IS MUSIC REALLY HARAM? With Eng. Subtitles - SHEIKH UTHMAN IBN FAROOQ

[@zahiruddin2610]

I quit MUSIC.......

[@SoufBouchahati]

Look at the comment section, Its sickening and mind boggling to see that on this issue of music, most muslims will say anything to justify music, because of some stupid whims,desire and addiction. Risking hellfire all together just to prove to himself that somehow its halal even when the evidence is presented. Wallahi sickminded people. I am being honest, yes, I myself listen to music from time to time, but I cant deny it absolutely haram. It diminshes my imaan, and takes away the sweetness of quran out of my heart, even if the lyrics are good. Dont fool yourself, there is nothing good in music. At least admit its haram, instead of evoking the wrath of Allah and risking hellfire for making haram in halal.

[@suhilawrasul4097]

Yes the first musical instrument was by shaytan, many don’t know; piano is the most evil of all the instruments

[@DreamIsh-dy5ix]

Hey brother. Just wanted to help you out. Listen to beautiful nasheeds first such as wedding,I rise etc. then w@r nasheeds such as jundllah, lightning. Then replace them with Qur'an. This worked for me so well. Inshallah for you too :)). May Allah help you for speaking the haqq. ( Btw you won't leave music in first moment, you'll slowly slowly leave inshallah).

[@pashapa11]

Anyone who thinks music is halal, i challenge you. Stop listening for one week. If you hear your favorites in your head still. If it still pulls you toward it then reflect why. If you can listen to quran for the same amount of time as you listen to music. Then reflect why its haram.

[@annonymousghostdetector8425]

u r my favourite uthman , who tells in detail unlike other scholars

[@shadowstorm5261]

He is not a scholar and so isn't Norman Ali Khan.

[@sohailkhan980]

This is the ummah now justifying own desires even with clear instruction n the effects it causes. Everything happens with the will of the almighty Allah. U can bs to the world but only he knows whats in our hearts. I use to listen to music and then one day the addiction of listening to music just simply vanished. Alhamdulillah to the almighty for guiding me and i pray Allah vanishes this sickness from all my brothers n sisters. Ameen

[@masterlee6828]

Music is considered haram (forbidden) in Islam, regardless of personal opinions or agreements. Allah's commands take precedence over individual perspectives.

[@NedimTabakovic]

If imams are your gods, why you even care, hell is certainty for such belief.

[@jackeylynch]

Allah didn't make music haram.. men did.. be honest in your statement.. with that said, youre making Imams and scholars partners with Allah.. a big no no..

[@masterlee6828]

The sources of Islamic law is Alquran, hadist and Ijma. Hadith: Prophet Muhammad (peace be upon him) said, "There will be people among my followers who will consider illicit sexual relations, silk, and musical instruments as permissible." (Bukhari)

[@NedimTabakovic]

​@@masterlee6828 Nope.

[@masterlee6828]

​@@NedimTabakovicWhat no, are you muslim?

[@rameezfakih8553]

Subhan Allah. May Allah increase you in knowledge

[@NedimTabakovic]

Well he surely need it to climb up from ignorance.

[@Repentingsinner1]

Cry​@@NedimTabakovic

[@NedimTabakovic]

@@Repentingsinner1 Why?

[@iqraa5557]

Very well explained

[@rizzkk1]

Mashallah aki May allah reward you for the effert u make so we Can understand our deen better.

[@Itielbryce]

Detailed enough alhamdulillah

[@SamanRex]

7:00 why no one say amusement rides/parks haram.?

[@Maha_s1999]

Not all music is equal. Of course there are revolting pop stars, but even the Qur’an is musical in its own right. Plenty of classical music for example is amazing and noble. A woman’s awrah isn’t the entire body. Sheikhs like these are just misery merchants trying to feel relevant by making absolutely everything reasonable haram.

[@JamesWilliams-co8qg]

Just like the jews did!

[@Rathore12438]

I feel pitty for you

[@Maha_s1999]

@@Rathore12438 Feel free to waste your time. If I want to listen to Mozart I will still listen to it. People like you are the reason why there is so much bad judgement about Islam.

[@Rathore12438]

@@Maha_s1999 And are you the type of people that Islam needs as its ambassador?

[@Rathore12438]

@@Maha_s1999 Sheikhs like these are not misery merchants....Sheikhs like these have ACTUALLY reverted scores of nonmuslims. Sheikh Usman does open Dawah to the non-muslims and has defended Islam in open in debate corners against the likes of David THE HAMMERHEAD Wood, Sam THE BULL Shamoun and Anthony THE CROOKED which resulted in many christians coming in the fold of Islam. Either you haven't gone through Sheikh Uthman's KZbin page. He is in actual a GANGSTER turned preacher.

[@meinwebserver]

Translation of ghina is not music but singing

[@PASSIFICATION]

LAHVU means VAIN/MEANINGLESS/DEVIOUS. HADEETH means SPEECH. that means every speech n text that contradicts allah's clear commandments. eg. COMMUNIST MANIFESTO, BIBLE etc. the discussion is on MUSIC. using musical instruments.

[@thedude2000zify]

You are not a scholar, and have not spend time learning Arabic, tafseer, fiqh, and other religious knowledge. Stop making these comments about matters you have no idea about.

[@PASSIFICATION]

@@thedude2000zify did u get some kinda divine revelation regarding that?

[@HamishandIsmael]

To judge something first we have to define it, or what principle in Usul al fiqih says " حكم على الشي فرع تصوره. So what is music ?

[@Orcaboy]

My conclusion from this is that music is still not haram, but many forms of it are - arguably the most popular forms. Music has the power to psychologically help people with dementia, it has the power to convey great messages to people and empower them. Music has many benefits. You can say “well Quran could do all those things and do so better”. This maybe so, but that shouldn’t make this meaningful music i just described, haram. What is haram is VAIN talk. What is haram is IDOLIZATION of anything other than God I.e. fans idolizing Taylor Swift. But this doesn’t make the concept of music itself haram. And the fact that there is a strong debate on this is proof. The Quran is clear on what it forbids us.

[@jasonthemuslim652]

Narrated Abu 'Amir or Abu Malik Al-Ash'ari: that he heard the Prophet (ﷺ) saying, "From among my followers there will be some people who will consider illegal sexual intercourse, the wearing of silk, the drinking of alcoholic drinks and the use of musical instruments, as lawful. And there will be some people who will stay near the side of a mountain and in the evening their shepherd will come to them with their sheep and ask them for something, but they will say to him, 'Return to us tomorrow.' Allah will destroy them during the night and will let the mountain fall on them, and He will transform the rest of them into monkeys and pigs and they will remain so till the Day of Resurrection."

[@Orcaboy]

@@jasonthemuslim652it depends if you take it in the context of the entire teachings of Islam and Quran, or out of context. He was referring to specific culture. What about these hadith. Bukhari 949 Allah's Messenger (ﷺ) (p.b.u.h) came to my house while two girls were singing beside me the songs of Buath (a story about the war between the two tribes of the Ansar, the Khazraj and the Aus, before Islam). The Prophet (p.b.u.h) lay down and turned his face to the other side. Then Abu Bakr came and spoke to me harshly saying, "Musical instruments of Satan near the Prophet (p.b.u.h) ?" Allah's Messenger (ﷺ) (p.b.u.h) turned his face towards him and said, "Leave them." When Abu Bakr became inattentive, I signaled to those girls to go out and they left. It was the day of `Id, and the Black people were playing with shields and spears; so either I requested the Prophet (p.b.u.h) or he asked me whether I would like to see the display. I replied in the affirmative. Then the Prophet (p.b.u.h) made me stand behind him and my cheek was touching his cheek and he was saying, "Carry on! O Bani Arfida," till I got tired. The Prophet (p.b.u.h) asked me, "Are you satisfied (Is that sufficient for you)?" I replied in the affirmative and he told me to leave. Bukhari 952 Abu Bakr came to my house while two small Ansari girls were singing beside me the stories of the Ansar concerning the Day of Buath. And they were not singers. Abu Bakr said protestingly, "Musical instruments of Satan in the house of Allah's Messenger (ﷺ) !" It happened on the `Id day and Allah's Messenger (ﷺ) said, "O Abu Bakr! There is an `Id for every nation and this is our `Id."

[@SheikhTariqAl-Quadir]

@@Orcaboy Bro can you differentiate between singing and music ? If yes , then you can justify the claim?

[@SheikhTariqAl-Quadir]

The exception to music is during medical conditions and other things when needed ,in this matter it is not disputed ,as you said ,it is a disease and music helps to cure them then its good but listening to it in general is haram.

[@farazahmed5166]

But how can something haram EVER be good? Is this the case with anything else in Islam? One could say if you drink anti-freeze, the cure is to immediately drink ethanol I.e. alcohol. But alcohol is explicitly mentioned in the Quran as with benefits, but the problems outweigh the benefits, so avoid because humans are weak minded and will be slaves to it. As it evident with society. But for music no such distinction is made whereby it is forbidden. Rather, the context of it’s use alongside haram activities is. Eg. Go to a night club; people drink, fornicate etc - and do so to certain kinds of music. Bob Dylan writing songs about liberation of slaves and the poor etc, inspiring generations to do better for their fellow human. There is a distinction here.

[@shamsali9903]

In the Name of Allah, Most Gracious and Most Merciful وَالَّذِينَ كَفَرُوا بَعْضُهُمْ أَوْلِيَاءُ بَعْضٍ ۚ إِلَّا تَفْعَلُوهُ تَكُن فِتْنَةٌ فِي الْأَرْضِ وَفَسَادٌ كَبِيرٌ And those who disbelieve are allies of one another, (and) if you (Muslims of the whole world collectively) do not do so [i.e. become allies, as one united block under one Khalifah (a chief Muslim ruler for the whole Muslim world) to make victorious Allah's religion of Islamic Monotheism], there will be Fitnah (wars, battles, polytheism) and oppression on the earth, and a great mischief and corruption (appearance of polytheism). 8: 73 Why are we Muslims not talking about reestablishing the power and control Allah SWT give us from the beginning? The command is to unite under one Khalifah. The number one concern on the minds of the Muslims is the tragedy in Gazza. The destruction in Gazza is worse than that of Hiroshima and Nagasaki combined. The Zionist Israelis are the modern day Amelak as they were a tribe from nation of the Israelites and their brutality in Gazza and West Bank is the evidence. We have to listen to what Allah SWT is saying to us in the above verse and from the beginning. "And Remember when your Lord said to the Angels, I am going place Khalifah on earth".... 2: 30 You see the UN which controlled by USA, is dead body in the muddy water as every resolution passed by majority, is vetoed by USA. Which means we have to create a balance of power in the world by creating United League of Muslim Nations. Which is to reestablish the Caliphate because we are children of Adam, peace be upon him . "United League of Muslim Nations" under one Khalifah will be a strictly defensive Force with a quick response to any threat to the Ummah of Islam. And it is easy to do it. It will be the Council of Muftis, from which they will choose the Khalifah. Under the Khalifah will be a seat for a Mufti from every country in world with 100,000 plus Muslim population as Islam is for entire World. From every municipality we will choose a representative till we have the Council of Muftis for that country with a Grand Mufti of that country to sit in the Council of Muftis under the Khalifah. All communication can be done remotely with everyone working from home. Most effective and real democratic way of governing where all decisions are made by the Council of Muftis but the Khalifah having the final say. Under the Khalifah, the "ULMN" will have its own army, navy and Air Force under one commander for defending the entire ummah. We already have the hardware from major Muslim countries. They just have to be relabeled "ULMN" when they out to defend any part of the Ummah like removing the Mediterranean Sea blockade by Israelis.The four letters "ULMN" will be enough to deter anyone from doing what is happening in Gazza today. But we have to be the Nation of Al Muttaqun for Allah SWT is saying now: "You are the Best of People ever raised up for Mankind, enjoying what is Good, forbidding what is evil and believing in Allah SWT" .... Quran 3: 110 Then how can we go wrong when the fear of "ULMN" will overwhelm the hearts of our enemies? That is what Islam is and we are Muslims to resolve every matter in a Peaceful manner, Insha Allah. Alhamdu Lillah. If no one is willing to act as the acting Khalifah, I will be the acting Khalifah till one is chosen and sincerely invite all Muslims to join me in this effort, for if we fail but we will never fail, we will still get one Hashanah for our intentions, Insha Allah Jazak Allah Khair Your brother Abu Saad Acting Khalifah (as Son of Adam, AS)

[@kaiserbeigh]

⁠its not about rejecting a hadith its about rejecting a certain interpretation of Hadith which Muslims have been doing forever a Hadith is not the actual words of prophet saw it is the words of narrators they differ in the selection of their words anyone who reads any Hadith compilation would understand this Hadiths r not transmitted word to word but transmitted as only meaning therefore muhadithun have always interpreted Hadith through quran or through reason saying a sahabi is saying this is not correct understanding of hadith

[@jackeylynch]

correct

[@aamirreacts1993]

I dont understand how people make music equal to Alchohol when Alchohol when Alchohol being haram came in Quran while Music being forbidden in Hadith and in those same books of hadith (specifically in bukhari) it is shown stuff like ansari female playing music in the house of the prophet and he enters and doesnt stop the ansari female from continuing the music another hadith stating that the Prophet (peace be upon him) said to Aisha (RadiAllah anha) to bring singing ladies to a marriage of an ansar as they are fond of music so how in God's earth is Music is equavalent or comparable to Alchohol is beyond me.

[@smtouheed3863]

*Conclusion:* In the light of the above evidences from the Qur’an, sayings of our beloved Messenger of Allah (Allah bless him & give peace) and texts of the various Fuqaha, the following is the decisive ruling with regards to Music: Musical instruments that are solely designed for entertainment are unlawful, with or without singing. However, to play the tambourine (daf) at weddings (and other occasions according to some fuqaha) will be permissible.

[@mohammadyosuf185]

If it is not mentioned in the Quran and Hadith then it is halal what makes it haram is the use and content. To add halal and haram in the religion is a major sin. All of those scholars that you mention are not prophets and that is their interpretation. The whole zaboor is songs.

[@shaheercp389]

When ALCOHOL was PROHIBITED, the SAHABAS immediately Destroyed those Barrels containing Liquor and threw it into the Drainage and it is said that Pools of Alcohol were formed. In the case of Music there were neither an Ayath nor Hadees Commanding To Destroy the Musical Instruments.

[@NedimTabakovic]

You can’t be that naive? Or can you?

[@PASSIFICATION]

abdullah ibnu mas'ood didnt say its music. he said it means ALGINA. ALGINA means those songs n poetries. meaning those songs n poetries full of jahaala and dhulm. that in no sense talks about music.

[@humangravity9188]

Many people bought music instruments not to mislead people , they bought music instruments for source of incom. They never disturbed others from thier worship, they stop singing during time of pray.

[@suhilawrasul4097]

U could say the same for alcohol. Many people sold/bought alcohol for income not to mislead people, they never disturbed others for their worship…

[@humangravity9188]

@suhilawrasul4097 not the same if we compare because instrument is called an USELESS while the alcohol or liquor is prohibited or haram in Quran.

[@amano22]

is there full video of this video with slide screen? we cannot see the narration...

[@navyblue-ui7fy]

'useless TALK' is NOT Music and Abdullah Ibn Abbas is NOT God - GAME OVER.

[@radwa.158]

Useless talk is that which has no benefit. Described by different ṣaḥābah as shirk (association with Allāh), misleading stories, frivolous songs, or music but includes all which distracts or diverts one from the Qur’ān and remembrance of Allāh. Abdullah ibn masud is a highly reliable sahaba, as he was praised by the messenger of Allah (sallallahu alaihi wassallam), so his commentary on the ayah cannot be ignored.

[@shaistahamid5633]

kzbin.info/www/bejne/bnm2q6WIqs5pqqc His old videos were very clearly against it all....may Allah swt guide him iam a great fan of his videos they are very relatable.. but the video in question was quite disturbing for me as well....jazakAllah sheikh Uthman for addressing

[@PASSIFICATION]

there are multiple instance that proves muhammed nabi (s) didnt prohibit music in general. for example hijra of muhammed (s) to madina. madinans paid him a grand welcome with people singing TALA'AL BADRU ALAINA and they used MUSIC in that to which nabi (s) didnt oppose, stop or even frown. that means songs with positive lyrics and using music in it is not haram.

[@blackmagic20vt]

If you think music is halaal i pray those lyrics are the last words on your tongues before you die rather than the shahada.. If not then you got your answer.

[@kihimbamushyaibrahim7284]

Barakallahu fiikum if a sheikh will say Music is Halal then we pray and ask Allah to guide him!!a muslim who is still listening to asinger ask yourself who is asinger!??if that singer believes in God He /she won't sing!!we have Qoran and No use with nonsense written words of singers!!God guide our young generation to know halal and haram we are proud to be muslims without Islam we are nothing on dunia earth and hereafter

[@saq3329]

After listening to arguments all I can say is... Lo maan liye humne...

[@jackeylynch]

Music is not Haram.. It is not in the Quran.. BUT.. its all about intention.. I can have 4 wives but God forbid i enjoy some good music.. I enjoy Uthman's points.. but I will also push back on this every time..

[@Zubairibnyameen]

@@jackeylynch 🤣🤣🤣 it's not like that. Read the tafseer of Surah Luqman Ayah 6

[@jackeylynch]

@@Zubairibnyameen Thats not what the Surah means.. you may want to go back and really read it. That surah literally speaks on people getting misled on purpose or allowing yourself to be misled.. allowing any speech or medium to lead you away from allah.. you have some contextual work to go do my friend.

[@suhailsinna]

1. One Ayath cannot be taken in isolation. The whole Surah has nothing to do with music so how can Lahwal Hadith mean music. 2. What you presented is not evidence. It is also an opinion of a person. Be it Abdullah bin Masood. Still an opinion. He also had an opinion that Surah Alaq and Nas are not part of the Quran. Hence, people are fallible. 3. Lahwal Hadith doesn't mean music mainly because in no other place Hadith means music. The Quran is consistent. Your opinion is not consistent.

[@simpleman8801]

Your second point has to be a total lie considering the quran tells us to learn from quran and sunnah/sahaba/hadiths + in the video mentioned the prophet peace be upon him told you can learn the quran from Abdullah bin Masood

[@suhailsinna]

@@simpleman8801 where does the Quran say that? On the contrary, the Quran asks: Al-Mursalat 77:50 فَبِأَىِّ حَدِيثٍۭ بَعْدَهُۥ يُؤْمِنُونَ Then in what Hadith after it [i.e., the Qur’ān] will they believe?

[@simpleman8801]

@@suhailsinna There is an article website: newmuslim --> quranic-evidence-hadith-valid-part-islam which explains how indirectly the quran confirms we need hadiths with references. Selamu aleykum, brother.

[@eclecticeccentrickamikaze6526]

Neither alcohol nor music is haram in Islam. Any questions? These insulated minded people are misguiding Muslims.

[@radwa.158]

‫یَـٰۤأَیُّهَا ٱلَّذِینَ ءَامَنُوۤا۟ إِنَّمَا ٱلۡخَمۡرُ وَٱلۡمَیۡسِرُ وَٱلۡأَنصَابُ وَٱلۡأَزۡلَـٰمُ رِجۡسࣱ مِّنۡ عَمَلِ ٱلشَّیۡطَـٰنِ فَٱجۡتَنِبُوهُ لَعَلَّكُمۡ تُفۡلِحُونَ﴿ ٩٠ ﴾‬ • Sahih International: O you who have believed, indeed, intoxicants, gambling, [sacrificing on] stone alters [to other than Allāh], and divining arrows are but defilement from the work of Satan, so avoid[1] it that you may be successful. Al-Māʾidah, Ayah 90

[@radwa.158]

Surah Luqman Ayah 6: And of mankind is he who purchases idle talks (i.e. music, singing, etc.) to mislead (men) from the Path of Allâh without knowledge, and takes it (the Path of Allâh, or the Verses of the Qur’ân) by way of mockery. For such there will be a humiliating torment (in the Hell-fire).

[@eclecticeccentrickamikaze6526]

@@radwa.158 Bro, i have done a lot of research on it. I know your references. Performing prayer is forbidden when one is intoxicated according to the Quran. Quran also says stay away from alcohol as its benefits are less as compared to its harms but no where in the Quran does it say Alcohol is haram. Did you know that there are tons of foods which contains alcohol e.g. vinegar, yogurt, bread, pineapple etc. Would you stop consuming all such food that contain alcohol. Hundreds /thousands of patients are intoxicated daily in operation theatre. Police don't arrest them because they are using the benefits side of intoxication. Tea also contains caffeine but we all including mulvi hazarat take it even in mosques.

[@eclecticeccentrickamikaze6526]

@@radwa.158 There are two types of knowledge one is revealed and the other is acquired. Sound waves of different tunes are produced by the vocal chords ( a kind of violin/rabab/sitar) in our throats when the air from our lungs passes through them. Our inner ear then turns these sound waves after reaching via medium into the electrical signals for our brain. This is how we hear all voices including recitation of Quran. Anything (not just music) that keeps us away from Allah is forbidden. We love our parents brothers, women but at the same time we never forgot our creator. In the same way we can listen to the music / lectures / singing etc. but we must not forgot our true Lord simultaneously.

[@freeyourmind7538]

4:30 im muslim asking...so women HAVE to be fully niqabed up? Women in hijab, loose clothing, abaya, not enough?

[@champmunawar6982]

Why are you so keen on watching non mehram women? Have some shame 😑

[@freeyourmind7538]

@@champmunawar6982 bruh, its a question, dont shoot down my curiosity, i asked HAVE because i understand hjiab is a HAVE to do commandment, and i am asking about the niqab? Is that a HAVE or CAN do so?

[@mohammadnusair]

first of all, It is mandatory for a muslimah that has reached the age of puberty or menstruation to wear niqab in front of non mahrams or when she goes out and cover her juyubihinna as stated in bukahri meaning to draw cloaks all over the body except eyes

[@mohammadnusair]

Second of all, hijaab and niqab are not different, I assume you are saying about the cloak that cover the entire body and exposes the face and hands, in this case her hijab is invalid

[@mohammadnusair]

Thirdly, yes, women have to cover their whole body except eyes, except when she is with mahrams and in a place where there are only women.

[@IshratAli-g8c]

Music is like a knife, cut something ore someone for good or bad reasons, they should study the the physics of sound to understad the creation and the creator, Allah subhana.

[@MuhammadShafiq-ei4mn]

پلیز کوئی یہ بات اُردو میں بتا دیں پلیز

[@maslam9324]

Simple music Haram in Islam

[@maslam9324]

Dr Zakir naik ki video dekh ly

[@rommeldionela1278]

Freedom to Choice, Democracy is the Best Goverment..

[@freeyourmind7538]

😂😂😂😂 no such thing as democracy or freedom, its just a white lie by whiten men. I will give an example in the next message because it might get deleted

[@freeyourmind7538]

Freedom to choose/democracy? ... Yeah, like i have the freedom to take cocaine, ya hypocrite!!!

[@osamabinladen4613]

that's because you do harm to others taking away their freedom maybe that's why it's illegal?​@@freeyourmind7538

[@freeyourmind7538]

@@osamabinladen4613 huh? Can you just confirm your statement. Are you saying its illegal because it harms others? I don't understand

[@osamabinladen4613]

@@freeyourmind7538 yes it's illegal because it can make a personal harm others.hence taking away their freedom Why Is Cocaine Illegal? Cocaine is considered a Schedule II narcotic by the DEA, which means it has a high potential for abuse (though it has some limited medical uses). The move to make cocaine illegal is rooted in mixed and complicated history of concern for public health and safety, politics, and racism.

[@Zvezda1366]

Is lofi haram

[@mohammadnusair]

ye

[@corniel657]

Absolute Haram to the core

[@smtouheed3863]

Sahih al-Bukhari 5590 Narrated Abu 'Amir or Abu Malik Al-Ash'ari: that he heard the Prophet (ﷺ) saying, "From among my followers there will be some people who will consider illegal sexual intercourse, the wearing of silk, the drinking of alcoholic drinks and the use of musical instruments, as lawful. And there will be some people who will stay near the side of a mountain and in the evening their shepherd will come to them with their sheep and ask them for something, but they will say to him, 'Return to us tomorrow.' Allah will destroy them during the night and will let the mountain fall on them, and He will transform the rest of them into monkeys and pigs and they will remain so till the Day of Resurrection."

[@nanaboateng1388]

The Jewish people own their story. Various empires confirm the Jewish story. This story continued through Europe, North Africa, Ethiopia, Iraq, Iran until they returned to their ancestral homeland. Jews were forced out of Judea which was renamed Palestine. The world persecuted and killed them but they returned home. Islam copied the Jewish story, Jewish prophets and kings and claim their version is the truth. How can that be? What is the proof that the Quran came from God directly. What is the imperical and archeological proof of the existence of Mohammed. Why was a mosque built on a Jewish Temple during the Muslim ottoman rule? The Jewish story was copied and altered to create Islam.

[@samasimOFsh]

Just like a knife music can be used for either harram or hallal. I think that studying music actually proves Islam as the true religion if anything. If music is harram why was a prominent Islamic scholar like Ibn Rushd also a phenomenal musician. The Muslims invented the rabbabah, uud and qanun and also the arabic scale. Music was stolen from us just like the rest of our Islamic knowledge. I believe they stole from us and then planted imams to make music harram meanwhile Islam has little to no people experienced with multimedia. All we have is hufadh and doctors

[@GO_142]

the Prophet (ﷺ) saying, "From among my followers there will be some people who will consider illegal sexual intercourse, the wearing of silk, the drinking of alcoholic drinks and the use of musical instruments, as lawful. And there will be some people who will stay near the side of a mountain and in the evening their shepherd will come to them with their sheep and ask them for something, but they will say to him, 'Return to us tomorrow.' Allah will destroy them during the night and will let the mountain fall on them, and He will transform the rest of them into monkeys and pigs and they will remain so till the Day of Resurrection."

[@GO_142]

Im not trying to belittle you in any way but whoever told you what don't listen to them you have to use the quran and sunnah to back up what we say otherwise what we say is meaningless

[@samasimOFsh]

I appreciate it, My advice to you however is not to take or make advice or quote your advice from hadeeth unless you know the context. Fiqh is not taken directly from a hadeeth , it's taken from the Fuquha. You must at least understand the fiqh before. Ibn Rushd is from the Fuquha, he most definitely has a better understanding of fiqh than you or myself? You are quoting a hadeeth which speaks about the end of times. We are still a long ways from that time. I don't think you actually understand the context of that hadeeth as we are not at the end of times?! Silk is allowed in Islam to be worn by women according to the Fuquha like Al Tirmithi and Imam Ahmad ibn Hambal... No Hadeeth or verses in the Qur'an specifically states that all music is completely harram or specifically the types of instruments. There is no clear haddeeth or evidence bottom line. Why did the prophet Muhammad peace and blessings upon him cover his ears and not ask ibn Umar to cover his ears as he passed by someone playing a wind like instrument? Why would he ask ibn Umar to tell him the messenger to uncover his ears when ibn Umar heard that the sound had passed. the Fuquha who explained the fiqh of this hadeeth also posed the question that if it was harram why didn't the prophet ask ibn Umar to cover his ears also. Why would the prophet Muhammad throw ibn Umar under the bus allowing ibn Umar to sin to save himself?? Our religion is not a deceitful one and neither is the beloved messenger. If it was harram he would also ask ibn Umar to cover his ears. We educated the West. They stole from us and made us like we are in the dark ages. Do you actually understand what historical innovations the Muslims have made by studying sounds and chambers? Why would Islamic scholars and scientists call down wells or make adhan inside caves to study amplification which they then engineered domes and chambers in the mosques to amplify the Friday ceremonies and recitation of the Qur'an. You are not realising it but they had knowledge that took Europe out of the dark ages. You should research how Islamic scholars and scientists experimented with sound. If it was all for nothing. Your problem is that your understanding of music is western music or is that of westernised influence or nature. I can totally agree that most of western music is harram as the subliminal messages or vibrations they put out are bad or harmful.I would have to say that most music from Hollywood is harram or used to corrupt. But again that is not our culture or music and historically we are not like them.Music and sound shouldn't take you away from the remembrance of Allah SWT. Funny enough our religion is mostly spread by "sound" and oral traditions. Most people don't understand that a bird or singing is classified as a musical instrument and the human voice is classified as an instrument. Where did the prophet Muhammad say that singing is harram? You can sing to call people to Allah or you can sing to push them away from him. You can sing to tell people to be good or sing to tell them to be bad. Bottom line Music can be harram or not depending on the individual and what purpose it's used for. I am not saying that all music is hallal but saying all music is harram is a bit farfetched.

[@samasimOFsh]

That is cool though If you don't want to listen to music. There are Muslims who don't even listen to drums as they believe it's harram. Even though I don't agree I still respect their beliefs.

[@GO_142]

@@samasimOFsh I got your point but I don't think you understood it does not take an Alim to get what The prophet Muhammad salalahu alayhi wasalam made music haram because that hadith that i quoted why would Rasulallah Categroize haram things with music he also said they will consider them to be lawfull so in a sense you can easily pick out its haram. And not all music is Haram except the Duff anything other than that is clearly haram. There is proof from the quran and it is idle talk, you may argue that idle talk is to vague but Rasulallah gave us a description The clerk of Al-Mughira bin Shu`ba narrated, "Muawiya wrote to Al-Mughira bin Shu`ba: Write to me something which you have heard from the Prophet (p.b.u.h) ." So Al-Mughira wrote: I heard the Prophet saying, "Allah has hated for you three things: -1. Vain talks, (useless talk) that you talk too much or about others. -2. Wasting of wealth (by extravagance) -3. And asking too many questions (in disputed religious matters) or asking others for something (except in great need). Sahih al-Bukhari 1477 Theres no way that singing to music is not useless talk theres proof from more hadith that Musical instruments are haram The Prophet (ﷺ) said, "The bell is one of the musical instruments of Satan. Riyad as-Salihin 1691 From this hadith the bell it's not the only tool that shaytaan uses Theres a common argument with muslims that say don't listen to western music about drugs and all sorts of profanity but instead listen to songs and music about the sunshine and rivers " it talks of Allahs creation" this is none other than shaytaans tricks to mislead them as it says in surah nisa And most certainly I will lead them astray and excite in them vain desires, and bid them so that they shall slit the ears of the cattle, and most certainly I will bid them so that they shall alter Allah's creation; and whoever takes the Shaitan for a guardian rather than Allah he indeed shall suffer a manifest. And even and even if you don't know whether it's haram or halal its better to leave doubtful matters this is something called Wara3 means high level of taqwa and leaving matters which are doubtful this is something the salaf would do.

[@HumanBeing-jj3mc]

Why don't you just migrate to Afghanistan? It'll give you way more Islamic life, no distractions. Isn't it shameful to prioritise dollars over Islam?

[@jasonthemuslim652]

He makes no money off of his preaching and works a normal job to make his money

[@maisamsadigi1658]

His lectures are for free you can visit the masjid yourself and by the way Afghanistan is not a true Islamic country like Saudi Arabia , Kuwait , Bahrain and so on because they are ruling by the Sharia and Afghanistan taking only a part from the sharia and not fully

[@champmunawar6982]

You dumb he is a working professional 🤦 he is doing all that for free for the sake of Allah

[@HumanBeing-jj3mc]

@@maisamsadigi1658 Yeah so why not move to Saudi Arabia? Why everybody wants to come to the West?

[@muzamelpamir4336]

@@maisamsadigi1658what do you mean by “ not a true Islamic country like Saudi Arabia “ 🤔🤔

[@thedude2000zify]

The fact that we even have a debate about this topic is beyond ridiculous. Music is Haram and there's sufficient evidence for it. Those who do not want to accept that, go on and do your thing.

[@rafidxhasan]

This channel owner did a bad job putting their pictures together in the thumbnail.

this is not islam

[@smtouheed3863]

Music lovers just try listening 🎧 to Sheikh shuraim 🎵 Or Mishari Alafasy 🎶

[@Repentingsinner1]

Shiekh yassir al dosari also ❤❤❤❤

[@ametsylla9040]

How do you go from vain talk to useless amusement? I mean what was the specific Arabic word that was used in this verse? Does the word mean vain talk or useless amusement or both at the same time

[@NedimTabakovic]

It may as well be pointed towards preachers preaching like this.

[@4827719]

Useless amusements- at best is a vague term - the Quran is never vague about halal/ haram. No one goes to Hadith for halal/ haram. You know that - say it

[@amirmalik6028]

I am a Muslim and I want to know sir that is there a single ambiguous statement that says music is haraam ?? … what about duff then … that is also music right … ???

[@mehedihassannayem4210]

Only duff is permissible just becaUse prophet Muhammad Sallallahu alayhi wasallum, played it on festive occasions.! Shahih Al bukhari mentions the hadith where Prophet Muhamamd (SW) clearly mentioned about musicial instruments being haram. Haram things are always tempting don't give in to these brother. May Allah guide you to the right path!

[@GO_142]

the Prophet (ﷺ) saying, "From among my followers there will be some people who will consider illegal sexual intercourse, the wearing of silk, the drinking of alcoholic drinks and the use of musical instruments, as lawful. And there will be some people who will stay near the side of a mountain and in the evening their shepherd will come to them with their sheep and ask them for something, but they will say to him, 'Return to us tomorrow.' Allah will destroy them during the night and will let the mountain fall on them, and He will transform the rest of them into monkeys and pigs and they will remain so till the Day of Resurrection."

[@Zubairibnyameen]

Al-Bukhari 5590

[@francescolombardi4866]

just think that (let's hope absolutely not) we could be among the people of hell, so there is little to listen to music.. let's think about preparing answers to Allâh Glory be to Him the Most High. Then if you are one who listens to music, after doing so, note if your faith has increased (I don't think so) so this is another proof that it is Haraam.. finally (and this is better than said above) there are authentic Ahadith like Sahih Al-Bukhari, 7/5590 as clear as the sun regarding this topic. and Ibn Mas'ud (Faqiih by the way) swore to Allâh that the Ayah 31 6 وَمِنَ النَّاسِ مَن يَشْتَرِي لَهْوَ الْحَدِيثِ لِيُضِلَّ عَن سَبِيلِ اللَّهِ And of mankind is he who purchases Lahu Al-Hadith to mislead (men) from the path of Allâh, it refers to singing. who are we near all this to say otherwise... let us be sincere and the truth will appear.. Allâh knows what is in the hearts.

[@truthtobetold9816]

Usage of musical instruments are haram indeed in singing and hence when we talk about today's music, it is known by necessity that its all BS. Incites hypocrisy. There is enough evidence from Quran and authentic Ahadith, the Athar, and concensus of Scholars of the past. Those who try to justify are ignorant heads and know nothing how a ruling is derived from Quran and Sunnaah and the interpretation of the pious predecessors who followed them. Those who want to listen will keep listening to it even if angels meet him and tell him clearly as this fellow is misguided and chosen to be misguided due to the covering of sins around his heart. How can a mere innocent lecture of half an hour will penetrate his heart and make any impact? This guy needs surgery

[@MohsinKhan-cd8nh]

Remember that Doomsday and Resurrection day is going to be announced by blowing of Trumpet. These guys cannot distinguish between using a vehicle for going to work or for murder declaring the vehicle Haram. The word Haram also cannot be used indiscriminately. It's the type of music and how it is used that matters. Don't forget the Hadith of Syedna Ayesha RA about the singing girls on Eid Day. So...husbands you can sing a romantic song to your wife.....

[@sohelchowdhury8098]

Assalamualaikum. Brother is there any amusement or recreation for Muslims?

[@Wiame-zv3jv]

الله يجازيك بخير

[@drpashalatif1523]

Music is an art , a science like physics chemistry, accountancy which maybe used for bad and good purposes. Those who comment on Music don't know abcd of Music. It has evolved mainly in last 2-3 centuries like other modern arts and scientific fields.

[@aamirahmed5047]

There’s a lot more science in Adultry and Alchohol still it’s Haram.

[@waleedhaji5610]

Ex-musician here. I had played music for 19 years before I stopped. I still have written pieces from when I started until before stopping, and I also have a diploma in music production. It would have been a bachelors but I left it right at the end of the year. I can tell you, unfortunately, there is more harm in it than good. I can’t say it is haram because I’m not a scholar, but I can say it is very dangerous to the soul. It is most certainly a distraction and something to be used as a form of mind control. You have no idea what the frequencies and vibrations are doing to the body.

[@drpashalatif1523]

@@waleedhaji5610 Distraction -- yes I do agree with it.

[@simpleman8801]

@@drpashalatif1523 Like he said not only distraction. stop cherry picking! Mindcontroll, manipulation of experience, emotional influence, distraction and also who knows how much it effects our body and soul. there is a lot more points i didnt mentioned but after all distraction is for sure not the only one!

[@drpashalatif1523]

@@simpleman8801 Allama Yusuf Qarzawi has discussed it in fine arts and said there is no clear ayat or sahih Hadith making it haraam. I have read it Urdu monthly magazine zindagi e nai from Delhi more than a decade ago.

[@rashidtemuri3419]

With all due respect, I would appreciate if you would upload the whole video. This is not enough.

[@ShortsMaster01111]

Assalamu Haleikum Brother i would like to know how Is this not enough? he give u aya of the quran with the most relatable tafsir mentioning a sahabi that the prophet ﷺ reccomend and its all authentic.

[@anisamian3978]

Please tell me who, why and on what rulings do we base from our core knowledge; why on earth do we choose to live in non Muslim societies. Who ever is born in a Muslim country, why flock to those countries. There are only 2 to 3 core categories. Ones from non Muslim countries and have to live as Muslims there is totally different categories.

[@k00lmoh]

who's 'we' bro but generally speaking I think it goes back to lack of morals and as you know we Muslims get our morality from Allah alone combine that lack of morals with the lack of blessings there are in our lands whether it be due to corrupt rulers or what not people just reach the conclusion: "I will immigrate to provide better/the best living conditions for my family" and I may remind the Muslims it was never about that, it was never about living a lavish life nor provide such living condition to your family because we are promised better in paradise. "The disbelievers will never be satisfied with us unless we follow in their footsteps" keep that in mind whenever leaving for a non Muslim land

[@champmunawar6982]

No Muslim go to non Muslim lands bcoz non muslims have better morals than us, many of them go bcoz these countries have attacked and sucked up the resources from the Muslim lands

[@alexojideagu]

The very fact people debate it proves it's not Haram. If it was clear, it wouldn't be debated for 1500 years.

[@champmunawar6982]

Because there are people like you that exists in every times ready to cause fitna

[@GhostRider-yh7sh]

You Donkey, of course music is Haram. I dont know wich you be listening to. Probably the one that follows his desires

[@al-Huwariyun]

Specific types of music is clearly haram. Other types of music can inspire thought and creativity but this is a difficult balancing act. Look up the scholars opinions of music of their time. Al-Ghazali and Ibn Rushd among them. Gangster Rap and New Genres are clearly haram because they contain haram themes. I would argue Classical Arabic music and African music and instrumentals are not haram. During the Islamic Golden Age music was very popular.

[@ReflectiveSmile]

This is a fair point. There is ikhtilaaf hence the ongoing debate. I like and listen to certain bands but not all the time. But I'm not going to try to justify it from an Islamic perspective. Where something is described as haram it's clearly forbidden like alcohol, fornication and usury. I don't feel music falls into this category but Allah swt knows best and I believe it's the sunnah to avoid things we're unsure about. Now I should take my advice. May Allah swt forgive me.

[@thedude2000zify]

Don't know what you're on my friend, but the debate has not been on for 1500 years. Only in recent times has this debate actually surfaced. For the majority of the Islamic history, this wasn't a debate at all and no one contested that music is Haram. It's only now, with the explosion of the music industry, that people are going to great lengths to make it halal.

[@4827719]

Please prove from the Quran that music is Haram. You are going on about halal !

[@Mr__ZED]

We don't use the Quran only, there's Hadith too (in case you didn't know)

[@quinnodwyer594]

Did you actually listen with ears or did u listen with opinion

[@4827719]

@@quinnodwyer594 I listen carefully to all sides of a discussion. I base my opinion on reason not on the person . Those whose reasoning is faulty use sentences criticising personally

[@abdullahmanj8878]

Do you know my beloved brother in Islam every thing that takes away you from your creator is haram. So I don't think so music takes you close to your creator.☺️ Do some research my boy. 😊

[@4827719]

@@abdullahmanj8878 May I remind you my dear brother that the gift given to Dawood( A. S) was of music which used to bring joy to the mountains and the birds. May I remind you that the joy of listening to Qirath , the recitation of our Quran is music . Does this take you away from Allah’s remembrance ? Of course those aspects of music which fall under fahashi are forbidden because of the vulgarity - not because of the music itself