NO CONTACT MEANS DONT CALL HER A DUMASSED B&%^H !! WITH A SURPRISE TWIST!

[@sprig.sprout]

I burst out laughing when the prosecutor said “bum ass bitch” 😩 this man’s level of delusion is so scary

[@chosenlevi7633]

Same😂😂😂😂

[@Pyle81]

Such the true romantic he is... 🤦‍♂️🤦‍♂️🤦‍♂️🤦‍♂️

[@KB-90]

Sis explaining the "eat my ass" comment 😂 The look on his attorney's face 🤣 The judge's reaction 😆

[@OSGCourtWatch]

priceless! 🤣

[@PrincessTargaryen]

I couldnt believe his dumb arse really said that shet😂😂😂

[@jdura5651]

my goodness, how everyone kept a straight face had me on the floor!

[@kimberlystone9306]

Right?!! Lol

[@astrid654]

😂😂😂

[@arthurwatt5162]

She's afraid of you bro and wants nothing to do with you so leave her the hell alone.

[@Mandy7D7]

Unfortunatly he just doesn't care. He only cares about his own wants.

[@janetcook3631]

But he wants a baby with her. He is frightening as hell.

[@retha1875]

She needs to get CCW as soon as possible. A piece of paper won't stop him.

[@Empuls]

​@@retha1875 Agreed 10000%.

[@jackmeoff9917]

​@@retha1875 in Michigan you can get an emergency cpl if you have a ppo

[@AliceA333]

Don't know what I stumbled into, but I'm petrified for this girl. She needs cameras w/night vision, firearms, and motion alarms to secure her home before returning each day.

[@wo6783]

I just watched a story about a lady with 3 children who had one die of complications from bronchitus. Soo her bfd ends her and her 2 kids that night. This that and all of it scares me. Folks gotta protect themselves and be cautious

[@811Tb]

I've never seen a more clearer case of delusion, whew! He need a padded room more than a restraining order!

[@Delatta1961]

We’ll hear about him violating the order. He doesn’t seem like the type that follows rules

[@ninthsquarecommunity]

I agree! I bet he forgot the deal 5 mins after he made it!!!!😅

[@c_me_now]

Hopefully it won't be on the news.

[@slingerssecretlaboratory]

Unfortunately, restraining orders are usually the beginning of the violence, not the end of contact. Sick man stalking a poor innocent woman.

[@dizzyyaya1076]

Mmm. The order was good for 5 years? Is that right? He’ll leave her alone and quietly watch her through the internet until that period ends and then it’ll all start again.

[@Slapsofathousand]

Chris really needs to be on supervised probation for the rest of his life.

[@HankBukowski]

Do you think that keeps anyone safe?

[@jamesdeanzbeans]

Dude is 33 years old and has a guardian . You would have to have an underline reason for that to happen. I'm assuming it's his mental state and mix with not having successful relationships for maybe his whole life. I understand why he would react the way he did and the feelings that he hasall of which could be viewed as a natural response

[@cristineconnell7803]

Definitely!

[@Andrew-un8tx]

He needs to be put down before he ends up hurting someone.

[@Slapsofathousand]

@@Andrew-un8tx probably.

[@AliceA333]

His attorney is INCREDIBLE, she took the only path she could to defend her client while still respecting the victim. Very hard to do, and Public Defenders are way overworked. Impressive!

[@jacobwilliams5776]

She is good, she’s doing very good at showing the courts he may have some mental disorder. Listening to the victim , I thought that he was a stranger on the streets that she never met before a day in her life, but his testimony sheds some light on the situation. I actually believe his testimony. The prosecutor is doing her job with using half the text, and I don’t believe the victim. An insult is to say “eat my ass” sexual in context is “eat my groceries”

[@morethanamazed8210]

I agree I have been watching her expression while he was being cross examined and she did the best she could with what she had.

[@BBB-rd2qi]

Agreed! She professional, well spoken, and seems genuinely kind.

[@Andrew-un8tx]

It's funny how she is smiling so hard when he's swearing in. It's like, "oh boy! Here we go."

[@channelone110]

I think she did a great job though I am surprised she didn't try to stop the most painful part of Ms. Kirby's cross of the defendant with some speculation objections.

[@KrysC-TX]

In the words of Oda Mae Brown, “you’re in danger girl.”

[@countrygirl432]

I have had my own experience of being stalked. I was 27 yrs old,a new mother to my only child, and married to my husband for 7 years. I worked as a receptionist for a very well known and large Dr's office (27 Doctors with 150 employees). One of the older married male patients decided that he must have me,take care of my son,buy me my own house blah,blah. I didn't even know this man and he was saying he would leave his wife and his grown children's lives. It was crazzzzyyyy. He went to his vacation home in Mexico with his wife and brought me back all this really good quality jewelry to drop it off with 99 rose bouquet and I love you balloons. I explained to him right in front of my supervisor, one of his treating Dr's who happened to walk by the front check in area and nurse supervisor what was going on. Administration attorneys from the hospital along with the Dr fired this man from the practice and every time I clocked out,I had to have hospital security escorting me to the private enclosed parking garage. Thankfully, he never showed up but it's really scary to have a stalker.

[@OSGCourtWatch]

sorry ya had to go through that…it’s amazing how far some folks will go even when repeatedly told no…

[@ronnieeubanks6559]

Good god😮!

[@Mimzie-Arizona]

Oh how awful

[@carmenlaporte6822]

A mother of four beautiful daughters I teach them about boundaries all the time and a fact No always means NO....

[@davidnorth8745]

So you first said your stalker was an older male patient but then you said he was fired from the practice. How can someone fire a patient? 🤔

[@callmelordhelmet]

After watching him testify, I think I know the real reason his attorney wanted the adjournment. This dude is high af.

[@Sniperboy5551]

Aren’t we all?

[@cindyterry347]

​@@Sniperboy5551 not me

[@joshfly210]

I just got the what you’re talking about OMG… bro is mumbling and surprisingly understanding the questions but he’s LIT.

[@cindyterry347]

@@joshfly210 Lit or on psychiatric drugs?

[@joshfly210]

@@cindyterry347actually I saw him take some pills so if that’s what you’re asking then I’m thinking he might be on Xanax. What I meant by lit was he is high af. Not that he’s a lit person to watch or type of person.

[@rivercitymud]

She started off slow, but once Cassandra got the hang of the procedure she turned into a very compelling witness. Prosecution did a good job of indirectly introducing her to the process while on the stand through carefully phrased questions and gently keeping the testimony germane. You could tell the exact moment when Cassandra understood the point of the questioning, after that she only included details that she thought could possibly be relevant. Not an easy task for either of them considering that all the prep work appeared to have happened under oath. Good questions, good answers, it's always nice to see a team come together like that.

[@retha1875]

Yes. Prosecutor was excellent in her questioning.

[@AliceA333]

@@retha1875 Both attorneys were! Very impressive women, and I LOVE that both attorneys were female since he clearly has no value for him.

[@cazkiwinz4300]

5:39 5:55 I don’t think these were good questions at all! Prosecutors and the Judge just handed him her address on a platter! City, road and a description of what she lives in - shouldn’t take long for a guy that’s been obsessed for decades to find!

[@mdgraves02]

@@cazkiwinz4300I agree I didn’t know why she was putting her address out in a stalking TPO.

[@HighTopJop]

I disagree... And @@cazkiwinz4300 I said the same thing. Like WTF

[@SDoyle-uq8wf]

So instead of taking the deal before trial, which was just a 5 year PPO, the defendant took a deal after the trial and was given a 5 year PPO and a conviction.

[@django1252]

Because criminals are fucking idiots..

[@Sniperboy5551]

That’s the kind of intellect I’d expect from a stalker

[@debcarpenter8519]

He's a smartie!! HA. HA , HA. Not.

[@sjones2195]

He's a psycho.

[@x43902467]

It's just another extension of the game he's playing, dragging this out as much as possible to continue to harass the victim, before jerking around at the end again.

[@django1252]

This guy should be locked up for mental health treatment and supervised..

[@felixtheo6847]

Exactly dude has mental problems

[@1398go]

Good for Carter for leaving after she finished….I’m glad the court didn’t order her to sit through his testimony and bs. This is gut wrenching and horrifying….you can tell he’s leaned in wanting her still!

[@JesusisLRD]

As a s.v survivor, This is a huge violation of her privacy. They should not disclose her new details or address. They have put her in danger .

[@Baby-picky-piggy]

I definitely understand where your coming from but unfortunately she had to establish justification to show how he’s been stalking her through different areas to increase the chances of conviction. She didn’t disclose her current address just the township.

[@cazkiwinz4300]

Well, he now knows the city and road and that it’s an apartment…. 5:39 5:55 He’s been stalking her for nearly 2 decades…. DECADES… and now they’ve just handed him a very, very small area to search for her!

[@Sympetrum]

​@cazkiwinz4300 if you think he doesn't already know her WHOLE address or he could find it in under 15min you are seriously delusional on how much info is on the web and how easy it is to access if you want it. She uses social media, I could find her in literal minutes, and her address. Guaranteed.

[@Sympetrum]

I just did a simple Google for Cassandra Carter in MI and her IG was the first result. She has links from there to her Amazon account and I found her address in 2 hops from there. This is why the web is terrifying and you have to be BEYOND CAREFUL using it.

[@cazkiwinz4300]

@@Sympetrum Well, durr… that’s the point… THIS is on the net, so if she had blocked a lot of her info and social media… this violated that!

[@Rando15]

The admiration I have for the judge and all the court officials grows every time I see them. They are truly amazing people.

[@OSGCourtWatch]

agreed!

[@incomitatus]

I wish we had more judges like him when it comes to certain crimes against kids. My neighbor's little girl was molested by a family member and all this bastard got was a suspended sentence & 5 years probation. That little girl gets to deal with what happened to her for life while this shit goes on with his life, like nothing happened. If I sound angry, I am, I have twin daughters a little bit older than this little girl.

[@AliceA333]

Absolutely, imagine the scumbags public defenders are told they'll be defending. Some have assaulted children, some wreak havoc on women like this toolbag, and they ALLL get a defense

[@cristineconnell7803]

​@@incomitatusI know of a case in Wa state where the little girl just ended up being abused more by adoptive parents while the Dad that had abused her horribly & SA was made a foster care parent in the same state!😡 20-30 yrs later she can still describe in detail what he did to her! It will make you puke & wanna kill someone! I had to leave quick 1 yr when I ran into him again & my Dad's rifle was in the truck!

[@MuzerlinaV]

I agree!

[@2ToneWalt]

I saw this live, he's a creepy disturbed troubled man who needs a great deal of help or guidence.

[@beccatorres]

So because she showed up to his basketball games and talked to him when she was 12-13, it’s ok for him to stalk and harass her for 20 years? This man is delusional and terrifying.

[@muthaluva]

He gave himself 20 different names James John malkoulysses and what not geez. Their both Looney tunes

[@kevinarnold8634]

That's not how he saw it. As a result he became bothersome to her for many years, but not dangerous as though his perspectives and perceptions were skewed he was not violent. Hopefully the verdict will not only take care of the bother he was inflicting but also help him resolve those factors contributing to his socialization issues so he too will benefit.

[@cazkiwinz4300]

Don’t worry… they gave him her city, road and description of what she lives in…. He’ll find her again soon! 5:39 5:55

[@cajuncraftysue]

Wow! 20 years?! That poor woman!!

[@RoughThief]

Dude's clearly mentally handicapped. I think the solution they worked out is good. Sending him to jail would achieve nothing productive.

[@sharonthompson672]

I really admire Ms Carter's strength, character and intelligence 👍 Oh, and with someone like Christopher: NEVER reply. If you ignore 200 attempts and tell him to eff off on 201, his evil pea brain will just conclude "I have to send 201 messages before she'll reply."

[@astrid654]

Ms Kirby’s reaction to the “eating my a**” comment is hilarious 🤣

[@ShannonMichelle7937]

This dude is terrifying. He’s the type to end her and then taxidermy her body and keep it as a wife. Girl you did the right thing!

[@jemandjemand2362]

get a grip. whats wrong with you

[@PepeDeezNutz]

He probably has a skin suit 💯

[@cristineconnell7803]

👍

[@SkotchOG]

It's a bit extreme😅, but he probably is that type.

[@brendaselzer9353]

And after all that a judge will come in and say he has mental health issues, given a script, put in a facility for a minute and then released back into the unsuspecting public. Our justice system is a joke...it's no longer meant to protect the public but the criminals.

[@MsKeebe]

I commend her on her composure. She is dignified, calm, and completely believable. Stalking should be a more serious felony.

[@sheylaabarca9754]

He's not stupid. He knows EXACTLY what he's doing. He likes to play dumb/stupid to get away with his disgusting, conniving, malicious, and shady behavior. Which makes him a complete psychologically disturbed individual. He needs to be locked up.

[@cowboyfan3729]

He's S L O W & therefore, Jail isn't the place for him as he will be mentally & physically abused to a worse state (exactly what his mom fears!) He needs HELP, not JAIL..

[@sheylaabarca9754]

@@cowboyfan3729 there's a psychiatric mental ward in jail. And that's where he BELONGS.

[@cowboyfan3729]

@sheylaabarca9754 Yes, where they lock you in a tiny cell by yourself (24 hours a Day!) with no access to the outside world, or at a minimum, Sunlight.. that's not Help, that's severe punishment (also known as the Hole/ Solitary Confinement). Jail isn't the paradise you're thinking it is & those guards don't give an Eff about anyone in there! They actually participate in the Mental Abuse, & sometimes Physical Abuse, of the inmates!

[@hatwarm]

@@cowboyfan3729 He needs to be locked up in a psych ward in the PRISON.

[@RobertHall-ef8yf]

Dudes High af on opiates.

[@ihaveallthequestions]

Oh wow I am very scared for her this is dangerous he needs court-ordered therapy😮

[@ScubaFanatic60]

So nice to heart a lawyer who doesn't say "um" all the time. Thank you Miss Kirby. I love watching you work.

[@hardcoreromeo2111]

YES!

[@johnharling5246]

That was a bit spicy .... Ms Reed did an excellent job of not down playing the effect these messages have had on Ms Carter while defending her client

[@OSGCourtWatch]

agreed!

[@MesoCarib]

@@No_n_NO__ She won't... because she will not need to justify herself. Overly emotional snowflakes probably should not watch these types of court videos if they so easily trigger them.

[@North_West1]

This was an agreement by both sides. A bit Unusual after bench trial, before verdict.

[@johnharling5246]

@@MesoCarib If claimed you had two viable brain cells I would need proof

[@BakerStudiosIndy]

Caitlin Kirby is not the prosecutor to trifle with.

[@HankyPankyMom]

I will have your baby if you eat my groceries….said no girl ever

[@DarkMessiah499]

Maybe I need my ears checked, but it sounded to me like he said eat her hoo ha. I've been wrong before, but I played it a few times and it sure sounded like he said she wanted him to dine at the y.

[@paub8260]

This is not going to stop him.

[@maddi.o]

Mrs. Reed is a phenomenal lawyer. Often people don't appreciate defense lawyers at all, especially public defenders, but they sometimes are dealt such a hard case and it just blows me away, how well they do for their clients. I really had no idea how Mrs. Reed was going to make a closing. That was borderline miraculous!

[@joshuamankiewicz1942]

I feel bad for how often she gets these cases, but she's always finding someone's silver lining. As my grandma would have said, Bless her heart.

[@robertedwards9055]

I thought she was such a competent lawyer. Credit to the profession.

[@PeachandSass]

She is amazing. very true

[@tomriddle3784]

Although not the crime of the century, stuff like this can easily become much more serious. Hopefully this man can get the hint and stop doing dumb crap like this. He should have got the message before, but sometimes the law needs to step in and guide people before they really ruin their lives

[@OSGCourtWatch]

sounds like his mom has built a good support organization to surround him...good job mom!

[@kerrypearce4264]

Looks like he wouldn’t get the hint even if he were hit in the head with a sledgehammer. (Rather an aggressive analogy but, hey, what the heck!)

[@beer1403]

A crime is a crime. It does not have to b “the crime of the century” to become a more serious crime. Your comment is ludicrous.

[@North_West1]

Being harassed for years would be scary. The complaining witness (victim) repeatedly told him to stop, she blocked him, his family told him to stop, and he kept at it. All she wanted was for him to stop and not be afraid.

[@loreleialexander8607]

I'm sorry you're having a bad day, I hope it gets better for you ​@@beer1403

[@douglasrobson3875]

The eating groceries bit had me almost calling an ambulance. I can’t believe she admitted to it and then clarified it too. He ain’t ever going to leave her alone now because he wants to eat.

[@joanneclarke952]

😂 And 😮🤢

[@cocodelight5077]

He is creepy!!!! Do you all see how he is watching her with the big ol' grin on his face. Damn he is off his rockers.

[@susiepittman601]

Her life is in imminent danger.

[@Annie1962]

Agreed..

[@justsayin1991]

He literally hasn't contacted her for almost 2 1/2 years . . . Like really?

[@pozzee2809]

Unfortunately I have seen where the “ending”, is a double murder suicide. He needs long term commitment to a psychiatric hospital. Jail isn’t going to address his damaged brain, and then he will get out.

[@eldritchwulfe]

@@justsayin1991 Why do you defend this pos? He's a stalker and won't leave her alone.

[@shanibmulkins]

He needs 24/7 supervision

[@SouthernOregonOrgani]

It’s stories like this that make me incredibly grateful to be a male. The bullshit women have to put up with is heart breaking

[@cynthiazullo8117]

Thank you so much for that

[@Myweevestiff]

I get stalked all the time people are literally just crazy

[@maryholden3136]

Occasionally, stalkers are women so while most are guys targeting girls it's a behaviour seen across all members of society regardless of genders, orientation and other factors

[@ThatOneBitch69]

Men also deal with this problem. Just not as often as women do period

[@purpleandred7]

This guy seemed to be delusional regarding what actually happened in their relationship and what he thinks happened. His lies caught up with him. This is the very reason why one should never put anything in writing (letter, text, email) that they don't want to someday come back to bite them in the arse. Another good one, OSG 👍

[@ittybittyynitta]

He sounds like there’s something wrong with him . I’m very scared for this woman

[@KarnageKollectibles]

He's mentally handicapped.

[@BostonCeltics19]

He was very high. He is also very crazy.

[@eeeeemeeee9047]

At 49:00 she really tells the judge what eating groceries means and he's like "OK thank you" 😂

[@pollycebula605]

These poor, poor victims of stalkers must be absolutely devastated by the behavior of these mentally challenged individuals. Instead of the stalker losing their liberty, the victim is, in fact, losing theirs. I can't imagine the torment these people cause. It doesn't help to know it is an illness. I don't believe enough is done to protect the victims.

[@ginamartinez1654]

Unless some screenshots weren't shown. Not in one of the messages did she say anything about having his kids or him eating her groceries (which is new one on me btw lol) she was consistently telling him to leave her alone. He is completely delusional.

[@kwp973]

Yooooooo the public defender really asked Ms. Carter "did you send the message about eating the groceries!!!! OLD SQUISHY GARDNER YOU JUST OUT DID YOURSELF!! BRAVO THIS IS PURE GOLD! PLEASE FIND MORE LIKE THIS PLEASE. I'M LITERALLY CRYING😂😂😂😂😂😂

[@lorimcbrayer8431]

These people are insane! This man needs to be in a mental hospital forever.

[@PrincessTargaryen]

Ive been stalked by a psychotic female before over my ex. She did the same in court rambled and said a bunch of non sense. Lucky for me she had a history of stalking her baby daddy’s girlfriend as well. So the judge made it clear if she violated the restraining order at all she would receive jail time. The day and hour the order expired she began stalking me again. Posting my old address online etc. never ever again has my drivers license ever reflected my real address. Apparently your drivers license address is public record which is so dangerous in these situations The delusions never end. Jail is where they belong when they are crazy.

[@jaykay1053]

This is public service at its best! Ms Reed & Pros. Kirby are gifts to the U.S. judicial system. This is democracy, in action, folks. Here’s to the unsung heroes of democracy! 🥂

[@rosesigner]

Like how else can we just say 'NO' and be heard. His lawyers point is that because she sent him 2 messages that could somehow, maybe, be construed as a se×ual invitation. That it's ok for him to stalk, harass and intimidate her for YEARS and even send her explicit photos? That feels like victim blaming to me.

[@silenceisgoldn]

No, no one blamed the victim. I'm wondering what everyone else watched and if I watched something different. For me, this man lacked the sophistication to do what many of the commenter are accusing him of. I thought he was actually confused by this woman and, for real, was hopeful she wanted to get back with him. I don't think he is capable of understanding what's really going on as a result of bigger issues he's contending with... issues that have resulted in this 34 year old mans need for a guardian. They didn't give us any back story on this man except when in closing, his attorney made reference to a guardian (but unclear why the need). I hope he stays away so she can feel safe. He has for the 2 years since the case stated so that's a great indicator. I wish then both well.

[@metaphysician7621]

The prosecutor, Ms. Kirby, is terrific - confident and an excellent questioner. Excellent lawyering.

[@srednivashtar4762]

“He has come into the light.” Priceless.

[@Mandy7D7]

This guy knows exactly what he is doing. He did a good job skirting the questions. The mental issues don't cut it with me, except to maybe to his own attorney as at 36:10 "Just to clarify" Makes a statement for the record that he never said. I hope he leaves this woman alone. 5 years seems ridiculous, just make it permanent. 😠 I'm so frustrated for her. 😄

[@messrsandersonco5985]

He did a terrible job of 'skirting round' the key questions. He was totally transparent and didn't have the WIT to deny certain missives! Mental health is NOT an excuse for criminal behaviour!

[@shelaghclark5188]

This poor lady 😨 dangerous, 20 of her lifeet looking over her shoulder because of a delusional dangerous man 😮💙

[@hildia5439]

Raises hand "he's in the dark judge!" (Smiles smugly in teacher pet mode)

[@jaibrooks2018]

😂😂

[@IToastMySocks]

Cringe..

[@messrsandersonco5985]

Absolutely LOVE her attorney, her line of questioning and the fact he made her repeat the scary stuff. Hilarious! Also, his avoidance of her key questions was very telling. His GUARDIAN needs some examination. She is not at all in control of him!

[@roguelily7957]

This is why when Ive ended a relationship i dont even leave the door opened a crack... fools think they can come back. Block them on EVERYTHING.

[@heatherbryant6090]

He is never going to leave her alone.

[@InsomniOwl_]

Poor woman. I feel like most women have unfortunately been in similar situations, including myself. Weirdos be weirding.

[@jaywan5553]

His attorney opened a lot of boxes that were not beneficial for her client.

[@msbrightside181]

My daughters ex was like this. Just would not leave her alone. Finally, he broke into her home in the middle of the night, tried to kidnap her, terrorizing her and her kids. He didnt realized she had a gun. When he saw it, he took off. Coward. These type of guys will find a million ways to contact you.

[@Bu11d0gz]

That guy is extremely scary. He truly believes what he thinks. He thought they were platonic even though she has had ZERO to do with him and she even told him to leave alone. He faked seeing her in places. He is the guy we see about on 48 Hours or Dateline. He will kidnap her and keep her in a dungeon. She needs lifelong orders keeping him away from her.

[@terrysueg8308]

The patience of court officers and staff must be unlimited! Some of the plaintiffs and defendants are so aggravating!!

[@gp5674]

Hmm, like, hmm, you know, hmm, like, hmm, you know, I think, hmm, you know, hmm I think like, hmm, I know like, hmm, what you mean, you know.

[@kellielangle4501]

Ms Reed did an amazing job defending this guy especially because he wouldn’t cooperate with her at all.

[@DarkMessiah499]

She must've known it was an impossible task. It's sad.

[@North_West1]

Ms. Reed and Ms. Kirby are always professionals and respectful to all involved. Arguing your side vigorously does not have to rude or condescending. Viewing interactions they respect each other.

[@tattletail9720]

I Wish I could buy Judge Simpson a beer or hamburger or something, he just seems like a reasonable and easy going guy, even in the face of madness.

[@MuzerlinaV]

Amen.

[@srednivashtar4762]

I note that Cassandra was cut off trying to explain that she needs social media for “her work” and that is a modern, lamentable, condition. I’m assuming she deems it necessary to keep her sites public. Again, a strange and seemingly unnecessary condition that “business” requires these days.

[@ejpendleton]

Outstanding PD. She did a great job in illuminating the facts that saved her client. We must understand, what seems to obvious to some, it is not to others.

[@yvonnemccartney9219]

I also wondered if I was the only one who picked up on that.

[@cynthiazullo8117]

I am very afraid for her

[@PeggyStentzCasey]

I hope we can follow that to the sentencing. I feel sorry for the guy because he is obviously ill (and possibly drugged from his speech) but I'm glad the young woman is being protected. She doesn't deserve to be on the receiving end of his delusions.

[@OSGCourtWatch]

hey Peggy! it definitely was an interesting case. from what I gathered he hasn’t made really recent contact and the victim got the protective order she sought and I’ll be a little surprised if he violates it but we will see

[@tipmn2979]

@@OSGCourtWatch would actually not be surprised at all if he doesn’t stop. When you make what 10 accounts because you keep getting blocked…ur really dumb or will never give up…can’t decide where this is

[@alalmquist9423]

His own mother knows it off his gourd.

[@jennstewart3003]

​@@OSGCourtWatch over 10yrs and he hasn't stopped.... A PPO is NOT gonna stop him

[@OldDood]

So HOW is she 'Protected'? What is stopping this guy from harming her? A Piece of Paper?

[@darla218]

Ugh. He took a screenshot of her when it froze. You can see the flash light his face. So gross.

[@evmcelroy]

The NRA would object to this guy being unable to buy a gun. And he is EXACTLY the kind of person who should have no access to guns. Ever. And let me add, I am gun owner myself, but definitely not an NRA supporter.

[@Pyle81]

Well since he has multiple drug convictions (FELONIES) a long with extensive criminal history record, Under Federal law 18 USC § 922(g) & (n), Mr Kelly is a "Prohibited Person" and can not purchase,posses, a firearm or ammunition.

[@ninamc1]

I hope Cassandra is safe!

[@dahof2789]

This predator will not stop. Predators have no regard for protective orders. Only one solution.

[@deborahfenley5825]

I was stalked by my extremely violent ex-husband in spite of a PPO. I drove a school bus with special service children. He even followed my bus and stopped behind me as I dropped my students. My boss even filed charges on him. I made a police report for every incident also. This was in 1991 and laws were different then. I was terrified because he ignored the PPO and even after being locked up I saw him lurking in the shadows just far enough away so he wasn't in violation of the PPO. He wanted me to know he was there, watching me every day. It took several jail stays and moving 4 hours away to get away from him. I had to uproot my 3 children from the school district they had gone to their whole life. They were severely affected too and had to have therapy too. Even after we moved I still looked over my shoulder constantly. My point is that after all that I was still being stalked in my mind even though he wasn't there. It took a long time and a lot of therapy to finally feel safe. The fear doesn't go away so easily. Laws against stalking need to be stiffer to deter contact early on. Especially where DV has occurred.

[@pattipeters9861]

The defense is really arguing that HIS perspective is more important than HERS? 😮

[@jwaller132]

Prisons are todays mental institutions. Thanks Reagan.

[@amandaadkins799]

Imagine how uncomfortable Ms Reed was asking about "eating the groceries" 😂

[@329er]

Social media. Makes it so easy for these people to terrorize the victims. I sure miss the 90’s!!!

[@1noteC]

I empathetize w/ her. My ex make 6 different FB pages, 3 IG pages and sent multiple emails to contact me after I moved and blocked him. These guys are PSYCHOPATHS 😢

[@julieroth3347]

I love this judge

[@amandaadkins799]

Soooo.. we aren't going to talk about the lawn chair in his room? 😂

[@kat8434]

😂

[@ninthsquarecommunity]

Lololol😂😂😂😂

[@ninthsquarecommunity]

Makes u wonder if he isn't one of those guys who can only eat with a spork!!!

[@dannolte5384]

I've never heard the term "eat my groceries" before, so I learned something.

[@analushington8994]

So did I 😂

[@carolinechew9155]

Is that heroin, alcohol, or a combination of both?!? Her life is certainly in danger. Imminent.

[@doodleydoo8264]

Love Judge Simpson... also love the chaos that is the Honorable Judge Herman Marable's court room. Love these guys.

[@OSGCourtWatch]

I still got a LOT of Judge Marable I need to work on 🤣🤣

[@doodleydoo8264]

@@OSGCourtWatch I definitely look forward to it, I love the channel boss. I have notifications and they all are acknowledged 🤜🤛🍻👏👏👏🥳

[@valerie362]

I learn something every time I watch Squish! I knew about different food emojis meant things but had no idea what "eat my groceries" meant. What is wrong with people?!?!? 😂

[@prettypeggy98]

Judge Simpson is wonderful 👍. I have been enjoying these videos and also getting familiar with just how Court proceedings work. Thank you for my on going education!

[@stephenjones101]

One of the best, most complete trial videos I've seen that also maintained interest the entire way through. A lot of longer trial videos are just plain boring. Anyway, thanks for posting this!

[@Juicetheeunuch]

5:45 Surprising that the prosecutor doesn't recognize that the vctim doesn't want her new address known. Wow. Some people really don't think.

[@sibusiso3909]

Prayers for safety and protection going out to this lady🙏🏾

[@_Tylor_]

I adore this judge, Judge Simpson 💗 he's professional but also has the ability to be human AND when acceptable, can laugh and smile and invites others to do so momentarily as well!! 👏👏👏

[@cynthiatolman326]

Perhaps, now that the attorney has stated her actual apartment complex, she's thinking she's going to have to move to feel safe. I would. What she didn't do years ago was to actually get the police involved, thank God, but I'm surprised she's still alive. She should have been told to answer questions short and sweet, don't go on with unnecessary details. She really does get carried away. The quicker she's done, the quicker he's done, I hope they order mental help

[@cynthiatolman326]

@@KrepCake Ahhhh.

[@Wildcat221]

Love judge Simpson, one of the most well rounded judges I’ve ever seen. Also love Ms. Kirby(not just cause she’s cute) she’s a solid prosecutor and she’s very intelligent. They got a good thing going in that county. ❤

[@NahualliUoxtitla]

I'm glad I saw this video. I've definitely done things that border on stalking and harassing in the past, just from not being able to move on, and sometimes under the influence. I'm glad and a little embarrassed this helped open my eyes. 😮

[@loisbolton1800]

Amazing work, Squish. You caught the end and we got the resolution. Thank you 🎖️

[@techniciandave9253]

Awesome job Old Squishy Gardener! Thank you so much!

[@mamamichellegist]

LMAO KIRBY😂 the question was when did the relationship end, he starts babbling into some ridiculous tangent leading to that it was ‘basically’ in high school and he continues into oblivion until she whips out- “okay, so, high school. thank you.” also hearing caitlyn kirby say “bum ass bitch” SENT ME LOLLLL😂😂😂

[@jpwhiddon]

What a hard job to be a public defender. I give her props for trying.

[@Jennifer72ification]

I could never defend a psycho stalker. Hell nah

[@LiquidSoul06]

​@@Jennifer72ification that's why you're not a lawyer

[@lindarodriguez576]

Wow, what a wonderful judgment.

[@michaelharrington75]

45:50 Prosecution: "Do you think that sending that photo would be disturbing to a reasonable person?" Defendant: "Depends on how they feel." He doesn't have the sense of a mule. Lol

[@ajred1976]

He thought judge Simpson was stupid and would believe his I don’t know how to work the camera. Ha ha ha!

[@Gingerhomeandgarden]

You deserve so much more. I am glad you aired this. I have had banning/restraining orders its scary and takes alot out of the victim. I wish her well

[@SOMD-THC]

Very interesting. Mr. Kelly needs help badly. Hope he will leave Ms. Carter alone! Glad you had the complete video! 😂😂🤷🏼‍♀️✌🏽🧿

[@CalvinBDaG]

The reactions by Judge Simpson and Ms. Reed at 35:54 are funny asf! When dude said, “Yeah she said she’d have my kid(s) if I ate her groceries, which I thought means if I ate her vagina…” (Edit:) Oh it gets even better! Thank you so much Ms. Reed for asking that question @ 48:16! And thank you Ms. Carter for correcting the them on what it means, and thank you Judge Simpson for laughing and going back over it! Oh man this is a great hearing! Thank you so much OSG for bringing this to us! PSA Kids: “Eat my groceries” doesn’t mean what he thought it meant…it’s the other body part, that’s all I will say on that😅.

[@cajuncraftysue]

Your attorney is there to HELP you! Why are you not speaking to her? Crazy! Yeah, this guy is dangerous! I pray for your safety young lady! ❤️🙏🏻. Just started binge watching your channel and I’m fascinated!! Love this!! New subscriber!