O Holy Night Tenor Battle - Who Sang It Best? High Note Compilation

[@jw12121212]

Bjorling for me. Ringing sound, well-placed in the mask, no strain or undue tightness, controlled, full, and resonant. Bravo!

[@DackxJaniels]

The way he just gently slides into that first "o helga" in the first chorus is sublime. Effortless.

[@isaiahjohnston823]

Same for me, jussi bjorling was the best to sing this Christmas song hands down.

[@jameskoon7109]

People don't understand why the high B is a game changer in this song. Any high voice can sing it with a Bb, but B slots differently in the vocal register and to nail it perfectly and precisely is astonishing. Phelps sings it with high notes that are all in the higher register which actually decreases the difficulty, however well the notes come out.

[@JoanJennings]

Björling!!!!

[@jnet59]

Everyone is raving about Phelps C# as it was spectacular. But Bjorlings high was big, full and ringing. One of the best opera voices of all time. Most all of these guys have great voices. But many are in another category outside of Bjorling, Pavarotti and Caruso. These guys don't need microphones. Phelps probably could have been on that stage but he chose a different path.

[@debc7741]

David Phelps is not only pitch perfect, but has beautiful voice control, can hold his notes forever and sings with emotion! I absolutely love listening to him!

[@yelyharmony2047]

Exactly... he's the best...and holds his high notes forever like you said 🤣

[@zombiekiller190]

He does have perfect pitch! I really think he is the best vocalist in the world!

[@ramonveloz977]

@@yelyharmony2047 pitch perfect?

[@maryroberts6357]

I loved him and his musical ability since the first time I heard him. He communicates the love of god, so we’ll go all who

[@503zzach]

*"Oh holy night" by ANDY WILLIAMS. No one can sing this like ANDY WILLIAMS*

[@johnbartlett9449]

Bjorling. I heard him for the first time on the Light Programme. My sister wrote to the BBC and asked who had sung Nesum Dorma. It was Bjorling. Subsequently when Pavarotti was asked how he approached a song, his reply was to say he would listen to how Bjorling had done it. A true great.

[@1079walter]

The greatest tenor ever to set foot on a stage. Hands down!

[@cherryclan1]

Bjorling my #1 too. His voice makes me melt and those turns/trills/what have you after coming off the Bflat were perfection.

[@lyndawise1042]

I agree It was Bjorling for me too

[@jussaraarundel9953]

Bjorling pleased my ears best.

[@Lt_Coldstream72]

I would like to hear Phelps do it on the same recording device as Björling did and vice versa...

[@willem1822]

Jussi Björling is my favorite of these. Followed very closely by Pavarotti and Bocelli

[@AnnaKaunitz]

Jussi Björling of course. There’s a reason he is still the most famous opera tenor in history even tough he died 61 years ago. Pavarotti said in an interview; “when I have to rehearse a new opera, I first listen to how Jussi Björling did it. His voice was unique, and I want to follow his path. More than anything else, I would like people to compare me to Jussi Björling. That's how I strive to sing”.

[@gracepeters6587]

His dead. David Phelps are the greatest 👌👏👏👏

[@MrMferg240]

DAVID PHELPS. when he sings ''fall to your knees, oh hear the angel's voices'' it's devastating.

[@janealaison1954]

Love him 💕💕

[@evamarlenekarlsson9139]

Agree

[@carolynjones6524]

Jussi Bjorling every time

[@neldaglick]

Every time I hear David Phelps’ voice, I imagine an Angel on earth singing, and that it may be how we all sound in heaven. Can you imagine millions of people with a voice like that! The reason why his version is the best is because he sings with such conviction. He BELIEVES what he sings, and it’s his assignment to bring Jesus to the world. None of the others sang with meaning. They were simply notes. David Phelps sings and feels every word and makes you believe him.

[@hl972]

💞 wow , hab Gänsehaut

[@carolynthomason7360]

I AGREE, DAVID PHELPS DOES IT BEST, MY FAVORITE CHRISTMAS SONG OF ALL TIMES!!!

[@mannfan12]

Yes you hit the nail on the head. Add his technical ability to his conviction and passion and you have a one of a kind performance that is unequalled in all of history singing this song.

[@bjornegan6421]

Amen! Thank you very much for that comment. I cannot begin to imagine! Just imagine what God sounds like when He sings! Zephaniah 3:17 Yahweh your God is in your midst, A mighty one who will save. He will be joyful over you with gladness; He will be quiet in His love; He will rejoice over you with joyful singing.

[@mattiasbjorklund5398]

Who cares about his faith? He doesn't even come close to Björling when it comes to sound and that is what it is all about

[@pattipton1488]

They all did beautifully! David Phelps takes the prize for the highest note! To hit that C# and drop to a B to come back to the chorus and hit that C# again and so clearly Wow! Fantastic job!!!

[@aileenhouston4486]

David Phelps without a doubt. Such control and clarity in his voice. He sings with conviction because he believes in what he is singing! It makes such a difference.

[@SylvainSybaris]

I agree, David Phelps is awesome, but I do like HOMEFREE too... Most those other guys in this video have a mechanical voice, like robots.

[@faifilitalaga7171]

David Phelps👍

[@ogelcrew]

He lacks the polish and is a more rugged performer.

[@PJGrams]

You are absolutely correct!! It gave me immediate goosebumps!!

[@Pastor24u]

Jussi Björling gets my vote of course since he is the greatest tenor of all times... But I also love David Phelps because the Holy Spirit ministers through him when he sings.

[@teresawhetstone1832]

Yes Goky Spirit!

[@haveagreatday2823]

@@teresawhetstone1832- Hope you realize all sins can be forgiven except blaspheme against the Holy Spirit.

[@RossNixon]

Jussi Björling - who I hadn't even heard of until yesterday. Listen to him sing the WHOLE song though. Unmatched to this day.

[@sylvialabadia4171]

David Phelpd is the best of all

[@cubablue602]

@@sylvialabadia4171 He's not even the loudest, not by a distance, he needs a mike practically in his mouth. There's no tremor or 'shimmer' to his high notes, no resonance or underflow to the low notes (ANYONE can sing high notes with practice). I'm afraid any comparison to Jussi Björling quickly falls away. Have a listen to the FULL song recorded live with NO amplification.

[@SD737.]

@@cubablue602 are you joking?

[@ttbass897]

@@cubablue602 Jussi is amazing but that is comparing apples and oranges. The measure of a voice is not "tremor or shimmer" (which is called vibrato) because you can also purposefully sing it straight-tone for effect (think more modern, Whitney or Maria). Phelps sings with vibrato on almost all the high notes but especially the C# which he covers (classical sound). He is classically trained, just isn't an opera singer. Lack of amplication is also not a requisite. It is just a fact of modern music. Modern concert halls are designed with sound systems, opera halls are designed with acoustics in mind. Besides that, Phelps is university trained and could easily fill a theater without a mic.

[@janealaison1954]

Not the best jussi need to listen to another version he really is brilliant

[@rolfeliason5950]

I heard David Phelps this afternoon on the television singing this song.......tears were flowing down my face, not just for the music in his voice. The music in his HEART matched the song. Heavenly.

[@robertpicton1578]

So true!

[@juliedonohue1654]

He sings with such passion! I've been a fan for years!

[@Marymass1]

He is an anointed singer.

[@alicetucker6641]

Jonathan Antoine is the best, bravo! So beautiful! ❤🎤🎼🎶

[@cindyhurd5488]

I so gotta agree!! 😍😍😍

[@kenr4186]

With due respect to all, it's Bjorling. Purest voice and superb breath support. Listen to his high notes. Wide open without stress. Most professional singers do not have proper breath support.

[@kristerjohansson9100]

Jussi Björling every day of the week! He is considered to be one of, if not the best, tenors ever recorded. Even Luciano Pavarotti said he couldn´t compare himself to Jussi Björling.

[@pcpachuau11sept79]

David Phelp

[@marcusdawson3740]

Hear hear

[@johangreybe5552]

Jussi Björling -- possibly best tenor ever

[@Mathias.Soderlund]

I totally agree, I am very proud to be from Sweden.

[@kateheiden8418]

Absolutely. His voice is in a category by itself ~ he’s the greatest tenor who ever lived.

[@cc8071]

David Phelps by a mile! God has blessed him with that amazing voice, and he uses it to serve God. We are all blessed to hear him sing.

[@MagnusKnutas]

Jussi is like a force booming still after all these years! You can really feel the energy!

[@isaiahjohnston823]

Bjorlings version is way better than Phelps! Who shouts with the Mike in his mouth! He's not even an opera singer! Bjorling is the 🐐🇸🇪👍.

[@user-fp8ig1cl9w]

Totally agree.

[@hebertomanuelromeromclaugh5232]

Without a doubt, Jussi Bjorling is fantastic, what a voice.

[@isaiahjohnston823]

I agree! Bjorlings version is way better than the rest. His voice is liquid Gold.🇸🇪👍🐐..

[@glenbearh9109]

@@isaiahjohnston823 I agree with a but-Caruso was close and one has to take into account the scratchy nature of the record it was produced on. I mean we ought to leave him out because it is not fair to him or others to judge a voice on a bad medium. Jussi? Wow yeah!

[@bobbrown200]

Just imagine what his voice would sound like with modern recording technology!

[@kcmuanpuia]

His long ending note was sharp though.

[@colteberlemusic5668]

David Phelps has the All time best version even now over 50 yrs old still doing a c5 and recently a D5

[@aundraking9343]

David Phelps. AMEN

[@tealpaisley8434]

David Phelps! The best.

[@FlameMoose37]

You can feel what he's singing. People don't always sing with passion.

[@gracebutler6568]

Totally agree.

[@joelhutchinson8475]

C#5

[@jeangraham1624]

My favorite Christmas song ever! No one has even come close to David Phelps. He hits you in the feels.

[@luamoliveira3467]

Jussi Bijörling is much superior in terms of techinique proficiency, control and power than David, no had like compare.

[@rubemgl6669]

@@luamoliveira3467Davis Phelps is not a opera singer you’re right cannot be compared

[@PinkieJoJo]

@@luamoliveira3467I want to hear passion and spirit in the song though, not just a technical operatic sound. That’s the difference.

[@kristahoward2687]

​@PinkieJoJo Yes! For me, it's not just about the technical. David has a true passion for the Lord and it's so moving!

[@mattiasbjorklund5398]

I went and listen to his entire version and was pretty darn awful to be completely honest. He doesn't even sing in the same Universe as Jussi Björling

[@rickriley7018]

O Heavenly Voices may they all vocalize in Heaven But David Phelps is simply one to reduce me to tears of Joy and Praise

[@Slibbs_Bathena_WandaVision]

David Phelps 100%. He is on a whole new level, and you can truly tell he is using his voice to praise the Lord with!

[@hakanborgsten456]

Jussi Björling by far the most best singer of them all. You have to understand the power of his voice when he sings. Wow!

[@isaiahjohnston823]

Bjorlings voice is phenomenal, he owns this Christmas song hands down. Phelps has up to date acoustics amplifications microphones and he almost has the Mike down his throat, jussi bjorling beats them all....

[@msmith5121]

David Phelps....best male vocalist in the world. I've seen him live 11 times now. Unbelievable.

[@Anonnamus]

I would give anything to hear him sing live. I’m jealous!

[@vilmacaponpon1650]

David Phelps is best👏

[@Derek-Barbosa]

I'm super jealous of anyone who's gotten to hear him live. I know that there is something about hearing a person sing, IN PERSON. Something about physically having their voice singing live in your ears that's different than listening to on a CD or video. I just bought 4 David Phelps Live DVD's and can't wait until they come in the mail. I live in Maine so it's kinda hard to see him perform. Would love to be at the Barn Bash one year.

[@msmith5121]

@@Derek-Barbosa I saw David in Alton Bay New Hampshire about four years ago. Fantastic....been to the Barn Bash twice. Go if you can....worth every penny. I am also from new England...lived in NH for 20+ years....my son lives in York Maine...small world!

[@judybutler9825]

I have seen him twice now and will go any time he is within 4 hours traveling time. Got to sit on the second row both times. Awesome is the only way to describe it.

[@janneyovertheocean9558]

These are all great voices but David Phelps not only has the voice, the pitch, the breadth - he is also the most thoroughly inspired and inspiring one. He not just sings for men, he apparently also sings to God almighty. At least that’s how I felt. His ‘No More Night’ is my favorite and go-to number whenever I need my perspective re-focused. He is a gift to us.

[@EmmaMagnolia-mh1ol]

I watched another comparison of David and Pavarotti and David sure has the highest and whole voice

[@ogelcrew]

@@EmmaMagnolia-mh1ol All due respect, he may reach the high notes, but he puts forth obvious effort while the Great Pavarotti's voice flows effortlessly with him hardly raising a brow. The difference is in comparing silk to cotton.

[@SvenEven]

Jussi Bjørling. Best tune, clear diction and fabulous voice control.

[@isaiahjohnston823]

I agree 100%jussi bjorlings voice is priceless. Phelps just eats the Mike!!

[@donnakelley3229]

I never tire of hearing that beautiful song and love hearing tenors hit those high notes, but there is no question that David Phelps sings it better than anyone else. He sings it from his heart. What a gift the Lord has given him and what a blessing to hear him sing.

[@theromanclub787]

The anointing that David sings with hits you in your spirit

[@lauraward6883]

Phelps

[@selyts4]

I’m telling ya! There’s no better vocalist than David Phelps. I am a professional vocalist and I can’t hit the keys that he’s so effortlessly hitting! It’s almost as if God sent us one of his angels to bless us with his heavenly voice!

[@theomartin9969]

If you listen to the entire song by each one, they are all great but David Phelps is in a league of his own with this song.

[@akenorlen7020]

…but Björling is much better!

[@sherilea01]

I dont believe him. He hits notes but I dont feel God when he sings.​@akenorlen7020

[@eddeddy7702]

David Freakin Phelps holy smokes!!!!!! I thought the heavens literally opened in half 💓

[@horticultureandhomes]

I had the pleasure of seeing Phelps sing this and Mary Did You Know with the gaither vocal band in concert and it was wonderful. Also heard him sing, Let Freedom Ring with the vocal band when it was Phelps, Taff, Gaither and Penrod. It brought the house down! So good!

[@Goosteady]

He's a total beast.

[@Truckerdaddy]

Ive seen him on the Gaither Gospel shows and he has an amazing voice.

[@alewicke]

I'm pretty sure that David Phelps is the soundtrack in Heaven.

[@cheshire4266]

Amen!!

[@kellybarrett7990]

Best comment! 😂

[@karenm502]

LOL...good one! True, but funny. haha

[@seaswirl95]

Love it! So true! David is what angels probably sound like when they're praising God 🙏♥️

[@AnneShirley73]

I can’t wait for that choir and to be a part of it! Can you imagine singing with David and Anthem Burger playing the piano!! I cannot even!

[@s.m.h.u.]

I've heard David Phelps' version about a million times and it still give me goosebumps now. Incredibly epic.

[@PJGrams]

ABSOLUTELY GORGEOUS!!!!

[@kmberger2633]

Björling was unbelievable, by far my favorite of all time!

[@hegesophieborgersen5868]

Jussi Bjorling without any question! Goosebump stamp!! No goosebump from any of the others. Except Jonathan Bovaine have a nice voice. Listen to the whole song by Jonathan. He is good and will even get better with age. Such richness and tone in his voice.

[@newstartdiscipleship]

I sang in a backup choir for Gaither Christmas concert once with my wife. We sang backup for David Phelps on this song (not this video, but on tour). It was a once-in-a-lifetime experience for us. He's an incredible vocalist. Each of these guys is fabulous, but Phelps defines tenor vocalists for this generation. :)

[@cleophusfowler]

I think you're absolutely right. Another wonderful rendition of this song is performed by Larry Ford. David Phelps and Larry Ford ( not mentioned here ) are two of my favorite tenors. Both are amazing and I always feel spirit filled when I hear either of these men. Merry Christmas!!

[@Jagsla]

No contest and I can tell you without any doubt ( David Phelps ) This is not only the best : O' holy night version but may be the best song anyone has ever sang!!! There are very few, but I have seen some performances that are life changing, once in a lifetime performances and this is one that is such!! I have listened to this song and version for year's and I have come to the conclusion that although David Phelps is a Great singer and has one of the most beautiful voices I've ever heard but on this night and in this place I feel like the very presence of God came down and visited him, us, the audience, the world!!! You can hear it if you listen!!!! Thanks for sharing and God bless.

[@brianhoffman3091]

Jason, you are spot on. This performance of this song brings me to tears every time I hear it. No other version I have heard moves me this way. To those watching this clip and seeing David for the first time, please watch the full version of this performance. It is amazing. And not just in the high notes.

[@stevenfacey77]

I think your observation is inspired, I’ve been listening to this performance for about an hour, crying like a fool trying to understand what it is about this performance that is brining me undone… your comment has answered that question for me…thank you for your insights. God bless you sir!

[@karenking5357]

And I totally agree with you without a doubt God's presence when there it filled the room it filled the heart of every single person that listens to him I mean the power of God is still in the recording not just that live performance and I told someone else all these gentlemen have been given a god-given talent it's just that David Phelps uses his to glorify God and that's why he has won this contest hands down every single person but one that I've read so far has voted for David Phelps and that's this song is one of those songs you'll performances that will never be forgotten it it changes your life I get so choked up I can't even I can't even hardly watch my eyes just flow with tears anyway God bless you sir this is such a blessing to be able to listen David Phelps and I know that you agree ✝️😇♥️

[@engjan]

It is all about legato and beauty of voice in the performance of this song. Only one man can make it - the God-sent Jussi Bjoerling

[@eileenhetherington3704]

💯 Jussi forever.

[@akenorlen7020]

Yes!

[@robw1866]

Jussi Bjoerling because a great tenor performance is music not a battle.

[@joanmccutcheon]

David Phelps

[@eileenhetherington3704]

@@joanmccutcheon 😆 Phelps is the Mariah Carey of gospel singers. He's a joke.

[@fumastertoo]

David Phelps is my all time favorite singer, ever! However, that was some awesome lineup of singing, fantastic video!

[@lettiereichel3318]

Wow David Phelps wow. I dont have words to discribe his voice. WOW

[@Zealor365]

J. Antoine has the crucial clarity of notation required to make this a perfect rendition. If you go back and listen again, his vocal timpani is quite solid.

[@Tadpoletofrogs]

He is nasal. Kermit the frog sound.

[@deecapetown]

Johnathan A. my favourite ....

[@mikaeldelebeck8972]

Jussi` s timber and power are still to date the best singing i ve heard in my life. Some people maybe have more power and/or have a higher note but the two combined, Jussi´s voice makes my ear want more........

[@Sjb2077]

bjorling, Caruso ,Antione and Bocelli. Never heard the great Caruso sing before, but boy, he was great. Nor Bjorling, just beautiful and of course Antoine and Bocelli. But they were all great and I would hate to put one above the other. Thank you to all of them for a few moments joy and pleasure. Thank you.🇬🇧

[@taramatheis1451]

David Phelps every time!!! The most stunning version of this song I have heard! I've listened to his version countless times and it always touches my soul..!🙏🥰🙏

[@andreasitzigehl8366]

There is only one, Jussi Björling! He outclasses them all.

[@1079walter]

The greatest tenor ever to set foot on a stage. Hands down!

[@oldtimer7635]

Agree!

[@Thelongshanks1956]

I agree - Jussi Björling, the one and only :)

[@kateheiden8418]

Absolutely!

[@isaiahjohnston823]

Yep jussi bjorling.

[@chrisdiikafa6678]

Everyone was on b4 note, but David was C5. Very challenging for a Male voice but the fact he sustain it with such clearity is something out of this world.

[@charliegold3227]

A c5 is hard when you are doing it in an opera hall, it’s not hard with a microphone

[@tammysamons4607]

@@charliegold3227 He doesn't need a microphone.

[@EW-ty6qw]

C#5, not C5

[@dubbelhenke854]

Jussi Björling was not b4.

[@eileenhetherington3704]

@chrisdiikafa6678 Silly. The other tenors are singing it in the key it is written in. The composer chooses the key so the song rings at it's best advantage. Björling can sing circles around Phelps, who is a gospel pop singer in the style of Mariah Carey. Can't even listen to him.

[@bamakeyman]

As much admiration as I have for every amazing artist in this video, there is no doubt Phelps has the most amazing male voice I've ever heard. I can't imagine many have ever been better, and it's not just high notes. This dude can sing. Incredible control, perfect phrasing and intonation. I wish I could sing like that just once in my life.

[@TheMumzzy]

I was super impressed with Jonathan Antoine's quality and control and high notes. He is young and a winner/runner up of America's got Talent I think... Correct me if I'm wrong...I think his career has just begun, and he will go far!! How can you not love Pavarotti??? But my fave hands down and the one who brings the most emotion and talent to the stage and heart is David Phelps!!

[@christinephipps8236]

It was bgt when he was 17, check him out singing unchained melody and also singing Parla piu piano in italian.

[@pietekoo5559]

Agreed.

[@Kvivian]

David Phelps - hands down!!!! Everything. Passion, tone, just enough vibrato, and soul. Yes. David! He is not just singing words - he believes them! Amen!

[@susanwarmbier4085]

David Phelps absolutely is the most amazing tenor ever.......he sings with passion and love for God! What a difference that makes! I can see his faith in God all through his songs. Wow! Thank you Lord.

[@johndoe-kf9ff]

without a doubt David Phelps

[@PinkieJoJo]

Absolutely 💯

[@pilaalcalinamadrid]

A gem of a video, all wonderful, but Jussi Björling is stratospheric.

[@annacarinhartvig6269]

Jussi Björling is the one and only! ❤️ Think about of he could have been recorded with the technology of today!!! Do listen to to all of his version, in Swedish, called "oh hegla natt" or "Adams julsång" It is AMAZING! ❤️❤️❤️

[@isaiahjohnston823]

I agree with you, bjorling made this song sound better than anyone else!!

[@maryconnealy]

The reason David Phelps wins this is the emotion he puts into it. The others are superb versions, beautiful, highly skilled voices. But I don't FEEL IT. Many of them aren't even live performances so those music videos while well done don't compare either. With David, I feel it right to my heart. Right to my soul. He's singing from his own passion and beliefs. So excellent. Such a blessing to hear him sing to praise the Lord.

[@susanwarmbier4085]

Amen! So true!

[@lucyjune]

Andrea Bocelli sang it with the most deadpan expression and not a bit of body movement. It's like he almost fell asleep!

[@bobalky3638]

@@lucyjune Bocelli's voice was flawless as ever. His body stillness is his style. You cannot expect a blind man to be moving his body and flailing his arms during a performance.

[@lucyjune]

@@bobalky3638 You are right, I apologize. I did not know he was blind.

[@keithtauber4153]

Tremendous analysis. So well said, thank you.

[@stevetromp1773]

As someone who has followed many of the great tenors, while I stand in awe of all of them, I do believe that David Phelps's voice is a particular gift from God to the church and the world and truly brings glory and praise to the Lord. Truly Amazing.

[@donavandean1078]

They ALL do it justice! Quite impressive!

[@rolling-roadkill]

I'm no fan of opera but I really love Pavarottis voice. But in this case there I have to go with Jussi Björling. His voice is absolutely unmatched when it comes to the finer details. His singing is crystal clear and you can hear each and every word articulated to perfection. He has such power without ever feeling forced and at times he manages to sound so soft and warm. I believe that no one will ever be able to match his performance on this song.

[@edwardkerrigan5356]

There are many, many versions of this song on record. Many opera singers beside Bjorling have recorded it, and many could be considered the equal of Bjorling, depending on personal preference for a voice, which is what it comes down to anyway, in the end. If someone likes a particular voice, that's the one they will go to. My personal favourite is by the American tenor, Jan Peerce, but I don't say it is better than Bjorling's version, just my preference. There have been some appalling 'pop singer' versions, which mangle both the melody and the lyrics, but no doubt they are liked by many. Each to his own.

[@PippaAT]

You are so right, his performance is mesmerising. I admit I was disappointed by Pavarotti's rendition. It sounded 'thin'.

[@tpVideoRestorations]

@@edwardkerrigan5356 Well put, Edward. My second fav version after Jussi of O Holy Night is Mario Lanza's version, and he is not in Jussi's league.

[@nafets4368]

Jussi is the best. The control he had over his voice was outstanding.

[@mariahisthe1]

Nah. David trumps him big time.

[@edwardkerrigan5356]

@@mariahisthe1 Phelps just shouts.

[@towardsheaven4196]

@@edwardkerrigan5356 Phelps is obviously the best...unless you're deaf!

[@edwardkerrigan5356]

@@towardsheaven4196 When he is singing I wish i was.

[@isaiahjohnston823]

Jussi bjorlings voice is so powerful and sweet, Phelps just eats the Mike!

[@jshearouse]

David Phelps took that song to an unheard of level. He shook it on it's head, hugged it, kissed it and set it down like a boss!

[@karenking5357]

Jennifer what a fantastic way to describe what David did I agree he is the best ever I've been saying that to everybody but you said it best in fewer words so awesome girl

[@R33AD]

This! I wish I had written this 🤣🤗🤣

[@dermotmccabe9042]

I really don't agree. David Phelps is a good singer and his version of O Holy Night is what I would call a pop version. So what if he pushed the register up a note or whatever at the end. He is simple not in the same class as those magnificently trained voices of the great opera singers like Pavarotti, Caruso and most wonderful of all, Jussi Bjorling, the great Swedish tenor whose version O Helga Natt is the supreme example of how this beautiful hymn should be sung.

[@violafox1999]

@@dermotmccabe9042 David Phelps is also a classical professionally trained voice. The only difference is, he chose gospel instead of opera.

[@susannebrunberg4174]

@@violafox1999 Yes, we noticed that, lol

[@beverlygiroux2824]

Mr. David Phelps sings to the very core of my being.. I would be so honored and blessed to hear and see him sing in person. Bev in Maine

[@dubbelhenke854]

Björling - he is a legendary superstar and rightly so. Caruso sings it noble and beautiful. These 2 are way ahead of everyone else. Unfortunately Pavarotti is too old and tiredsounding here but of course he was otherwise a real singer. The rest are not in the competition but Antoine is better than Bocelle (and Phelps isnt that bad in the pop department).

[@peggylouise3848]

Pop department? You do know Phelps is a classically trained tenor? Not bad? He hits the notes none of the others do. With Phelps, he sings it from the heart, not an opera performance.

[@edwardkerrigan5356]

@@peggylouise3848 Then why does he sing it like a pop singer. Obviously not that well trained.

[@peggylouise3848]

Why do you comment when you obviously don't know music. People who know music claim he is the best in the world on this song. It is obvious you have never heard him sing it in person.@@edwardkerrigan5356

[@millie1280]

He was trained in Opera at Baylor University. He sings a variety of styles in music. He is known for it. He has a incredible range to his voice and sings higher than most.

[@dubbelhenke854]

@@millie1280 He doesn't sing bad but of course his voice is no match for Björling.

[@deloreanwaters3455]

In hs I used to go see operas put on in my town. I always loved them but outside of being there, I never went out of my way to really listen to any operatic music. And god, have I really been doing myself a disservice. Jussi Bjorling’s voice is insane. I see a lot of people saying he’s one of the best voices in the history of opera. I don’t know many singers but jeez, that guy 😅😅😅 absolutely beautiful

[@meredithgreenslade1965]

Jussi B, has such strength in his voice. Antoine was very good as was David Phelps. I've always been an Il Devo fan they have great voices. I think Jussi won it for me, amazing.

[@1079walter]

The greatest tenor ever to set foot on a stage. Hands down!

[@odumosuolusegun2781]

@@1079walter David phelps sounds very small and like a silly child singing.. Jussi and Caruso are the best, that is operatic sound

[@engjan]

David Phelps sounds more like shouting than singing, although he's singing. How come?

[@christinedudley-uc6td]

David Phelps all day long!!! So much heart and anointing!!!

[@armandocasanova7174]

I'm partial to Jussi Bjorling. Strong, sharp, precise and powerful without yelling.

[@isaiahjohnston823]

Yep I agree, jussi bjorling blows the rest out of the water with this Christmas carol/Hymn...

[@karindidriksen2768]

My vote goes to Jussi Bjørling, not just because I happen to be Scandinavian, but he is simply the best. 👍

[@edwardkerrigan5356]

There are many good versions of this song. Check out also the version by Jan Peerce - a contemporary of Bjorling's at the Met.

[@davidcraig9938]

How is overtone singing sharp and precise?

[@moonlightelf591]

​@@davidcraig9938compared to other tenors like Caruso or even Di Stefano in the same note, he sounded "sharp" Caruso and Di Stefano sound more more open.

[@vn8525]

That C#5 twice and to hold it...I mean.... God blessed all of them with beautiful voices. But he sure gave David Phelps a little extra 💚

[@barbarathomas5938]

David Phelps for certain

[@ecsluder]

David Phelps, imagine that. A Gospel singer singing higher than the greatest operatic voices in history.

[@aimanisahac]

Thrice actually

[@aimanisahac]

​@Ernie Sluder yup.

[@mrbee8834]

Phelps hands down: clarity, effortless and he hit the highest note better the opéra singers. Bravo Phelps!!

[@patriciasepulveda4537]

Jussi después Caruso sigue Pavarotti, Bocelli IL Divo.y los otros grupos todos muy buenos y hermosa su interpretacion. David Pelph no lo conocía me parecio muy bueno y hermosa su voz❤❤❤❤❤

[@PA-ss5cq]

For me, nobody sings it more superbly than Jussi Bjorling

[@jms3spinoon]

Jussi Bjorling without a doubt. His rendition of O Helga Natt (O Holy Night) is the most beautiful version I have ever heard.

[@erikhedqvist8221]

The best

[@murielkinsella3526]

@@erikhedqvist8221 yes. I'm inclined to agree.

[@johnmiller9858]

Have just discovered Jussi Bjorling’s O Helga Natt, it is superb, beautiful.

[@clongownian1]

This is the correct answer.

[@Dannycorcuera]

Jussi bjorling is not so good than David phelps, David phelps has a tono more hight

[@aranit69]

The version of David Phelps is the best of all Times, not only of the highest note but without dubt for interpretation too.

[@janetlaytham8991]

In order of favorites: Bjorling, Caruso, Home Free, Jonathan and then Andrea Bocelli followed by Pavarotti. Never heard of Bjorling and I'm a BIG Home Free fan and really enjoy Andrea Bocelli. I need to find more recordings from Caruso and Bjorling.

[@judyscott9733]

Without a doubt, David Phelps! He’s absolutely the best I’ve ever heard!

[@wendellnelson1118]

The only one that gave me goose bumps was David Phelps. No matter how many times i hear it, I always get them when he sings this song. So he wins by 5 bumps!!!

[@garybrower611]

Not only that, but he nailed it in a higher key than any of the others.

[@mikecaffery8832]

I have to agree, even though I had not heard of him before I watched this video.

[@wendellnelson1118]

I would like to add that Jussi is without doubt one of best voices of a generation, but the notes on this carol were delivered with such force and velocity as if it was a battle victory from a opera. I'll go to David for Oh Holy Night and Jussi for opera aria's.

[@debhinkle4413]

David Phelps by far. He sings from his soul.

[@MrEugCs]

Yes,direct Worship To God... extreme soul praise for Him. Tecnica and devotion

[@kendallsherryleech7035]

When he sings, you can actually see the song! Amazing!

[@Couldnteventhink]

I'm not a musician or singer, I just totally enjoy listening to these beautiful voices. If I had to pick, I'd pick Enrico Caruso. Only because I listened to it on an old victrola very old record. Considering that recording sound back then was relatively new. That still came across so beautifully.

[@suegeese6339]

David Phelps is my favorite by far!! He can bring so much emotion in his singing.

[@sylvialabadia4171]

David Phelps by far is my favorite. Then Homefree

[@steveaalbu1148]

David Phelps. Great voice, great vibrato, great diction. Amazing! That is my favorite recording of him singing that song.

[@karenking5357]

It's mine too Steve I could just listen to that high note you know like all day long I think it's just absolutely so Heavenly it's hard to put it into words this version and God bless you sir and thank God we have David Phelps using his voice to glorify to God and we get to enjoy it ♥️✝️😇

[@Cmonkey49]

David Phelps HANDS DOWN. It's not that it was a higher note. It's about tone, pitch, and mostly feeling. I can't not cry when I listen to him sing this. A voice that is truly a gift from God.

[@karenking5357]

You said you can't not cry when you listen let me tell you Carl I can't even speak I get so choked up during the song I mean try to tell somebody about David Phelps with this particular song and it just I'm just a puddle of tears and they are tears of joy and Thanksgiving and also pride as a Christian that the world has all these beautiful singers of course but are David Phelps is winning this contest here hands down only one other person has mentioned a different tinner besides David!!✝️😇✝️😇✝️😇😇✝️

[@pensandodireito8204]

I cried when i heard D. Phelps singing Let Freedom Ring. His emotion and the song's lyrics are amazing!

[@themcool8824]

And he KNOWS it's a gift from God. Makes a difference.

[@debbywoodard3574]

Amen, Carl!!!

[@deanrobbins8102]

With this cross section of vocalists, choosing is difficult. It would be nice to see each of these performances in their entirety. With that in mind, David Phelps' performance was beyond amazing. Like others in the comments, it's hard to hold tears back when you've watched/heard the entire version. If you haven't seen David Phelps' full video, please go watch it.

[@gracebutler6568]

David Phelps has the best tenor voice ever! He spreads the Word of God through his music 🎶. He is true to his faith and sings with such heartfelt emotion. Keep singing David!

[@dno36]

Thank You for putting this together!! What a group of super-stars. One of the greatest songs ever written. It is a mainstay for scores of vocalists and choirs throughout the world, for good reason. Thank You Again. My vote is for David Phelps. The complete production, with his perfect delivery, the Christian All-Star Choir behind him, and amazing Piano work by the late Anthony Berger, makes this a complete and stellar experience. David has an amazing volcal gift, and he combines it with a perfect delivery, so strong, so controlled, and so clear. This puts him in a class by himself. Everybody I play this for is amazed, and they start shaking their heads in amazement. I get chills every time I hear it done by David. It is 22 years old, and it NEVER gets old.

[@sherirowlett3371]

Amen! Agree. David Phelps rendition of this song brings me into the Throne Room of God...on my face in awe.

[@edwardkerrigan5356]

I'm not amazed - I think it's awful.

[@kahearne5361]

Loved Jonathan Antoine & David Phelps!!!! Just fabulous! Merry Christmas!!!

[@TheTimrodlady]

They were all wonderful but Jonathan, David and Jussi were my favorites. David has the highest voice and sings with such passion. The other two are magnificent also. Hard to exclude anyone.

[@AmbrosieTica]

❤

[@bjornolsson2696]

1:Jussi. 2: Also Jussi 3: Have to say Jussi. I haven’t heard Phelp’s entire recording. It’s vocally impeccable but feels a bit like “all frosting no cake” musically.

[@edwardwagner2679]

David Phelps amazing, powerful rendition wins this one with greatest clarity at the highest notes and his ability to convey the ethereal emotion of the lyrics is unparalleled

[@daveg6096]

As David Phelps hits the C# and the chord resolves it sent absolute chills across my soul and indeed tears to my eyes as the spirit used his voice to proclaim that Holy Night! All of these great tenors are worthy of all accolades!

[@efrayinefrayin1566]

David Pheĺps hands down, No argument about it.

[@fireseeker4him]

I loved Jonathan Antoine and Andrea Bocelli (I guess I’m partial to the more operatic versions). But David Phelps takes it to another level - I’m not sure how he jumps an octave plus another whole step and a half up to C#5 then back down to Bb4 so seamlessly. It’s like the other tenors are all great singing Bb4 and David was like “hold my eggnog …”

[@blacksorrento4719]

Loved your comment, I agree……👍😊 For a more sedate version, I am a HomeFree fan, the boys do everything acapella

[@curedbytheonomy]

“Partial to the more operative versions.” Like Antoine/Bocelli but ignores Pavarrati/Bjorling. You don’t like operative versions. You like pop singers with pronounced vibrato.

[@af5825]

Very well trained

[@af5825]

I love opera versions beautiful, David is highlly trained in voice. Frankly I enjoyed all of them thanks for sharing

[@vickithomas949]

Phelps had classical training. League of his own!

[@rickyperkins813]

David Phelps, Wow, what an amazing voice!!

[@jkradio8201]

Jussi Björling - A once in a lifetime performance of unparalleled perfection and spine chilling beauty.

[@Athena621]

💯

[@Arkay66]

Yep. His rendition gave me chills. The others are very, very nice, but not like Jussi.

[@briannalarimore9928]

Absolutely David Phelps!!! Been hearing his voice since my early childhood! Only he can sing "O Holy Night" like that - such passion, it overwhelms me. I've had the blessed opportunity to have gone to one of his Christmas concerts a few years back and I was able to hear him sing this masterpiece, which is one of my favorite Christmas songs ever! I've also had the privilege to hear him sing with the Gaither Vocal Band - they are absolutely amazing!!!

[@sirstormystefan]

Jussi Björling is on another level. Another planet. The best voice in human history.

[@kateheiden8418]

Yes!!

[@robertpicton1578]

Stop it! LOL...you silly goose, you. Ahhh...

[@mizofan]

@@robertpicton1578 Many would agree

[@kathywoody1321]

David Phelps by far! Love his voice

[@alanbayliss8611]

I have to go with Bjorling. A great top note and exceptional purity of tone.

[@JulianaBlewett]

I agree.

[@nanasundborn4196]

So do I.

[@RossNixon]

Me too. The recording tech of the 1950s didn't pick up as much detail as these days.

[@leshelmuth8827]

Agreed!!

[@Dannycorcuera]

I don't agree 👍

[@jag03ljg]

#1 David Phelps, and to hear him sing that live is an outer body experience, even at the age of 51, he's still the best!

[@PrestoPaulTV]

@David Phelps There is no once else besides an Angel that can worship our Lord God than you!

[@bruceweis2235]

All very beautiful voices and renditions, but I have to go with David Phelps, he hold the note so clear and long, I'm blown away every time I see him perform this.

[@Daffob1nt]

My fellow countryman Jussi Björling is definitely number one!! And after him, Jonathan Antoine. For me, the lyrics in Swedish are the most beautiful, although the original French text is also quite beautiful. Here in Sweden, the song also goes by the name "Adam's Christmas Song".

[@mungode]

I liked Jussi Bjorling because of the bright tome in his voice and David Phelphs because he is super-human C# and holds it forever!

[@miloowen1]

Jussi Bjoerling, one of the most beautiful voices ever. But also: where are the real powerhouses? Franco Corelli and Mario del Monaco? Or even Lanza, for sentimentality.

[@1079walter]

Jussi. The greatest tenor ever to set foot on a stage. Hands down!

[@johnfalstaff2270]

The present audience includes youngsters who lack knowledge or ignore to learn anything what happened before their birth. So, no wonder that names of del Monaco, Corelli, Bergonzi or di Stefano are unknown to them. They probably cannot distinguish achievements of Christopher Columbus and Captain Cook. This is how schools are teaching our next generations who one day will take over...

[@pintificate]

@@johnfalstaff2270 You're right John. One way or another the young are getting the idea that nothing ever existed before they were born. And this might not bode well for the future.

[@erichughes3896]

David Phelps. I literally listen to him sing Oh Holy Night all year long, in addition to so many of his other songs. I saw him live 5 or 6 years ago in Macon GA with GVB. I think he will be leading heavens’ choir in eternity. Wish he knew how much his music blesses me. It just makes me happy!

[@karenking5357]

Eric it blesses you and it blesses me and it blesses millions multi-millions of people around the entire world can you imagine God has blessed him because he has used his voice to praise God✝️😇 kind of gets to me; just to say that makes me cry😢 TEARS OF JOY AND THANKSGIVING... God has given to us MANY GIFTS and David Phelps is one of THE BEST ONES EVER!!! I love listening to this song over and over and over again and I don't need Christmas, either, to listen to it...God bless you Sir.., don't we have a magnificent voice to listen to in David Phelps⁉️⁉️⁉️⁉️ and many other of the Gaither people throughout the years I'm a huge fan of both David and Gaither vocal band and really all of his concerts are just really incredible

[@debbieforhim7800]

I've met him a few times now and have said those very words to him! He loves to hear how his talent HUGELY blesses us all. I get to see him perform this very month at his Barn Bash Christmas concert. Can't wait!! He is so amazing live and sooo connects with the audience.

[@looknotes]

i will quote my grandpa, pipe in his hand while operating the record player on christmas eves in the 70s "son, when it comes to o holy night there is only one, jussi"

[@Anonnamus]

There is zero comparison, in my opinion. There is everyone else who sings perfectly fine, and then way up here above the entire world is David Phelps.

[@vheth5968]

AGREE!!!! 100%%%%

[@Ignasimp]

Lol are you saying he sing better than Pavarotti and better than provably the best male singer in history, Caruso?

[@Algorox]

@@Ignasimp In this particular song, yes.

[@Ignasimp]

@@Algorox you couldn't be more wrong. Both his technique and his voice type are not apropriate for the song. And his pop stilitsic choices he used didn't fit the style of the aria either.

[@Tropicalbliss45]

YES! You said it best! He gives me goosebumps every time I hear him sing But especially O Holy Night!

[@bettyh7586]

Jonathan Antoine should get an honorable mention. He hasn’t sung as long as others, but he has a power and potential to kick everyone else out of the competition.

[@scherryvalentine9673]

Actually he was the best by far. Clear as a bell. That’s the point of that song, not who can scream a note for several minutes at the end. The Phelps fellow was horrifying.

[@ttbass897]

His recording was by far the most "overproduced" with pitch corrector and more compression than should be necessary. Talent is there but not the polish.

[@kathparry864]

Jonathan Antoine actually refuses to allow pitch correction anywhere near him, ever! Having said that, the example used here was recorded for a television/streamed concert by a charity, so who knows what they did to it in post production. I, however, love it, and think his performance is the best here. Jonathan's own recording of "O Holy Night" on his "ChristmasLand Platinum Edition" album is indicative of his talent, and if you hear him sing this live, you will hear perfection, guaranteed. (He sang it in December 2022 with the Los Angeles Master Chorale, at their Festival of Carols at the Walt Disney Concert Hall and it was superb!)

[@diplomamilldoc8562]

@@scherryvalentine9673 I'd love to be as "horrifying" as David Phelps. His vocal stamina is incredible.

[@trcooper5793]

Horrifying? I think you may need to get your hearing checked!!

[@paulnewman4624]

Of course Pav and Phelps are the gods but Jonathan A, truly has a beautiful voice. Nice to see him doing well

[@risiateb]

I agree.

[@FiberglassWarehouse]

I believe once Jonathan A's voice finishes maturing, he was be considered up there with Pavarotti.

[@mizofan]

Bjorling a true god of opera.

[@kimmillard9445]

Bjoerling by light years. The top B4 just SHAKES for to the core. It's bright, round but piercing at the same time, absolutely no loss of core in the sound, ideal vibrato action, and replete with that unmistakable Bjorlingesque "shine" he was so renouned for. On the pop side, the lead tenor in Homefree phrased gorgeously and delivered a beautiful clear top B4 but also phrased exquisitely and tastefully going into it and coming off of it although he couldn't quite match Bjoerling's phrasing. (Nobody has.) Hometown just sounded to juvenile with a performance directed at 13-year-old girls. There's just something I find off-putting about David Phelps I can't quite put my finger on, except to say every time I hear him, it feels like he's working extra hard to show off his technical brilliance and gives you a heaping helping of the stratospheric notes. It feels like the ice skater who has all kinds of great jumps and spins but can't quite put together a coherent program to save his life, so they just try to hit you with more technical brilliance. Luciano Pavarotti is quite a bit past his prime here, and that once brilliant open soaring voice sounds tired, pushed and overly covered. You really need to hear the maestro prior to 1985 to get a real sense of his greatness. David Miller of Il Divo delivers a better- than-average top B-flat 4, but what has always impressed me about David both here and in the opera house is his splendid command of the messa da voce in the phrase coming off the top note. Wonderful underrated lyric tenor.