Our 2024 Catcher Tier List (with Jolly Olive)

[@generallukeproductions]

I’m absolutely starting Twitter beef for Heim

[@chriskucholtz6967]

Me too, dawg. No respect for my man. 😊

[@mightygerot4427]

Absolutely

[@zacharycarr2213]

Nah Fr

[@FTLnovaKid]

😂😂😂

[@glucosaminecondroitan9135]

Awesome to see Cal Raleigh talk at the beginning.

[@joshdude1975]

Thanks for this guys Your whole media team has really helped me learn more about baseball this past year

[@Indicadominant07]

Wholesome ass comment

[@mightygerot4427]

Heim is a dominant defensive catcher being known rn as one of the best framers in the game and he also led the position in RBI’s

[@chriskucholtz6967]

Top 4 in MLB in all aspects.

[@jacksonholloway5535]

RBI are more of a team statistic than individual

[@mightygerot4427]

@@jacksonholloway5535 shows he can get hits when it matters

[@chriskucholtz6967]

@jacksonholloway5535 not strictly. Still an individual stat as well... and an important one.

[@alexisborden3191]

LMAO, you just cited cited a pretty good statistic, and then immediately brought up one of the worst stats of all time.

[@Robertstevens11567]

As a Mariners fan I would put Heim in twitter beef.

[@MusicKidRem]

One thing that's underrated about the Angels' young players that no one seems to be talking about is their leadership qualities. O'Hoppe and Neto are natural leaders in the clubhouse, something that I feel has been missing for some time now. There's a lot that needs to be fixed before we'll be a good team, but having those young guys as clubhouse leaders is awesome to see and makes me hopeful as a fan.

[@mcgarbage4974]

Cal and Garver with that M’s pitching is absolutely nasty

[@RileyMerlino]

I love the comments about Cal Raleigh. I think he makes the all star team this year behind Adley. I agree he is not quite S Tier, but if he plays like he did in the second half of 2023 to start 2024, he’s definitely making the all star team. He hit 19 home runs in the second half of 2023 and I truly believe he could get to 35-40 home runs if he stays healthy

[@pickeledpeanuts1127]

Jake: S-Tier BBD: Set It and Forget It Jolly: Let's Find the Ceiling

[@TheSmithhhz]

Danny Jansen is loved in Toronto. We're hoping to get a full season out of him without injuries. He was injury plagued last year and still put up insane numbers.

[@diegogutierrez2415]

Kirk's the best.

[@emeraldvalleykush]

I will go to war for Cal Raleigh

[@walkertube4912]

Bigggg dumperrrrr

[@davidwindell]

He’s nice, but .308 OBP? Woof.

[@tjtribble.]

About the Mariners and the Polanco trade, the front office has pretty much said they’re done. Or at least they don’t feel the need to do anything more. They also were ADAMANT about keeping their starting pitchers, so don’t expect any of them to be traded. Oh and real ones know that Darren Bowen was the biggest piece in the return package

[@Turttoepain]

These are more fun than I thought to watch. Thanks guys!

[@nolankahler6705]

As a Mariners fan, I’m going to war over Cal Raleigh not being in S tier tier

[@Durantcj]

What’s with the Jonah Heim hate! Definitely should be higher ranked higher… 4th or 5th best catcher in all of baseball IMO. AL Allstar, Gold Glove, world champ… does everything well offensively and defensively… one of the most well rounded catchers on the list

[@chriskucholtz6967]

Have no idea. There is hatred for the Rangers in general. I had to check these comments before I watched the video. I assumed right. Everyone is saying no respect for Jonah... so I'm not going to watch the video. It will just make me mad. It's hard to take these guys seriously when they ignore greatness routinely. That and they still can't pronounce Adolis after the 23 world series? Right... and you're a baseball fan?

[@HymnLee]

@@chriskucholtz6967 I don't think its hatred lol, but I think it's just maybe a lack of acknowledging how much respect they deserve for what they've done. Alot of the times when people call into question the amount notoriety, or rather lack of that they recieve, people say in response "yea they should've won, they were in first all years till the end and we talked about em'." which kinda ignores a lot of the trials and tribulations they went through with injuries during the season (imaging losing your 5 year, 100+ ace 6 games to their pitching in lol), and the issues with the bullpen at the end, and that even though the rangers were 1st all year, the Astros were favored to win throughout the season which they did to give them credit 'cause the rangers went into their first slump of the year at the end, but fuck bro, the 'stros are still favored to win the division even though the rangers just won the whole thing lmfao. Jonah Heim is in my opinion a top 5 catcher in the game right now considering Heim is 5th in throwing out runners, 3rd in framing, and has a little less than equal to stats batting wise to Rutschman's, but Rutschman with his 4.3 WAR in 2023 compared to Heim's 2.9 beats him there. It's just a mixture of people who think they give the rangers their credit, but have to do so in a backhanded way that feels as if anyones who tries to question it may be seen a spoiled hater lol. This being said, I mostly agree with their tier list lol, but not giving heim his flowers is the norm for most rangers. Adolis García had one of the greatest post-season performances of all time, but people still are hesitant to give him his due praise in some areas. (I mean hell, even the rangers are fighting for money arbitration with him rn lol).

[@chriskucholtz6967]

@Hemmle yes, well said. And I'm joking when I say hatred. Lol I'm sure there is no hate. But, Good grief... you're telling me you can't pronounce Adolis... still? I think that's intentional. But I hope Adolis doesn't get his feelings hurt in his arbitration hearing. It's normalfor clubs to do this. Though, I do think he's been a little underpaid for the past 3 years... pay that man. He puts butts in seats. He has the whole dugout dancing... and that smile... it's invaluable.

[@jacksonholloway5535]

How is rating a guy as a top7/8 catcher in the MLB "hate" 🤣

[@chriskucholtz6967]

@@jacksonholloway5535 because he is top 4 or 5. Simple. Lol

[@Bruc_eTheBear]

I can't wait for a season where my boy Danny Jansen doesn't break a bone in his hand and ends up hitting 40 home runs

[@jacobbyers7914]

As my wise Canadian mutual says on Twitter: "And here's another hit, Danny Bonds"

[@FTLnovaKid]

😅

[@diegogutierrez2415]

Kirk's better.

[@Zachrdoodle]

Patrick “best defender in baseball” Bailey

[@FTLnovaKid]

29:58 why is it Vazquez and not Jeffers? Jeffers is the starting catcher. You even mentioned the twins “shopping Vazquez”. 🤨🤨🤨

[@davidott886]

As a Tigers fan, if Jake Rogers can give us average Defense and 15 homers until Dillon Dingler becomes the everyday catcher is all we can ask for. Side note, the Tigers might make some real noise in the Central next year with the Twins getting a little worse and the Guards and Sox not improving at all

[@raycmuck]

As a Dodger fan, Austin Barnes Give us one thing. Since he’s our back up for Smith

[@jacksonroberts2205]

Patrick Bailey had 2.8 fWAR last year, more than Willson Contreras. Tyler Stephenson had -0.7, less than Tomas Nido.

[@MrGrammarPolice]

They don't watch West Coast baseball lol

[@VegeMaticPragtarian]

Shoulda had a “ARE these MFers Real?” for the lower end and a “Are these MFers REAL?” For the higher end

[@averystanley7013]

We need a waiting on Kyle Teel category for Boston

[@isaacmartinez_]

Jonah Heim should be in the S-tier conversation, once he was on the IL the Rangers faltered

[@generallukeproductions]

Also REALLY good defensively

[@ericmcclellan6901]

I’m putting him in the twitter fight tier, but yeah he’s underrated by these guys

[@RyanDudziak]

I think the issue with Heim is he’s only in his 2nd full season and he’s only been an above average bat once.

[@jacksonholloway5535]

He is very clearly at least a tier below Adley, Murphy, Contreras and Smith

[@jacksonholloway5535]

Also don’t know how he could be S tier given that he’s not better than Cal Raleigh

[@oworthing]

I think Henry Davis fits in Is that MFer Real? for this year with Endy Rodriguez being out this upcoming season. Should see a bit more time behind the plate than last year

[@GymAndSun]

Will Smith rebirth 2024 and Logan O Hoppe breakout 📈

[@TheQuestKids]

Great video, but why aren’t you ranking the players within the tiers???

[@curtisbradley6397]

Someone hasn’t looked at yan Gomes’ stats recently and it shows

[@dylankrejci9965]

For real. Gomes is kind of a boring catcher but he calls a good game and produces enough offensively to not be a liability. I like him

[@ricdeleon85]

Splits for Y. Diaz, better hitter when he was catching games last year

[@lathanmckinney]

True Jays fans know that Jano is the better bet and that we should have sold high on Kirky and kept Moreno in the DBacks trade.

[@carolynquinn8325]

Co-sign!

[@Faded_36]

Thank you for the love for Luis Campusano.. he is a stud and a half. Padres fans are so excited for him. And he is a Hot Boy for sure!

[@baileysmith4744]

Jonah Heim is literally Twitter Beef with Raleigh. he is so good for the Rangers and is such a guy. he at the very least is the bottom end of Twitter Beef

[@stlpatty12]

I think the tier that Willson Contreras is in is fair but definitely needed to bump him ahead of Salvy tho

[@caseyhancock6295]

Yea. Jonah is a top 4 catcher. Y'all wild.

[@Prunesquallor]

You guys forgot about Ryan Jeffers, who just had a huge year for the Twins.

[@siddhshahi8649]

Jake is a man of culture for knowing that tiffany gomas name good ig follow 🤣🤣

[@Antw0n22]

I start SO MANY twitter fights for Jonah Heim. Needs to be up one tier

[@chriskucholtz6967]

I'm with you. No respect. It makes no sense.

[@5TUNT1N]

Pat Bailey was injured a lot near the end of the season.

[@joegaster34]

Gomes was a beast last year

[@ghost64626]

I'm really excited to see more of Gabbi Moreno this season

[@waxknucklebearingjuice5592]

Cal took us to the playoffs two years ago. Hey now , hey now , hey now ! He's pnw royalty for life. Sea us rise !

[@waxknucklebearingjuice5592]

Let's not forget , he's calling pitches for arguably best pitching staff in baseball. Plus ......DAT ASSSSS!

[@ChunkyRacc]

That's so funny. I just watched the video where joez destroyed their spirits for 30 minutes. I think it was the mlb top 30 of active K leaders

[@jacef551]

Francisco Alvarez’s offensive stats are scarily similar to Volpe. Crazy to hear Jolly say he loves him and to see how us Yanks fans feel skeptical of Volpe. I think the kid is really gonna bang this year (in Boone voice)

[@jenbaseball7611]

Love Cal Raleigh and where you ranked him. He’s fantastic and I’m a huge M’s fan.

[@flood7203]

We love ya jake and jolly

[@blakecarter1312]

Willson and Salvy in the same tier is kinda wild

[@spencerharkins2021]

Love Jake for zinging the blue jays fans

[@davidwindell]

Bo Naylor 1) had better WAR starting at C than Yainer, and 2) led ALL MLB catchers in WAR per plate appearance (min 200PA). At 4.7 WAR per 500 PA, he was far ahead of second place William Contreras (4.4/500) and significantly more productive than Adley (3.7/500). Bo is about to have a massive year if he stays healthy. He has exceptional pitch selection and his ability to draw a walk will lead to an OBP around .360-.380 and an OPS over .830

[@colingentry296]

Hiem was dominant defensively golden glove all star starter and won the world series I'm fighting day and night for hiem

[@mitchellL1]

Jolly being absolutely FRIED in this episode is a real JM classic. I spent the entire video trying to figure out whether or not his eyes were open.

[@Crunchy_Zen]

I put Heim right below S tier. Maybe in S tier, but I thought he was probably 24 so I'm Mayne not the guy to complain.

[@Durantcj]

I’m taking Heim over Raleigh all day! I’d rather have Heim then JT also!

[@jacksonholloway5535]

Heim over Raleigh is delusional XD

[@willc5208]

@@jacksonholloway5535every single one of heims stats is better than Raleigh’s

[@mack72711]

From a hitting standpoint Yainer Diaz is gonna be a top tier catcher this season

[@laserred87]

lol at jolly saying "People might be starting to think the snakes won the moreno trade". Im a Jays fan and we got absolutely fleeced lol. we probably lose the trade if it was moreno for varsho 1 for 1. but lets not forget they also got gurriel than went on to make the world series while toronto got swept by the twins. not even close imo 😄

[@Mxkavelii]

[@MrGrammarPolice]

Bailey got fatigued catching nearly every day/back to back for the first time in his career. His offense slumped, as most rookies do, but he finished 2nd in the gold glove after 90 ish games in the MLB. But....this knowledge would require you watch a west coast team not named the Dodger 😮‍💨

[@ayydubs987]

you’re not helping his case at all. and none of them are dodgers fans or watch any dodgers games. you’d know that if you watched any of their videos 😮‍💨

[@MrGrammarPolice]

@@ayydubs987 the only west coast team they talk about is LA, you'd know that if you watched any of their videos lmao. Not knowing Bailey had more fWAR in half a season than realmuto, Alvarez, Wilson contrares, naylor, Diaz etc is crazy. Dude finished 2nd in the gold glove for a reason

[@ryancooper3603]

Gabby is going to be in S-tier after this year. He's already top 3 defense and his offense is going to greatly improve this year

[@tysonmaddox1090]

Nah I actually agree as a Phillies fan about JT. If you watched the team consistently, you saw that he took a step back offensively and even a small step defensively

[@guy38800]

Wong was appropriately placed. Might’ve been a bit too kind actually.

[@ssjdaiko739]

God damn im early Nothing a wake n bake while watching some wake n jake to start off the morning

[@jkdubya85]

The Jonah Heim slander!

[@adamb27473]

Bo Naylor put up 2.4 fWar in 67 games, 2nd among the young guys to only Alvarez, who had 0.3 more in 56 more games. In fWar/162 he blows them all out of the water. I understand why he is where he is on the list, but his ceiling is nuts.

[@MrGrammarPolice]

Pat Bailey had 2.9 Fwar soooo

[@davidwindell]

⁠​⁠@@MrGrammarPoliceyeah, but all on defense. Bailey doesn’t belong in this conversation until he can hit. He also played in 30 more games, so I’m pretty sure Bo still takes that cake. You extrapolate Bo to the same 97 games and he’s at 3.9 fWAR

[@connersloan08]

I am 10000% starting twitter and ig beef for Cal Raleigh. That’s my ride or die

[@GeneralSalsaa]

Love the bo naylor recognition

[@kebobs3727]

Us Cubs fans will go to war for Yan GOATmes

[@ZaneSmaaladen]

I'm sorry but you rank Christian Vazquez instead of Ryan Jeffers who was a top 5 catcher in the AL last year?

[@BigZ7799]

I need to see a 1B Tier list. That would be fun.

[@maxxramas]

Why am I even starting this? Adley Rustchman no question.

[@chamoisauce7491]

the bottom tier for SS should’ve been “DOWN GOES anderSSon DOWN GOES anderSSon” 😂😂

[@acgonzales7]

Langeliers was in the Olson trade, not Murphy. That's 4 catchers on this list the Braves have had the last 3 years lol.

[@JK-tw3ne]

They got another catcher coming up they really like Drake Baldwin. He's in that William Contreras category where they like his bat but defense is questionable right now.

[@acgonzales7]

@@JK-tw3ne yea he's raked in the minors so far. He should be at ST and in AAA this year so we should get more insight on him soon. I wouldn't be surprised if he got called up later this year if they needed another catcher or DH.

[@kylewoodring706]

Willson kinda doesn’t have a tier right now because he’s definitely not Twitter beef but he’s also not a set it and forget it. He might only play 80ish games at catcher this year and is gonna have a TON of DH days because Ivan Herrera is gonna get a lot of run.

[@ryanfoster2936]

shea was the centerpiece (with pache) of the olson deal, not the murphy deap

[@diegogutierrez2415]

You'll remember this: Alejandro Kirk #1! He has 3hr all ready. 😂 I'm buying Kirk if you guys are selling😂

[@jaredfreeley8283]

Contreras and Salvy on the same tier??

[@jbbeats2042]

Jonah played half the year with an injury that required surgery to heal without having surgery. And by commenting I am proving him to be in twitter beef category. Lmao

[@willc5208]

No way you put cal Raleigh above Jonah Heim

[@carsonblythe8604]

Bailey under alvarez is criminal to me. Bailey was the better last year and if he finds his bat, I am starting legitimate beef over him

[@justinlatini4725]

You guys really need to learn more about players. I had to turn off the video as soon as Raleigh wasn’t listed in the top category. He’s better than all of the dudes listed above him.

[@GaninIsMyName]

I’m starting beef for Cal. 30 nukes is awesome, but why aren’t we talking about the fact he catches and calls for some of the nastiest pitchers in the league? They’re all nasty, and he makes them look even nastier with his calls, framing and consistency. 145 games? And how are we glancing over the switch hitter aspect and, perhaps more importantly, the clutch factor? You know how many times we had the rally shoe on for Raleigh? Bout to start calling it the Raleigh Shoe. Anyways, with all that said, I think it’s fair to add a tier above S tier just for Cal. Thank you for coming to my ted talk.

[@AnthonyNabor]

I wanted Austin Barnes on this list

[@Seigerootz]

They probably would have put him in give me one thing but Austin Barnes

[@Jasonwfd]

Do SS next!

[@kebobs3727]

The Yan Gomes disrespect! We do not need or want Gary while Yan is still in town >:(

[@arcticredpanda4598]

Are you guys in the same room?

[@betecki]

No Ryan Jeffers?

[@cidmontenegro8225]

Love the Rays just get a logo. That's all the love their catchers deserve, they should hide their faces.

[@ptpc_official]

I mean me personally, I'd bump Wilson Contreras up (yes I am a Cardinals fan,) but in the beginning of the year I was like, "this mf can't block or frame fs" then as the season continued he adjusted to his new team. First season ever with a different team (yes I know same division,) but Cubs and Cardinals are still a rivalry, so I think he was bad at the beginning. Getting the new team jitters out, but slowly picked it up to his elite level again. He was like the best hitter right after the All Star break for like 3-4 weeks he just popped off. So yea, I think he should be up higher, but overall love the list.

[@joshzuniga8643]

jolly got a lil sauce lately

[@bamesbamesbames]

Big Dumper gonna go off this year

[@samuelwestwood6255]

Moreno is my catcher, i would start twitter beef for him

[@andyclaassen3487]

CF tiers next!

[@karlapants]

Fransisco Alvarez is my catcher and I will start a fight on any platform for him and he will prove himself this season!!!!

[@asdfaeou]

Interested to see how the Will Smith takes pan out in a few years.

[@ayydubs987]

meaning…?

[@adamgt4037]

How do you say a guy (Gabby Moreno) that just Won a Gold Glove, isn't for Real? Gabby is an absolute Stud and will be the best Catcher in the Majors along with Adley Rutschman for Years to come!

[@votekyle3000]

Definitely want to see what sophomore Yanier Diaz has to offer, is he real. To note, he was offensively much better when behind the dish, and also really needs to work on plate discipline

[@pickzkickz]

U say this because of playoffs...

[@r0btimUs0341]

Listen at two times the speed and Jake sounds like Ben Shapiro😂

[@Deesweezy]

😂

[@D.A.D.8686]

Apparently you're looking for beef with Braves fans. Travis would start on 20 other teams.

[@WhiskiDev]

What is this? A tier list for ants??? 🐜

[@zoom3184]

I’m a Mariners fan mad that Cal isn’t in S tier, but I guess that proves he belongs in twitter fight tier

[@pickzkickz]

Half a season for Yainer....23 homers. Astros record. Correa 22.