Nine Inch Nails - Wish (Live: Beside You In Time)

[@ReverseNegativeTV]

All the members look like different versions of Reznor. The guitarists are the 90s Trent, and the keyboardist is With Teeth Trent, and the guy singing is current Trent!

[@roguetoken5640]

Gordie looks like Perfect Drug era Trent.

[@nirupa5092]

@@roguetoken5640 is that twiggy?

[@roguetoken5640]

@@nirupa5092 sure is!

[@mikevogler5455]

It's extremely depressing to realize that this song, and the Broken EP in general, came out in 1992...when I was only 13 years old...32 years ago now! Where has the f**king time gone to???

[@loveHIMmetal]

...Josh Freese kicks ass here! Man, he's like an octopus...this is one awsome performance!

[@masseffectmafia]

My favorite NIN lineup. Aaron North was an absolute fucking beast who is sorely missed.

[@jonmeans2637]

My favorite line up as well. Geordie White and Aaron North really added to the band

[@alexisarrizon6083]

@@jonmeans2637 I saw them in 2005 with this line up and Alessandro cortini

[@paulcoates5699]

Imagine Aaron north in the self destruct era! Pure chaos.

[@fourkings_]

Aaron added so much to the live band. His energy cant be contained. Pure Madness.

[@ivayloandonov4177]

best NIN line up

[@patriciasalazar3712]

This was honestly the best lineup ever. Josh was a beast. Super nice when I met him.

[@MrIgorek13]

Who is running guitarist Robin?

[@shazeemshezi]

@@MrIgorek13 I think its aaron

[@Alex-ut7rg]

Best WISH in my mind and best line up. AARON NORTH in your FACE !!!!

[@ddust102]

there was a real element of chaos that all subsequent live bands didn't have..

[@VuotoPneumaNN]

To be honest, most of the time Aaron North sounded like he had no idea what band he was in.

[@timlai1219]

Aaron North guitar play rules!!!🤘

[@carllouisyoung]

As much as I love that Robin is back in the fold, I ABSOLUTELY miss and LOVED Aaron North, he brought an energy and attitude on stage and in his playing that was reckless and beautiful at the same time. When I saw them in St. Paul, MN during the With Teeth he was awesome..

[@okapilovers2]

This performance is great overall, but I think the drummer is what engaged me most about it. Dude fucking nailed it all the way through. Didn't expect to see a live NIN drummer I liked as much as Ilan Rubin but here we are.

[@lornecui4967]

This drummer is legendary Josh Freese. Personally, I would say NIN has the best musicians during this period.

[@jackieblu7111]

@@lornecui4967 couldn't agree more,luv them ❤

[@hawaiianfire27]

Josh is an amazing drummer.. dude has played for pretty much every kick ass band

[@DuffyJ1111]

I have broken more shit and blown out more speakers to this song in my childhood than any other. Honestly it's a damn miracle I'm still alive.

[@brandonleague3641]

Hands down, my favorite NIN song. This version just slays...

[@mitchduffy]

@aditsetan jeordie white is the bassist (on the left) but this song has no bass parts so he's playing g-tar

[@GEORGEISWOKE]

OF EVERY LIVE SHOW I HAVE EVER BEEN TO, NINE INCH NAILS HANDS DOWN IS THE MOST INTENSE AND WORTH EVERY PENNY SHOW I HAVE EVER HAD THE PLEASURE OF GOING TO. LONG TIME FAN SINCE HIGH SCHOOL, I HAVE SO MANY OF THE PHYSICAL HALO'S. GO ON TOUR, I MISS YOU.

[@ericpanissidi6761]

I grew up from 20 to 55 with nin.i love every song im sober now 10 years but when i hear the songs i lovve i want to get drunk and high.

[@GameSlimeOG]

So, I was a Linkin Park fan before. Always advocated about it and shared my passion for the band. I discovered Nine Inch Nails after listening to the music in the trailer for "300". And with that experience, I can say that both versions will appeal to a different set of people. Linkin Park themselves are covering a NIN song and that is an awesome thing in itself. Johnny Cash covered "Hurt". And that is awesome too. Overall, NIN is in a different league altogether. Trent Reznor is in a different league altogether. There is no comparison. Just love for your artist. I prefer NIN version of Wish because I find LP kiddish. But I do love LP's original songs and compilations till Collision Course album.

[@mathewhair4615]

I was there. Badass show in Oklahoma City in like 2006.

[@michaeloxner2073]

NIN sounds great on my speakers... but seeing them live and in person is an entirely diff experience You feel that ish to your core!!!

[@frehleyfan6]

The lighting is so fucking on point

[@lizashleyc]

I saw this in concert.. absolutely incredible.

[@mahesaparameswara4509]

This live version is much better than the ep version, imo 😘😍

[@topher2179]

Was at this show best show ever

[@LinkinParkKanenite]

I heard LP's version first.....but it gave me exposure to Nine Inch Nails. I had never heard of them before that. Now I'm listening to all NIN's albums

[@12345678905693]

Ok after viewing some opinions i think its time to express mine aswell. I listen a lot of lp and this band is the reason that i learnt this song. Now. I dont understand why both sides claim that their favorite band performs this song best. To NIN fans: How you ever thought that lp might sang this song due to deep respect towards NIN and NOT to surpass them and by trying to prove that they are better than them??......

[@guitarhero3150]

Trent is such an amazing live performer..

[@youllneverknow304]

this song is forever

[@HomebrewHorsepower]

Wow. Never heard of NIN before... makes me feel old. Still, welcome to the experience!

[@DeathwingDuck]

God, I regret ever missing this band live. It's very rare that a live version, YEARS later, is done actually clearer and overall better than the master recording and yet still retaining that raw live sound, but they did it!

[@alanc420]

I saw them on this tour. one of the best shows I have seen.

[@TheMatt_SD]

Hey guys, I figured something really cool out, you can like both the NIN and LP version of this song for their own merits! Woah, amazing! Right?

[@EMdemo]

Ah yessss

[@dbrohrs4668]

You can, but you shouldn't. Chester > Trent

[@bonifaceo]

​@@dbrohrs4668 Ahahah! What?! I prefer Trent tone. And what about that??? I don't care the power, I prefer the tone. Once more, and what about that? LP for me is irrelevant, but I respect the ones who likes their stuff, but only their stuff, this is not their stuff...! And in creativy Chester

[@JuiKuen]

@@dbrohrs4668 Linkin Park is audio diarrhoea for cry babies, so no.

[@dbrohrs4668]

@@JuiKuen lol thats pretty cute dont get ya panties in a bunch, boy. comment wasnt serious everybody likes their own thing trent reznor is a legend and so is chester k? but so that you dont lose any more sleep; trent = chester. thx, gnight kid.

[@Michchamps]

I saw them at Woodstock 94, when they climbed out of the crowd covered in mud!!!

[@boskoantonijevic]

drummer kills it!

[@joshuaweston6531]

Performing this live looks like an absolute workout!

[@Matthieu1983]

the drummmmm crazy best version ever

[@paolocastillo7171]

“Fistfuck!” Best song lyric ever

[@RockigualAnime]

definitely I love Trent. truly a great musician and an inspirer man.

[@nb3853]

why cant people just admit that both nin and lp versions are good. obviosly nin deserves more credit for writing and performing such a great song, but lp did do a pretty kickass cover of it.

[@punkerband73]

one of the best lineups nin had

[@CARETAKER89able]

So True there is Nothing Like F**k up like Today.My Favourite NIN Line up.Love North on Guitar!!

[@jakobjensen6598]

I prefer this version over the one by Linkin Park. People who prefer LP's version are entitled to their opinion, but could you please call it an opinion rather than a universal fact that LP's version is better? I find it annoying to read (and I think a lot of NIN fans would get less pissed off about it). Thank you.

[@remains_BS]

+Jakob Jensen In my opinion, I think it's safe to say Linkin Park did great justice to the song. How's that? ;)

[@jakobjensen6598]

Totally fine ;)

[@JuiKuen]

LP's version misses the idea and like all their music, is gash for tje simplistic mind.

[@Janine.Najarian]

Linkin Park cover this? Gross.

[@jimlunn]

@@Janine.Najarian Nah don't be like that. A cover is playing tribute to a song. Not 'gross'

[@Rylai_xiv]

ahhhh this is how i like my NIN shows. the last couple i've been to have been so lame. people just standing there listening even during the bangers like this and march of the pigs. THIS MUSIC DEMANDS PEOPLE TO BE IN MOTION.

[@xxashton92xx]

I love bands that sound the same LIVE as they do in studio

[@megtwinkles]

Better

[@HoodyBoy85]

Man! That drummer has got to be exhausted!!

[@jackieblu7111]

OH MY GOD WHAT A BAND... THEY BLOW MY MIND

[@OG_PennyWise]

Really wish he would go back on tour one last time. Seen him in concert 5 times already and each show was better than the last. Mike = rock god

[@arikay123]

This song gives me chills. Ahhh so much emotion!

[@Angeloanagnostou]

What a sound!!!!

[@David-zo7to]

I mean, why are people commenting here on which version is better? Go to LP's video and talk about it, leave NIN videos alone, it's getting annoying.

[@bridgedown1]

awesome,so full of energy.....

[@megtwinkles]

Heard them do this in Milwaukee during with teeth ❤❤

[@ILYUHIN]

Одно из лучших выступлений!

[@qwertyuiip9132]

И один из лучших состава

[@alexisarrizon6083]

I love nine inch nails saw them live twice in 2005 best concert ever

[@mayamoon722]

Jeordie !!

[@ceck.8843]

WooT! My all time favorite NIN song

[@bloodandashes75]

Aaron North is the greatest thing about BYIT. Dude was incredible

[@TurskyOFFICIAL]

I heard of NIN when I was like 8 or 9 from The Hand That Feeds being in Rock Band. loved it, but LP was my favorite band at the time. I heard LP's cover of Wish when I hadn't heard the original and thought "this is awesome" then went to the original and i was like "wtf dis suxz l0l lp allde way1!!1!" now i've listened to more of NIN's stuff and I actually know what the song is about, so I have to say, nothing can beat the original. :)

[@C0sm1C2u]

i saw them at the outside tour it was my 18th b-day best birthday present it was badass they had bowie sing 5 of their song

[@dewy29657]

Everytime I hear this my head goes into the ace of spades can't help it luv this song but to me I'm expecting lemmy to start singing I just wanna live forever

[@Ochovarium]

So glad I managed to see NIN live before they stopped touring. Best show of my life!

[@LinkinParkKanenite]

I'm watching this version now cos I was just watching Linkin Park's cover. There really is no need to compare the two. This sounded really good and I usually don't like songs on first listen. Linkin Park's aim was not to try and better NIN's version but just to pay tribute to a band that inspired them to create music....LP are NIN fans.

[@NothingCompares2U]

Greatest band ever during the event of a childhood gone bad.

[@ThisIsMischa]

It's get better and better, when it's get weter and weter picturial POV

[@dorianand]

Breathless song. Amazing.

[@31619halo]

its amazing how north created his own guitar solo in this song, better than how robin finck plays it live, even though finck played with guns n roses at the time, his playing in guitar with different bands sounds so different

[@jasondanis9490]

So many of thier songs have so much going on, but this one WOW!. Experience it live is something one needs to do before they eat dirt.

[@jackieblu7111]

Joshi Freese 🥁

[@intrugens]

Originality inspires greatness.

[@Mike19910711]

Шикарное исполнение. И ударные, и гитары, и вокал.

[@americanbradley]

@MegaKoolaid33 REZNOR is a god among music. How could you ever insult his voice like that? This guy worked harder than over half of all of the other musicians and singers of his time and he still has it! Everyone has an opinion but who ever said he had to sing "pretty" and perfect throughout the entire show. Besides, with many types of art, the imperfections are what make it real because it adds to the uniqueness and the INNER FEELINGS and EMOTIONS of the song and music. He is TRENT REZNOR! NIN!

[@Tprime999T]

i love their live shows so much more than the songs by themselves......

[@bluewater82]

Wow, haven’t listened to NiN in over a decade. Stumbled on this and was surprised at how well they slayed it. I listened to Broken lots when I was younger and must admit this live version is waaaaay better.

[@bridog6996]

I love how the drums are basically playing a bluegrass/country beat, but add in everything else and, well, obviously it's completely different.

[@tiesioglinas]

I'm a fan of LP (well I used to be a bigger in their first days, but still I have respect for them) . Yet compared to Reznor, Chester looks like an angry teenager complaining about highscool in his cover :) . NIN owns this song, no competition

[@JuiKuen]

The ultimate performance

[@serioussowhy1011]

I love robin finck but aaron’s stage presence and style is irreplaceable. Dude was an absolute madman during the with teeth era.

[@sneeuwpopjes]

I finally found this song aggain! Heared it once but never found it, finally!!

[@12345678905693]

To lp fans now: Remember that NIN created this song. Noone can represent a song better than its creators. 2nd, lp are on their primes now and NIN is a very old band. SO THERE IS NOT A FUCKING COMPARISSON. I FUCKING ENJOY BOTH GREAT PERFORMANCES

[@joshquilty3068]

i think aaron played a real cool part at 2:00 and he did some cool shit with on tdtwwa everything else was mostly a huge feedback with him and his amp unless they were already broke hah. cool/bitchy guy met him in 2005 at the meet and greet

[@DaZeDmerlin]

Yes, totally in sync, fucking amazing live band!

[@SlasherMiniFilms]

I was lucky enough to see them last year! AMAZING show!

[@c.alejo8846]

you know me, I hate everyone.... damn.... still true? Sometimes I still feel that. wow

[@dlagrua]

Todays bands just don't play with that much emotion anymore.

[@Rotties9292]

@jonmakcharoenwoodhi I was saying the same thing,, the way scumgod was talking it sounded like NIN is a band, when it's really Trent who does all the writing.

[@hberk24]

OMG!

[@budzoganmeruosmy]

just the best song ever recorded :)

[@mikejaxer]

@MegaPrayers True that... i just hate people saying "LP is better" or "NiN is better"

[@RaptorJesus.]

RIP epileptics XD rock on the rest of us! :D

[@tomhatl4690]

They nail it aqein . bravo

[@신동국-l9e]

iloveit

[@salvador1534]

Can we all stop being fanboys and just embrace the fact that there are 2 excellent versions of this song. I love Linkin Park's version, but for me nothing tops the original. Both bands are great.

[@fulldisclosureiamamonster2786]

Yes. Two excellent versions. The original... And the Dillinger Escape Plan cover ;)

[@3third3eye3]

Anyway..is an awesome song...

[@DEMchannel]

@Villagran Normally I hate those things, but that's the best one I've ever heard.

[@rengmeng6919]

Good job boyz

[@milotrix44]

@aditsetan I agree where's the bassist?

[@romu7999]

Great drums on this track !

[@CheesyKFC]

Next person who says Linkin Park's version will get swarmed by Robotic Unicorns, and get shat on. Mark my god damn word.

[@awsmdrummer62]

listen to the whole year zero album and the downward spiral, 2 of the best albums ever

[@Tapeleg247]

I haven't seen Reznor since the late '90s or something. until i heard him sing right here, i would have thought he was that guitarist on the right.