OCTOBER 2024 MACY’S BEAUTY BOX UNBOXING: Did We Finally Get it Right??

[@sherryhenley3327]

I liked this months..I got it last week..I like the blush stick..thank you ❤

[@SherSharesBeauty]

@@sherryhenley3327 I think the hurricane affected my mail. It usually gets here earlier. I tried the blush stick today too and love the shade:)

[@SanayaDiamonds]

That blush looks beautiful ❤

[@SherSharesBeauty]

It’s gorgeous! I tried it on and it’s a perfect shade!

[@TenajNikki]

Good box this time around!

[@SherSharesBeauty]

Yes very happy with it:)

[@missmandaa]

Yay another blush!! My favorite type of product to get aside from lippies!😅 love beauty stat! You got some great brands and products this month! Funny how allure and macys are giving the same products 😅

[@SherSharesBeauty]

Yes! 👏 same! I’ve become a blush junkie lol! 😂 And yes allure and macys must have the same dealer! 😝

[@penerusluckyarul23n]

Beauty Box ❤❤

[@Kayyouhu77]

I like that Cherie shade! Although I'm plenty happy with my Sunset Strip from Allure. It looks like the mini colors are different from what is available in the full size.

[@SherSharesBeauty]

Yea I was trying to figure that out too on the shades. I love the Cherie too! I got picante in the allure choice but Cherie is a little closer to the shades I wear all the time. Love it!

[@loribreitbarth2215]

Love Nudestix ❤. Looks like a great box. Thanks for sharing with us ❤. Or should I say Sher-ing 😂

[@SherSharesBeauty]

Ha ha my pleasure. That’s why my channel is “Sher SHARES Beauty” 😉😂

[@AnnKray-t3n]

I also got soft brown in the brow color, and I'm a blonde

[@SherSharesBeauty]

lol, geez, it is sounding like everyone got soft brown. Makes no sense to give everyone the same shade.

[@LivinLargewithLCruu]

not sure how I feel about some of the shades...thats always tough since everyone has a different look and different preferences! i wonder if that roller actually works?

[@SherSharesBeauty]

Yea it sounds to me like everyone got the same shade too which doesn’t make a lot of sense:(

[@JacquieShupe]

I also got the light brown. It may be too light for me. I’m going to give it a try.

[@SherSharesBeauty]

It ended up working for me! I tried it on this afternoon:) So hopefully it will work for you too. I’m kind of hearing everyone must’ve gotten light brown. 🤔

[@JacquieShupe]

@@SherSharesBeauty after seeing it on you I’m sure it will be fine for me. Thanks for trying it on first!

[@Primadivasm0520]

Hello...I got soft brown on the brow sample also but that will work for me...the November video is already up if you want to do a video on that and one video I saw said Easter Lauder is dropping their holiday box October 10 so would be interesting to get your thoughts on that one

[@SherSharesBeauty]

I tried it on and it does work after all so I’m happy about that. 👏 And yes, thank you, I actually just filmed the November spoilers today so I’ll have them up by tomorrow:) I also worked on a part 1 of my advent calendar series so I’ll probably get to Estée Lauder as part of my advents/holiday series. :)

[@MellaYellow]

I ordered the soft brown my first time not getting taupe. Hope it works. Wish they could color match us.

[@SherSharesBeauty]

Hmmm I hope it works for you. It ended up working out for me so I hope it’s not too dark on you. Maybe just go with a light hand.

[@FilthyOrchid1]

Just heard Milton has turned into a hurricane and is heading towards central Florida. Please stay safe. I hope it won’t be anything major. I’m still sick about what happened with Helene.

[@SherSharesBeauty]

Yes, it’s just terrible. Hurricane season is brutal this year! 😢 I’m probably not going to get as much of this one in my area with it going more central, but it’s sure going to affect so many people!

[@michelezeigler6167]

I received soft brown for brow product.

[@SherSharesBeauty]

It sounds like everyone got soft brown then. Hmm…

[@PureLottie]

I think I’ve had that shade of nudestix blush. I can’t find it now so I must have decluttered or passed on to a friend 😂 The brow def looks too blonde :( Cute little box tho

[@michelezeigler6167]

Only .17 oz for at least 2 items and blush is smaller.

[@HonesTeaBeauTea]

I have the beautystat. I have many. I just tried the eye one.. Its gritty and very oily kinda. Have you tried that one? Opinions? I don't care for it so I have been using it as all over night cream before bed as its kinda like a sleeping mask. I have always wanted to try the Peter Thomas ♡ excited. I pray I get soft brown. Soft brown is ALWAYS my perfect shade. I can work with light brown BUT get this.. my brows are dark brown.. nearly black! You should be able to do soft brown. Plz try it and let me know. I dont know why but I cant use medium brown or brown.. its too harsh, its WEIRD. Girl Oct is the month of brows for you! The P.louise box is ALL brows. Im excited. It looks from swatches like I can use a lot. Are you buying the advent train? I may. Its SO expensive but they have pay in 4.

[@SherSharesBeauty]

So I have the Beautystat eye one but I still haven’t fully used it yet to give a good review. But this universal c is my favorite. It is a little gritty, but it’s such a unique texture. It made such a difference for me in my skin and my age spots! I usually don’t do gritty ones like that but that one was an amazing exception! And I DID just try the soft brown and it DOES work! I’m very happy. It honestly ended up looking as dark as my benefit medium brown. So hopefully it still works for you lol. I can’t do too dark so I know what you mean. But I don’t like the ones that are too warm brown, if that makes sense? It’s gotta be a good neutral shade. I am so excited for my PLouise to come! 👏 I definitely and thinking about the advent calendar but haven’t decided yet. I’m going to share some other calendars and try to make my selections after that:)

[@annamendoza3479]

I've gotten free beauty samples from a company called So Post. I wonder if this is the company that either boxes use.

[@SherSharesBeauty]

Oh interesting. Wouldn’t that be something if they all just use that same site? I might have to look there myself.

[@annamendoza3479]

@SherSharesBeauty Most often if you click on free sample offers on IG or Facebook ads in exchange for an email, it will give you a thank you message at the end from So Post + confirmation email of your 'order' being accepted or processed.

[@michelezeigler6167]

I like the products but they are super tiny.

[@SherSharesBeauty]

@@michelezeigler6167 yes agree. Sometimes our products are so small:(

[@crystalgatliff6342]

I didnt get any of that. My box was totally different

[@SherSharesBeauty]

Oh really?? For October or did you end up with the November box?

[@HonesTeaBeauTea]

I forgot to cancel so I hope its good. I need cute things for stocking stuffers and I purchased advent calenders last year to have the actual boxes to make my own for my kids ♡. Macys is not helpful.

[@SherSharesBeauty]

Whoops yea they’re always very mini sizes though. But I guess that sometimes works ok for stocking stuffers. I thought it was good this month. I’ve got November spoilers loading tomorrow and a heads up, it’s all skincare.

[@HonesTeaBeauTea]

@SherSharesBeauty I thought it may work well for the small spots in an advent. I just started getting it though so we shall see. My daughter will love trial perfume for sure