(OUTDATED VIDEO, READ DESCRIPTION) The Sonic and Sega All-Stars Racing Trilogy - Which is Best?

Hi all, this video is outdated, if you want to see the updated version of this video, you can watch it here! - • The Sonic and Sega All...
Once again I'm going back to my favourite racing game of all time except today I'm also taking a look at it's two sequels and pitching all three of them in head to head matches in several categories to find out which game is truly the best of the best.
Huge thanks to Cocoafizz for the new Avatar drawing!! / cocoafizz
#SonicandSegaAllStarsRacing #SEGA #Skythe_LOC
SOCIAL MEDIA:
Twitter: Sk...
Discord: / discord

[@AstralKat]

Hi all, this video is outdated, if you want to see the updated version of this video, you can watch it here! - kzbin.info/www/bejne/lZSXn2l4ebl5atE

[@NicolasAndrade-zn1wo]

Transformed.

[@06Deluxe16]

The 1st game

[@DIEFORME173]

@@06Deluxe16 yeah

[@DIEFORME173]

@@06Deluxe16 even though I never got to play it I wanted to play when I was a child for the longest time but never got the chance to play it

[@watto6491]

Team sonic racing

[@WarrenDicey]

First one is best In my Opinion

[@louisemcmahan6858]

Yes I agree to and it isn’t cause I don’t like sonic cause I did grew up playing the first 1 and the 2 but I just love the other sega characters such as beat bonanza bros bd joe billy Hatcher the first is just a really great game the other 2 is still great games but I have a soft spot for the first

[@hitwid]

Yes

[@keithnotofficial7674]

Agreed

[@Maccakit]

Ikr

[@G.o.d_k.i]

Fax

[@watto6491]

FINALLY A PERSON WHO THINK THAT sonic and sega Allstars racing is the best out of the trilogy! Thanks mate also I love the original sonic and sega but I'm more into to team sonic racing but the original sonic and sega has the best version of wave ocean in my opinion

[@YBNKASHWAYS]

People don't I thought it was obvious it was ? xD.

[@gabrielhernandez9321]

Sonic All Stars Racing Transformed.

[@idaholana]

I love the OG due to the fact that it’s pretty much the funniest you can get of a racing game

[@arcadeavalanche]

The way I feel about Wreck it Ralph's inclusion is since his film was set in an arcade with loads of video game characters, it only makes too much sense he's in(especially with the PC exclusive characters), he's essentially racing with all his other video game chums! :D That said, it did feel like a missed opportunity and also ironic not having Vanellope part of the roster, yet Ralph is...

[@PizzaMonster-i9w]

And also because of Sonic's apparition.

[@yxngjosehxvi7117]

i remember my older brother buying me "sonic & sega all stars racing with banjo-kazooie" for my birthday when i was like 8 or 9. brooooooo the memories...

[@jayceyaboi]

FR

[@justsomesimplenuclearbirbs4313]

Both All-Stars Racing and Transformed just have so much charm. Both of the openings showcase some the roster and mechanics of the game. Also, fun fact about the All-Stars Racing. The game never saw a Japanese release so the opening theme for game was added to the soundtrack of Transformed as a bonus track for those who never got to play the game. Which is odd considering Zobio and Zobiko's game never got released outside of Japan even though the game itself does have an English language version on the BIOS of the Rom that is selectable and they're the only characters to be from a game that never got released internationally. But SEGA and the devs of All-Stars Racing wanted a rep from House of the Dead and the two were the only ones that could fit in without raising the game's Age Rating and because Loving Deads: The House of the Dead EX was still being developed alongside All-Stars Racing Zobiko's ENG VA wasn't able to record lines for the game or having any available lines in English which resulted in Zobiko being silent throughout all of the races she's in. Although because of the limitations of the DS it actually makes sense for Zobiko to not speak because she's not there to begin with! Another fact about both games, although depending on how you look at it it may not be so fun, is because the House of the Dead series is banned in Germany the series is often called "Curien Mansion" or even abbreviated as "HOTD" which is why all of the SEGA crossover games while have the name of the mansion itself rather than the name of the series regardless of the region. Anywho, enough trivia about one series, let's start talking about trivia the games themselves. The OST for All-Stars Racing is mostly tracks taken from the original sources, even the All Star Move themes and race intros are taken from their original sources. The only original tracks in All-Stars Racing are the menu themes, result theme and jingles that play after completing missions and earning SEGA Miles. And while there's nothing wrong with the remixes/rearrangements in Transformed and TSR, I do kinda prefer some of the original tracks from the source game rather than the remixes. The stages in TSR are directly ripped from All-Stars Racing (minus Ocean Ruin and Egg Hangar) but with various improvements with Ocean View also being ripped directly from Transformed but without the boat segment almost like you're doing a permanent Time Trial and the Big the Cat cameo due to Big himself being playable once again in TSR. The voice clips in both All-Stars Racing and Transformed are either reused or re-recorded from previous games depending on the character. Some characters were also given new lines due to them either not having a speaking role originally or due to their voices not matching the current voice cast. One example is Big the Cat. Unlike what happened with Sonic Riders where they used clips of Dean Bristow from SA2 instead of having Mike Pollock record new lines for gameplay, they had Big's Voice actor at the time, Oliver Wyman, record new lines for All-Stars Racing and it's pretty noticeable with some lines.

[@valemontgomery9401]

In terms of the car designs, I love how wacky the vehicles are in ASR compared to the others. Seeing Shadow in his chopper racing Eggman in a monster truck is just so novel compared to the more unified designs in the sequels

[@akechi3764]

Loved that bit with Wheatley and I could see him being the VA for the FM lol. great vid

[@thelegendarymario5642]

Never liked how they changed sonics all star move to floating stars from super sonic

[@rubyzkarlet]

"Reclassifying Silver as a doofus" lmao I swear that the Omega quotes on TSR are the funniest of them all XD

[@BATTIE07SHANE]

personally transformed is my favorite because I mainly had the pleasure of playing the ds ver. of the original. But I can write an entire essay on a tier list of these three games. But my least favorite is Team Sonic Racing. Only three characters I like in it, Metal Sonic, Zavok, and Vector. While with the others, there are a lot more creative characters.

[@jackyp2711]

The original is the most memorable. As you said the characters, the commentator, the tracks and music are amazing. I haven't played the original in years but I can't wait to re-live childhood. Transformed is somewhat memorable too but wasn't as fun as I'd hoped. I really didn't enjoy team. I liked the car customization and some characters included but that's all. It's been years since I've played Transformed and the Original but Team Racing felt like a lot slower, a main reason why I loved the OG and Transformed, because they were faster driving than Mario Kart. Are they slower or is it that I'm just older and don't remember

[@AestheticNerdLive]

Felt slower to me to man the original just to good I played on the wii

[@justinc.5591]

I understand that the original game has the best all-Star moves and character roster, but to me track design is the most important part of a racing game and Transformed dominates in that category. Each of the tracks are unique and brilliantly designed which is why Transformed is my favorite.

[@Hyper_Kong]

I hope you talk about Sega SuperStars Tennis soon. My first game in the franchise I played which introduced me to the series.

[@AstralKat]

I certainly plan to!

[@Lethargy514]

I can't help but question how you handled round 3. It looks like you judged the items by how much sense they made in terms of logic and lore rather than critiquing them in regards to balancing and their effects on the race. While I also agree with your placement of Team Sonic Racing being 1st place in items, my reasons are different. Team Sonic Racing may not have strong tracks like the other two, but their itemplay is a lot more dynamic with how your teammates can help mitigate or enhance the effects of items. A quake can easily be dispatched with a few well-placed missiles or a team ultimate, a missile can be blocked by a speed type drift boosting, and if you get hit by an item in general, a teammate can help skimboost you to make sure you're not down for too long. Team Sonic Racing is a lot more combative than the others, and their items as well as the team mechanics that are made to facilitate and even accelerate the interaction with items are responsible for that. I don't get why you critiqued items based on what "made sense" rather than focusing on how they affect the gameplay and its balancing. Do I really need to care about the pufferfish breaking the laws of physics by floating in the air in a universe of anthropomorphic animals? I care more about if the item will hinder how well I enjoy the game, and the answer is that it does not. The pufferfish can be thrown ahead and behind you and can be countered with skill by either dodging it, catching it, or shooting it. It's main strength is hindering the movement options of the opposition by taking up space while its weakness is it mediocrity as a projectile if you shoot it forward. It is balanced like all the items in Transformed. The only reason why I would give the original 2nd place over Transformed is that the All-Stars for the original are significantly better and more original than Transformed, where most of the characters just float and press one button to throw something at someone in Transformed. Now as for round 4, I disagree with how you treated Team Sonic Racing. You spoke anecdotally and said that you cannot remember the track themes and that they are bad. That is not enough in my opinion. Team Sonic Racing uses a shit ton of remixes and unique leitmotifs in their songs that you don't give them credit for. For instance, the stage you were racing on not only uses a remix of Cool Edge from Sonic Unleashed, but has the melody of Reach for the Stars tucked away around the end before it loops. Furthermore, all the tracks are adaptive, having portions that play when you're on the final lap and a unique jingle for when the race finishes. The songs are practically a love letter to their origins that you did not acknowledge and bash on the sole merit of "I can't remember it". You didn't even mention anything about how all the characters have unique remixes of their main theme when they use their ultimate. I would actually put the original at the bottom since it doesn't do anything new with its music. Tldr; I agree with your placement for round 3, but not with your rationale for the placement. And I disagree with your placement and rationale of Team Sonic Racing in round 4. I like the work you put into this though.

[@karuzzi6934]

Well said, I was thinking the same thing while watching the video.

[@IshmaelSimpson]

Well written and I agree completely. I thought the exact same thing.

[@YaBoyZyon]

Bro idc wat yal say og sonic racing will always be my favorite with transformed being my second

[@SrHiroo]

so true

[@DIEFORME173]

Indeed

[@evelynnleague2232]

Same, sonic team racing is trash i literally cried when they dindt had an all star💀😭

[@DIEFORME173]

@@evelynnleague2232 me too 😭

[@n19ntendods]

Wow! Well done, mate! This video is so detailed and intricately explained! Even if my opinions are slightly different to Transformed, I still respect yours and think you’re awesome! The first video I saw from you was your Sonic & Sega All-Stars Racing All-Star Moves ranking video and that was awesome, too! 😎🤩👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏

[@argh2571]

This is a great video, personally I think the first game is the best but I like transformed too

[@theblackjfshow]

I enjoyed all 3 of the Sonic Racing games, but imagine if we get a 4th Sonic Racing game that takes the best elements of the first 3 games and expand on them. It would make one heck of a game!

[@th33g3n6]

If so i hope they get all the characters from the past 3 games

[@RicardoZapata-iw3kl]

@@th33g3n6 And i hope a final boss race. I propose Sweet Tooth from "Twisted Metal"

[@WIGGYMEISTER76]

My 7 year old son prefers the original because it’s all land based. He struggles to control the planes in the Transformed version…I enjoy transformed but also love the original. I plan to introduce the Nintendo giant Mario Kart to him a little further down the road, it’s inevitable, everyone has to play that game! But Segas racing games are great too, not sure if it’s as good as Mario Kart, but it’s not far behind at all.

[@Spezialagent_Oso_Fan_2009]

The reason why Ralph is in Transformed, It’s because the Game was released in 2012, the same years as the first Wreck it Ralph came out in Theaters, and Sonic apeared in the Movie.

[@AstralKat]

I've mentioned this before, my issue with Ralph being there is not due to the tie in, it's due to the fact that Wreck it Ralph the movie has a secondary protagonist who is an actual racer, Ralph being the rep makes no sense despite him being the main character, Vanelope should have been the rep, even if it was like Zobio and Zobiko from the original where its the two of them in a car and Vanelope is driving

[@Cody-5501]

WHERE DID YOU LEARN TO DRIVE A BARN?

[@sgamer1770]

transformed is pretty fun so far. thanks for your review

[@agusauv6842]

I only tried team racing (ps4) and all stars racing (xbox360), I definitely agree that all stars racing is the best of the trilogy because the characters are unique, the cars are so creative like ulala on a "spaceship" and big on a tiny motorcycle. the tracks range on different categories (my faves were the casino/samba de amigo) and even with those categories the tracks are different from each other. I didn't play the different modes that frequently but I loved the grand prix and the different cups, I think that asr is the most complete one in the trilogy, maybe because I played it since I was a kid!

[@destroyermcw626]

First one still has the most tracks being 25 and the 3 battle maps

[@jdawson7877]

" i do think humans should stay away from the sonic universe" so you don't want eggman in the sonic universe

[@TearingUser935]

The first one because of the vast game franchise varieties, better all-stars than Transformed, the announcer, and my childhood

[@Luxembourgz6101]

Original > Transformed > Team

[@CiderVG]

I mean Transformed is clearly the best -the plane sections were awesome, the boat with it's slippery controls are what held it back-

[@AstralKat]

I'm glad you enjoy the plane and boat sections, I wasnt a huge fan of them lol

[@defmul]

I grew up with the original on my ps3 at 5 years old getting good at the game and I still play it.

[@06Deluxe16]

1st Sonic & Sega All Stars Racing 2nd Team Sonic Racing 3rd Sonic & Sega All Stars Racing Transformed (This is my opinion by the way)

[@mesacboy7939]

Finally! Someone else who agrees the original is better than Transformed. I played both for the first time recently, and the first game is now my favorite racing game of all time. Transformed on the other hand was a huge disappointment after the first game, and there's sooo many reasons I could go into about why I personally think it's inferior (though it's of course completely subjective). I think my main issue with Transformed is how long the tracks are, they're a complete slog. Some of them take up to 6 minutes, and they generally just feel tedious to play through, overstaying their welcome. For reference, the average Mario Kart track is 2-3 minutes long. ONE lap of Transformed is almost as long as an entire track in MK. Some people might like this, but for me they just drag on a little too long. Made it hard for me to get motivated and grind in the World Tour mode to unlock characters. I agree with every other point you make in this video too; the character roster, music, items, commentator, etc. are all far superior and give the game so much more charm and liveliness. I also generally just prefer how the original plays and controls, it's so much more fun for me to drift through the courses without them being interrupted and bogged down by mediocre water/flying sections. Transformed definitely has an edge over the original in some areas, but overall I was left extremely let down by it, and was really surprised to hear that a lot of people think it blows ASR1 out of the water. Great vid!

[@segaspice4062]

Transformed was the best one but it's missing Billy Hatcher so... :(

[@tekloerlandson9010]

Personally i prefer the way the menus work in the original, but ive never even heard of Teams before the track-ranking videos. Plus, there were so many tracks in the original that i loved so much, not to mention the music.

[@Vantoxify]

Nice video man

[@AstralKat]

I Appreciate it

[@thegoldengamer1021]

"Reclassifing Silver as a doofus", DAMN YOU DID NOT NEED TO DO HIM LIKE THAT

[@iamthejesuschristofchristm259]

Such a really clever and funny video, I love it!

[@Iamjustakid01]

I actually love sonic and all-stars racing transformed.

[@kingofthekoopaz5217]

Transformed is fine, but the original is so much better, like it isnt even a contest. I never played team so I cant say either way.

[@jasonblack2477]

Team is the weakest one. I bought it played like 4 hours with my friend didnt play it much alone. With a friend its fine

[@cinnamondan4984]

I fall asleep playing Sonic Racing while Sega All Star games keep me on the edge of my seat

[@originalentertainers]

I have such a story with sonic and all stars racing transformed, for me is BY FAR the best in almost everything.

[@galaxyt.hedgehog8667]

F's in the chat for metal sonic constantly being called a disappointment

[@aqee1]

1st SASRT 2nd SASASR 3rd TSR I know i’m going to get hate for stating my opinion but Transformed’s ost is my favourite and I really enjoyed the transformed gimmick surprisingly as the level design accompanied for this. I think if I tried SASASR on the PS3 my opinion would change as I only tried the DS version which was good for the DS but wasn’t as fun as how the console version looks. One day when I try the PS3 version of SASASR I will come back to this comment and see if my opinion has changed lol

[@terrio2726]

This is exactly my order

[@jamespearce1420]

@@terrio2726 that’s my exact order too!

[@tryhardquesadila]

Thank u so much for mentioning that you had Sonic and Sega all stars racing on pc.. I thought it was only on console and sense I sold my ps3 a long time ago I thought there was no way for me to play it... turns out I had enough money in my steam wallet to buy the game. I to share your same love for sonic and sega all stars racing and its downloading rn. Cant wait to play it again

[@kirbygamer0640]

One thing I didn’t like about Transformed- and even Team Sonic Racing- is that…they lost personality. In the first game, Shadow has his iconic bike, but he has a more…tank like car in Transformed. And another thing that loses personality are the all stars. They were a lot more tailored to the characters using them in the original compared to the other two. And of course, the announcer was best in the original. Also….the original had an amazing intro cutscene, and to me it actually aged kind of well. Though the lack of personality kind of hurts it still.

[@escucharbog2118]

I like the character choices of the first but i hate the choices of transformed. Why did they cut out characters like billy hatcher and opa opa only to replace them with wreck it ralph and fucking danica patrick

[@TopHatOnline]

I recently bought the first Sonic SEGA Racing game yesterday just to relive my childhood days and not spend an eternity with its 2 sequels. I really like how you analyzed all of these games; I think the first Sonic SEGA Racing is the superior than the next 2 sequels because everything about it such as the mechanics and characters are all balanced, compared to Transformed with questionable roster, its slow acceleration and hard as fuck vehicle swapping gimmick, and TSR with its disappointing roster. The All-Stars in the OG game makes a total lot of sense and gives them originality as to what these SEGA characters can do in their respective universe/game than just the Sonic characters. Forcing them on a superpowered plane or a super boost is a big letdown, though I think the super boost in TSR is much better than Transformed. My 360 copy for the OG Sonic SEGA Racing will be arriving this Saturday. They should definitely rerelease this game as backwards compatibility because at least the game looks like it's up to date with other 8th generation games like MK8 and Crash Team Racing.

[@elclaud]

I play all these 3 games a lot and at some point I even start to speedrunning ASR and ASRT. The og ASR is my favorite for his mechanics, the vibes of all Sega chars that I love and how fast The game is. My main problem is that not all character can do all shorcuts for example at The start of Dark Arsenal at The left you have a ramp that Only less than half of the roster characters can do without a speedshoe. I also love Transformed cuz how different is for other Karting games and I feel like The plain dosnt have the best controll but its not bad and you can go fast when your drifting and changing directions playing with both sticks is a bit tricky but is so weird and fun that I cant describe. My Only problem with Transformed is the roster and some old tracks like Sunshine Tour feels so slow but overall The game is great and The music is by far my favorite of the trilogy. And lastly Team Sonic Racing... I hate this game. The Team mechanic is weird and stupid in my opinion, The tracks are really flat and dosnt give anything new. The Kart custommisation is fine and my biggest problem with this game os that its feel so slow when your not in that weird Team special boost or constantly having a ton of boost panels in your way.

[@Swift_Vortex]

Racing transformed is my favourite its the first one I played in 2013 when I was 4 on my dads phone the nostalgia

[@STYLIX_]

Hey can you review Cars 2 the video game? You seem to love racing games and cars 2 is actually really good. Nostalgia classic for me that still holds up.

[@AstralKat]

I dont usually talk about licensed games, My channel is more focused on Nintendo/Sega content with the occasional indie game rant sprinkled in, I might make a video based around tie in games in the future if people are interested enough though

[@tiga2001]

I only got Transformed because Vyse and Ulala is in it, I'm a product of my time :D

[@GamingCreed47]

FINALLY, someone who shares the same love for SaSASR! I played this game on the DS, Wii, and have it now on my Xbox 360 which probably says a lot about my love for it. I'll always be a B.D. Joe main though.

[@weegeedollgaming]

I Remember Playing The Original On My XBOX360 For Hours Because I Never Had A Nintendo To Play Mario Kart On. Eventually, My Little Brother Broke My XBOX Disk and I Was Stuck Playing A Demo Of Sonic & All Stars Racing Transformed Which I Hate The Flight Controls. But Now That I Have The Nintendo Switch, I Am Happy (A Little Bit) To Play Team Sonic Racing And Mario Kart 8 Deluxe.

[@teeyel_leyeet]

I had sonic and Sega All-stars racingon my Wii console. The family edition to be exact

[@josegamer947]

Tails in team sonic racing be saying " who's your daddy shadow" lol that gotta be first

[@orenz.272]

*"Who's your daddy, Shadow ?"* - Tails

[@innactiveaccount6185]

Mans really chose chuchus for sandy drifts 😭

[@lightninja4795]

Why was there a section for the all star moves that should have been under the items section because it is a item.

[@jayceyaboi]

1st one the best

[@lightninja4795]

Your items section was so bad. Instead of looking at what the items did you looked at if they made sense. While transforms items mostly dont have to do with sonic at least they tried to separate the items from mario kart unlike the first game. Man could have sworn the traffic cone was a banana or the green glove was a green shell but maybe im wrong. Gameplay is more important then sound or looks.

[@SnaksiXD]

Fun fact: The Garbage Puyo was suppossed to make an appearance instead of the Pufferfish item in S&ASRT, but SEGA hates it whenever anything Puyo Puyo leaves Japan so it was not meant to be.

[@a_real_human_being7979]

oh cool another sonic and sega video!

[@echomurata8654]

I agree with almost every opinion here except for 1 Music i think TSR has better music than transformed. because TSR originals songs makes feel more energetic and face paced and it really gives of the racing vibes . And those TSR remixes are the bomb cuz each of those remixes had more personality than the og imo(especially roulette road remix) transformed remix felt the same cuz of those synths and waves being over used imo. but the og get 1st place TSR gets 2nd and Transformed 3rd

[@aaronmcewan774]

You have to realise the time that sasrt came out the trend was dubstep

[@MeMyselfI__]

I’ve played Transformed Recently and I’ve had a Blast. But I still think that Sega All Stars is still the Best. But Transformed isn’t that far behind. I do agree on the 3rd Party Characters. They all felt out of place

[@andyr5579]

Third party characters were all about marketing. Widen the appeal. It’s a bit cynical but hey, no micro transactions!

[@MeMyselfI__]

@@andyr5579 I can kinda Excuse Wreck it Ralph because Sonic was in the Movies and Stuff and the Movie released around the same time as the Game. But cmon Danica Patrick??? Was all hell really gonna break loose if Ms. Patrick wasn’t included?

[@craigthehedgehog848]

My honest opinion: The original is amazing And the other two games I do not like at all

[@juniorchandler4669]

Yeah the first one is the best honestly speaking, it’s the only game that goes against Mario Kart Ds and Mario kart Wii

[@castleofrandom7975]

Sonic and all stars racing transformed is my favorite

[@davanime877]

their allstar moves are the Final Smashes of racing games, which I love it

[@Tech-187]

I have all of the games and I prefer the first one indeed over the other 2 but unlike you I prefer Transformed over TSR. I swear I used to spend a lot of time in the Time Attack mode in transformed and the original is just good I wish you included the bosses in the mission mode though for the original

[@thezapperyt]

Damn I thought this game was really obscure! Glad to see it talked about!

[@monique6490]

Team Sonic Racing is the best game Sonic & All-Stars Racing Transformed is the best Fun-Racing game Sonic & SEGA All-Stars Racing is the most nostalgic game.

[@kokichikuncookie4764]

jackie and gira was one of my most used character, kept going last just to see the super speed of their move(sonic all star racing). then was opa opa and bananza bros.

[@R_K_S2401]

Opa-Opa stans rise up.

[@diegovarela4690]

Top 10 Karts videogames: 1. Mario Kart 8 Deluxe (2017) 2. Crash Team Racing Nitro Fueled (2019) 3. Team Sonic Racing (2019) 4. Diddy Kong Racing (1997) 5. Crash Team Racing (1999) 6. Mario Kart: Double Dash (2003) 7. Mario Kart DS (2005) 8. Sonic & All-Stars Racing Transformed (2012) 9. Crash Nitro Kart (2003) 10. Sonic & Sega All-Stars Racing (2010)

[@plasmapj1183]

Sonic and All-stars Racing Transformed Sonic and SEGA All-stars Racing Team Sonic Racing This is my list.👌🏾

[@optimuscrime1023]

First is the best, second isn’t far behind, third one is fucking terrible since it’s only sonic

[@ロスオライリー]

the original isn't bad or anything, but to say Transformed isn't the best in the series in every way (other than items perhaps) is madness.

[@AakaNacho]

I remember as a kid playing the original on mobile and loving it a ton. I’m sad to see it be removed from the App Store now ;-;

[@nebulavonmad7967]

13:00 WHAT DID TAILS SAY?!?!?! 🫢😱

[@NicolasAndrade-zn1wo]

While i don't necessarily agree, you did make some great points. On the topic of ASR, i'd like to see you make a concept for another Sonic Racing Game by Sumo, whether it'd be All-Stars 3 or TSR2.

[@alexmendez3681]

All Stars Racing is the best. It had the most characters. Please bring this to the Nintendo Switch with 60fps

[@viktoryc]

My favorite I think is transformed because of how much I played it. I never really played the original, so obviously I'd chose transformed because if the sheer quantity of playtime

[@samiahl5957]

Just wish sonic all star racing was available on newer console now and days

[@alfredc.7777]

First one will always mean everything to me

[@cameronroberts6517]

Man i just love how he complains about the items not making sense but ignores their function. Man I really love how transformed separated its items from Mario kart unlike the original. Man i could have swore the traffic cone was a banana but I must be missing something. Transformed is literally better than the original in every way besides all star moves and the announcer for the all star moves. Everything else he says was bad about that game is either subjective or wrong.

[@z_kokiiitoos]

I think they should make a sequel from Team Sonic Racing, which includes Sega racers in teams of three, so that would be aweaome

[@lordrambo7898]

From my experience I gotta go with ASRT on this. Love all the fast paced action from the time I played it. Team sonic racing is meh. I love the emphasis on needing to work as a team but the racing feels like I’m playing on 100 & sometimes 50cc on Mario kart and the times are ok I guess But I haven’t gotten to play the first one of the trilogy. Only a demo

[@imbad6730]

If we ignore nostalgia: 1. Team 2. Original 3. Transformed But... 1. Original 2. Team 3. Transformed Only bc I feel Team toom too much from mariokart

[@cinnamondan4984]

Not Sonic Racing is the answer always. Love the first two. Wish Sega did not force the third one to be exclusively Sonic themed

[@mariopokemon955]

maybe i need to give team sonic racing's story mode a chance, because i ADORE the mission mode in sonic and sega all stars racing

[@johnotaro6660]

Sonic transformed is my personal favorite

[@soosmanxd4844]

You should try the German commentator on transfromed. He is way more energetic

[@AstralKat]

Well i dont speak German lol

[@ovatails]

Sonic all stars racing is the best. The all stars are actually unique, and its the best out of transformed are just the same thing with different themes, and team sonic, EHHHH-

[@cubbbgd402]

Thumbnail to Shadow be like: *It all starts with this...*

[@stefanolopez1478]

Can you believe the first game is not on series x

[@finnyorfinz1323]

First one was the best 😎 last one is the worst

[@lightninja4795]

Yea 3 characters in transformed definitely ruin the entire rooster if they even do ruin it lol. Man guess those other 15+ characters don't matter then huh. If he was looking at this objectively then some categories like characters transformed wins. 4 releastic characters out of 15+ and if it does ruin the rooster then man anything little ruins the game for you. More characters then the original or team sonic racing. Anyway great video dude keep it up. Dont this comment come off as rude im just pointing out the problems i see in your rankings despite you saying you pit aside you biases

[@ohjoshua67]

Sonic Racing Transformed hands down

[@SpyYoshi]

I like the first

[@kennyMcCormick602]

Same best racing game ive ever played i used to play it more than mario kart ds and now im playing the pc version

[@mysticdigital5936]

I love the original game. Transformed was alright, it had its charms but definitely not as fun as the original. I didnt bother with Team and I'm glad I didn't. Honestly I kind of hate the interactions you showed betweent the characters. The voice acting is REALLY bad and the writing isn't much better. Omega saying "doofus" is not clever at all.