Nooran Makhdoom Answers Every Question You Ever Asked About Tere Bin | Haute Talk

[@sassiahmed6818]

The way in which Amna is indirectly trying to educate her on her absurd flawed writing and illusionary justification of harmful concepts is so sophisticated and respectful... We love you Amna❤❤❤

[@uswa1383]

Really , I observed it.

[@shaguftaaziz517]

suberb Aamna

[@sairarahim9052]

Amna is gem of a person she's so educated sophisticated and polished she tried to convey her message in a very polite way but to the point .

[@wannatopnotch]

​@@sairarahim9052 Most bad written character in pk tv do you think its meerab?

[@saima019]

Yes amna is gem well educated women ..and meantality level is peak.... Amna plz it's request...plz yumna nd wahaj ko bulaye ......

[@tehniyatahsan354]

This is how educated people interact with people they have a difference in opinion. Amna handled the interview beautifully. Asked all the hard hitting questions with a touch of humor and gave the guest the due respect 👏🙏👍💕

[@anikacutipie5237]

This is called respect 🥰🥰bd people ki tara toxic or criticism nehi karta

[@IQVLOGz]

Creative criticism is necessary so proper content can get promoted, No doubt Nooran’s writing had flaws, but that doesn’t mean to degrade her in an interview… One must know how to value the difference of ideas and opinions n yet scrutinize them constructively…Nooran at the end of day was the writer to the massively popular #TereBin so applause to her but hopefully she learns n focuses more to improve her upcoming content be it Season 2 or any other venture… I may not be the target audience to her other projects but #TereBin did bring in viewers so her story along with #WahajAli and Yumna created some of sizzling shorts directed by SerajulHaq which will be cherished for years to come…

[@sumanchander1692]

After watching the writer of Tere Bin and her intellect I am convinced that Tere Bin has reached its height only because of Yumna, Wahaj & the director of this drama.

[@shifatnaz2476]

100%

[@sharmoalvi1240]

yes

[@shahmanz]

Nooran is cunning

[@humarizvi3471]

Yes

[@narjisrubab872]

💯👍

[@Chocoscupp]

Drama was hit because of writer too the way she wrote the character Murtasim captured our heart and all those romantic scenes which enhanced the drama and of course the chemistry created by yumhaj. So lets give equal credit to all of them. Yes there were some mistakes too but overall we enjoyed the journey. Hoping best for #TereBin2.

[@manobillimiaon]

In an interview Wahaj told that the character of murtasim was written full of violence originally but wahaj changed a lot of scenes as he did not agreed to them

[@harleenkaur3510]

Amna tried hard to direct the discussion towards intellectual aspects. But Nooran is a person with regressive mindset, and it is reflected from her writing and how she barely touch the surface of issues that needed addressal

[@ashmash4563]

💯

[@radharao1711]

Amna, you were extremely gracious and balanced throughout the interview. Very subtly and politely you addressed the inadequacies in the script. 😊

[@anayakhan2412]

The most awaited IV in the history of something haute. Nooran Makhdoom VS Aamna Isani😂 I must say she is daring😂

[@anayakhan2412]

​@@AyeshaMazhar-i kind of agree with you. Hassan should have done this interview

[@Victoryput]

Very daring!!

[@Victoryput]

​@@ashdwer4719Because Aamna is a lady in the truest sense. Apne show main bulake kya gali degi!

[@itshasan2687]

​@@Victoryputexactly 💯 guest ko respectfully grill Krna tha.....bezati to nhi karni thi.....even hasan would have done the same, maybe wo itne calm nhi hote but beizzat to koi nhi karega na

[@Victoryput]

@@itshasan2687 Aur Aamna within a certain limit, Jo Jo puchna hain sab puch toh liya but Noora Makdum is behaving in a very obtuse manner toh kya kar sakta hain koi. She cannot shake Noora Makdum and ask ki why did you murder the storyline as the show progressed. Hope Noora Makdum will be more careful next time around. This serial is a blockbuster because of Wahaj and Yumna's screen presence and acting. Nothing else to say about it.

[@faranizainab1797]

Hats off to Aamna’s patience 😂 She’s way too intellectual for the writers IQ

[@shaguftaaziz517]

true

[@azrana8379]

بلکل یہی بات محسوس ھوئی خورے کس طرح برداشتکیا امنہ نے ساڈے ولوں اس بی بی کی لکھائی واے ڈرامے دا جوابا ھیگا چلو ہن اگے ٹرو 😂

[@elite5489]

So so true

[@safiakadir7695]

This is a fundamentally a disrespectful post. Sorry. She created a romantic hero loved by the world. Then she made a few mistakes and everyone is ready to stone her to death!

[@FazilaQazi77]

Very very true

[@Gogala]

Let’s be kind to the guest even if we disagree with them. It was brave of Nooran to show up for this interview. Aamna asked all her questions with a lot of respect and grace and Nooran answered sportingly. The story has flaws for sure but no one till date wrote this sort of romantic fantasy like her before. The romance is what drew people in and let’s give her the credit she deserves. She’s young and says she takes note of audience feedback and will course correct in future scripts. That’s all any of us can do in life, learn from our mistakes and do better next time. I liked her personality :). Nooran, keep going, keep learning and improving, keep giving us romance that makes our hearts flutter❤

[@ifrahzia4031]

Truly Agreed. ❤

[@ibraheemahmed574]

Absolutely i saw other comments full of critism on the writer and found this one comment sensible

[@binachakrabarty8096]

She has also ended the story happily which is very rare in famous Pak dramas.

[@ibraheemahmed574]

@@binachakrabarty8096 ofcourse that's the main pointt atleast she fulfilled the demand of audience bcz audience was demanding an Happy ending and every persom makes mistakes and they learn from mistake allag ny insanon ko isiliye to banaya hai kiunke wo gllti kreingy aur apni hi gltion se seekhein gy isiliye to hum insaan ashraful makhlooqat hain kiunke agr dekha jo to nooran ny bhi apni galtion se seekha hai agr ap logon ny pura interview dekha ho to usne last main kaha hai ky koshish krungi ky s 2 main wo galtian na karon jo season 1 main ki hain

[@sukhqazmi5837]

Watch "iss pyaar ko kya naam doon"... " qubool hai"... "Geet- hui sbse parayi".. U will realize, what shiit u watched in the name of " fantasy romance"... In what fantasy does a cousin get spanked or a cousin spits or does contract marriage that has no Islamic base

[@sadiaaaa]

Lots of respect for Nooran for agreeing to the interview and answering all of Amna’s questions. Both ladies handled the conversation gracefully and beautifully. Now imagine a male host and a male writer attempting this type of a dialogue 😂

[@sanzalt]

All said and done I respect her for having the guts to come and face Amna after all the fiasco😊

[@rubabzehra6177]

😂😂

[@sarabilal994]

Damn I agree

[@umarshoaib1509]

I think its an attempt to prove she can be considered for tere bin 2

[@manasibrhm]

Yes 100%Agree

[@seemalhasan2931]

Agreed. And I think she did well answering too. Obviously it was Fantasy and looks like she will be lil careful in season 2

[@sabuhikiran6382]

I have to agree Nooran is a positive person and very brave. Even though she did not admit the flaws in storyline.. i felt she understood them and is ready to improvise… Aamna you are indeed very kind and asked all questions very respectfully.. No doubt we love you 💗

[@meerasim7]

True

[@sadiasiddique3202]

Huge appreciation for Amna and Nooran. Despite all the criticism and roasting of TB Amna conducted the interview with such politeness and respect when she could have easily been condescending; and Nooran for being gracious enough to agree to this. She is young and has good potential. The flaws in the writing of TB could have been pointed out or corrected by the far more experienced team of the drama before it went on the floors, why put all the blame on Nooran. Thank you SH for this sensible and mature content.

[@user-ac3187]

Script was week. We should not blame alone for writer. What production house, producers, directors were doing???

[@sadiasiddique3202]

@@user-ac3187 exactly

[@NadyaAftab]

It was a very compelling script for a new writer. Nooran is talented. She has not recieved the appreciation she deserves and unfortunately, the actors have thanked everyone except her. Production house and director could have rewritten the flaws out themselves. Writers are often underappreciated.

[@zahra698]

@@NadyaAftab Yumna and Wahaj Ali need to thank her!!! That's kind of sad

[@emanfatima5945]

How beautifully she dodge amna. Well done,nce. As kaam lktay hiii qqq ho jska anwer apna krskooo

[@zehrafatima987]

We all must agree that Nooran is really brave that she agreed to answered Aamna's question.

[@atiny7805]

The face of a writer who wears her ignorance as a badge of honour, A woman who is proud of her misogyny . She is not brave for answering questions its a classic case of ignorance is bliss.

[@ai172]

Goodness! Nooran is far too shrewd. How well does she dodge and deflect Aamna's questions! And Aamna , you have conducted the interview with such grace and decency♥️

[@shahmanz]

I think Amna was weak. Nooran Makhdoom is slippery, too slippery

[@anupmakumar3353]

Well, Aamna could not have screamed “ the nation / world wants to know “ . She asked all the right questions.

[@doctoraqsa]

Indeed. Amna is always impeccable with her questions!!

[@anikacutipie5237]

​@@anupmakumar3353yes nooran k liye a yumhaj mila hume this story is unique uncommon 🥰

[@ai172]

@@shahmanz with all due respect, I beg to differ. I wouldn't interpret Aamna's decency for her weakness. She asked the right questions in a forthright manner.

[@kiranjeetkaur2806]

Yumna and Wahaj… both are epitome of acting.. Tere Bin is hit because of their versatility

[@sharminafrose8259]

Tere Bin broke all the records only because of yumna & wahaj magical chemistry❤❤❤ it's yumhaj who made it blockbuster ❤nothing else

[@azkashaikh3148]

It was the Writer who made the story who created character of Murtasim and meerab..Why not others drama go such a huge hit why only tere bin because of the story and unique writing and romance..she must be given acknowledgement and appreciation by actors...wahaj only acted but the character was written by her..she should be given what she deserve..so ungrateful of yumna and Wahaj who didn't mention Nooran

[@bakhtawarjj]

No, not only those, credit go to the writer

[@charuupreti5087]

I agree to the fact that script had some flaws and a few impractical things but can't deny to the fact that the way she showed romance with just dialouges and eye contact is really appreciating because without them I don't think it would be this successful so the credit for the huge success of tere bin not only goes to the lead cast but also to her for writing such romantic dialouges. My personal favorite was" Achhe ka to nahi pata par ab bure nahi lagte" ❤

[@anayazahra8150]

The real credit goes to yumna and wahaj for playing meerab and murtasim so well❤

[@bakhtawarjj]

Not only wahaj and yumna, the credit of success go to the writer

[@hiramemon9861]

​@@bakhtawarjjkya credit goes to writer itni fazool scripts likhi thi flaws se bhari flash back se bhari koi logic nhi tha story me bv se husband ko thapar thookna dikhaya phir husband ka bv ko rape krna dikhaya and your saying credit goes to writer

[@bakhtawarjj]

@@hiramemon9861 💯 percent

[@sumanh9750]

Here's my analysis on nooran: 1. Her forte seems to be romantic scenes but stringing together a coherent story along with that romance->she still lacks that expertise. (If that is fixed there's so much more potential) 2. She's heavily obsessed/influenced with Ekta Kapoor's modus operandi, specifically- making negative characters infallible and stretching their plots like chewing gum. Her mention of komolika confirms it.(if you are reading this, please don't go that rabbit hole, your audience will thank you for that)

[@nice865]

Well said, I hope our dramas don’t end up like Star Plus.

[@kiransamana]

I honestly don't get why people are still excited for season 2. I wouldn't want to watch anything from Nooran Makhdoom again after knowing that despite most people pointing out everything wrong with her script to her, she still finds a way to justify it and still believes those slaps were necessary.

[@fawadaa4907]

Yes me too, Drama was OK, but flashbacks and making Story longer was terrible

[@MAbd-pt8dv]

I'm not in favor of a second season. I don't understand. People were complaining that the story was being stretched and that it was not getting over, and now they want a second season. 🤷‍♂

[@nott29]

​@@MAbd-pt8dvyeah because now meerab and murtasim got together so now people want to see there romance after having a daughter.

[@MAbd-pt8dv]

​@@nott29 I understand your pov. However, considering how poorly they stretched out and handled this season, especially after the MR scene, along with the disappointing ending, I don't have high hopes for the second season.

[@Taimurkhan-ct7uw]

No no one is excited

[@ayeshaakram7216]

Lets be honest people, the reason this drama was a hit was because of the romantic scenes. As a society we are deeply deprieved of seeing and experiencing romance. And Nooran wrote all that romance so lets give her credit for it. Lets also appreciate her for writing a postive character like Murtasim who despite being a rich privileged man still wasnt your typical dominant aggressive husband which I feel most similar characters are portrayed as. We fell in love with Murtasim because he was a perfect man, kind, fair and no anger issues. I wish more writers start to write positive male characters and more romance instead of the garbage we usually get with the typical saas bahu drama, cheating husband or the dominating aggressive husband.

[@NutanNaringrekar-l2i]

Whole highlighting male character in positive & modern outlook, she totally degraded woman character. Roming around in the late hours is not done in any respectable family. Then to repair the fault. The character of bus conducter, was introduced in every nook of corner, which was absurd. Instead she should have shown Change in Meerab' attitude. Also the main culprit Haya was given undue importance. She should have been lashed by Marium thus saving her brother' s marriage.

[@ayeshaakram7216]

@@NutanNaringrekar-l2i I like your story…..maybe you should start writing scripts and send to production houses 😊. You are right about Meerabs character though, at times she wasn’t shown as a sensible person.

[@ashgrathom]

@@ayeshaakram7216 but at times, people are not really sensible. The whole storyline , I've heard it in one way or the other from many couples. Meerubs character actually reminded me of me. But instead of running away and suffering..... I decided to change while suffering the anguish of the destruction caused by words and attitudes....

[@riddhinigamsem2secc-406]

Respect to Amna and Nooran for being so polite in the interview with each other.

[@zaraejaz7481]

Very interesting interview! I love how brave is Nooran to show up for this interview and answer all the questions and how nicely Amna conducted the interview. Good watch!

[@laibasami336]

If there is Tere bin 2 then only actors are Yumna and Wahaj bcz without them there is no Drama like Tere bin

[@afshankhan093]

Huge respect to Amna for sitting through the interview and never snap at her cz of her problematic thought process

[@mariamtariq1708]

Amna she is clueless and doesn’t want to acknowledge what she did … but hats of to you to bring her and same for her !

[@wannatopnotch]

Amna ko puch na cahiyey tha ki rohail key pass nehi hey janke bhi kyu saadi mey beythi kyu murtasim

[@syedareal1332]

What annoys me is she never admits she was wrong that she wrote MR jhoot and keeps defending 🙄

[@anayakhan2412]

She is so proud of her bizzare writing and she always try to justify it. Its not shocking to me she has said these things in her previous interviews also. Her mindset is really backward because any sane person can't justify abuse and marital rape. She thinks the popularity of this drama is due to her epic writing lol but in reality the success is due to Wahaj and Yumna.

[@nice865]

So true, no class. I hope our dramas don’t turn like star plus dramas. The writers have a responsibility, we need to see what we are feeding our masses through these dramas.

[@nishakhan2721]

I believe Tere Bin’s credit should go to the writer even though there were many flaws but she made everyone popular who worked in Tere Bin👍❤️✌️

[@adibaaa]

One thing i noticed about aamna is that she handle the individuals as per their persona , 😅 Because when she personally meet nooran then find she is ameture or younger writer then she interviewed her with politeness despite the all anger and issues of the flaws of the scripts she complained in tere bin roast with hassan And was not harsh.

[@amnaazeem5721]

A big shout out for how amna has gracefully conducted this interview with all grace and respect conveyed and asked all controversial questions

[@mahnoorqureshi3281]

I liked that Nooran took SH roasting and Amna’s tough questions positively, humbly, and with a pleasant attitude. I was waiting to know the truth about the MR from the writer herself. Instead of the truth she went with the changed version, but very unconvincingly, and we could read between the lines. Secondly, she said people perceived Murtasim as someone who could do nothing wrong, when it was not the audience but the writer herself who put Murtasim on the pedestal. Hope she rectifies the flaws in the sequel, and makes it worth watching.

[@gicnusrat2734]

why is she lying or she has to hide cause every sane person knows it was MA but they changed narrative which we cant buy what do u think mahnoor .

[@manasibrhm]

Yes...same thoughts .... But wo ab marta kya na kerta ki situation main hain....accept kr ni saktien kiun k baqi team k sath hi chalna hai....or agay un k sath kaam b kerna hai....🤷

[@mahnoorqureshi3281]

@@manasibrhm true, I guess.

[@gerryburntwood9617]

I won’t wait with bated breath to have anything substantial out of this writer, for season 2! Like Marina Khan said that this writer may decide she needs to go from point A to C as she knows what she wants at point C yet getting there she uses no logic nor intelligence and make the journey from A to C traumatic & insulting to the audience, and also flies in the face of being relatable ! I wish Yumna and Wahaj do not feel obligated to do it, because they could do a well written project which will still garner support from their newly developed fan base.! Sadly From the announcement by the producers, it’s a done deal & Nooran is writing the script!😳😩

[@mahnoorqureshi3281]

@@gerryburntwood9617 They can’t afford not to have Wahaj and Yumna, would offer them huge some of money. 😀After all the drama’s success was all due to the two.

[@hrishitachakraborty]

The fact that she is still allowed to write for Tere Bin Season 2 makes me choke! I really really hope Wahaj Yumna back out of this project and I'll see if it works... 7th sky and GEO needs to tank..so does Nooran, Siraj, Marie and team!

[@sans7045]

After seeing this interview, I truly feel that what Nooran wrote made a lot of sense to her. In the flow of writing, it worked. But the choppy editing and the weird production has made things very very weird

[@Rupadattamajumdar]

Yes I thought the same thing. Editing team is very bad

[@user-ac3187]

Execution was poor.

[@zoey33527]

Exactly, I'm in no way a nooran apologist but SOMETHING went wrong in the execution of the script. Evidently, some of the character tweaks made by Wahaj for Murtasim's character should not have been made, becuase the plot obviously didn't change and that left a lot of the audience and honestly even the editors confused lol.

[@user-ac3187]

Infact story was good till 30 episodes. It was a clash of egos and murtasim's love for meerab. After 30 it could have been way better because she gave more space to marium. After 43 she truly messed up. On top of that editors and producers who decided to drag and adding flashback. We can't blame entirely nooran. Production house could have changed the plot after 43. A good script executed poorly after 30.

[@startrends8122]

But her writing MR was wrong and it’s obvious she wrote that but don’t want to talk about it

[@ranjanachouhan2425]

Loved the way Amna mam asked questions. So polite n so respectful. I request Noora mam to be logical in the next season.

[@manjusthia]

I feel Humsafar and zindagi gulzar hai was so much better. Ive watched each several times. But i couldnt see tere bin again.

[@shahmanz]

Yes. Its over and forgotten already

[@sassiahmed6818]

The way nooran is saying why people are focusing on logic is the proof how much she lacks logic in life 😅

[@ambershehzad]

She is one of those digest writers who wrote those afsanay my mom forbade me to read. She must stick to that only 😂

[@zaraa.2198]

So a married couple had consensual sex???? And they are also in love????? But still the wife leaves????? Cuz shaadi se pehle she said he could never touch her??????? Even though now she loves him more than he loves her??????? And this is all reason enough to keep his child away from him???????????

[@humarizvi3471]

Yes Nooran’s terrible writing skills

[@sidrakafeel9160]

I want to watch this show ..but it's hard to listen noraan lame excuses for her illogical and meaning less twist and turns in Tere bin..

[@radharao1711]

Nooran, don’t justify the slapping scenes as “action & reaction”. In society & in peoples’ personal lives it is a grave issue. And making Meerab spit on Murtassim was disgusting. These things are not ok. You cannot pass them off as action - reaction. It’s just not done. You are still young, Nooran. You have a lot of potential. But be responsible and sensitive, not frivolous.

[@sidsaraj4391]

She has potential to learn. She has a tendency if making her heroiens dumb as hell . Also she completely denied marital rape. I mean if we take what shes saying and the wasnt any marital rape then it was a trash writing

[@niharikamishra_]

She needs to acknowledge the fact that a script like this would have worked in the bygone era. The "original" twist was also done by Rhett Butler in Gone With the Wind and we still call it one of the most popular romances. But it doesn't mean that it needs to be equally accepted in a modern show. "Murtasim is only human" is not a good enough excuse. Many fans used to look up to this character as an ideal romantic hero and this kind of a twisted twist did end up messing with their mental health.

[@farhanasonyahossain8720]

It's the problem of fan not the writer, actor actress or the team. Abdullah kadwani also said fan forgot murtasim is human being, to err is human. But they believe Murtasim is an angel living in other planet. That's why so much issue.

[@mythologicalmainstay5029]

@@farhanasonyahossain8720The issue is not that. People look to these larger than life shows to transport them to another reality full of romance and fairytales. The fact they projected it as a show of great production value drenched in romance that’s the issue. If they had shown it as a social drama people would have not been this traumatized. And if it were to be taken as such they should have addressed many issues which were just brushed under the carpet and Murtasim should not have gotten Meerab in the end. If MR was retained, it would propagate the wrong message to young men that they need not wait for consent and can force themselves on their partners if they are romantic in general and apologise for their actions later. Worse the women will even forgive them. Even whole team dubbed Murtasim to be non-toxic. He assaults her and was willing to marry the woman who did nothing but to ruin his relationship with his wife. He is toxic but he is also an idiot.

[@sss-pg7zc]

Right

[@lakshmisubramony7219]

@@farhanasonyahossain8720 the creators and writer created him like that. they should have shown some flaws in him from the beginning itself. but theydidn;t they showed him so nice and in the episode 46 like that doom they made him fall so audience will react like this. then Wahaj acting also did a lot of expectations with Murtasim.

[@mehwishfaisal8286]

Exactly, her replies are illogical like drama.

[@mohammadtharik1287]

Honestly I love this drama, helped me learn Urdu and also I loved the story plot and could connect a lot with the characters. Love from Tamilnadu 🇮🇳♥️🇵🇰

[@zarajawed8474]

Apka id name theek nhi hy please change kren

[@mohammadtharik1287]

@@zarajawed8474 Mohammad tharik I don’t find it to be a bad name, I mean unless you’re a kafir you’d have an objection 🤔

[@zarajawed8474]

@@mohammadtharik1287 ok if you spell tariq as tharik i read this as tharki my bad

[@mohammadtharik1287]

@@zarajawed8474 Thariq is the actual spelling but in Tamizh it’s tharik..

[@Kinglykhadija_]

Sexual assault should never be a part of a romantic script. No iff's and butt's. The blunder that the writer made in the whole drama with that slap scene first, then murtasim asking meerab to jump off the roof just to prove her innocence, then meerab spitting on murtasim and then this marital rape happened. So yeah it was a stupid, illogical and disgusting drama with no positive points in it.

[@saadia3588]

💯

[@humarizvi3471]

💯 true

[@ritabhattacharyya7522]

A beautiful love story... this psycho turned it into Tere bin to dustbin..

[@khushikhan527]

Right murtasim ki adult nhi krne chahiye

[@MBfromToronto]

The writer doesn't have any clear answers for any questions. So defensive and clever in avoiding controversial topics

[@zahrasalah]

I am so disappointed Aamna you didnt ask the most important question, why the hell she didnt write dialogues for Meerab, there was no monologues or even pov of Meerab throughout the drama the way Murtasim was given millions of monologues and povs...why the unjust behavior between male and female leads...

[@samansiddiquie1902]

Amna’s tact and patience with this woman 😂😂😂😂😂😂😂

[@YumHaj.forever_]

I understand that Nooran did not write Tere Bin with the expectation of it reaching every nook and cranny of pak and beyond nor did she write Murtasim with the idea that women will start idolizing him. This insane viewership is a gift of god and a blessing for Yumna, Wahaj and everyone involved. Their talent was bound to reach the masses and for that I'm grateful to TB:)

[@Vhagar_Green]

You just can't hold the writer responsible for the MR if it did happen. The actors are equally responsible. Wahaj and Yumna should have denied this. No one asked them at a gun point to enact this scene. There are actors who have disagreed upon such subjects at script level. So STOP blaming Nooran alone. The actors and director are equally responsible for the MESS created post episode 46.

[@emanfatima5945]

When you sign a project you have to done it. You can't leave in the mid

[@zahirarahman8104]

She doesn't have the intelligence to understand the deeper implication. I believe this drama is a success because of the way in which the other departments put the contents together as well as they could. And the phenomenal acting of Yumna and Wahaj. The writer is so naive to the point that she has zero ego. She is so honest and pure. 😅❤

[@kiara6220]

Thank you team Something Haute for bringing Nooran on the show, I was one of them who requested for this. Being a huge romance lover and avid reader of Mills n Boon…this is what is expected out of a trashy romance (which via a book people secretly enjoy) As a romance story she had a strong story arc, leaving aside morality aspect, it was a well written love story! #unpopularopinion Even though I had alot of issues with the drama (possibly creative misses, I wished the ep 47 would have shown where Muratism intended to show Meerab her place in the heat of moment but ended up it being consensual)

[@arhamsmommie6530]

15:48 “ Aap logic dhoondna chahte hain, toh aapko kahin nahi milega” LOL!

[@zahra698]

lol true !!!!

[@Tamanna-hw6ii]

We should thanks to Nooran...There were amazing dialogues...She made the Yumhaj chemistry so romantic through her writing💓 and their tom and jerry fighting!! Although there were some mistakes in the storyline...but people do mistakes and they also learn from that.

[@SHEIKHASNABCBLA]

I hope they dont continue with the same story and give us new story with yumhaj..

[@aimenvlogs6010]

Exactly. Finallyyyy someone said it

[@kulbirkaur6646]

I'm from India Amna it seems that the writer is influenced by ekta kapoor's serials... this is a request to Pakistani drama writers from India kindly don't copy Indian serials kindly don't let Pakistani drama standard go down❤

[@divyashapachauri]

If anyone on earth can transmit this message to tere bin team then please do. Please do not hire her as writer. Please hire someone who is experienced and has aced his/ her talent. She is just realing the fruits of yumhaj. One drama of her with any other actor, she will discover she needs a lot of experience. Saying this in sane words.

[@MuhammadBilal-gw5lg]

She is a story writer. If you dont like her, dont watch.

[@unstoppable865]

Divya please .. do u know whatever the story was this drama did a huge business, it made 1 billion on KZbin do u know 1 billion = 100 crore ... 🎉 so the channels and production would go for her if she gives another big hit and no matter what's the story ?? ...😂😂😂

[@sanamonster1]

Yaar! Hats off to this woman's courage that she came to this interview when she had no answers 😂

[@salroomawiya]

Nooran makhdoom 's guts to explain episode 47 promo I think she should apologize rather than justifying

[@creations10]

iske sath hua h bhai ye sab😂😂

[@bfatima007]

Kis baat par geo ka tactics par? 26 episode ko 50 epi banadoya

[@faiqafahadahmad]

Amna rocked Nooran shocked 😂🤣 I am absolutely delighted for both #YumnaZaidi and #WahajAli That's why i always said #TereBin is a breakthrough for both of them. Well deserved mass popularity, which made them superstars overnight 👏 Terebin will always be remembered for #YumHaj chemistry and #Meerasim ♥️

[@hamnaaamer9339]

Just wondering how firm this woman is in her ideologies that she wasnt the least bit swayed or be compelled to question at least one of her writing choices through watching at least one episode of something haute ?!?!? Along with Hassan and Aamna, there were so many different perspectives people were wonderfully explaining in the comments and she couldn't entertain even one of them?!

[@TabasumReehana]

We should thank the writer also.... Without her the drama could have been soo successful around the world❤

[@saranaeem7633]

Sure man sure a man slaps a woman and you're saying "its a reaction" but she didnt even bother saying that it was wrong. Romanticizing violence WAHHHH!!!

[@saadia3588]

She said the same thing in Arabia’s interview. She came across as very blasé and not up with the current times due to her views. I think she should go back to the pre Islamic Middle Ages era where wife beaters were considered the norm.

[@ashbal17ramzan76]

Actually the whole credit goes to yumna and wahaj... other than them any underrated writer can write such a script only Wahaj and Yumna made Tere bin ...THE TERE BIN and that is it

[@riziliencecoaching55]

I was not expecting this to happen! Kudos to the writer for being so open, upfront and owning her work even though most us were having our WTF just happened moments whilst watching the drama! 😅

[@komalsehgal472]

All credit goes to everyone.. Even the audience who appreciated the story writer cast production everything.. Hats off to everyone for making this a masterpiece.. n special thanks to writer without uh we were not able to see such sweet drama...

[@mahlaqakhan286]

The popularity of Dustbin is solely due to Wahaj and Yumna who have put their souls in it…!! Her writing had nothing to add. It has brought both phenomenal actors a bad criticism for doing this horrible content. There is no take home message from this Kuchra writing..!!

[@s123khan5]

😂😂😂😂

[@sakshimahawar1125]

True.

[@FaithLuckDestiny]

I hope everyone including the cast and crew and production just reads and proof reads the script before shooting for S2. It’s going to be the most awaited sequel in the history of Pakistani tv and the world is going to be watching. And for stupid plot lines there should be a writing team to vet ideas.

[@shifau346]

She herself don't know what she wrote.terebin script is highly problematic and illogical script I ever seen .I really wished Wahaj and Yumna say no to season 2 if she is writing it

[@iqra4397]

Bcz she wrote 3 ,4 years back 2 years writing mai lge or shooting Mai bhi time lgta h yr

[@emanfatima5945]

Why they refused it?? Anko paisay mlll ray hhh axhay khassay

[@sidsaraj4391]

I think she kept wroting romantic amd erotic piecea individually and for her own romantic fantasy. Amd just complied everything and threw it together. Because she did mention i have the scene of qhat happened in the bed room written for myself

[@hera.naushahi]

I dont usually comment on videos but oh my god, it was SO infuriating to listen to NM talk!!😐 She answered none of the questions asked & it was just one long whataboutism conversation! Hats off to you, Aamna, for being so gracious with your words & trying your hardest to not repeatedly ask the same questions (even though at certain points i wanted you to- NM’s constant “but what about this, but yeh dosri cheez tou aisi thi” etc. was SO FRUSTRATING!!). I hope you & Hassan will talk about this interview & I hope we get to hear what you thought about it all, Aamna!

[@sehbanabi9235]

Writer is responsible for showing MR in episode 46, not showing consistency in Meerab character, no one questioning Haya. But director, actors, content team all are responsible to some extent

[@2doubleard439]

SHE DENIED THE MR!!!!!!! She said it was consensual !!!!!

[@FNaveed23]

These kind of stories are very often seen on ‘APlus ‘ channel or Tvone BUT only difference here is Wahaj and Yumna and the director…..

[@adibaaa]

She deserved credit for writing those romantic scenes and engaging audience It's team work don't know kiske luck se ye drama itna bada bna Actors directors Producers Crew Ps : no doubt galtiyan bhi kafi hui thi but it hooked us ❤

[@sukhqazmi5837]

Writer is a teenage girl mentally n i feel so sad that such "bloomer wattpad writer" got her work adapted exactly as it is into drama without hiring a better script editor or drama writer to improve her writing n bring sense in her work that should be acceptable according to OUR DRAMA Culture, but clearly the purpose was to appeal confused foreign lots that are thirsty crows n only crave shiit nonsense romance on characters that makes no sense in our households or culture... The producers n directors are so clever to push this writer under bus by allowing her to come for this interview just to tell ppl that look the writer is actually too young when it comes to writing skills, inexperienced n mentally confused about her own fantasy n plot , n have done this stunt to make us unnecessarily interested in season 2... For people who wish to watch season 2 must know that this lady is confused n it is not her fault that noone in the drama director n producer staff never bothered making the story worth making sense to support face value of the cast.

[@khushisingh0603]

What an interview👏👏👏. And we can't take this away from her that she wrote tere bin and all the scenes that made us happy were her imagination and if she feels that yumna and wahaj are not thankful towards her then it's her right to say that but i feel she is being hypocrite here cause in the beginning even she didn't appreciated them, she was all about that i wrote these characters and it's success is because of my writing but as we all know that tere bin is " TERE BIN " Just because of yumhaj❤. But i must appreciate that she is a very confident woman

[@user-ac3187]

True. In initial iv she didn't give credit to wahaj and yumna.

[@emanfatima5945]

Exactly infact she said she thought hania would be better for playing meerub. And I thought assey maheer sambalti nhi hhh atnay muskil character ksay sambhalay gy

[@khushisingh0603]

@@emanfatima5945 Exactly, only yumna can do justice to any kind of role. She is a phenomenal actor❤

[@khushisingh0603]

@@ayat4408 yup even I feel hania is overrated just because she is beautiful and has more followers on Instagram that's why she is getting so many offers. She still has to learn a lot and she is not even trying to do different kind of roles. Wahi rona dhona wala character har baar

[@emanfatima5945]

@@ayat4408 I get ur point . Mera bbb yehi khyal hhh hania se nhi hona taa ye asne bs roye jna taaa. Yumna ne khud kaha taa kay meerub ko sambhalana bara muskil taaa. Wasay ye role maya Ali bbb axha krletiii. Wo asay role axhay krleti hhh but not hania yrrrr

[@288amna]

Poor woman!! Domestic violence must be normalised in her family so she doesn’t think it’s anything wrong. I can not even imagine this kind of upbringing. So sad for her and women like her who don’t even know that they are being abused and they’ve internalised it

[@BK-ii6kb]

Beautifully expressed reason for why it all feels wrong and psychologically uncomfortable in the name of romance. Poor woman indeed. Bigger problem is that evidently we have a society full of such women who have lapped up this nonsense.

[@Sidra3567]

Just because she wrote that script, it doesn't mean she went through the same voilance. How judgemental!

[@288amna]

@@Sidra3567 no one is saying she went through it but the casual way she’s defending it like aisa reaction to hota hai, tells that she’s seen this being normalised in her surroundings. That’s why I said poor woman doesn’t know any better. It’s her upbringing that’s making her write and DEFEND such behaviour

[@narjisrubab872]

Amazing this lady has a courage to be interviewed by such a good journalist Amna, knowing the fact the writing was so weak and full of flaws.....but like Meerab (as she wrote the character) portrayed her stubbornness of ignoring the bad writing........🤪

[@farahkhan3570]

Thank you Amna for giving us this interview. It’s brave of the Nooran to come for the interview after what happened on social media post 46th episode. But I felt there was no reflection on her part - why the uproar happened and no clear condemnation of showing slaps and rape without any thought of reaction/ impact, instead there was lot of explanation and hai tu drama hee 😮

[@archnayadav6989]

It was a nice interview! One good thing about Nooran is that she is open to receiving feedback. Next season, I am hoping she takes the feedback and gives us a better story with less loopholes. I totally agree that Tere Bin isn't the only show to have the flaws. But because of it's popularity, it got love and criticism. All I am hoping for next season is give me a love story. Do not make it one sided till the end when you promise a love story. No more slaps from the female or male character. More communication and of course the most important thing romance! All said and done, Tere Bin has been a good show with it's flaws. There were some really good things to appreciate about the show. -I liked that Murtasim wasn't the typical toxic and problematic hero. He slaps but he apologises and never repeats it. This is progress and realisitc. It's not to normalise violence. He was very respectful to the women in his family. Even if he didn't agree with Meerab on many occasions, he defended and did things on her insistence. Haya was a nuisance but he never crossed the line with her. He was respectful with his mother and balanced things with between mother and wife. As a hero, he wasn't one of those who had a problem saying sorry, thank and please. He was forgiving by nature. -Meerab was a girl who fought for her freedom. She was extremely stubborn which became annyoing after a point. But we saw a girl who had this attitude of not being a sacrificing person. It's a rare thing. Definitely deserved a better journey where she would've understood that she can be herself and find her space in this new world. No one was bad. It was her prejudices which needed to change over time with her experiences and learnings. -We saw a mother-in-law that liked seeing her son and daughter in law happy. Her only concern was that. She never plotted against her bahu. -Romance was the best thing about Tere Bin and we deserved more. In pakistani dramas, this is the first drama to show this kind of romance and it deserves the hype for this simple reason. Why is there a lack of romance? Love is beautiful and it should be celebrated. I just wish we see more romance which included Meerab's side too. Hopefully next season. In tere bin 2 I was hoping we would have the same characters but we start their story in a different setting. I think we deserve it. But lets what is planned. I think Nooran will deliver better and she has learnt from the mistakes. I just wish people would be sensitive and not be rude to her when pointing out flaws and constructive critism. It's so sad to see people say things like "I wish she never holds a pen again" and all. It's really sad. Don't forget to be a human. It's okay she has made mistakes which she is not going to repeat again. Nooran gave really good answers. She is prepared with her answers because she knows her story and her intent.

[@mamunaanwar6481]

The reason is simple, there are more talented people out there, who can deliver much better script than this if given a chance. The cast, director, production and viewers do not have to be tortured with a script with so many flaws.

[@debjanidas5895]

I appreciate the writer though there might be some flaws since human character is never flawless. This story is very similar to my married life. While watching the drama now I understood many traits of male character which I recently discovered. Thanks to the writer.

[@saminasalahuddin7461]

Good job Amna, you addressed all the important questions with "slow" roasting. The writer was not able to give apprpriate answers.

[@myreaction708]

Sorry to say she didn't answer any questions logically

[@kukuali]

Very sorry to say that the way she speaks says a lot about how she wrote! It’s not her fault….she wrote what she wanted but Yumna and Wahaj took it to the level where they couldn’t justify her poor writing….. Big No to season 2!! Kafi torture ho Gaya 😅😢

[@itshasan2687]

But habs was good

[@ehsaanali6158]

​@@itshasan2687Habs is written by her sister.

[@isratsarker7930]

Ap mat dekhna. Kisine force nahi kiya

[@iyonapereira3076]

Hats of to Amna her patience is commendable I could not watch anymore she does not make sense n she cannot explain it either

[@muhammadmuhammad4415]

We want season 2 without Haya,..😢😢😢just Wahaj and Yumna ❤❤❤

[@tamannayeasmin2106]

Haya hogi to maja hogi haya na hogi to interesting na hogi samjhi

[@itshasan2687]

Villian ke Bina story kaha hoti hai 😂

[@Goeeegi]

@@tamannayeasmin2106 the last 10 episodes were all about Haya and I found them the most boring. I’m okay with Haya for a few a minutes each episode, but if she’s the main character again, im out 🙏

[@MAbd-pt8dv]

I'm not particularly in favor of having a second season, but if it does happen, I wouldn't mind if Haya is included. However, this time she should face the consequences of her wrongdoings and not be let off easily.

[@MuhammadUsman-nf6gx]

Yes

[@rashiya.sheikh_Art]

The characters she has given us in Tere Bin is incredible ❤❤❤

[@ipshi17]

First of all the reason of Tere Bin success credit goes to only n only to Wahaj and Yumna because of their acting and chemistry. I’m sure if this drama had any xyz in this it wouldn’t had got this kind of success. Writer was neither able to justify her writing nor admitted her mistakes. I’m not interested in season 2.

[@anupmakumar3353]

Humiliating Haya for each of her misdeeds was absolutely needed!

[@nataliakhan3324]

She comes from a feudal background so a lot of her writing depicts that life ….. she will not understand the response. However I think she is good at firstly giving her view point ( incorrect as it maybe ) but at the same time admits that she will respect peoples feelings

[@ilmanjan1046]

And we want season 2 very romantic than season 1 please 🥺

[@mahlaqakhan286]

Khuda kae liyaey Save us from S2 of Dustbin. Amna you were very kind to host her. But honestly she failed to satisfied audiences for all the flaws that really repulsed the audiences. She still answered as if audiences are Dumb. Not in one sentence she respected how disturbed audiences were. Rather as a saddest and Narcissist she is not flexible to register genuine weakness of this Dustbin. Her answer that audiences should not watch it. Well Pakistan’s hold a huge responsibility to keep an eye what is being slowly normalized in the society..!! She needs checks and balances for sure..!!! She can’t normalize crap that is against our social, moral , cultural and religious norms. And she wants the audience to behave Dumb, idiots ???? Seriously?? In 21 century she wants to use romance to accept rest of her crap writing??? No way..!! Period. Things have to make sense. If romance is making sense and is happening between husband and wife.. It is real it’s not fiction. Now couples do express love in front of kids and in family. But at the same time to accept all that nonsense content.. No way..!! Our views still strongly condemn it. And please for a while Ban her..!!! She has insulted audiences brutally ..!! Hasan and Amina please you need to respect our opinion and I know you guys do..!! Kis sadi main reh rahaey hain hum.. All her justification of Merub running away is Crap 💩..!!!

[@shaguftaaziz517]

writer galat bol rahi hn k murtasim arrogant ziddi apni chlany wala tha lkn 2sri trf esi se sary piar krty hn he is loving all of yahn tk k 1st scene ma hi mazlom Hari ki madad keta ha .Haya ki bdtamezi or Meerab k rude behavior pr bhi calm raha .koi or hota to sabaq sikha data...

[@muskan6110]

I appreciate Amna for respecting the writer and this conversation was really really good and humble, i loved it

[@zubaida0511]

I just loved the vibe of Nooran 👏 she is just sooo sweet and amazing... she answered all the questions to its best... Excited for tere bin s2..

[@eskay5106]

Great interview. Nooran ji did a good job answering any questions that you had and because she wasn’t defensive about her characters, it made for a pleasant listen. Maybe the drama wasn’t story wise the best out there but we all enjoyed it and the views are a testament to it. Success is always a team effort and I wish her the best of luck.

[@anamumar3997]

well...Tere bin is only popular beacuase of the lead pair..their chemistry played the major role... writinh of the drama was very very poor. its a request Nooran if you want to write again plz do some research atleast read something about writing about characterization.

[@user-72892shjsjs]

Season 2 with yumna and Wahaj only!

[@mussharatnaaz1325]

Mam..now please interview Siraj Ul Haq sir.. I want to know who was behind the foreshadowing dialogues and scenes and behind the mythological references in the drama. It's not a coincidence because there were many and they were bloody brilliant. The stories were woven and intertwined beautifully. Please fulfill my wish 🙏

[@MyselfIsika21]

Nooran said "jo bhi hua bhul jao firse karenge ek aur bacha peyda karenge " oh my god 🤣🤣😂

[@diju1]

wtf... she actually said that?

[@sidsaraj4391]

Hahahaha amd not just once. The season 2 will be murtasim over ciming his trauma of touching his legally wedded wife and again he will MR and the wild goose chases all over again.

[@abherigummadidala3081]

I think Tere bin was a great drama with some phenomenal performances and great storyline! Can’t wait for season 2