Nightwish - Bye Bye Beautiful [Reaction/Review]

Nightwish KZbin Channel:
/ nightwishofficial
Support us on Patreon: / apreacts
A&P-Reacts Merch: apreacts.ca
Feel free to leave a comment with a video/band suggestion, we try our best to get to as many requests as possible.
Concerts we will be attending and providing a review:
Aug 23rd - Dimmu Borgir
Sept 7th - Parkway Drive, August Burns Red, The Devil Wears Prada, Polaris
Sept 10th - Amorphis, Dark Tranquillity, Moonspell & Omnium Gatherum
Sept 14th - Cellar Darling
Sept 22nd - Alestorm & Gloryhammer
Oct 2nd - Carach Angren, Mors Principium Est & Wolfheart
Oct 7th - Paradise Lost
Oct 9th - Wintersun & Ne Obliviscaris
Nov 4th - Korpiklaani & Arkona
Dec 8th - Ghost
Lyrics: Bye Bye Beautiful
Finally the hills are without eyes
They are tired of painting a dead man's face red
With their own blood
They used to love having so much to lose
Blink your eyes just once and see everything in ruins
Did you ever hear what I told you
Did you ever read what I wrote you
Did you ever listen to what we played
Did you ever let in what the world said
Did we get this far just to feel your hate
Did we play to become only pawns in the game
How blind can you be, don't you see
You chose the long road but we'll be waiting
Bye bye beautiful
Jacob's ghost for the girl in white
Blindfold for the blind
Dead siblings walking the dying earth
Noose around a choking heart
Eternity torn apart
Slow toll now the funeral bells
“I need to die to feel alive”
Did you ever hear what I told you
Did you ever read what I wrote you
Did you ever listen to what we played
Did you ever let in what the world said
Did we get this far just to feel your hate
Did we play to become only pawns in the game
How blind can you be, don't you see
You chose the long road but we'll be waiting
Bye bye beautiful
It's not the tree that forsakes the flower
But the flower that forsakes the tree
Someday I'll learn to love these scars
Still fresh from the red-hot blade of your words
…How blind can you be, don't you see … that the gambler lost all he does not have…
Did you ever hear what I told you
Did you ever read what I wrote you
Did you ever listen to what we played
Did you ever let in what the world said
Did we get this far just to feel your hate
Did we play to become only pawns in the game
How blind can you be, don't you see
You chose the long road but we'll be waiting
Bye bye beautiful

[@Nameless0061]

Great choice. Anette may not be the best Nightwish singer but she certainly is a great part of it. Dark Passion Play and Imaginaerum are both amazing albums. I'm very grateful to her.

[@maxrav1831]

But she, was the, best nightwish singer. Not as pretentious, as, Tarja and not so luxuriously overrated as floor 😊

[@fredverkerk838]

@@maxrav1831 anette is overrated , the studio singer .

[@fdsannie]

This song is from Dark Passion Play. It was the first album after Tarja left. This was their darkest album. Tuomas wrote this album when he was depressed, hurt and angry. When you do Anette songs make sure you do official videos. If you want to hear Marco really angry you need to listen Master Passion Greed. It is really bad ass!

[@michaelshort2388]

It was my least favourite Anette album though, because it wasn't written with her in mind.

[@valoxiii422]

"Seek her! Seduce her! Tame her!"

[@maxwelljeremy5659]

The performance Marco pulled off in Master Passion Creed is imo the best singing performance in the whole Nightwish discography. No disrespect to the ladies but the emotion in Marcos performance is real. The song also has one of my favorite intros ever.

[@michaelshort2388]

I disagree. it was one of the best songs of the album but one of their worst of any other album.

[@michaelc3480]

good song but i still think floor could do this one better as well love to see her give it a try !!!!!!!!

[@MladenGavric]

If you guys want a REALLY HEAVY Nightwish song than you should check out Master Passion Greed. It'll blow your minds away! Marco is the singer in that one.

[@lizlee13]

You should consider checking out Rest Calm. The contrast between Marco's desperate voice and Annette's soothing one in this song is very interesting, but for some reason it seems not very popular. Scaretale is another good choice if you want to check out Annette's delivery.

[@vailismyname]

Rest Calm is one of my all time favourte Nightwish songs 😍

[@TheWiseGrif]

I will never forget: it was my very first Nightwish concert in 2012 (9 days before the split with Anette), I had a regular ticket but was there hours early and made friends with the other first people there. When they split the line into general and VIP one of the people I had been talking to offered me his second VIP ticket because his daughter wasn't able to make it, so I got to be in the front of the VIP line (long unnecessary intro) When we heard the band doing sound checks, we slightly opened the venue door to hear better and heard them perform Rest Calm in full as a warmup...only time I've heard it live

[@sonjaemery]

llyz13 yes Rest Calm is in my top 5 Nightwish. LOVE IT!!

[@vailismyname]

That's a really cool story

[@JessyBee1313]

agreed...love this song so much!

[@dodgrblu]

Nightwish - For the Heart I Once Had If you want to hear a song that really fits with Anette really well and highlights her voice, I think this is the one. Not amongst my favourites, but I feel like she is in her element and I don't feel like Tarja or Floor could sing it better.

[@anapereira6814]

Like that one too...

[@akuoksanen9155]

Nightwish - Eva. That was the song that nightwish introduced Anette with. Peaceful song where Anette sounds very good.

[@Aurinkohirvi]

There's also a live video of her singing Eva. It's made of two live videos actually, because the other obviously lacks the beginning. but the somg is live, not the studio version. This link cuts away the very bad quality start of the video: Eva (live fan video) kzbin.info/www/bejne/jqPPdaWAbLd9js0

[@MarsTurunen]

Nightwish Amaranth official video Nightwish Scaretale official live (one of her best)

[@vegard-k74]

Tarja was actualy fired from Nigthwish, with a letter from the rest of the band. It was dilvered to her, directly after "End Of An Era" show. So the lyrics in this song makes sense.

[@lakabaka]

Ok my picks for Nightwish with Anette 7 days to the wolf Sahara Escapist Cadence of her last breath

[@elsapham7908]

Yes the escapist is my favorite song from her

[@despairingleonardo]

Scaretale is her trademark

[@guillermoruizrojas]

Don't forget the poet and the pendulum

[@nightlydreamer_]

You have to check out Master Passion Greed by Nightwish. It's by far their heaviest song! And it's pretty much another Tarja (or her husband's) diss track.

[@johnmclellan2257]

Nightly Dreamer idk man the breakdown in Dark Chest is pretty fucking heavy

[@zoltansilling3755]

Hey guys! Do you wanna hear a freaking badass heavy song from Nightwish? Check out Master Passion Greed! In this song there's no female vocals, just Marco's vocals. The heaviest song from Nightwish. Epic symphonic power/speed metal with agressive vocals. It will blow your mind guys, i promise!

[@michaelvondrake7489]

Zoltán Silling Also a song about Tarja's husband.

[@zoltansilling3755]

Aaron A. Foster yes, that's right.

[@alejandroalcalacastillo4923]

Romanticide and Master Passion Greed these songs are the most heavy of all Nightwish Career

[@zoltansilling3755]

And Song Of Myself, Yours Is An Empty hope are pretty heavy staff too.

[@nightwisherr1]

So you should chech Nightwish - Amaranth with Anette. It has 100 milion views

[@dodgrblu]

Great song, Marco really makes it shine. It's the only one that gets regular repeated plays from me. It may be more mainstream sounding, but who cares. And as others have said, check out Master Passion Greed, it's heavy and intense and got me interested in Nightwish more.

[@JackM.]

This is exactly a diss track to Tarja. There's another track too called "Master Passion Greed". It's the true anger song towards Tarja's husband who was her manager and brainwashed Tarja to be a diva who wanted special treatment. He thought the band was just a background for the true star Tarja and demanded her to have much more benefits than the rest of the band. It was too much for the guys so the break up was inevitable.

[@marlonlx]

Do people still believe Tarja was in the wrong, even after the way Anette was treated by the same group of people?

[@WarlonWinterheart]

I was about to suggest Master Passion Greed too. One thing to note is that Marco does all the vocals in that song in case they're looking to hear more Anette

[@WarlonWinterheart]

Tarja's husband was killing the band. There would be no Nightwish if they had continued with Tarja. We don't know what exactly went wrong with Anette, since it's not been discussed publicly.

[@JackM.]

Anette case wasn't nearly as big drama. There's no songs about her, no open letters, I don't think there's too much bad blood between them. She just basically jumped in too big boots, starting on with huge tours as a nobody and getting much abuse from Tarja fans who hated her. That made her depressed and she was sick all time, problems with her voice etc. She wanted to cancel tour or at least some shows. The band was faced a decision, cancel tour or get a new singer. They chose the latter and brought in Floor mid-tour. Watch the Nightwish document "Please learn the setlist in 48 hours", it's all there.

[@michaelvondrake7489]

Marlon YES. Tarja's husband was trying to say Tarja should get most of the money and that the band would be nothing without Tarja. I love NIGHTWISH with Tarja but it was an initial agreement within the band that all members get paid Equality despite the fact Tuomas wrote the vast majority of the music and Tarja contributed the least to the songwriting. She stopped attending half of the rehearsals. I would feel so backstabbed and betrayed that I would kick her and her manager out of the band too.

[@annelipohjonen6792]

Big love from Finland.You guys brought back my love for finnish metal. thanks guys.

[@Piia2023]

Tuomas Holopainen reveals his emotions and inner feelings through his music and lyrics, and we can be so thankfull to him for that. He gave Anette one of Nightwish era's best songs, her two albums are amazing. That is a very good interpretation from you, this song most have been written of anger. Sadly you will not hear this live anymore! Hope you had a great holiday in Portugal. Listen to Eva with Anette, it doesn't get any more beautiful than that.

[@fdsannie]

I agree Pia. I absolutely love that song. When I first heard it I played it over and over........ :-)

[@michaelplurad4879]

Never? Damn it, why not?! That’s a pity because it’s my favorite song, and I’ve been dying to hear Floor’s vocals on it.

[@sovex9331]

Refreshing to see your thoughts on her period too... a lot of the Nightwish fans I know say Anette was a fluke... but honestly some of Nightwish's best songs come from that period.

[@anapereira6814]

Totally agree with you guys. Those two albums were definitely my favorite ones from Nightwish. To me, for that alone, Annette will always be a good memory in Nightwish history. Thank you Annette, wish you the best of luck 😉

[@MsAbixxx]

Pia Lindqvist Even though my favourite Nightwish singer is Floor, Annette will always have a special place for me because Imaginearum is my favourite Nightwish album and the album that introduced me to the band. I fell in love with Nightwish and their music. I enjoy listening to Tarja, Annette and Floor but I never really understood the amount of hate Annette had.

[@MrMike2489]

You guys really need to check out the music video from Nightwish-Amaranth. It's one of the most famous Annette's songs with Nightwish.... And it's an incredible song aswell!!!

[@music_lover2211]

Yeah! And it's the best song and the best music video!!!

[@GUevanescence]

One of the most famous song of Nightwish

[@AdrianCardona01051011]

Must check Master Passion Greed, best heavy song Nightwish has ever done. Another recommendations are Beauty Of The Beast, Islander, Creek Mary's Blood or Kinslayer :)

[@julijakordic6462]

This is execly my list that they must react to!!! I would love Beauty of the beast,it is pretty underrated, but that is one of my fav songs, shame there is not a great audio and video quality. I think it is time for something easier hahaha 😊

[@zelou_27]

DPP is by far my favourite album from Nightwish, all of the tracks are amazing ❤

[@gelionrunsthrough3973]

Good reaction! I'm glad u reacted to some Nightwish with Anette too. For me best Anette track is Nightwish - Escapist.

[@NatteKrant29]

Song with Anette Storytime! of course! or the Crow the Owl and the Dove

[@sonjaemery]

OmgItsRubenLol yes! The crow the owl and the dove! Amazing song!

[@Aurinkohirvi]

Yeah Storytime is best from Anette.

[@Kipex]

Spot on comments about the lyrics and the fact that it's Marco singing the chorus. It's such a heavy piece of music and the history and meaning behind it all just makes it even heavier. Musical therapy right there.

[@jamesmansfield67]

Yes! Glad you guys finally did this song. Loved your reaction/analysis of it! Thanks!

[@Latexi_LMX]

Nightwish - Amaranth (OFFICIAL VIDEO)

[@alasanoei]

The worst song of the band.

[@music_lover2211]

@@alasanoei The best song and the most popular!!!

[@pauldoerwang4879]

The band's "open letter" to Tarja is out there to read, as well as Tarja's letter in response. I have a soft spot for Anette and feel bad that with singers such as Tarja & Floor as bookends around her, she inevitably doesn't get the respect she is due. If she is judged solely by her own vocal style & ability, she deserves to be regarded as a truly excellent singer. Really, not many mortals could stand in the shadows of those twin demigoddesses and emerged unscathed!

[@Aurinkohirvi]

Floor fans sure think Anette is between two demigoddesses, I don't. Anette was clearly more succesful than Floor has been, her albums sold more (DPP sold 5 x platinums by 2010) than Floor's and her videos are most watched in KZbin and her single (Amaranth) is then most selling Nighwish single. I think Anette got hate because she was different style than Tarja (nobody even knew about Floor at this point). Currently most zealous fanbois watching Nightwish videos are rather fans of Floors than Tarja's, most Tarja fanbois have left NW videos well over a decade ago, and it's those Floor fans that are mostly attacking Anette now.

[@JLTS76]

Anette-era Nightwish imo is amazing, Storytime, Ghost River and Scaretale are fucking masterpieces

[@romaliop]

A couple good Anette songs are Storytime and Amaranth. For a great Marco song, you could check out The Islander if you haven't already.

[@JessyBee1313]

"The Islander" is what brought me back to Nightwish...being in the US, before then all I'd ever heard was "Nemo" and then they were gone from the charts here. Yay for streaming music to bring them back into my life :)

[@RusselF013]

And also The Birdie song.

[@fabianechevarria]

Within Temptation- What Have You Done

[@taijat]

Nightwish: Bye, bye beautiful Tarja. This song really shows how Tuomas and the others felt like.

[@NatteKrant29]

React to the Nightwish movie (i think more of a review) Imaginaerum (2012) really amazing movie, with all the band members as actors playing songs

[@vailismyname]

Yes yes yes!! I've been thinking this for a while! That they make an event out of reacting to/reviewing the Imaginaerum movie :D

[@JessyBee1313]

YES!!!! Especially "Scaretale" and "Slow, Love Slow"...incredible scenes!!!

[@anapereira6814]

Great ideia... Please, do that 👍

[@GUevanescence]

yes yes yes!!! best movie ever!!!! i watch it and cry!!!!

[@EsaValkama]

Dark Passion Play is their best album. Anette isn't their best singer technically, but she has the best songs. You should try Amaranth (It has a music video), it's a very similar song to this one except it's more famous and has more things for Anette to sing. You should really check out Sahara too as it's just an absolutely awesome song (It's perhaps a bit less catchy than this one but it's definitely more epic and complex and, IMO, it's also better).

[@TheSiminification]

Probably not the best choice of song, very radio friendly though it's a nice sing along song :) I'd recommend Turn Loose the Mermaid or Scaretale for a better example of Anette's abilities, I'm sure you'll both love it. Have fun guys ! French cheers to you :)

[@ruthayala88]

If you liked the heavy sound of this, You should listen Master Passion Greed, of Dark Passion Play Álbum... Maybe it's the most heavy song of Nightwish... And never be played live... Grettings from México City!!

[@gabrielleite8092]

From the END OF AN ERA - Sleeping Sun - Tarja Another song with Anette - Amaranth

[@joeN1992]

As others have said check out master passion greed if you like angry Marco lol. Although I'd like to point out that Marco wasn't in Nightwish since the beginning as you said in the video. As to which video with Annette you should check next I'd recommend Storytime

[@zoltansilling3755]

They have checked Storytime, Wacken 2013 live version with Floor.

[@ImberNoctis]

Not so hidden. :) I really enjoyed this reaction and analysis. Anette Olzon doing Song of Myself demonstrates how her belting grew in nuance in the five years she was in the band, but I also think that Eva showcases the best parts of her voice: her soulfulness and her clear head voice. If you want a Nightwish song that has only Marco's voice, Master Passion Greed. It's another diss track.

[@Mike-ci2bm]

well if you look back at this video, we can say you have come a long way and now we have even made Nightwish pay attention to you guys

[@dodgrblu]

Kamelot - Memento Mori Soilwork - Petrichor By Sulphur

[@GhostRavenFIN]

Great vid and analysis! However, Marco wasn't in Nightwish from the very beginning. He joined in 2001 after the third album.

[@skeletankmcgraw7343]

If you like Marco's vocals and the heaviness of this song you should check out Master Passion Greed from this same album "Dark Passion Play". Even though Floor has been my favorite female vocalist for long before she joined Nightwish, Dark Passion Play is still by far my favorite Nightwish album.

[@altiusgym4657]

SONG OF MYSELF!!!

[@vailismyname]

YES! THIS!!

[@taup184]

You are 100% correct about this being a song bashing Tarja. Master Passion Greed is also about Tarja. Check it out. This album, Dark Passion Play was mostly written before Annette was a band member. To hear her really shine, listen to Imaginaerum, written with Annette in mind. A great example of what she can do is Scaretale. Or for a softer song, The Crow, The Owl, and the Dove is a beautiful track!

[@AntonTati]

Sad truth is that as badass as this song is, they will never perform it live again. :( Understandably so but this would be perfect live song and it would also be cool to see Floor sing this.

[@michaelc3480]

Agree i think she would be amazing would love to see it done with Floor !!!!!

[@vailismyname]

Everyone is recommending Master Passion Greed, and it is a fantastic song, so I too recommend it! It doesn't have a video of any sort, though. It might be one of those ones you end up having to enjoy on your own :O

[@robbarbe551]

Hey Guys , great review .....great t- shirts by the way..... Check this please Epica - Kingdom of heaven (live lyrics video ). It wil blow your Canadian heads to the roof... Cheers mates , have a nice day... Your Dutch fan

[@joeN1992]

Rob barbe I second this

[@Stagnating_]

Just listened to Master passion greed, it's been a long time since i've heard it and yes. It's an absolute must-listen for you. Marco on vocals and heaviest nightwish song out there.

[@pompekdev3119]

If you want to listen more Marco then check out Nightwish - The Islander (Live At Tampere) and also their song Master Passion Greed.

[@nebucamv5524]

Listen to "Sahara", my favourite song from this album!

[@MsAbixxx]

I was introduced to Nightwish through their album Imaginearum, an album where the lead singer is Annette. I fell in love with Nightwish and their music and it was sad to see people really dig into Annette because she was not 100% like Tarja. Even though my favourite Nightwish singer is Floor, their current singer, I will always have a soft spot for Annette. I also feel that Tuomas is the true heart of Nightwish, a lot of people stopped listening to them after Tarja left and I think that is pretty stupid. Tuomas writes 90% of the songs and composes the music and he brings the songs together. If he left, that is when Nightwish would be truly dead to me.

[@rafaelduarte7806]

Master Passion Greeeed :)

[@Nameless0061]

Anette's best songs: The poet and the pendulum. Seven days to the wolves. Sahara. Cadence of her last breath. Storytime. I Want My Tears Back. For The Heart I Once Had.

[@vailismyname]

Song of Myself 😍😍😍

[@weakfantasy2]

The one u are looking for is nightwish-heart asks pleasure first. (NW cover from film"piano")vocals Anette.

[@btlarsen]

Tarja - I walk alone is a great follow up

[@laurenwolfe7812]

This entire album is very good, and definitely worth listening to. It gets quite heavy in many places and is also very dark. There's a reason Tuomas describes this album in interviews as "the album that saved [his] life." As others have said already, you'd probably quite like Master Passion Greed from the same album. It'd be another studio version, because you'll never hear them play it live, but it is very good, and is also all Marco on the vocals, which is always nice. As for another Anette song, Eva is one of my personal favourites of Anette's. kzbin.info/www/bejne/qqTTmKSqjKZnfqM

[@michaeldougherty2807]

Imagine having this being your first exposure to Nightwish. You should listen to official Storytime video, and watch the Imaginaerium movie.

[@julijakordic6462]

check out The Islander, not havy but... amazaballls :D Marco is singing OFC Beauty OF the beast ( there is also beauty and the beast), they are both great, take your pick. Creek mary's Blood The islander The Kingslayer Fantasmic First three are amazing and slower, but not Kingslayer, Fantasmic is a story for itself hahah 😎 check one of them you won't be dissapointed 🤗🤗

[@mjpmattos]

Guys, just do it "Master Passion Greed", it's a ballad to relax your ears from all this noise :p

[@MADDEN0985]

100% react to Master Passion Greed for more of Marco's incredible vocals!!

[@misskaisuli]

Your interpretation of the song is almost spot on, however the band openly admitted that this is about Tarja. As many people here have mentioned, you should listen to Master Passion Greed which is about Tarja's husband, who according to the band was the real "villain". Now that is a diss song...It's great though! Probably the heaviest Nightwish song ever. By the way, Tarja also did a song about her being fired from the band - it's called I walk alone. Then to other things, wanna discover a new symphonic metal band from Finland? Then react to Dark Sarah - Evil Roots or Aquarium. They are really talented and the singer Heidi Parviainen has probably the most beautiful classically trained voice in metal. They deserve so much more appreciation! Also, are you familiar with a Swedish band called Amaranthe? I would describe their music as dance metal. Not usually my cup of tea, but their new single 365 is great, you should react to that!

[@DanasLilMakeup]

Yeah this song is actually full of anger (not the angriest though, in the whole album Master Passion Greed is literally a big F.You to tarja’s husband and I guess in some way to her as well) check the whole album, I think is one of the best albums in their history. I have been a fan of the band since the year 2000 and dude, I have never heard Tuomas (through his writing) so hurt and so angry and even petty than in this album. Musically is an absolute jewel.

[@fireeaglefitnessmartialart935]

this is one of my favorite nightwish songs. not my top, but top 5-7.

[@fiona2240]

The best song with Aneth is Whoever brings the night. An Emppu's one 😉 so... heavy riff ❤ Or Scaretale...

[@franciscomacias3994]

The chorus is just lethal. It was a clear message for Tarja.

[@paulwakefield]

Everyone has said it, but you guys need to do Master Passion Greed - this is where Tuomas really lets rip at the person who he thought took Tarja away from them, her husband. Its the heaviest song Nightwish have done to the point where you just couldnt get any heavier riffs in a song. Its from the same album as Bye Bye Beautiful and its just Marco singing. You wont believe this is the same band that can do something as epic as Ghost Love Score. kzbin.info/www/bejne/rYSaf6WGg890eas

[@GabrielaHernandez-kj3ip]

Epica - Kingdom of heaven (live lyrics video )

[@kielitaidoton8076]

I love these reaction videos!!

[@EnzoMPonce13]

Not one of my favourites, to be honest. Still, not bad of course! If you want to check more NW material with Anette, I'll suggest you these ones!: - Amaranth - Eva - Sahara (GOD her chantings in the end are so hypnotic

[@michaelvondrake7489]

It IS a two-way jab. Saying goodbye to Tarja but also admitting they can be premadonnas. Annette was FANTASTIC in the studio and I think NIGHTWISH was motivated to play heavier after the departure of Tarja. I also think Tuomas did some of his very best songwriting...

[@stamaalexgabriel2262]

Great review, you have a perfect interpretation!! Next one - Amaranth or maybe Scarytale

[@mikkosak]

You better check out Tarot: Tides, and you will hear another aspect to Marco's singing... He has so great variety on his voice. AND if you like to hear more Anette, not on Nightwish, check out Brother Firetribe: Heart Full of Fire, she is featuring on that particular song. In that band is also Emppu, guitarist from Nightwish. BF is Finnish Hard Rock!!!

[@antonsdefrancua]

Well from a person who doesn't know the history of the band so well, you felt the song meaning on the point.

[@801Guitarshredder]

Either watch the "Amaranth" music video or the "Storytime" music video... BOTH are with Annette

[@MultiQeQe]

Great you got your sense finally. AO era have few of best Nightwish songs. Rest calm is masterpiece, but don’t know is there any official video from it.

[@metalheaddave666]

Amaranth is Anette’s most popular song

[@sjcarr37]

Amaranth and Bye Bye Beautiful was my starting point with Nightwish!! Love the Annette stuff. I think the right adjective for Marco's voice is sinister!!

[@andrewb2452]

Annette is so under rated, unfairly for sure.

[@djdatabase1]

this is the only song i like from the time she was in the band, its fun to see you guys reacting to songs from the bands that are from my home country aka Finland, i have so far enjoyed all your reactions of all bands from Finland and other countries :D

[@lakabaka]

cmon dude!! The poet and the pendulum, sahara,7 days to the wolf, storytime, Escapist, Eva, Cadence of her last breath, The islander. Are those bad songs?

[@EsaValkama]

More stuff from old bands? Blind Guardian - Wheel of Time: Epic, symphonic, lots of choirs, long and complex... Twilight Force - Twilight Horizon: Soaring vocals, catchy melodies, lots of keyboards Completely new stuff? Crystal Eyes - Panic: Soaring vocals, catchy melodies Eagleheart - Until Fear is Gone (Yesterday was the one year anniversary of the release of this song): Catchy melodies, progressive

[@nebucamv5524]

Marco is one of the best metal voices of the world! It's as good as Roy Khan's, which I admire!!!!

[@vailismyname]

So! Here is Tarja's response video/song (Until My Last Breath) to this. She has two versions of this video, and this one is the one geared towards responding directly to Nightwish. kzbin.info/www/bejne/bpi5f2WGn52ei6s

[@petriojanpera2996]

If you like Marco's voice then you should really check band named Tarot. I bought their vinyl in mid 80's and I was sold. They were Finnish heavy metal pioneers and band were active 'till fall 2016 when their drummer past away.

[@Kiwi-Araga]

This is indeed a song about Tarja. The other girls appeared as a joke. They wanted to make everyone to believe that the entire was replaced and now is a band with only female members. Those girls have no musical education at all, the band spent a day before filming the clip to teach them how to act like they have a bit of an idea about what they are doing. Anyway, you must watch this, not in a reaction video, but you see both Tarja and Floor together on stage after Floor joined Nightwish kzbin.info/www/bejne/jnjanoShlMd1hMk As for Anette songs, there are Amaranth, Poet and the Pendulum and Story Time which have their own music video and Anette is the only vocalist, then there is Scaretale, it has both Marco and Anette and there is only an unofficial video. Other good songs but without a video are Ghost River and I want my tears back, but you already listened to Floors live performance.

[@KierenP]

Hi guys. Great reaction. Just one nitpick. Marco hasn't been in the band from the beginning. He replaced Sami Vänskä on bass in 2002. Try out their cover version of "Walking In The Air" from their 2nd album "Oceanborn" from 1998 to see a different side to the group pre-Marco. There's a pretty good live show featuring that too.

[@kleopratavonrostigburg9055]

The music video of Storytime and the official live of scaretale are very good songs with Annette. The poet and the pendulum and song of myself are some of their best songs, though maybe not the best choice for a video, since there is no music video and the live versions are shorted.

[@dodgrblu]

For any of you that love the intro to Sahara, check this out: kzbin.info/www/bejne/hHSlm3elm9mosLs The song Sahara from the same album has an amazing intro, but the rest of the song is quite different, so I made this edit of it.

[@creativetrance1]

that message to Tarja wasn't even that hidden :D

[@aardappel8450]

Good song, and you're getting a glorious beard mister ;)

[@omegadrake6119]

I love nightwish . I like all albums lol

[@VJScope]

You should check the song Avantasia - Master Of The Pendulum. It is sang by Marco and Tobias Sammet. One of the best songs I have ever heard.

[@vitorsilvacunha7063]

"Storytime" is the best video/single with Anette imo, you guys should do that one next.

[@tarmotyyri6733]

I think that your analysis about the vocal roles between Marco (in the band with Tarja) and Anette (replacing Tarja) is spot on. I also think that Anette is a great singer and not at all a bad choice for Nightwish, but too big a change in vocals/singing style from Tarja, which many fans of the band couldn't handle since most people are resistant to change and prefer the status quo.

[@henri877]

Try Heart Full of Fire by Brother Firetribe, Nightwish guitarist`s other band featuring Anette on this particular song, its a brilliant song :)

[@kimk24]

Hi Guys. The song dont have a hidden message to Tarja, its a song directly to her. I could remember I had heard about it before and know I just googled it, and it is true, it is about Tarja and the fact she left the band :) Keep up the good work, best regards from Denmark.

[@nohandlenoservice]

I spent the last few days watching every single Winter Sunday video (seriously.. every. single. one.). Really enjoyed watching you two hearing Wintersun for the first time. I just searched your channel and did not find any results for a particular band that I'm excited to tell you about. I don't think I've heard you mention them, but I'm sure you've seen/heard about them somewhere. Agalloch. Please react to Agalloch. They can take you on journeys quite similar to those of Wintersun - maybe less 'epic', but definitely thought-provoking. I don't even know where to tell you to begin. It's like trying to show someone Wintersun for the first time (ok, don't default to Vintersun, Stars of Vinter). They may be a little different from what you two are used to, but I guarantee you'll be able to appreciate them. I would start with their older stuff. Agalloch - In the Shadow of Our Pale Companion Agalloch - Falling Snow Let me know what you think.

[@dandyprime5338]

If you want the heaviest Nightwish song from this album, then listen to "Master Passion Greed". It is sang entirely by Marco. If you want a video that is more Annette focused, then listen to "Amaranth".

[@kenrickstadt7753]

Nightwish is fun and all (I am going to see them live) but I'd love to see you guys do some Enshine - Dual Existence Sci-fi melo death, no lasers or cowbells though. They don't really have official videos.

[@aleksierola5093]

It was terrible to find that most of from early NW until DPP was written mostly to articulate Tuomas' lost love and little bit of freakish obsession to Tarja :( And all the credit to Tuomas for making the most important music and maybe the most loved form of emotion for me, but still it is kind of depressing. His song only borrowed her grace. Clearly it wasn't enough for Tuomas.

[@Aurinkohirvi]

I think most Nightwish songs always were about Tuomas' crush on Tarja. Like they sing in "Bye Bye Beautiful": Did you ever hear what I told you Did you ever read what I wrote you Did you ever listen to what we played

[@michaelplurad4879]

It’s because of this song that I’m a Nightwish fan. It’s because of Marco Hietala that I’m now a metalhead.

[@mattikarhunen7382]

This is possibly their biggest hit. Nightwish doesn`t play this one live ever by the way. Other one is Master Passion Greed.

[@OskoreiMick]

Master Passion Greed from the same album is about Tarja's Husband and on a similar vain