Рет қаралды 20,699
PS, I probably could have used lots more examples of good basses (Bohnen, Talvela, etc.), but I really had to limit myself! You'll get the idea.
The examples I used of good singing are Ghiaurov, Kipnis, Chaliapin, Pinza and Mardones.
The bad examples are Furlanetto, Groissböck, Pape, Terfel and D'Arcangelo (who horribly ruins the Anna Bolena trio and uses an abbreviated version because he cannot sing it!).
The music used is from Don Carlo, die Walküre, Boris Godunov, Verdi's Requiem, Faust, die Zauberflöte, and Anna Bolena.
Mainly the problem with the modern singers is nasality (poor vowel formation, i.e. nasal vowels "aw" instead of "ahhh") and a lack of strength.
I tried not to just pick "funny" examples of how bad modern singing is. I tried to get each of the modern singers at their "best" but still show how they pale in comparison to the older technique! (I also levelled off the volume… as well as I know how to).
Thanks for watching :)