Nouman Ali Khan (NAK), is he reliable?

[@umaradil1330]

I converted to islam because of Nouman Ali Khan

[@al-hikmahproductions]

May Allah reward you. Allah guides us however he wills, I was also motivated to study Islam because of brother Nauman years ago. However, we do not bear loyalty to anyone but to the Prophet and the methodology of the companions. It is entirely possible for someone to be a means to guidance for us - yet not be on the sound methodology. Please protect yourself from the celebrity speakers and refer to the scholars.

[@اهل_التوحيد_والسنة]

I started praying because of « mufti » menk does that make him a shaykh or alim. Both of them are innovators Nouman even rejected al wala wal bara

[@Unknown_user__1]

Alhamdulillah You converted to Islam because of Allah through Ali

[@awwalibrahim2635]

بارك الله فيك ​@@al-hikmahproductions

[@sibudi6158]

Maybe just maybe, it will be wiser to correct him personally in private than beat him publicly like this. It's kinda sad that we're look like we're fighting each other (again)

[@Bilal21160]

He was often advised privately, for example by Abu Mussab and he did not change or anything. Adding to this Nouman Ali Khan does this openly so he can be advised and refuted openly because his deviance misguided him and many muslims with him

[@sibudi6158]

It's just my opinion, from a person that doesn't have fancy education or a good source of knowledge, from a person that doesn't understand Arabic whatsoever, from the person that doesn't know anything about the Qur'an, I think he is doing a good job to awaken my curiosity towards the Qur'an and make me want to learn more about the Qur'an in their own language. I think he helps a lot of people like me who were far away from the Qur'an to be closer to the Qur'an. Please I beg you o people of knowledge, please don't fight each other like this

[@Bilal21160]

@@sibudi6158 bro, just because he is benefiting you in some things doesn’t make him good, learn your deen! And this from the real scholars and not any random youtubers like nouman ali khan ali dawah or muhammad hijab. Watch the video of shaykh faris again and understand it, because you don‘t seem to understand, just because a rapist does good doesn’t make him good and the same in religion

[@sibudi6158]

​@@Bilal21160okay

[@abdulwadood.8]

@@sibudi6158guidance is from Allah.

[@Guidingly]

5:22 Sahih Muslim 2188: Ibn Abbas reported that the Prophet Muhammad (peace be upon him) said: "The influence of the evil eye is a fact; if anything were to precede the divine decree, it would be the influence of an evil eye."

[@cOnfidentialcOrp]

I used to listen to NAK ALOT , like ALOT ALOT, but then stopped after i learned proper beneficial knowledge I think the problem with NAK is that he sits and learns from every innovator and it made him what he is today . May Allah actually guide him.

[@SalafiReminders]

Nouman Ali Khan is living in the west, so yeah, the disbelievers style has gotten to him, wearing jacket, giving da'wah like a Christian Priest, too busy pleasing the audience, loves to make fun of Islamic teachings. The real Islamic scholars are like Sheikh Shalih Al Fawzan (hafidzahullah), they don't joke around and don't care about pleasing the audience, always straight to the point and ittiba'. Just follow the Salafi brothers like Abu Khadeejah, Hasan As Somali, Oemar Quinn, 'Abdulilah Lahmami (hafidzahullah). BarakAllahu fiikum.

[@rutbashaheen._.]

who is NAK??

[@rutbashaheen._.]

which type of protests are wrong? do you think protests for Palestine are also wrong? and if yes why?

[@omerali580]

​@@SalafiRemindersBruh what logic is? Because he's not wearing a thobe he shouldn't be listened to?

[@bilqisnjama1387]

​@user-gc6wd7dm4wwearing a jacket is imitating christians Wow

[@shekishral6570]

Nouman Ali Khan broght me closer to Quran, and made me love the Quran and made me want to try to understand it. Insted of talking about others do for yourself something beneficial for the umah, don't let the saitan play with you!

[@Farishammadi]

@@shekishral6570 kzbin.info7TcKaZP5zc4?si=pyIgHXBqNr_DwGzI

[@supremeleader6837]

doesn't mean a thing. There are plenty of speakers that brought me closer to Islam but when I noticed they had other major flaws that could make my beliefs wishy-washy I stopped listening to them. And this is beneficial for the ummah. Forbidding evil is recommended in Islam. For anyone who is a revert or just new to learning Islam, they'll just be taking everything NAK says at face value and believing every word of it and corrupting their beliefs without even knowing. So it's important to make the public know that he's misguided, because his videos reach the public. It's not like hid deviancy was done in privacy to refute it privately.

[@erlangga59]

This is stupid, if NAK makes mistake talk to hin personally. Don't air out in public. Are we not.an ummah? You guys are supposed to be our source of knowledge and good examples in character and manners

[@idearikas]

It's because he's a public figure and that misguidance has been spreading publicly, therfore it should be warned against publicly. The aim is never NAK himself, it's to have the same ummah you mentioned be on the straight path. It's never personal.

[@erlangga59]

@@idearikas or maybe it's about follower numbers...

[@idearikas]

@@erlangga59 Have حسن ظن, brother. Wallahi this is so beneficial for so many people. Just imagine how many people of this ummah seeing NAK denying evil eye for example, if scholars don't point it out, how would they know? Aren't we supposed to spread the truth? Didn't Allah tell us to enjoin good and forbid evil?

[@GvgVhc]

If someone spread misguidance openly he shall be refuted openly

[@AbuInayaAl-Athari-po3yj]

He is a misguided innovator. It is the way of the Salaf to refute and warn against innovators like him publicly

[@hilalreshi5045]

People are taking things out of context. For example his stance about nazr. I watched the whole video and didn't hear him saying anything bad or un-Islamic.

[@ToHimWeWillBeReturned]

Denying Evil Eye is not bad?

[@hilalreshi5045]

I have watched the whole video regarding that. He didn't deny the evil eye but said everything that happens can't be ascribed to evil eye. Let's say you aren't careful and stub your toe, it may just be because you were careless and not looking down while walking, it doesn't necessarily mean that your toe was injured because of evil eye. ​@@ToHimWeWillBeReturned

[@ad.808]

Why did he then mock it by using words like laser shooting or of the eyes? ​@@hilalreshi5045

[@nooh4911]

But he did say music is halal right? ​@@hilalreshi5045

[@Mohamed-ye5do]

Would it be permissible to pray behind him, while rejecting the core violations he's guilty of?

[@saad-5473]

Assalam Alaikum, Can you make the same type of video about Yasir Qadhi so that I can show it to a relative who listened to him(Yasir Qadhi)?

[@MenkIsAMubtadiiDeobandi]

also zaid el omar is advertising yasir qadhi's book.

[@muhammedriyasa5647]

Va alaikumussalam

[@yougotthiss]

Astagfirullah how are you guys wasting too much energy in putting scholars down. Wa tum izzu man Tasha wa tuzillu man tashaa

[@MHabesA]

@@yougotthisshes not a scholar

[@NormalMuslim7]

​@@MenkIsAMubtadiiDeobandican you provide proof?

[@crowntailor]

I think you’re wrong He’s doing great explaining Quran Allah give you hedaiya

[@Anas.M-z7r]

Do you have knowledge to know if his tafsser is correct , it's not about you like it or not, it's about is it correct or not.

[@ahmedshawki5029]

Do you follow Allah and His messenger صَلَّى ٱللَّٰهُ عَلَيْهِ وَسَلَّمَ, or your own desires, if you follow Allah and his messenger, then judge by the criteria of Quran and Sunnah as learned by the Salfe Salehin

[@bestmaryam]

Are you reliable?

[@idearikas]

Yes. لا نزكي على الله أحد But he is بإذن الله على السنة.

[@undercoverangel1410]

Nope

[@undercoverangel1410]

🇵🇸

[@noordonia7082]

​@idearikas how are u sure?

[@jenniferjasmineo5787]

Lol what's funny is that people in the comments are criticising EVERY SINGLE MUFTI😂😂 like they have spent years studying Islam and the mufti's know nothing.. Honestly if everyone is misguided who should I listen to?.huh

[@IbnMazroofTech]

Same thing I am suffering with lol, so I became a ghayr muqallid & take knowledge from everyone but acting upon only the authenticated ones :)

[@aj__love5919]

Right🤣🤣🤣🤣 you summed it up pretty greatly

[@MHabesA]

Listen to الله and his messenger with the interpretations of the 3 favourite generations

[@axsanime8968]

Learn proper aqeeda bro ahlul sunna al jamah​@@IbnMazroofTech

[@IbnMazroofTech]

@@axsanime8968 I know it brotha, don't worry cuz I am persuing the islamic studies course. And literally there are a lot to learn about this all stuffs.

[@bayumaulana7882]

Have you done tabbayun with NAK?

[@mohammadiaa]

Brother Abu Mussab's refutations were very beneficial. Sadly his latest one on NAK got taken down due to copyright قدّر الله وما شاء فعل

[@MDshajahanMDshajahan-vb9wm]

Nouman ali didn't make any clear statement about music..but about evil eyes there are few videos he talked about and the whole point he tried to make is that Everything happens by the will of Allah, There is evil on earth ( he did tafseer on surah falaq, Naas) We should seek protection., and Allah allows those evil to happen in a limited way., the other points you made 'attributes of Allah' , just pick up any of his lecture he explained hour after hour about the greatness of Allah 's names..And i didn't find anywhere he said about backwards reading of Quran!

[@ahmedshawki5029]

There ar clear documents of his deviance, search it up

[@bilqisnjama1387]

Assalaam alaykum Please would you show us a video where he says music is halal

[@19shafaq]

It’s a manipulative statement about NAK, that was totally different statement what @nouman ali khan Nouman Ali Khan has said about music and he also mentioned that it his view he has never forced or declared his views on anyone he don’t even call himself a scholar, he always say that he is a student of Quran he is learning Quran and sharing his learnings and he wants others to do the same. Listening to this Vedio I am surprised how come people who claim that they have knowledge give a manipulative statements about others in public. May Allah guide us all.

[@acethegreat2946]

This is the video he lies and says music is halal kzbin.info/www/bejne/b4SwqYiCiKZmm9Esi=jKLovosrj_yo4rgF I used to like the guy. I spent years listening to his lectures but as the guy in the video, some mistakes can't be overlooked so I dropped listening to NAK. and in this video he says aqeedah is not important because it's not mentioned in the Quran. kzbin.info/www/bejne/o4rSiaSqfs-efpYsi=Ll90NT-AlDRLLQ9v What a deviant. Aqeedah literally means to believe what Allah and His messenger told us to believe and to disbelieve in what Allah and His messenger to us to disbelieve in. It doesn't matter if the exact word is used the Qur'an because the definition is all over the Qur'an.

[@acethegreat2946]

Here says music is halal kzbin.info/www/bejne/b4SwqYiCiKZmm9Esi=jKLovosrj_yo4rgF because it's quote on quote not mentioned in the Quran. and in this he says aqeedah is not important because it's quote on quote not mentioned in the Quran. kzbin.info/www/bejne/o4rSiaSqfs-efpYsi=Ll90NT-AlDRLLQ9v

[@KITRAMANKKITRAMANK]

May ALLAH Forgive and Guide us all

[@لاتداهن]

بارك الله فيكم وجزاكم الله خير الجزاء وأحسن الله إليكم ونفع بعلمكم

[@preciousdvine]

Please refrain from speaking negatively about anyone who has spent his lifetime learning quran. Sheikh if you have issues please speak privately to him instead of ruining him in social media. This is not how our Prophet PBUH would have done and this is not a sign of a good muslim. Who are we to point fingers on so many muslim brothers? No good muslim would speak in such manner and create chaos. Right now instead of focusing on Palestine and our brothers and sisters in the war zones we are focusing on pointing fingers on other muslim brothers. Not Right. if you are really so good speak about the ones suffering of our muslim brothers and sister in the warzones specially Palestine isntead of ruining the image of ourselves only and diving us. May Allah subhanawtala guide us to the right path.

[@ahmedshawki5029]

Those who publicly spread deviance should be publicly refuted,

[@keepitreelcatfishing5883]

NAK is wrong about marriage advice. He claimed that the money of the husband is also the wife’s money.

[@mukadasokediran4320]

Yea, I understand you're not doing it to be praise but You are looking for is downfall rit? Allah will elevate him for his effort in the deen

[@aj__love5919]

Ameen summa Ameen!!! Nouman Ali has helped me a lot I can never say anything bad about his lectures or him. Everyone makes mistakes, we are all human beings, we all take things out of context at times. To each its own I have no problem with Nouman Ali’s lectures

[@ahmedshawki5029]

@@aj__love5919 If nouman ali khan is more important than Allah and His prophetصَلَّى ٱللَّٰهُ عَلَيْهِ وَسَلَّمَ, then okay, go on with your own opinion,

[@statixlaw5675]

Asalamualaikum please make a video like this for Yasir Qadhi. He lives here in Texas with us and repeatedly spreads contradictions to usool as Sunnah. One of my brothers started listening to him and he started becoming more agnostic and I was so shocked because I kept telling him not to listen to Yasir Qadhi. Please do it, I ask Allah to reward you heavily in this world and the next if you do so explaining the aqeedqh principles he violates. JazakAllahu khairan ya Ustadh

[@JaimeAdamoSaide]

Don't listen to him

[@UdruusJayyida]

جزاكم الله خيرا وبارك الله فيكم

[@IndoraptorPlayz]

Assalamualaikum, Shaik please tell me if Nouman Ali Khan’s book Revive your heart authentic? Because I purchased the book last month but after this I have got doubts in my mind. Can you please read the book and list it as authentic or non authentic. Please Ya Shaik

[@Farishammadi]

@@IndoraptorPlayz Walaykum Assalam dont read anything this man writes or says. He is not reliable at all.

[@IndoraptorPlayz]

ok, Jazakallah Khair Shaik

[@uzmamohammadajazshaikh2242]

Bro how to ask you questions

[@UrDreamNet]

I don’t think we can take every word he says as a Ruling. When you teach people it requires a build up. I understand your point though. May Allah preserve you.

[@fidamuhammad2589]

I am sure this man has never listen to him( NAK) go and just talk to him personally on his mistakes

[@Ilm_an_nafi]

الحمد لله the video is back

[@carridonn4149]

Having listened to qadhi, he always bases his arguments on the various schools of thought. He advises viewers to choose that applies to them about matters that are grey. He also advises them to listen to their scholars in their countries and context. The US is different from Yemen, Arabia or Indonesia, so better to listen to the scholars there regarding grey areas. Listening to NAK, he uses the attributes of Allah on a constant basis. Perhaps he may have a different understanding of some concepts, but the methodology used here i dont think is perfect. Allahs knows best and may he guide us all where we falter and communicate to each other respectfully to enrich Iman.

[@rizzwan-42069]

You said boycotting is haram.

[@taimurahmad]

he said calling fpor boycott is haram collectively in mslim countries only not that individual boycott is haram--although scholars like sa'di say otherwise...vid between "farisalhammaadi and the scholars ibrahim ibn mahmud"

[@fbhistoriador]

Assalamu aleykum. What NAK did and does for many people would not be possible even with 1 million Salafi sheikhs, (this is not a criticism, it is a fact) but I understand the purpose of the criticism, unfortunately I can neither agree nor disagree. Allah is the one who will make the right judgement, and may He have mercy on us all.

[@abdulwadood.8]

Truly, incorrect. Just Shaykh Ibn Baz alone, the eminent scholar of from the land of Saudi Arabia, who passed away on about 1999 or 2000, ‎رحمه الله Affected millions of people, through him Allāh guided millions, he was the founder of the Islamic university of madina which has had hundreds of thousands of students, students who were taught authentic Islamic knowledge. This is just 1-2 achievements of the Shaykh Ibn Baz, he has done a lot. So just to make this short, your statement is wrong and you should retract it and infact repent, because you told a lie.

[@IbrahimaDrameh-hz7wz]

Yes your statement is true for misguiding 1 million people 😂 the salaf sheikhs are guiding people to the true Islam since the death of the prophet ﷺ till now. This is what happened if you follow people like NAK you’ll understand the salaf in a negative way

[@raheelmasood8656]

@@abdulwadood.8may be youtube was not there that is why no one refuted him. Now it is a fashion.

[@acethegreat2946]

Your lying. Look at what ibn Taymiyyah as just one Salafi scholar did. Over the last 800 years, billions of muslims have benefitted from him and he's helped shape empires such as the Ottomans (In their early days). and read about how he helped the muslim armies as they went to fight the mongols and won. And if you want a present day example, look at shaykh muqbil. He establish a center by himself in Yemen and it has produced thousands of students of knowledge who went back to their people and continue to benefit til today. How many students of knowledge has NAK produced? Not even one. He likes to teach arabic right? How many people did he teach the alfiyah of ibn Malik (a famous mid to low level book of arabic grammar)? I doubt he's even studied it. Just because millions of people watched his videos is an illusion. Look at quality not quantity.

[@acethegreat2946]

@@abdulwadood.8 You're without a doubt correct. Comparing the quality of students that ibn baz produced by the permission of Allah to the quality that NAK produced is an insult.

[@MenkIsAMubtadiiDeobandi]

No, just like Yasir qadhi who says shirk is not shirk but just haram. He is a woman please". Also haytham al haddad who hugged Yasir Qadhi. Remember don't follow celebrities.

[@nazeemaisha7030]

Change your user name

[@GO_142]

Your getting sins from your username and profile picture kinda shows what your character is like

[@MenkIsAMubtadiiDeobandi]

@@nazeemaisha7030 cheikh وصي الله عباس who teaches in makkah confirmed the username.

[@MenkIsAMubtadiiDeobandi]

@@GO_142 is cheikh وصي الله عباس also getting sins for saying the same thing??

[@rutbashaheen._.]

can you explain what has happened with nouman ali khan?? what did he do??​@@GO_142

[@treelover848]

What are you doing? Most of what you said about him is either wrong or taken out of context, are you really that comfortable destroying the dignity of another Muslim so easily for cheap views without even doing proper research? Seriously stop this foolishness.

[@nabilasahmed]

Exactly! Well said 👏 Some people forget that they will be called to account in front of Allah

[@aj__love5919]

All I’m saying is Nouman Ali’s videos have helped me a lot so people if you disagree with me good, if you agree with me good too that’s just life. We all have different opinions at times but I Like Nouman Ali’s lectures he’s helped me a lot and I won’t back talk about him it’s ridiculous

[@junaidrao05]

Can we as the Ummah please stop being divided on trivial things??? NAK is trying to do a good job maybe he might be a little misguided but we need to support him and tell him the right thing, not attack him. What is wrong with us??? Please unite as an Ummah. Our enemies are killing our people and we're here fighting with each other. We need to be one to fight against a common enemy not with one another. We are all brothers as Muslims. The enemy wants us to be divided so that we will remain distracted from being United. They fear us being United

[@hilalreshi5045]

My God this is a lie. He emphasises a lot about the attributes of Allah. He is so careful about it. And maybe you people are just not digesting his success. About evil eye he said that people are giving too much importance to evil eye, it is not the only thing.

[@malikattar1670]

Except this is not a lie. I stopped listening to NAK way before stumbling upon videos refuting him. My biggest red flag about him is how he openly mocks the Companions, the Tabi3in and the scholars. Especially scholars who do not align with him. Especially scholars who are long gone like At-Tabari & Abu Hanifah. He won’t often name them but sometimes he will like with At-Tabari, he will minimize them and minimize their work. This is not the way of the scholars. At some point, I stopped caring about him and how nice he is. If he gave me 30 nice things and one poisonous apple in between; it was gonna make everything else rotten. Who cares where Allāh is? Who cares about niyyah? Music is not haram. These are all things he said and mocked people who advised him against it. I used to believe he was genuine. But the way is sarcastically makes fun of people advising him and mocks old scholars. I pulled out. There are scholars he made fun who taught the ENTIRE religion to generations upon generations for free, they didn’t get a single dime for it. Then he goes mocking their work and charging 30$+ for a half baked explanation of a single surah and inside his explanation he takes a bit from here, a bit from what the Bible says, what the Jews say, what this obscure guy he won’t even name say. What is this? He will twist you in a way you won’t ever appreciate the beauty of Islam for what it really is. You will think religion is all about feeling good and being at peace and smiling and life is nice. Religion is a serious matter and he just doesn’t take it seriously in his acts despite everything he says. May Allāh guide him and us. Be wary brother. This deen is your only valuable asset on Judgement Day, be very very very cautious about whom you take it from. It is corrupt scholars that say whatever they want when they explain the religion that destroyed the Jews & the Christians. So let’s not follow their path.

[@hilalreshi5045]

@@malikattar1670 I appreciate your concern. It is interesting that in the new video uploaded on Bayyinah TV, he proudly calls himself a Hanafi and states how unfortunately many people aren't able to appreciate his work and knowledge and how overshadowed his genius is. Incidentally these days in the thematic overview of the Quran, the crux of his lectures center around how people should be reasonable and not just act upon feeling. And his reverence for the companions of the Prophet SAW is unmatched. I request you stop watching snippets from KZbin and see the whole picture. Jazakallah Khair.

[@MenkIsAMubtadiiDeobandi]

You are likely hired by him and trying to polish his image alongside your click buddies.

[@hilalreshi5045]

@@MenkIsAMubtadiiDeobandi I wish I was hired as I would have used some money.

[@MenkIsAMubtadiiDeobandi]

@@hilalreshi5045 then don't accuse him of lying. He is exposing a deviant misguided person who has misled people for years and now his followers are in the millions. You are disabling this.

[@omara9427]

Protest is Haram? I would have to question this so called Hadith. Quran allows you to fight or protest against those who fight against you, your beliefs and Islamic rights. “Fight in the cause of Allah ˹only˺ against those who wage war against you, but do not exceed the limits.” The Salaf had their Iman and understanding of God based on their culture, language and intellect at the time. Any learned man can pick up any device with a screen and read the Quran and cross reference Hadith and other explanations and come up with solutions on their own. You don’t need a scholar to tell you his opinion and how he understands God. We don’t want our Deen turned into Catholicism and how they control and feed people knowledge of God. Every man’s journey towards Allah and truth is different because we are all made different.

[@E.Cerulean]

I first studied Islam with him at his institute and his main issue is that he takes from MAJOR deviants (past and present). This is my opinion but I think he and his associates (like YQ) either dont truly believe in the Sunnah (bc they reject so many sahih ahadith) or they are trying to bring a new deviant way of understanding the Sunnah. YQ has an agenda (I know this from an inside source) but NAK I think he is just too influenced by the wrong people so he is very dangerous too

[@FPMASY]

May Allah guide NAK to Sunnah

[@ozone2126]

I used to listen to him, but then I stop

[@SalafiReminders]

Is it really that hard to notice that NAK is misguided? Let's just make it simple, is he a Salafi? No? Okay, move on! Stay away from people who are not Salafi!

[@ramizparkar4199]

And why should we stay away from people who are not Salafis, when Salafis disobey ahadith?

[@mohamedshembesh8688]

@@ramizparkar4199 disobeying fake Hadith you mean

[@mohamedshembesh8688]

If disobeying real sahih ahadith then this is not from salafiyah

[@ramizparkar4199]

@@mohamedshembesh8688 No, I'm talking about ahadith which scholars say are sahih (authentic)! Salafis ignore those!

[@mohamedshembesh8688]

@@ramizparkar4199 no they don’t, authobillah, I suspect you are Sufi/ Maturidi authobillah

[@MrBanana552]

Yeah say what you want about nauman ali khan, but his works in the quran tafseer is amazing and beneficial full stop

[@mohammadiaa]

We take the religion from reliable people. Would you take tafseer from a christian?

[@mohammadiaa]

@@MrBanana552 nouman ali khan, a man who mixes with ahlul bid'ah is reliable? Nice joke

[@MrBanana552]

​@@mohammadiaa Let me know who to take knowledge from then?

[@ansif3981]

Akhi his tafseer is not totally crrt. Take frm scholars if uk arabic like the masjid nabawi clsses channel. And othrs like ibn baz , bin uthaymeen , albani رحمهم الله . There r channels with their small clips several of it translated. Or take frm close studnts of othr ulama like in english garden of ilm channel utube.

[@MrBanana552]

@@ansif3981 okay jazakkalah, inshallah

[@shakilmahmud5996]

NAK has other bigger issues.He believes aqeeda isn’t important.He mocked the matter that people should do all good deeds only for the sake of Allah. These 2 are the biggest issue of Islam and he rejects both. Ngl I started reading the Quran with meaning and tafseer after watching his videos.But stopped watching him when Allah had mercy upon me and gave me right knowledge Alhamdulillah! May Allah guide him and save muslims from his misguidance.

[@FPMASY]

That matter is bigger than Hassad, may Allah guide him

[@FPMASY]

If he has Aqeeda problem he is gone, cancelled from roots

[@shakilmahmud5996]

@@FPMASY He openly said that aqeeda isn’t important. I just stopped watching him.

[@noorunnisa7]

Can you send me the link where he said aqeedah is not important

[@shakilmahmud5996]

@@noorunnisa7kzbin.info/www/bejne/o4rSiaSqfs-efpYsi=P62mblheddxOBsRD here we go.NAK ranting 8 minutes straight. Every single point he made here is false. He is not just misguided but also misguides people in a way that is terrible. Misinterpreting the Quran, belittling the scholars,and discouraging people from the books of scholars and the list goes on. This happens when someone thinks he is knowledgeable enough to understand the Quran on his own and learn the deen without taking knowledge of the salaf. May Allah guide him and save people from his misguidance.

[@SJ-jz8wx]

JazakAllah khair ustadh, please viewers see sheikh Abu zaid zameer’s video clips in Urdu on Nauman Ali khan he also highlighted his mistakes.

[@salamsweet2100]

Alhamdulillah nice advice may Allah sobhanutala give us guidance Ameen

[@farhatfatima181]

I have not heard any of this videos saying this.. is it true guys?

[@zainsdifferent5014]

No this is an extremist opinion. He is basically saying anyone who isnt a salafi is misguided.. Its laughable for him to say that the vast majority of Sunni scholars are misguided lmao. He is straight up lying when he says there is consensus on those issues. Consensus among salafis maybe who make up a tiny percentage of the Muslim population.

[@ramshasaleem4759]

Nak says music is halal and evil eye doesn’t exist

[@h.f3544]

yes, it is true.

[@h.f3544]

@@zainsdifferent5014 considering that a minority in the Ummah pray 5 times a day does not make that invalidated. The same applies to the salafis, which follow the Sunnah and Quran in the original way. It does not matter how many are correct, what is important is to know majority is following innovations and deviations , what is quite alarming.

[@zainsdifferent5014]

@@h.f3544 The majority of Sunni scholars don't pray 5x a day? That's news to me.

[@khaledabdelnaser05]

جزاكَ اللهُ خيرًا

[@mukadasokediran4320]

May Allah protect us and you guys from your hatred speech, NAK( may Allah have mercy on him) has never come out in public to accused you guys. You are saying what you are saying with no proof that he said

[@notoriouscruyff8260]

We simply apply Jaarh and Ta'deel. He commited mistakes like fabricating hadiths and that is a huge thing that he has not retracted after the brothers have tried to advise him in private (which he has completely neglected). Therefore, we don't take this indivudual for knowledge of the deen of Allah. Like ibn Sirin said: This knowledge is your deen, so beware from whom you receive your deen

[@yaseen692]

The guy made it very clear.. he said, " You should know where I come from!?.. that's ego talking to you guys.. He's a saudi from you know where.. so what do you expect?!?! Mr. Al Hammadi... rent your own hall, gather 2000 people and get NAK to come and debate..or test his knowledge in Quran. He might excel your knowledge.

[@Farishammadi]

@@yaseen692 kzbin.info7TcKaZP5zc4?si=Y1upPo7inX9T8p51

[@sabreenausman576]

Say something about Palestine. Palestinians are dying and you say nothing. Rest ethg after that

[@undercoverangel1410]

I wish he said nothing....He is against the boycott. He went as far as to offer a new convert cola which has a factory in the settlement zones. I literally clicked to see the audacity...he is the last person in the universe to be talking about people misguiding people...his hypocrisy is terrifying..

[@FootballPeople-tv7si]

(just speaking from the point of view of someone who listened to a bunch of NAK analysis) he brings up Allah being above us. He brings up music not from the point of view that it is halal but from the point of view that people tend to be convinced of things being haram without definite daleel so like if a scholar argues music is haram sure but if a random 18 year old is haram policing without understanding the matter him/herself he has a problem with that attitude. Cant speak for the rest. lets not compare anyone to a rapist. Allah knows best.

[@shadansaleemkhan4651]

Sheikh then what about different riwayahs like riwayat hafs and shoba

[@rizzwan-42069]

It's like i can choose between 4 harakt madd and 2 harakat madd except in this case in riwayah differences tend to be vowel changes. For example in surah rahman there's a verse in riwayah shoaba that can be recited with kasra or fatha, but in hafs it's read with only fatha. This topic is more complex for me so I'd recommend finding more specialized resources. It's like going to the dentist when you're supposed to go to the orthodontist.

[@bingbong-m5r]

BarakAllahu feek shaykh

[@sarkarmahbub9304]

In the end we all are humans we make mistake that’s our nature no one is perfect neither you

[@mewzi]

I have a full playlist against NAK Alhamdulillah Very clear he is misguided

[@Jammylune]

Baraka Allahu feek ya Ustadh, may Allah bless you and your family! I have known NAK for more than a decay, and he is one the MOST DEVIANT AND MISGUIDED SPEAKER IN THE WEST.... There are many other deviant BELIEFS he holds regarding Islam, and he MISGUIDEDS masses, and he promotes all kind of falsehood.... Jazaka Allahu khairan for this beneficial video!

[@maryammudassir9507]

Please can you give me an example I’m really curious

[@scrsonsam9199]

Don't forget that he says aqeedah is not important because if it is, it should be mentioned in the Quran (insert confused Mr.Bean face) 😂

[@Qaranwadani1993]

Imagine Rabbi Faris attacking anyone? Lol

[@coffe2270]

@@Qaranwadani1993your mum is a rabbi lol

[@ponderingspirit1475]

​@@Qaranwadani1993Muslims are not Rabbis, beware of making takfir

[@amatullah4977]

جزاك الله خير❤

[@janferiancik5]

So he disagree with attributes of Allah swt and that he is above creation or he just doesn't speak about it?

[@h.f3544]

it is worse, he does not even mention it,. Never. As if these fundamental concepts do not exist in Islam.

[@janferiancik5]

So fundamental concepts that Abu hanifa, imam malik and shafi never really talked about them neither.

[@acethegreat2946]

@@janferiancik5 They did. One of the most famous statements about Allah being above the throne is by Imam Malik. One day as Malik is in the masjid, a guy came up and asked how did Allah rise over the throne? Malik got angry and said, "Allah rising above the throne is known (because it's mentioned in the Qur'an), believing that Allah rose over the throne is mandatory and asking how is an innovation." So don't lie about these scholars

[@janferiancik5]

​@@acethegreat2946yes this story is only one so far I heard that is there, about istawa of Allah swt. Is there some others from these scholars? Any talking about such an "fundamental concepts" as "hand" "face" ....

[@acethegreat2946]

@janferiancik5 your ignorance is a product of you not surrounding yourself with knowledge. Read the musannaf of abdurrazaq for starters

[@ThsThslegal-cw3dj]

And we should listen to you?

[@proud2bmuslimah1]

Assalamualaikum Can you please give a word about Mufti Menk and Sheikh Assim Al Hakeem as well? They are spread over everywhere, and everyone seems to be following them

[@taimurahmad]

mufti menk is a no go. Assim al hakeem has mistakes but good in fiqh.

[@h.f3544]

Sheikh Assim Al Hakeem is a good Sheikh, he follows the Sunnah and Quran . " Mufti " Menk is from a deobandi sect, a deviated one.

[@faaniinsaan2528]

May Allah protect us from misguided people like Noman Ali Khan

[@mahajaved3883]

About music I agree that is not right. Music is haram, but the video published isn't complete. We not sure what he said afterwards. So can't completely judge. About Aqeedah, I watched the video what he said is simply that don't complicate matters, just teach what's in the Quran and what Allah said is very simply that just pray to Him, make dua to Him. If this foundation is strong which is taught in Quran, you won't be involved in the shirk major or minor so Quran is simple, learn from it That's it This was so right About evil eye, he agreed to evil eye but the stereotype that everything is bcz of evil eye that he doesn't agree with As lot of people do apply makeup overnight and then say it's bcz of evil eye I got acne so it's not bcz of that This is what he said which again is right Yeah few things he might say which aren't so accurate But not a single person is accurate in this world Take the information, do your research Take what's right and leave what's wrong That's what Allah gave you brain for Don't waste your deeds about talking bad about others

[@AsSalafAsSalih]

You do not need to listen to Nouman Ali Khan when we have lectures and videos from the great Ulama of this ummah. We have quotes and books from the salaf as salih. We have ahadith of Rasool’Allah صلى الله عليه وسلم. We have Al Qur’an. Listen to the likes of Shaykh ibn Uthaymeen, Shaykh ibn Baz and Shaykh Salih Al Fawzan. Read books from the likes of Imam Ahmad ibn Hanbal and Imam Ash Shafi’i. Allahu’Musta’an

[@thetruth27786]

They lied about nouman ali khan like how people lied nabi saw married aisha at 6 and waited till she became older to sleep woth her because they speak up for women Most women love nouman ali khan,he speaks correct knowledge when it comes to women against misogyny,there's no proper proof of the filth they invented against him.

[@azzahra8495]

Baarakallaahu feekum Ustadh, I'm from Indonesia, Mufti Menk will come to my country, can you make the same type of video about Mufti Menk?

[@97_Crown_vic]

BarakAllahu feek

[@deen4_All]

Pls make a vid on Omar Suleiman also. I have close relatives listening to him

[@MDshajahanMDshajahan-vb9wm]

@deen4_All Omar Suleiman doing great., why do you need his confirmation about other scholars??

[@handleandbrake]

I smell foul intentions in this VIDEO... May Almighty Allah forgive us all. Pls don't use ambiguous reference of some scholars says that u say in start and then using ur biases ... u need to be open to discussion rather than following ur 'sect' ... pls talk to him in open debate rather than doing what u r doing now. Is there not any fiqhi rules and violations on what u r doing ... ? All are bad and deviants except u ... kidding ...not serious for those who might misunderstand my comment. Just a question ... do u ever actually talk on what u should be actually talking upon instead of leg pulling each other s.? AVOID 'SCHOLARS'WHO THEMSELVES SHY AWAY FROM REAL STUFF AND KEEP THEMSELVES BUSY TO BRING DOWN OTHERS WHO DO WHAT IS BEST IN THEIR CAPACITY !

[@keepitreelcatfishing5883]

NAK gives simpy marriage advice

[@Qaranwadani1993]

You sound bitter and have relationship problems with women. NAK isn't your issue, man.

[@ozone2126]

❤❤❤❤

[@abdulkarim-sw4eb]

All you said about him i agree Excpet the last protest thing I think you need to fear Allah and read the hadith about rulers in Sahih Muslims ....the worst of your rulers are those whom you hate...... When they make laws against Islam you keep quite but when someone says this is haram You ( not you personally but people with that fikir) call that person kawarij my advice shiike The verse in sura towaba Is against this They have taken their احبار and monks as ارباب other than Allah Ask a jew ,he will say we don't worship them ,so this verse is about law So Allah forgive me if I am wrong but I heard so Muslim countries have allowed public relations women and men So if a sheike says this is haram People say he is a kawarj I see those people are under the threat of this verse which I have mentioned So Allah quide me you and all of us Ameen

[@FatemaAbouElEla]

لا حول ولا قوة الا بالله. May Allah guide you for doing such harm.

[@detoxpractice6533]

Protest is Haram? You tube is a place of confusion too. NAK is an Evanglical preacher plus safeguarding his greencard and american passport just likes of yasir Qadi etc American based scholars should not be trusted for authenticity of knowledge.

[@quaerite_sapientiam]

Salam alaikum brother, do you still hold the position of boycotting us useless and it’s not a WAJIB at this point, I mean those companies do business with Israel, they help them in evey way shape or form, this is facts, are you still on the position of it’s no problem to still consume products who are linked to Israel? JAZAK lah khyran

[@fatytim2771]

So you want everyone to listen to you only? Are you a true Muslim? Why you are cosing Fitna??? Go and speak with Nouman instead of speaking behind his back!!!! May Allah guide you 1 st because you need this more

[@akiim1532]

stay away from people like NAK Yasir Qadhi and even Yaqeen institute has a lot of deviant papers and content. They all support each other

[@Spmrue5831]

You couldn’t be more clear

[@afrinhussain8783]

You support King Salman.You did not make any video against him rather you make video in support him . King Salman make All Haram things. Halal , music , nudity , non muslim enter in Holy sities support israel . Allah is the best planers

[@crowntailor]

Who are you ? What is you knowledge

[@aljoumeyli]

No to Nouman Ali Khan, Muhammad Hijab, Ali Da'wa, Yasir Qadhi, period. ⚠

[@ramizparkar4199]

Then no to Salafis who don't say a word when Al Saud mock Islam!

[@h.f3544]

include " Mufti " Menk also.

[@ramizparkar4199]

@@h.f3544 Then the Salafi madhhab in general for neglecting something in the ahadith!

[@taimurahmad]

@@ramizparkar4199 negelcted what..?

[@ramizparkar4199]

@@taimurahmad Here's the thing: If the Prophet (ﷴ ﷺ) said that his beloved cousin, Ali ibn Abu Talib, was the leader of the Muslims after him, then will you accept it? And send my regards to Shahzad Ashraf for sharing your post! Jami‘ut-Tirmidhi 3719, Book 49, Ḥadith 116, graded ‘Ḥasan’ by Darussalam: “حَدَّثَنَا إِسْمَاعِيلُ بْنُ مُوسَى، قَالَ حَدَّثَنَا شَرِيكٌ، عَنْ أَبِي إِسْحَاقَ، عَنْ حُبْشِيِّ بْنِ جُنَادَةَ، قَالَ قَالَ رَسُولُ اللهِ صلى الله عليه وسلم ‏ "‏ عَلِيٌّ مِنِّي وَأَنَا مِنْ عَلِيٍّ وَلاَ يُؤَدِّي عَنِّي إِلاَّ أَنَا أَوْ عَلِيٌّ."‏‏ قَالَ أَبُو عِيسَى هَذَا حَدِيثٌ حَسَنٌ غَرِيبٌ صَحِيحٌ.‏ Narrated to us Isma‘il ibn Musa, he said: “Narrated to us Sharik, from Abi Is-ḥaq, from Ḥubshi bin Junadah, he said: “The Messenger of Allah (ﷺ) said: “`Ali is from me and I am from ‘Ali. And none represents me except myself or ‘Ali.”””” Sunan Ibn Majah, Volume 1, Book 1, Ḥadith 121 (126 in Arabic), graded ‘Ṣaḥiḥ’ (Authentic) by Darussalam: “حَدَّثَنَا عَلِيُّ بْنُ مُحَمَّدٍ، حَدَّثَنَا أَبُو مُعَاوِيَةَ، حَدَّثَنَا مُوسَى بْنُ مُسْلِمٍ، عَنِ ابْنِ سَابِطٍ، - وَهُوَ عَبْدُ الرَّحْمَنِ - عَنْ سَعْدِ بْنِ أَبِي وَقَّاصٍ، قَالَ قَدِمَ مُعَاوِيَةُ فِي بَعْضِ حَجَّاتِهِ فَدَخَلَ عَلَيْهِ سَعْدٌ فَذَكَرُوا عَلِيًّا فَنَالَ مِنْهُ فَغَضِبَ سَعْدٌ وَقَالَ تَقُولُ هَذَا لِرَجُلٍ سَمِعْتُ رَسُولَ اللهِ ـ صلى الله عليه وسلم ـ يَقُولُ ‏"‏ مَنْ كُنْتُ مَوْلاَهُ فَعَلِيٌّ مَوْلاَهُ ‏."‏ وَسَمِعْتُهُ يَقُولُ ‏"‏ أَنْتَ مِنِّي بِمَنْزِلَةِ هَارُونَ مِنْ مُوسَى إِلاَّ أَنَّهُ لاَ نَبِيَّ بَعْدِي ‏."‏ وَسَمِعْتُهُ يَقُولُ ‏"‏ لأُعْطِيَنَّ الرَّايَةَ الْيَوْمَ رَجُلاً يُحِبُّ اللهَ وَرَسُولَهُ."‏ Narrated to us `Ali ibn Muḥammad: “Narrated to us Abu Mu`awiyah: “Narrated to us Musa ibn Muslim, from Ibn Sabiṭ, and he is `Abdur-Raḥman, from Sa`d ibn Abi Waqqaṣ, he said “Mu`awiyah came on one of his pilgrimages and Sa`d entered upon him. They mentioned `Ali, and Mu`awiyah criticized him. Sa`d became angry and said: “Are you saying this of a man of whom I heard the Messenger of Allah (ﷺ) say: “Whomsoever I am a Mawla of, then `Ali is his Mawla.” And I heard him say: “You (`Ali) are from me, with the Manzilah (Position) of Harun (Aaron) from Musa (Moses), except that there is no Prophet after me.” And I heard him say: “I will give the banner today to a man who loves Allah and His Messenger.””””” Musnad Aḥmad 961, Book 5, Ḥadith 386; Darussalam graded it ‘Ḥasan’ because of “corroborating evidence”: “حَدَّثَنَا عَبْد اللهِ، حَدَّثَنِي عُبَيْدُ اللهِ بْنُ عُمَرَ الْقَوَارِيرِيُّ، حَدَّثَنَا يُونُسُ بْنُ أَرْقَمَ، حَدَّثَنَا يَزِيدُ بْنُ أَبِي زِيَادٍ، عَنْ عَبْدِ الرَّحْمَنِ بْنِ أَبِي لَيْلَى، قَالَ شَهِدْتُ عَلِيًّا رَضِيَ اللهُ عَنْهُ فِي الرَّحَبَةِ يَنْشُدُ النَّاسَ أَنْشُدُ اللهَ مَنْ سَمِعَ رَسُولَ اللهِ صَلَّى اللهُ عَلَيْهِ وَسَلَّمَ يَقُولُ يَوْمَ غَدِيرِ خُمٍّ مَنْ كُنْتُ مَوْلَاهُ فَعَلِيٌّ مَوْلَاهُ لَمَّا قَامَ فَشَهِدَ قَالَ عَبْدُ الرَّحْمَنِ فَقَامَ اثْنَا عَشَرَ بَدْرِيًّا كَأَنِّي أَنْظُرُ إِلَى أَحَدِهِمْ فَقَالُوا نَشْهَدُ أَنَّا سَمِعْنَا رَسُولَ اللهِ صَلَّى اللهُ عَلَيْهِ وَسَلَّمَ يَقُولُ يَوْمَ غَدِيرِ خُمٍّ أَلَسْتُ أَوْلَى بِالْمُؤْمِنِينَ مِنْ أَنْفُسِهِمْ وَأَزْوَاجِي أُمَّهَاتُهُمْ فَقُلْنَا بَلَى يَا رَسُولَ اللهِ قَالَ فَمَنْ كُنْتُ مَوْلَاهُ فَعَلِيٌّ مَوْلَاهُ ٱَللّٰهُمَّ وَالِ مَنْ وَالَاهُ وَعَادِ مَنْ عَادَاهُ‏.‏ Narrated to us ‘Abdullah: “Narrated to me ‘Ubaidullah ibn ‘Umar Al-Qawaririy: “Narrated to us Yunus ibn Arqam: “Narrated to us Yazid ibn Abi Ziyad, from ‘Abdur-Raḥman bin Abi Laila, he said: “l saw ‘Ali (رضي الله عنه) in Ar-Raḥbah, adjuring the people, (saying): “I adjure by Allah anyone who heard the Messenger of Allah (ﷺ) say on the day of Ghadir Khumm: “Whomsoever I am a Mawla of, then ‘Ali is his Mawla,” to stand up and testify.”” ‘Abdur-Raḥman said: “And twelve men of Badr stood up. It is as if I can see one of them. And they said: “We bear witness that we heard the Messenger of Allah (ﷺ) say on the day of Ghadir Khumm: “Am I not awla (closer) to the believers than their own selves, and my wives are their mothers?” We said: “Yes indeed, O Messenger of Allah (ﷺ).” He said: “Then whomsoever I am a Mawla of, then `Ali is his Mawla; Allahumma wali (O God, take as friends) those who walahu (take him as a friend), and take as enemies those who take him as an enemy.””””””””

[@husainahmad1542]

جزاك الله خيرا

[@Thobe_Bryant_]

Not to mention he said that aqeedah is not important and is not mentioned in the Quran….

[@watermelon8057]

Faaris, you often speak haqq and when you speak haqq u need to be more direct, stop caring about what these people think. Trash NAK because he deserves to be trashed, trash him and his reputation with zero remorse. Please stop being so nice, it takes away from the refutation. This man NAK has been upon what you mentioned for many long years, enough is enough! Trash him, no need to water down or have a nice tone at all.

[@idearikas]

You're right, but it could backfire. Many people are emotionally attached to that personality so when they discover the truth and find that it was all wrong, it's not that easy to accept. Now imagine broth Faris, on top of that, adding some harshness to the criticism, that would make NAK look like a victim in the eyes of those people and thus it wouldn't serve the main purpose here, which is guiding these very people.

[@fatytim2771]

Nouman never said that evil eye doest exist!!!! Please do not try to impres us with your poor Qoranic Arabic Better for you not to speak

[@Nouralislam28]

The video is back🎉

[@IbrahimaDrameh-hz7wz]

Alhamdulillah

[@qasirali1364]

Evil eye is wrong educate yoursekf

[@thatiswhyali]

Too much jealousy

[@mz8452]

Rabbi Faris maybe the Jews like you believe in a magical sky fairy but Muslims know that Allah is the creator of places and directions and no place or direction contains Him. تعالى الله عن مشابهة المخلوقين

[@VexLooter]

Nice job, your adhab will surely convince everyone to see your point and take it seriously. Keep doing it, your baseless slander will give him free hasanat and you will stand before Allah and get punished for spreading fitnah ya fatan.

[@mohammadiaa]

So when Allaah says he's above the throne, he's a jew God? When the slave girl pointed up and Muhammad ﷺ said she's a muslim, did he actually mean she's a Jew?

[@taimurahmad]

When the wuran said Allah above His throne is the quran lying????

[@taimurahmad]

And Allah exists we exist so is this also tajseem?

[@Muhammad_Nuruddin]

When Allah said that He is above the throne, are you saying that Allah is wrong?

[@samsmitec]

Brother. Why are hellbent on distributing all your Hasanaat among the Du'aat?

[@muadth2004]

al-Imām Aḥmad said: “There is no backbiting of the people of innovation” وقال الإمام أحمد: «لا غيبة لأصحاب البدع» طبقات الحنابلة (274/2) Ibrāhīm (an-Nakhaʿī) said: “There is not backbiting for the people of innovation” وعن إبراهيم قال: «ليس لصاحب بدعة غيبة» الإبانة (2/ 449) al-Ḥasan al-Baṣrī said: “There is no backbiting for the people of innovation, and for the Fāsiq who openly does his immorality” وعن الحسن قال: «ليس لصاحب بدعة غيبة، ولا الفاسق يعلن فسقه غيبة» شرح أصول السنة للالكائي (158/1) Ismāʿīl ibn ʿUlyah said about (giving) criticism: “Indeed this is a trust (Amānah) not backbiting” وقال إسماعيل بن علية في الجرح: «إن هذا أمانة ليس بغيبة» الكفاية للخطيب ص: 61 Shu‘bah said: “Come, let us go backbite for the sake of Allah for an hour”, meaning, let us mention the criticism and the praise. وقال شعبة : تعالوا حتى نغتاب في الله ساعة يعني: تذكر الجرح والتعديل الكفاية للخطيب البغدادي ص 62

[@qasirali1364]

Behave shaykh stop it you need guiding yourself

[@qasirali1364]

You are wrong how do i contact you ?

[@paragjyotideka1246]

He is a crypto Jew. Don't even need to talk. He is a liar.

[@idearikas]

Better contact yourself, you need it.

[@uzmamohammadajazshaikh2242]

Bro how to ask you questions