Nigel North Talk on Division Playing on the Lute

Nigel North Talk on Division Playing on 19th Nov 2022
A full transcription + the slides can be found in Lute News Edition 144, December 2022. For more info abour the lute Soceity Uk please visit www.lutesociet...

[@tompommerel2136]

Very interesting presentation. About parallel 5ths, because the nature of plucked instruments is that the sound fades, you clearly showed that those 'pesky perfect parallels of the division are not actually audible against the FADING anchor sound. This begs the question as to do whether the eventual prohibition of these 'naught errors' was more obviously heard in organ playing, where the sound of the anchor note could be sustained (by touch) against which the 'pesky, passing note' became a no-no. I suspect that this instrumentally-specific observation could have become the origin of the norm for the prohibition of all parallel 5 or 8, which NOW includes such things as hidden-parallels. Any other thoughts?

[@paddymeboy]

Er...huh? :)