you are dead & also nicola had the signs of drowning such as asphyxiation so again how can it have been a whack on the head? Also the police were the ones who had been in the old mans caravan when they searched the caravan park 2 weeks later so that answers that question. Also can you image what state a body would be in stored in a caravan for 8 days? Did this caravan have a chest freezer in it? & Dont you think the pathologist would know better? Also what would have happened if the police requested to search the caravans in the first day or two? You'd have to be stupid to store a body in a caravan just metres away from the area. The theory falls flat on its face.

[@Mark-gti]

the old man reported to the police a couple of days after Nikki disappeared that his caravan had been illegally entered and the blind damaged, that's 12 days before the police searched. also the volume of water in Nikki's lungs was inconsistent with drowning. the specks of dirt you mention on her vocal cords along with signs of asphyxia suggests more forced head under water than a accidental fall in and drowned. i appreciate the points you make but as simple as you try to make it look like an accident, it doesn't explain other factors like pf being the only witness to see the harness on the floor between bench and river, how the harness mysteriously made it's way onto the bench when no one moved it. and pf also stated she said she didn't know who's dog it was yet when kb passed her pf first instinct was to explain she's tying the dog when common sense would be to ask if they knew who's dog it was. also pf states she didn't have a mobile to ring the number on the collar, why not ask kb?

[@crimelatnem2091]

Someone could keep her somewhere, eventually when they noticed heat was getting to high they decided to get rid of her- only way of doing so was by putting her in that water. They put her on that water weeks after to go with narrative of drowning so there won’t be any more digging. Water in the lungs is simple explain, they made her uncouncious before they drop her on that water. Just cause someone had water in their lungs doesn’t rules out a murder.

[@DavidMathieson-hf4ip]

Luke , I whole heartedly agree with your theory, E,V shared the same one as yourself while his channel was on the go ....Can I add a bit more to your theory as This has been mine as regards seeing Curtis Media talking to the caravan owner .....Peters equipment was allowed into the caravan park area for access to the river .....Penny would have had to have been approached about this in advance , Knowing there was an expert coming into the search, that would be an ideal opportunity to insert Nikki into the water for the expert to find , and to confirm the police theory as to her being into the water.....But it didn't quite work out like that , Peter was tasked with searching below the weir when he arrived , doing so for 3miles past the weir , He stated that part of the river was as clear as a bell and was happy to show anyone the footage.....when he searched above the weir , Peter finds a " target " within 6 minutes......The police divers team say they will dive the spot , and declare there's nothing there.....This in my opinion is where the plan to put Nikki back has not gone to plan , leading to this theory we now find ourselves debating over ....This is opinion only until proven .....If this caravan can be found and bare fruit via a dna examination .....Someone has a lot of explaining to do .......

[@Breaktheice123]

I need to reiterate that eddy said he thinks she was pushed into the river and drowned and I am not saying that. If she was pushed and drowned she would have been found right where she went in. A few people are hearing the name Penny and are assuming me and eddy are suspecting the same thing happened, we really aren’t

[@DavidMathieson-hf4ip]

@Breaktheice123 .👍

[@jasonking1948]

Her "accidental" injuries according to the inquest 🤯🤯🤯 Bruise on back of left thigh, front & back of right arm. Bruises to the knee, shin and arm. Forehead & hair covered in mud, wound to bridge of nose & eye. Bruising to all four limbs, front and back, bruising to chest, Petechiae haemorrhaging to two eyes (suggest suffocation) L shaped bruise 14.2cm left thigh upper third, bruise 14x14cm back and front right upper arm middle third.

[@Breaktheice123]

Thanks Jason

[@tiggywinkle5933]

Where did you get this information from?

[@karlaparker7988]

​​@@tiggywinkle5933MSM and others on KZbin some who were present covered the Pathology report at the inquest. Quite ridiculous along with 2 separate witnesses hearing screams and a Fitbit recording a heartbeat for 8 days to come to a conclusion of accidental death.😮 absolutely no evidence of her going in, muddy areas surely would have had slip marks, nothing.

[@rothesaylad]

They could all be explained though from being thrashed about under the water

[@jasonking1948]

@@tiggywinkle5933 inquest 👍

[@simonpayne54]

Parts of your explanation are correct, but if there was an altercation, it would not have been with Penny and Nicola imo. It would have been between a male and Nicola as there were bruises on Nicola which means that there was a tussle and Penny would not have been strong enough to tussle with Nicola. The only place where Nicola could have ended up was the caravan park as the park was not searched for the first week or so. Nicola might have initially been placed in the vacant caravan, but I don't think she would have been kept in that vacant caravan for the entire duration before she was dumped in the river at a later date. I do agree that dna should be taken from that vacant caravan and am surprised that the Police did not do this. The fact that the only cctv camera that was off that day was the one that would have seen what happened at the kissing gate is a huge clue imo. Like I said last time, the fact that there are so many keep your dog on the lead signs that have gone up on the kissing gate is another big clue. That broken fence has nothing to do with this case. The fence was not broken on the day she went missing and has no relevance to this case. Willow's lead was never found. That is another big clue. That points to Nicola having the lead in her coat pocket and I would question where that lead ended up? There were no head wounds on Nicola, just bruises. Was she rendered unconscious? The other thing I would concentrate on is the timings of the witnesses on the day she went missing in terms of who and when she was seen on the lower field and the top field as if you study those times, you will see that they do not add up. aimo of course. not accusing anybody of any wrong doing, but someone needs to study this whole case again as there are so many anomalies imo. Peter did not find her body btw. It was another chap who was out dog walking with his partner, who saw her floating in the water. I think from memory that he is a distant relative of Paul. Anyway mate, good luck with your research and I hope you can finally crack this case as Nicola deserves justice. aimo.

[@yvonnemorris-wd5gi]

You are wrong the chap and his woman friend wasn't walking their dog they didn't have one with them he's a physic he doesn't live in that area but he had also visited St michael's on wyre days before too.

[@simonpayne54]

@@yvonnemorris-wd5gi Yes, I believe you are correct from memory Yvonne. It has been a long time since I studied the case.

[@jasonking1948]

The reason whoever was potentially involved in this didnt want the body found quickly is because after 2 weeks in water, its almost impossible to confirm cause of death due to composition. All the experts state this.

[@Breaktheice123]

Appreciate the input Jason, cheers

[@elliotgeorge999]

virginia woolf put herself in a river and drowned, those 2 women in Aberdeen allegedly put themselves in a river and drowned. lots of people choose to exit in a similar way. All very sad cases. often in a case like this its someone close to the victim or its suicide. she allegedly had emotional difficulties and looked mightily p****d off in her last video. RIP Nicola.

[@dixedot90]

Totally agree with you , on the caravan park and placing the body after the event. We said this right from the start, you're right on point I feel.

[@jacquelinealexander1052]

Always suspected the grandson at caravan site swore a lot...agree with you do far...still a puzzle to me so many many questions. You must see video of the former caravan owner who left ....says so much!!01.30

[@Tington-q6z]

I followed this on different blogs but that’s what I believe too , when the man was ordered off site out of season and he thought something had been in his caravan, then the police were called by site owners who were furious this man was talking and on site to this owner of caravan strange maybe an accident but never fell in dry dog was a red flag to anyone who has a dog who swims in the river

[@Adrian-bt4nf]

This explanation does work , but I doubt penny could knock NB out , however it was more likely an angry shove , NB falls back and hits her head on the bench and is dead ! ……… That farmers gate could be a big clue to how a truck , quad bike , car etc 🛻 could have got thru and then be used to transfer the body of NB to the caravan park …………………however what about the man in black and red van ?……also it beggars belief as to why the police didn’t search that caravan park with a fine tooth comb , unless the local plod is covering for penny

[@aspadeaspade7163]

Odd that key witnesses weren't at the court.

[@robertcoombs3562]

Way off Nikki wasn’t even seen with Willow or seen on dashcam going on her walk you have one witness who thought she saw Nikki in the top part of the field from a distance that cannot be seen as clear evidence it was her…. Nikki is in witness protection now the cop was found dead then a month later another women is found to have died by a river…. A lot of sinister things are going on behind closed doors and you will never find out the truth…. Best to leave it now

[@PatriciaGalvin-ke5fh]

Well, maybe because they're ALL Masons?

[@janewillsart3134]

@@aspadeaspade7163 police wanted it all done and dusted . Lots of things were omitted from the inquest as far as I could see

[@Adrian-bt4nf]

@@janewillsart3134so now the question is WHY did plod want this out the way asap 😮

[@KevinWoodsWorkshop]

No one would be stupid enough to leave a body in a caravan, knowing the all area was going to be searched. I believe she was taken out alive that morning in back of a car, I’m not saying which car but someone had to go to an urgent appointment after tying willow to the bench, and then waited over one hour before reporting it.

[@OwenCochrane-z2u]

This was actually my original theory, but one would have to believe in involvement from these people. We know she had an appointment and it would not seem suspicious because it would have been caught on the local cctv camera in the lane (the departure and return times) Although I don't like to accuse people who could be innocent. But it would have been one way to get Nicola away from the area quickly and nobody would suspect anything. To keep her around the caravan park would be too risky, if skullduggery is playing a part.

[@KevinWoodsWorkshop]

@OwenCochrane-z2u I don't want to accuse anyone but I'm sticking to my theory, everyone can make their own mind up. I still believe the red van around the corner was involved.

[@OwenCochrane-z2u]

Food for thought: Penny is an old woman...at least seventy, and possibly closer to eighty ( I don't know her exact age) Nicola is still a young woman, and wouldn't she be the stronger of the two? Even in an altercation, it does actually take quite some force to actually unalive somebody, even if its accidental. Wouldn't Nicola fight back if such an event happened? And wouldn't such an event take up considerable time with much counter arguing? It's possible that the theory doesn't stand up to scrutiny, although it's one of many possibilities...

[@ThePixey1000]

@OwenCochrane-z2u Penny is not a frail old women and a bit of a battle axe so a hard push could put anyone on a slippey bank in a river. Anyone can do any thing if the other person is in a precarious position IMO

[@leannetucker648]

If nicola was put in the caravan and kept in for eight days, wouldn't the caravan ower or whoever bought the caravan would notice a smell of decomposition and bodily fluids, especially the caravan owner knowing there own van , I think you're on the right path just think the caravan isn't involved... Keep up the good work

[@audreyezzo1288]

I've followed this case for months and years.... I never believed for one minute that she slipped and fell into the water! I highly suspected Penny also. But in the back of my mind... I think the husband is involved. The bruising around his eye doesn't make sense. He mentions changing his clothes, which doesn't make sense. And he had absolutely no emotion when speaking about the incident. He only mentions the children and hardly talks about Nicola at all. And what was the well-fair check all about before her disappearance? Penny and Nicola's husband both had something to do with it... I think some crooked dealings were going on (drugs or something illegal), and Nicola didn't want to be involved, so they took her. Maybe some accomplices helped, and they tried to convince her to be involved or to keep quiet, but she refused. She might have been accidentally killed, but nevertheless, or she was murdered to shut her up. Look back at the interview with the husband... Nicola's dog acted very strangely towards Nicola's husband. Animals can speak without saying anything. I found it curious that the dog went over to the interviewer but gave Nicola's husband the cold shoulder. She may have been snatched in the parking lot, and the dog was later taken to the bench and tied up. I'm not sure if Nicola was ever put in the man's trailer... I think that is too risky. I'm also suspicious of the police. They may be all covering up something BIG! How did the lead detective end up dying suddenly? Did he also know something or discover something? It's all very suspicious to me.... Sorry, but I don't believe in coincidences....

[@Red-lm1rz]

Exactly what I have just said .

[@Pauly-m4z]

Either her husband and her best friend was at it or Paul and Nicolas sister was at it

[@barbarashepherd9667]

Wow l forgot that well remembered absolutely miss managed

[@barbarashepherd9667]

Come on Police investigate. Why would a working woman with two lovely children and a loyal pet not come back home it was too shallow to slip and drown don’t we have any detectives any more ? My faith is lost 😞

[@earlbee3196]

The Lancashire mother-of-two disappeared on 27 January 2023 while walking her dog in St Michael's on Wyre, shortly after dropping her daughters at school. Her body was found in a river on 19 February 2023 and an inquest in June last year found she had died due to accidental drowning It’s all a very big mystery .

[@ritabrett7739]

Be good to get justice for Nicola ♥️♥️♥️

[@nickcoles9246]

The best justice is for people to let her rest rather than comtinue spouting out nonsensical CTs.

[@Moonstone115]

Brilliant work mate 👏 I still can't shake this case off, the whole thing stinks! Personally I found her fella never seemed upset, it was always like he was talking about losing his wallet, not his partner who was found deceased with no explanation 😢

[@Red-lm1rz]

But how did she end up at the final resting place at the side of the road ! And I don’t believe the spiritualist had a vision and travelled all the way from Manchester and low and behold she came floating past . Don’t believe that for one second . I got told his brother was in prison with Paul’s brother both for supplying and selling heroin and coke . Don’t know if that’s true. And why were the police laughing while dragging Nicola up the bank . I think Nicola new something and she had to be taken out or shut up or held for a ransom and that’s why Becky Smith was involved in this case , she was the one that built the drugs trafficking case against Paul’s brother and the spiritualist . I wish I could remember where I read about it . Keep digging Luke . ( maybe Paul couldn’t get the ransom money in time and that’s why she was killed after eight days !!!

[@evan14vev]

not his brother his cousin

[@Red-lm1rz]

@ Thank you

[@petersmith2199]

To me, the abduction theory is far fetched. According to the pathologist, Nicola died of drowning. She was conscious when she entered the river. Are you seriously suggesting that someone abducted Nicola, took her to an empty caravan, then submerged her in water to drown her, then put her body in the river? Really?! Come on, pull the other one, it's got bells on!

[@Breaktheice123]

No, I’m not suggesting she was abducted for a moment

[@petersmith2199]

@@Breaktheice123 You suggested she was taken to the caravan park against her will.

[@Breaktheice123]

Please watch again Peter I did not say that she was taken against her will

[@Anna-w2p3o]

@petersmith2199 I'm not suggesting, I'm telling you, Nicola was killed deliberately, of horrific injuries she was brutally murdered... Judging by your post u probably new that's the truth

[@Adrian-bt4nf]

Serial killer on the loose ??

[@Pauly-m4z]

Maybe she were sat on the bench and the man sneaked up from behind, held her at knife point? Forced her to walk in the bushes?

[@nickcoles9246]

​@@blackmoonlilith455you should reign in your libellous statements. Could land you in big trouble.

[@crimelatnem2091]

Someone should look well deep into all those woman who were just ending up in the rivers all over the UK. Families if those woman should start speaking out as they the only one who can be trusted of ALL those woman were really suicidal as I highly doubt that was the case!! Police wants this to go away cause they don’t want public chaos and pressure from public. Only families of thosr all woman know the truth and they should start speaking out! Make the voice of your loved ones to be heard for their justice cause with your silence you only helping police to keep this quiet and don’t belive in they have to keep this quiet to solve it and find perpetrator cause it won’t work/ only way it will work if families will start making noise!!

[@K.j.h.279]

Thers zero proof nicola was around that day. Conspicuous by her complete absence.

[@zephead2112]

It’s still worth considering Rowan Water as an exit point IMO unless the CCTV there would prove otherwise. Would it fit with the timeline when Nicola was last sighted and the 10+ minutes before the phone (and possibly Willow) ‘moved’ to the bench? Somebody mentioned an altercation taking place in the top field next to Rowan Water. I’m not sure if that’s accurate but it would be interesting to confirm it (or not). Rowan Water is rarely mentioned now as all the focus is on the bench area which could be a complete red herring.

[@CrystalGlow-mu4bf]

I was all over this story like a pig in heat when it blew up in the media mainly because it was just so incrediably sad that she left behind two small kids and a clearly loving family/partner and many friends. Just a few weeks ago, i was out walking down a bank towards the sea and slipped on wet mud, it felt as tho someone had poured cooking oil all over it - it was so slippy, luckily, the sea is blocked off by fencing but then I realised how easily accidents could happen and potentially be much worse.

[@Theresa-h7f]

If I remember correctly didnt Eddie vinyl say something similar regarding penny

[@Breaktheice123]

He said he thinks that she pushed Nicola in the river and I’m not saying that. If Nicola was pushed in the river and drowned she would of been found right where she went in

[@Breaktheice123]

Yeah we both have our theories and it’s not about who is right or wrong as long as the truth comes out. We certainly both smell the same smell though don’t we. I would have expected a comment from you commending my work though and unfortunately I never received one. I just see you replying to comments with your name on it. I don’t care who is right as long as the truth comes out. Also taking in too much a gulp of water insinuates drowning.

[@thesquaredisc]

Deleting my reply yet leaving your response to my reply seems strange. You’re better than that Luke. Remember, you are an influential KZbinr, what you say carries weight and generates your theory into reality for some. We may not see eye to eye but to allow comments from some comparing our opinions when we do not yet deleting my stance is wrong. If you’re going to delete my comments, delete the whole thread and not just part of. Nikki did not drown immediately and that’s my point. You’re going to take this tragic story down into conspiracies rather than reality. You want to be right and that’s fine, this time you’re not. I use my names channel when I communicate, I have no other way.

[@WalkingDeadFan89]

Great video Luke keep it up. Would love to see you do more of these kinds of videos. I agree with you and your theory but I do believe the sighting of fisherman seen the day before is connected to this case. One of the fisherman have a channel on hear and can not stop talking about this case. So many strange people in that neck of the woods if you ask me.

[@janewillsart3134]

In a follow up video curtis media revisits the park and the caravan has gone . Did she want it gone so phorensics could not do a detailed examinationn

[@JulieMulligan-x4s]

This is just what I was thinking, if so then that would say a lot.

[@Victor-q4p6g]

it certainly makes sense very very important that caravan is examined

[@wendylane6636]

Great point...

[@DavidBarry-kn2uk]

Im totally into this caravan mob being guilty but they couldnt have kept a dead body in it for 7 days due to smell /decomposition etc,that caravan the old guy had was broken into due to camera being moved from view

[@evan14vev]

rowan water luke is where she was spotted arguing with 3 people

[@zephead2112]

I thought about Rowan Water in the early days. Would Nicola disappearing there fit with the timeline/the last sighting of Nicola and those ‘missing’ 10+ minutes when the phone ‘moved’ to the bench? Rowan Water is rarely mentioned now but it’s definitely worth consideration. I can’t recall the CCTV coverage there but perhaps that would debunk any connection with Rowan Water. It is a potential ‘exit point’ however.

[@chimenemunroe-ju6uk]

You've failed to mention Jason Rothwell, he was the one that found Nicola's body whilst walking his dog along with his female friend.

[@susanrichardson1670]

Apart from he did not have a dog!

[@jasonking1948]

His story has more holes in it than a Swiss cheese!!!!

[@SandraSwadkins-si8vi]

I get your theory Luke and you could be getting close to the truth but then the PM said that her lungs proved that she was alive when she went into the water/river(whatever water it was )as it was inhaled water,this isnt possible after death,this is if the PM was conducted correctly which is also debatable according to many

[@scarletmontana7]

Thanks for sharing these theories very good. However wouldn’t a good medical examiner be able to tell how long a body had been in the water though?

[@evan14vev]

this was never spoken about at the inquest

[@jennybarnsley8338]

Did you see the guy getting interviewed by curtis regarding penny and his empty carvan?😊

[@gloriamcneil5398]

Where is he now ??

[@jennybarnsley8338]

Yeah need to find him

[@5park5]

Great video explaining your theory Luke. I am no expert but the fact that she had water in her lungs makes me wonder whether the row led to the scuffle causing nicola to fall into the water and smack her head, penny couldn't get her out and called her colleague for help. They realised when she was out that she had drowned and then your theory of panic comes to life. She may have been stored in caravan but not for the full 8 days as the owner would have known straight away on opening the door as that is an aroma you cannot easily hide. Anyway, just my thoughts, keep up the great work. Justice for Nicola❤

[@Breaktheice123]

Thank you for the nice comment

[@ralfgertie]

She was alive in caravan for 8 days. Fitbit data was very weak. It was her wearing the fitbit not somebody else. After 8 days she was taken to river and drowned. Barely alive hence the small amount of water in her lungs

[@aspadeaspade7163]

😢​@ralfgertie

[@Theresa-h7f]

Yeah I meant Eddie thought there was an altercation with penny but I didn’t mean you said she was pushed in. Like u said we need justice for nicola and what you said makes perfect sence, good work x

[@Breaktheice123]

It doesn’t matter who’s theory is right or wrong and I if it meant justice was served I would be more than happy to be wrong and eddy to be right

[@hazard3020]

Interesting update. Thank you. For info If a Caravan is sold like that. It doesn't always - automatically - mean that the Caravan is moved OFF the Park. Sometimes these Caravans are - eventually - just moved to a different location on the same original Park. Especially if the Sale involves the Park owners getting a % of the sale, or, alternatively, selling the actual Caravan on behalf of the owner. This can vary between different Parks......

[@jasonking1948]

Also, for the whole investigation from start to inquest, i believe it was managed by someone very very high up with influence and power. I read around the time that Penny had some association with the person who used to be the MP for that area, who then for some unknown reason quit politics and the gvmt later that year. They would certainetly fit the criteria and profile of someone with that influence and power to do this 😉 Too much of a coincidence to be a coincidence?? 🤔🤔🤔

[@helenhoneyman546]

Hi there, brilliant video! This is indeed plausible. I just have one very small thought - Peter Faulding found Nicola near the other side of the bank, near the island. If she was put in on the bench side, wouldn't she have been nearer to that side of the bank?

[@ralfgertie]

I think they placed her in the water at the weir. There is an iron ladder from the weir house down to the weir hence the L shaped bruise on her inner thigh. She would have sunk to the bottom. At the bottom is a reverse current from the water that is trapped at the weir. The reverse current would have pushed her back upstream. Her body came to rest at the little island. The river has a left bend before the island hence she was pushed to the opposite side of river.

[@nickcoles9246]

Faulding didn't find her anywhere.

[@nickcoles9246]

​@ralfgertiewho are 'they'?

[@nickcoles9246]

​@ralfgertiesounds plausible 🙄🙄

[@ralfgertie]

@@nickcoles9246 Penny and her gang

[@carolinnerushford4033]

I think she was grabbed and took to the caravan park and later on taken to emmas farm and put in one of her man hole/ storm drains until the police stopped patroling the area, then dropped off where she was found next to a lay by near emmas farm

[@WMW-82]

God always takes the most beautiful and brightest shining angels early 🕊🌹🥀Rip Nicola Bulley sleep tight🥀🌹🕊

[@kerrybolger65]

A witness saw three people on the field , one of which was Nicola bully having an argument and willow barking excessively. I totally agree with your theory.

[@JulieMulligan-x4s]

🙏🙏🙏❤❤❤Justice for Nicola❤❤❤❤

[@Pauly-m4z]

I dont trust her partner

[@Breaktheice123]

I didn’t but on reflection I think he was just a man in pure shock and disbelief

[@Pauly-m4z]

@Breaktheice123 after watching penny for the first time yesterday I totally agree with you 💯

[@ace12kyTheInvincibles]

Couldn’t been that shocked he was very well dressed and clean didn’t looked shocked at all and didn’t really show any emotions wen wife meant be missing and saying he was at home because he worked from home seemed very Suspicious in other words I work at home so for that reason I was at home and wasn’t me can’t say 💯 was him for sure but if I had guess I would trust my gut feeling and think way he was reacting maybe truth closer to home than people think

[@ace12kyTheInvincibles]

If husband plan this he could easy thought of ways hiding her body especially if he knew people on caravan site or car near by if it was planned way before happening

[@ace12kyTheInvincibles]

Especially wen he was one who probably knew her daily routine

[@evan14vev]

the dog was as far as Garstang rd on the tow path originally

[@Bonnie-c1s]

You can trace the man from his car number plate

[@sandra_44]

Did the coroner say she had drowned? You would expect them to be able to determine if nicola died from drowning?

[@m4tt2410]

Would the police not know after post Mortem how long a body was in the water for? Also would there not be signs of how she died? Also iv seen other cases where somebody has been drowned in a bath and then been put in the sea or river after and they was able to differenciate between the types of water in the body.

[@jasonking1948]

Problem comes with the majority of suspected drowning cases, that if they find a body in water, then the automatic conclusion will always be that they drowned. To go into the forensic detail and investigation required costs too much money, so sadly it's easier just to say "drowned....case closed". That said, the coroners findings as I've posted on here, do leave more questions than answers as to whether she actually drowned (not 2 litres as suggested in drowning cases in her lungs, just 200ml, which I would put in a cup to see how small an amount it is) or died and then was placed in the river, hence no inhalation of water. 😉😉

[@johnnewman6387]

On the Saturday after nicola went missing a sky camera crew and paul ansell took willow to the gate she was told to stay which she did, then back in the field paul called willow to come to him willow did not go to the gate or under it,she made 3 attempts to scale the stile after struggling she made it over the stile,ivwatched this on sky news sky were criticised by dog owners so the kissing gate is irrelevant, nicola must have scaled the stile and she was chased,paul said the nicola and penny had had many arguments about about willow being off the lead in the field ,nicola had argued that the field was common land,paul said once they arrived at the gate the lead would be put on willow he said that he and nicola had always done this so the harness being off and on the floor must have been like the phone plants,the lead was never found hence willow was tied up with string,cheers.

[@BillkoLevesley]

Good work . I hope you get that caravan owner to contact you . Justice for Nicola

[@juliegoodge2680]

Luke please explain man in black also multiple bruises on Nicolas legs and bruising on back and the interest in ski pool creek at the time kind regards pete

[@neilwhitaker]

I've always wondered about the man in Black. It was briefly mentioned by Luke to Peter but swiftly moved off the topic. These pics need to be released and the man finding....it will lead back to the caravan site

[@Theresa-h7f]

I think u r absolutely right, glad u r keeping this going , I don’t believe she fell in , what a lovey lady Nicola was, I feel for the family, it’s an insult to the public to say she slipped in, I watched d j media and heard him say his caravan got broken into.really bad it wasn’t investigated , keep going Luke, we need justice for this beautiful lady.

[@ThePixey1000]

The caravan was closed for the winter but owner said when he came back said someone had been in his caravan. The police did not search caravan site for weeks they were too involved with the river. The women who owns the site comes rushing out as soon as anyone sets foot on one blade of grass so who did she see in that caravan. Is she silent because she knows who it was or knows them really well or did she enter that caravan the owner knew someone had been inside. The police will not open this case again because if they did they would have to find Nicolas killer. But I think those searchers on those caravans were shabby to say the least owners not there should have been notified to come check theirs and that one that had been entered could have held vital information if look at within a day or so. All in my opinion

[@jacquelinealexander1052]

It was the women caravan park owner who found??? Willow???

[@soccergalsara]

wasn't there a live due yesterday at 7pm i cant find a link?

[@Breaktheice123]

@@soccergalsara There was yeah but I cancelled it. There is nothing more I can do now. People need to connect the dots here. I advise watching my entire playlist. Cheers

[@soccergalsara]

@@Breaktheice123 :(

[@Prairiestar193]

I agree with you but my only problem with it is that surely there would have been tyre marks from the gate to the caravans. I also wonder why Penny didn't just run off and leave Nicola to be found by someone else, rather than put herself at the scene.

[@DJ-cb2yv]

Thanks for this. My 1st. thoughts were altercation, and cover up, disgusting people. The truth will out ❤

[@frankmanley3588]

The impression I got from the Curtis video was that the caravan park owner had keys to all the vans probably for maintenance, but went into his caravan without his knowledge which peeed him off and was only one reason for him wanting to get off the site

[@theobjectivethinker64]

Penny was inconsistent in her testimonies.

[@Breaktheice123]

Indeed

[@Bonnie-c1s]

The case will never be re opened on opinion

[@neilwhitaker]

That's because police won't admit fault and blame Peter, the fall guy

[@nickcoles9246]

Why would it be re-opened?

[@SteveTheCockney]

Luke, Did Peter Faulding identify a body on his sonar in the search and it was dismissed by Lancashire police?

[@Breaktheice123]

He found what he said looked like a body and was told it was “nothing”

[@SteveTheCockney]

@ tragic case mate, keep up the good work, I always thought the caravan park was a major red flag and where Nicola was found by the lay-by was a very convenient drop off imo🇬🇧🫡

[@saratoussaint5553]

Is there any solid proof that Nicola was ever on that bench? All her stuff could have been placed there?

[@Breaktheice123]

@@saratoussaint5553 depends what you walk by solid proof, there are witnesses but no CCTV

[@saratoussaint5553]

@Breaktheice123 I think that the fact the phone was already logged into a Teams call suggests she was there. But we also know the phone had been picked up and moved by someone else at least once after Nicola left. It's difficult to say when the place is so quiet at this time of year (it's local to me), but I will say that I was always of the mind that Nicola went through that gate also, due to Willow's behaviour (as stated by that witness).

[@Mark-zp3jc]

Can’t wait 👍🍷

[@Anna-w2p3o]

😇🧐Gooo ooon,Luke 💚

[@superangybog4063]

95% of people are killing by people they know, i would be very surprised if it was a stranger, especially when she walks that way nearly everyday, i think the dog and phone where planted, to make it look like she had gone to the bench, and her body was deposed of in the river several days later, the husband is very suspicious

[@Bigdugs]

It's actually 89%

[@theobjectivethinker64]

There had been a spate of dog walkers usually female being attacked whilst out walking often by canals and rivers attempting to steal dogs, it does happen.

[@set5742-u9y]

Thanks for not giving up. Makes me sad that the police didn't investigate this well. Keep working on it and the puzzle will get together eventually. The girl who did the video on the Fitbit had good info. God Bless you!

[@GillParkinson-n5t]

I think the 40 detectives who worked on it would know more than the conspiracy theorists.

[@set5742-u9y]

@@GillParkinson-n5t Well it appears they didn't do a very good job or it would have been solved! Anyone with half an eyeball can see something is not right with the whole investigation. She was K we all know it. If you think they did so good, then why are you here!

[@traceypattison7987]

Maybe Nicola was unconscious and not unalived until she was put in the river at a later date. Thats why the Fitbit was still reading and also why the coroner found the cause of death as drowning

[@nayantarapatel1412]

I believe what Eddie Vinyl was correct when he said it was Penny. She had an altercation was peeved with Nicola and pushed her and killed her accidentally in heat of the moment. Penny should fess up to her error that it was a freak accident. Then with the help of her grandson disposed of Nicola in the caravan until the coast was clear. Eddie was spot on Great investigation by you I hope we find justice.

[@Breaktheice123]

Eddie said she was pushed into the river…it’s a bit different to what I am theorising. She would of been found in the river straight away if that was the case

[@katlowe1228]

Penny's Grandson was horrible

[@Breaktheice123]

With respect, I trust the words of Peter Faulding on how bodies act in water when they drown over yours mate.