Nightmare on Sodor

[@ajplaze8001]

This whole episode is just taking shots at Mattel.... I love it!

[@AntBro214]

😂😂😂😂

[@lukegoldstonofficial1614]

This one of the most Funniest Episode in the TWR Community. 06/16/19: Holy Crud, getting this many likes on the Comments that I put rarely happens to me

[@shinosuya668]

🤔🤨😴😯😬😵🧐🤬🤓ASGUIGGKKFHKTTKKFNMGHYJ TR RJKH123FBMJJJV BBN MBVBADGRUUEJEWJWJEJ

[@lukegoldstonofficial1614]

Maria Guillen what does that mean?

[@ismaeltrujillo8904]

it’s a kid spamming :/

[@calebc.2290]

Seems like Edward has been huffing on the welsh coal recently before sleeping

[@IndustrialParrot2816]

whats welsh coal?

[@overhillsndales1826]

@@IndustrialParrot2816 coal from Wales

[@onetrackmind3558]

@@overhillsndales1826 so Wales Coal? 😂

[@harrilewis18]

@@onetrackmind3558 Welsh coal

[@harrilewis18]

@@onetrackmind3558 like me I’m a human from wales it mean and a Welsh man not wales man

[@PRRFanDoesTrainz]

1:57 BEST. LINE. EVER!! I absolutely love this episode and the Thomas Wood and BWBA bashing.

[@Trainboy17]

Yeah it’s such a great way to bash Thomas wood as well

[@thomasjeremy2534]

I know right!?

[@Eternitygate]

@@Trainboy17 this guy just bashed Thomas wood so he is a good man

[@OhTheIndignity]

@@Trainboy17 why am I keep running into you?

[@MadHymek323]

“Anyway, Gordon and I have to pull this giant birthday cake in an unsafe and highly contagious manner to the Docks for a birthday party!” - Keekre24, 2019

[@zhiweilim3187]

“Leave him alone officer, he’s my friend and he’s legally drunk” Gerorge Carlton

[@jpbrennan4904]

“That was weird”

[@lilrandy73]

I'M NOT GORDON! I'M EDWARD! Does anyone remember me?

[@MegaBeatle77]

I see you all the time but I know you really like thomas

[@MiddletownBranchProd.]

It’s especially fitting in this time of c-virus

[@railfanmicahturner]

“We’re here to celebrate Thomasas birthday, though I don’t really care”😂 ThomasWoodenRailway, you should be the new RevWAwdry and take over the series. What little bit of dignity the show has left is all in you! Keep it up!

[@Ninja11125]

111th person who liked this

[@Ninja11125]

Lol I get what u said

[@anthonyn.6176]

Mattel puffed away, he had seen everything.

[@EthanTheEngine7]

XD 40th like

[@nmuniz2]

They had seen everything

[@steamiesandiesels1232]

Does anyone think that Mattel ruined Thomas and friends I mean they started out good with Season 22 but the rest of the seasons are just ruined

[@DouglasTheBlackEngineNo.10]

Mattel isn’t the only one who ruined Thomas and friends Guess Sharon Miller My friend: what’s a Sharon Miller?

[@colecamclay]

145 like

[@whizzolightred7153]

8:57 Edward: You all look horrible. You're not painted anymore, the bigger engines have been shrunk down, and some your faces just awful. LOL!

[@angelinarouman8869]

I won’t be a part of this change!

[@tanman8461]

"Leave my friend alone officer, he's legally drunk!!!!!"- George Carlin

[@vitalitylimited]

I remember that! George Carlin was awesome, R.I.P.

[@CrystalClearWith8BE]

A week before his 11th death anniversary. June 22nd is his death anniversary. After that, in June 23rd, it's my father's 51st birthday.

[@ASMRLemon]

R.I.P George Carlin, and Happy Early Birthday to your father. :)

[@FlyingDuckMan360]

@@CrystalClearWith8BE Your father has the same birthday as Sonic the Hedgehog; his first game came out on June 23rd, 1991.

[@CrystalClearWith8BE]

I've never heard of that release date. Thanks for the information!

[@davinsmith7543]

Me if I was Edward: I ain't dealing with this, I'm out of here. He's literally having the same reaction as everyone else to Mattel's decisions about the show and merchandise.

[@margogoralski6294]

I just wish there was scene where the characters bounce around and Ed is in even more shock.

[@davinsmith7543]

@DawkJones92 thank you!

[@stephenpatton3411]

@DawkJones92 I want Hit Entertainment back!

[@davinsmith7543]

@Jetacer Brincefield I know, I don't mind having two new girls in the main cast, but they didn't have to get rid of Edward and Henry.

[@juniorgarcia1102]

I have been a few doctors doctors appointment tomorrow so I am going to have to go back to

[@TheLittleWesternDuo]

A very clever use of those horrendous 2018 Wood engines. I will say this may go down as one of my favorite episodes from your series!

[@brightredmogul1912]

This is the only episode in your series(ThomasWoodenRailway) that talks about its brand.

[@carsonwiggle]

Edward’s nightmare’s a huge wake up call for Mattel and all of us

[@JamesIsHere5]

2:22 Percy! Steven! Toby! I mean Diesel! Diesel: *Did you just asu-*

[@indrajitprayogo14]

Jame is here i am one of youre subcribers

[@nimrat5685]

IM A HUGE FAN OF YOUR VIDEOS!

[@Trainboy17]

I did not mean to call diesel toby

[@newseriesfan]

Me my gender

[@saraihooper75]

Me too!

[@Vincente22]

Okay, that Toby/Diesel bit was funny.

[@PrettyDecentCreations]

Sometimes I wonder if when he was voice acting this he accidentally said Toby but just went with it

[@TheSwordofDestiny]

:)

[@MacsensRailway]

Yes it was

[@WidelyWide]

Edward: what is going on??? The fat controller: I banished u to wellsworth

[@Ilikebakconn2]

Thomas5257 Channel noooooooooo

[@faridunmohammadibrahim4820]

noob

[@Ilikebakconn2]

faridun mohammad ibrahim who?

[@eldmusic]

Thomas5257 Channel his station is now his prison

[@nmuniz2]

I just noticed what that line meant

[@awesome-xk8vj]

The best use of Thomas wood and referencing a terrible things that Mattel did to Thomas by far one of your best videos I love it

[@XleeHS]

Mattel: Ayo listen... We’re gonna need you to put your hands behind your back...

[@Arlesdale]

This episode was hysterical! Definitely one of my favorites in your series. Sir Topham Hatt's personality in this episode was awesome and I loved every part of it!

[@AnnieCYouTube]

I was chuckling all the way through this. Poor Edward.. This may be one of your best works yet. I absolutely love how wonderfully clever, well-crafted and fun your videos are but this one in particular was like dialed to 11- the fact that it all takes place in a dream is such a perfect setting for this type of story and I love how it allowed you to do whatever the heck you want in a really fun, fantastic way. The jokes were so well done and beautifully cathartic in a really awesome way. My gosh, Edward was the perfect main character for this.. I know I'm 'that guy' who tries to see the positives in Thomas Wood (as a side line for younger kids) but believe me, this video reminded me in a big way of just how insane it is that this product was meant as a total replacement for Thomas Wooden Railway. Man oh man.. Like Edward said, thank you for keeping the true magic alive!

[@UsefulEngine11]

This was the most creative story I have ever seen this is a example that Thomas Wood is the worst

[@Clueback]

Thomas Wood 2020 is better

[@henrysfireman4497]

noctor all Thomas WOOD is terrible

[@tfoltzyt111]

noctor u joking

[@UsefulEngine11]

Why the heck are people commenting on my comment this video was made a year ago surprisingly enough

[@tfoltzyt111]

Useful Engine 11 its good

[@Little-Oshawott-2010]

Keekre I love how you made fun of Thomas Wood and Mattel's decision to remove Edward from the Steam Team in this episode.

[@nachojjful]

2 years later after Thomas Wood gets fully painted, Edward, Henry and Toby get made into Wood.

[@Frenchguy261]

Possibly the best mockery of Thomas Wood and cheap merchandising. Really enjoyed this one!

[@Toytrains4uCoUk]

Great story! 😊

[@Elieditsfootball]

I know your channel it’s Awsome

[@Jonathan-RF-402]

Omg omg big fan

[@onetrackmind3558]

@@lysander.o.c.3580 Rude much?

[@amaraatugbokoh8851]

Can you make a video about Thomas telling a funling about how he first came to sodor

[@Azxr3_]

@@onetrackmind3558 rude but true

[@rsconover7957]

4:55 “EEWWW!!!” Gasped Edward. “This one’s overflowing! That can’t possibly be sanitary, Sir.”

[@thesodorsamurai2002]

S13-16, S22 onwards and 2018 Wood in a nutshell.

[@capitollimitedproductions211]

Don’t forget 9-12

[@thesodorsamurai2002]

@@capitollimitedproductions211 S9-12 weren't that bad.

[@harold5337]

TankEngineProductions1 8-12 weren't that good either.

[@Woodenrailwayoliver20]

Anyone who defends BWBA automatically hates children and don’t respect their intelligence.

[@Turbo711]

Great! Mattel needs to see this! Watching this with 3(including Percy I guess)users and we loved it! Thanks again!

[@margogoralski6294]

I can't believe I'm saying this but laughing at your awesome commentary on crappy Wood led to tears once you brought up Henry and Toby.

[@SegaMario]

A truly glorious piss-take on the Miller era and Mattel's terrible decisions on merchandise! Love it!

[@Trainboy-ee4us]

Edward is The Rev W Awdry and the rest of the environment is Mattel!

[@JollyGoodIdeaFilms]

This is the funniest episode ever. Way to make a statement!

[@engineboy53productions15]

Very Spooky and Terrifying Wooden Railway Episode!

[@prestonsvideos6133]

Trainboy53 Productions true, true.

[@CrystalClearWith8BE]

TWR (Keekre), I'm glad you have the successor of Thomas Wooden Railway. It's called Thomas Wood.

[@liljakejake2503]

Love this! This new Thomas Wooden toy line really is a nightmare. 😂

[@prestonsvideos6133]

liljakejake250 you can say that again.

[@margogoralski6294]

Yep.

[@nmuniz2]

Its getting better now

[@thomasegcouplesandships1956]

8:38 "I hope they never scrap my favourite character Henry in the actual TV series! :-O

[@prestonsvideos6133]

Harrison R.C White Henry is my favorite too.

[@nicholetheotter1957]

Preston And Henry A fan fave who isn’t respected by the writers, that’s who!

[@thomasegcouplesandships1956]

@@prestonsvideos6133 :-)

[@margogoralski6294]

Same.

[@margogoralski6294]

@@nicholetheotter1957 Yep.

[@FlyingDuckMan360]

This episode greatly satirizes both the Thomas Wood line and the Sharon Miller and Big World! Big Adventures! eras. It's probably a blessing in disguise that Edward didn't get his own Wood model in 2018. In my opinion, the Thomas Wood line still has a long way to go if it wants to be a high-quality merchandise line like Thomas Wooden Railway was, but I do think that having the engines be fully painted again in 2019 is a step in the right direction.

[@Woodenrailwayoliver20]

Comparing the 2019 wood and 2018 wood is like comparing a wrecked car to one that exploded, it’s not much of an improvement.

[@xiuyi]

The most scary part is the shear amount of thomas wood products you've bothered to purchase

[@danschannel2644]

I thought that 😂

[@nycblockboy5656]

True

[@salaryman43]

Nah, he just used em for fire wood!

[@margogoralski6294]

This was by far, one of the funniest, truest, coolest, saddest, cleverest things I've ever seen! :D

[@eslm-studios2996]

If there was one way to describe the current series and merchandise as well as where Thomas and Friends are going these days, this is definitely the best way to describe it. Well done.

[@thesudriana016]

What a crazy and funny episode! Reminded me of Special Tunnel, guess that Duke and Edward both have a similarity. Also, I love how it reflects on the bad stuff that happened before like the new (and not painted) Thomas Wood and the Miller Era.

[@ThomasandDBZ2010]

Been watching for the umpteenth time, and I like how you portray Edward as the "Only Sane Man" or the "Only Sane Engine" among the BWBA-themed engines.

[@Mr.Face222]

"Percy! Stephen! Toby--I mean--Diesel!" I laughed so hard.

[@ThomasSirHandel]

The dislikes are the employees of Mattel.

[@spacebricks4578]

True

[@Dogzy1980]

Yes

[@imsonicnoob2112]

Not anymore, they removed them

[@Mr.Face222]

@@imsonicnoob2112 Get the Chrome extension and you'll still see them.

[@ConorDaRobin]

Can't say Mattel didn't deserve their punishment. XD

[@Douglas57647]

Hilarious episode, I think you've just summed up how everyone feels about Thomas & Friends Wood! I suggest you make a video where you take all of those horrendous unpainted engines and burn them!

[@jacobg6299]

I mean really, Thomas and friends wood is just a cheaper version of the wooded railway toys and should NOT be bought at all costs

[@thatonecollector8285]

*This has got to be one of my favorite episodes so far from this season!!!*

[@FfarquharEngine]

you're making fun of Wood because of its dip in quality but you still bought the products despite disliking them, so who wins in the end

[@vitalitylimited]

"The hardest choices require the strongest wills."

[@shivamkamil1581]

I thought he bought them for the TCC?

[@gyroi17]

But how about that he burned them

[@AverageOhioan1903]

Good point but I mean if your collecting them all you would need this age

[@AverageOhioan1903]

Of course that doesn’t mean I liked this

[@AlexTheCatGirlQueen]

6:55 the fans remember you Edward

[@StroudleyStudios]

That was amazing! I actually do have a Thomas Wood Item (Don’t hate me for saying this), it is the Day Out With Thomas Coach that came with Sir Topham Hatt. It is surprising that Edward is the main character (possibly because wood did not make a model of Edward nor Henry).

[@nicholetheotter1957]

ThomasTankEngine76 Blame their token female “woke” replacements Nia and Rebecca as the reason why Edward and Henry never made it into Wood.

[@tabletaussendienst2721]

@@nicholetheotter1957 yes

[@BryCrowell]

Basically the whole summary of this episode is that Mattel went from saving the franchise to basically ruining it for everybody with Wood, Removing Toby, Henry, & especially Edward the 1st EVER character created in the world of Sodor from the Steam Team, & of course the Big World Big Adventures garbage.

[@MiddletownBranchProd.]

Ye

[@ayeshafenner7180]

But toby, Edward and Henry are in thoms wood

[@MiddletownBranchProd.]

Ayesha Fenner now they are that comment was a year ago

[@xoxokennzie]

But Toby season 24 the walking bridge episode he and henritta cross it

[@cythereanmapping]

The worst part about this is that he spent money on all that Thomas Wood merchandise. xD

[@northwesternsplendor]

This is great! Loved all the not-so-subtle Wood insults! Plus it's an Edward episode!

[@nfilms1762]

This episode was funny and kind of freaky at the same time! Good job! (Also went Edward crashed into rusty I thought that the other wood engines would come and take Edward away to be downgraded)

[@ianmurphy3840]

This really remind me of one of the episode where Duke was stuck in wacky version of his narrow gauge line where Duncan can fly, Skarlorey only sing acapella, & Proteus is a regular engine that have magic powers. I really like those kinds of episodes and I hope we can see them more.

[@damianbalderas5738]

🤔Back then, I understood why Edward in this episode said Stephen had an extra tender (though he's not copying Flying Scotsman like Henry and James did ) is because is back then when Stephen's wooden railway model during King of the railway Mattel accidentally made his model not how it is in the film, the model of Stephen has his tender attached to him making him look like Bertram's old model, as they're supposed to be separate, so yes I know the wood model is Stephen is terrible like the wood models, but one thing I can say that wood made Stephen's tender separate from instead of stuck to him.

[@ianiant306]

This is "Forever and Ever" done as right as possible.

[@Brooksville_]

This entire video is just a defined definition of "SHOTS FIRED"

[@cashbanooka9166]

"And Diesel is really happy for some reason." - Edward the Blue Engine, 2018

[@arandomtransformersandbion6722]

Nothing could be better than this episode, ever!

[@prestonsvideos6133]

Nice reference to Thomas Wood. They started fully painting the engines but they are still blocky and the bigger engines are still short. Hopefully Mattel gets brought by another company that can actually make the show and the merchandise better.

[@MidwestSirenProductions]

This has to be my favorite episode that you have put together; GREAT job!

[@DianaSttar]

Thank you so much for making fun of Mattel’s bad choices

[@TramEngineStudios]

I both love and hate this. For real though, this was the funniest one you've done yet. Got a giggle out of it not gonna lie.

[@onetrackmind3558]

Right?

[@johnshoepack]

This is the best roast of an entire toy line ever!

[@dfsstudios8463]

Nice episode really does remind me or Nightmare on Elm Street

[@Trainboy17]

4:40 *Sir Topham Hatt Laughed* -17th comment-

[@TidmouthYardStudios]

This was a amazing episode and was so funny they were saying to take a birthday cake in a unsafe manner 10/10!

[@margogoralski6294]

(Sees thumbnail) This is gonna be *GOOD!*

[@Trainboy17]

Yes it was

[@dcspotter]

Sharon Miller era and Mattel ruining Thomas past Season 22 in a nutshell

[@psi_mae]

*sees thumbnail* I’ve been waiting for this one

[@ABellEngine]

lol This must be an episode where Keekre roasts Mattel's past/current direction.

[@TheCloakedTiger]

Man... That is just terrifying! The new trains look so strange...

[@PeruvianPotato]

This definitely one of the best episodes in your series

[@harrilewis18]

this is the best rant episode in the TWR community EVER

[@DavidTheNickjrFan2003]

Thomas puffed away, he had seen EVERYTHING

[@woodenrailwaythomaskid.3231]

Edward: what’s going on? The Fat Director: I thought banished you to wellsworth. Edward: *Confused Screaming*

[@lorijennings6376]

It's really sad that people are changing what we love! I like this episode it explains how it is now! They roonind Thomas the tank engine and friends!!!

[@Woodenrailwayoliver20]

You misspelled ruined

[@SeanShang2005]

A brilliant satire! This is like something we would study in English class in school.

[@Oliverfan2005]

This has got to be one of my favorite episodes I’ve seen in a heck of a while, mostly because it’s so hilarious Amazing job dude

[@JonLukevilleTV]

Wow! An Episode all about the 2018 Thomas Wood Engines including Belle! I hope you can get the 2019 verisons of the Thomas Wood Models! Those look so much better!

[@CJcrazyTrain]

Ur so clever. This is freaking incredible

[@JamDread99]

I'm glad that I'm not the only one who feels this way about the monstrosity that is Thomas wood.

[@noahnorman6877]

I just realized that the part in which Sir Toppam Hatt says that Toby was sent away to a museum echoes what one of the Horrid Lorries said would happen to Toby when they started doing the engine’s jobs in that one episode.

[@Lismism2023]

I love this episode. Also I love how this is a commentary on BWBA and it’s toy lines.

[@leighann_314]

This one is my favorite thomaswoodenrailway video

[@zhiweilim3187]

Henry - scrapped Toby - put in a museum Edward - on the run

[@ToastTheThe]

And banished to Wellsworth

[@damianhendriks6162]

R.i.p. henry 1984-2019 Toby out of service There are now buffers at wellsworth preventing edward from leaving (but he broke the buffers)

[@tristanchan4949]

Great episode, it reminds me of the episode an engine of many colours except with Edward instead of James and having a dream about everything looking in the Thomas wood form and your episode from season 9: special tunnel, when Duke dreamt about strange things happening with the narrow gauge engines. Also I prefer the original Thomas wooden railway era too but I decided to get the wood train of Yong Bao (the fully coloured one) to be with Frieda Gina Vinnie and Ashima.

[@horizon4057]

This episodes makes fun of how bad Thomas wood is and and how terrible big world big adventures is and it’s hilarious

[@johnrutkowski4166]

I've never seen that final era of the show but have seen those wood models 7 learning certain absences, i got to say this is SPOT ON for an episode.

[@evancross9873]

Best episode of the series so far. 😂😂

[@barrymoon4069]

Now this is one of the most bizarre but funny episodes you did so far. Great job!

[@horridlorries1237]

I find it sad that Mattel openly mocked all us Thomas fans in an episode of season 22 so I think this is well deserved.

[@margogoralski6294]

I agree, but what episode? Forever and Ever?

[@horridlorries1237]

I can’t remember but it’s about Gordon getting so angry that everything is changing like Henry moving to Vicarstown and Edward moving to Wellsworth (which at least made a bit of sense) but in the end he accepts the changes which is what Mattel basically wanted the fans to do.

[@margogoralski6294]

@@horridlorries1237 1. Yeah. I've seen the episode. It offended me slightly. 2. Mattel is disgraceful, disgusting, despicable.

[@horridlorries1237]

Margo Goralski Everything they did except for Rebecca since I am fine with her for the most part made me stop watching the show altogether.

[@margogoralski6294]

@@horridlorries1237 Same here.

[@superrhinobros8236]

This is my favorite KZbin channel because I love how he makes these cool Thomas and friends stories with wooden trains great KZbin channel

[@bananacarlin]

Ever since I was a (younger) child I watched this channel it made me happy and still dose today.

[@onyxprima]

I never thought I would ever get to see a sodor engines' fever dream.

[@nachojjful]

What about in Calling all engines and S22-24?

[@onyxprima]

@@nachojjful I think we can all agree those were acid trips.

[@x-fun3149]

@@nachojjful those aren't canon

[@nathangitz2674]

The perfect combo of mudslinging the Sharon Miller writing styles, BWBA, and Mattel's horrible decision to warp one of the most beloved toylines, all in one.

[@BenTheBlocksworldEngine]

James, Winston, and Sir Topham Hatt are the only ones who remember Edward! Also, what are your thoughts on Thomas Wood 2019?

[@TWRfan1992]

This is Mattel's goals in a nutshell

[@nicholetheotter1957]

The Angry TTTE Fan And PAW Patrol was to blame for the show going in this direction. That show only succeeded because it was fast-paced and had enough action to draw kids away from changing channels. That was where Mattel developed the mindset that the only way to win kids over is to win over their attention span that last only three seconds. Think of the TV Tropes term, Viewers Are Goldfish.

[@JamesSmithStudios]

this is legit the new show in an Edward nutshell

[@everythingthomas5669]

That was the funniest thing I've watched this entire year! Good job!

[@lukegoldstonofficial1614]

EverythingThomas this is a joke: Edward wasn’t feeling well so he decided to disintegrate.

[@everythingthomas5669]

@@lukegoldstonofficial1614 you think I don't know that?!

[@comicfan1324]

Still no Thomas Wood Edward. Can’t tell if that’s a good or bad thing.

[@nicholetheotter1957]

Comic Fan 13 Edward, Henry and Toby were never released in Thomas Wood due to them being replaced in the main cast by Nia and Rebecca, aka the twosome introduced only to serve as the token “woke” females who get shoehorned as much as possible.

[@comicfan1324]

@Nichole The Otter Well I agree that Nia was just shoehorned in. Rebecca I think was introduced quite well. She’s very positive and optimistic but can also be quiet shy. But still no way that they treat her like an actual character unlike Nia. (I dare you to tell me any notable character traits Nia has besides being from another country.)

[@tabletaussendienst2721]

@@nicholetheotter1957 yes

[@tommycraft5699]

This sums up everyone’s opinions on those models