NIN: Survivalism live w/ Saul Williams, Atlanta 5.10.09

[@boombam44]

The energy around the crowd when I was down there during this song and even the whole concert, was amazing. When I saw Saul come on stage I freaked out.

[@boneor...7022]

Unnecessary comma between concert and was

[@boombam44]

@@boneor...7022 bro I made this comment 11 years ago calm down lmao.

[@hovazane4091]

I miss the Atlanta live music scene. Houston crowds suck and it makes the musicians not feel it either.

[@FUCKCHRISHANSEN]

should of put a comma between ago and calm

[@zeppelin6601]

May 10th will now be remembered for the battle of the pants.

[@rock00dom]

Thanks for making me chuckle :)

[@melissamikan6486]

🌟Hahahahahah hahahahaha hahahahaha hahahahahah hahahahaha Hahahahaha hahahahaha hahahahaha hahahahaha hahahahahah HAHAHA🌟 😄 You're funny! ☺

[@Dogfacedboy1980]

They look like the pants from MOTP...

[@bmofano]

5th of October * trousers*

[@tommmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmm]

i hope you got ya cool pants ironed

[@Goatchild90]

Saul just casually walks in and just goes crazy on vocals 😂😂😂

[@jrgussngussn7093]

Just call saul...

[@jannastieg6572]

That was the best part!

[@TheArenaGod]

I think Year Zero was just mind blowing. The whole album really told the story of what was going on during the years Bush was in office. And in my opinion, NIN's sound hasn't changed all that much. Year Zero may have been leaning towards catchy dance beats but not all the songs were like that and the album was just meant to tell a story anyway. Even if the music became a little more simplistic, theory-wise, its still good and its still industrial. And a lot of the time, simple is beautiful.

[@bobbystone3100]

This is America. It's not at all specific to Bush.

[@TheArenaGod]

@@bobbystone3100 bro I posted that 13 years ago

[@workshop777]

Saul walked out and owned the stage. Truly awesome moment on that tour. I saw them during this tour but it wasnt Atlanta and Saul wasnt with them at my show.

[@MamaGator]

😭 iconic

[@michaelg2502]

I agree with Whatever below, this album is his most underrated. This was his greatest single imo blows away Came Back Haunted

[@Theghostdiaries]

Came Back Haunted is sweet though. In fact, I think Hesitation Marks is his best album since The Fragile, which is untouchable for eternity of course.

[@daffyshakilfur3563]

Year zero is so strong. I fucking love it. Has a sexy sound a lot of his other material doesn't have,...not to put that material down in anyway.

[@thepims]

NIN are so damn awesome, they are one of the few band that sound even better live

[@lordofsquad]

I'm loving the intro to this.

[@garcismarus3503]

Thats the main reason I dig this so much

[@dawnbreak3299]

My god NIN was the MOST AMAZING group I've EVER SEEN. Trent is just an amazing artist and I've seen them 63 times...last time being less then 10 years ago...one of first was with Davie Bowie...did hirt together and was brilliant

[@matteofazio7845]

63 times??? You're the goat!!!

[@mikegollihue]

I love how much Trent is into it in the beginning

[@colinfitzgerald8221]

Love the ketchup & mustard pants combo between Trent & Saul... 😂👍

[@gladdippy]

Regaurdless of how good or bad you think Trent's newer work is, he didn't sell out. He is still amazingly creative and Survivalism/Year Zero are in no way mainstream, I love how Trent has always done what he has wanted, even though he loves and supports his fans, when it comes to his music, he makes it how he likes it. My point being Trent doesn't give a shit about idiots who think his new music is bad, because it's good to him. (and to me) ;D

[@xaqxiq9281]

I so wish this version of Survivalism was on Apple Music! It’s the best!!!!

[@Starr_Apathy]

Agreed! The energy on this is off the Charts!

[@ComaAlpha]

M. Trent Reznor looks like a UFC beast version of himself. Definitely not the scrawny kid I remember from Woodstock 94.

[@adamblister6005]

***** He discovered protein and weights.

[@ComaAlpha]

He discovered steroids

[@adamblister6005]

***** Trent doesn't do steroids. He's clean. Does only protein and juices.

[@ComaAlpha]

If you say so.

[@johnnyscifi]

+Pete Agassi Not like it really matters, i mean i dont care regardless, but i higly doubt he got to be so beefy, not taking testosterone!!!

[@stephanieann9770]

Im sooo glad you did a song with Saul :) and I still love NIN since I was 12 yrs old.... that's more than half my life since im slmost 30!

[@MamaGator]

Stephanie Ann literally my lullaby music, its in my babybook haha

[@jackpitman15]

he produced a whole album with saul "the eventual rise and fall of niggy tardust"

[@tysonoff]

AWESOME!!!!! I love the Saul version as much as the original.

[@maykay.jaykayman9647]

Better call Saul

[@petercarmody1606]

Best performance of this song EVER?!

[@danimoonstar]

some people are lucky enough to live in places where this type of thing takes place.

[@mutnine]

This is so awesome, all the instruments, trent, saul... wow, i wanna die...

[@tribaltyn]

both the sound quality and visual quality of this vid is superb I love trent for just sharing this stuff with his fans instead of releasing some dvd and asking a small fortune for it...

[@Ermac97]

I love the way Saul Williams shakes his ass!

[@konstantinepope]

OMFG 13y late to the party but the fact that he picked Saul for this......F me backwards the man is a timeless genius

[@flippinggenre]

Man I’m just getting to know the fact that they go long way back ! My mind is kinda blown away rn

[@ceejayessee]

I've loved NIN for years now, and discovered Saul through them and I love him just as much.

[@eighty1net]

Wow. Holy shit. The song was intense before Saul walked out, then he just fucking FLOORS IT. Awesome.

[@Z52]

That was sweet! i would give my left hand to have seen that live!!!

[@dinothegonzo]

Bruh, I would've given my left nut. I've seen the minimalist lineup in 2018 and I wanna see this.

[@NikCarterNYC]

Saul is no joke if you dont know the rise and fall of Niggy Tardust sounds very Trent but you cannot deny Saul's power. This is ten shades of awesome!

[@HaloSmyth]

Omg I was there for this it was amazing. I was so excited to see Saul

[@88qwop]

this lyrics is more true now than ever

[@007fiber007]

Yehh.. This is undoudtedly awesome. You can't compare a cell of art w/ another. PERIOD!! Great capture of a live event w/ nin/ Saul Williams. Only if people would listen and not hear music. That simple. And those of you who do know this is TRUE.say it...

[@bpo88reloaded]

no me canzo de ver este video !!! esta bien chingon!! recordando cuando los vi en guadalajara!

[@JamesonMortimer]

Always a pleasure listening to NIN!

[@SilentBombr]

Well, what can one say. These performances are so incredibly tight and entertaining.

[@underdavid]

I witness that too.. greatest music on the planet. perfect show in my life.

[@SphericSenseS]

What an awesome combo w/ NIN....got to hear Saul Williams at the Justice League in SF with a D&B band and it was freakin' off the hook.

[@thegrimp]

Best Survivalism version available on KZbin!

[@blahbipblah]

Appropriately long. Now I know about Saul Williams. Thanks for that...

[@The_sound_Of_Thunder]

Love these stage cam videos, gives it a very personal vibe.

[@dragoslavs]

Perfect sound, as always! I love that camera floating around.

[@Holtzy95]

That transition at the beginning was sick!

[@ChrisMo44]

2:05 This beat is awesome during the verse, gotta love Ilan for little things like that

[@stigmatavendetta]

Notice Trent wore red pants, Saul wore Yellow, they're like ketchup and mustard LOL

[@chrisdavis1814]

Saul rocks!!!

[@quatreryukami]

Great performance. We would have never gotten footage like this if NIN was still on a Label.

[@Cassandrahope89]

i was here!!!!! OMG IT WAS AMAZING!!!

[@ninskier5685]

It just wouldn't feel right watching this video if i didn't watch banged and blown through after!..AMAZING!

[@tribaltyn]

this is fucking amazing love all those stage videos but survivalism is a personal favourite

[@velikipalachinke]

love this. great performance!

[@PvtPlatypus]

Saul was great with this.

[@wallofsheep5645]

Trent, thank you for being you!

[@aaronccheatham]

Nice job Saul!

[@BJZnRPZ]

some of the best high def videos on KZbin keep postin brother, i love this shit.

[@moebear]

Saul Williams kicks ass.

[@Not_Likely_319]

@skateNappreciate I'd agree. Saul Williams is the seed of hip-hop that was meant to sprout.

[@460maxx]

saul is great for this song and is tallented singer with them too.

[@junkyMM]

guys you are awesome! cant wait to see you on the openair st.gallen! love you!

[@getthoseskills4451]

Saul Wiliams is amazing. He brilliantly merges rap with industrial music. Also love other darker industrial hip hop artists like Ho99o9, Death Grips, Dalek, Backxwash, AllFlaws

[@foskos6025]

man i love dalek! absence was top tier

[@Rockoutloud2172]

i like how saul just rambles on stage and then just rocks out

[@drchipohpoh]

it was great, thanx for sharing it nin

[@GBuck276]

I love Saul

[@elBOBAnme]

great performance

[@roseagain2]

AWESOME!

[@woahXgirl94]

i love nin so much wow. red pants , nice.

[@Boppa83]

@Bangieflea Well put Saul Williams has a lyrical prowess that most other artist would kill for!

[@petharti]

Saul is the man.

[@GoryRory]

So hard to focus on the music when all I see is ketchup and mustard...

[@jharbid]

Yeah, Robin is fuckin' incredible. I've gotten lots of footage of him at the 10 shows I've been lucky enough to attend.

[@Recovrd1]

I was there! Jane's Addiction kicked ass too!

[@ny5280]

Cool shit, nin rocks!!!!!

[@Mafila]

When I first saw Trent Reznor with Saul Williams I honestly didn't get it. Then I listened and I was blown away.

[@FrazatiVideos]

THAT WAS AMAZING!!!!!!!!

[@kefka242]

sounds good live

[@daleweber2579]

For a second I thought Rob was going throw camera guy in the crowd :D

[@afthefragile]

whooo!!! Two of my favorite artists on the same stage!!!! This is epic!!!!!!!!

[@MachinaSapien]

these video's are fucking ledgend. i saw him live in calgary july 29 2008

[@madame__madness]

OMG this is awesome! Oo I can't wait to see them on June 29th...

[@iscleyva]

Best intro ever!!!

[@BEHEDETY]

genial !!! increible !!!! yea yea ea aaaaa !!!!

[@wormmm]

Fucking. Awesome. I love Saul- CRAZY energy.

[@tiberbeats]

bloody awesome!

[@daftmarzo]

Wow, the camera work is really good.

[@doomreaperx]

Awesome just fucking awesome.

[@nin56665]

How fucking cool is this performance!?!?!!Saul is badassss!!:)

[@DJ4x]

that opening is freaking crazy.

[@beautysVlogUSA]

very nice dera thanks enjoyable

[@FIATFROSTvideo]

Awesome show!

[@Jallandhara]

HOLY. FUCK.

[@michugurumi]

THIS IS MAD! SO COOL!! GO NIN!!!

[@curlyquotes]

saul + trent together is amazing

[@Idolcruisefix]

wow, new good music with a live great sounding performance recorded profesianally. i cold watch it all day but i just listen to get amped, then i'm good to go, i pod or not. trent is not a sell out, wake up and enjoy the culturally unabashed talent having it's way. this is what makes reality and freedom seem tangible. the video and the collection of well recorded life songs, not just the single itself.

[@NiklasKing87]

awesome

[@2112Primus]

OH MY GOD DAT STAGE PRESENCE

[@ak47rocksbigtime]

perfect timing :)

[@urbanknight1001]

probably by tomorrow, that option will be available. it usually takes a bit after the videos uploaded for hq or hd to show up.

[@NynesGG]

Him and Saul go waaaayy back. i believe that he helped him produce the fragile.

[@SilentBombr]

Damn, they totally rock out at the end.

[@merseymarinermusic]

Robin is my fave, so awesome

[@mal4m]

Well this was somewhat of a crossover into "Banged And Broke Through" which they played immediately afterwards. ;) Plus Saul is in the actual Survivalism recording.

[@synfulpinion]

I haven't seen Saul live since '06 =( still fantastic though

[@MutleeIsTheAntiGod]

SAUL FTW!!!