No Alternative to Israel Invading Gaza, Hope We Can Prevent Inevitable Revenge: Yossi Beilin

[@bharatpopat9835]

Mr. Thapar, I am your admirer for several years. Please keep it like this - bold, forthright, unbiased and factually correct

[@rohitjain6616]

Justice minister is not talking about waves of grabbed land and inhuman behaviour. But repeatedly talking about waves of rocket which seldomly hit the ground. ( °-°)√

[@shahnawazmattoo1633]

Imagine what hardcore mindset will be if this is mindset of justice minister

[@josephrarichen1229]

Israelis r living in their own dreams & r not seeing the truth. Israelis think that as they went through hell during WW2 they have the right to do what they wish. As they have support of US and Europe they can crush Palestinians but current reality is different. The adamant Israel will bring its own destruction and destruction of its allies if it still does not meet the justified demand of an independent Palestine state.

[@shalimar1792]

Plse karan thapar interview gabor mate,the jewish psychologist who escaped holocaust.he escaped to usa.... His views are very true and fearless...

[@advghc1279]

Good job by Mr. Karan Thapar. This interview highlights hypocrisy of learned Israeli representative

[@KonarkB]

Did the Allied forces were asked to think of the people of Berlin before entering the city to eliminate the Nazis?

[@StandupForHumanityB4Its2Late]

The audacity of Yossi Beilin to act as the saviour of the people of Palestine is nauseous and disgusting. Thank you Karan for stating the truth and asking the tough questions. It is so clear that the lives of the Palestinians are of lesser importance. Human beings, people, children, women, elderly, sick, pregnant women are just numbers to these people. Where would the sick people go? How can they move? How can the elderly travel? Why should people leave their homes so the Israeli’s can take their revenge.

[@anonymous_4276]

I think the Israelis could answer that they don't have a choice here either. If they don't end Hamas, these periodic attacks will continue indefinitely and they will always risk facing what they just faced from Hamas.

[@alibazzi8197]

If this is the view of a JUSTICE minister, GOD helps the peace loving people.

[@matthewjoseph7671]

Well, The Poor Chappy is After all One of the Individuals " affected " by the BARBARISM of " HAMAS " .....What Else COULD the Poor Chappy Say Other than the Objective TRUTH ?

[@matthewjoseph7671]

HAMAS Has to " Get Out Of GAZA " and ALL Will be Well - and Israel has NO Choice Other Than to FREE the Innocent People of GAZA of SAVAGES - The SAVAGERY & BARBARIC Acts Commited by HAMAS Last Week in Israel IS Beyond Redemption by ANY Measure of Humanity

[@philipkavilae5338]

Peace loving indeed 🙃

[@thetroll1887]

peace loving? 😂😂 have some shame now.

[@anshuraj4277]

Hamas started it

[@shanuv12]

Totally agree with him on this. Israel has no option until Hamas is neutralized.

[@huma3968]

I am greater admirer of an excellent impartial interviewer like you. Every one should watch you and you must stay on the air for a very very long time.

[@backbencher10054]

It was a very good Interview & The ex Justice minister was really Honest..

[@vikshri8387]

Perfectly spoken Yossi Beilin. Kudos to Israel 🇮🇳❤️🇮🇱

[@triptoroy]

Karan Thapar is the last man standing who asks questions because that's their only purpose of being what they are. We had some brilliant one's till the end of the previous millennia but that's where it ended. Just a few remains of an era that is definitely Jurassic now.

[@thepskrishnan]

Every crisis today, will almost trace back to the British. That’s also because they were the last to colonise at such a large scale. Given more powerful weapons, the damage today is immense.

[@matthewjoseph7671]

And ALSO : They Were The MOST Barbaric too 😆

[@priyankakumar2292]

Thanks for series of wonderful interviews on Israel providing critical insights into the issue..

[@thetroll1887]

tu kya karegi insights ka? 😂 jana tujhe kisi maulvi ke ghar hi he.

[@lgopalakrishnan3181]

@@thetroll1887 Get back to your job of cleaning toilets at Nagpur. OOPS I forgot you can't understand English. Nagpur mein shauchaalay saaf karne ke apney kaam par vaapas jao. 🤪🤣😆

[@thetroll1887]

@@lgopalakrishnan3181 katwa aa gaya fake id banakar. ab fake passport banakar Gaza ja apne bhaiyo ke paas. 🤣 katwa brotherhood

[@lgopalakrishnan3181]

@@thetroll1887 Bhai tumne apney liye sahee naam chuna - "troll". Ab Israel mein jao lado. Maine suna hai ki Sanghi ladae mein shaamil hone ke liye Gaza kee aur bhaag rahe hain. Unke ladae Hamaas par surakshit doori se gaaliyaan dene tak hi seemit rahegi. 😝😜🤪

[@thetroll1887]

@@lgopalakrishnan3181 jal to bahot rahi hogi. aaj kal news hi kuch aisi he. tere aakaao ka naksha badalne wala he. 🤣🤣

[@shaheenali7276]

Yes there is an alternative. Give freedom and their land and their soveinity to Palestinians.

[@hassobhatia990]

In fact Israel did give full freedom to Palestinians to run Gaza, but Hamaz took over and subjugated them..

[@shaheenali7276]

@@hassobhatia990 Hey you call this freedom? Isreal got out of Gaza but they controlled all around Gaza border, air and water, and electricity . You call this freedom. Come on learn more. And for your information Isreal created Hamas to counter PLO and Fatah. They learned this tactic of divide an rule from Britain. This is what America did created Mujahidin to counter Russia in Afghanistan.

[@vipintyagi9281]

KT u r simply brilliant !

[@ramiahgopalkrishna2024]

Pose a similar question, what alternative did the Hamas/ palastine s had except to launch this attack in face of stubborn and arrogant refusal of the Israel backed by the western white supramiscts to ignore their just demands for their land.

[@Suresh_Kamath]

This is what is put in satirical publication Onion. "'The Onion' Stands With Israel Because It Seems Like You Get In Less Trouble For That"

[@user_ar6332]

By hurting innocent civilians, women and children and even babies. Hamas has lost the sympathy of the world. If it had been a purely military attack, they would have had more support.

[@inammir1979]

@@user_ar6332 like you had any sympathy for them before this attack...

[@tvwatcher5938]

@@user_ar6332What do you think the Zionists have been doing for 73 years but their propaganda machine has won hearts, like yours, perhaps!

[@Suresh_Kamath]

@anuradharaghavan1 when the Israeli army has been hurting women an children for decades, why do you still sympathize with them? This has been continuing for decades and the world does not fo anything about their plight. The same western powers that are supplying weapons to Ukraine to fight occupiers are providing weapons to Israel that is occupying Palestine land.

[@kalyansinghal5557]

Karan Thapar at his best. I live in America and I find that this is one of best programs on this issue in any country.

[@emotionalIntelligence2078]

Justice to a Palestine State should be followed like the ultimatum given to Gaza civilians. Israel cannot have it both ways for Jewish fanatics. - Israel should tell itself and its people about the flip side(long- term issue) of the War. - Apart from How/ When, the 2nd question arises in the conscience : *Why Israel continues to be under threat/ Why there is no peace?!* - Hamas actually never was wiped out despite several similar bombings & raids. It won't happen this time too. New recruits are getting ready as it raids gaza today. The present ones similarly joined as they were raided and delrived too. - Peace will be a rarity in Israel unless it doesn't subscribe to 2 state. Its own civil society is fed up with radical right wing interference in daily lives. Their hate spewed actions put israel tourists on target around the world or targets of criticism.

[@archiem654]

Does arab world agrees to a two state solution? Didnt they reject the un plan? And decided to wage a war against israel. We dont know what these people want. I think religious fanatics exist on both sides.

[@fredrickdemello2260]

Yesterday's interview of Gideon Levy was really good. Keep it up

[@MrBigBlaster001]

Karan Thapar is absolutely genius,a perfect interview ,wow

[@nandlalchogal7508]

Thanks Karan for another wonderful interview.

[@muneerahmedadiladil9059]

The only alternative is the establishment of an independent Palestinian state.

[@Myanmartiger921]

Another Pakistan like will be formed

[@pointtobenotedyespointtobe2762]

​@@Myanmartiger921terrorist red handed spotted 😂

[@EoamerGaming97]

@@pointtobenotedyespointtobe2762 kid this is not some middle east country, Cope or leave. Im an opposition guy but foreign poilicy has NOTHING to do with local politics.

[@pradeenkrishnag2368]

Which was offered 5 times by Israelis, but the Palestinians rejected it 5 times. It is not a geopolitical matter. It is more of religion than politics if you study it carefully.

[@muneerahmedadiladil9059]

The truth is Israel came into being in the name of religion just like Pakistan.

[@arunlahori6898]

The guest is A SAVAGE 😡

[@cafewaves]

And Hamas are quite civilised?:)

[@peacelover7000]

OMG a JUSTICE minister? God Save the innocent people on both sides!

[@Waltznumber2]

A very honest interview - a rarity in this age

[@AftabKhan-lg8uc]

Karan you questions are very relevant

[@cafewaves]

Are you Karans IT cell?:)

[@HasanAhmed-ki8yh]

There is an alternative. Most obvious is to END the brutal occupation

[@12345678966607]

DYNAMIC ANCHOR OF INDIA ''KARAN THAPAR''

[@vyseerx]

Hamas had breached the borders of Israel and killed hundreds of civilians -with out warning ( caught them off guard )with air strikes and terrorists coming in mechanized air gliders and killing Israelis who are celebrating ( videos available). Is this acceptable? Hamas or any terror organization should realize that there would be consequences for a terror act. Why play victim card after being an aggressor to begin with ? I hope better sense prevails and cease fire happens so that millions escape suffering , displacement, loss of loved ones.

[@gamechanger0656]

right

[@kishoretejaswi1948]

Shalom, Yossi... I wish there were more people like you. Forget the Ben-Eliezer thing.. you still speak the truth.. and do so always... I wish there were more like you.. Sensible people. Not mindless hawks.

[@shagulhameedfakhruddin733]

Awesome questions Mr. Karan. Other media fear to speak

[@gulabh]

Justice minister and Israel exposed.

[@judefernandez4932]

Karan is bold and fearless as a lion!

[@gamechanger0656]

LOL..........Biggest JOKE

[@loretoanthony]

I agree with the interviewee

[@AdiRosli]

You should suggest to him for Israel to start negotiate with the Palestinian towards agreeing two state independent state in which Israel must stop the occupation, oppression, allow Palestine to return the land n dignity!!

[@OmNamahhShivay]

When it comes to Armenia & Azerbaijan , there is no solution so called as Two State Solution for Ngorno Karabakh. But when it comes to Palestine, there is always an advice for it.

[@urmila16]

Where is the Palestinian leadership? Arafat pulled out repeatedly when solutions were in sight.

[@waseemraja8968]

I m very good fan of urs , U r the real representative of journalism .very wel done sir .

[@reloadedseban1]

Great to see him answer honestly even if he knew the answer would not be liked ..

[@ahmedjooma2880]

Netenyahu published a map at the UN that included Gaza, West Bank and Golan Heights as part of Israel. So how does this interviewee say that Israel does not want Gaza?

[@Peaceful_World130]

Gaza ko ab Israel control karega taki phirse waha hamas atankwadi waha na aaye

[@NoToWokesOrReligious]

Muslims should think of a better negotiation. Give Mecca and take Gaza

[@megroslmegr7504]

@@NoToWokesOrReligious cluless Indian

[@jennyloubhiwandiwalla3368]

Always watched your interviews. Frank and brave and candid, the questions you ask. I appreciate you don't take sides and are not biased. And I appreciate that you speak English well. Grammatically and diction.

[@elainetuki3206]

I visited a Christian church in the USA that blew the shofar to come to worship. It is so powerful! I would think that blowing shofar sounds around the world right now would ignite healing, hope and love for our Lord

[@navdeepwalia4317]

We support you sir

[@danishahmadmsw]

Israelis will pay the price in future for sure. Remember all the crusades what was the outcome.

[@adas19581024]

Cannot agree more

[@yaseenraza7310]

Excellent explain sir g

[@miniammakc8291]

So there is going to be no end to Palastenien problem.They were in the land when Israel was formed.Gaza strip and West Bank should be given to thebPalastenians whith full sovriegnity to them. They have every right to live as anyone else.

[@neelakantaraopanda7316]

Thank you for the interview

[@AP-do8mi]

Thanks Karan Thappar for your blunt questions.

[@SM-kd9iw]

plz interview indian expert on such geopolitical issue. As common indian we are confused by our social media opinions on india's stand as nation

[@inmyopinion651]

The problem is Gaza is made up of young people with average age of 18 means there will always be a resistance group. Call it Hamas or any name they choose later but I think Israel has a goal that is not possible. The young people see the PA as conspiring with the enemy. Yossi is right in fact there is no easy answer. There is no military solution to this problem.

[@paradigmnnf]

And do you fit the atrocities for the last 2 decades with an illegal occupation of the Palestinian land?

[@vivek1raja]

Israel wants neither a one state solution or a two state solution - that’s all hog wash. They want all the land from the Jordan river to the Mediterranean sea and they will keep settling jews from all over in these occupied lands till the Palestininans will be left with no choice but to leave.

[@nasirqureshi1785]

Karan you should have asked him whether the continued occupation of West Bank would naturally lead to reaction in Gaza, which happened. Then , for seventeen years Gaza has been the world's largest open air prison. Why not ask this ?

[@drvbgogte]

ONE WONDERS AT THE THICKNESSES OF KARAN THAPARS SKIN

[@vijayalakshmi1948]

You have kept me glued to your programme

[@ParthaRoyChowdhury]

The pain of being an Israeli today, that too a former Minister of Justice - while the world could still overlook the misdeeds of the "Animals", it keenly awaits the deeds of the "Civilized Humans" ...

[@vijayghatage5780]

Right now I am reading O'jerusalem,by Dominique la Pierre, and Larry Collins. Terrific and horrible miseries for these people of that region.Yahudies , Arabs, immediately after 14/5/1948. Sad part is that both warring parties are still continuing to follow that holocaust. God save Israel and Palestine.

[@RoyFelix-m7t]

Thanks Karan, very well done interview.

[@wenderis]

Yossi Beilin is a moderately sane voice in this. He's certainly bias, like all of us, but he is not a right wing nutjob. From what I can gathered thru my Jewish and Israeli friends, his view is shared among many centrist in Israel and beyond. Sadly, the Israeli government, even after an emergency coalition, would not be this moderate.

[@zalelegaming]

Israel ❤❤❤❤

[@rbanyal]

The former Justice minister of Israel sounds more like a minister of revenge :-(

[@thetroll1887]

Revenge is must now to teach islamic terrorists not mess with progressive people. not to create terror organisations or support them

[@anshuraj4277]

Their people died by terror attack

[@rbanyal]

@@anshuraj4277 What led to this terror attack? I am not justifying the violence, just asking?

[@anshuraj4277]

@@rbanyal Islamist barbarism Before U complain about blockade Remember... Egypt blockades too Why should Israel help terrorists They could have elected PLO.. BUT no.. They chose hamas

[@rbanyal]

@@anshuraj4277 Not the blockade alone. IDF atrocities, illegal settlements, detention and inhuman treatments, denial of basic rights. People of Palestine have been prisoners in their own home land since 1948. BTW, who propped up Hamas and helped destroy PLO.

[@71samrath]

Mr Beilin seems like a decent guy, hopefully most powerful men are like this.. May be I have to be powerful and take care of stuff

[@noorchaudhry976]

Please ask him { Stop} New development on occupied land. (2) show your country’s boundaries. (3) why don’t you act upon 2 state formula.

[@matthewjoseph7671]

Karan: The Name of the US Secy of State is Antony Blinken and NOT Antony "CLINTON " 🙃

[@deccanheart]

Justice Minister is not talking about Justice - just how Justice should be meted out to the Palestinians (who have NO justice).

[@84qwe84]

Is this man for real.??????

[@shamimkhan4349]

Intelligent questions by Karan Thapar

[@naseemfirdaus1789]

A big tragedy is in the offing. Why did it come to this? Because of the cunning British. They are the ones who should be made to pay for this devastating situation.

[@akhilghag5898]

Show me 1 video where Palestinians are criticizing Hamas.

[@shaikabdulkareem7822]

Truth will prevail.❤

[@dsrao7288]

"With due respect, had I known I would not have told you!" What an answer. I am sure, KT must have learnt a few lessons from this interview.

[@MrPeaceGuy54]

Many things are known but asked anyway for the benefit of the listeners.

[@rajeshjk06]

This answer from him showed his intellect and shrewd acumen.

[@nraphael9004]

He is indeed a no nonsense man...!

[@akbarkhalidi1750]

Hamas came to existence through public services. It is a religious organisation. Islam insists that we do not take injustice lying, rather face it our lives. If all the current members of hamas are eliminated and Israel continues with its savagory, other Palestinian will take over. So rest assure, mr x minister you are not going to get away with your crimes.

[@farrukotech]

Shameless people, asking people to leave their homes. It's annoying to even put a comment, simply wait for the return from Almighty.

[@mohammedmurtaza3257]

Alternative as per the UN partition plan implement it, stop bulling, cutting down trees, stop illegal occupation, stop settlements.

[@razahussaini5468]

Your settlements are illegal

[@shahidmeir7379]

does Israel has "Justice Minister" what a joke.

[@maikshah5014]

The cruelty and killing of innocent Palestinians don't you think that is crime and and terrorist acts

[@babajikaghanta8842]

I still support Palestinian freedom struggle against oppression from Israel.

[@Toca-rainbowfantasy]

Violence is not the solution. No matter how much right you are. You cannot correct one wrong with another.

[@saskiademoor8400]

Israel PLEASE stop the violence immediately

[@Zeus11223]

He talking like Hitler. Pharoah long gone Hitler long gone

[@pselvara3355]

The savagery started in 1948 when 500 Palestinian villages were raised to the ground and the population was expelled from Israel prosper and expelled to Gaza, Lebanon, Jordan and the West Bank.

[@loretoanthony]

No killing of innocents in a situation like this would be extremely hard and to the detriment of Israel and Palestine

[@siddhu75]

People talk of two state solution - what are the two states? Hamas doesn't want two state solution and has killed 100s of Fatah/PLO people who are the recognised representatives of Palestinians (including by various governments in India since Nehru).

[@vivek1raja]

Sure just keep blaming the Palestinians. So if Fatah are the goog guys why is Israel still steaking land in the occupied west bank on a daily basis?

[@siddhu75]

@@vivek1raja Keep equating Hamas with Palestinians and you will keep losing everyone who supports the Palestinians with respect to what Israel is doing in the West Bank. Egypt is the largest Arab country and even it considers Hamas such a nuisance that it has blocked Gaza from the south.

[@essamshaikh7928]

Mr thapar will you ask justice minister why they are not giving back their land.

[@nalinthakar7059]

Aap chronology samajhiye: Holocaust: 1933-1944 Perpetrators: Nazi Germans Victims: Jews Holocaust 2:0 1948-2023-ongoing Perpetrators: Zionist Jews Victims: Original Palestinians. The only difference being:- * The Victims in first case are taking revenge on third party; while the victims in second case are fighting back. *In first case; world was oblivious to the happenings; while in current one, the world has become a mute spectator.

[@PrasadHalebidu]

If only Karan Thapar showed the same concern when Kashmiri Hindus were being driven out of Kashmir !

[@MrPeaceGuy54]

There is no indication that he had not done so. His 2019 article in Hindustan Times shows that he clearly condemns what had happened. At the same time, bringing voices that aren't heard by most is not a terrible idea.

[@paris2993]

If only your Hindu ministers showed the same concern for Manipur when it is still burning. Wudnt it be amritkali for such a gud act Mr. If only.

[@loneranger4469]

So I take it that you agree that Israel commited war crime by driving out Palestinians from their homeland.

[@vanithav7339]

Kashmir, Manipur - same story. We are biggest hypocrites. We are unable to defend our land and giving such huge lectures to Israel for trying to defend it’s people.

[@MrPeaceGuy54]

@@vanithav7339 We are also going to become hypocrites if we look at only one side. The consequences of no water and electricity in a land where around 40% of people are not even adults are not going to be pleasant-and this is after the colonies that have already been built. Also, th8e Islamic world needs to come out of the delusion that trying to destroy Israel is a good idea (and the UAE and Saudi Arabia appeared to have understood this).

[@sujoymukherjee1930]

Yes there is an alternative, lift the 16_year blockade of Gaza

[@cpvk]

Great channel

[@renzo6490]

How do you prevent something that is inevitable?

[@attudapatus]

An eye for an eye will make the world blind

[@NoToWokesOrReligious]

If one population thinks all non-believer's eyes be poked in the name of God and is their duty and other population believes an eye for an eye is not good then it will make good population alone loose eyes

[@gangadharhiremath7306]

"Crazy savage ppl.." Isrealis were angels all these years? How many Palestinians killed by Israel in the last ten years?And How many Israelis killed by Hama's at the same time?

[@As-zc3kt]

This is all। about West white superimist, thank you for exposing hypocrite s

[@hassobhatia990]

Smart person like Karan asking stupid questions of the ex minister, who is being reasonable..

[@youknow6968]

Israeli logic is a joke 😂, truly twisted.

[@mrj-zl2m]

One vlog on Black September

[@shahihamdan2803]

Some time i am horrifying how much courage Karan sir has.

[@temp1851]

Great interview and the genuine views of the israelis.

[@Sureshkumar58123]

Sir You must have to ask him that how can a legitimate army behave like a militia OR a bunch of war lords ?

[@rpsoni1088]

Karan Thapar, how much money you get for biased interviews

[@krisgopi_8]

Hardly people will listen him Gone are the days when people had time to listen .