"Office Hours" with onemorebrown 5

[@onemorebrown]

audio is fixed at this point: kzbin.infoSmt6_vwDBUM?si=V9w1c0PbHC7GqM2h&t=493

[@MrLbsrdi]

Yo Professor Brown, it’s always great when you upload.

[@onemorebrown]

Thanks, I appreciate it!

[@andystewart9701]

I’d love to see you discuss with Peter Godfrey Smith, Andy Clark, and Jesse Prinz, and Barbara Montero

[@onemorebrown]

Great suggestions, thanks!

[@timang3138]

Beyond double modality and strength of intuition, what's Chalmers' main objection to shombies?

[@onemorebrown]

The double modality objection misunderstand my argument so isn't much of an objection...other than that I don't think there have been any objections to the argument, which is pretty frustrating!

[@timang3138]

Even if your argument establishes that current conceivability is weak evidence for failure of entailment, the structure-function argument remains primary to antimaterialism. Even conceivability still plays its role towards absence of analysis. Am I missing the point of your deprioritising?

[@onemorebrown]

My argument directly undermines the second premise of the structure-function argument as well as challenges the 'absence of analysis'

[@timang3138]

Thanks for replying!