Outlander | Jamie Argues With Claire About His Secret Marriage

[@sulleys1929]

Why are these two not winning all the awards! Their acting is perfection!

[@virgoqueen8950]

THEY HAVE WON AWARDS IN THE UK

[@lindatimmons3675]

@@virgoqueen8950 .... have they won awards here in US?

[@virgoqueen8950]

@@lindatimmons3675 NO AND THAT IS BECAUSE STARZ DOES NOT GET INVOLVED WITH THE AWARD SHOWS

[@thegratefulliving6073]

@@virgoqueen8950 Really, is that the reason? They deserve all kinds of awards from US.

[@themarketingbrat6468]

I agree and refuse to watch The Emmys...political BS, snubbing Outlander and Sam and Cait🤬🤬🤬 The horrific rape scenes they filmed together were Academy Award worthy (if this were a movie).

[@bronwyn117]

I will never understand how actors can get into character, remember their lines, and deliver them so passionately…..all while there are cameras and people almost on top of them. And this scene……simply amazing. So beautifully done.

[@luwamalem9537]

Ikr?! I always wonder that too! I guess a LOT of practice to the point where they don't even see the cameras and actually embody the chacters when they have to play them! 🤷🏽‍♀️

[@Ms4everSweet]

I always wonder how actors can kiss somone without feel anything. No wonder some actors fall in love afterwards. 🤔

[@trev021889]

Well said...they are unreal and this and so many other scenes between the two are outstanding!!!

[@deirdrepasko9965]

@@Ms4everSweet I know!

[@irenejillson4276]

For what does Claire tell Jamie to “thank “leaougrie?

[@bluefamily3937]

"I told you to thank her, not marry her!"...that knife was delivered beautifully on a silver platter.. This is was most fantastic scene ever... Every line.. delivered with ... absolute perfection

[@doychinkutsarov9866]

I was once in Scotland and saw a man with red hair, I went to him and asked him - Are you from the Frazer clan ? He was like "Not again"

[@Blue-rl5dp]

The red hair is from dark haired Celtic natives mixing with blond haired Norsemen (Viking raiders). Anywhere along the coastlines of all the countries around there you find redheads because of the Vikings. The ancestral Frasers weren't coastal so it would be more rare among them. Of course after the rebellion they all got mixed around and moved around so no simple clan tracing means anything anymore.

[@natashan8656]

🤣🤣🤣

[@lindatimmons3675]

A lot of Scottish are red haired.

[@Blue-rl5dp]

@@lindatimmons3675 Same with the Irish. Vikings came to their shores a lot for several centuries.

[@karimesalem8686]

🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣 thanks! Jaja

[@kathyb7425]

I think that was a very powerful scene. Such passion and range of emotions. Both actors portrayed the emotions with raw talent.

[@juneD6994]

Loved Jaimie, so infused, he stumbles over his lines after smashing that object. Think he felt like smashing her, "I could kill you for...!"

[@kasienkakaminska6915]

Very powerful scene!😍

[@luwamalem9537]

Too good! One of my fave scenes at the of them! 🙌🏽 Just pure emotion!

[@prvtgraham5]

@@kasienkakaminska6915 Hello there are you one of my lovely fan's out there?

[@Sassenachwhiskey]

You must be a true Sam Heughan’s fan Ms I guess you can’t wait for LOVE AGAIN to really hit our screens this coming May 😊

[@_LexiMae]

I think a lot of people are taking this scene the wrong way. She isn't really mad at him per se, just disappointed in his choice of wife and horrified that he might have slept with Laoghaire and had kids with the woman who tried to kill her. He isn't really mad at her for going back to Frank. He ordered her to do it as she points out in this video. She didn't react this way when she found out he had a kid with a random woman. They're both really mad about time and how they had no control over it. They both did what they needed to do to survive and this is them airing out the last 20 years of the pain of not being together and all the things that they lost in those 20 years. They know it's not rational to blame the other, but this scene gives them a chance to work through the unfairness of it all. I also think it's funny how he points out there are other men with red hair, but Claire is so in love with him that she only sees him. It never occurred to her they could be some other man's children because Jamie is the only redheaded man that exists in her mind 😂🤣

[@denisebrown-johnson2073]

I agree☝️! I have enjoyed viewing all the scenes from season 1-5 of Outlander. I must say this scene was very powerful as well.

[@calisweetheart333]

I share your point of view. Though I will say, Claire had it way more easy than poor Jamie, in those 20 years. Of all the possible women to marry, he marries Laoghaire, that was a stab in the heart. Even I felt betrayed…lol🤦‍♀️

[@nicoleschuerman2559]

I do agree. Let alone what Jamie doesn't think about is that she spent 20 years attributing a little redheaded girl (Bri) with him so when Claire sees a little redheaded girl call him daddy it makes perfect sense.

[@MdmLuna]

Yesss, when she says Its LAOGHAIRE! What a betrayal 💔

[@sheezaejaz7086]

Yessss perfectly said!

[@indirajack142]

I just discovered this series. He is an uncommonly attractive man, I must say.

[@ryanwatt6706]

Oh yes he is~

[@sharonmcmurrick3853]

Jamie is a unique specimen. If you ever get the chance, read the books.

[@rhondathompson6942]

@@sharonmcmurrick3853 yes read the books jamie is wild man

[@Blue-rl5dp]

@@rhondathompson6942 Barbarian with very pretty manners. They even liked him in Paris! Like an exotic tiger.

[@klimtkahlo]

I just found this is 2021 and I have to watch it every day. Addictive! I can’t stop and get bored by any other movie.

[@rassie16]

My heart broke when he said "you left me"...We know that was not the case and that he doesn't mean it like that, but he's been hurting for the past 20 years and he basically married out of pity and he's still overwhelmed with Claire being back... There's so much frustration it just had to come out...This was a fantastic scene, so well acted!

[@carolenelson6763]

Yes, I loved this scene. I just Jenny would have left them alone. That would have been a terrific love scene ❤️

[@Xaforn]

In the book it wasn’t out of pity, he was just so lonely and empty, he said himself he wanted to die.

[@lindatimmons3675]

@@Xaforn yes he did.

[@withintheshyness]

Also Claire's a hypocrite, she was with her first husband for 20 years after leaving Jamie!

[@brittaneysmith1946]

well in the book at the end of book two she ran to the stones while he was in a "house" trying to take down or evade a redcoat she was chased by a few redcoats before jumping through so in the books unlike the show she did leave him

[@Blcastillo74]

Jaime-“……..even though you left me..” Claire- 🚨TRIGGERED🚨 prepare for war

[@sandrasiqueira3277]

😂😂😂😂 He asked for

[@samledoux7837]

Right! That was all him then he's gonna blame her lol she is wierd though for not looking him up the instant she got back. Then if he was dead, go back to frank. It took that other guy like two days to find Jamie lol

[@kennemedia01]

Her whole face changed after he said that

[@Blcastillo74]

@@kennemedia01 my face changed when he said that 😂

[@mistyfreya]

“So you have chosen death.” Rightfully so! He made her go back through the stones!

[@deannadiehl5160]

Well, there are other men with red hair in Scotland, Claire. Lol.

[@juneD6994]

Reasoning with one, not to be reasoned with. Had tried about 5 times since her return. Look back and see.

[@annraynor846]

It’s rrrrrred headed but lol

[@virgoqueen8950]

BUT I FELT HER EMOTIONS WHEN SHE SAID THAT ................ I LOVE CAITRIONA, I DON'T THINK ANYWAY ELSE COULD HAVE PLAYED CLAIRE

[@lindatimmons3675]

Exactly. I was hoping he would slap some sense into her.

[@jeffsanchez2086]

@@juneD6994 He married someone he knew tried to have her burnt alive so she could dance on her ashes. And she needed sense slapped into her? Do women really accept literally anything for a man? This comment is this misogynistic fandom in a nutshell. Claire should have married BJR since you know, it’s all good. 👍

[@mariaelenavazquez9297]

It’s difficult to find a fictional couple as good as this one.

[@samscott7519]

So true! I can’t find one better than them! They are amazing actors that did an outstanding job bringing Jamie and Claire to life!

[@sherryallen6213]

Difficult? IMPOSSIBLE!! I've read about many couples in my almost 75 years and there isn't a single one that comes close!!

[@mariaelenavazquez9297]

@@sherryallen6213 Completely true.

[@Blue-rl5dp]

True, Diana has a knack for writing desperately addicted love. Going to have to compare to see what it is she does that others don't. I do seem to remember an older novel though, "Shana" by Kathleen Woodweis, that I was enthralled with about 40 yrs ago. (He was condemned to hang, She needed a husband in name only, so she married him "at the gallows steps" as the saying went, trusting he'd be dead and off her hands in a day or two. But, those wily fates stepped in.) It might be hard to find, being so old, bit as I remember it was very worth reading.

[@patriciasales9029]

I couln t find any...they are great couple..excellent chemistry..great actors.❤❤❤❤

[@NWCountryGirl17]

"She did try to kill me," "She WHAT????" "Oh did I never actually tell you that part?" "Ye dinna think I'd have marrit her if I knew she was behind you being arrested for a witch?" --Jamie in The Fiery Cross NOT KNOWING was the only way Jamie would've married that blonde harpy

[@sherryallen6213]

I agree... but with the addition in the show of the two daughters who needed a Da so much, Jamie was lost in the thought of being part of a family.

[@NWCountryGirl17]

@@sherryallen6213 the girls are a thing in the book too and they explain the real reasons he married MUCH Better

[@sherryallen6213]

@@NWCountryGirl17 I do agree... the books give much better detail but they do give us as much as possible in the show. I love both... in different ways... but I'm totally gobsmacked at the way the characters are brought to life. Jamie really does love the girls, as if he is really their Da.

[@mokachyna22]

Harpy is a perfect description. Yuck.

[@gpcheng87]

I spat laughed at "blonde harpy"

[@ryanalexander4687]

I wish I never watched Outlander.... so I could watch it for the first time again. Ugh, there has never been such a magnetic chemistry between an onscreen couple like Jamie and Claire. A few come close. But not like this

[@eliseadventure3644]

Uhg same! I'm rewatching the entire thing 😭

[@ryanalexander4687]

@@eliseadventure3644 that’s a great idea🙌

[@assi4237]

I agree that their chemistry is great but i couldn't watch Outlander because amount of violence was disturbing to me.. I really think it's to much..

[@jaybra2429]

@@assi4237 yea it was over the top, but everything else about the show was amazing. Maybe you should skip those scenes that’s what I did.

[@jacquelineking467]

one year yea it's too much! They're trying to be realistic but it's too gross 4 me to watch the violence really..ew..

[@MrsRanchoFiesta]

They screwed up when they made Jamie aware of Laoghaire's involvement in the witch trial. Made Jamie's marrying Laoghaire impossible to believe

[@crystalcarty9908]

Yes in the books he didn't know, and when Claire was thinking about it one day she realized she never told him and Jamie was like do you think I would marry her knowing she tried to have you killed?

[@deannadiehl5160]

I agree with this post. Jamie may have been lonely, but it seems from other scenes his love for Claire would have made him feel guilty of even thinking about Laoghaire. He fell in love with the idea of being a father. He could have been a factor in the girls' lives without trying himself to Laoghaire.

[@sharonstonts]

I agree, but as someone who has never read the books I thought that he knew she was involved, but didn't get how involved she really was. I assumed he was confused about it since Clair told him to thank her that one time.

[@barbieg821]

Also Laoghaire never testified in the book, it was just assumed she set Claire up to be arrested, also Jamie did not tell her about Willie until after they met up with Lord John Grey looking for Ian, Claire originally was told about Willie through Lord John Grey. I love the show but after reading the books they really missed the mark on a lot of things especially Brianna delivering Jemmie, Claire delivered him and Jamie stayed by Brianna's side the whole time, that was a powerful moment in the books.

[@katlynbailey7846]

Yes!! I agree! The acting in this scene is superb by the way.

[@melissabowers6268]

Even when they are angry, they are still madly in love with each other, violently. Even a splash of water doesn't stop them completely!

[@Blue-rl5dp]

I've been married to my DH for 49 years. I've been so angry at him I could just throw him out the window (wouldn't do me any good, we live on the ground floor). Still, I loved him. When he took a little step out with another, still I loved him (that's when I seriously considered an electric cattle prod). When I get mad enough to slap him he does as Jamie does, pins me down and kisses me, hard. See, Diana Gaboldon knew what women want when she wrote Jamie. Take the slap like a man and kiss her.

[@juneD6994]

@@Blue-rl5dp 😄

[@annraynor846]

@@Blue-rl5dp agree, when he’s on top of her and he says I love you, I love only you, you’d be putty in his hands wouldn’t you... really...

[@Blue-rl5dp]

@@annraynor846 Well, I'd still want to bite him, but otherwise putty. That's why they end up with her on top, ripping off his shirt and Jenny comes in and ruins it all by breaking up their make-up sex. There's no abuse going on here. LOL

[@hannahh2977]

@@Blue-rl5dp she only came in because the whole house could hear everything 😂😂

[@tania38513]

"we were on a break"

[@mariacmantovani]

Best comment 👏🏼

[@martamarcosbradley8261]

🤣🤣🤣

[@helolange1132]

Lmaoo

[@clairebtz7980]

😂

[@24sailorvenus]

Ross and rachel could NEVERRR

[@IamLegend256]

Goodness, their chemistry is so amazing.

[@deletedaccount1990]

Claire and Jamie are the embodiment of true love's passion and the vigors and wishes of youth. Everyone wants a relationship like the one they have.

[@laylasami7324]

When she said “do I know, do I know that” I said to myself: she deserves an award for that!

[@rayray108]

Love this scene!! So much passion. Must remember Claire had time to process knowing Jamie was alive. Jamie was surprised and had to deal with it in real time. Life changing.

[@yolandavelazquez6012]

Definitely one of my top 10 scenes. Love the power their love is for each other.

[@samrolandheughan6085]

Hello fan I’m wishing you a happy new year 🎊. Thanks for your comment and support for my movies, your comments and constant love has brought us this far. Keep Listening and supporting, how long have you been a fan of mine ?

[@Sassenachwhiskey]

Hello Ms, How are you doing ? Hope your anticipating to see the new movie of Sam “Love again! Are you a fan of Sam, How long have you been a fan of sam?

[@milaycastillo5723]

Best thing with Jamie is that he knows when to give up the fight for the sake of the couple. He's the best partner ever.

[@mistyfreya]

Because he is written by a woman.

[@milaycastillo5723]

@mistyfreya if only men learned from these male characters!

[@mistyfreya]

@@milaycastillo5723 exactly

[@Amylou690]

Claire is a breath of fresh air, from her upbringing of her uncle the archeologist she is strong, beautiful, has her own mind, not indecisive, and she loved Frank (before she met Jamie) and Jamie without inhibitions...what a gift in life. The passion and anger shown between the two of them says it all...uchh!!!

[@jennifergriffin6962]

I love how passionately they love each other! I want this 😭😭

[@Improbable_Fiction]

Theses two are so freaking good at playing these characters!

[@rebeccamccoy2346]

My favorite is: after seeing you again I would do far worse then lie to keep you. That really says it all for me.

[@vannessa1191]

Agreed. I was starting to think I was the only one that thought that too. For a fleeting moment, his demeanor changed & became dark when he expressed the extent he would go to keep her with him. Great scene!!

[@prvtgraham5]

Hello Rebecca are you one of my lovely supporter's out there?

[@susanireland3714]

Both should’ve won award after award. And been paid handsomely for their 12 episode per season work. When I think of other nominees and winners, I can hardly believe it. Also, costuming, set design, authenticity-- Outlander never disappoints.

[@nadyaperez7110]

Yes! This is by far one of the best shows I have ever had the pleasure of watching, it’s so passionate and painful, but all of those emotions makes it all the more real! This show deserves so much more credit than it’s given, every aspect of its production is magnificent!

[@DSmith-gs4tr]

The fiery passion and intensity between these is enough to set heaven and hell ablaze. I love it and I'm here for all of it

[@lisameyer604]

Better that it was Laoghaire, because if it was a sweet lass who they cared for each other, how could honorable Jamie leave her to go back to Claire?

[@aneshaberry5901]

Didn't think of that!

[@xzmafmm9998]

Bruh easy

[@fluffyunicorn7187]

This was set in the 18th century. Marriage and vows were taken seriously back then. He vowed to be with Claire till death and Claire's not dead. Legally and under church law, she's still his wife and the marriage with his second wife is void

[@felicialovesnkotb]

@@fluffyunicorn7187 In that case his marriage to Claire wouldn't have been legal anyway since she was still married to Frank.

[@bigoof8284]

@@felicialovesnkotb technically her marriage to Jaime happened in the past before frank was even born so I’m guessing that means her marriage to frank is the one that doesn’t count

[@ellietucker5212]

0:35 the best line ever spoken in the entire show. My family and I always quote it to each other randomly 😂

[@launabanauna496]

Yes, great line! And, that is why I'm packing up, selling everything and flying to Scotland to find my very own Jamie.

[@sherryallen6213]

@Felicity Tucker: Okay.... so many great lines in this scene. Which line? Not "you left me"? Just color me curious.

[@ellietucker5212]

@@sherryallen6213 at 0:35 Jamie says, “There are other redheaded men in Scotland Claire.”

[@sherryallen6213]

@@ellietucker5212 Thanks!! "AYE" I also love that line. I love the line where Jamie says, "I love you and only you".

[@lindatimmons3675]

@@launabanauna496 you're one of the lucky ones that can do that. I would love to be able to do that.

[@lizzie354]

How the heck haven’t they won or even been nominated for an Emmy yet?! Seriously it’s a crime against the entertainment industry as a whole that they haven’t...

[@samrolandheughan6085]

Hello fan I’m wishing you a happy new year 🎊. Thanks for your comment and support for my movies, your comments and constant love has brought us this far. Keep Listening and supporting, how long have you been a fan of mine ?

[@ErutaniaRose]

"Well, there are other red-headed men in Scotland, Claire." XD, so true.

[@meganswistak1144]

The worst part about this argument in particular is that they both have valid arguments...

[@locloc7748]

Thank you for being a Fan liking my pages, supporting my dream and career. May God continue to bless you

[@j.a.fligor97]

The best part is.... They are human.

[@pejr1982]

They have such intense passionate chemistry as couple. Wow!!!

[@marlenemorgenstern7288]

The 20 years apart and the unique circumstances that forced that sorrowful separation, are now out in the open. The initial awkwardness and joy of their reunion, the fierce frustration, loss, and uncertainty of whether they can be one again, are all there. Every syllable, every facial expression, the quiver in their voices, their unbridled anger, the desperation in their desire for each other…..It’s all coming home to roost now. They are working their agony, love and jealousy out in this scene and it’s absolutely necessary and beautifully executed! They NEEDED to passionately love one another at that moment, to heal. They were about to do so….. Jenny’s interference broke the spell and hindered the healing process. Damn her!

[@Blue-rl5dp]

My thoughts exactly. Too many people saying this scene is violent but the only victim is a tea table that gets smashed. He's a man of blood raised in a world where violence is commonplace. She knows this and eggs it on, intentionally or not. Proof of his adoration for her is that all he does to her is wrestle her down and force a kiss on her. It all ends up with her on top so she's being as desperate as he. If Jenny had stayed out of it they'd have spent their frustrations in hard-core give all take all physical release and been gentle and all fine tomorrow when they woke among the rubble.

[@mahanayj]

These two can act 😳 And holy chemistry!! 😍

[@JTV-zq8cw]

The way she slaps him and then he kisses her! Gold!

[@TK-eh8cs]

Hello there 👋👋, how are you doing today???

[@samrolandheughan6085]

Hi big fan!!!! Wishing you happy new year 🎆🎊. I’m using this medium to appreciate you in particular as a fan of mine keep supporting me, Love you

[@amyparker9816]

Abusive!

[@joslynhill3529]

Academy award winning performance

[@jessicathompson6403]

Jenny walking in and yelling at them after this is one of my favorite moments in the whole show 🤣🤣

[@heughansam4804]

Hello baby girl,how are you ?thank you for being a great fan of mine ,I really appreciate your love and support shown you are a special fan of mine,what is your name and where are you from ?

[@valrk247]

Their chemistry is amazing.

[@dixiero8687]

This is one of my many favorite scenes! There is so much emotion going on between these two, who obviously deeply love each other. This is some of the best acting I have ever seen, truly! They are both amazing!!

[@prvtgraham5]

Hello There are you one of my lovely supporter's out there?

[@ambercastro2887]

One of the best -- if not the best -- scenes in the series!!! The actors delivered all the emotions we needed to see in this pivitol scene.

[@prvtgraham5]

Hello Amber are you one of my lovely supporter's out there?

[@arizonarangershat3831]

It’s not him getting married again that’s the real issue. The issue is marrying the woman who tried to kill her. I might be able to forgive him taking a wife for the simple fact that he might be supposed to have one, but taking Laoghaire as a wife? That’d be hard to get over.

[@paranoidandroid682]

jamie should've used his big iron on his hip on laoghaire

[@arizonarangershat3831]

@@paranoidandroid682 I agree

[@Blue-rl5dp]

Had it been any other woman. Personally, I wouldn't want my loved one to live his life alone and empty. I'd have wanted him to find someone sweet and caring to keep his demons and ghosts away the way Mary did for one night only while he was living in that cave. But Laoghaire betrayed them both because she didn't do that for him. And Jenny should have stayed out of it. They were working it out, though it seems a bit violent to some. Twenty years of pent up frustration, fear and passion sometimes comes off that way, I guess.

[@awnnieshankweiler3271]

so clearly you haven't found the love of your life yet... everyone thinks that until they find that one special person.. the majority of people never find it...

[@awnnieshankweiler3271]

my bad, I admit I responded too early before I saw there was more,... I agree that if you truly love someone/find your soulmate. that you inevitability want them to be happy even if its heartbreaking that its not with you... I could defend Laoghqarie, but the truth is: she was fake nice to Calire and was OBSESSED with Jamie who she did'nt event know!!!

[@Blue-rl5dp]

@@awnnieshankweiler3271 I HAVE met my soul mate/love of my life. We have been together 49 years. I would have gone to the stake with him. He is my brown haired Jamie. If I had died years ago I most certainly would not have wanted him to go through the misery Jamie did over loosing Clair. I would want him to meet someone who would do their best to keep his ghosts away and have a little love. I would never want him lonely. He is old now (92) and I will, no doubt, bury him before too many more years go by. I'll have no reason to be when he's gone. Perhaps Grace will be good to me and I'll go to join him soon after, but I'm much younger than he so I'll be forced to live in my own little metaphorical 'cave'. I don't know. You caught me on a melancholy day. Tomorrow I'll be more cheerful.

[@awnnieshankweiler3271]

@@Blue-rl5dp You will get through this I swear. My grandma lost the love of here life (my grandpa) because he passes before she did, but she pushed every day because she believes it's what he wants her to do- for her to be happy. And I believe that real love can make things bearable, and just know that you're strong and either one of you can make it because you'll be happy together once again... I truly believe that.

[@awnnieshankweiler3271]

lots of typos, I know, so sorry!

[@mels2702]

Sometimes you just need a man to throw you down and tell you how much he loves you. 🤣🤷🏻‍♀️

[@jeffsanchez2086]

He married the woman he knew tried to have her burnt alive so she could dance on her ashes. That’s not any sort of love 🙄

[@OreadNYC]

That very much depends on precisely what the man in question understands the word 'love" to mean. Every person defines it somewhat differently based on their experiences but not every person's definition of love is hralthy. A hell of a lot of people tend to believe that love is about control when control is actually the polar opposite of love (unless it's part of a BDSM scenario, that is). A woman who is unfortunate enough to have a male partner who defines control as love actually *doesn't* need a man to throw her down on the bed, because that's a man who probably believes deep down (whether he's able to admit it or not) that what he wants is far more important than what she wants...and that is certainly not love as I understand it.

[@jeffsanchez2086]

@@OreadNYC He MARRIED a woman he knew tried to have her burnt alive so he could dance on her ashes. The fact that some are concentrating on his actions around man handling her and how somehow that equates to either sexy or love obviously missed the ENTIRE reason for the fight. Nobody who has ever loved you would do what he did. So his rough handling of her was just that, nothing more 🙄

[@OreadNYC]

@@jeffsanchez2086 In all fairness, at least in the books, Jaime's marriage to Laoghaire was not his choice or even his idea. It was his older sister Jenny's idea and Jamie went along with it. It could be argued that one of Jamie's weak points is that for a man of his time, he appears to be unusually susceptible to the influence of the women in his life (and not just Claire). He had no reason to believe that Claire would ever be able to return to him...and there is every reason to think that Jamie might still desire companionship even though he cannot be with Claire.

[@jeffsanchez2086]

@@OreadNYC Jamie fully admits that he married Leoghaire because he wanted to, not because Jenny forced him. Nobody could force him to do that. He also runs after her jealous that she’s screwing someone else years after Claire’s return. So his feelings for Leoghaire run much deeper than he admits. It’s why he leads her on for decades. It becomes a very one sided love story once Geneva and his other women come into the picture. It never resumes what it was prior to that.

[@Richard_Fouts]

Damn ... the chemistry with these two is immeasurable.

[@veronicadiaz9895]

I don’t know what’s worst, him having a bastard son or marrying the woman who tried to kill Claire

[@introvert211]

I’d say the fact that Leerie (phonetic spelling) trying to kill Claire is worse

[@Blue-rl5dp]

She had to allow him to have a life in that 20 yrs. so the son is fine. Even marrying would be ok if he'd married someone who was kind to him. She didn't want him suffering and lonely all that time. It was Leerie that was the problem.

[@adora721lux8]

I've always hated the term "bastard". It's not a child's fault how he or she was conceived. Giving a child the title "bastard" seems to put the blame and shame on the child. Always hated it in Shakespeare's plays, too, and he often made these people the villains. Genetics doesn't determine character nor does conception within or outside of marriage.

[@Blue-rl5dp]

@@adora721lux8 You're right, for any year past 1950's. Before that most people would jump on you and say you're wrong. I think you're right, but like slavery and a dozen other topics, attitudes change.

[@diannebdee]

What's worse is thinking we, the audience, wouldn't see the severe stupidity of Jamie being with Laoghaire at all. Willie couldn't be helped as Geneva forced him to be with her or else she'd sell Lallybroch out and Jenny and the family. But this was just needless melodrama.

[@talkswithmeme8844]

Frank wish he had this with Claire.....he was no where near. Scenes like this one gets me excited about falling madly in love some day. 😍🥰🥰

[@irenekramer3891]

You're setting yourself up for disappointment. A guy like Jamie does not NOW and NEVER WILL exist in the Real World....unfortunately.

[@Sassenachwhiskey]

Hello Ms, How are you doing ? Hope your anticipating to see the new movie of Sam “Love again! Are you a fan of Sam, How long have you been a fan of sam?

[@Sassenachwhiskey]

@@irenekramer3891 Hello Ms, How are you doing ? Hope your anticipating to see the new movie of Sam “Love again! Are you a fan of Sam, How long have you been a fan of sam?

[@yz6835]

You left out the best part; when Jenny came in, threw water on them and shamed them for disturbing the whole house with their fighting and humping. LOL

[@terrydecarolis5855]

I agree that Jamie knew about Laoghaire, he didn’t even want to say thank you to her when Claire asked him .The writer’s made a lot of mistakes. Especially the ones who read the books know the difference, “come writers”get on the ball”. But on the other hand ,I love Jamie and Claire and the outlander cast and look forward for it to come back.❤️👍💋💓🥰😍

[@samrolandheughan6085]

Hello fan I’m wishing you a happy new year 🎊. Thanks for your comment and support for my movies, your comments and constant love has brought us this far. Keep Listening and supporting, how long have you been a fan of mine ?

[@virgoqueen8950]

I LOVE THIS SCENE FROM BEGINNING TO END

[@user-gerarg80]

The best scene of all seasons... In a few minutes they accomplished to explode all their emotions hidden 20 years cause of the sudden break up If I could select one scene from all The series This is definitely the winner Both the actors deserve congrats

[@candyqueen0064]

Even though I don't like Jamie holding and kissing Claire against her will and forcing her to stay, I'm so glad he did bc they really do love each other and deserved to be together after so much🥺👏

[@stephenthorsted9383]

The way I see it, it wasn't abuse it was passionate love and Claire wanted it!

[@candyqueen0064]

@@stephenthorsted9383 Well, we know they love each other as viewers. But from the way she struggled, yelled at him and how hurt she felt, no I wouldn't say she wanted him within a 10-foot radius. Pls learn to read social cues and consent from others 🤔😳

[@sanarahim9697]

The chemistry between these two is unmatched.

[@TuliTheUnruly]

I've never read or seen another fictional couple that's as devoted or perfectly paired as Claire and Jamie. Jane and Rochester come close, but still not to this level.

[@Sassenachwhiskey]

Hello Ms, How are you doing ? Hope your anticipating to see the new movie of Sam “Love again! Are you a fan of Sam, How long have you been a fan of sam?

[@heughansam4804]

Hello baby girl,how are you ?thank you for being a great fan of mine ,I really appreciate your love and support shown you are a special fan of mine,what is your name and where are you from ?

[@SuperLaurielove]

I agree with all the folks who think this was a very well acted and directed scene with a range of emotional states -subtle and not so subtle - "nailed" by the actors. Leading up the fight, J and C verbalize clearly "where they are coming from" emotionally and then their physical engagement reinforces with actions what they just told us they felt. Yet they take it to and even higher level so we "feel it too." I was surprised then by the comment below which saw J as an "abusive dude" and C as not fighting back enough. So I watched it again to try to "get" how someone could construe that from the scene. When I turned down the volume ( and didn't hear the dialogue leading up to the fight) and just watched the action of the fight, I could see how it might look like (without being "into the characters" and having not listened carefully to the dialog.) that the woman is saying "NO " to the man's aggressive sexual advances yet she ultimately is turned on by them and responds to him as if she had been protesting too much and didn't mean it ! What if he'd just rolled over on the floor in frustration as she continued to fight him off with her fists ? It could have been another " your tearing my heart out" moment and may have reinforced how enraged she was and how on the point of leaving she was . As soon as they are "at it again" you know they're on the road to recovery which is a tad anticlimactic... Of course the bucket of icy water wouldn't have been as "dampening" were they not locked together the heat of passion. Folks berate the person who saw this as "abusive" ; one can disagree with another's perception or you can try to understand why they may have perceived it that way. Many of Outlander scenes - especially those between C and J - are very rich in emotional "meanings" that can be interpreted differently which to me is what makes it so entertaining - or like watching "art" on TV.

[@serafinmma]

😊

[@13wilsonh]

"Well you were the one who told me to be kind to the lass.".... oooooooo Jamie you really stepped in it now...

[@patriciajrs46]

I love how he kisses her once, slapped, then kisses again, her struggling- oh no you don't, I'll be damned attitude, coming out, the wrestles and they show the love. It's great.

[@TK-eh8cs]

Since you started watching who is your favorite character and why?? How are you doing Patricia, hope you are safe from the crazy Covid??

[@patriciajrs46]

@@TK-eh8cs Yes, I am safe.

[@TK-eh8cs]

@@patriciajrs46 It's my pleasure to meet you here 😊, what part of the world are you occupying if I may ask???

[@TK-eh8cs]

@@patriciajrs46 ???

[@TK-eh8cs]

@@patriciajrs46 Are you there Patricia???

[@EsthieAsh]

This is definitely one of the best scenes that’s came from this show

[@shirleynitka5030]

even though you left me. I die laughing every time I hear that line. He forced her to go.

[@Beccalb818]

I’m only on season 1. I shouldn’t be here 😅

[@deedeemeredith5081]

Same girl same!!!! Now I have to binge watch!!

[@mrsdragonite]

@@deedeemeredith5081 I'm in season one and am here lol. It gets worse, sugar lol

[@carolenelson6763]

Well you have lots to look forward to but if you can get the audible books, they are wonderful. You can listen while you are driving or doing chores, shopping, etc. They are beautiful books.

[@claudiacervantes5379]

Lol! Stop watching all these video clips and start binge watching the series. Lol season one is my favorite but season 5 left me excited for the next season! So much crazy happens! Enjoy!

[@Beccalb818]

@@claudiacervantes5379 oh I’ve been binging! I’m almost done with season 4! 🤣

[@martinabordakova2750]

This may sound weird, but I love this fight

[@karenwatson1104]

I think what is funny is that he was starting to tell her about it when they were interrupted by the kids, but neither of them remember this during this struggle. And every time I watch, when she says "get off me," it just cracks me up!!! LOL! I love this scene. The acting is flawless!

[@Simba.Luna.]

Lol. I can’t stop watching when he takes his anger out on the table. His cute little face right before he does it 3:15. He looks like a cute little puppy sniffing the air. That face is too cute as well when he screams that he didn’t care about Leerie.

[@RojaJaneman]

He feels this growing frustration ready to reach it’s zenith, that’s been brewing since she came back to his time. And he’s like, “Where do I put it?? 🤔🤨😤😤 Where🤬🤬???” And then he takes it out on the table before he does anything that he can’t take back.

[@Simba.Luna.]

@@RojaJaneman Lol! Yes. This scene is too cute. That little nose of his sniffing the air. I can’t help imagining little whiskers on him when he does it. It’s a good thing he took it out on the table since he swore to never put his hands on her again. He also makes a cute sound when he hits the table.

[@glorfindelchocolateflowery6392]

@@Simba.Luna. did he abuse her?

[@Simba.Luna.]

@@glorfindelchocolateflowery6392 He spanked her before when they first got married.

[@arbihamzah3976]

k​@@Simba.Luna.

[@pinkywinky911]

I find it funny that Jamie kept saying the wrong things again and again 🤣🤣🤣🤣

[@jasmineramirez2445]

The first time I want him to keep his mouth shut 🤣🤣

[@amyparker9816]

No, Claire kept overreacting again and again

[@Sassenachwhiskey]

Hello Ms, How are you doing ? Hope your anticipating to see the new movie of Sam “Love again! Are you a fan of Sam, How long have you been a fan of sam?

[@luwamalem9537]

This scene always gets to me! The emotion that they are able to bring into it just too good! 🙌🏽

[@janetstory594]

Ha! They cut this clip right before Jamie's sister comes barging in, telling them to quit fighting and rutting like animals, waking up the whole house! LOL

[@allsbrookm]

Every woman wants to be loved like Jamie loved Claire. I can't imagine how that would feel.

[@emilyn9230]

It’s soooo effortless to just sit back and watch them work their magic like I was shocked when the clip ended it went by so fast

[@susanireland3714]

Both are sensational in this scene. And never the recognition they deserve. So maddening

[@samrolandheughan6085]

Hi big fan!!!! Wishing you happy new year 🎆🎊. I’m using this medium to appreciate you in particular as a fan of mine keep supporting me, Love you

[@mhadman427]

My girlfriend and I argue about these scenes. I can see where both characters are coming from and why they did what they did. My GF comes down firmly on Claire's side. Jamie lost Claire for what he thought would be forever. He was hopeless at ever finding that kind of love again. He wanted to be a father to this two girls and have a normal life.

[@janprudden9221]

in the books he admits he mainly married her to not be alone..though the series does portray it as you say

[@Blue-rl5dp]

I agree with you. He waited 18 years for her to come back. When she didn't he just wanted to be a father because he liked children, and have some company. He wasn't looking for love, or even children of his own blood, just decent companionship. Claire was just over-reacting to Leerie. Some sweet little crofters daughter who treated him kindly wouldn't have got her dander up nearly so bad. She claims she's insulted that he lied to her, but he didn't. It was one of those "secrets" they agreed they could have if they must, but he never lied. He never loved Leerie and THAT is what SHE was angry about.

[@christinaag7970]

@@Blue-rl5dp Actually when she first arrived that night in the brothel he did try to tell her but she said to him to take it slow.

[@Blue-rl5dp]

@@christinaag7970 You're right. In the book Claire said she didn't care what he'd been doing all those years, she wanted him. Even if he'd been a bigamist or public drunkard. That, of course, pinched him in the arse and spurred him to confess the bigamist part. But she wasn't currently in the mood to hear confessions and told him it could wait. It was her fault she didn't get told, though Jamie too willingly let it go by too long.

[@RojaJaneman]

Sometimes, we think we know what we’re getting into and can handle the ‘terms’. UNTIL... Reality hits us in the jaw and injures us. And we realize, NOPE! Can’t take THAT PAIN. They both did great, until she realized it was Laoghaire and he realized that he did fail to give her a vital piece of information right away. He knew he should’ve, that’s y he said that he was a coward. Sometimes, us as being human, fall short, and that’s okay. If there’s a strong bond and u realize that u r liable to make such mistakes as well, u would eventually forgive each other for weaknesses or misjudgment. It takes understanding and empathy. No relationship can survive without them. Because people will always make mistakes.

[@hellokitchic]

When his sister threw water on them both. I just laughed and thought "Yeah. I could see myself doing that to my brother" LOL!!

[@lindawitherington9010]

I’ve read all the books published so far and rarely have I seen an adaptation for tv or film that is actually better than the books, this is a perfect example of the tv show being better than the books. All the actors are brilliant in it they are all believable, but these two main characters are on another level they show their love for each other and also show the struggle to make his century blend with hers. The only problem I have with outlander is all the false stories coming out about Catriona and Sam’s real life and their so called off screen romance. They are clearly the very best of friends whenever you see them they are laughing and again rarely do two main characters get on so well on and off screen. I wish them both all the best and I’m glad the producers chose these two to play Jamie and Claire I just can’t think of any other actors that could portray them. Well done to the cast,producers,writers and all that are involved with this program and THANK YOU Dianna Gabaldon for writing such a masterful series of books roll on November so I can read Go tell the bees I am gone,

[@aqueneable]

Far and away my favorite love scene, where Jamie and Claire bare their souls more than in any other scene.

[@tillie3545]

Yall this is like a fluffy bunny compared to their fight in the book. Like even Jenny was terrified when she entered the room to stop the fight.

[@valentinaelizondo6854]

Oh please do tell us how the real fight went 🤭

[@mamiyasakura669]

@@valentinaelizondo6854 please

[@carolenelson6763]

The books are wonderful. What about the fight they had when they returned to the castle after the wedding dog tired & Claire thought Jamie left right away to go find Laoghaire & they had a big argument when he returned. She was so JEALOUS😂🤣

[@daizfully1364]

can i be told which book and what chapter the fight occurs??

[@Blue-rl5dp]

True. In the book Jamie was much more desperate, angry and violent over her intent to leave him. It was very nearly forcible rape going on and Claire was afraid as well as angry. He had told her long before that there was a beast in him that got released in battle, and he could neither control it, nor remember all that he did. Claire said she saw that beast that night before Jenny interfered, and we can presume Jenny saw some small bit of it because she was afraid of him too. She took her daughter and Claire and locked themselves in the parlor.

[@patsymontana7670]

Sending gratitude and thanks to the terrific writers of this series who took the excellent books by Diana Gabaldon and crafted this fabulous program just for all the fans. Thanks also to Starz for taking on the project. I’ve never been so entertained in my life. And I’m running out of adjectives…

[@codyandjessisalazar3429]

Outlander is the best!!! I’ve never loved a tv show so much in my entire life….and the acting..omg..absolutely insane!!

[@beverleyjeffkins6768]

I totally agree. I feel exactly the same about this wonderful series ❤️

[@samrolandheughan6085]

Hi big fan!!!! Wishing you happy new year 🎆🎊. I’m using this medium to appreciate you in particular as a fan of mine keep supporting me, Love you

[@aliciabustos2206]

Esta escena es realmente fascinante.Tiene un aura teatral.Y ambos ,Sam y Caitriona están magníficos.El amor,la furia,los celos y esa pasión cotenida durante veinte años,fantasticamente dirigida,filmada y actuada.Felicitaciones para todo ese equipo!!

[@pohordebbarma4505]

Jamie has ample qualities The red hair, the accent, Heavy muscle, handsome, kind hearted, loyalty, Man of honor 😂😂😂😂 everybody wants single piece of him

[@brittaneysmith1946]

Is anyone else uneasy about the title of this video? It makes him seem like he was married on purpose to two people at the same time in THE SAME CENTURY. He never thought he would EVER see Claire again and he didn't want to get married again but Jenny thought he needed a family or take care of these children that weren't his. I just think this title is very misleading and make Jamie look like the bad guy, when it was Claire who went back to her husband and lived with him and was married to him for 20 years and only came back once he was dead. And she was the only one who was willing to travel through time. SHE SHOULD HAVE NEVER GIVEN UP ON HER SEARCH FOR JAIME WHEN SHE GOT BACK AND SHE SHOULD HAVE DIVORCED FRANK WHEN SHE GOT BACK

[@Blue-rl5dp]

yeah, it's not a secret marriage. The whole neighborhood knows. The ONLY one who doesn't know is Claire. Jenny was just a busy body match maker and thought Jamie would be happier with a family. I think it would be true, if he'd married some sweet and happy natured cottars daughter or shop girl. Jamie was healing from the loss of Claire by then but was lonely. He wanted to be a father, and having met skippy happy little Joan and Marsali, the fact that their mother was Leerie was inconsequential. He just wanted children in his life. Yes, Claire only came back after Frank was dead, but it was about 4 years later. She wasn't going back at all because she thought Jamie was dead. She thought he died at Culloden. She didn't even dream of going back until she found out Jamie had survived.

[@bonganimoyo7764]

SOME ACTORS ARE MILLIONAIRES FOR A GOOD REASON. THEIR PERFORMANCE IS WORTH MILLIONS. FOR ME JAMIE AND CLAIRE,THEN AMY AND TY(IN HEARTLAND) ARE THE BEST LOVE STORIES OF ALL TIMES.

[@sussezqt.1439]

This is a scene I watch over and over. So incredibly written and acted. And we were anticipating it with all the foreshadowing with Jamie talking to young Ian, Ian and Fergus... all the foreboding. DAmn Jamie she tried to have her burnt alive! Frank wouldn't have married her. Jamie so typical "you told me to be kind to the lass".... *rolling eyes*

[@TuliTheUnruly]

I think he showed up to the courthouse a little late to notice L's vengeance, spite or fury. Claire should have told him the entire exchange between them. Maybe he would have been less forgiving and compassionate if he knew she planned to kill his soulmate.

[@anneldamorris]

I have noticed that throughout the seasons that Jamie’s accent isn’t a strong it was in the beginning of the series to how it is now in seasons five and six

[@TK-eh8cs]

Since you started watching who is your favorite character and why?? How are you doing Annelda, hope you are safe from the crazy Covid??

[@samrolandheughan6085]

Hi big fan!!!! Wishing you happy new year 🎆🎊. I’m using this medium to appreciate you in particular as a fan of mine keep supporting me, Love you

[@triciahoogendoorn523]

Can't say enough about this show and how amazing the cast and producers are. Will watch this over and over again!

[@samrolandheughan6085]

Hi big fan!!!! Wishing you happy new year 🎆🎊. I’m using this medium to appreciate you in particular as a fan of mine keep supporting me, Love you

[@terrydecarolis5855]

This is not the best but one of the best.There are so many ,and the two of them masters them all. BRAVO Sam and CAITE. 🤩

[@sergiovargas9942]

I get lost it feels real like it's not acting I feel there emotions so real

[@ruthmckay6740]

I Love this scene.....what chemistry!!❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️

[@Sassenachwhiskey]

Hello Ms, How are you doing ? Hope your anticipating to see the new movie of Sam “Love again! Are you a fan of Sam, How long have you been a fan of sam?

[@sandrahouck4814]

Somewhere along the line someone forgot that Claire was married for 20yrs...not a happy 20 but she was married. Why should Jamie feel so bad other than he was afraid to tell her. The way things look to me is, a double standard.....Claire's life wasn't much but it was a whole lot better than Jamie....

[@tolemac8998]

The series is so good I finished watching all seasons in 4 days😅

[@nazm23]

How I wish all fights btw spouses ended this way 😌❤️

[@travisstephens3888]

Ikr

[@d.s.5615]

They delivered their lines so good! I am in wonder

[@sandracancelliere8590]

I never get tired of watching this. I love Jamie and Claire xx

[@beverleyjeffkins6768]

Mr too💕

[@TK-eh8cs]

Since you started watching who is your favorite character and why?? How are you doing Sandra, hope you are safe from the crazy Covid??

[@keithsmith4780]

In later seasons their marriage approaches perfect harmony, which is what I would wish for them if they were real people, but as characters they were more interesting when there was tension between them, as in this scene. Best TV marriage: maybe Coach Eric and Tammy Taylor in Friday Night Lights. The lack of friction between the Taylors didn’t make FNL dull because it wasn’t primarily a love story; the drama came from outside. But Outlander rises and falls with the drama or lack of it between Mr. and Mrs. Fraser.

[@samrolandheughan6085]

Hello fan I’m wishing you a happy new year 🎊. Thanks for your comment and support for my movies, your comments and constant love has brought us this far. Keep Listening and supporting, how long have you been a fan of mine ?

[@IAmWithinEverything]

I am watching this every day. Saves my sanity from living in this crazy world♥️

[@theladyprincess]

this is basically their “we were on a break” 😭😭

[@susanpark3451]

They cut off the best part when the sister comes in and chucks water on the pair of them lol

[@prvtgraham5]

Hi Susan are you one of my lovely fan's out there?

[@camilleb.2810]

It is humorous that who ever did the closed captions when it came to Loaghaire's name the closed captions called her "Larry" lol

[@lilyflower4225]

This scene is satisfying to watch! Love the acting! Kudos for both!

[@toniahusbands7635]

I love me some Outlander!!! One of the best series ever

[@juneD6994]

Fabulously acted scene! Not such a secret marriage, but just not sufficient time to explain.

[@Blue-rl5dp]

Oh everybody knew about the marriage but Clair. He was trying to find the time and way to explain it so she wouldn't be hurt, and wouldn't leave. He'd do anything to keep her from leaving. Through the whole rest of the book series he's anxious every time she goes somewhere.

[@juneD6994]

@@Blue-rl5dp Exactly, he never lied to her as she claimed. They had agreed to secrets but not lies. He was about to explain to her when the step children barged in. Jenny's doing!

[@Blue-rl5dp]

@@juneD6994 By secrets he meant the "I'm a faerie and live in a dune" kind, or the "I'm a witch" kind, not the "I have a wife" kind but you're right. She's over sensitive because of WHO the other wife is. Otherwise I think she would have been more open minded. After all, when they made that deal she did have to tell him SHE had a husband and he wasn't dead.

[@mary.gcarpenter1490]

@@juneD6994 I used to think he should have told her when he told her about his son. But on second thought Im thinking she probably would have turned around and left again and he knew that. I have more of a problem with him letting an 18 year old blackmail ??? him "with what" into having sex which caused a pregnancy, and him not being able to raise the kid himself, even though both the Mother and supposed Father are dead. Especially now that they live in Georgia and nobody would need to know about that. Also how happy Willie would have been knowing he was his Father. Knowing how much he loved Mac. He's not really an Earl. And I'm also thinking Willie would much prefer his real Father to being an Earl. It will probably all come out in the end anyway.

[@carolenelson6763]

He was going to explain the first night when she asked and then she said "you don't have to tell be everything now. I only want to know one thing....did you ever fall in love with anyone else?" So it's really her fault he didn't tell her.

[@Kat17CR]

They are so good... I love them!!

[@1LaOriental]

Sam Neughan? Right...

[@samheughan9632]

Yes! Text me on hangouts