No Birthright Citizenship for H1B Holders’ Children in US; Indians Hit Hard

[@Tirumala77]

మీరు చాలా జాగ్రత్తగా రిపోర్టు చేస్తున్నారు. నాణ్యమైన, ప్రామాణికమైన రిపోర్టింగ్.

[@nageswararaoavasarala7603]

మీ విడియోలు అన్ని బావుంటాయి రమేషు గారు.

[@saiprasadgadiraju3523]

We appreciate your genuineness sir.

[@bvkksprakasaraju4993]

Dear Ramesh Garu Some times it may happen You are corrected immediately Very nice of you Your analysis and information in Telugu excellent ThankYou

[@nandakishoreanagani3050]

Also I think what President Trump has taken is the correct decision because of our children US citizens are loosing the seats which is same as KCR asked for separate Telangana. At that time people said good thing for KCR now when it comes against them now it feels the pain.

[@venugopaladivivenugopal8592]

నేను ట్రంప్ మాట్లాడింది విన్నాను. ఆటోమేటిక్ బర్త్ రైట్ రాదు అని చెప్పాడు. గ్రీన్ కార్డ్ హోల్డర్స్ కి మినహాయింపు ఉన్నట్లు చెప్పలేదు. మీరు కరెక్ట్.

[@satyanarayanamurthy2102]

మీరు సూపర్ సార్ చాలా నుంచి మీ వీడియోలు చూస్తున్నాను సార్ నాకు ఎవరూ నచ్చరు మీరు తప్ప

[@subramanyaml3680]

You are 99.999% correct sir.

[@rameshbandi5976]

There is no skewed reporting by you sir. There is skewed judgements and blatant violations . Your analysis is an analysis without bias.

[@sivaramakrishnaprasad3509]

Thank you .Good knowledgeable Information.

[@nani6520]

Sir American supreme court lo unna 9 judges lo 6-3 Republican majority undi ,,, and aa 6 judges lo 3 of them were appointed by Trump himself during his first tenure,,, this will have a huge impact on decision of supreme court

[@MrcRao58]

Good point

[@kum48188]

Ramesh garu, The quality of your reporting is extremely exceptional.💕

[@bvkksprakasaraju4993]

Expecting Stay order Ramesh Garu Yes

[@sridharguntupalli9867]

Ramesh garu always gives crystal clear information 👌👏👍

[@janardhangala977]

Very good job. Nicely presented with facts and figures

[@mvrameshbabu]

చాలా మంచి నిర్ణయం..

[@doctoranjaneyulu3875]

Humble as usual.

[@chetan8395]

In my opinion it is right decision. Its their democracy they have every right to do whom they want to give. Even though it hurts some in larger interestes it is good

[@sriranganaidu6222]

@@chetan8395 Larger interest, right decision antu pedda pedda words ye use chesav 😂😂.. Youngster 20-25 years lo USA ki velthe, Prime age lo valla tho work cheyinchu ko ni, Valla ni 60 years vachhaka get out anadam.. Valla ki puttina pilla 25-30 years varaku USA lo perigina valla nu get out anadam larger interest, good aah 😂😂.. Dhani ni exploit cheyadam antaru.. USA lo putti, USA lo ney 20-30 years perigina vadi ni vellipomanadam inhuman antaru..

[@rameshbandi5976]

An excellent analysis and an view point.

[@reddypoguvijayaraju]

Excellent declaration

[@kalyany7134]

That’s correct. I was closely observing this

[@kiranmainelakurti4786]

You were right about this news in you last video also. In my husband's company they all got this news in detail point by point stating all new executive orders. All that we can expect is a stay on this birth right act as of now. That will help us stay stress less.

[@ratnapagadala764]

Upto schooling absolutely no problem. Fees etc issues will start only from under graduation

[@vengampallidhananjaya8978]

Good after noon sir your super correct

[@manimohandas]

As per my knowledge Real draft is "Among the categories of individuals born in the United States and not subject to the jurisdiction thereof, the privilege of United States citizenship does not automatically extend to persons born in the United States: (1) when that person's mother was unlawfully present in the United States and the father was not a United States citizen or lawful permanent resident at the time of said person's birth, or (2) when that person's mother's presence in the United States at the time of said person's birth was lawful but temporary (such as, but not limited to, visiting the United States under the auspices of the Visa Waiver Program or visiting on a student, work, or tourist visa) and the father was not a United States citizen or lawful permanent resident at the time of said person's birth," the order says. Mani Mohan Das

[@UnbornWarrior123]

Great video...

[@itscarcontrolvicky4478]

Very good

[@potharajukrishnaveni5646]

I don't agree we are not that greedy for money, we can do wonders if we stay in India.

[@manimohandas]

According to the drafting understanding I know, it is not clear that these birthright provisions apply only to those born from now on. I really like your political analysis Ramesh garu. Mani Mohan Das

[@g.raghavendranaidu864]

Mi video correct ga vuntai Ramesh garu

[@gchennak]

Your analysis was correct. All Supreme Court judges are nominated by trump. So this case definitely favor to trump.

[@maheshpeddykudi5009]

H1 lottery is only 65k per year? How can 2.7 lacks go?

[@MohanReddy-kg3fl]

Good explanation. Most of what you said is correct Mr. Kandula. "Lawsuits filed by immigration attorneys"? No. Lawsuits are filed by more than 20 state attorney generals (democratic states). Note here, US is union of states. States have lot more independence and the state laws over-ride federal laws in some instances. In contrast, India is one country sub-divided into states for administrative convenience. So, the federal laws govern in India.

[@balajich7298]

only US has birth right citizenship. In Europe no country does this.

[@sucharithapulivarthy484]

అవును అండి F 1,H1 వారు పెళ్లి చేసుకొని కని సిటిజెన్ కావాలి అనుకోవటం చాలా తప్పు, మరి మనం వెళ్లి పోటీ పడి usa సిటిజెన్ కి చాలా నష్టం

[@chethireddysai]

Adee court lo nilabadadhuu

[@rao8714]

There is no auto citizenship by birth to illegal immigrants. And within legal H1, F1 and tourist visa. Who is eligible with in legal citizens is either of parent having citizenship or green card.

[@vmnetnet8793]

India passed the citizenship amendment act in 2019. This act appears to sideline some section of the people but it is accepted. India does things for it's own interests and so will any other country. Regarding the birth right citizenship exec order, it will come to effect 30days after the bill was signed. So atleast until a court upholds it it will be a law until Trump is the president. For a constitutional amendment it appears challenging as it needs 75% approval in both the houses and also 75% of states need to approve it. The Supreme Court has already given a verdict on the "and subject to the jurisdiction thereof" a long time ago that except kids of diplomats or foreign soldiers any other kid born on the US soil is an american citizen. The question is, will the Supreme interpret differently on the same issue now? No one knows the answer!

[@syamala54]

Is it a restorative effect!

[@harshaprasadsrustu98]

Hello Sir, We kindly request your team to correct the thumbnail for this video. It is showing incorrect thumbnail. I am sorry to point this out, as we like your analysis. Thank you andi.

[@dhittenttRT41]

Just now, Trump announced that he is in favour of H1B visas

[@ManiNaiduMedasani]

👏👏

[@kancharlakrishnarao8060]

రమేష్ గారు Trump ఇచ్చిన excutive order ను excute చేయాలంటే 1858 లో జరిగిన రాజ్యాంగ సవరణను తిరిగి సవరించాలంటే బహుశా republicans కు ప్రస్తుతం ఉన్న బలం సరిపోదు కాబట్టి ఇది జరగడానికి అవకాశం లేదు అని చాలా మంది అభిప్రాయపడుతున్నారు.

[@Vinjas-s7b]

Merru cheppindi correct

[@Rraj88]

In telugu states it becomes status symbol to study or work in USA. Even parents are forcing to go to America.

[@GopalKrishna-b9t]

Good sir

[@prolives2067]

తెలుగు రాష్ట్రాల్లో ని పిల్లల అమెరికా కాలో వున్నారు, ఇప్పడు వారి తల్లిదండ్రులు తీవ్ర భయంతో వున్నారు,ప్రస్తుతం మీడియాలో దీన్ని గురించి ఊహాగానాలు, వక్ర భాష్యా లు, కూడా ఉంటున్నాయి, కాబట్టి మీరు దయ చేసి, మాకు ఈ విషయం మీద లోతైన పరిశీలనతో వీడియోస్ చెయ్యగలరు,,🙏

[@arunagiribabut6286]

Judiciary becomes a puupet for pklitrical and billioneers

[@krishnachandkaripineni9808]

H-1b not in this category .

[@ajaybabucherukuri1813]

They can just exempt for H1B Visa holders

[@nandakishoreanagani3050]

Sir in ur Video u said that for children who born here and if they don’t get citizenship it will be difficult for them to get the admission in schools. As per me its not true because we have moved here recently on H1 and I got the admission for my 6yr old kid in just 3 days after we have taken the house and also there will be same treatment from the school as they treat the citizens here there is no difference and also they provide everything same and also they don’t ask for ur visa status of the child also. I am sure this will be there till high school level

[@RameshKandula]

Assuming that it is so at pre-college level, you will find that visa holders' children will find it increasingly difficult to get admissions into good schools (by which I mean college and university) later.

[@sucharithapulivarthy484]

కానీ usa సిటిజెన్ కి jobs ఇచ్చిన తరువాత మనకు ఇవ్వ మనండి IT jobs మన ఇండియన్స్ ఎక్కువ ఉన్నారు అందుకే గన్ షూట్స్ ఎక్కువ అయి నాయి

[@potharajukrishnaveni5646]

Crores our indians are giving them.

[@radhanandigam9270]

What happens to already born children to H1B visa holders

[@gajawadakishan7680]

ట్రంప్ తీసుకున్న నిర్ణయం ఒక విధంగా మంచిది ఎందుకంటే మన పాత జనరేషన్ అమెరికా అమెరికా లో స్థిరపడి ఇన్ని రోజులు అనుభవించారు ఇప్పుడు ఈ తరం వాళ్లకు చాన్స్ వచ్చింది ఇది మంచిదే కదా ఎప్పుడు వాళ్లే అనుభవించాలంటే ఎలా కుదురుతుంది

[@sriranganaidu6222]

This order is absurd, few examples are Atleast Already H1B midha undi pregnant tho unna valla ni exclude cheyalisindi.. Ala ney already H1B midha unna parents already childrens undi again future lo another child ki birth ichhina exclude cheyalisindi as giving citizenship for 1 child and asking another child to leave country is cruelty.. There are lot of flaws in order

[@IdoCareForPeople]

So niku benefit iyye la law rayala? Migata vallu elala chachina niku badha ledu....

[@sriranganaidu6222]

@@IdoCareForPeople I just pointed out the absurdity in law.. Meegatha vallu yela chachhina Naaku badha ledu ani neeku yevaru chepparu tammudu.. Enduku drama create chestunnav 😂😂

[@IdoCareForPeople]

​@ there is nothign absurd about it.... what would have been absurd is if the law made exception for h1B pregnent women... why ? emi J1, F1, L1 minda pregant undara...? i have seen this entitled behaviour from visa holders... anduke respond iyyanu... what you asked for is outright stupid...

[@sriranganaidu6222]

@@IdoCareForPeople Nenu male ani comment chesthe, Nuvvu matram ye male aah, Nannu female or third gender antava aah ani nuvvu comment chesthe, nenu em cheptha tammudu.. Nenu casual gaa H1B ni refer chesa enduku ante dhani midha yekkuva discussion avtundi ani.. Comment section lo naa thoughts anni fill cheya lenu kabatti casual gaa H1B annanu.. Balance antha nuvvu imagination chesukunnav anthe.. Nee name lo @idocareforpeople tisesi, “lokulu kakulu” ani pettuko..

[@rameshbandi5976]

Is it prospective or retrospective like in India many are retrospective.

[@RameshKandula]

Prospective. It's there in the video.

[@nagendranadella6699]

I don't think whatever trumps excutive orders may be challenged in the supreme court, by opposition. Jagan also issued so many GO s finally all disqualified.

[@dhittenttRT41]

22 US states, where Democrats are in power, approached Top courts ,opposing Trump's order on birthright citizenship

[@kongaranandakumaar8910]

H1 visa 30-35 ఏండ్లు వయసు ఉన్న వారికిఅమెరికాలో జన్మించిన పిల్లలకు అమెరికన్ పౌరసత్వం వచ్చినా, డాన్ని ఆధారం చేసుకొని ,తల్లిదండ్రులు (తల్లిదండ్రుల visa కొనసాగకపోతే) అక్కడ నివసించడానికి వీలుకాదు గదా! తల్లిదండ్రులతో పాటుగా పిల్లలు స్వదేశానికి రావలసిందే కదా! పిల్లలు మేజర్లు అయినాక, వారు అమెరికాలో నివసించుటకు వీలౌతుంది. తరువాత పిల్లలు అమెరికా వెళ్ళి, తల్లిదండ్రులకు (అప్పటికి వారి వయసు 55-60 ఉంటుంది )అమెరికన్ పౌరసత్వం ఇప్పించి, అక్కడికి తీసికెళ్ళినా ఉపయోగం ఏమీ ఉండదు.

[@SrinivasaRaoVemulakonda-l2b]

Eppudu e rule newly married couple's or who are planning for kids to apply right?

[@venkateswarlukancharla5259]

In this 30 days c sections may increase in Indian population who are near delivery date who are on H1b and other types who are not having green card or citizenship

[@Vinjas-s7b]

US lo doctors dabbula Kosam c section cheyaru .. but cheppalem mana Bally edaina route kannukuntaru

[@grangarao40]

Either parent must be a citizen or green Card holder and either parent should not be an illegal immigrant. There are some categories of people like diplomats, airlines staff and maritime staff who are not subject to the jurisdiction of US ( such people are governed by international conventions like diplomatic immunity under the Vienna Convention) and babies born to such parents are not entitled to birthright citizenship. The main point here is that babies born on and after 20 February 2025 will not get birthright citizenship. If such babies have to travel, they need to apply for their native nation passport. If the court sets aside the Executive Order, then those babies have to surrender the native country passport. Requirement of military service may not be correct because you cannot join the military if you are not a citizen. Aliens cannot join the military in any country. You are talking about unborn babies which is misleading and unnecessary.

[@kiranmainelakurti4786]

I wish u can do a video in lgbtq in USA. How that is so trending California. How kids are getting effected in schools.Many other social elements. This is going to be a threat to USA itself. I live in Bay area my daughter is middle schooler and I'm already seeing these things around her in school. If kids don't address their transgender teacher they/them, that's it that r done😂😂

[@madhavijoshi481]

Almost cllarity icharusir

[@venkateswarareddychitte2782]

From which date , implementation will start?Some body says it will be implemented from February 2025.

[@karthik9272]

Feb 20

[@enugantisrinivasu2826]

👍👌

[@balajich7298]

Peeda poindhi. Chalaa mandhi Travel risk unna pregnants kooda velli pre mature delivery's kooda avuthunnayi.

[@ravikumarsirigudi9686]

What about the children who are born and granted citizenship before this order was signed, will the citizenship be cancelled , the parents are having green card issued in December 2023.

[@MrcRao58]

No retrospective effect Only future application

[@nani6520]

Sir simple ga white house lo pettina executive order chusthe accurate ga vastundi kada sir

[@potharajukrishnaveni5646]

What about eb5 visas

[@MrHymarao]

It would be better if you take the quote from American newspaper. For example, Wall Street newspaper published this executive order in detail. That confirms the real news. However your comments are exactly reflective of Trump’s new executive order on citizenship

[@radhakrishnaupadhyayula3617]

Sir H1B ki వర్తించదు అన్నది నా అవగాహన. మీరన్నట్టు మరో సారి చూసి మమ్మల్ని guide చేయండి

[@reset.india20]

Better not to go to USA for studies and save around 60Lacs

[@bharathkumar19]

Ee president executive orders iccheroo ,next vacchy president malli marchi inko executive orders istharu sir,,

[@maheshpeddykudi5009]

Still ur wrong.... as court haven't given verdict on it

[@krishnapabba2355]

Correct the thumbnail please 😊

[@RameshKandula]

What is the problem?

[@muddusathyanarayanagangapu3114]

Sir what happens to the baby born before Jan 19th 2025 , will they get american passport??

[@RameshKandula]

Yes.

[@HyderabadInfra]

not all indians

[@arunak2682]

Already h1 visa born vallaki em ledandi only effective from feb 20 or 1 st

[@skommaraju]

Ramesh Garu, we trust your news best among best in Telugu social media. Do not understand Trump decision on H1B holders. This is against Elan Musk strategy on Population Demographics.

[@KameshUpadhyayula]

Kandula variki kandhala variki teda emiti

[@potharajukrishnaveni5646]

Emi undavu asalu thagguthayi, present lo bathukutharu

[@Kutami333]

Vachi india ni develope chesukondi

[@KameshUpadhyayula]

Jai bheem jai bharath

[@saiprasadgadiraju3523]

What about already born babies sir

[@harshsud9924]

Nothing will happen to them.

[@cherukururuthwik2347]

Every law is prospective hence no worries , any law cannot be retrospective unless if they have any constitutional issues happy ha Nidra poo

[@Coloratura43]

Please make video about Fake Telugu IT Experience People

[@vedasyatapasvi4914]

jeethalu saganiki padipovali,america lo udyogam chestunnamani akasam lo yeguru thunnaru ,valla pogaru anachali,vallanu nela mediki dinchali

[@kingking-uj7mp]

Africa lone evadam ledu.trump zambia ni fallow avutunnadu

[@kanthmy981]

India lo reservations dismiss chesthanu anii bodi gadu sign chesthe em avuthundhoo akkada e trump gadu chesindhi kida same so dont worry guys nothing will happen.

[@potharajukrishnaveni5646]

American economy inka down

[@kanakadurgadantu5469]

Suthi waste vaagudu.

[@bssp815]

నేను మాట్లాడింది అంతా కరెక్ట్ అవ్వాల్సిన అవసరం లేదు.. కొన్ని సార్లు తప్పులు కూడా దొర్లాయి.. అని ఈ వ్యాఖ్యత ఈ వీడియోలో అన్నారు.. అంటే గతంలో వైఎస్ జగన్ మోహన్ రెడ్డిని దోషిగా చూపిస్తూ.. అనేక వీడియోల్లో ఈయన వ్యాఖ్యలు చేశారు.. వాటిల్లో కూడా తప్పులు దొర్లి ఉండాలి కదా!!

[@Chowdary.Thumati]

ఇప్పుడు వాడి గురించి ఎందుకు బ్రదర్....

[@sudarsanaraokomma9244]

అయ్యుండొచ్చు?

[@Rraj88]

Kasko iskisko.

[@SuryaD-i8o]

Yes , tappu ite correct chesi cheptadule

[@jayalakshmigavirneni8434]

Minimum two years India nundi okkaru kooda USA ki study kosam vellakandi, appudu USA loni univercities money leka moota padatayi , appudu chachinatlu Indians ni invaite cheystundi USA anni soukaryalu kalpistundi.

[@Tirumala77]

మీరు చాలా జాగ్రత్తగా రిపోర్టు చేస్తున్నారు. నాణ్యమైన, ప్రామాణికమైన రిపోర్టింగ్.